PDA

View Full Version : Interesting TMNT Comics Info


Dragon Turtle
06-19-2009, 08:08 PM
I recently e-mailed Dan Berger over at ninjaturtles.com, with a few questions, and received some interesting bits of info (sorry if any of this is old news).

1) Will we know more about the future of Tales of TMNT at SDCC?

Tales is going to go at least until May of 2010 unless Diamond drops it due to poor sales.


2)Has there been any recent attempts to see if other publishers would be interested in doing a crossover with the turtles.

Mirage has sought out another company to do crossovers in recent years, but despite enthusiasm from their creators and editorial departments, their top brass passed as they didn't want to help the TMNT establish a larger market presence.

3) Has Mirage though about licensing the turtles out to another comics publisher?

We've currently got another proposal in the works for a different publisher - we'll see how that goes. It would use the Mirage universe TMNT.

Spitfire
06-19-2009, 08:19 PM
Mirage has sought out another company to do crossovers in recent years, but despite enthusiasm from their creators and editorial departments, their top brass passed as they didn't want to help the TMNT establish a larger market presence.

Wonder what douche bag company that was. They didn't want to help them establish TMNT in the large market? Like **** you turtles your not allowed to be anything other then independent.

Andrew NDB
06-19-2009, 08:27 PM
We've currently got another proposal in the works for a different publisher - we'll see how that goes. It would use the Mirage universe TMNT.

Mirage has sought out another company to do crossovers in recent years, but despite enthusiasm from their creators and editorial departments, their top brass passed as they didn't want to help the TMNT establish a larger market presence.

I think I know the answers to both of these questions. You can probably guess the second one.

Lordmylar06
06-19-2009, 08:30 PM
So, not wanting the TMNT to be a presence in the market is a crossover deterrent? I agree, total douchebaggery on their part... I don't care who it is either, that's just a sucky thing to do. Wonder which publisher would be producing the TMNT comics...

TristanHuwJones
06-19-2009, 08:36 PM
My guess would be one of the big two... Marvel probably, though one would have to wonder what the TMNT DC connection would be like with WB being involved in the movies...

Lordmylar06
06-19-2009, 08:47 PM
I could imagine WB quickly snatching up rights for the comic if it came down to something like that. Then you'd see DC take their shot at ruining TMNT. Lovely.
Edit: Don't get me wrong. There are some wonderful Marvel, DC, and DC owned Vertigo titles out there, but the creative team would have to take it seriously and not treat it with kid gloves or portray it in the light that it's a kids property. This IS the MIRAGE version of the TMNT we're talking about here.

Andrew NDB
06-19-2009, 08:49 PM
I could imagine WB quickly snatching up rights for the comic if it came down to something like that. Then you'd see DC take their shot at ruining TMNT. Lovely.

The CCA-free DC of nowadays could probably do a pretty good TMNT book... but they pretty much have zero tolerance for less-than-blockbuster sales. And then that'd be the end of them.

Lordmylar06
06-19-2009, 08:59 PM
The key word is "could". My worry is that it would not be treated seriously enough. They could do great with no CCA, but who writes DC's TMNT? It COULD be a disaster.

Spitfire
06-19-2009, 09:23 PM
The CCA-free DC of nowadays could probably do a pretty good TMNT book... but they pretty much have zero tolerance for less-than-blockbuster sales. And then that'd be the end of them.

Turtles would get good sales if they started the series up with a very "in your face" attitude. Making the series both interesting to fans of the old and roping in new fans.

It worked for Moon Knight who was a C list character until David Finch and Charlie Huston re-booted him in '06. It became one of the top selling titles of that year and was noted as one of the best come backs in a long time.

The story worked very well as it told a completely new story but used flashbacks to give the reader hints at what happened in the past. While it wasn't necessary to read the older comics it did help. I was following the story just fine without reading the older issues, I just decided to for the hell of it. Story like that would work great for turtles. Jump ahead into their future. I think the way Image started off was a good way to rope you in they need a bang intro like that or to start off with something shocking, such as an event that we haven't seen yet that's eluded to. A main character dieing or them doing something they seriously regret.

Andrew NDB
06-19-2009, 11:37 PM
Turtles would get good sales if they started the series up with a very "in your face" attitude. Making the series both interesting to fans of the old and roping in new fans.

Maybe... but would it ever be pulling Batman numbers? JLA numbers?

With a white hot writer and white hot artist team it might get enough buzz to get off to a running start... but I wouldn't have any confidence TMNT could ever see -- long-term -- a healthy run at the Big Two.

junkboy
06-20-2009, 03:20 AM
Even if it was the Mirage U that they used, it would not be the same you know. What a pity the Turtle concept is TOO much for a big company to make it good. I am least optimistic about the success of such a thing. But that company would publish the omnibus and such stuff for old volumes if they got the rights and that would be cool.
Maybe most ppl do not like Volume 3 ( i like it ), but not just cause that it is my fave. comic-book company... Image would be the most fitting company to publish TMNT in today's conditions imo. The reader type of Image is ready to embrace TMNT. ( at least more ready than Marvel or DC )
And tho IDW is starting to get ahead of them in sales nowadays. Image and Dark Horse are still third/fourth biggest publishers in business for me.

Mr._Mutant_Man
06-20-2009, 09:32 AM
The CCA-free DC of nowadays could probably do a pretty good TMNT book... but they pretty much have zero tolerance for less-than-blockbuster sales.

Isn't Marvel pretty much the same way, though?

I'd like to see them get licensed to another publisher if Mirage isn't able to continue things on their own. Would probably increase the likelihood of more TPBs too.

CyberCubed
06-20-2009, 01:49 PM
Why are people acting like this is the first time Mirage has done this?

Why do you think both the Image and Dreamwave series were canceled? It wasn't because of the writing, it was because of a lack of sales.

I also don't understand why Mirage is doing this, and then Pete will decide to retcon everything if another publisher takes interest. The whole Image series started off as a direct continuation of the Mirage universe, but Pete decided to retcon everything and start from scratch.

If another publisher continues to use the Mirage-universe Turtles, who is to say Pete won't retcon everything a second time after it ends like what happened to Image?

ToTheNines
06-20-2009, 01:54 PM
If another publisher continues to use the Mirage-universe Turtles, who is to say Pete won't retcon everything a second time after it ends like what happened to Image?

Dude, does it matter? It's a work of fiction, so you can accept what you wanna accept. I'm sure alot of people pretend volume 4 never happened.

Plus if Pete calls it quits he won't have a change to retcon anything.

Lordmylar06
06-20-2009, 02:31 PM
Maybe... but would it ever be pulling Batman numbers? JLA numbers?

With a white hot writer and white hot artist team it might get enough buzz to get off to a running start... but I wouldn't have any confidence TMNT could ever see -- long-term -- a healthy run at the Big Two.

And this is why I don't think Marvel or DC would be a good choice, even though they may be likely. I would love it if Dark Horse or Image had a shot with the book. Dark Horse has Usagi Yojimbo and Stan Sakai has had about 120 issues
there. As for retconning or acting like it didn't happen, I know Laird retconned after the Image run, but I'm one of those people that finds himself enjoying the Image run. I even kinda liked the Dreamwave series. I'd hate to find myself enjoying something again only to have it unfinished. IF this happens, I just hope it happens right.

Cipher
06-20-2009, 06:06 PM
If another publisher continues to use the Mirage-universe Turtles, who is to say Pete won't retcon everything a second time after it ends like what happened to Image?Maybe, but as long as it's good, who cares? The Image run was, and still is, a great read, whether or not it connects to Tales Vol 2 and Volume 4. Nothing wrong with a couple of continuities if it opens up the way for good stories.

And this is all extremely hypothetical to begin with.

darthsmozers
06-20-2009, 08:17 PM
My guess would be one of the big two... Marvel probably, though one would have to wonder what the TMNT DC connection would be like with WB being involved in the movies...

Archie ;)

haha j/k

Coola Yagami
06-21-2009, 03:17 AM
Archie ;)

haha j/k


Why not? isn't their Sonic series still running?

Mr._Mutant_Man
06-21-2009, 05:27 PM
Why do you think both the Image and Dreamwave series were canceled? It wasn't because of the writing, it was because of a lack of sales.

I also don't understand why Mirage is doing this, and then Pete will decide to retcon everything if another publisher takes interest. The whole Image series started off as a direct continuation of the Mirage universe, but Pete decided to retcon everything and start from scratch.

If another publisher continues to use the Mirage-universe Turtles, who is to say Pete won't retcon everything a second time after it ends like what happened to Image?

Well wasn't Dreamwave run into the ground by the guy that was in charge? The guy that nobody likes?

If Laird decided to retcon future series, who cares? Is it really that big a deal whether or not a story is considered "official"? If that was the case, then there would be no reason to read DC Elseworlds.

odupianist
06-22-2009, 10:13 AM
I have a feeling the reason the big publisher didn't want it is because it would be like Moon Knight, a big comeback that would get great sales (provided the art and writing were good of course). I think their pride is getting in the way because they know this would happen and they know the TMNT isn't one of their own in house creations

Spitfire
06-22-2009, 11:34 AM
Well wasn't Dreamwave run into the ground by the guy that was in charge? The guy that nobody likes?
Yeah that's exactly what happened. Everything got canceled including the Devil May Cry comic that only had one issue left. Also no one would touch their projects. They tried to get other publishers to publish the rest of their series but no one would do it.

So that had a part in it. Also the fact it was hands down the worst turtles comic. It had to do with everything but the turtles. The artwork is amazing but they had to kill it by focusing on background characters.

If Laird decided to retcon future series, who cares? Is it really that big a deal whether or not a story is considered "official"? If that was the case, then there would be no reason to read DC Elseworlds.
Yeah those Elseworld stories are awesome. I love Batman Vampire.

CyberCubed
06-22-2009, 01:05 PM
I'm surprised Mirage is really looking for another active publisher, but not so surprised that nobody seems to want to do it.

Other comic publishers know that even if TMNT sells decently at first, sales always decline as the series continues. It happens to just about every TMNT comic...it starts off fine and then barely lingers on until they finally pull the plug.

I am surprised Tales actually managed to get more than 60 issues, its an amazing feat when you think about how long it lasted compared to other series.

bedbugjones
06-22-2009, 01:30 PM
aaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhh dont be negative

ToTheNines
06-22-2009, 03:48 PM
I'm surprised Mirage is really looking for another active publisher, but not so surprised that nobody seems to want to do it.

Other comic publishers know that even if TMNT sells decently at first, sales always decline as the series continues. It happens to just about every TMNT comic...it starts off fine and then barely lingers on until they finally pull the plug.

I am surprised Tales actually managed to get more than 60 issues, its an amazing feat when you think about how long it lasted compared to other series.

Holy ****in damnit man! Let's make a deal... between the General TMNT, New TMNT movie, New TMNT cartoon and Comic discussion sections, you have to choose one of them to never bitch in again. You're killin us from all angles man, chill out.

Archon_Turtle
06-22-2009, 05:51 PM
Holy ****in damnit man! Let's make a deal... between the General TMNT, New TMNT movie, New TMNT cartoon and Comic discussion sections, you have to choose one of them to never bitch in again. You're killin us from all angles man, chill out.

Quoted for truth. Seriously CyberCubed. Why do you even post here? You can't seriously consider yourself a fan right? I mean...nobody else does...

Dragon Turtle
06-22-2009, 07:24 PM
Other comic publishers know that even if TMNT sells decently at first, sales always decline as the series continues.


You can say that about 90% of all comic book franchises. If you put out a good product and support it with equally good marketing, there is no reason why a TMNT comic couldn't find it's place in the current comics market.

Dragon Turtle
08-17-2009, 02:48 PM
UPDATE:

Sadly it seems that there will not be a new series from another publisher, according to Dan Berger.