View Full Version : Questions for the avid and thorough readers...
TristanHuwJones
05-17-2009, 01:07 AM
I've been rereading everything and have kind of stumbled across a few things that I wanted to share/discuss with the other fans.
First and foremost -- Tales #35. I still don't get it. It could be that I don't want to get it, but I still don't get it. Is it Splinter simply trippin' balls while meditating and witnessing his own demise well before his time, or is it something else? I can't say I'm fond of the Rat King origin, if this is meant to be it...
Second. Volume 2 seems to take place in roughly the space of two weeks, overlooking Shadow's hair growth, and happens a lot closer to the end of City at War than I'd initially thought.
Third. With the exception of the time jump of 6 months after the Utroms land. Volume 4 - up until that point, seems to take place over a few days, and then from #6 (I think) through to 30 only seems to have taken 3 weeks (roughly).
Anyone care to weigh in on these? I've been working on a definitive timeline for the Mirage material based on my own reading and the excellent thread up above regarding the continuity, and just looking at how events seem to progress and the turning from day to night, certain things seem to happen a lot quicker than I first thought.
I just want to hear what people think.
Peace!
Cipher
05-17-2009, 01:46 AM
I'd have to re-read Volumes 2 and 4 for your last two questions, but I can weigh in on Tales #35, "The Pantheon". It's...pretty confusing.
Splinter is approached by a mythical animal pantheon, denies them, and accepts as he dies in Volume 4. That much is clear. The Rat King's portrayal, and his interaction with Splinter, cause a lot of problems. With some stretches, they can be solved.
In "I, Monster", Rat King is a crazy man who believes he's a monster. The Turtles injure and defeat (but do not kill) him. When he next shows up during "City at War", he's a spiritual guide for Splinter and his corpse is discovered in the silo. That much is fine.
But in "The Pantheon" we see that he's given the powers of the Pantheon by the previous Rat King while escaping a (mental?) hospital. He then abuses the powers of the Rat (in stark contrast to his character in other issues), battles Splinter, and loses. When he shows up again in "City at War", Splinter doesn't remember him, and he's an entirely different, wiser character. Finally, he appears in the doorway as Splinter dies, presumably to offer up his place in the Pantheon.
-------------------
So, it's fairly convoluted, and I don't really like it, but here's what seems to be a rough timeline for the Rat King:
1. Rat King is an insane human who thinks he's a monster. He is defeated by the Turtles in an abandoned factory and left in a silo with his rats.
2. At some point, the Rat King is taken into a mental hospital. Attempting to escape, the Pantheon's Rat King grants him the powers of the rat. (The Pantheon position shares a name with his supervillain alias. Coincidence, huh?)
3. The Rat King abuses his mystical position for personal vices. At some point before "City at War", the Pantheon calls Splinter to duel the Rat King. Splinter wins, but refuses to join. He will recieve the offer once more at the moment of his death.
4. Splinter's memory of the incident must be wiped so that he doesn't recognize the Rat King in "City at War." Nothing implies that this couldn't be the case.
5. The Rat King becomes a wiser and calmer spiritual guide over the years. The events of "City at War" take place. The Rat King appears to Splinter and helps him accept his animal nature.
6. Splinter dies in Volume 4. The Rat King appears in the doorway to offer him a position within the Pantheon once again.
That's what I got from it, anyway.
--EDIT
Decided to skim some issues of Volume 2 right before going to bed. I just happened to catch this little tidbit. In #3, Nobody stakes out the Northampton farm. In #4, Donatello catches him and asks, "Was it you that came to the farm a few weeks back?"
So there's a sizable time gap in between #3 and #4.
TristanHuwJones
05-17-2009, 02:56 AM
Good catch on that last one, I must've overlooked it... admittedly my reading of Volume 2 was a little less thorough than it should've been this time around, as I was going mainly through visuals to ascertain a rough estimate of how long each issue takes in terms of "real-time".
There are a few other glaring inconsistencies in the timeline (the appearances of characters who should be elsewhere at that time, real-time dates throwing timeframes out, issues referencing other issues, etc.) but I'll get to them later.
Andrew NDB
05-17-2009, 03:00 AM
In "I, Monster", Rat King is a crazy man who believes he's a monster. The Turtles injure and defeat (but do not kill) him. When he next shows up during "City at War", he's a spiritual guide for Splinter and his corpse is discovered in the silo. That much is fine.
I've always taken that to mean that the shuriken/fall in that original Tales issue really did kill him. Like, after that last panel of him laying there with the rats around him... if we were to have continued onto a new page, he'd have just dropped dead.
TristanHuwJones
05-17-2009, 04:10 AM
Alright. I reread things up until the DARPA raid, which'd take about 24 hours or so at most to happen. We don't know how long the invasion takes, or if it even takes place.
Here's what I got:
Don's leg is busted in #1 still. Given the Turtles have an advanced healing rate thanks to the mutagen, this, I'm assuming this takes place fairly close to City at War. But it would mean that, unless he damages his leg again somewhere between Vol.2 and City at War, NO Tales stories involving Donatello can occur during that time.
In issue 2 his leg is fine, so it could be a minor thing that might not have anything to do with City at War. Either that or there really is a sizable gap between 1 and 2. Issue 2 takes about 12 hours.
In #3 Braunze says that April and Casey have been in the place for about 3 months. If I remember right, April moves in around December.
There's a three week gap between #3 and #4 according to Donatello, as Cipher mentioned.
Baxter arrives in #5, which is a 3 day trip by car. Assuming the robot is fast, it could do that. The fight with the fishwoman and Terrorpin takes about a night.
#6 takes place a day after #5
#7 is a continuation of #6 and Baxter launches his attack. Don and Nobody arrives at the end.
#8 Baxter fight continues, and Raph is kidnapped.
#9 would have to be a day after, as it would take Longer/Nobody time to go over the files to track Raph. The Feds raid Caseys.
#10 The next day. Braunze tells Casey about everything. They leave the next morning at 4 am and arrive in Nevada 3 days later.
All up, depending on how you read the ending, Vol.2 takes about 6 weeks then...(?)
Aztec General
05-17-2009, 09:14 AM
I am really not a fan of the Rat King's "origin" in Tales Vol. 2. He was much better off as the enigmatic being he was in Tales. Vol. 1 and CAW. I hope that "Pantheon" nonsense is retconned out of existence.
CyberCubed
05-17-2009, 11:18 AM
At least it explains how Rat King was able to talk to Splinter beyond death in City at War, and why Rat King re-appeared in that one Vol. 4 panel before Splinter's death.
Likewise now that Splinter is the new "Rat King," he's already made several appearances with the living. He calms down Gamera Raph before he can speak, he helps give April confidence to live when she's about to fall off the cliff in that Tales issue, and he gives Don the confidence boost he needs to power that spaceship in the Tales issue with the Triceratons/Styracons (sp?).
So we already see how Splinter has taken over the mantle with those 3 appearances.
DrSpengler
05-17-2009, 11:26 AM
Personally, I always placed "Pantheon" as happening in the "early years" era, before TMNT Vol. 1 #1.
As for the quality of the story, I also can't say I'm particularly fond of it. Rat King worked best as just a plain ole crazy person. Making him a deposed animal deity reeks of "too much plot", kind of like turning April into a sentient doodle.
Some times less is more.
Cipher
05-17-2009, 11:52 AM
I've always taken that to mean that the shuriken/fall in that original Tales issue really did kill him. Like, after that last panel of him laying there with the rats around him... if we were to have continued onto a new page, he'd have just dropped dead.That's what I used to think. But it doesn't add up with what we see in "The Pantheon." In that issue, he's granted the powers of the rat while he's alive and in a hospital. If he died at the end of "I, Monster", he would already have to have been the Pantheon's Rat King, which makes no sense.
Of course, the corpse being in the silo doesn't make sense then, but we can just chalk it up to his willy-nilly magic powers.
Personally, I always placed "Pantheon" as happening in the "early years" era, before TMNT Vol. 1 #1.Can't be. The Rat King is clearly not a Pantheon member when he meets the Turtles in "I, Monster." Unless someone has a glaring reason why my Rat King timeline doesn't work, or has one that works better, I'll stick by it.
As for the quality of the story, I also can't say I'm particularly fond of it. Rat King worked best as just a plain ole crazy person.I agree completely.
And Tristan, your Volume 2 timeline seems about right.
PAAATE
05-17-2009, 12:11 PM
Can't be. The Rat King is clearly not a Pantheon member when he meets the Turtles in "I, Monster." Unless someone has a glaring reason why my Rat King timeline doesn't work, or has one that works better, I'll stick by it.
I'm with you on this one... It's clearly the story that makes most sense... At least to me
I mean... First he becomes a God, then he's mortal and crazy, then a God again that passes his duty on to Splinter? Huh?
No, Cipher's right if you ask me.
DrSpengler
05-17-2009, 12:47 PM
Can't be. The Rat King is clearly not a Pantheon member when he meets the Turtles in "I, Monster." Unless someone has a glaring reason why my Rat King timeline doesn't work, or has one that works better, I'll stick by it.
You see, I don't think "Pantheon" can take place between "I, Monster" and "City at War" due to the Rat King's personality.
In "Pantheon" he isn't crazy in the least, just a hood trying to escape from a hospital (no indication it's a mental hospital) who is complete in control of his faculties.
In "I, Monster", he's a madman who thinks he's a shambling beast.
The implication I got was that after being deposed as Rat King by Splinter in "Pantheon", the process of losing all that power is what drove him to madness.
Cipher
05-17-2009, 12:51 PM
The implication I got was that after being deposed as Rat King by Splinter in "Pantheon", the process of losing all that power is what drove him to madness.Only to have his mystical powers again in "City at War" and Volume 4?
I guess you could say that he died in "I, Monster" and was reinstated in the Pantheon. But who would be the Rat King in the interrim? The whole reason they accosted Splinter was because there needed to be a new Rat King. It's all a big mess.
DrSpengler
05-17-2009, 03:09 PM
Well, I didn't really see his presence in "City at War" as him having godly powers, simply him being a ghostly spirit guide. Cuz he was dead. And dead guys can do that. In comic books, anyway. It's just something that ghosts can do.
And since the whole "deposed rat deity" thing was a retcon made over a decade later, that seemed to have been the initial intent, too.
Aztec General
05-17-2009, 03:13 PM
As for the quality of the story, I also can't say I'm particularly fond of it. Rat King worked best as just a plain ole crazy person. Making him a deposed animal deity reeks of "too much plot", kind of like turning April into a sentient doodle.
Some times less is more.
I couldn't agree more! I wish someone would retcon those two plot points away.
Not So Teenage Terd-le
05-31-2009, 04:24 PM
I am new to the Mirage universe but I am trying to do as much reading that is available to me between work and school. I am sure my ideas are not even close but just to share what I thought about Pantheon...
First off I always felt like Rat King killed Splinter in Vol. 4 maybe by poisoning his tea. Splinter clearly felt another person in the room at that time. Not to mention the cat that ate the bird after Splinter tended to the both of them.
I felt like the characters in Pantheon were spirits or Gods... so Splinter being dead is the perfect oppurtunity to become King of the Rats in the "spirit world".
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.