PDA

View Full Version : The "Guest Artist Era" - Why Do You Hate It?


Cipher
06-12-2009, 06:22 PM
Seriously. If I ever see anyone mention Vol 1 #22 through #45, it's only to say, "Skip them. There are some good ones like "The River," but most of them are really bad."

Now, I haven't read the entire run of guest artist issues. In fact, I haven't yet read "The River," the ass of which everyone seems to have their head about a foot into. But just today I finally got Zulli's "Soul's Winter Trilogy" and Matt Howarth's "Turtle Dreams" while browing a used bookstore with friends. I have now read 90% of the run, I can honestly say that I haven't read a bad issue yet.

What I've read: 27-28, 31-43.

What I really liked: 27, 28, 31, 35, 36, 37, 42

What I liked: Everything else.

Why do you guys hate these issues? I'm so glad Mirage was willing to experiment with the series. Is it the lack of continuity and action?

And I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that Matt Howarth's and Hedden/MckWeeney's issues are the least liked. The former I found very interesting (he actually remembered they were teenagers!) and appealing with its off-beat, independant style. I'm actually interested in finding some of his self-published work. The latter, is actually quite funny, and an enjoyable experiment if nothing else. The only artist I'm not real hep on is Mark Bode, but his Egypt issue was kind of fun.

CyberCubed
06-12-2009, 06:30 PM
I admit, when I read those issues for the first time a million years ago, I disliked them because of the lack of continuity and the constant changing tone. We'd go from slapstick comedy issues to all-serious issues, to thought-provoking issues, to some very weird stuff.

However a year or so ago I decided to re-visit them now that I'm older and could appreciate the stories better. And you know what? You're right, most of them are pretty good.

I do think the comedy issues are a bit out of place, especially Mark Martin's stuff and #38-41, but if those were released as separate specials like "The Maltese Turtle" was, it wouldn't be that much a problem.

Also, I think its kind of like "anime filler syndrome." Its like Leo just decapitated the Shredder and you're excited to see what happens next...only to go to a comedy story where a giant rat called "The Fannywacker" starts smacking people around. In a similar way to people disliking anime filler, that's sort of what #22-44 felt like.

Its generally filler, but some of it is very good. And I wager that stuff is better than some of the new Tales issues we've been getting.

Cipher
06-12-2009, 06:48 PM
Its generally filler, but some of it is very good. And I wager that stuff is better than some of the new Tales issues we've been getting.This I'll definitely agree with. If you want to talk about "filler syndrome," Tales Volume 2 is filled with it. Whereas the guest artist era of Volume 1 was brilliantly experimental (you really remember you're reading an independant comic), some of the Tales issues do nothing to break the mold or further the story. The very worst issues of Tales are episodic without being deep, and you actually feel that the artist/writer is being held back by the series' restraints.

Lordmylar06
06-12-2009, 07:21 PM
I won't lie, I really, really dislike the Hedden-McWeeny stuff. The River was cool, It was kind of self contained, but it felt legit. Much of the guest artist era felt kind of legit. The only other thing that really felt like it didn't belong was Soul's Winter(the Zulli stuff) and that was GOOD. It was just kinda else-worldsy. The rest of the "guest artist era" was kinda nice. I especially love the A.C. Farley issues because they could stand alone, yet they seemed to fit into continuity perfectly, AND I just love his take on the turtles.

So to sum it up, the only stuff I really didn't like was the Hedden-McWeeny stuff. It just all seemed to belong in Turtle Soup, or a spoof anthology book. I would have accepted it it more that way I think, or possibly would have been more inclined to even like it.

oldmanwinters
06-13-2009, 11:26 AM
So to sum it up, the only stuff I really didn't like was the Hedden-McWeeny stuff. It just all seemed to belong in Turtle Soup, or a spoof anthology book. I would have accepted it it more that way I think, or possibly would have been more inclined to even like it.

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3569/3361341128_07eb64558e.jpg

Spitfire
06-13-2009, 11:42 AM
Honestly the only issues I disliked were the ones that Mark Martin did. Probably a few others but his off the top of my head were the ones I couldn't get into. His arts not bad but his stories made no sense and his books read like novels. There's so much text a page it takes forever to blow through them.

Lordmylar06
06-13-2009, 08:29 PM
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3569/3361341128_07eb64558e.jpg
HAHAHAHAHA! This is funny. Well at least he has a sense of humor about it. :D

Skinkie
06-14-2009, 12:37 AM
While the occasional off kilter issue would have been ok, especially if not included in the regular issue numbering, so many in a row that aren't official, is a little off putting.
________
Infants Prilosec (http://www.classactionsettlements.org/lawsuit/prilosec/)

Dan
06-14-2009, 12:47 AM
What do you mean aren't official? They were published by Mirage weren't they?

MurderOfCrows
06-14-2009, 01:18 AM
What do you mean aren't official? They were published by Mirage weren't they?

I think that they mean that they're not genuinely In Continuity. They're Just There. Stories about turtles, but not in the main continuity. If they'd put them in Tales, it might've been a better idea.

DK2
06-14-2009, 01:28 AM
What do you mean aren't official? They were published by Mirage weren't they?

Its just that in the overall context of the Vol. 1 series' intended main narrative, it'd be impossible to say that these "guest issues" are in canon/continuity. Sure they were from Mirage, but can anyone honestly believe that #16,22-23 as an example, belongs with the TMNT Eastman & Laird stories? There are other issues too that'd be in the same category. About half of Vol. 1 series are the main canon. Its generally, TMNT 1-11, TMNT solo issues, 19-21, 48-62, Fugitoid solo. I'm not sure which others would count. I can't see why the River 24-26 can't be in this. Issue 28 (great story) should count as it references the "River" arc and #21. Maybe #45 if I'm not mistaken, that had Leatherhead didn't it? But I don't know what else should or shouldn't be in canon. Do you think any of the whacky cartoony TMNT Vol.1 guest issues would be a part of the Mirage canon? Or the Micheal Zulli issues, 31, 35-36? The TMNT look really creepy and lifelike in those. Its just whatever Peter Laird says is the overall core Mirage issues, which I don't think he's stated officially what is. Most TMNT readers know what is main canon. I know this can be confusing to any new TMNT comics reader.

Cipher
06-14-2009, 01:53 AM
Apart from Mark Martin's, Michael Zulli's, and Hedden-McWeeny's issues, I don't see what issues couldn't easily fit into Mirage continuity, if only with minor tweaks.

I'm even inclined to consider Howarth's issue and, yes, Hedden-McWeeny's "Spaced Out" trilogy. Sure, the stories are silly, and include some elements of the cartoon Turtles, but it's easy enough to say that those events really did happen, albeit with a different tone than the artist presents.

As for what is definitely canon according to the Mirage honchos, #27 and #45 are on the list. I actually don't include #45 in the "guest artist era," because it's drawn by a Mirage regular and is the first step back into a continuity-focused series.

Lordmylar06
06-14-2009, 11:07 AM
Apart from Mark Martin's, Michael Zulli's, and Hedden-McWeeny's issues, I don't see what issues couldn't easily fit into Mirage continuity, if only with minor tweaks.

I agree, and some need no tweaks at all. There's some high quality good canon reading in there. These guys treated the ongoing issues with respect, and didn't get all goofy or interpretive with the subject matter. The others(mentioned in the quote) didn't do so well for what the ongoing series could have been.

shuriken
06-15-2009, 12:33 AM
I liked a lot of those comics. I reall wish Dooney would have drawn more issues though.

CyberCubed
06-15-2009, 12:56 PM
#27-28 and #45-62 are all done by Mirage artists.

Issue #29 was also done by A.C. Farley, and it has vampires in it, I seem to recall it being included in canon although I don't remember.

discordiatookie
06-15-2009, 08:20 PM
I love the fact that Eastman & Laird opened up their arms and let a whole buncha artists do different takes on the TMNT.

Honestly, the only one I actually dislike is #34, Toitle Anxiety. However, the Spaced Out trilogy I find good fun.

I absolutely love Mark Martin's three issues, but I don't like his parody one (Green-Grey Sponge-Suit Sushi Turtles) I could never get into. Still, for Mirage to actually print that is pretty awesome.