PDA

View Full Version : Which elements made for the 2k3 show should come over?


Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
05-18-2009, 10:46 PM
I think Hun would be a great addition. Maybe Agent Bishop if they get sequels. What do you think?

Coola Yagami
05-18-2009, 11:00 PM
Nothing really.... Just real REAL minor details... like maybe an occasional 'what the shell' or Raph calls his bike the Shell Cycle as a sarcastic gag or whatnot. Make Shredder say 'You will not leave here alive!'

Cipher
05-18-2009, 11:19 PM
Like maybe an occasional 'what the shell'No. The Turtles can swear just like normal people. Or not. But they do not need to make puns based on their species.

Raph calls his bikeNO.

Make Shredder say 'You will not leave here alive!'Dialogue fail.

Bishop and Hun are about the only elements unique to the 2003 cartoon that would be successful on film.

CyberCubed
05-19-2009, 12:10 AM
Considering the 2k3 universe is over (as far as we know), and that this film will potentially re-boot the franchise yet again, I doubt anything will be taken from it.

I'm betting the 2k3 universe will fade away into obscurity now, aside from the stuff appearing in the Mirage universe like Hun and the Battle Nexus.

The 4kids cartoon didn't leave anywhere near the impact that the original cartoon did, so there's no reason to take much from it when nobody will recognize the easter eggs but about 70 people on thetechnodrome's forums.

trustno1
05-19-2009, 01:13 AM
Considering the 2k3 universe is over (as far as we know), and that this film will potentially re-boot the franchise yet again, I doubt anything will be taken from it.

I'm betting the 2k3 universe will fade away into obscurity now, aside from the stuff appearing in the Mirage universe like Hun and the Battle Nexus.

The 4kids cartoon didn't leave anywhere near the impact that the original cartoon did, so there's no reason to take much from it when nobody will recognize the easter eggs but about 70 people on thetechnodrome's forums.

perhaps not to our generation, but there are probably thousands of kids around the world that have spent the last six years of their lives watching 2k3 just the same as we did with the old toon.

on topic though i think hun would work. if tristan and paul could make it him work in the comics then i think he would work well in the movies. finding someone of that stature and acting ability would be something else though.

Dan
05-19-2009, 01:29 AM
Master Khan

Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-19-2009, 04:59 AM
Personally, even though I loved the 2k3 series, I think most of the things that are exclusive to it shouldn't make an appearance at all in this new movie. Same with anything that's exclusive to the '87 series.

If anything, I want them to do NEW things. Something that will be, in people's minds, linked specificially to this new universe, much like Tatsu, Tokka, and Rahzar were linked to the old movies.

ToTheNines
05-19-2009, 09:02 AM
The action plus some blood, that's about all I can think of.

Whitewolf89
05-19-2009, 03:23 PM
No. The Turtles can swear just like normal people. Or not. But they do not need to make puns based on their species.
I agree. Raph said "Damn!" in the first live-action movie a couple of times (not real sure about the other two, swearing-wise), and if you read the Mirage comics (no matter WHICH volume), you'll notice that the guys DON'T exactly tend to talk like Sunday School teachers in THEM, either, most of the time.

TerranigmaFreak
05-20-2009, 03:31 PM
The turtles transforming into dragons.

Cipher
05-20-2009, 04:43 PM
The turtles transforming into dragons.Ya I also think that donatello shud build a flying car in da sewers and the turtles shud go itno cyber space. Cuz that'd be awesome with computer grafix.

Also Karai shud be in it and have like, lotsof angst(!) and luv leo. Leo is angry but he find himself.

And also LAAAAZER GUUUNS!

Vincent
05-21-2009, 11:07 AM
Nothing really needs to come over from the 2k3 show, but some elements could work fine while others didn't even work on the show to begin with.

Could: Saki being a respected businessman (though it would take some very clever writing to deal with his motivations). Hun. Bishop. Stockman working with the Foot. Guardians (possibly even Yoshi being one), Mr Mortu and certain other expansions of the Utrom storyline (not counting Ch'Rell). A number of things that build on the conspiracies and mysteries and such (again, excluding Ch'Rell). The Purple Dragons being a part of the world rather than just making one appearance and then never being mentioned again for years, spite having been referred to as "the toughest street gang on the East Side". Splinter having an active role.

Shouldn't: Utrom Shredder (a.k.a. the previously mentioned Ch'Rell). Shredder's bulky full armor (I've said it before and I'll say it again, less is more, the costume from Vol. 1 #1 was always the best, in terms of style, practicality and by virtue of making Shredder rely more on his skill than on the fact that he's safely covered by a thick metal coating like a coward - he's not Darth Vader and shouldn't try to be, he needs to be as human as possible to be interesting). Silver Sentry & Turtle Titan (Justice Force didn't even work in the comics, IMO, for a number of reasons, so no superheroes please, it detracts from the impact of the turtles both by having weird things out in the open and by taking away the idea that the turtles are fighting a fight that nobody else can or will). Mikey being an anoying and cowardly idiot who never gets any character development and just when it looks like he has learned a lesson, he seems to forget it shortly thereafter. Anything at all from Ninja Tribunal, Fast Forward or Back to the Sewer.

Note that I'm not suggesting that all the "could" elements could be crammed into one movie. Just that they could hypothetically either partially use some of them or sprinkle them over a trilogy or somesuch, if they felt like it, without tainting the new universe, while anything from the "shouldn't" list would be detrimental to the impact of the film(s).

CyberCubed
05-21-2009, 02:24 PM
Also keep in mind this movie is coming out with 2k3 being canceled for 2 years.

The old toon influenced the original trilogy (pizza, April being a reporter), the 2k3 series influenced the 4th movie a tad (you could arguably place Movie 4 in the 2k3 universe sans the different lair), but this movie comes out with no cartoon.

Vincent
05-21-2009, 02:36 PM
Also keep in mind this movie is coming out with 2k3 being canceled for 2 years.

The old toon influenced the original trilogy (pizza, April being a reporter), the 2k3 series influenced the 4th movie a tad (you could http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/imgs/editor/separator.gifarguably place Movie 4 in the 2k3 universe sans the different lair), but this movie comes out with no cartoon.

One should probably also keep in mind that it's possible that Peter Laird and/or the writer (whoever that may turn out to be) may have fallen in love with some aspects introduced or explored further in the 2k3 cartoon and that might end up influencing the movie, much in the way that Pete put the Battle Nexus in vol 4 and Tristan Jones adapted Hun into Tales.

Donny
05-21-2009, 03:35 PM
Both Hun and Agent Bishop could work, but I doubt that we will see them in the movie or any possible sequels.

Ginny
05-21-2009, 04:20 PM
I'd like to see Hun in the new movie.

Jelly Bean
05-21-2009, 06:52 PM
Splinter with a wry sense of humour that likes to poke fun at his sons.

Keldor1578
05-23-2009, 12:33 AM
I could see Ch'rell the utrom Shredder and agent Bishop and also the Rat King as Bishop's Slayer working on film.[

Shred Head
05-23-2009, 02:23 PM
Agent Bishop and 2K3 Rat King probraly should be in it. Agent Bishop was an awesome character who had alot of depth to him and he just seems to be a character who would work great in the movies. Even if the cartoon is gone his character should not be forgotton about. His version of the Rat King would be great since it sticks with the whole mutant Sci Fi stuff. I think that origin would work best for the general audiance.

Also a Baxter thats simular to the 2K3 version one where he works for alot of the badguys and is always trying to betray the main villain so he can do what he wants. Well this isn't exactly 2K3 since the 80's did this to but I think it works. That and it help put April into the Shredder conflict if there going with a more Mirage April.

This how I think the movies should go espceailly if there going for a new trilogy.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Maybe an adapation of the first few issues except throw in baxter as a Shredder minion and have his Mouser robots and Shredder Elite. I think this one showed be kind of a combo of the 2K3 cartoon and first movie. Also Shredder should die at the end of this movie and stay dead. Also some foreshadowing of Karai and Bishop.

TMNT 2: I think an Utrom story would be good but no D'hoonib or Triceratons that stuff is beyond a live action Turtle movie budget will ever get. I think a conflict between Bishop and the Utroms with the Turtles caught up in the middle would be good and work well for the movie that and its something new so the old school fans wont bitch they have seen it before. Also I think Baxter should work for Bishop in this version as well. Maybe gets the robot from the volume 3 comics as the end.

TMNT 3: Adaption of City at War not straying to far from the comic book version. The only thing from 2k3 that could work in this is adding Baxter in the City at War story. Maybe working with a Tech based Foot faction not the Mafia like in 2K3 and then add in the nanotech comic book story from Volume 4.

Thats how I would do the movies and what I would add in from the 2k3 series. The live action movies need to be grounded more in reality or as much as you can with Mutated Turtles who fight ninjas in the shodows of New York City. No going oveboard like massive invasions from alien Triceratops or Superheros flying everwhere or worse yet going into the future or turning into Dragons using magic.

Vincent
05-23-2009, 09:41 PM
I could see Ch'rell the utrom Shredder and agent Bishop and also the Rat King as Bishop's Slayer working on film.[
If I see Ch'rell in the film, I will be hugely disappointed. The Shredder should be human. Makes him more interesting. Makes him more mysterious.
How did he get so skilled? Why is the shredder so inhuman? Why is he so dangerous and fearless? Where does his hate come from? What is his motivation? "Oh, he's just an alien blob in a robotic exoskeleton" is a pretty cop-out answer to those questions, IMO. And the Shredder being human is a perfect contrast both to how inhuman his behavior is and to the fact that the Turtles are not human. Ch'rell was just a bad excuse to keep the Shredder around after getting decapitated. Which, by the way, could have been one of the most awesome moments ever in an American cartoon if he hadn't picked his head up and walked away afterward. Perfect end to a character. Except they went the other way with it and had the Shredder jump the shark before the crowning moment of awesome had even sunk in. They should have just left him dead and never brought him back, and the show would have been so much better for it. Hell, if they had to have an evil utrom take his place, they could just as well have reimagined Krang. Sure, he originated in the OT, but he could still fairly easily be made much more interesting than Ch'rell ever was. And if they desperately needed someone to wear the Shredder armor...hello? Karai, anyone?
Ch'rell was just simply a poorly concieved idea, and should never have been on the show in the first place. So to bring that abomination against storytelling into the new movie would be a huge mistake.
That's just my opinion, but I think it's pretty well motivated.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-24-2009, 11:34 AM
I originally said I didn't want anything from the 2k3 series to be in this movie, but I changed my mind. There's ONE thing I do want, and that's Shredder to be a respected businessman. Other than that, though, I don't think anything else should make it over at all. And I must be one of the few people that doesn't really care much for Hun.

Buslady
05-24-2009, 01:02 PM
Hun and Bishop.

Vincent
05-24-2009, 01:13 PM
I kinda like how Hun motivates Casey. The character has much potential.

Andrew NDB
05-27-2009, 12:13 PM
Absolutely nothing from the 4Kids material. Not a thing.

Keldor1578
05-27-2009, 12:45 PM
Absolutely nothing from the 4Kids material. Not a thing.

I guess only lame pathetic villains from mirage like savanti romero and complete carnage,triceraton should be in future tmnt films.:roll:

Andrew NDB
05-27-2009, 02:56 PM
I guess only lame pathetic villains from mirage like savanti romero and complete carnage,triceraton should be in future tmnt films.:roll:

I'm not aware of any villain named Triceraton.

The other two villains you mention could be in a TMNT movie (though I'm not sure I'd like to see them in a TMNT movie)... but not until after the first movie.

Why are we talking about villains, anyway?

Keldor1578
05-27-2009, 03:30 PM
I'm not aware of any villain named Triceraton.

The other two villains you mention could be in a TMNT movie (though I'm not sure I'd like to see them in a TMNT movie)... but not until after the first movie.

Why are we talking about villains, anyway?

I mean the triceratons as a faction like the foot clan,would you have a problem with Bishop and Hun if they were in a tmnt movie.

Cipher
05-27-2009, 08:28 PM
Absolutely nothing from the 4Kids material. Not a thing.Seems a bit reactionary.

Based on your posts, I think we're on the same boat about the 4Kids cartoon. It's better than it had any right to be, but its eclipsing of the Mirage material is undeserved and ridiculous. It is, for however good it was at its job, a children's action cartoon, and it's irritating when people are too forgiving of it.

BUT - It did make some legitimate contributions to the Turtles mythos, a few of which could translate to film. Among them, the characters of Bishop and Hun. That's about it, though.

I guess only lame pathetic villains from mirage like savanti romero and complete carnage,triceraton should be in future tmnt films.Dude, f*ck you, Complete Carnage is awesome and you know it.

Ryona
05-27-2009, 10:15 PM
Nothing really.... Just real REAL minor details... like maybe an occasional 'what the shell'

No. The Turtles can swear just like normal people. Or not. But they do not need to make puns based on their species.


Thank you, Cipher.
"What the shell" is the dumbest substitute for cursing. Anyone who says "What the shell" ought to be punched in the mouth. Seriously.


Now, back on topic, people already mentioned Hun and Bishop, which I agree with. I also think the Ancient One is definetly a keeper. It was nice seeing who was the master behind Yoshi. And the Ancient One is definetly full of character and charm. Who didn't love that little butterball?

Cipher
05-27-2009, 10:53 PM
And the Ancient One is definetly full of character and charm. Who didn't love that little butterball?Personally, I thought he was absolutely the worst new element of the show. He's a totally irritating stock character.

Also, try to decide if he's Chinese or Japanese. Can't tell? Neither could the show's writers.

Jester
05-27-2009, 10:55 PM
I'm not sure why I this was a to the comic and not in the new movie but if they do it right, Bishop and Hun would be cool.

Doc_ock_4mugen
05-28-2009, 08:20 AM
Thank you, Cipher.
"What the shell" is the dumbest substitute for cursing. Anyone who says "What the shell" ought to be punched in the mouth. Seriously.

Somehow I can see it sneaking into the movie...

Shredder appears and beats the Turtles.
Mike: "What the shell is that thing!"
Raph smacks Mike in the back of the head.
Mike:"Why did ya do that?"
Raph: "For being an idiot..." Raph smacks Mike in the head again.
Mike: "what was that one for?"
Raph: "For getting your ass kicked by..."
Leo: "Raph! Mike! Focus!"
The turtles jump to strike Shredder.
Mike: "Cowabunga!!!"
Raph: "I'm so gonna kick your ass when we get home!"

Vincent
05-28-2009, 09:45 AM
Somehow I can see it sneaking into the movie...

Shredder appears and beats the Turtles.
Mike: "What the shell is that thing!"
Raph smacks Mike in the back of the head.
Mike:"Why did ya do that?"
Raph: "For being an idiot..." Raph smacks Mike in the head again.
Mike: "what was that one for?"
Raph: "For getting your ass kicked by..."
Leo: "Raph! Mike! Focus!"
The turtles jump to strike Shredder.
Mike: "Cowabunga!!!"
Raph: "I'm so gonna kick your ass when we get home!"

And later in the film, Raph is about to smack Mike in the back of the head again, but Mike catches Raph's hand in the air without looking and says "Don't...hit me".
Mike seriously needs some proper character development.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-28-2009, 09:54 AM
"What the shell" is the dumbest substitute for cursing. Anyone who says "What the shell" ought to be punched in the mouth. Seriously.

Well, it was a "shell" of a good hit.

And later in the film, Raph is about to smack Mike in the back of the head again, but Mike catches Raph's hand in the air without looking and says "Don't...hit me".

That does seem a bit more like Mirage Mike. I can picture him getting annoyed from constant head slaps.

Doc_ock_4mugen
05-28-2009, 10:55 AM
And later in the film, Raph is about to smack Mike in the back of the head again, but Mike catches Raph's hand in the air without looking and says "Don't...hit me".
Mike seriously needs some proper character development.

That's perfect!! If the "Don't... hit me." evolves into a Mike/Raph sparring match it would be super mega awesome!

Andrew NDB
05-28-2009, 10:56 AM
Based on your posts, I think we're on the same boat about the 4Kids cartoon. It's better than it had any right to be, but its eclipsing of the Mirage material is undeserved and ridiculous. It is, for however good it was at its job, a children's action cartoon, and it's irritating when people are too forgiving of it.

BUT - It did make some legitimate contributions to the Turtles mythos, a few of which could translate to film. Among them, the characters of Bishop and Hun. That's about it, though.

I just think that when we're talking about a rebooted, relaunched TMNT movie franchise that will hopefully stick closely to the Mirage material... as with most like franchises, we're only talking about potentially three or four new films that might get made. At most.

I'm pretty TPTB can find three or four films worth of material and villains from the Mirage material before they throw their hands up in the air and have to go mining stuff from the toddler spinoff shows.

Ryona
05-28-2009, 11:33 AM
And later in the film, Raph is about to smack Mike in the back of the head again, but Mike catches Raph's hand in the air without looking and says "Don't...hit me".
Mike seriously needs some proper character development.

Agreed. Mikey does need to break out of the dumbass persona he got stuck with. He was annoying in the 2k3 series, and he was such a gimp and even more annoying in the 2007 movie. It's like he just keeps spiralling downward.

I blame the NT: the Next Mutation. That was the beginning of a stupid Mikey.

Mirage Mikey kicks ass, and even Mikey in the original 80s series kicked ass. Sure, he always had the munchies and was spaced out half the times, but he was still badass and took no sh*t from anyone.

If Raph from the 2k3 series smacked Michelangelo from the Mirage comics or 80s tv series, Raph would get a fist in the face. Garanteed.

Keldor1578
05-28-2009, 12:10 PM
I just think that when we're talking about a rebooted, relaunched TMNT movie franchise that will hopefully stick closely to the Mirage material... as with most like franchises, we're only talking about potentially three or four new films that might get made. At most.

I'm pretty TPTB can find three or four films worth of material and villains from the Mirage material before they throw their hands up in the air and have to go mining stuff from the toddler spinoff shows.

Bishop and Hun,Ch'rell are better villains, I hope we never get to see mirage villains like like Savanti Romero and complete carnege or triceratons vs federation, These villain are corny as hell and one dimensional characters to be in a tmnt movies. Do you really believe these lame villains can work a tmnt movies.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-28-2009, 12:31 PM
If Raph from the 2k3 series smacked Michelangelo from the Mirage comics or 80s tv series, Raph would get a fist in the face. Garanteed.

Well, I picture '87 toon Mike probably complaining to Raph and telling him to cut it out (which is more than I can say about 2k3 toon Mike or 2k7 movie Mike), but not outright punching him. Come to think of it, I don't think ANY of the '87 toon Turtles ever punched anyone that wasn't a robotic foot soldier. But Mirage Mike would DEFINITELY punch Raph, no doubt in my mind.

Bishop and Hun,Ch'rell are better villains, I hope we never get to see mirage villains like like Savanti Romero and complete carnege or triceratons vs federation, These villain are corny as hell and one dimensional characters to be in a tmnt movies. Do you really believe these lame villains can work a tmnt movies.

I suppose you're entitled to your opinion and all, no matter how wrong you are. Personally, I think the Triceratons are pretty awesome. I'd love a live-action movie that had the Triceratons as well as the Utroms. If this movie does well, I'm really hoping all those aliens get used for the inevitable sequel. Then the third installment of this reboot can bring things back to Earth with an adaptation of City at War, where we get to see two of the most awesome Mirage villains to date: Karai and the Rat King (I know the Rat King didn't debut in City at War, but that definitely was where he was the most badass).

Keldor1578
05-28-2009, 04:27 PM
Well, I picture '87 toon Mike probably complaining to Raph and telling him to cut it out (which is more than I can say about 2k3 toon Mike or 2k7 movie Mike), but not outright punching him. Come to think of it, I don't think ANY of the '87 toon Turtles ever punched anyone that wasn't a robotic foot soldier. But Mirage Mike would DEFINITELY punch Raph, no doubt in my mind.



I suppose you're entitled to your opinion and all, no matter how wrong you are. Personally, I think the Triceratons are pretty awesome. I'd love a live-action movie that had the Triceratons as well as the Utroms. If this movie does well, I'm really hoping all those aliens get used for the inevitable sequel. Then the third installment of this reboot can bring things back to Earth with an adaptation of City at War, where we get to see two of the most awesome Mirage villains to date: Karai and the Rat King (I know the Rat King didn't debut in City at War, but that definitely was where he was the most badass).

I just think a few characters from the 4kids tmnt cartoon could work like Bishop and Ch'rell,Hun in a tmnt films.There are several mirage character like Savanti Romero and complete Carnage, traceratons are too over the top to work in a tmnt films.

Vincent
05-28-2009, 06:30 PM
I'm pretty TPTB can find three or four films worth of material and villains from the Mirage material before they throw their hands up in the air and have to go mining stuff from the toddler spinoff shows.
The comics weren't movies, though. There's no single issue or arc that could be adapted word-for-word, panel-for-panel, into a feature length movie. The material would need a little bit of fleshing out and restructuring in order to work as a movie, and the 2k3 show did flesh some things out pretty well to make it work as a television series, at least up to the point where the shredder picked his head up from the ground and ruined everything, so I'd say there's an argument to be made for letting some things carry over from the 2k3 show into a movie in some way, such as, for example, the connection between Stockman and the Foot, which would make the story feel more connected, or even the Guardians, who did help make the TCRI storyline quite a bit richer and less random.

Ch'rell
Please. No. Stop saying that. Ch'rell was a horrible idea that ruined everything that made Oroku Saki interesting. Oroku Saki needs, for the sake of drama, for the sake of storytelling, for the sake of contrast, to be human and nothing else. Making him an alien that wants to take over the world (OF COURSE!) takes away all the depth and mystery surrounding Saki's motivations. Putting him in a super-strong robotic exoskeleton makes his skills completely unimpressive. The fact that he is a human who has pushed himself to the limit of human potential for the sake of hate makes him impressive and scary. The fact that he is human also gives him a fascinating contrast to the Turtles, who are not, yet act much more "human" than he does. There are so many reasons why Ch'rell is a bad idea. When Leo decapitates the Shredder, the Shredder should be over. No more Shredder. End of an era. It symbollizes time for the Turtles to move on and grow up. Ch'rell was a travesty of storytelling. A huge mistake. To repeat it would be nothing short of madness.

Cipher
05-28-2009, 06:48 PM
The comics weren't movies, though. There's no single issue or arc that could be adapted word-for-word, panel-for-panel, into a feature length movie.I'll actually maintain that, with minor tweaking, "City at War" is set up fairly well for a feature length movie.


(Stuff about Ch'rell)I like Ch'rell within the context of the 4Kids cartoon. He actually made that Shredder more interesting. Shredder in the 4Kids cartoon was always a boring, "bwahaha!" villain, so at least making him a millenia-old alien with an identy crisis put a wrinkle in his character. It also played with the standard TMNT vs Shredder formula. Whereas normally the Turtles are blood enemies with Saki, here they were merely a strange footnote that began bothering him centuries after his prime.

So, yeah. Ch'rell's alright. But he's not the definitive Shredder, and no way would he translate well into a serious movie.

Andrew NDB
05-28-2009, 07:45 PM
The comics weren't movies, though. There's no single issue or arc that could be adapted word-for-word, panel-for-panel, into a feature length movie. The material would need a little bit of fleshing out and restructuring in order to work as a movie

I feel like I need to explain myself over and over on this, but I will again.

By "staying close to the Mirage material" or "adapting the Mirage material" I am by no means expecting or wanting a literal caption-for-caption adaptation. That would be silly and dumb.

and the 2k3 show did flesh some things out pretty well to make it work as a television series

For little kids, sure.

at least up to the point where the shredder picked his head up from the ground and ruined everything

No... there was a ridiculous helping of cheese and camp added into the pot leading up to and including that.

Vincent
05-28-2009, 10:23 PM
No... there was a ridiculous helping of cheese and camp added into the pot leading up to and including that.
I never said there wasn't. What I did say was that inbetween all the camp and cheese there were also a few genuinely good ideas that could very well be reinterpreted in a more "adult" context and actually add something to the story, in a similar way to how Tristan Jones reimagined Hun for the Mirage universe, thus adding some new depth to the character of Casey Jones. Similarly, one could argue that an adult interpretation of certain other diamond-in-the-rough ideas introduced in the 2k3 show might actually enrich the story and themes of the film and help bind its structure. Say, if they're planning to adapt the TCRI storyline for the ending or a possible sequel, it could be made less of a random Deus Ex WTF by building up some mystery beforehand, for example by using some variation on the Guardians and maybe even tying it together with Yoshi to make the story less disconnected and the mythology richer. Provided they get a writer who knows what they're doing, that is. If poorly executed, it'll be crap no matter what elements are included or where they originated.

Harley Quinn was first introduced in Batman: the Animated Series, but she's now an accepted part of the DC Universe, simply because she turned out to be a pretty fascinating idea when used properly, and I wouldn't say all the comic book storylines she's been in since then have been kid friendly just because she came from a cartoon. It's not where you come from that matters, it's what you bring to the story and how well the writer realizes that.

Again, I should add that I'm not of the opinion that they absolutely should use elements from the 2k3 show. Just suggesting that if reinterpreted and done right, some elements could hypothetically work and even possibly make for a more powerful story.

Keldor1578
05-29-2009, 11:26 AM
I just think that when we're talking about a rebooted, relaunched TMNT movie franchise that will hopefully stick closely to the Mirage material... as with most like franchises, we're only talking about potentially three or four new films that might get made. At most.

I'm pretty TPTB can find three or four films worth of material and villains from the Mirage material before they throw their hands up in the air and have to go mining stuff from the toddler spinoff shows.

Can you tell me which villains from Mirage could work as the main antagonist for future tmnt films.

Andrew NDB
05-29-2009, 11:37 AM
Can you tell me which villains from Mirage could work as the main antagonist for future tmnt films.

The Shredder & the Foot Clan.

The Shredder Elite.

Karai.

Bloodsucker and Old Man River.

The Adversary.

Traquer.

Loki.

Complete Carnage (and no, I probably wouldn't want to include Radical).

Savanti Romero (not my first choice to see in against the TMNT in a movie, but if they ever want to do a time travel romp -- properly, this time -- it would seem logical to include him as the central threat... and yes, he can be done badass).

Triceratons (an all-out Triceraton invasion of Earth might work if done in a realistic fashion, otherwise the original TMNT space odyssey that would culminate with the TMNT in battles-to-the-death in the Triceraton gladitorial arena seems like a sound synopsis for a film).

Don't really want to see Baxter Stockman or Rat King heading up any movies. Baxter could be in like the first 5 minutes of a movie, explaining how the Turtles hook up with April before he's promptly arrested and never seen again. Rat King (who's not even really a villain in the Mirage material) could be in a movie in a supporting role, maybe as some kind of a mentor or kindred spirit for Splinter.

Doc_ock_4mugen
05-29-2009, 04:01 PM
Absolutely nothing from the 4Kids material. Not a thing.
HOLD IT!!

Triceratons (an all-out Triceraton invasion of Earth might work if done in a realistic fashion, otherwise the original TMNT space odyssey that would culminate with the TMNT in battles-to-the-death in the Triceraton gladitorial arena seems like a sound synopsis for a film).

http://i53.photobucket.com/albums/g55/do4m/haruhiobjects.gif
OBJECTION!!!
You want NOTHING from the 4Kids Material yet, the Triceraton invasion of Earth is from the 4Kids version of the TMNT... so much for not "mining stuff from the toddler spinoff shows"
TAKE THAT!!!
I gotta stop playing Ace Attorney games.

Andrew NDB
05-29-2009, 04:03 PM
You want NOTHING from the 4Kids Material yet, the Triceraton invasion of Earth is from the 4Kids version of the TMNT...

No. It's from Volume 2 of the Mirage TMNT.

Thanks for playing, though.

Archon_Turtle
05-29-2009, 04:18 PM
no. It's from volume 2 of the mirage tmnt.

Thanks for playing, though.

zing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

CyberCubed
05-29-2009, 04:48 PM
The reboot is probably going to include Baxter in some form, since April isn't going to be a reporter.

I can see Baxter working for Shredder though like the cartoons did.

Doc_ock_4mugen
05-29-2009, 06:22 PM
The only thing that bothers me is that I wasted a good Phoenix Wright/Haruhi Suzumiya OBJECTION!! gif just to get pwned... just like it usually happens to me while playing the Ace Attorney games...
I humbly accept my defeat...

The Terror of Death
05-30-2009, 02:53 AM
I wanna see The Green Mantle and Garbageman in this movie. Hell, they should give Cody Jones a cameo.

Vivi
06-01-2009, 09:01 AM
Bishop. Hun. I've always liked Karai's head lackeys though I'm not 100% sure if they're 2K3 exclusive, and it would be great to build up more identifiable characters in the foot. The rivalry caused by 'new blood' in the foot (as the 2k3 show explores) would suit a movie, I feel. Bishop would act as a great antagonist but in a different way to Shredder...complementary,even. The grey area.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
06-09-2009, 09:58 AM
I wanna see The Green Mantle and Garbageman in this movie. Hell, they should give Cody Jones a cameo.

Not sure I'd want to see any of that, personally. :ohwell:

Andrew NDB
06-09-2009, 10:34 PM
I wanna see The Green Mantle and Garbageman in this movie. Hell, they should give Cody Jones a cameo.

Not sure I'd want to see any of that, personally. :ohwell:

For the sake of my faith in humanity I'm choosing to assume that The Terror of Death is just putting one over on us.

shuriken
06-10-2009, 12:14 AM
For the sake of my faith in humanity I'm choosing to assume that The Terror of Death is just putting one over on us.

Ha, melodramatic much?
I don't think the question here is SHOULD these potential movie elements from the 2k3 toon be brought over to the big screen, BUT COULD they be brought over into the big screen and not be horsesh*t.
Because we could argue all we want about it and end up all agreeing on a simple "yes" or "no" (ha all the dromers agreeing on something) or we could see what can elements (stories, characters, character traits) could work in a film without being a convoluted non-sensical mind f*ck.
Personall I think Bishop and the whole Stockman and Foot Alliance could work well in a film. As well as connecting Yoshi to the Gaurdians. Other than that not much. Maybe making the Rat king being a mutant clone of Bishop and having mad ninjitsu skills, but that's just my inner action junkie talking.

johnnyblaze
07-10-2009, 03:26 PM
I don't see what would be wrong with bringing Hun in. Hell, even the Mirage saw him as a character with potential and brought him into their world.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
07-11-2009, 07:02 AM
I don't see what would be wrong with bringing Hun in. Hell, even the Mirage saw him as a character with potential and brought him into their world.

I don't hate him, but I never really cared for him, either. To me, he seems to be a defining element of the 2k3 toon, and for that reason I'm actually a little irritated that he was ported over to the Mirage universe. Someone here has already stated that the 2k3 toon often overshadows the Mirage comic... I think adding Hun to the Mirage universe serves to only push that overshadowing even further.

TMNTD
07-19-2009, 05:07 PM
Hun and Bishop

Baxter working for the Foot.

The Big Bad
07-20-2009, 06:42 AM
Please. No. Stop saying that. Ch'rell was a horrible idea that ruined everything that made Oroku Saki interesting. Oroku Saki needs, for the sake of drama, for the sake of storytelling, for the sake of contrast, to be human and nothing else. Making him an alien that wants to take over the world (OF COURSE!) takes away all the depth and mystery surrounding Saki's motivations. Putting him in a super-strong robotic exoskeleton makes his skills completely unimpressive. The fact that he is a human who has pushed himself to the limit of human potential for the sake of hate makes him impressive and scary. The fact that he is human also gives him a fascinating contrast to the Turtles, who are not, yet act much more "human" than he does. There are so many reasons why Ch'rell is a bad idea. When Leo decapitates the Shredder, the Shredder should be over. No more Shredder. End of an era. It symbollizes time for the Turtles to move on and grow up. Ch'rell was a travesty of storytelling. A huge mistake. To repeat it would be nothing short of madness.

Huh? While I can see why Ch'rell is a divisive character, I think you're seeing waaay too much Mirage version's. Cause you see, I don't see anything like that in the original version of the character, nor do I think the creators intended for him to be anything other than a stock martial arts movie character in a distinctive costume. When it comes to actual personality, I feel either Shredder is as one-note as the other--heck, you can argue that Mirage version fares worse, since the latest version at least lasted long enough to have the appearance of hidden dephts.

I'm pretty TPTB can find three or four films worth of material and villains from the Mirage material before they throw their hands up in the air and have to go mining stuff from the toddler spinoff shows.
You go out of your way to insult the cartoons. Could you tell me why?

Vincent
07-20-2009, 10:22 AM
Huh? While I can see why Ch'rell is a divisive character, I think you're seeing waaay too much Mirage version's. Cause you see, I don't see anything like that in the original version of the character, nor do I think the creators intended for him to be anything other than a stock martial arts movie character in a distinctive costume. When it comes to actual personality, I feel either Shredder is as one-note as the other--heck, you can argue that Mirage version fares worse, since the latest version at least lasted long enough to have the appearance of hidden dephts.
I don't deny that the original Shredder was somewhat underdeveloped. But at least he had mystery and humanity going for him. That's not something to be scoffed at. A dangerous human motivated by actual relatable emotions is almost automatically a more fascinating villain than some canned blob from space who is "just plain evil" and "wants to take over the universe". Might be that a space blob is a bigger threat, but it's not a graspable threat, it doesn't make you think, and wanting to take over the universe is not a relatable motivation. Thirst for power may be relatable on some level, but the idea of taking over the universe is so far out of reach that it doesn't mean anything. It has no emotional impact. Especially when the one wanting to take over the universe has nothing in common with a human being. I could mention Hitler as a real world example. It's mind-boggling how a normal human being could go so completely wrong and do such unspeakably heinous things. If he had simply been a space invader who openly called himself evil, you wouldn't think about it. You'd just go "well he's an evil space alien, what do you expect?".
Do I think the Shredder should be portrayed exactly as in the Mirage comics? Not necessarily. I see nothing wrong with developing the character a bit if it makes the story more powerful. But making him a space blob who wants to take over the universe is very counterproductive in terms of emotional impact. You wouldn't do that to the Joker, for example.
"How did this man go so wrong?" is a very important question. "He's not a man, he's an evil blob, he was wrong to begin with" is a complete cop-out answer.
That's not to say that an evil alien blob will always make for a lousy bad guy. That's not the case at all. You just have to find the impact of it. Connecting it to something that people can relate to. Making it a metaphor or allegory for a part of the human condition. But there are ways of doing that with Krang that would work much better than having the Shredder be an alien. And I'm not saying that as a Krang-apologist. I definitely don't think Krang should be in the movie. But I know a way in which I'd rather see that than Ch'Rell.

Andrew NDB
07-20-2009, 02:54 PM
You go out of your way to insult the cartoons. Could you tell me why?

I don't go out of my way to insult the cartoons. I just feel, at times, it's pertinent to point them out for what they are: they're spinoffs. They're for little kids. They're toy-driven. If any of the preceding three things bother you when I point them out... well, it shouldn't.

Now I'm well aware that one man's garbage is another man's meat, but I think it's important to not lose sight of the fact that the children's cartoons aren't indicative of the original (and continuing) TMNT and the source material comic books.

Keldor1578
07-21-2009, 02:27 AM
The Shredder & the Foot Clan.

The Shredder Elite.

Karai.

Bloodsucker and Old Man River.

The Adversary.

Traquer.

Loki.

Complete Carnage (and no, I probably wouldn't want to include Radical).

Savanti Romero (not my first choice to see in against the TMNT in a movie, but if they ever want to do a time travel romp -- properly, this time -- it would seem logical to include him as the central threat... and yes, he can be done badass).

Triceratons (an all-out Triceraton invasion of Earth might work if done in a realistic fashion, otherwise the original TMNT space odyssey that would culminate with the TMNT in battles-to-the-death in the Triceraton gladitorial arena seems like a sound synopsis for a film).

Don't really want to see Baxter Stockman or Rat King heading up any movies. Baxter could be in like the first 5 minutes of a movie, explaining how the Turtles hook up with April before he's promptly arrested and never seen again. Rat King (who's not even really a villain in the Mirage material) could be in a movie in a supporting role, maybe as some kind of a mentor or kindred spirit for Splinter.

With the exception of Shredder and the Foot,The Mirage turtles's rogues gallery is awful.Karai is not even a villain to begin with,the rest of them are a bunch filler villains.

Vincent
07-21-2009, 09:37 AM
With the exception of Shredder and the Foot,The Mirage turtles's rogues gallery is awful.Karai is not even a villain to begin with,the rest of them are a bunch filler villains.
What about Baxter Stockman? And Bloodsucker, the Adversary and the Rat King may not all technically be villains, but to call them filler or awful is most unfair. Bloodsucker and Adversary made for some of the more compelling stories I've come across, and the Rat King had a very nice subplot.

The Big Bad
07-21-2009, 02:03 PM
I don't deny that the original Shredder was somewhat underdeveloped. But at least he had mystery and humanity going for him. That's not something to be scoffed at.
[...]

Interesting points. I do think you have a point when it comes to the difference in motivation between characters. However, I don't think that Ch'rell's status as an alien was meant to be taken as a reason to think of him as less than human (so to speak), any more than one would with the turtles, Leatherhead, the Triceratons, etc. Heck, given the Utrom's depiction as more-or-less universally noble, "how did he go wrong?" becomes an even more pressing question. I can see countless ways to make the Ch'rell seem as compelling as the other characters you mention (hint: why did he feel the need to adopt Karai?). However, the writers didn't feel the need to go in that direction, which personally, I think worked to make the other characters more compelling. In any case, thanks for answering.

Vincent
07-23-2009, 07:29 AM
Also, I think, much like the Joker's "light" image is a great contrast to Batman's "dark" image, The Shredder being human is a great contrast to the Turtles being...essentially "monsters". It kind of turns the whole "humans fighting monsters" thing on its head and redefines the concept of a monster and the meaning of being human.

The Big Bad
07-23-2009, 02:00 PM
Actually, now that we're on the topic: what exactly makes the Mirage Shredder "evil"? Yes, he's a criminal, but this is seen as value-neutral within the series--it's only treated as a negative when it negatively affects the turtles. He killed Yoshi in revenge, and tried to do the same for the turtles, but this was done within a particular culture wherein this is acceptable, even expected. The only real evil that stands out is killing Tang Shen. Am I missing anything?

Vincent
07-27-2009, 09:36 AM
Actually, now that we're on the topic: what exactly makes the Mirage Shredder "evil"? Yes, he's a criminal, but this is seen as value-neutral within the series--it's only treated as a negative when it negatively affects the turtles. He killed Yoshi in revenge, and tried to do the same for the turtles, but this was done within a particular culture wherein this is acceptable, even expected. The only real evil that stands out is killing Tang Shen. Am I missing anything?

I seem to remember the New York Foot being involved in some quite shady business. Drugs, hired assassins, there may have been something about human trafficking, but that might just have been me reading between the lines. But in terms of motivation and the whole personal vendetta thing, The Shredder was kind of morally ambiguous, which was great. Nobody is just plain evil for the sake of being evil. Everybody thinks they're righteous, no matter how twisted their perspective or atrocious their actions may be. All the subsequent versions of the Shredder have been moustache-twirling "Look at me I'm evil"-evil, which isn't particularly realistic.

Coola Yagami
07-27-2009, 08:47 PM
From what I gathered, similar to the first ep in the OT, Saki ran some kind of business protection agency.... and he would later send out the Foot Ninja to rob the same places he was being hired to protect.