View Full Version : Are The Turtles A Parody?
Not So Teenage Terd-le
06-01-2009, 06:03 PM
I know it has been mentioned that the Turtles are supposed to be a parody of comics that were being published around the same time as TMNT vol. 1. I am not saying it is or is not a parody but I can not find any evidence to support the claim that it is... can you?
Cipher
06-01-2009, 06:13 PM
Eventually they decided to get all serious and experimental, but the first issue is a parody. The cover is an homage to Frank Miller's Ronin, elements of the origin story are a direct reference to Miller's Daredevil run. (Including the Foot themselves.) It came out in a time when anthropomorphic animals, mutants, ninjas, and teenagers were hot sh*t in comics. The idea of "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" is totally ridiculous.
It was a joke. It's a certain type of humor that points out the ridiculousness of trends by throwing them all together and still playing it straight.
So the evidence is, like...actually overwhelming. Case closed.
Archon_Turtle
06-01-2009, 06:26 PM
I'm not really sure what I could possibly add to Cipher's post...now I feel inadequate...
*wanders off*
sai of relief
06-01-2009, 06:34 PM
same.
i walked into the room and the jobs been done.
*exits*
Dark 5cythe
06-01-2009, 07:08 PM
*dusts off hands* yuuuup.......mission accomplished........*walks off into sunset*
Lord Nightwalker
06-01-2009, 07:54 PM
You know, I've read that issue (Issue one) a gazillion times, and allthough I noticed it's little tributes, it never felt like a parody to me. Not ever.
So no matter what, I don't look at it in that light.
Andrew NDB
06-01-2009, 08:00 PM
A few parody elements. The whole parody aspect was abandoned after the first issue.
I've noticed that the only people drawing the "It began as a parody, folks!" card are the people trying to defend/downplay how childish the cartoons and other media are.
Raph's Girl
06-01-2009, 08:49 PM
On one hand it's a parody, but on the other hand it's an homage. There are elements of Daredevil:
Daredevil: His sensei is....The SticK
TMNT: Splinter (or Sliver...depending on the er timeline *lol*)
Daredevil: Ninja clan is...The Hand
TMNT: The Foot
The Hand also appear in Jackie Chan Adventures (altho they're known as The Dark Hand).
In some ways Elektra = Karai
The blind guy Chet saves from being run over by the TCRI truck was apperantly Daredevil himself.
Dark 5cythe
06-01-2009, 08:59 PM
Havent the TMNT Creators said repeatedly it was started in parody? With the mutants and teenage thing from xmen and new mutants, Daredevils ninja aspects, and the turtles was just capitalizing on the anthropomorphic animal fad goin on. TMNT was a tribute if anything to comics of the time!
Why would anyone need to defend the cartoon and its childishness is its just as big if not a bigger part in tmnt mythos. It certainly reached more people world wide in that format.
I doubt comic readers will like that but its the truth. It was easier as a kid to turn on a tv and watch it for free than have to beg your parents to buy you a comic book at the store when and IF you found them.
Not So Teenage Terd-le
06-01-2009, 09:23 PM
I agree with you Dark 5cythe! I had two tmnt toys before I even saw the cartoon, then I fell in love with the cartoon, and then found out it was a comic book which I was too young to read at the time. They are two different worlds, both very good. Being familiar with the cartoon world really helps older people appreciate the comics. Especially volume 4 where I am actually the same age as the turtles now!!
Cipher
06-01-2009, 09:35 PM
I've noticed that the only people drawing the "It began as a parody, folks!" card are the people trying to defend/downplay how childish the cartoons and other media are.I've noticed that, even though I agree with you most of the time, you love to shoehorn these ideas into every thread.
Andrew NDB
06-01-2009, 09:40 PM
I've noticed that, even though I agree with you most of the time, you love to shoehorn these ideas into every thread.
Just making an observation.
I think Kev & Pete abuse this term a bit. While TMNT was conceived as a parody ("satire" would be more fitting though), it quickly evolved into much more than that. Simply looking up a definition can tell you that much.
CyberCubed
06-01-2009, 10:51 PM
I liked the fact that Peter said if #1 wasn't originally a one-shot, they wouldn't have killed off Shredder in the first issue.
Could you imagine how different the Mirage universe would have been if Shredder was a recurring villain who lived for a long time?
Cipher
06-02-2009, 01:30 PM
Could you imagine how different the Mirage universe would have been if Shredder was a recurring villain who lived for a long time?Worse?
A lot of the Mirage comic's best elements come from their experimentation and "happy accidents" though.
I think Kev & Pete abuse this term a bit. While TMNT was conceived as a parody ("satire" would be more fitting though), it quickly evolved into much more than that.Until the Leo and Raph one-shots, I'd say the series has its tongue placed clearly in cheek.
CyberCubed
06-02-2009, 05:49 PM
Until the Leo and Raph one-shots, I'd say the series has its tongue placed clearly in cheek.
What was #2 a parody of? Seemed like that issue was when they established TMNT as a proper series.
Cipher
06-02-2009, 06:21 PM
What was #2 a parody of? Seemed like that issue was when they established TMNT as a proper series.But it's still a totally ridiculous plot, very purposefully hokey, right up until the fake-out ending. You can kind of tell that even though Eastman and Laird are setting up a continuity, they're doing it very irreverently. Almost like, "Alright, let's see how long this Turtle thing can keep going."
If there are any other Dragon Ball fans, it's kind of like this: The first arc was a direct parody of "The Journey West." But even after that, the series had a very toungue-in-cheek tone for a while. Same thing with Turtles.
BoggleKng
06-02-2009, 08:20 PM
On one hand it's a parody, but on the other hand it's an homage. There are elements of Daredevil:
Daredevil: His sensei is....The SticK
TMNT: Splinter (or Sliver...depending on the er timeline *lol*)
Daredevil: Ninja clan is...The Hand
TMNT: The Foot
The Hand also appear in Jackie Chan Adventures (altho they're known as The Dark Hand).
In some ways Elektra = Karai
The blind guy Chet saves from being run over by the TCRI truck was apperantly Daredevil himself.
Ahaa!!! It was Daredevil!!
Lil G
06-02-2009, 10:20 PM
I had two tmnt toys before I even saw the cartoon, then I fell in love with the cartoon, and then found out it was a comic book which I was too young to read at the time. They are two different worlds, both very good.
I actually started out with the OT and then went on to the toys from eBay, then the NT. I remember being on eBay when I was 7 and looking up "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" and coming across 3 of the comics. I begged my mom for them and she bought them for me. When I got them in the mail I of course read them right away. I remember saying to my mom, "Mom, its says 'the d word' in here, but i skipped over it." And she kind of said, "Oh." :lol:
Kendamu
06-03-2009, 10:36 AM
A few parody elements. The whole parody aspect was abandoned after the first issue.
I've noticed that the only people drawing the "It began as a parody, folks!" card are the people trying to defend/downplay how childish the cartoons and other media are.
You must've forgotten our few disagreements. I draw that card because, as serious as the stories get, I still find the concept funny at the end of the day.
PAAATE
06-03-2009, 11:03 AM
I have a hard time seeing even the first issue as a parody, probably because I'm not very familiar with the source material.
Though it's pretty clear there's some intertextuality going on :)
Dragon Turtle
06-03-2009, 09:15 PM
I kinda wish Mirage would still do a few more of their homages to other comics.
Other homages/parodies might include Nobody(Batman), Mr. Braunze(Doc Savage), Raptarr(Angel/Hawkman), and recently Galactose(Galactus).
The Big Bad
06-06-2009, 12:18 PM
I'd place the first issue of TMNT in the same category as Kill Bill is--it plays a lot of tropes straight out of love for the genre. Whether it can be called a parody...I have no idea. I would not call it a satire, though, as it doesn't have anything to say about the tropes it uses. Pastiche, maybe?
Andrew NDB
06-09-2009, 03:19 PM
Here's what Peter Laird has to say on the matter: (fresh from his blog)
There are definitely parodic elements in TMNT, but to call it a parody is stretching the definition. I look on it as a fairly straightforward adventure story with some elements of parody.
However, it has been my experience that many journalists tend to be lazy, and calling it a parody is an easy way to describe it... even if it is not very accurate. -- PL
Candy Kappa
06-09-2009, 03:35 PM
Its a serious parody paying homage to other comics
"Serious parody" does not compute. While humor isn't a necessity in all definitions of the word (http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/parody), it is in the majority.
Cipher
06-09-2009, 04:59 PM
"Serious parody" does not compute. While humor isn't a necessity in all definitions of the word (http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/parody), it is in the majority.Joke concept + Straightfoward execution = Still a joke = First few issues of TMNT.
How hard is that to understand?
Not too hard, but it's still a stretch of the definition, like Laird said. If that was the definition, that would why comic books aren't usually comical... because they are all joke concepts, most of which are handled as serious epics.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.