PDA

View Full Version : Scott Mednick (Producer) Interview**Lots of Information**


Aztec General
05-13-2009, 04:09 PM
Enjoy:

http://tinyurl.com/ojsfpy

TerranigmaFreak
05-13-2009, 04:16 PM
Nice, thanks for the link!

steve
05-13-2009, 04:37 PM
Oh ya nice link. Always great to hear the news =D

Cipher
05-13-2009, 05:07 PM
Everything there was vaguely re-assuring, at least.

Raph's Girl
05-13-2009, 05:52 PM
Ooh.. an Elias Koteas cameo would totally rock. Last thing I saw him in was Benjamin Button (he was the clock maker). :D

Tinuvielsdreams
05-13-2009, 06:16 PM
He had to be pretty vague but I am happy with what I am hearing for now.
I like to read that they want to use the best costumes makers they can get to keep TMNT in the real world and also using character cameos would be great.

CyberCubed
05-13-2009, 09:55 PM
If they haven't even started the basic idea for the movie yet, how are they going to have this ready by 2011?

We're already halfway through 2009, they better start figuring out what they want to do with it, let alone the casting/acting/etc.

sdp
05-13-2009, 10:08 PM
2011 is already crowded with a lot of big name movies, it'd be for the best if the movie was pushed to 2012.

Mr. Stay Puft
05-14-2009, 12:39 AM
2011 is already crowded with a lot of big name movies, it'd be for the best if the movie was pushed to 2012.

2012? But isn't the world supposed to end by then?:D

Nelson
05-14-2009, 06:33 AM
"So it’s really trying to modulate the expectations of the fans today, the expectations of those kids and teenagers of today..."

Uh oh...

DougieTMNT
05-14-2009, 08:44 AM
Since they know they are doing an origin story, they're off to a pretty good start. The origin is already in place for them, it just needs to be adapted well. If need be, they'll push the date back. At this point in production, a release date is just a rough aim.

I hate to seem to be negative, but anyone wanting a Turtles movie solely for the "fans" is going to be disappointed. It's too hard for movie studios to define exactly what a Turtles fan is. Is it just someone who read the comics? People who love the old toon, the new toon, the movies? Since all of these are different tonally, the best we're likely to end up with is a composite.


I would be all in favour of a (I hate this word) darker Turtles movie, along the lines of The Dark Knight. I'm just not holding out any hope that we'll get that, as I don't know if the suits will see it as being commercially viable. There's a stigma now that the TMNT are for kids, so to make something accurate to the original comics would be a massive risk.

Spitfire
05-14-2009, 08:51 AM
My faith in this has dropped a little. For one this guy has only ever actually produced one movie, "Freedom To Choose" a documentary that never came out. All the others he was an executive producer which means he gave money to the makers to get his name in the credits.

He'll have some practice producing American Gladiator the movie... and Shame on You. The big name movies they're tossing around, like them or not, he had nothing to do with other then tossing money at them. We'll see, sometimes new blood is good and sometimes it turns into a big fat failure.

Producers can be all over the map sometimes. I'll see whose directing and most importantly whose writing it before I get worried.

The Shelf
05-14-2009, 10:35 AM
2012? But isn't the world supposed to end by then?:D

Not until December 21, 2012. I'm sure it will be out before then. :roll: :lol:

Sage Ninja
05-14-2009, 11:09 AM
I'm feeling good about this movie so far. I would love to see Elias Koteas make a cameo, or play a larger role in the new movie. I'm just psyched that this is going to be live action with live action customed turtles with cgi enhancements!

I wonder, since it's going to be live action, do you think we might see the turtle voice actors from 2k3 toon popping up here and there playing bit random people in the movie?

DougieTMNT
05-14-2009, 11:14 AM
It would be good, but only if they kept these guys in the background. Something for the hardcore fans to notice, not something that calls attention to itself.

Otherwise we would end up with the Turtles equivalent of Die Another Day, where every scene is filled with in your face references. Too distracting.

Ninjinister
05-14-2009, 12:09 PM
Not until December 21, 2012. I'm sure it will be out before then. :roll: :lol:

The world ends when I say it does! :x

We have another circa 7000 years to go.

Andrew NDB
05-14-2009, 12:15 PM
"So it’s really trying to modulate the expectations of the fans today, the expectations of those kids and teenagers of today..."

Uh oh...

Nothing to worry about, it's simple Hollywood demographic talk.

Canadian Turtle
05-14-2009, 09:18 PM
To dispel some rumors and miss conceptions on here. Scott and Galen know what they are doing!

I know both of them and in fact Exec producers do a LOT more than just throw money at a picture. I would say this is the case with Scott for sure. He is a very passionate man and knows and cares who his audience is! I have a good feeling about this movie!

Things are very early yet, and however possible that the movie could get pushed in the big world of reality, but not likely. Things are moving well!!

Also I have seen the new trailers for "where the wild things are" Which Scott was involved with and it sure as heck looks like they got that one right! Looks awesome!

Mr._Mutant_Man
05-16-2009, 08:57 AM
I would be all in favour of a (I hate this word) darker Turtles movie, along the lines of The Dark Knight.

I think that might be a little too dark for the Ninja Turtles.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-16-2009, 01:47 PM
"So it’s really trying to modulate the expectations of the fans today, the expectations of those kids and teenagers of today..."

Uh oh...

Well, he did say "teenagers". And teenagers are people of ages 13-19, which generally the age range for PG-13 movies. Perhaps I'm being overly optimistic here, but the fact that he included teenagers and didn't just say kids does seem like a good sign.

Buslady
05-17-2009, 02:41 AM
but the real hard core fans are us, adults, the 18+ and way older.

they need ot look at what we wanna see....screw the little kids. Lets have a good dark tmnt movie

Andrew NDB
05-17-2009, 03:16 AM
but the real hard core fans are us, adults, the 18+ and way older.

they need ot look at what we wanna see....

Well, yes and no. No, they shouldn't and can't worry about what a niche, dwindling existing fandom like you and I want to see on the big screen (because we simply aren't enough to fill up any seats in any signfiicant way)... however, given that pretty much every other approach has already been tried and ultimately failed... they're literally left with no other sound course of action than to explore doing a proper Mirage/comic book TMNT movie. Especially post-Dark Knight. And by a proper Mirage TMNT movie I don't mean some kind of "Let's please everybody! Fans of the cartoons and comics and everyone!" -- that is going to fall on its face and I hope they can see that.

TMNT needs a hard, Mirage-flavored reboot, no two ways about it. And it needs to market on the premise and story within, not to any existing TMNT fandom -- it can't afford to.

DougieTMNT
05-17-2009, 03:32 AM
Well, yes and no. No, they shouldn't and can't worry about what a niche, dwindling existing fandom like you and I want to see on the big screen (because we simply aren't enough to fill up any seats in any signfiicant way)...

Exactly, I hear a lot of complaining (I'm not speaking about anyone on this forum, but others I'm a member of) about Comic-Book movies not tailoring exclusively to the fan base. Many don't understand that most fan-bases aren't large enough to make a movie like this a success.

however, given that pretty much every other approach has already been tried and ultimately failed... they're literally left with no other sound course of action than to explore doing a proper Mirage/comic book TMNT movie. Especially post-Dark Knight. And by a proper Mirage TMNT movie I don't mean some kind of "Let's please everybody! Fans of the cartoons and comics and everyone!" -- that is going to fall on its face and I hope they can see that.


The Dark Knight should prove to them that darker comic book movies can work. Unfortunately, I have a feeling that they are going to go with a "catch all" type of flick.

They only need to look at the original movies to see what does and doesn't work. The original movie holds up much better (and is generally better thought of in general) than 2 or 3, which were considerably lighter. Take the original movie, bring it much closer to the comics and turn the "dark" up a notch = damn good movie.

Mr._Mutant_Man
05-17-2009, 08:52 AM
but the real hard core fans are us, adults, the 18+ and way older.

they need ot look at what we wanna see....screw the little kids. Lets have a good dark tmnt movie

I can't imagine the movie being much of a success if they narrowed their focus to such a small target audience.

A darker TMNT movie is probably going to be the way to go, because they already explored the really kid friendly option and it apparently didn't work as well as they hoped. However, I don't think it will or should be as dark as the Dark Knight. Were the comics ever really that dark? As violent as they were, things still seemed more light hearted than the Dark Knight.

lukekeith
05-24-2009, 02:00 AM
Well, yes and no. No, they shouldn't and can't worry about what a niche, dwindling existing fandom like you and I want to see on the big screen (because we simply aren't enough to fill up any seats in any signfiicant way)... however, given that pretty much every other approach has already been tried and ultimately failed... they're literally left with no other sound course of action than to explore doing a proper Mirage/comic book TMNT movie. Especially post-Dark Knight. And by a proper Mirage TMNT movie I don't mean some kind of "Let's please everybody! Fans of the cartoons and comics and everyone!" -- that is going to fall on its face and I hope they can see that.

TMNT needs a hard, Mirage-flavored reboot, no two ways about it. And it needs to market on the premise and story within, not to any existing TMNT fandom -- it can't afford to.

I definitely have to agree with you on this one. I personally don't think a turtles film should in any way consider the demographic of it's fans (though if they had to pick, I would prefer they go with the hardcore fans, the 18+ guys). If they would stop worrying about which age group they want to please, and just worry about making a badass movie, then their target audience no longer matters because everyone will want to see it!!!

And even if they did decide to cater to the 18+ guys, it's not always just as easy as saying "just make it darker". You have to put some serious time into the story, and bring on some incredibly talented people to produce the movie. You don't just pick up Chris Nolan level talent on the street, even Hollywood is short on that kind of creative mastery. Clearly, they key is vision! Any bozo can throw 100$mil at a movie, but that doesn't make it any good. Mirage/WB need to focus on finding a good vision for the next film, or no matter how much money they spend, how many talented artists they hire, how many great actors they cast, it will still fail. Vision first!!!

Instead of writing a story trying to fill a quota of surface issues like "giving Mikey more screen time", "making the movie darker", "make it PG or PG-13?", "including mousers", and many of the other silly issues that are commonly debated... just STOP, and focus on writing a compelling story. If you can find a good story, then you don't have to write the characters in because they will write themselves in!!! Stop forcing lines down a character's throat and let a character do what a character does best, live in the story you have created. Let the characters breathe!!!

If a story is truly compelling, I should be able to tell the story from the perspective of a pigeon on a wire without loosing any of it's luster.

Good stories will live forever, bad stories will die young!

Aztec General
05-25-2009, 09:55 AM
LK,

While I certainly agree with you that story should come first, that's kind of obvious if you think about it. I think it's safe to say that we ALL want a kick-ass story. It's VERY important though to know BEFORE going in to writing this story just who your audience is. Ask any writer and they'll tell you that you need to decided upon your audience before you being writing. So it is worthwhile to say before creating the story: "We need to make a TMNT film for the PG-13 crowd" or whoever.

I also agree with you that the Nolan brothers (David Goyer deserves next to no credit for The Dark Knight) don't just grow on trees in Hollywood these days. That's why it is so important to find a writer who is intimate with the source material and understands the characters. I mean look at how well Iron Man and The Dark Knight came out. It's because Marvel was directly involved in the creation of Iron Man and the WB found a truly gifted writer/director in Nolan.

Some people were surprised by my thread supporting Tristan Jones for the screenwriting position, but my intention was to support someone who has fresh and interesting ideas for characters that he knows backwards and forwards. This film has a significantly better chance of being well written if it is in the hands of someone as close to the material as he is.