View Full Version : Creative decisions regarding Vol.2 and Vol.3
Mr._Mutant_Man
06-07-2009, 11:54 AM
Something I've been wondering about lately is the "behind the scenes" of why the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles have four volumes, as opposed to having one ongoing series. I'm wondering if the fans have ever been given any insight into the creative decisions that went into the history of the different series. I know there is a transition to color from volume one to volume two, but at the same time they could have just said "issue 63 will mark TMNT going to color". I suppose it could have been a marketing thing too, since it was all the rage back then in comics to have "issue #1" as a collector's item. It's probably why Marvel did the volume 2 thing too, when they restarted Fantastic Four, and eventually Spider-Man (although the old numbering eventually returned).
CyberCubed
06-07-2009, 12:41 PM
Kevin/Pete say right in the editorial section of the City at War issues that they restarted at #1 because the book was going full-color and they wanted to better distinguish it.
Volume 2 of course was suppose to go on much longer than it did, I suppose if they knew they would only print 13 issues, they probably would have just had it been Volume 1 and continued from #63.
Image made sense to restart at #1 since it was published by a different company. And of course when Volume 4 started, since Image is no longer canon, it made things less confusing to simply start at #1 again.
Mr._Mutant_Man
06-07-2009, 02:45 PM
Was Mirage in trouble at some point? Is that why Image started publishing the comics instead?
Mirage wasn't in trouble from what I can tell. But they also weren't a huge comic publishing giant even with the backing of Eastman & Lairds income from the TMNT's success. Its a business descison of whats best for Mirage Studios. They did state in the mid-'90's when Vol. 2 was ending, due to the comic book market at the time, they decided to forego on publishing comics due to the lack of sales or orders if you will. The TMNT had huge orders on the old Mirage comics when the TMNT craze took off, but I think collectively all the comic stores saw it as nothing compared to when that surge of fame whithered and the stores cut back their orders, and the readers/comic buyers started to walk away from the TMNT. Plus I don't think the constant change in style and stories helped TMNT Vol. 1 series from a store owners thoughts of TMNT comics. They probably did better with the Archie TMNTA comics, cause the kids would still want that. This ceasing of publishing from Mirage also led to their intended other line of comics "Next Comics" to grind to a halt as well. Thats Why A.C Farley's "Bioneers" only had one issue, and the Next line whithered to with not much of an output of titles released. I guess thats when Erik Larson's Highbrow Entertainment and Image Comics came in a year or so later and licensed the TMNT for the Vol. 3 series. Eastman & Laird OK'd the notion of a new series for the fans, just without their involvement from the publishing side as Mirage was on a "hiatus" so to speak. Although I think they did sort of ghostly edit this book, at least from what I heard Peter did, but he really didn't interfere with the stories from that creative team at all. We all know he'd ret-con the Image series anyway in Vol.4. Its not the stories he'd have wanted told in Vol.3 if it was done by Mirage.
Andrew NDB
06-08-2009, 12:08 AM
Was Mirage in trouble at some point? Is that why Image started publishing the comics instead?
Yes, they were. There was flooding, and otherwise a great deal of hardship at Mirage pretty much forcing them to shop it around to a new publisher. Kevin was friendly with Erik Larsen, who launched Volume 3 through his own Highbrow Studios at Image.
Kevin and Peter both tried and fought to keep Volume 3 afloat -- even when it was operating at a loss the two of them would pay out of their pocket to keep it coming to shelves.
Lordmylar06
06-08-2009, 12:35 AM
Yes, they were. There was flooding, and otherwise a great deal of hardship at Mirage pretty much forcing them to shop it around to a new publisher. Kevin was friendly with Erik Larsen, who launched Volume 3 through his own Highbrow Studios at Image.
Kevin and Peter both tried and fought to keep Volume 3 afloat -- even when it was operating at a loss the two of them would pay out of their pocket to keep it coming to shelves.
That's serious dedication right there. Not to mention that what I've read of vol. 3 is pretty good. I can't give a good enough reason as to why I didn't buy when the stuff came out, other than living in the boonies of TX where there were no comic shops. Sad turn of events for vol. 3.
DMC362
06-08-2009, 01:57 AM
Enjoyed the series but wish vol 3 did not end the way it did though.
Wished Mirage would bring back that Vol. 3 team of Carlson and Fosco and let them finish their stories like the TMNT Adventures is getting with the "Forever War". I mean why can't Mirage treat Tales of TMNT as an anthology of any TMNT stories, like DC"s former Legends of the Dark Knight"? This would be a great way for them to at least show us a conclusion or continuation of the Vol. 3 series. Is this a bad idea? I mean Mirage could always slap inside the front "not in canon".
Andrew NDB
06-09-2009, 01:20 AM
Enjoyed the series but wish vol 3 did not end the way it did though.
Having spoken to Gary on numerous occasions after the series ended, even years later, 2-4 more issues and things might have ended much more amicably for fans.
I think it'd be cool to see Gary writing an issue or two of Tales.
Archon_Turtle
06-09-2009, 01:54 AM
Wished Mirage would bring back that Vol. 3 team of Carlson and Fosco and let them finish their stories like the TMNT Adventures is getting with the "Forever War". I mean why can't Mirage treat Tales of TMNT as an anthology of any TMNT stories, like DC"s former Legends of the Dark Knight"? This would be a great way for them to at least show us a conclusion or continuation of the Vol. 3 series. Is this a bad idea? I mean Mirage could always slap inside the front "not in canon".
did they not finish it? I honestly haven't read any of it yet cause I have a thing about starting a series I don't own all the issues to (and Im still missing a handful of volume 3)...
Cipher
06-09-2009, 07:45 AM
did they not finish it? I honestly haven't read any of it yet cause I have a thing about starting a series I don't own all the issues to (and Im still missing a handful of volume 3)...Not really. It kind of has a slap-dash little ending with all the major plot threads still up in the air.
CyberCubed
06-09-2009, 11:47 AM
It depends. Do you view the Turtles disfigurement to be "loose ends?" There were plans to have Don lose some more of the cyborg armor, and there was something about Leo regrowing his hand hinted...but meh.
The book ends with the Turtles at war with the Foot Clan again, Pimiko becoming their friend, and Lady Shredder (Karai) as the leader of the Foot again.
Cipher
06-09-2009, 05:03 PM
It depends. Do you view the Turtles disfigurement to be "loose ends?" There were plans to have Don lose some more of the cyborg armor, and there was something about Leo regrowing his hand hinted...but meh.Since their inclusion was obviously building to something, and was going to be resolved, yes.
The book ends with the Turtles at war with the Foot Clan again, Pimiko becoming their friend, and Lady Shredder (Karai) as the leader of the Foot again.Isn't Splinter's life still being drained by a rogue Foot Mystic or something? I forget, but do Casey and April ever get a conclusion to their troubles? And Lady Shredder is clearly introduced as the beginning of an arc, rather than the end, since they didn't even get to reveal her identity in the book.
I guess it has about as much of ending as the Fast Foward cartoon does. All the immediate threats are wrapped up, but some of the longer running conflicts and side characters don't get resolved.
CyberCubed
06-09-2009, 06:32 PM
Isn't Splinter's life still being drained by a rogue Foot Mystic or something?
Cheng said he was zapping away Splinter's lifeforce, but I always figured Raph would hunt him down. I'm just happy Splinter got turned back to normal before the book ended. Can you imagine if Image ended and Splinter was still a mutated bat? Thank god that was resolved before the end.
I forget, but do Casey and April ever get a conclusion to their troubles?
The check bounced that Casey got for killing those giant komodo lizards in the sewers. Their money troubles though is just a fact of life for any young couple with a kid, I don't view that as a loose end.
And Lady Shredder is clearly introduced as the beginning of an arc, rather than the end, since they didn't even get to reveal her identity in the book.
They had said previously that Karai mysteriously disappeared for some reason, so seeing her back at the head of the Foot Clan was a satisfying ending. She even says to Leonardo as they were fighting, "Don't you remember me?" as if they were close rivals or something.
The Turtles will always have an uneasy rivalry/truce with the Foot Clan, (look at how in Tales, future Raph was fighting Foot in Tokyo in 2060 or whatever it was), so it ends letting us know the Turtle Vs. Foot rivalry will continue.
I also liked Pimiko somewhat becoming their friend, so it gave decent closure to her character at least.
Jester
06-09-2009, 07:42 PM
I think it'd be cool to see Gary writing an issue or two of Tales.
Maybe even a couple issues to make Vol. 3 canonical. :P
Newton Gimmick
06-09-2009, 08:16 PM
I've always thought Volume 3 was great. It was drastically different because the TMNT were essentially dropped into a new setting, but the characters and stories played out well.
TMNT had better exposure with Image because it was more likely that Image could get the book to shelves than Mirage could, but the comics industry was taking a HUGE hit around the time the Image book started and it was in a lot of ways doomed from the start.
This was really before you had all the different venues of distributing media that exist now.
I've always thought Volume 3 was great. It was drastically different because the TMNT were essentially dropped into a new setting, but the characters and stories played out well.
TMNT had better exposure with Image because it was more likely that Image could get the book to shelves than Mirage could, but the comics industry was taking a HUGE hit around the time the Image book started and it was in a lot of ways doomed from the start.
This was really before you had all the different venues of distributing media that exist now.
Your right the TMNT Image run probably gave the TMNT better exposure. The book would come out on time somewhat. But the TMNT weren't too popular among comic stores for their "order lists". There were not enough readers or TMNT fans supporting the book for it to continue. Like AndrewNDB said, Eastman & Laird even offered to fund the book to continue when Erik Larson and Image were going to pull the plug. But Image told them there'd be no point as the numbers were so bad it really wouldn't be worth the effort to only prolong its cancellation. But the comic was suffering sluggish sales slowly. It ran for 3 years but only produced 23 issues. In that time it was monthly, then went bi-monthly, then quarterly almost. These were signs of its demise coming soon. Even with Image Comics publishing it, this TMNT vol.3 couldn't stand out on shelves and get readers. But it really helped fill the void for TMNT comics though and its the only time I committed to an Image comic title.
Andrew NDB
06-16-2009, 08:55 PM
Like AndrewNDB said, Eastman & Laird even offered to fund the book to continue when Erik Larson and Image were going to pull the plug.
No, they actually did for the last few issues... but when sales kept slipping even more it was like keeping a patient that was brain dead and dying on life support.
No, they actually did for the last few issues... but when sales kept slipping even more it was like keeping a patient that was brain dead and dying on life support.
Oh really? I didn't even know they did fund the last couple issues. Learn something everyday.
CyberCubed
06-16-2009, 11:04 PM
Makes you wonder how much Pete/Kevin gave to Image to keep the book printing.
Cipher
06-17-2009, 12:50 AM
Makes you wonder how much Pete/Kevin gave to Image to keep the book printing.Also makes you wonder why people continue to claim that one or both of them doesn't care about the TMNT.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.