PDA

View Full Version : Sarah Michelle Gellar and Chris Evans reprising ?


sdp
07-12-2009, 12:35 PM
http://www.whedon.info/Sarah-Michelle-Gellar-Teenga.html

Anyone remember when Laird mentioned a few times that he'd like them to reprise their roles? This wasn't so long ago either.

What are your thoughts on this?

At first to me Sarah seems like a perfect April, however after I looked how old she was she is not that young anymore.. She'd be 34 by the time the movie comes out (IF it comes out in 2011). And if it indeed ended up being a trilogy( of films (like Laird hopes) she'd be nearly 40 by the time the third one came out (counting they came out only 2 years apart). And while you could say she looks younger, I looked up some recent pictures and she is starting to look older. She's also pregnant but she would have had the baby before shooting would begin. So yeah I'm not so sure she'd be great for the role anymore, she seems too old. In comparison Judith Hoag was in her early 20s (~20) when she played April. And so was Paige Turco.


Chris Evans is around the same age as Elias Koteas was which is a good age for casey. If he grew his hair a bit he could pull it off, however I still don't like him since he'd still look too much like a "pretty boy" to actually be Casey, who has to be someone who looks more "rougher".

Aztec General
07-12-2009, 01:42 PM
Ummm...that link is from September 2008. You better change your thread title, it's very misleading.

ToTheNines
07-12-2009, 01:53 PM
Dude, you scared the **** outta me. Change title before **** blows up lol.

gobo
07-12-2009, 03:37 PM
Someone must not understand the point of a reboot if they still want Evans and Gellar to reprise their roles. But, let me echo the fact that this thread title is very misleading.

Slap-Happy
07-12-2009, 03:45 PM
Thank GOD this isn't happening.

sdp
07-12-2009, 03:54 PM
I can see how the title can be read to be misleading, sorry, tried to add a question mark but its too late to edit titles.

Ummm...that link is from September 2008. You better change your thread title, it's very misleading.
Its not even a year old, the quote is still relevant.


Someone must not understand the point of a reboot if they still want Evans and Gellar to reprise their roles. But, let me echo the fact that this thread title is very misleading.

So? its a reboot storywise, that doesn't mean they can't reprise their roles as the character. In animation reboots sometimes use their old VAs as well. Marlo Brando was in Superman Returns and that was a reboot.


You guys make it out like the quote is very old but its not, just a couple of months old its still relevant.


Its funny when the quote first appeared I remember people liking the idea, but I guess not. I mean I also don't like the idea, mostly because Gellar is too old and Evans too much of a "pretty boy" but other than that they wouldn't be too bad.

The Shelf
07-12-2009, 03:57 PM
NOOOOOooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!

...

Wait, this isn't actually happening? *phew* We can only hope that it never does. I'm sure they're great and all, but I'd rather they get someone else. I loved TMNT '07, but I wasn't a fan of April or Casey in that movie.

EDIT: I don't think Gellar is too old by any stretch of the word, but she's too tiny, and I don't think her voice suits April very well. Same with Evans (the voice part, not him being tiny :P) Plus, Evans was just annoying in Fantastic Four, so... No.

Ninjinister
07-12-2009, 04:09 PM
Its not even a year old, the quote is still relevant.


But this was written before the current plans for the new movie had been cemented.

johnnyblaze
07-12-2009, 04:14 PM
NOOOOOooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!

...

Wait, this isn't actually happening? *phew* We can only hope that it never does. I'm sure they're great and all, but I'd rather they get someone else. I loved TMNT '07, but I wasn't a fan of April or Casey in that movie.

EDIT: I don't think Gellar is too old by any stretch of the word, but she's too tiny, and I don't think her voice suits April very well. Same with Evans (the voice part, not him being tiny :P) Plus, Evans was just annoying in Fantastic Four, so... No.

He was playing an entirely different character in Fantastic Four though so of course he's not going to act the same way. And he could very well just use a different voice for a live action Casey which would make sense since he'd be playing the character in a different medium in a different style film.

The Shelf
07-12-2009, 05:19 PM
He was playing an entirely different character in Fantastic Four though so of course he's not going to act the same way.

That's irrelevant. I'll always see him as an annoying Johnny Storm. He might be able to play a good Casey, but I'd rather they just get someone else.

ToTheNines
07-12-2009, 05:23 PM
http://www.webwombat.com.au/entertainment/movies/images/fantastic4-chris-evans-1.jpg

NO!

johnnyblaze
07-12-2009, 09:08 PM
That's irrelevant. I'll always see him as an annoying Johnny Storm. He might be able to play a good Casey, but I'd rather they just get someone else.

The fact that he wouldn't be playing Johnny Storm and thus everything about him would be different in the film is irrelevant?

Buslady
07-13-2009, 12:00 AM
we dont need buffy oneil
and chris evans is fine as flameboy but not casey...no way

Vincent
07-13-2009, 07:48 PM
I wouldn't have a problem with it, they could do worse, but I wouldn't mind a new April and Casey either. Best suggestions I've heard so far are probably Cobie Smulders and Taylor Kitsch.

Andrew NDB
07-13-2009, 10:10 PM
http://www.webwombat.com.au/entertainment/movies/images/fantastic4-chris-evans-1.jpg

NO!

http://www.thegreenlanterncorps.com/evan2.jpg

Might not be my first choice, but he could probably pull it off fine.

I don't want to see Gellar as April, though, as much as I love the actress and as much as I love Buffy. Just doesn't fit to me. Her old Buffy co-star, Eliza Dushku, however... now she seems a perfect fit to me.

http://www.shinyuniverse.net/assets/images/eliza_dushku.jpg

Though I dunno. Too pretty, maybe? April should look a little bit everywomanish.

Jester
07-13-2009, 10:31 PM
http://www.thegreenlanterncorps.com/evan2.jpg

Might not be my first choice, but he could probably pull it off fine.

I don't want to see Gellar as April, though, as much as I love the actress and as much as I love Buffy. Just doesn't fit to me. Her old Buffy co-star, Eliza Dushku, however... now she seems a perfect fit to me.

http://www.shinyuniverse.net/assets/images/eliza_dushku.jpg

Though I dunno. Too pretty, maybe? April should look a little bit everywomanish.
I dunna, Andy, I's starting to agree that Evans, though a decent actor, is too much a pretty boy to be Casey.

And as for Eliza, I like her too, but I also agree April's more "average" than Eliza is.

Andrew NDB
07-13-2009, 10:45 PM
I dunna, Andy, I's starting to agree that Evans, though a decent actor, is too much a pretty boy to be Casey.

Well... it's not like Casey Jones is Frankenstein under the mask. It's never been shown or alluded that he's unattractive or anything. As long as Evans could play up the machismo with naivete angle I think he'd be fine.

gobo
07-13-2009, 11:40 PM
Eliza Dushku?? O_o And, here I was, always believing you had respect for the property. >_<

Ninjinister
07-13-2009, 11:49 PM
I'd like to know why out of the thousands of images there have to be out there of this guy, somebody keeps bringing up the same damn pic.

Andrew NDB
07-13-2009, 11:51 PM
Eliza Dushku??

She's got... spirit. :)

odupianist
07-14-2009, 09:49 AM
I could see Eliza pulling it off, but she's just like Chris, too pretty for it. April was a computer tech. Last I checked, not many comp techs looked like her lol. Casey doesn't have to be ugly, but he does look like he has taken many punches over the years. Granted, they could do that with the proper make up, so if they could do that, Chris might be able to pull it off

TMNTD
07-19-2009, 05:11 PM
No to Evans, and HELL NO to Gellar.

April : Allison Mack

Casey : Taylor Kitsh

' nuff said.

Wes
07-19-2009, 05:24 PM
Yeah, I don't want to see either of them.

Nor do I want to see Eliza Dushku as April. As much as I liked her as Faith, she's a terrible actress -- the horrible "Dollhouse" pretty much proved that Faith is the only role Eliza can play even remotely convincingly. I can do without April Lehane thank you very much. :P

I love Allie Mack, but I just don't see her as April. I was thinking maaaybe Anna Torv (Olivia Dunham on "Fringe") or Ari Graynor (who plays her sister on that show). Like Judith Hoag, I kinda want the next April to have freckles. :lol:

sdp
07-20-2009, 01:53 AM
I remember when this interview first came out response seemed more positive...


Anyways my opinion is already in the first post but I think you guys are being too harsh.


SMG would have been a perfect April IMO, if it wasn't for her age I would have loved to see her play April.

Chris Evans could have pulled off Casey pretty good as well, not as good as SMG but I wouldn't be angry if it happened.

Wes
07-20-2009, 03:41 PM
So I was watching True Blood last night... and what would y'all think of Deborah Ann Woll for April? :D

http://www.imdb.com/media/rm3983513088/nm2832695

Vincent
07-20-2009, 05:24 PM
So the casting discussion has been moved to this thread now or what?

Wes
07-20-2009, 09:11 PM
I guess there was some overlap. My apologies! :lol:

Jephael
07-28-2009, 09:48 PM
So I was watching True Blood last night... and what would y'all think of Deborah Ann Woll for April? :D

http://www.imdb.com/media/rm3983513088/nm2832695

Now she would definitly make a good April!

TMNTD
07-31-2009, 03:21 PM
Now she would definitly make a good April!

Yeah, and she's HOT too !!!

turtle83
08-03-2009, 10:09 PM
http://www.whedon.info/Sarah-Michelle-Gellar-Teenga.html

Anyone remember when Laird mentioned a few times that he'd like them to reprise their roles? This wasn't so long ago either.

What are your thoughts on this?

At first to me Sarah seems like a perfect April, however after I looked how old she was she is not that young anymore.. She'd be 34 by the time the movie comes out (IF it comes out in 2011). And if it indeed ended up being a trilogy( of films (like Laird hopes) she'd be nearly 40 by the time the third one came out (counting they came out only 2 years apart). And while you could say she looks younger, I looked up some recent pictures and she is starting to look older. She's also pregnant but she would have had the baby before shooting would begin. So yeah I'm not so sure she'd be great for the role anymore, she seems too old. In comparison Judith Hoag was in her early 20s (~20) when she played April. And so was Paige Turco.


Chris Evans is around the same age as Elias Koteas was which is a good age for casey. If he grew his hair a bit he could pull it off, however I still don't like him since he'd still look too much like a "pretty boy" to actually be Casey, who has to be someone who looks more "rougher".



Bad idea. April should be hot, not average. Sarah is a little on the average side and I can't take Chris Evans serious as a Casey Jones.

I know it won't happen, but Collin Ferrel would be a really good Casey Jones.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
08-03-2009, 11:44 PM
If only one actor from TMNT were to reprise their role for use in a live-action movie, it should be Zhang Ziyi as Karai.

Just my two cents.

Wildcat
08-04-2009, 02:09 AM
Sarah Michelle Gellar too old and average? Some of you guys need to get to an eye-doctor. Sarah would make a great April.

I also think Elisha Cuthbert would make a good April. As for Casey Ive never really thought of it. Seriously though you guys are way too picky. Back in the day I bet none of you put so much emphasis on who played the human characters, granted I never thought the original April looked quite right (I liked Paige better) but it didnt bother me that much.

Brodie
08-04-2009, 02:24 AM
Gellar is a CHUD.

And she can't act.

Andrew NDB
08-04-2009, 02:34 AM
Sarah Michelle Gellar too old and average?

Little too old and too freakishly bone-thin. Right attitude and mannerisms, though. Kind of.

Gellar is a CHUD.

lol... yeouch.

Wildcat
08-04-2009, 03:11 AM
Little too old and too freakishly bone-thin. Right attitude and mannerisms, though. Kind of.

So what if shes in her early 30s? She doesnt look old and besides who ever said April had to be some young college-graduate type girl that was in thier 20s?

Original Toon April was obviously an older woman and had worked for Channel 6 news for sometime before she met the turtles. Even the two Aprils from the Live-Action movies were older women.

As far as her weight, shes not freakishly skinny like alot of celebrities are plus she will have proabably gained a few "baby fat" pounds after she has her baby.

The Stryker
08-04-2009, 11:44 AM
As far as her weight, shes not freakishly skinny like alot of celebrities are plus she will have proabably gained a few "baby fat" pounds after she has her baby.

Ok. Can't we get someone who can act then?

Sage Ninja
08-04-2009, 12:12 PM
If only one actor from TMNT were to reprise their role for use in a live-action movie, it should be Zhang Ziyi as Karai.

Just my two cents.

I completely agree with you. I love Zhang Ziyi and she had just the right presence to voice Karai in the 2007 movie. I would love to see her do a live action version of Karai; she'd be perfect. The only issue I see with her is that if she where to actually play Karai, I would want her to occassionally have some dialogue in Japanese, and since she is Chinese, I doubt she would know any in order to have any.

As for April and Casey? Get a good make up artist and have Elias Koteas reprise his roll dammit!! :lol: :lol:

Nah, but seriously as long as the actor playing him can bring Casey Jones to life for me, and make me believe he is a vigilante and some 'tude and not some goofball idiot, I'll like him. But they have to depict him as a badass, not a dumbass!

As for April, if she was still young enough, I would have loved to see Renee O'Connor play April. She would have done a great job in my oppinion. She played Gabrielle on Xena Warrior Princess and she just had this great presence. However I think the Renee O'Connor is in her mid or late 30's now so she obviously can't do it.

Who ever plays April should be attractive but not cover girl model beautiful.

turtle83
08-04-2009, 10:32 PM
No to Evans, and HELL NO to Gellar.

April : Allison Mack

Casey : Taylor Kitsh

' nuff said.

I totally agree with Allison Mack. She has a sweet personality and is kinda cute, BUT she looks a little too young even though she is 27 years old. Funny how Judith Hoag looked mad old in the 1990 movie when she was barely 21.

Sage Ninja
08-04-2009, 11:43 PM
I didn't think she looked that old...

CJStyles
08-05-2009, 12:54 AM
She was 21? Damn, she looked about 34 to me...

syk_skillz
08-05-2009, 01:13 AM
Yeah she did look kind a old to me also.

The Shelf
08-05-2009, 08:22 AM
What's wrong with you people? She looked like a woman in her 20's... which she was.

Cure
08-05-2009, 06:31 PM
She looked old to me, too, which is part of the reason of why I think she's so ugly.

turtle83
08-05-2009, 07:22 PM
but somehow she was perfect as April.

Jephael
08-05-2009, 09:43 PM
She did okay as the voice of April, but she didn't physically play the character.

NameGoesHere1066
08-11-2009, 04:26 PM
Original Toon April was obviously an older woman and had worked for Channel 6 news for sometime before she met the turtles. Even the two Aprils from the Live-Action movies were older women.

which is yet another reason why I respect the orginal toon so much, they portrayed April like a mature adult woman who was established in her career and had her own place. And for the most part I believe other mediums of the turtles have treated April fairly in this regard as well. But I don't see why April has to be this fresh faced teeney bopper 20 year old whos still in college or something to be a convincing April.

As for April and Casey? Get a good make up artist and have Elias Koteas reprise his roll dammit!!

damn straight!

sdp
07-31-2021, 08:09 PM
Well Chris Evans is clearly out of their budget nowadays but what about sarah michelle gellar?
https://www.hellomagazine.com/imagenes/healthandbeauty/health-and-fitness/20210112104361/sarah-michelle-gellar-swimsuit-photo-motivational-throwback/0-502-648/sarah-michelle-gellar-t.jpg

She was beautiful in the early 2000's but she aged out really fast, but she could play old April in an adaptation of a future event like Same as it never was?
https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-2003-series/images/d/d8/Futureapril2.jpg

frank_one
07-31-2021, 08:23 PM
She is ok for her age.

CyberCubed
07-31-2021, 08:29 PM
Sarah has actually aged really well, remember she is 44. Here is her instagram where she posts pics of herself daily and her family:

https://www.instagram.com/sarahmgellar/?hl=en

She's aged like fine wine. I'm usually hard on women aging but SMG is amazing.

Wildcat
07-31-2021, 11:48 PM
I was just about to bring up her instagram account. You can tell she uses a filter or extra make up in a lot of posts but there’s a few where she doesn’t and she looks so good. (girls really need to stop with the makeup, tanning and artificial stuff. They look so much better natural).

I don’t care what anyone says. She’d make a perfect live action April, currently.

CyberCubed
07-31-2021, 11:51 PM
Pretty much the entire female Buffy cast has aged well. Charisma Carpenter is over 50 now and looks amazing.

IMJ
08-01-2021, 12:30 PM
Might as well use that hot chick from the old "Veronica Mars" show - the star - she married that dufus from Jackass I think? What was her name?

frank_one
08-01-2021, 12:53 PM
Veronica Mars is my waifu.

oldmanwinters
08-01-2021, 09:59 PM
My apologies for the delay on this:
hihEhsdwiIk