View Full Version : F*ck the CGC. No really. F*ck Them.
Archon_Turtle
05-27-2009, 04:32 PM
So I sent in my copy of Scat #1 (Peter Laird's first work that was not self published. The book that Kevin found that eventually led him to meeting Peter) to the CGC to be graded, and after holding the book for well over a week, they have decided to refuse to grade the book based on the grounds that it is "Easily Reproduced".
I am not one that enjoys having total bullsh*t shoved down my throat. Which is what this is. Complete and utter bullsh*t.
With books such as GobbledyGook 1 and 2, I can understand the easily reproduced excuse. Those books were self published using a photocopier. Scat however, was printed by a professional printer, using professional processes, on paper that was customary for comics at the time. Scat was produced using more professional methods then Ninja Turtles #1 (which they DO grade). When asked what attributes of the book lead them to believe it is easily reproduced, they refuse to give me answers.
Here is the truth as I see it. The CGC cares more about playing it safe then they care about grading, documenting, and preserving a book that is historically priceless to the independant comic lineage. If they don't know about a book, it automatically falls into the category of "Easily Reproduced". And you know what? If they can't determine the difference between an original and a fake book, doesn't that bring into question their ability to grade anything? F*cking hack pricks.
willtupper
05-27-2009, 04:41 PM
But how do you really feel about the whole issue? :P
Seriously, though. That is too bad, and definitely their loss (as well as, obviously, yours). And I'm very sorry to hear it.
Slightly related topic: have you posted any pictures of Scat #1 online, anywhere? I ask because I've gotten such a kick out of seeing your photographic records of other early Turtle treasures.
Newton Gimmick
05-27-2009, 04:42 PM
Thus is the problem with any grading agency.
Grading sadly is just for elitists anyway. It's just not worth it. If you got something valuable, you know it.
But this goes all over. Not just in comics and toys. You should check out "Who the F&*k is Jackson Pollick" and see how it happens in the art world too, for MILLIONS of dollars.
Archon_Turtle
05-27-2009, 04:54 PM
Slightly related topic: have you posted any pictures of Scat #1 online, anywhere? I ask because I've gotten such a kick out of seeing your photographic records of other early Turtle treasures.
http://smg.photobucket.com/albums/v247/JNCOPosterboy/The%20Collection/Comics/Scat/
Peter's comic is pages 10-12.
willtupper
05-27-2009, 06:40 PM
Oh, yeah. I remember now.
In other news: I am a forgetful baffoon! :(
Thank you, all the same.
http://smg.photobucket.com/albums/v247/JNCOPosterboy/The%20Collection/Comics/Scat/
Peter's comic is pages 10-12.
Leonardo19
05-27-2009, 07:45 PM
WTF? I can see how you think they are F@&%^ pricks! Seriously this would really piss me off as well.
BoggleKng
05-27-2009, 08:09 PM
Yes. Recockulous.. Cool to see the Scat book though..
Sadly, that is the case with CGC (and other grading companies). Sometimes I'm baffled by the books that I see ultimately in slabs and others that they reject. As you said, the Gobbledys it makes perfect sense on, but this book? Very odd and this sux you are having such a bad experience with them.
I'm obviously a fan of them, and find them to be a fantastic way to get an impartial grade on your books while providing a displayable yet protected environment to keep important books in. The restoration detection service alone makes it worth it on key books.
But I guess on books like this, possibly a copy they have never seen before, they just didn't know what to do and decided to play it safe. Definfatly sux for you man.
Andrew NDB
05-27-2009, 08:19 PM
Can't really blame the CGC. If it looks like photocopies, smells like photocopies... you probably wouldn't want to stake your company and its reputation by putting your company's stamp on it.
Archon_Turtle
05-27-2009, 09:49 PM
If it looks like photocopies, smells like photocopies...
But that is the thing. This book does neither.
Additionally, it wouldn't bother me at all if they were just honest and said "we aren't comfortable grading the book due to our inexperience with it" but instead they choose to discredit the book calling it low in production value.
Jester
05-27-2009, 10:07 PM
Does the CGC grade free periodicals, like Scat was?
Archon_Turtle
05-27-2009, 10:25 PM
Does the CGC grade free periodicals, like Scat was?
yes. And ashcans.
Jester
05-27-2009, 10:27 PM
http://southdakotapolitics.blogs.com/south_dakota_politics/images/scarecrow_oz.gif
Ash can what?
Archon_Turtle
05-27-2009, 10:30 PM
Ash can what?
From wiki:
An ashcan copy is a term that originated in the Golden Age of Comic Books, meant to describe a publication produced solely for legal purposes (such as trademark), which was not normally intended for distribution.
The word "ashcan" is an older synonym for wastebasket, trashcan, or other garbage receptacle. The implication is that the printed material will go straight from the printer to the trash, which was often the case. Ashcan editions frequently contained unlettered stories, unfinished art or even just whatever wastepaper had been conveniently available at the time. The goal in making them was to get something out with the wanted title slapped on as quickly as possible so that the publisher could make some claim to having been the first in print if a competitor tried to publish a similar title. Ashcans were also produced to demonstrate the publications to potential advertisers.
One well-known example is Flash Comics #1 by Fawcett Comics, which introduced Captain Thunder (later Captain Marvel). Competitors had already beat Fawcett to publishing a "Flash Comics" and a character named "Captain Thunder", so it failed to claim those trademarks for the company, but it did establish a publication date for copyright purposes.
Other entertainment industries have similar productions. A well-known film example is the 1994 version of The Fantastic Four, produced by Roger Corman, made only to maintain the license to the property. The movie had a $2 million budget and was not distributed.
In modern comics, ashcans may be used as a promotion or as an inexpensive format for independent self-publishing. The term is sometimes synonymous with minicomics.
sai of relief
05-27-2009, 10:54 PM
thats unfortunate about your book. its unfortunate that CGC looks at some amazing comics as a business liablility as opposed to what it is.
but they're a business, and i guess that can be expected. :ohwell:
what amused me most when i saw their stalls at all the cons i worked at last year in the states was that they 'grade all of their comics impartially'. but they don't price their services impartially.:lol:
ah, capitalism :evilgrin:
edit: and i guess as a side note, the company itself was designed for safe trading over the internet due to fakes, incomplete comics etc. so from a certain point of view they've gone back on that point. if something is absolutely known to be 100% genuine, and can be backed up as being such, that particular book should be graded. hypothetically speaking. :)
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.