PDA

View Full Version : Are the mirage tmnt rogues gallery are good compare to other superhero comicbook?


Keldor1578
05-27-2009, 06:50 AM
I noticed the turtles in the mirage comic has a very small rogues gallery compare to other superhero comicbook.

TristanHuwJones
05-27-2009, 09:31 AM
Workin' on it... :P

Cipher
05-27-2009, 09:51 AM
No, a few more villains (or better use of existing ones like Complete Carnage) would be appreciated. But then again, TMNT isn't a standard format superhero comic. Can we stop comparing it to them?

Ninjinister
05-27-2009, 10:03 AM
Keep buyin' Tales, folks, and Tristan's master plan may come to fruition.

willtupper
05-27-2009, 04:44 PM
If Tales sells well enough, Tristan's plan to introduce "The Slicer, The Dicer, and The Cutter," ("The Cutter" is the first emo bad guy) all as major villians (they've got knives for hands!) will finally happen.

And Hun will get an evil, diabolical sidekick - named ATTILA! :D

Keep buyin' Tales, folks, and Tristan's master plan may come to fruition.

Andrew NDB
05-27-2009, 05:06 PM
I noticed the turtles in the mirage comic has a very small rogues gallery compare to other superhero comicbook.

The TMNT isn't a superhero comic book. Never has been.

Ninjinister
05-27-2009, 05:20 PM
Quiet you. If you keep telling people that, they might actually believe that.

DrSpengler
05-27-2009, 09:16 PM
Berger himself expressed a disappointment in the TMNT's rogues gallery.

I think they have plenty of good quality villains, but just that they don't use them very frequently. Outside of the Foot-related baddies, I think Savanti Romero is the most frequently used villain in the Mirage comics.

As Andrew NDB pointed out, though, TMNT isn't like Batman. There's no "Arkham Asylum" or what have you where villains can be conveniently stored until future use. The TMNT tend to kill their foes in each encounter, and Mirage typically doesn't have a revolving door death policy.

Still, there's a stable of quality one-shot villains I'd love to see make a comeback, though many of them are from TMNT Vol. 1 issues of questionable canon status.

And then there's all the villains with still-lingering plot threads I'm dying to see resolved...

Keldor1578
05-28-2009, 10:40 AM
Now that Hun is a mirage character, are there any plan to bring Agent Bishop and Ch'rell The Utrom Shredder from the 4kids tmnt cartoon to mirage comic to expan the tmnt rogues gallery.

Ninjinister
05-28-2009, 10:47 AM
Probably not. A Ch'rell-like entity was scene in one panel in an issue of Tales, but he was sans scar, and referred to as a friend.

Tristan's been working on getting a (markedly different) version of Touch & Go to Tales, but that's apparently only if it continues onto next year.

Andrew NDB
05-28-2009, 10:52 AM
Now that Hun is a mirage character, are there any plan to bring Agent Bishop and Ch'rell The Utrom Shredder from the 4kids tmnt cartoon to mirage comic to expan the tmnt rogues gallery.

I honestly would probably stop reading at that point.

Keldor1578
05-28-2009, 12:20 PM
I honestly would probably stop reading at that point.

How do you feel about Hun a character from the 4kids catoon being part of mirage comic.

Raph's Girl
05-28-2009, 01:02 PM
Rogue's Gallery?

Shredder = Dead
Rat King = Well the original one is dead...Splinter is the new one *lol*
Triceratons = No longer enemies to the point that there's a TMNT animated series on the Triceraton homeworlds. :lol:
Savanti Romero = Defeated himself in a way....but yeah...he was like one of their main reacurring villians
Complete Carnage = Leo will kill him sometime in the future....
Foot Clan = Peace treaty of sorts
Hun = Has only just begun his battle with the turtles...
Utromi = I have a feeling we'll be seeing them again

As for no Arkham Asylum. Well in Fast Forward all bad guys they defeated were sent to Riker's Island, which is the Marvel's version of Arkham for the minor bad guys (major ones of course get sent to another demension)

Andrew NDB
05-28-2009, 01:44 PM
How do you feel about Hun a character from the 4kids catoon being part of mirage comic.

I hate the concept and even the reasoning behind it, but Tristan made him suitably badass and set far enough away from the toddler version.

Lordmylar06
05-28-2009, 02:03 PM
Since in vol. 4 the Turtles can move about in society kinda freely, I think it would be cool to see them alienated again in some way, some sort of conflict. I dunno, maybe a war with natural earthlings vs. aliens? The turtles wouldn't fit in either category, and I'm sure the turtles would have differing opinions on who was right, or even if they'd take part. They'd probably go back into hiding, but while being hunted. Their rogues gallery would include MOST humans.

Dragon Turtle
05-28-2009, 07:26 PM
Now that Hun is a mirage character, are there any plan to bring Agent Bishop and Ch'rell The Utrom Shredder from the 4kids tmnt cartoon to mirage comic to expan the tmnt rogues gallery.


I could see Agent Bishop introduced into the Mirage universe, especially given the direction of Vol. 4. But it is not number of antagonists the turtles have, but the quality, the turtles need at least 2 or 3 villains that can really challenge them physically and mentally, who can push the stagnant plots and direction of the Mirage universe forward.

I could personally care less where these characters come from, either another existing TMNT universe, completely new, or even preexisting villains Mirage has already introduced. Right now Hun is the most interesting villain the turtles got going, and hes only been around for one issue.

Mr._Mutant_Man
05-28-2009, 09:30 PM
I hate the concept and even the reasoning behind it, but Tristan made him suitably badass and set far enough away from the toddler version.

I'd say the new TMNT cartoon is a little more than just "toddler". It's not like the turtles were like the Rugrats, with Hun kicking them out of the sandbox or stealing their milk money.:ohwell:

With the way the Mirage TMNT is written, there has never really been a need for a "rogue's gallery". The comic seems to often be about different adventures as opposed to fighting the same people over and over. A lot of their enemies seemed to come back for an additional story line, but that was about it.

Newton Gimmick
05-28-2009, 09:36 PM
I think it's silly and a bit nieve to complain where the Turtles villains origins come from. (And that's not a shot at you Andrew)

It's like Laird's stance against Rocksteady and Bebop. You can't tell me that those two characters couldn't be reinvented into total badasses. But because they came from that silly cartoon, they can't be touched? Nonsense.

It's like saying Batman can't be tough because of the 1960's show.

There were some good villains in the Image run as well, but Mirage kicked them out.

I think the Foot represent an interesting Rogues Gallery as it were, because they could at any time continue to hassle the Turtles and take on a variety of forms.

Andrew NDB
05-28-2009, 10:37 PM
I'd say the new TMNT cartoon is a little more than just "toddler".

All right, a little. Fair is fair.

willtupper
05-28-2009, 11:51 PM
Not Ch'rell.

Just an utrom who's tight w / the Turtles.

That was all.

EDIT: emperorzod, I love the redundancy of this thread title. Like anyone is going to say, "Yeah, the Mirage TMNT rogues gallery is good. But the DC and Marvel TMNT rogues gallery totally blow, dude!" :)

Probably not. A Ch'rell-like entity was scene in one panel in an issue of Tales, but he was sans scar, and referred to as a friend.

Tristan's been working on getting a (markedly different) version of Touch & Go to Tales, but that's apparently only if it continues onto next year.

willtupper
05-29-2009, 12:07 AM
I forgot to mention...

this terrible trio will be called THE GINSU GANG! :o

Edit: Sorry for the double-post!

Edit-edit: Not really sorry, to be perfectly honest. Just being polite :P.

If Tales sells well enough, Tristan's plan to introduce "The Slicer, The Dicer, and The Cutter," ("The Cutter" is the first emo bad guy) all as major villians (they've got knives for hands!) will finally happen.

Keldor1578
05-29-2009, 11:12 AM
I think it's silly and a bit nieve to complain where the Turtles villains origins come from. (And that's not a shot at you Andrew)

It's like Laird's stance against Rocksteady and Bebop. You can't tell me that those two characters couldn't be reinvented into total badasses. But because they came from that silly cartoon, they can't be touched? Nonsense.

It's like saying Batman can't be tough because of the 1960's show.

There were some good villains in the Image run as well, but Mirage kicked them out.

I think the Foot represent an interesting Rogues Gallery as it were, because they could at any time continue to hassle the Turtles and take on a variety of forms.

Andrew is a mirage purist who believe any characters that were not created from mirage are just for kids.Both Bishop and Ch'rell are bigger badasses than all mirage tmnt rouge gallery.Mirage have their share of lame villains,but because they were from mirage he believe their not for kids.

Andrew NDB
05-29-2009, 11:17 AM
I have every confidence Christopher Nolan could bring in King Tut from the Batman 60s TV show and do a badass version of him in a sequel to the Dark Knight... but the simple fact is, it shouldn't be done.

Andrew is a mirage purist who believe any characters that were not created from mirage are just for kids.

You're a delusioned individual if you believe that either TMNT cartoon was made for anyone other than little children. Characters created for said shows are, ergo, for kids (that adults find aspects of them endearing is neither here nor there). It's not a difficult equation.

Though that's not even the point.

Keldor1578
05-29-2009, 11:39 AM
I have every confidence Christopher Nolan could bring in King Tut from the Batman 60s TV show and do a badass version of him in a sequel to the Dark Knight... but the simple fact is, it shouldn't be done.



You're a delusioned individual if you believe that either TMNT cartoon was made for anyone other than little children. Characters created for said shows are, ergo, for kids (that adults find aspects of them endearing is neither here nor there). It's not a difficult equation.

Though that's not even the point.

It doens't change the fact the Mirage tmnt has their of corny villains.

TristanHuwJones
05-29-2009, 11:53 AM
Yeah, that's a good point right there. A number of the Mirage villains are just as maleable, and just because something is geared towards kids doesn't mean that the villains aren't any good, or can't be brought across appropriately. There are a ton of villains in 2k3 that could be transplanted into the Mirage continuity without causing any kind of rifts. If anything, I'd say that until Fast Forward came along, the 2k3 series was pretty much on par with the comics tonally (sans the graphic violence). Sure the stories in the comics were OFTEN better (not always, but that's what time does), but I'd say tonally, they were close. I think Sho'Kanabo's storyline and a couple of the FF ones were a little more sophisticated than they probably should have been, but the execution of those stories (the jokes, etc.) brought them down to being accessible for kids.

Andrew NDB
05-29-2009, 11:56 AM
It doens't change the fact the Mirage tmnt has their of corny villains.

They have some, sure, but the key is in their portrayal.

But if you want to compare apples to apples, what kind of ratio of halfway decent villains to cornball toddler-pandering villains do all the universes outside of the Mirage universe have? For every Hun there's a dozen Garbage Men or Bonesteels.

Andrew NDB
05-29-2009, 12:00 PM
Yeah, that's a good point right there. A number of the Mirage villains are just as maleable, and just because something is geared towards kids doesn't mean that the villains aren't any good, or can't be brought across appropriately

It still doesn't mean it needs to be done.

If the Mirage universe is truly so hard up that it just has to start mining material from the children's cartoons that are its polar opposite... it honestly doesn't deserve to continue.

Dragon Turtle
05-29-2009, 02:45 PM
It still doesn't mean it needs to be done.

If the Mirage universe is truly so hard up that it just has to start mining material from the children's cartoons that are its polar opposite... it honestly doesn't deserve to continue.

The Mirage universe doesn't need to mine anything, but there is no legitimate reason why, under their own volition, Mirage couldn't decide to bring in these characters over themselves, such as how they have already done with Hun and Cudley the Cowlick. I don't see how even characters like Bebop, Rocksteady, or Krang could destroy the fabric of the Mirage universe, if those characters were rewritten for Mirage continuity. If Batman could use characters and story ideas from a children's cartoon, the Ninja turtles can as well.

Cipher
05-29-2009, 02:54 PM
If anything, I'd say that until Fast Forward came along, the 2k3 series was pretty much on par with the comics tonally (sans the graphic violence). Sure the stories in the comics were OFTEN better (not always, but that's what time does), but I'd say tonally, they were close.Woah, couldn't disagree more. If you think we'd ever get a "Sons of the Silent Age" out of the 4Kids cartoon, you're way off. (I know they actually did adapt that issue. And they made it unbelievably sh*tty.)

The cartoon did a decent job with adapting the straight action stories. The one plot I thought was actually better handled by the show was the Triceraton space arc. But the tone of the comics involves a lot more than "look, ninja action!"

This isn't really here or there to the "is adapting cartoon characters morally bankrupt" discussion. I'm pretty ambivalent about that. It's just a little tid-bit I decided to jump on.

TristanHuwJones
05-29-2009, 07:17 PM
It still doesn't mean it needs to be done.

If the Mirage universe is truly so hard up that it just has to start mining material from the children's cartoons that are its polar opposite... it honestly doesn't deserve to continue.

Point of what I was saying was that 2k3 is hardly the polar opposite. If you hadda been talking Next Mutation or Old Toon, sure I'd agree, but 2k3 is hardly what you're claiming it to be here.

And no, nothing needs to be done, but I personally get a kick out of seeing familiar faces made use to their full potential.

Here's who I reckon would work EASILY and without tipping the scales of that gritty, play-for-real aspect of the comics without too much alteration (like Hun):

Nano
The Ultimate Ninja
Abigail Fin (the monster hunter)
Dr. Malignus
Touch and Go
Dr. Chaplin
That thing from The Darkness Within
Drako
Turk and his gang
Bishop
The Spiderfreak from Dragon's Brew
Mephos
The Ancient One
The Councilor and the lizard men from Trouble with Augie
the Mokusei-no-Bushis from The Ninja Tribunal
Sho'Konabo
Inuwashi Gunjin
Torbin Zixx
Viral
The Street Phantoms

Of course, you could give them a complete overhaul. If people read between the lines over at my blog they'll see what I'm talking about. But if you were going to completely overhaul villains and transplant them into the Mirage Proper universe, then you could take just about anyone and make them work.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying it should or shouldn't be done. I'm all for it if it works for the comics and is done right, but I do like seeing comic-exclusive villains as well.

TristanHuwJones
05-29-2009, 07:21 PM
The Mirage universe doesn't need to mine anything, but there is no legitimate reason why, under their own volition, Mirage couldn't decide to bring in these characters over themselves, such as how they have already done with Hun and Cudley the Cowlick. I don't see how even characters like Bebop, Rocksteady, or Krang could destroy the fabric of the Mirage universe, if those characters were rewritten for Mirage continuity. If Batman could use characters and story ideas from a children's cartoon, the Ninja turtles can as well.

King Tut was just brought into Batman's continuity just recently too. Haven't read it yet, but I was told it worked.

Andrew NDB
05-29-2009, 07:41 PM
And no, nothing needs to be done, but I personally get a kick out of seeing familiar faces made use to their full potential.

I believe it. It probably would feel a bit self-gratifying if the writer was a big fan of the cartoon, wouldn't it?

Nano
The Ultimate Ninja
Abigail Fin (the monster hunter)
Dr. Malignus
Touch and Go
Dr. Chaplin
That thing from The Darkness Within
Drako
Turk and his gang
Bishop
The Spiderfreak from Dragon's Brew
Mephos
The Ancient One
The Councilor and the lizard men from Trouble with Augie
the Mokusei-no-Bushis from The Ninja Tribunal
Sho'Konabo
Inuwashi Gunjin
Torbin Zixx
Viral
The Street Phantoms

Violently opposed to ever seeing many of those in Mirage.

But if you were going to completely overhaul villains and transplant them into the Mirage Proper universe, then you could take just about anyone and make them work.

But if you have to "completely overhaul" said villains in order to transplant them (and no mistake about it, you would have to completely overhaul them, or at least to a large extent)... why bother at all? Why f*** with something created not only by someone else, but for an entirely different milleau? I don't mean to sound rude, but it smacks of a bit of self-indulgance... a bit of the old, "Let's see what I can salvage from the 4Kids cartoon I like" instead of, "What can I come up with that's original that would be badass and be what's best for the Mirage universe?"

The whole thing begins to feel like fanfiction, or fanwank at a certain point if we're now on a monorail that's heading nonstop towards Cartoon Import City. I'll be honest, Tristan, it's beginning to sound like you have a bit of an agenda at play and I'm not sure it's one that I like.

Let me temper this post by saying that I love what you did with Hun in Tales. Let's see more of your version of him... but beyond him, let well enough alone. Bro, we all know you're a talented, creative creator... now let's see some creatin'.

Newton Gimmick
05-29-2009, 07:51 PM
A lot of the villains wouldn't need a "complete overhaul" at all. You could minorly tweak any of the cartoon characters and they could be viable Mirage characters. In some cases very, very miniscule tweaks.

Again the whole idea that someone came from the cartoon and now can't be taken serious, is foolish. If you can't take something serious because of where the idea came from, then you yourself can't be taken serious. Especially when at the crux of things, we're talking about mutant ninja... turtles.

And the whole "toddler" thing needs to stop. Toddlers are 2 to 3 years old. NONE of the cartoon versions were that demographic. They're the 6-13 demo. Which interestingly, used to be the main demo for comic books. Although it's not anymore, because the comics medium is largely dead. But that's another issue altogether.

Andrew NDB
05-29-2009, 07:55 PM
Again the whole idea that someone came from the cartoon and now can't be taken serious, is foolish

No. It's just a little bit short of being creatively bankrupt.

Newton Gimmick
05-29-2009, 08:02 PM
I'm all for creating new ideas. I think that's great, honestly.

But using other characters, recreating them or reimagining them is one of the staples of comics, movies and television and has been since the creation of time. So I'm not sure why it bothers you so, unless it's just a biased you have specifically against the TMNT toons. And I'm purely speculating there, so feel free to explain.

But I mean, reinterpretation of other characters is a stand by in EVERY medium. Smallville, as an example is a reinterpretation of Superman (Whether you like it or not) and it's certainly not "creatively bankrupt" even though it's using tons of previous ideas done in a new fashion.

People have been retelling the story of Hercules since the beginning of recorded history.

There have been thousands of versions of Batman, the Joker, etc...

I don't see how TMNT is any different in that respect.

TristanHuwJones
05-29-2009, 08:11 PM
I believe it. It probably would feel a bit self-gratifying if the writer was a big fan of the cartoon, wouldn't it?

I'm not a big fan of the cartoon. In fact, I'm just barely a fan of the cartoon. I was actually amazingly bored by 2k3. I thought there were some good ideas, but hardly any of them utilized to their full potential.


Violently opposed to ever seeing many of those in Mirage.


A bit of an extreme reaction. You were the same about Hun...


But if you have to "completely overhaul" said villains in order to transplant them (and no mistake about it, you would have to completely overhaul them, or at least to a large extent)... why bother at all? Why f*** with something created not only by someone else, but for an entirely different milleau? I don't mean to sound rude, but it smacks of a bit of self-indulgance... a bit of the old, "Let's see what I can salvage from the 4Kids cartoon I like" instead of, "What can I come up with that's original that would be badass and be what's best for the Mirage universe?"


There might be some self indulgence, but I can tell you straight up that that wasn't the case when I said I wanted to use Hun. I had a story I wanted to tell and I thought Hun would make an excellent piece to that story.

Besides, what's wrong with self indulgence in creators if you get a good story on the other side? Look at what Bendis has done with Ultimate Spiderman and the whole "Spiderman and his Amazing Friends" deal. He was completely up front about how self indulgent it was, but it was still a great read and didn't do any sort of damage to the book in any way.

I know for a fact that there's far more self indulgence involved in creating your own characters and using them than using Hun. Using Hun is a ******** of fun, but characters like Razorback, King Cobra, and November's Burning Man are far more satisfying.

What's best is an entirely different can of worms and completely subjective in a fan forum too.

The whole thing begins to feel like fanfiction, or fanwank at a certain point if we're now on a monorail that's heading nonstop towards Cartoon Import City.

That's exactly what's happening. The Mirage comics are slowly transforming into the 2k3 cartoon.:roll: Get a grip man! All we've had so far is the Battle Nexus, which was completely different to the cartoon one, and Hun.

I'll be honest, Tristan, it's beginning to sound like you have a bit of an agenda at play and I'm not sure it's one that I like.

Then I'll be honest and say that you're paranoid. My "agenda" is pretty apparent, and it is about as far from what you seem to think it is as you can get.

All I'm doing is playing Devil's Advocate here. It reads like you're being OVERLY volatile and shutting yourself of from what could be fantastic reading. It could be complete ****, but you don't know that until it comes out. To be completely honest, if Tales #35 was Mirage's Rat King origin, then give me the 2k3 origin any day of the week. It's far closer to what I imagined the Rat King's origin being (but still pretty distant).

Let me temper this post by saying that I love what you did with Hun in Tales. Let's see more of your version of him... but beyond him, let well enough alone. Bro, we all know you're a talented, creative creator... now let's see some creatin'.

If you did a bit of reading and saw what I've got in the pipeline then you wouldn't have even needed to write any of that. June is more Hun and more NEW CHARACTERS, August the Razorbacks and Mousers are back as is Whitmire and Diamondback, November is MORE NEW VILLAINS and more of the ones I've been using. If I get any stories in next year then it'll be more development of my "agenda" and the characters I've already laid out.

Dragon Turtle
05-29-2009, 10:17 PM
But if you have to "completely overhaul" said villains in order to transplant them (and no mistake about it, you would have to completely overhaul them, or at least to a large extent)... why bother at all?



Actually, looking at most of the characters from the 2k3 series, I don't see a complete overhaul being necessary, even Hun (based on one issue) isn't a major overhaul from his 2k3 version.



Why f*** with something created not only by someone else, but for an entirely different milleau? I don't mean to sound rude, but it smacks of a bit of self-indulgance... a bit of the old, "Let's see what I can salvage from the 4Kids cartoon I like" instead of, "What can I come up with that's original that would be badass and be what's best for the Mirage universe?"





Creating a new characters and concepts (or building on preexisting ones)is great, and I would be the first to welcome them with open arms, but if a writer likes a character and thinks he can take that character and write interesting story with him, to me there is nothing wrong with that, it certainly doesn't mean writers are not allowed to come up with their own ideas. You can be allowed to do both, just as long as the end result is a good story.

Cipher
05-29-2009, 10:36 PM
I think the importing of characters depends entirely on the situation.

If a writer sits down and says, "Let's see what I can do with Bebop," yeah, that's a bit brankrupt. It's just tweaking someone else's character to make them fit their own story. Why?

On the other hand, if a writer designs a script, looks at it, and says, "Geeze, this character's basically Bebop, isn't it?" They might as well make it a new version of Bebop, so people won't question their intentions and they'll get that little homage kick in there. Nothing wrong with that.

I just can't be that bothered by the importing of characters within the same franchise. Silver Sentry? That's the bottom of the creative barrel. The Ancient One? Right there as well. They were probably meant to be homages, but instead they were played as the worst sorts of rip-offs/archetypes. Creating dead-weight characters ripped off from other fiction is creatively bankrupt. I'm much more tolerable of in-franchise imports as a nod to the property's history.

On a less related note, seriously Trist, The Ancient One? What on God's green Earth makes you think he's interesting, original, enjoyable, or workable? Also, quiz time: Is he Chinese or Japanese?

TristanHuwJones
05-29-2009, 11:31 PM
I think the importing of characters depends entirely on the situation.

That's essentially why I picked out Hun. He serves a purpose.

On a less related note, seriously Trist, The Ancient One? What on God's green Earth makes you think he's interesting, original, enjoyable, or workable? Also, quiz time: Is he Chinese or Japanese?

The idea of the character is an interesting one, but only in relation to certain other aspects. I hate the character as he is in the TV show. He stinks of Yoda and pandering (the farts?). Or even putting like a has-been twist on him would make him more interesting -- like he USED to be this incredibly skilled warrior, but somewhere along the road something went wrong and he just stopped caring. Like I said, you'd need to change him, but he'd still be a workable concept.

Just going back to this Andrew:

Violently opposed to ever seeing many of those in Mirage.

Which ones, and why?

Andrew NDB
05-29-2009, 11:33 PM
I'm all for creating new ideas. I think that's great, honestly.

But using other characters, recreating them or reimagining them is one of the staples of comics, movies and television and has been since the creation of time. So I'm not sure why it bothers you so, unless it's just a biased you have specifically against the TMNT toons. And I'm purely speculating there, so feel free to explain.

But I mean, reinterpretation of other characters is a stand by in EVERY medium. Smallville, as an example is a reinterpretation of Superman (Whether you like it or not) and it's certainly not "creatively bankrupt" even though it's using tons of previous ideas done in a new fashion.

People have been retelling the story of Hercules since the beginning of recorded history.

There have been thousands of versions of Batman, the Joker, etc...

I don't see how TMNT is any different in that respect.

I'm not sure you're reading me correctly. My problem is with the reverse-proliferation of said characters... some spinoff Elseworlds thing like Smallville has carte blanche to do whatever they want with the Superman family and its franchise.

Now, if a bunch of characters and stuff from the show reverse-proliferated back into the comic books from Smallville... this is where I have a problem.

And I'm by no means saying Tristan is the first one to do something like this, or will even be the last. I just find it's a little bit lacking in creativity and when you dig deep, actually just seems pretty self-gratifying and the equivalent of rubbing oneself off in public.

I'm not a big fan of the cartoon. In fact, I'm just barely a fan of the cartoon. I was actually amazingly bored by 2k3.

That's not really consistant with the lion's share of the posts I've seen from you about the show.

Now, I'm not saying you've ever raved about the show, but you've certainly sung its share of praises. Particularly your clamoring that so many of the 4Kids episodes are so close to their namesake comics is eyebrow-raising indeed.

A bit of an extreme reaction. You were the same about Hun...

And I'm willing to grin and bear it as a one-off thing... if things are to become "Tales of Tristan's Refurbished Cartoon Villains™" in a continuing manner, though, that's really not a thing I want any part of.

There might be some self indulgence, but I can tell you straight up that that wasn't the case when I said I wanted to use Hun. I had a story I wanted to tell and I thought Hun would make an excellent piece to that story.

Yeah, I know. And it was Pete who offered him, you said.

Not accusing here. I'm only wary of where you want to go from here, since you seem to be championing this movement toward revisiting cartoon villains so much lately.

Besides, what's wrong with self indulgence in creators if you get a good story on the other side? Look at what Bendis has done with Ultimate Spiderman and the whole "Spiderman and his Amazing Friends" deal. He was completely up front about how self indulgent it was, but it was still a great read and didn't do any sort of damage to the book in any way.

Don't read Spider-Man so I can't really comment on this on one side of the fence or another.

If you want a good example of self-indulgance hurting a project, though, you have to look no further than Frank Miller's "The Dark Knight Strikes Again" or even "All-Star Batman."

Or pretty much anything Judd Winnick has ever written in comics.

I know for a fact that there's far more self indulgence involved in creating your own characters and using them than using Hun.

Hm. Could you elaborate on this? Because I really am at a loss for how creating a new character is self-indulgant.

If Hun was already a Mirage character using him wouldn't be self-indulgant. The fact is, he didn't exist in it until you shoe-horned him on in (nicely, I'll admit, nicely).

That's exactly what's happening. The Mirage comics are slowly transforming into the 2k3 cartoon.:roll: Get a grip man! All we've had so far is the Battle Nexus, which was completely different to the cartoon one, and Hun.

We don't know what the heck is up with that yet.

Then I'll be honest and say that you're paranoid. My "agenda" is pretty apparent, and it is about as far from what you seem to think it is as you can get.

It's not actually paranoia if they're really out to get you... or in this case, you pretty much publically declaring intent to put on a hardhat, grab a pickaxe, and dive into the children's cartoons for "new" villains for Mirage.

All I'm doing is playing Devil's Advocate here. It reads like you're being OVERLY volatile

I wouldn't say so. I'm just not interested in said movement.

Coupled with an already waning general interest in the direction of things in Tales and out (outside of things like your and Dan's issues)... it could well be the straw that broke the camel's back.

It could be complete ****, but you don't know that until it comes out. To be completely honest, if Tales #35 was Mirage's Rat King origin, then give me the 2k3 origin any day of the week. It's far closer to what I imagined the Rat King's origin being (but still pretty distant).

To be honest, I hate both origins and picking one would be like picking which obese chick I want to bone. I rather liked the "origin" as it was pretty much described in the Palladium material.

If you did a bit of reading and saw what I've got in the pipeline then you wouldn't have even needed to write any of that. June is more Hun and more NEW CHARACTERS, August the Razorbacks and Mousers are back as is Whitmire and Diamondback, November is MORE NEW VILLAINS and more of the ones I've been using. If I get any stories in next year then it'll be more development of my "agenda" and the characters I've already laid out.

So no children's spinoff stuff beyond Hun? Then I have no quarrel.

Actually, looking at most of the characters from the 2k3 series, I don't see a complete overhaul being necessary, even Hun (based on one issue) isn't a major overhaul from his 2k3 version.

Maybe not, but if Hun on the children's show was at a 6 O'Clock nitrous level, the comic book kicks it up to midnight.

It'd be like... if Rocksteady appeared in the comics tomorrow, and actually started shooting and killing people with his machine gun. Maybe that doesn't qualify as a "complete overhaul," but I'd certainly call that a pretty fundamental change in the character -- so why not just make a new mutant that wields a machine gun? #1) You can contribute something new to the pantheon of the comics that will be all yours, #2) You won't step on the toes of a villain -- someone else's -- that wasn't really ever intended to be seen in the light you want to drag him to.

I think the importing of characters depends entirely on the situation.

If a writer sits down and says, "Let's see what I can do with Bebop," yeah, that's a bit brankrupt. It's just tweaking someone else's character to make them fit their own story. Why?

Yeah, absolutely. If the creative process begins with, "How can I import Nano into a story?" then that's pretty much when I grab a torch and go to Australia. :)

But I don't think that's what we're talking about here.

On the other hand, if a writer designs a script, looks at it, and says, "Geeze, this character's basically Bebop, isn't it?" They might as well make it a new version of Bebop, so people won't question their intentions and they'll get that little homage kick in there. Nothing wrong with that.

But if a writer keeps doing that (retooling cartoon characters) to fit their stories over and over again (in the name of, "Well, I needed a Bishop/Nano/fill-in-the-blank-like villain in this story, so I just went ahead and used Bishop/Nano/fill-in-the-blank villain)... it kind of becomes a sham and we can call the writer out on it, can't we?

Again, not pointing a finger at Tristan. It doesn't sound like I have much to worry about.

Archon_Turtle
05-29-2009, 11:34 PM
Which ones, and why?

Violent Opposition is kind of Andrew's shtick :-P

Ninjinister
05-30-2009, 12:14 AM
lol, this reminds me of the episode of Batman: The Brave & The Bold from earlier tonight.

TristanHuwJones
05-30-2009, 12:27 AM
[QUOTE]And I'm by no means saying Tristan is the first one to do something like this, or will even be the last. I just find it's a little bit lacking in creativity and when you dig deep, actually just seems pretty self-gratifying and the equivalent of rubbing oneself off in public.

As far as character creation, yeah it is kind of an easy out, but if you take the characters and do good things with them, like Harley and X23, I have no beef and the creative bankruptcy argument is kinda moot. Ultimately you're telling a story. Any goonbag can come up with a character (Robert Liefeld) but the character isn't **** without a decent writer behind it (Fabien Nicieza).

That's not really consistant with the lion's share of the posts I've seen from you about the show.

I think my intentions may be being misinterpreted here. Most of my praises come from the fact that we have them. There was a considerable amount of unwarranted disdain being geared at the show as it went on, then there was this retroactive love for it when Fast Forward came around. It's like how people enjoy Fast Forward now that BTTS is what we have. Overall, it wasn't a bad show. But by season 3, I was completely bored by it.

I will say that I did have fun watching Fast Forward though. I was disappointed by the Lost Season, but thought there were good ideas. Really didn't like the Triceraton invasion, or many of the Triceraton related episodes to be honest... and I love Triceratons! The first couple of seasons always started out well, but then dropped substantially as the seasons went on.

Particularly your clamoring that so many of the 4Kids episodes are so close to their namesake comics is eyebrow-raising indeed.

Just because they're close to the comics tonally doesn't mean I'm still a raving fan of the show. I get my kicks from the comics when it comes to turtles. Comics and the first movie. That doesn't mean I can't say that there are aspects of a show that people seem to selectively overlook when jumping on it for others. I didn't particularly enjoy The Batman, but that doesn't mean I can't sing the praises of what I thought was good about it.



And I'm willing to grin and bear it as a one-off thing... if things are to become "Tales of Tristan's Refurbished Cartoon Villains™" in a continuing manner, though, that's really not a thing I want any part of.

You want to see what's coming up, click my blog link and have a back-read.

Not accusing here. I'm only wary of where you want to go from here, since you seem to be championing this movement toward revisiting cartoon villains so much lately.

My "agenda" REVOLVES, absolutely REVOLVES around the Shredder. Not Oroku Saki, but the mantle of the Shredder. The person you need to keep an eye on is Lin. This isn't just directed at you Andrew, it's towards everyone, but people need to look between the lines. Why would Lin spring Hun from jail? She's part of a group dedicated to the Shredder. The man who Hun hates more than anyone. Hun is possibly more anti-Foot Clan than the Turtles and Splinter. And that's a big clue as how he fits in. The direction of things is pretty obvious when you read #36 and #56 back to back, and it's gonna be made amazingly clear come the last page of #64. There are some little things written into the linking stories that are very specific. The appearance of the Foot in #59 is something to pay attention to as well.



Don't read Spider-Man so I can't really comment on this on one side of the fence or another.

If you want a good example of self-indulgance hurting a project, though, you have to look no further than Frank Miller's "The Dark Knigth Strikes Again" or even "All-Star Batman."

I'm on the other side of the fence with All-Star. I knew it'd be self indulgent ********, because Miller said it would be from the start. We already have Dick's origin, this is just another no holds barred romp. I will agree with DKR though.


Or pretty much anything Judd Winnick has ever written in comics.

BOO! The only thing he did wrong with Batman was how he brought Jason Todd back to life. Superboy Prime?!



Hm. Could you elaborate on this? Because I really am at a loss for how creating a new character is self-indulgant.

It's your character!! King Cobra's appearance in #64, Lauren Stanton in #59 and Razorback coming back in #61 were ridiculously fun to write to the point I would consider it self-indulgent. If people enjoy it, then that's cool too, but I had an insane amount of fun with those specific pieces.

If Hun was already a Mirage character using him wouldn't be self-indulgant.
How so? Isn't any character choice by a writer an act of self indulgence?

The fact is, he didn't exist in it until you shoe-horned him (nicely, I'll admit, nicely).
Thanks dude, :) I get what you're saying though.


We don't know what the heck is up with that yet.


Exactly my point here.

It's not actually paranoia if they're really out to get you... or in this case, you pretty much publically declaring intent to put on a hat, grab a pickaxe, and dive into the children's cartoons for "new" villains for Mirage.

Except that we know this isn't what's happening.

Coupled with an already waning interest in the direction of things in Tales and out (outside of things like your and Dan's issues)... it could well be the straw that broke the camel's back.

Yeah, but Dan and I both said this... the problem with Tales is the format more so than the stories.


To be honest, I hate both origins and picking one would be like picking which obese chick I want to bone. I liked the "origin" as it was pretty much dsecribed in the Palladium material.

I don't hate the 2k3 one (though I REALLY, really don't like the comic one and am constantly baffled by it), as it's something more in line with the way I'd imagined him coming to being. What was the Palladium one?


So no children's spinoff stuff beyond Hun? Then I have no quarrel.

I do have a couple of girls who I want to use the Touch and Go alias for, but that's as far as it goes. Purely because it just works WAY too well for them ;)

It'd be like... if Rocksteady appeared in the comics tomorrow, and actually started shooting and killing people with his machine gun. Maybe that doesn't qualify as a "complete overhaul," but I'd certainly call that a pretty fundamental change in the character -- so why not just make a new mutant that wields a machine gun?

What if said character was only to appear once, and once only? People would accuse it of being a rip-off of Rocksteady and it'd just be a throwaway, which is what so many people complain about with Tales. You could at least give that story some resonance by making it a one off with a character people will get excited about and leave it at that, kinda like the FCBD/Anniversary year One-Shot I pitched.

I think the importing of characters depends entirely on the situation.

If a writer sits down and says, "Let's see what I can do with Bebop," yeah, that's a bit brankrupt. It's just tweaking someone else's character to make them fit their own story. Why?

I think what you mean to say is it's just that thing of trying to come up with a story to suit a character. I didn't say "I want to use Hun, better come up with a story to suit him". If I had've, then yeah, that'd be a problem. Same with the Bebop and Rocksteady story. I actually had a pitch ready where the Foot use arcane lore to open a dimensional rift, and this monster manages to come through by accident. We were joking around after NYCC about the old toon characters and we came to the realisation that Bebop and Rocksteady would work in that story in place of the monster and would make for a great One-shot FCBD/Anniversary story to help attract more fans towards the comics. My story wouldn't've been affected in any way whatsoever, outside of this random one-off monster suddenly becoming two iconic characters for a special once off appearance.


[QUOTE]But if a writer keeps doing that (retooling cartoon characters) to fit their stories over and over again (in the name of, "Well, I needed a Bishop/Nano/fill-in-the-blank-like villain in this story, so I just went ahead and used Bishop/Nano/fill-in-the-blank villain)... it kind of becomes a sham and we can call the writer out on it, can't we?

Yep. But then again, isn't that what virtually the entire Marvel Ultimate line is? And that's far from a sham.

Again, not pointing a finger at Tristan. It doesn't sound like I have much to worry about.

You have nothing to worry about. It just woulda helped me out if you had a look at my blog beforehand :P

Andrew NDB
05-30-2009, 12:39 AM
Ultimately you're telling a story. Any goonbag can come up with a character (Robert Liefeld) but the character isn't **** without a decent writer behind it (Fabien Nicieza).

I guess the point, then, is to be a decent writer. And get the job done.

I will say that I did have fun watching Fast Forward though.

Though having written some comics for it, you admit that maybe you're not completely impartial to it.

BOO! The only thing he did wrong with Batman was how he brought Jason Todd back to life. Superboy Prime?!

I wasn't really talking about his work with Batman, but now that you mention it that was pretty horrible as well. Maybe worse than the agenda-based Winnick material I was thinking of (in Green Lantern, Outsiders, and Green Arrow, actually).

It's your character!!

OK... but unless we're talking about creating characters in a Mary Sue capacity, that a writer will occasionally be introducing new characters is a given.

How so? Isn't any character choice by a writer an act of self indulgence?

Depends on the circumstances and motivations, I think.

I don't hate the 2k3 one (though I REALLY, really don't like the comic one and am constantly baffled by it), as it's something more in line with the way I'd imagined him coming to being. What was the Palladium one?

I'm too hot and sweaty right now in my apartment to rummage for it, but suffice to say it built on the original Tales story with him in it, the whole, "Today I'm the Monster, last week I was the Ghost" schdict.

What if said character was only to appear once, and once only?

Meh.

Though I didn't have a problem with your proposed idea to have the actual cartoon-universe Bebop and Rocksteady cross into the Mirage dimension for a one-off bit of fun. Because that's literally using the actual characters... not twisting them to fit inside Mirage and then leaving them there.

Yep. But then again, isn't that what virtually the entire Marvel Ultimate line is? And that's far from a sham.

That's not really apples to apples, though. You know that. The Marvel Ultimate line itself is a spinoff thing, given carte blanche to play with whatever/cherry pick from what has come before in the original universe and elsewhere.

Though I would challenge that as time goes on, the Marvel Ultimate line is a sham. The fundamentals behind its creation is that they would make a new Marvel universe that is free of all the continuity and baggage of the existing Marvel universe; creating something easily accessible.

The problem with something like this is, even if it starts fresh on a fresh page with a clean historical slate... as time/the years pass, it's inevitably going to develop its own history and continuity... and before long it will just become the very thing it's trying to avoid. How can it not?

Dragon Turtle
05-30-2009, 12:52 AM
Hm. Could you elaborate on this? Because I really am at a loss for how creating a new character is self-indulgant.


There are tons of people who complain when comic creators create new characters, "why can't he use (fill in the blank)?", and there is a habit of making the new pet character "too good", in a way he's better then any preexisting character, it may even involve dumbing down or neglecting the preexisting characters.

You're either damned if you do, or damned if you don't.


Maybe not, but if Hun on the children's show was at a 6 O'Clock nitrous level, the comic book kicks it up to midnight.

It'd be like... if Rocksteady appeared in the comics tomorrow, and actually started shooting and killing people with his machine gun. Maybe that doesn't qualify as a "complete overhaul," but I'd certainly call that a pretty fundamental change in the character --


As you mentioned with Hun, there was no fundamental change in his character, just a change in the medium he was represented in, Hun hit people in the 2k3 cartoon, the end results just weren't as graphic. Rocksteady used his gun to shoot at people in the old cartoon, but because it was a comedic 80's kids cartoon they were not going to show him killing people.



so why not just make a new mutant that wields a machine gun? #1) You can contribute something new to the pantheon of the comics that will be all yours, #2) You won't step on the toes of a villain -- someone else's -- that wasn't really ever intended to be seen in the light you want to drag him to.



Because perhaps the writer likes them and wants to use them, I really don't see how that is any different then when a writer takes a long forgotten character (like Cat Man for example), or any character they didn't create and then decides to use them in there stories, usually far removed from how they were first portrayed.

Andrew NDB
05-30-2009, 01:00 AM
There are tons of people who complain when comic creators create new characters, "why can't he use (fill in the blank)?", and there is a habit of making the new pet character "too good", in a way he's better then any preexisting character, it may even involve dumbing down or neglecting the preexisting characters.

You're either damned if you do, or damned if you don't.

I don't disagree with any of this. The difference here, I think, is that Hun, or Viral, or any of those guys aren't pre-existing characters in the universe -- the core universe -- in question. To include them at all requires reverse-engineering them and recreating them to suit said universe, whether substantially or not.

Because perhaps the writer likes them and wants to use them

Which comes back to self-indulgancy for self-indulgancy's sake. And again, it's not like Hun or Rocksteady or Viral already existed in the Mirage universe and just haven't been used for years and years... they don't exist in the Mirage universe unless they're created anew and shoe-horned into things.

I really don't see how that is any different then when a writer takes a long forgotten character (like Cat Man for example), or any character they didn't create and then decides to use them in there stories, usually far removed from how they were first portrayed.

Not apples to apples. Developing a character that's always existed in a specific universe later on in the same universe, even if said portrayal is a little different than folks might be used to, is quite a different thing indeed.

Plus the DCU has all kinds of McGuffins to explain away things like the Crisises, Zero Hour, etc.. Not that I'm a fan of writers using those things as a crutch. At all.

And out of curiosity, are you referring to Gail Simone's treatment of Catman lately in Secret Six (which I do read)? I can't say enough good things about her work.

willtupper
05-30-2009, 01:02 AM
How soon until you guys start griping that they're still using the actual Turtles in the comics? :P

Ninjinister
05-30-2009, 01:05 AM
I'm too hot and sweaty right now in my apartment to rummage for it, but suffice to say it built on the original Tales story with him in it, the whole, "Today I'm the Monster, last week I was the Ghost" schdict.

Which one is it in? I've got like 6 of 'em here at my fingertips.

And I concur on the hot apartment. S***.

Archon_Turtle
05-30-2009, 01:05 AM
I wish I could quit you will.

Andrew NDB
05-30-2009, 01:08 AM
Which one is it in? I've got like 6 of 'em here at my fingertips.

Either the original & Other Strangeness or Transdimensional TMNT.

And I would strongly, strongly recommend even casual Mirage fans pick up the Transdimensional TMNT book. It's a fascinating encyclopediac read on its own, forget about the RPG business. Even gives us a starmap of the Mirage universe's space sectors, too, I think. And tells how Time Travel works in Mirage, what with Renet and all, and in a very logical manner.

Lordmylar06
05-30-2009, 01:19 AM
I think as far as getting away from original creators intentions and stepping on the toes of the creators' Rocksteady and Bebop are fine examples, Eastman and Laird created them to be machine gun wielding powerhouses with some idiot-like behaviors. By the 2nd season of the original cartoon, they were toned down so much that both Laird and Eastman REFUSED to use them in the second TMNT movie. I wouldn't have a problem with characters like this being introduced into the Mirage universe at all. And while on the subject of original intent of characters, and source of origin, the turtles themselves would look like that first drawing of a ninja turtle, and we'd have never seen anything past a Ronin parody. Harley Quinn from Batman wouldn't be a comic book character. The entire current DC universe would be forfeit. I'm a purist too, but there are some adaptations I'm willing to accept.

Ninjinister
05-30-2009, 01:22 AM
Either the original & Other Strangeness or Transdimensional TMNT.

And I would strongly, strongly recommend even casual Mirage fans pick up the Transdimensional TMNT book. It's a fascinating encyclopediac read on its own, forget about the RPG business. Even gives us a starmap of the Mirage universe's space sectors, too, I think. And tells how Time Travel works in Mirage, what with Renet and all, and in a very logical manner.

Will flip that, I don't see him in Other Strangeness and Transdimensional is one of the ones I don't have.

Andrew NDB
05-30-2009, 01:29 AM
I think as far as getting away from original creators intentions and stepping on the toes of the creators' Rocksteady and Bebop are fine examples, Eastman and Laird created them to be machine gun wielding powerhouses with some idiot-like behaviors.

Eastman and Laird didn't create them. At least, not the characters we saw on the screen, per se. They did some sketches and offered suggestions in the genesis of things, which weren't really heeded much by Fred Wolf.

Among other things. The one thing they asked Fred Wolf was, "OK, if you can promise to NOT change one thing, don't f*** with the origin and the mutation and all that." They went and f***ed with it.

By the 2nd season of the original cartoon, they were toned down so much that both Laird and Eastman REFUSED to use them in the second TMNT movie.

Do you blame them? They were tarnished. And the way the mutagen works in the comics/movies, would be otherwise incompatible.

the turtles themselves would look like that first drawing of a ninja turtle, and we'd have never seen anything past a Ronin parody.

Believing that an artist's rendition of a character or characters is static and never-changing is a very weird thing, and I wonder if you've ever really read Frank Miller's Ronin. Apart from a very obvious borrowing of the style of Ronin's titular logo, I don't see much of Ronin inside the book aside from the general tone and cutting of the action paneling.

Harley Quinn from Batman wouldn't be a comic book character.

I'm OK with that. Her shoe-horning into the DCU of comics, if well-intentioned, has been much ado about nothing... and DC doesn't seem to know what to do with her anymore, if Countdown was any indication. What has she done in the DCU of note since her inclusion? We'll see what happens in Gotham City Sirens.

Lordmylar06
05-30-2009, 01:42 AM
Really? they didn't create Bebop and Rocksteady? I thought for sure I'd read somewhere that they did. I agree they were tarnished, but the 2nd movie wasn't technically canon with Mirage. Not sure that matters much.

The point I was attempting to make with the Ronin comment(and I have read it) as well as the goofy 1st turtle drawing was exactly what I said. Things evolve. The comic only borrowed the style of art and continued after a stopping point and grew into more.

I enjoyed the Harley Quinn comic series very much before it was canned(yes I suppose I was one of the few) and as far as DC not knowing what to do with her, well let's just say that's a trend that follows most of DC's lineup.

I agree with you to an extent Andrew, and I actually find your defense of the title (against what would seem to you a step down in honor) quite admirable. I'm just not against Mirage borrowing from the other TMNT universes for content.

Andrew NDB
05-30-2009, 01:47 AM
Really? they didn't create Bebop and Rocksteady? I thought for sure I'd read somewhere that they did.

On a technical level they did. I'm pretty sure they named them, and I've seen sketches of their initial designs for them. But what Fred Wolf did with them from there is quite different altogether.

but the 2nd movie wasn't technically canon with Mirage. Not sure that matters much.

Of course the second movie wasn't canon with Mirage. Or the first. Or the third. Or the fourth.

The point I was attempting to make with the Ronin comment(and I have read it) as well as the goofy 1st turtle drawing was exactly what I said. Things evolve. The comic only borrowed the style of art and continued after a stopping point and grew into more.

Evolution is one thing. Reverse-proliferating characters from children's spinoff universes is quite another.

I enjoyed the Harley Quinn comic series very much before it was canned(yes I suppose I was one of the few) and as far as DC not knowing what to do with her, well let's just say that's a trend that follows most of DC's lineup.

With the current regime in charge at DC, I very much agree.

Dragon Turtle
05-30-2009, 01:54 AM
I don't disagree with any of this. The difference here, I think, is that Hun, or Viral, or any of those guys aren't pre-existing characters in the universe -- the core universe -- in question. To include them at all requires reverse-engineering them and recreating them to suit said universe, whether substantially or not.

Which comes back to self-indulgancy for self-indulgancy's sake. And again, it's not like Hun or Rocksteady or Viral already existed in the Mirage universe and just haven't been used for years and years... they don't exist in the Mirage universe unless they're created anew and shoe-horned into things.



But is the creator being equally self-indulgent when creating a new character of their own instead of using a preexisting character? I think our main disagreement here lies on just how much the thought of using characters from another universe bothers you. Personally, as long as the characters contribute to good stories and are themselves interesting, then where they originate from doesn't really matter to me, since the motivation for using them by any particular creator isn't going to be different, no matter if the character is new, old, or borrowed.




And out of curiosity, are you referring to Gail Simone's treatment of Catman lately in Secret Six (which I do read)? I can't say enough good things about her work.

Yes, I'm not a huge fan of the DC universe, mostly because of my disdain for the villains, but Simone's work on Villians United and Secret Six has been impressive.


How soon until you guys start griping that they're still using the actual Turtles in the comics? :P

The actual "Turtles" haven't been used in the comics since the Terrapin Riots of 94, just stuntmen in rubber suits.

Newton Gimmick
05-30-2009, 02:01 AM
Well I think LordMylar's point still sort of stands. Rocksteady and Bebop and literally like 500 other characters started as sketches from Eastman and Laird. Many of them for toys before the toons even. So if they were to go back and give them an official story now, it'd be no different than a lot of the things that Laird and others have done with characters since then that may not have been fleshed out originally.

I think you might be getting a bit into the semantics of it all with how it's coming about, but regardless of how it's read I'd say as a whole you're probably in the minority. Others have pointed out where reverse-proliferating has worked and worked to a great extent.

Although... I have no idea honestly how any of these related to Mirage's rogues gallery. We got way off topic, haha.

Dragon Turtle
05-30-2009, 02:17 AM
My "agenda" REVOLVES, absolutely REVOLVES around the Shredder. Not Oroku Saki, but the mantle of the Shredder. The person you need to keep an eye on is Lin. This isn't just directed at you Andrew, it's towards everyone, but people need to look between the lines. Why would Lin spring Hun from jail? She's part of a group dedicated to the Shredder. The man who Hun hates more than anyone. Hun is possibly more anti-Foot Clan than the Turtles and Splinter. And that's a big clue as how he fits in. The direction of things is pretty obvious when you read #36 and #56 back to back, and it's gonna be made amazingly clear come the last page of #64. There are some little things written into the linking stories that are very specific. The appearance of the Foot in #59 is something to pay attention to as well.



I was thinking Lin was using Huns dislike of the Foot Clan in order to recruit him as an ally against Karai's faction (without telling him she is a Shredder loyalist). Will we be seeing the real mastermind behind the Foot Elite from City at War in the form of a new Shreddder?

TristanHuwJones
05-30-2009, 02:45 AM
Don't want to get hopes up in case things don't continue into next year, or in case freelancers don't get any space to tell stories (which was almost the case this year), but the person Lin is working for will come to light, it does involve the Shredder, but it has more to do with the mantle of the Shredder than Saki.
There are a lot of pieces that need to be put into place first (in my mind at least). Hun's one of them. A really big one.

Andrew NDB
05-30-2009, 03:24 AM
Don't want to get hopes up in case things don't continue into next year, or in case freelancers don't get any space to tell stories (which was almost the case this year), but the person Lin is working for will come to light, it does involve the Shredder, but it has more to do with the mantle of the Shredder than Saki.

Sounds like something worth seeing.

Mr._Mutant_Man
05-30-2009, 11:07 PM
I have every confidence Christopher Nolan could bring in King Tut from the Batman 60s TV show and do a badass version of him in a sequel to the Dark Knight... but the simple fact is, it shouldn't be done.



You're a delusioned individual if you believe that either TMNT cartoon was made for anyone other than little children. Characters created for said shows are, ergo, for kids (that adults find aspects of them endearing is neither here nor there). It's not a difficult equation.

Though that's not even the point.

Why shouldn't it be done, aside from there being more well known villains to have in the movies? If it's a good story, who cares where the villain originated from? Mr. Freeze was a really goofy villain until the animated series reinvented him. Then the live action movie screwed him up. So I guess that would be the reverse of what some speculate could be done with TMNT characters.

The TMNT cartoon was made for children, just like most cartoons. Then again, most people still assume comics are for kids, and a lot of them appeal to all ages. I don't see the point in pointing out that it's kid stuff. A lot of people might assume that Batman as a whole is kid's stuff. It just takes the right creative team to show that it can appeal to all ages. I think the same can be said for certain characters that may have started out in the kid's version.

I don't get the argument that a character shouldn't be retooled because it would be unoriginal. When a character becomes popular, a lot of people end up putting their own spin on the character over the years. A ton of people have written Batman stories, in the comics, the cartoons, and the movies. Batman has been "retooled" quite a bit too, because everyone has their individual take on the character, even when it's mostly in line with what others have done.

willtupper
05-30-2009, 11:41 PM
I love you too, brother. Always and forever :P.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/a/a1/Brokeback_mountain.jpg

I wish I could quit you will.

The Big Bad
05-31-2009, 06:33 AM
Several points here; let's see if I can address them all.

Personally, I think the idea of having rogues gallery—a consistent group of recurring antagonists—doesn’t really fit the Mirage-verse. Superhero comics had to create (or at least popularize) a couple of tropes in order to justify the concept, tropes which I fear would hinder the Mirage verse more than it would help.

Personally, I think that the problem with the Mirage-verse antagonists isn’t in approach, but in execution—one-shot villains can be great fun if used well (see: Usagi Yojimbo). However, the villains introduced in Tales have either been a) dull, b) have not had time to be developed and stretch their legs before they’re dispatched, c) have been set up nicely, but have not been dealt with since.

It's like Laird's stance against Rocksteady and Bebop. You can't tell me that those two characters couldn't be reinvented into total badasses. But because they came from that silly cartoon, they can't be touched? Nonsense.I don’t think it’s ever been a question of whether it can be done, but whether it can be done and still keep the characters as Bebop and Rocksteady. Given that neither character had a personality aside from “too dumb to live”, turning them “into total badasses” wouldn’t be a reinvention—it would be creating entirely new characters and giving them old skins.

On the other hand, adapting them but keeping them as joke villains would probably have more merit—it would certainly fill a void left unfilled since Savanti Romero began being played straight—but would still present problems, the first being how to make them viable in a world in which would be a) less tolerant of their stupidity, and b) less likely to let them escape scot free time after time after time. Minor recurring characters? Yes. Credible long term antagonists? No.

Hun, on the other hand, had none of these problems. He was already an established threat, with an established history, backstory, and character relationships, and an established personality. All things ripe to play with.

Now, if a bunch of characters and stuff from the show reverse-proliferated back into the comic books from Smallville... this is where I have a problem.
Eehh…personally I think the comic books would only be strengthened by the addition of characters such as Chloe Sullivan and Lionel Luthor, as long as one had stories to tell. Aside from them, however, I don’t see any others that would be worth translating.
Would bringing them in be creatively bankrupt? Done well, I don’t see how. In any case, I don’t see why retro-fitting characters is inherently such a detestable idea, as you seem to think. I mean, this…
I just find it's a little bit lacking in creativity and when you dig deep, actually just seems pretty self-gratifying and the equivalent of rubbing oneself off in public.
…Can be said about anything, particularly when one of the main reasons for creating is pleasure. On that note, why is bringing a character from another universe creatively bankrupt, but not writing characters you didn’t create (see: DC, Marvel, Mirage, Archie)? It seems to me you’re in the wrong genre/medium to take this stand on.

You're a delusional individual if you believe that either TMNT cartoon was made for anyone other than little children. Characters created for said shows are, ergo, for kids (that adults find aspects of them endearing is neither here nor there). It's not a difficult equation.Hostility aside, this is true enough: the show’s primary audience is children. It’s not the only one though—the creators didn’t set out to make something that they themselves wouldn’t enjoy. In any case, the fact that children are the intended audience of a work doesn’t make it bad (there is plenty of art intended for children better than stuff created for older audiences) or unpalatable for anyone outside its main audience, nor does it mean that one can think of those works in other ways—death of the author, and all that.

If the Mirage universe is truly so hard up that it just has to start mining material from the children's cartoons that are its polar opposite... it honestly doesn't deserve to continue.

What makes you think that TMNT 2003 is the Mirageverse are polar opposites? The fact that Stockman, Savanti Romero, Mr. Marlin, and the Justice Force (among others) managed to make more-or-less seamless transitions from one to the other makes the opposite case.

Yes, the universes are different—different enough to make

But if you want to compare apples to apples, what kind of ratio of halfway decent villains to cornball toddler-pandering villains do all the universes outside of the Mirage universe have? For every Hun there's a dozen Garbage Men or Bonesteels.Ehh…all in all, I’d say that Archie’s original villains are about on par with Mirage’s—lots of duds—a handful of really good ones, and that the 2003 cartoon is better in almost every conceivable way.

I think Sho'Kanabo's storyline and a couple of the FF ones were a little more sophisticated than they probably should have been, but the execution of those stories (the jokes, etc.) brought them down to being accessible for kids. Care to elaborate? Taken on its own, the phrase “more sophisticated than they probably should have been” sounds vaguely condescending. On a different can I ask you to please keep a lid on the hints for your stories, or at least mark them as spoilers so I can avoid them? Your issues tend to work better when I can make the different connections for myself, and you, well you’re spoiling my fun. :P Pretty please?

Woah, couldn't disagree more. If you think we'd ever get a "Sons of the Silent Age" out of the 4Kids cartoon, you're way off. (I know they actually did adapt that issue. And they made it unbelievably sh*tty.)

The cartoon did a decent job with adapting the straight action stories. The one plot I thought was actually better handled by the show was the Triceraton space arc. But the tone of the comics involves a lot more than "look, ninja action!"

Eh, while I get what you’re saying, and I don’t totally disagree, I also think you aren’t giving the cartoon enough credit. “Insane in the Membrane” is, I think, just as poignant as stories like Vol 4. 22 (I haven’t read “Sons of the Silent Age”). Still, you’re right; their strengths lie in different places, and atmosphere and poignancy are not the cartoon’s.

On that note, I think the turtles arc is the worst part of comic “City at War”.

As for no Arkham Asylum. Well in Fast Forward all bad guys they defeated were sent to Riker's Island, which is the Marvel's version of Arkham for the minor bad guys (major ones of course get sent to another dimension). Also, a real jail.

Newton Gimmick
05-31-2009, 05:51 PM
I don’t think it’s ever been a question of whether it can be done, but whether it can be done and still keep the characters as Bebop and Rocksteady. Given that neither character had a personality aside from “too dumb to live”, turning them “into total badasses” wouldn’t be a reinvention—it would be creating entirely new characters and giving them old skins.

On the other hand, adapting them but keeping them as joke villains would probably have more merit—it would certainly fill a void left unfilled since Savanti Romero began being played straight—but would still present problems, the first being how to make them viable in a world in which would be a) less tolerant of their stupidity, and b) less likely to let them escape scot free time after time after time. Minor recurring characters? Yes. Credible long term antagonists? No.

Uh, there's no real need for a total reinvention. It's pretty simple. Rocksteady and Bebop instead of being "goofy"... Kill people. Pretty cut and dry actually.

Both characters were threats in the first couple episodes, but soon degenerated into jokes. Still, the basic characters, street thugs turned into mutants, is quite viable. With little change to the overall character. Because as you said, there was a lot room for development there because we never got a ton of character background information.

This happens in comics and other properties all the time where characters that only had a minimal amount of development are explored later and made into viable characters.

Cipher
05-31-2009, 06:02 PM
On that note, I think the turtles arc is the worst part of comic “City at War”.I'm not sure what that has to do with anything. Maybe your point went over my head.

Either way, while I don't think the Turtles' arc is the worst part of the story, it is much, much stronger with April, Casey and Splinter's arcs. I think that's one of the many reasons the 4Kids adaptation is kind of a snoozer.

“Insane in the Membrane” is, I think, just as poignant as stories like Vol 4. 22.That episode might be strong medicine for a kids' show, but it still aims lower than the "deeper" Mirage issues. It's dark and maybe a little sad, but not really meaningful in any larger way. That's the real difference. While the cartoon constantly runs dark and intricate, it never gets into those little pockets of artistry like the comics sometimes do. Because it's written for kids. Different animals.

Keldor1578
06-03-2009, 02:11 AM
It really doen'st matters where these characters are from as long you can tell good stories with them.Both marvel and DC has their share of canon immigrants that worked .

Andrew NDB
06-03-2009, 02:13 AM
I have nothing further to add to this thread at this point other than to further underscore that the very title of the thread is inherently flawed in its comparison.

While you can compare one thing that isn't the same as another (like oil to water), you simply won't come up with any satisfying results.

The Big Bad
06-04-2009, 11:11 PM
Uh, there's no real need for a total reinvention. It's pretty simple. Rocksteady and Bebop instead of being "goofy"... Kill people. Pretty cut and dry actually.

Both characters were threats in the first couple episodes, but soon degenerated into jokes. Still, the basic characters, street thugs turned into mutants, is quite viable. With little change to the overall character. Because as you said, there was a lot room for development there because we never got a ton of character background information. I disagree: I think Bebop and Rocksteady's stupidity and incompetence is an integral part of their appeal; taking it away would render the new characters to be not quite Bebop and Rocksteady--it'd be like making Team Rocket or Dr. Light competent.

Also, we seem to have a fundamental disagreement on the meaning of the word "threat"--I really don't think "lasting more than thirty seconds" is enough for a villain to qualify. Also, given that their first scene as humans features them getting beat up by the turtles with no trouble, I think the argument that incompetence was something thrust upon them falls on its face.


I'm not sure what that has to do with anything. Maybe your point went over my head.

Either way, while I don't think the Turtles' arc is the worst part of the story, it is much, much stronger with April, Casey and Splinter's arcs. I think that's one of the many reasons the 4Kids adaptation is kind of a snoozer.
Actually, it was meant to be more than aside than an actual argument, but the point was that much like emotion is often not the 2003 cartoon's strengh, action is oftentimes not Mirage's--take away the four other stories, and you're left with a story that's not all that much better than its TV adaptation. But while we're on the topic, I don't really think adapting the other four storylines to the cartoon would have helped any; those stories aren't the type the cartoon was equipped to tell, and given the place were the characters were at the time, trying to adapt them would have dangerously derailed the cartoon. What the 'toon version of "City at War" needed was better action, better pacing, and the sense that people could actually die. Had the arc been animated like something like the Spectacular Spider-Man episode accomplices, and had the minor-but-established characters actually died on screen--I'm imagining a battle scene not unlike "Same as it Never Was", here--I think the whole arc would have been considerably more succesful.

Coola Yagami
06-05-2009, 12:32 AM
True but eps like Same as it Never Was, Reality Check and Virtual Reality Check were able to get away with all the deaths because in the end, it was 'all a dream' or could be done away with. No way they'd get away with killing off Rat King, Gabriel and a handful of Foot Ninja in a kid's show.

Keldor1578
06-05-2009, 02:31 AM
I realized the problem is not the rogues gallery is small, But the fact the turtles don't have main antagonist or a big bad who a threat to them in mirage.

The Big Bad
06-05-2009, 03:50 PM
True but eps like Same as it Never Was, Reality Check and Virtual Reality Check were able to get away with all the deaths because in the end, it was 'all a dream' or could be done away with. No way they'd get away with killing off Rat King, Gabriel and a handful of Foot Ninja in a kid's show.

Actually, I wasn't talking about incorporating the other storylines--like I said, they go against the cartoon's ethos, so I think the creators were wise not to attempt adapting them. I was talking about the other, canon-fodder combatants, such as the mobsters, Dragonface, and the Foot Elite. Heck, given that we never saw many of them again, one can easily assume that they were hunted and killed after the fact (and although I can't prove it, I believe that this is what the writers meant for us to assume).

And while agree it couldn't have been done then in the second season (after all, it wasn't). I think we could have seen it if it had been done sometime between seasons 3 and 5--plenty of people were killed on-screen then--Mashimi, Tang Shen, The Demon Shredder, Volpehart...

Keldor1578
06-11-2009, 09:35 AM
I was thinking Lin was using Huns dislike of the Foot Clan in order to recruit him as an ally against Karai's faction (without telling him she is a Shredder loyalist). Will we be seeing the real mastermind behind the Foot Elite from City at War in the form of a new Shreddder?

You probably right, I think the new Shredder is the mastermind who pulling the string from behind the scene.Also i think the new Shredder goal is to take complete control of the foot clan from Karai.

TristanHuwJones
06-11-2009, 10:40 AM
You probably right, I think the new Shredder is the mastermind who pulling the string from behind the scene.Also i think the new Shredder goal is to take complete control of the foot clan from Karai.

Just to be clear, I have no intention of resurrecting the Shredder, or creating a new one, but more will be laid out in #59 and #64. Hopefully, if things go well and I get even a couple of stories approved for next year, more will come to light (Lord knows I need the work too :P)