View Full Version : If this is "The One", what do you guys expect?
Slap-Happy
07-14-2009, 12:56 AM
If this is to be the definitive Ninja Turtles movie, what do you guys expect or want from it?
1. I want them to stay as close to the mirage books as possible (though it's pretty much garunteed that there are colored masks) to get a PG-13 rating.
2. I want them to interest more people in the comics, rather than the cartoons.
3. I want this movie to be marketed the way other superhero movies are marketed.
4. I want the director of this movie to love the TMNT, to understand how all of us fell about it, for him to know what we will feel if he f**ks it up.
5. I want these people to listen to the fans.
But, my most wanted thing out of this movie is...
6. I want this movie to be GOOD.
What about you guys?
Cipher
07-14-2009, 01:19 AM
What I'd love but do not expect: Red masks.
What I have every right to expect but probably won't get: High caliber writing.
Andrew NDB
07-14-2009, 02:06 AM
Everything except the "listen to the fans" part. At least, broadly. Because there's a lot of crazies out there that speak more from "Bring back my childhood, cartoons, toys, and all!" and less from "Do what you need to make the best possible TMNT movie that's most becoming of the source material!"
And I think all-red bandannas would send a clear message -- as long as the rest of the film follows suit -- to all that this is a new beginning, a true reboot, and that all bets are off as far as the toddler-pandering of yore.
Spike Spiegel
07-14-2009, 10:35 AM
And I think all-red bandannas would send a clear message -- as long as the rest of the film follows suit -- to all that this is a new beginning, a true reboot, and that all bets are off as far as the toddler-pandering of yore.
I'm all for truly badass, actual "ninja" turtles that actually do "ninja" things. I hope this movie is the TMNT equvalent of "The Dark Knight."
Cipher
07-14-2009, 11:38 AM
I hope this movie is the TMNT equvalent of "The Dark Knight."The only way that could happen is with a "City at War" adaptation. But if it plays its cards right the movie could be the equivalent of Batman Begins.
Doc_ock_4mugen
07-14-2009, 11:49 AM
My Dont's:
no fart jokes, your momma jokes, no Venus, no Hyperactive/borderline special kid Mikey, no Mega angry Raph vs Splinter's boy Leo (at least knock it down a few notches...) stealing the spotlight and trurning Mike and Don into props.
My Do's:
NINJA ACTION!!! (They're called Teenage Mutant NINJA Turtles) Red Bandanas would be cool... (Chances are that we won't see them) A Real threatening Shredder (even if he's killed off in one Battle, he should be a REAL threat... not a pansy that can be beaten in three minutes.) PG-13 Rating... (We don't need a mega watered down bordreline G version of the TMNT.) An adaptation as close to the source material as possible and treated with respect... MOUSERS!!! Hundreds of them...
Andrew NDB
07-14-2009, 01:14 PM
The only way that could happen is with a "City at War" adaptation. But if it plays its cards right the movie could be the equivalent of Batman Begins.
"City at War" would be a very strange place to begin for a reboot. The whole story revolves/hinges upon the resolution of fallout from... events that haven't happened yet in the rebooted universe.
Cipher
07-14-2009, 01:46 PM
"City at War" would be a very strange place to begin for a reboot. The whole story revolves/hinges upon the resolution of fallout from... events that haven't happened yet in the rebooted universe.Oh, I know. I'm just saying we're not going to get a The Dark Knight in terms of story quality unless that's the source material. The original issues just aren't up there in the writing department.
Andrew NDB
07-14-2009, 01:58 PM
Oh, I know. I'm just saying we're not going to get a The Dark Knight in terms of story quality unless that's the source material. The original issues just aren't up there in the writing department.
Only if you're expecting a panel-for-panel adaptation. Which is silly. Not even The Dark Knight is a panel-for-panel adaptation, or close to it.
Aztec General
07-14-2009, 03:32 PM
I expect a PG-13 action movie that takes the characters seriously, and attempts to tell a coherent story that is respectful of the original source material (Mirage Comics).
PAAATE
07-14-2009, 03:34 PM
I expect an evil alien goo that transforms Casey Jones to a dancing emo boy. And then he hits April. :)
Or.. PG-13 movie, that treats the characters with respect.
I expect Krang and Shredder.
Cowabungas and Pizzas!
Technodrome, Rocksteady and Beebop too.
Slash/Rat King and Baxter Stockman as a fly in a sequel.
ToTheNines
07-14-2009, 04:40 PM
An intelligent story, decent characterization, solid acting and brutal fights.
Of course there's alot of other specific **** I'd like to see, but I won't get started on that.
Arcade Joe
07-14-2009, 07:39 PM
I too, would like a PG-13 rating for the movie, but I'm not holding my breath.
I think the movie will have a good balance of action, humor and drama. I also expect multi colored bandanas, not all red ones.
The movie will be successful if they choose the right people for the major roles for Shredder, April, etc....
I would try and avoid cliches, or keep it to a minimum.
I am a screenwriter, and if I were handling this, and had a say-so, I would do one thing.
The ending would be the Turtles losing to Shredder. You only get better with time, and if this is an origin story again, and it's back to square one, then have the Turtles lose the first round.
It could work as an ending wether they have a sequel or not. They are just learning and learned a lot throughout the movie. That you don't always win in fights, but you do learn a lot. So if there's a no-go on a sequel, at least they learned a lot from their experience. However, if there is a sequel, then they live to fight another day.
Whatever the case may be, Shredder shouldn't die. If they defeat him in this film, it should stay at defeat or near death. Not for the sake of bringing him back over and over, but because for Shredder to be a real threat - to me - he should last longer than one film.
The Terror of Death
07-14-2009, 08:47 PM
This film only needs one thing to be the definitive turtle flick...
The guys ghost-riding on the roof of the Turtle Van while PG rap plays in the background.
PAAATE
07-14-2009, 08:53 PM
I would try and avoid cliches, or keep it to a minimum.
I am a screenwriter, and if I were handling this, and had a say-so, I would do one thing.
The ending would be the Turtles losing to Shredder. You only get better with time, and if this is an origin story again, and it's back to square one, then have the Turtles lose the first round.
It could work as an ending wether they have a sequel or not. They are just learning and learned a lot throughout the movie. That you don't always win in fights, but you do learn a lot. So if there's a no-go on a sequel, at least they learned a lot from their experience. However, if there is a sequel, then they live to fight another day.
Whatever the case may be, Shredder shouldn't die. If they defeat him in this film, it should stay at defeat or near death. Not for the sake of bringing him back over and over, but because for Shredder to be a real threat - to me - he should last longer than one film.
Let's just say that I disagree...
Avoid clichées, YES, but I don't wanna see Shredder in more than one movie this time around...
And that's because I wanna get to a City at War-movie as soon as possible ;)
ToTheNines
07-14-2009, 08:58 PM
Whatever the case may be, Shredder shouldn't die. If they defeat him in this film, it should stay at defeat or near death. Not for the sake of bringing him back over and over, but because for Shredder to be a real threat - to me - he should last longer than one film.
I agree. So the sequel could be Return to New York and the 3rd could be City at War.
Andrew NDB
07-14-2009, 09:03 PM
The Turtles getting beaten at the end and not killing Shredder wouldn't be a very satisfying ending to audiences. And carrying Shredder over into multiple back-to-back movies pretty well misrepresents his role in the source material.
Ideally, I'd like to see the first movie be completely urban, just a personal story of the Orokus and the Yoshis over the ages juxtaposed against the TMNT growing up and training for the day that Splinter finally sends them to accomplish their goal: the assassination of Saki. And we see that day. Cue ending credits.
Second movie I'd be OK being a little more outlandish. We can see the Utroms, maybe even a little Triceraton Homeworld jaunt ala the comics.
Third movie could reel things back in for a City at War finish to the trilogy, bringing back in the Foot as the central nemesis, the Shredder Elite, Karai, etc..
Andrew NDB
07-14-2009, 09:22 PM
The Turtles getting beaten at the end and not killing Shredder wouldn't be a very satisfying ending to audiences.
I should add that this would be doubly so... especially coming off of a movie where the big payoff, big climax of the film is just the Turtles pushing some statues into an energy gate.
Mr. Stay Puft
07-14-2009, 09:26 PM
I have to agree with Andrew on this, except I'd prefer the second movie to focus more on the "Silent Partner"/"Return to New York" stories. Personally, if they went that route, I'd love to have Shredder state, before attempting to finish Leo off in the opening antique shop battle, "Now I shall take your family from you as Hamato Yoshi did to mine!"
Mainly, I'd want this just to set up some internal conflict between Splinter and the turtles, leaving the team to not only heal physically, but emotionally as well. The turtles would have to overcome the fact that Splinter held such a major part of their "family" history from them and, while they begin to doubt his teachings at first and are angry that their brother almost died because Splinter brought them into his blood feud with Saki, they eventually grow from it and become a stronger family before deciding it's time to return to NY and finish off Saki for good.
Of course, this would only work if they told the origin as simply having Oroku Saki kill Yoshi and Tang Shen in the first movie and expanding upon it to include Oroku Nagi in the origin in the second movie.
Andrew NDB
07-14-2009, 09:37 PM
I have to agree with Andrew on this, except I'd prefer the second movie to focus more on the "Silent Partner"/"Return to New York" stories. Personally, if they went that route, I'd love to have Shredder state, before attempting to finish Leo off in the opening antique shop battle, "Now I shall take your family from you as Hamato Yoshi did to mine!"
Mainly, I'd want this just to set up some internal conflict between Splinter and the turtles, leaving the team to not only heal physically, but emotionally as well. The turtles would have to overcome the fact that Splinter held such a major part of their "family" history from them and, while they begin to doubt his teachings at first and are angry that their brother almost died because Splinter brought them into his blood feud with Saki, they eventually grow from it and become a stronger family before deciding it's time to return to NY and finish off Saki for good.
Of course, this would only work if they told the origin as simply having Oroku Saki kill Yoshi and Tang Shen in the first movie and expanding upon it to include Oroku Nagi in the origin in the second movie.
I agree with you on pretty much every point. I would absolutely like to see it made clear just how personal it really was between these two Clans, these two families, and for that to be the crux of things. Not shifting the focus onto extraneous tangents like, "Oh no! Will Little Danny become one of the Evil Foot?? Can he be redeemed??"
I only differ in that I believe all of the above can be accomplished suitably in a single movie. The second movie should be a complete breather from Shredder... but the fallout from his death can be felt in movie #3.
Mr. Stay Puft
07-14-2009, 10:02 PM
I only fear that jumping from turtles vs. Foot in the first movie to Utroms and Triceratons in the second might be too much of a leap for some viewers who aren't quite familiar with the source material and might kill a chance for a big screen adaptation of "City at War".
Lil G
07-14-2009, 10:13 PM
I'm all for truly badass, actual "ninja" turtles that actually do "ninja" things. I hope this movie is the TMNT equvalent of "The Dark Knight."
.....................except shorter..................................
Dragon Turtle
07-14-2009, 10:33 PM
1) Story: As an origin story there really isn't much to do, other then not filling it up with bad humor and long winded training scenes, a combination of the first three issues would be ideal, with Shredder and Baxter as your main antagonists.
2) Characters: The only thing that the different factions of TMNT fans may agree on is their love of the main characters, all FOUR ninja turtles must be developed, all FOUR characters most be relevant to the story , this cannot be a Leonardo movie, Leo/Raph movie, Mike/Don movie, ect, it needs to be a movie where all four characters can shine both individually and as a group. The villains also most be developed into characters that can engage the audience, and that means going beyond the Shredder/Baxter portrayals in the Mirage comics.
3) Action: Realistically, this is what is going to bring non TMNT fans into the theaters, given their nature (and most likely budget), the movie cannot rely on massive CGI eye candy or huge explosions, and moviegoers have become numb to CGI stunt doubles and over produced fight scenes. This movie needs to set itself apart from the glut of dreary cookie cutter Hollywood action movies, perhaps by going back to old school fight choreography, but with much higher production values. And of course the action has to be PG-13.
4) Good Looking Turtles: There may not be another bigger make or break factor then the look of the turtles, good looking CGI/suit turtles can go a long way in getting people excited about the movie, bad CGI/suit turtles can be a promotional nightmare, leading to months of a bad press and mockery.
Andrew NDB
07-14-2009, 11:34 PM
I only fear that jumping from turtles vs. Foot in the first movie to Utroms and Triceratons in the second might be too much of a leap for some viewers who aren't quite familiar with the source material and might kill a chance for a big screen adaptation of "City at War".
I get what you're saying, but one of the paramount principles of the source material is it's ability -- and nature -- to shift gears. One story in the comics can be gritty and urban and completely down-to-earth (the weirdest thing in the story being the Turtles themselves), the next can be some sorcery-type fare in the woods, the next can involve time-travel, the next can be some kind of space epic... and then it can go back to gritty and urban. It's one of the things that has always given me an appreciation for the material and the characters: their versatility.
I mean, of course if someone held a gun to my head and said, "Andrew, pick the type of TMNT stories you like best!" of course it's going to be the urban, gritty, down-to-earth material where they're ****ing sh*t up with other ninjas... but I think that in only doing those type of stories you're selling the proven versatility of the characters short.
And it's not to say that outer space/Triceraton/Utrom stories can't be gritty and badass. They can. They have. And could on screen as well.
Powder
07-14-2009, 11:58 PM
i agree with most fans thusfar in terms of what you'd really want to see.. some violence in the field of pg-13, red bandanas, less focus on the corny jokes etc.. Alot of these 80's franchises and comic movies made in the last.. 8 years roughly, all seem to have unnessecary love stories thrown in there. Id hate to see that happen.. Also the whole drama between leo/raph and don/mike complementing eachothers humor thing.. they can pass on that. It would be cool if they had a scene where each character is put in a situation that could be somewhat selfexplanatory in regards to how they deal with things.. whether it be fight scenes or whatever else. It'd also be neat if they not only put empahsis on the ninja aspect, but the teen one aswell.. being that there in the field of like 13-18 years old or whatever, there will always be a repressed desire to rebel, or curse or whatever else, and they should show that even though they get trained and stuff, at the end of the day they are teens that have difficulty with finding out who they are and ****. either way i have a feeling this film will blow up just like batman and transformers, which could be really good or really bad depending on whether that awsome appeal is for the mass, uneducated movie goers, or the hardcore fans.
Andrew NDB
07-15-2009, 12:16 AM
As I've said, my biggest fear is that the filmmakers behind this will do the old, "Let's try and please everyone" approach (to such a degree I believe it's almost an inevitability... which keeps my expectations at a healthy level of "nil"). "Everyone" meaning hardcore fans of the cartoons and such.
Such a thing is doomed to failure. Or mediocrity. Or both.
Krutch
07-15-2009, 03:05 AM
My ideal movie would be something in the same tone of Hellboy, personally. It had a really nice balance of comedy, action, seriousness... Very well paced with an interesting story to boot. And its also along the lines of the visual upgrade I'd like to see.
Barrons directing is good in the first TMNT, but it did have a music video feel to alot of it. Which, of course, comes from his background. But have any of you watched any other movie directed by him? I saw "Rat" and wasn't too impressed. That being said, if he's announced as the director I wont complain. Just wish we'd get a fresh set of eyes taking on the helm.
Red bandannas would be neat, but still not preferable. I know it would be a great shout out to all the hardcore fans, but c'mon guys... its just the color of their bandannas. I personally like the colored versions, myself. The colors speak alot about their personality. It's kinda symbolic. Plus, think of a dark fight scene in an ally with four turtles wearing red masks and take away their weapons. You'd be too busy trying to figure out whos who than enjoying the fight scene.
As for the story, I'd really prefer something original. The first few volumes of Eastman and Lairds are great stuff but its nothing that hasnt already been mined and retold before in some fashion or another. "TMNT" had an original story, which was nice because it was new. It was just too bad, y'know, the story sucked.
I'd like to see equal character development for each turtle. We all know Leo and Raph tend to take center stage in the flicks. Time to change that up. I dont want to see a "Mikey and Don" movie either, but there's gotta be an easy way to balance out the development without giving any turtle the shaft.
Ground it in reality before going nuts. The beauty of TMNT is that you can place them in ordinary and exteeeeemly extraordinary situations and it never seems out of place. If I'm willing to believe that there are walking, talking Ninja Turtles I'm pretty much ready to believe anything else you throw at me. But before you start throwing Utroms and Battle Nexus's at the rest of the audience, put them in New York facing real, exisiting danger. Save any Star Wars stuff for the sequels.
Not sure what else to say cept the obvious stuff: great fight scenes, witty dialogue, and a fun experience that I'll want to revisit again and again like the first movie. I think that about covers my ideal movie ;)
nimrod
07-15-2009, 12:31 PM
My Do's:
NINJA ACTION!!! (They're called Teenage Mutant NINJA Turtles) Red Bandanas would be cool... (Chances are that we won't see them) A Real threatening Shredder (even if he's killed off in one Battle, he should be a REAL threat... not a pansy that can be beaten in three minutes.) PG-13 Rating... (We don't need a mega watered down bordreline G version of the TMNT.) An adaptation as close to the source material as possible and treated with respect... MOUSERS!!! Hundreds of them...
I think the Shredder in the first movie was a pretty real threat. He pretty much took on all 4 turtles by himself. There were other things wrong with the first movie but Shredder's abilities were not one of them.
Sage Ninja
07-15-2009, 01:14 PM
Decent characterization. I re-he-he-eally don't want to see the typical sterotypes for their characters.
Andrew NDB
07-15-2009, 02:52 PM
Red bandannas would be neat, but still not preferable. I know it would be a great shout out to all the hardcore fans, but c'mon guys... its just the color of their bandannas.
Which is supposed to represent their Clan. The Hamato Clan. When you have them with different colored bandannas it just makes them metrosexual/trying to make fashion statements with them. Which is sh*t.
Though as I've also said before, if colored bandannas is the only necessary evil to finally getting a TMNT film that resembles badass... I won't make a big stink about it.
I personally like the colored versions, myself. The colors speak alot about their personality.
I'm just curious. What does purple speak about Donatello?
It's kinda symbolic. Plus, think of a dark fight scene in an ally with four turtles wearing red masks and take away their weapons. You'd be too busy trying to figure out whos who than enjoying the fight scene.
The suits/faces/heads in the films are very distinctive, the voices are very distinctive, and there would be precious few times when you wouldn't see them with their weapons. If you still can't recognize who's who, then you deserve it.
And anyway as ninja, you're not really supposed to tell them apart. Historically they dress alike to disguise their numbers. The TMNT are stealth-killers... not the gang from "The Hills."
Cipher
07-15-2009, 03:47 PM
Red bandanas + Different skin colors, voices and weapons = No problem.
If you've managed to make it through one issue of the comics without saying "Who dis turdle? I confuzzed," you'll be alright.
Andrew NDB
07-15-2009, 04:11 PM
Red bandanas + Different skin colors, voices and weapons = No problem.
I could grudgingly agree to those terms... even if the different skin color would be a little asinine (red-earred sliders don't have different color skins), at least it wouldn't be their own doing (i.e., like the different colored bandannas would be something they'd consciously be decorating themselves with).
If you've managed to make it through one issue of the comics without saying "Who dis turdle? I confuzzed," you'll be alright.
Agreed. And we're not even talking about comics... we're talking about feature films in which there can be a great deal of detail put forth in differentiating the bodies/faces/heads and such.
I have to wonder if the same people who honestly fear that they won't be able to tell the TMNT apart on-screen if they didn't have different colored bandannas are the same kind of people that say that black people and Asian people all look alike.
ToTheNines
07-15-2009, 04:18 PM
I could grudgingly agree to those terms... even if the different skin color would be a little asinine (red-earred sliders don't have different color skins), at least it wouldn't be their own doing (i.e., like the different colored bandannas would be something they'd consciously be decorating themselves with).
They don't have to be red-earred sliders though.
I have to wonder if the same people who honestly fear that they won't be able to tell the TMNT apart on-screen if they didn't have different colored bandannas are the same kind of people that say that black people and Asian people all look alike.
From my experience, that's only old people.
And mega-hicks.
Andrew NDB
07-15-2009, 04:28 PM
They don't have to be red-earred sliders though.
True. But that's what they are in the source material.
From my experience, that's only old people.And mega-hicks.
I've known several people my age that, when it's just you two, they'll kind of do the move where they lean over, smile, and whisper, "You know, I get those black/asian people so mixed up all the time, they all look alike!"
Jester
07-15-2009, 04:30 PM
Height is also a way to differentiate. It or musculature, weight. There are ways to make the 4 turtles distinct and individually recognized and still give them all red bandannas.
turkishproverb
07-15-2009, 04:38 PM
On sliders, I can tell you skin coloring on the actual animals does differ a bit, so on mutant turtles it could easily increase slightly, much as pigmentation within an average ethnic group varies somewhat.
Powder
07-15-2009, 05:04 PM
It'd be cool if they could at least give a shout to the classic by starting them off with red bandanas, maybe as younger turtles.. then as they grow up maybe they would want to express theyre individuality by wearing different colors and since raph wouldnt give a damn anyway, hed still be in red. Cause odds are they will be colored for the sake of idiots.. but that would be an awsome way to do it, by giving it recognition.
Andrew NDB
07-15-2009, 05:16 PM
then as they grow up maybe they would want to express theyre individuality by wearing different colors
Ugh. I'd rather get no explanation for them saddling the Turtles with multi-colored bandannas than that explanation.
ToTheNines
07-15-2009, 05:34 PM
Ugh. I'd rather get no explanation for them saddling the Turtles with multi-colored bandannas than that explanation.
Yeah, multi-colored bandanas are for the kids. Any other way just comes off as "metro".
Cipher
07-15-2009, 05:37 PM
Yeah, multi-colored bandanas are for the kids. Any other way just comes off as "metro".I think in one of the very first threads about this new movie, Tristan pitched the only explanation for the colored bandanas I've ever been okay with.
ToTheNines
07-15-2009, 05:40 PM
I think in one of the very first threads about this new movie, Tristan pitched the only explanation for the colored bandanas I've ever been okay with.
I remember, April being confused. That was pretty darn good, better than anything they'll think of without stealing that idea.
Andrew NDB
07-15-2009, 05:56 PM
I think in one of the very first threads about this new movie, Tristan pitched the only explanation for the colored bandanas I've ever been okay with.
If there had to be one, while I wouldn't say I'd be OK with it... it'd certainly be the least painful explanation I can come up with.
Like, the Turtles live with April in her apartment and she kind of forces them to wear different color bandannas. And it sticks.
Dragon Turtle
07-15-2009, 06:14 PM
I think the Shredder in the first movie was a pretty real threat. He pretty much took on all 4 turtles by himself. There were other things wrong with the first movie but Shredder's abilities were not one of them.
It would be nice to see more then a few minutes of fighting on screen between the Shredder and turtles this time around, though.
The turtles will most likely have multi-colored bandanas, makes the turtles more marketable to kids.
Doc_ock_4mugen
07-15-2009, 06:43 PM
I think the Shredder in the first movie was a pretty real threat. He pretty much took on all 4 turtles by himself. There were other things wrong with the first movie but Shredder's abilities were not one of them.
A rough list of the events of the Shredder fight...
1:17:30-1:18:50 Shredder appear and the Turtles attack him one by one. (Each Turtle jumps towards Saki and gets pwned in one move) Small scene with Casey and the Kids. Now Shredder is WAITING for the Turtles to finish a meeting
1:18:50-1:20:30 The Turtles try again to attack one by one (and fail). Another Small Scene with Casey and the Foot. Setting up the Garbage truck. Leonardo seems to have wounded Shredder's arm.
1:20:30-1:21:29 Shredder taunts the Turtles and Leo becomes the "Damsel in Distress" after trying the cannon fodder attack. Enter Splinter.
1:21:29-1:22:30 Splinter drops the big reveal. Shredder tries to attack Splinter in rage and Shredder ends up hanging on the building side. Now Saki is at Splinter's Mercy. Shredder is reaching for a blade...
1:22:30-1:22:53 Saki falls and Casey "Murders" him with the Truck.
Roughly 5 minutes of movie time. (Substract the Casey scenes and the talking scenes and its roughly three minutes.) Shredder was beaten in around 5 minutes. (and I think it takes almost as long to see the "Super" Shredder beat himself... Unfortunately I don't have Secret of the Ooze on the PSPright now to do another list of the fight.)
Sure the Shredder was beating the Turtles with one move per turtle, but they were jumping one by one to attack him. (Why didn't they gang up on him?) The Shredder lets them have a conference meeting... I mean if Four guys are attacking me and I'm kicking their butts. I would not going to let them reorganize and plan a new strategy to attack me...
Andrew NDB
07-15-2009, 08:38 PM
The turtles will most likely have multi-colored bandanas, makes the turtles more marketable to kids.
It just doesn't mean we have to like it.
Coola Yagami
07-15-2009, 09:20 PM
I always thought it was kinda scary/badass/lame to see Shredder just standing there in the background while the Turtles were doing their little huddle. Scary cause the agent of death is there watching you... waiting to strike.. bad-ass cause Shredder just looked bad-ass.... and lame cause well.. he's just standing there... he should take the inciative and finish them off.
In retrospect... maybe they should have added an extra scene of all 4 TMNT trying to attack Shredder and STILL getting owned, meaning they really did need Splinter to come save their shells.
Slap-Happy
07-15-2009, 09:37 PM
I think it's just more intimidating for him to just be staring, waiting to attack them.
Powder
07-16-2009, 12:44 AM
isnt that also somewhat of a ninja code too? like.. dont strike those with their gaurd down lol
Krutch
07-16-2009, 02:13 AM
Andrew NDB, dont' take any disrespect from this, as I appreciate everyone's opinion, but you'd be a nightmare for studio execs :P Find the right balance between what the studio wants, what fans want, and what you want(like the TMNT 1). It's Hollywood and I'm not sure you're ideas are being realistic. Then again, maybe I'm silly since this is technically a "how would YOU make a movie" thread lol so what am I talking about. And as for the colors being symbolic, I wasn't referring to "red = anger" kinda symbolism. I mean Orange, Red, Blue, and Purple is Ninja Turtles to everyone. You see those four colors together, anywhere, and your subconscious makes the connection. If you saw four people dressed in those colors, or playing a board game where your player pieces are only in those colors, you make the connection. Whether you love or hate the old toon, parts of it helped define who TMNT are to us.
I think we just have very, very different views on what a perfect Ninja Turtles movie would involve:P You seem to want a Sin City version, I'm leaning towards something thats fun with serious undertones and alot of heart.
Andrew NDB
07-16-2009, 03:07 AM
isnt that also somewhat of a ninja code too? like.. dont strike those with their gaurd down lol
Ninja code? Ninja code would compel one to kill your enemy with any means at your disposal, and as quickly and stealthily as possible. Not that I'm even sure there even ever existed such a thing as a "ninja code" outside of things like TMNT children's cartoons where ninjas are some kind of superheroes.
Ninja were looked at as scum by wayfarers and samurai of Feudal times. Not because they were without honor or anything, but because they marched to the beat of... a different drum.
Andrew NDB, dont' take any disrespect from this, as I appreciate everyone's opinion, but you'd be a nightmare for studio execs :P
Haven't been in the past.
Find the right balance between what the studio wants, what fans want, and what you want(like the TMNT 1).
It's well proven that the existing fandom can't fill any seats substantially. It's all about how to reel in the laymen. Literally the only thing that remains to be tried, the only rock left unturned is a proper treatment of the source material... which it sounds like this reboot may be.
But maybe not.
It's Hollywood and I'm not sure you're ideas are being realistic. Then again, maybe I'm silly since this is technically a "how would YOU make a movie" thread lol so what am I talking about. And as for the colors being symbolic, I wasn't referring to "red = anger" kinda symbolism. I mean Orange, Red, Blue, and Purple is Ninja Turtles to everyone. You see those four colors together, anywhere, and your subconscious makes the connection. If you saw four people dressed in those colors, or playing a board game where your player pieces are only in those colors, you make the connection. Whether you love or hate the old toon, parts of it helped define who TMNT are to us.
Regardless of what they may or may not symbolize, it would still boil down to, "Why would the Turtles colorize themselves with variant colors of bandannas? And aren't they supposed to be a ninja clan?" And the answer could only be ridiculous.
I think we just have very, very different views on what a perfect Ninja Turtles movie would involve:P You seem to want a Sin City version,
Don't put words in my mouth. That would imply a panel-for-panel adaptation, something I've loudly proclaimed probably wouldn't be the best route.
I'm leaning towards something thats fun with serious undertones and alot of heart.
I find it interesting that you think a faithful treatment of the source material precludes it from being that.
TristanHuwJones
07-16-2009, 09:24 AM
And the answer could only be ridiculous.
Well, what's that answer in your mind then?
TerranigmaFreak
07-16-2009, 09:51 AM
If this is "The One", what do you guys expect?
Topless roller skating nuns I guess.
Slap-Happy
07-16-2009, 10:00 AM
Well, what's that answer in your mind then?
He wouldn't have one. He (like many) wants a:
faithful treatment of the source material
The Shelf
07-16-2009, 10:46 AM
I just hope the new movie has great choreography and great camera work. The best part of the '07 movie was the way the camera followed the action, particularly during the Leo vs. Raph fight. The first movie had some good martial arts action, but none of it was as cool as the Leo vs. Raph fight. If they're gonna do a proper live-action TMNT movie, then they need to at least top that.
plastroncafe
07-16-2009, 12:59 PM
Off the bat I have to admit that I'm not pleased with the whole "Men in Suits" aspect of this movie. Until such time as I'm proven wrong, I'm sticking to the notion that you can't get the mobility the turtles are supposed to have with a guy in a suit. If there's one thing the CGI movie got right, it was that.
I would very much like this movie to prove me wrong.
I'd also like Raph to come across as more than just "an asshole", Mike as more than "just the village idiot", Don as more than "resident Q", and Leo as more than just "stuck up."
No-name, or professional voice actors for the turtles and Splinter.
And finally, make it a good movie in its own right. Throw us fans a bone every now and again, but...don't make the movie for us. Make the movie for the characters.
Doc_ock_4mugen
07-16-2009, 03:17 PM
I always thought it was kinda scary/badass/lame to see Shredder just standing there in the background while the Turtles were doing their little huddle. Scary cause the agent of death is there watching you... waiting to strike.. bad-ass cause Shredder just looked bad-ass.... and lame cause well.. he's just standing there... he should take the inciative and finish them off.
In retrospect... maybe they should have added an extra scene of all 4 TMNT trying to attack Shredder and STILL getting owned, meaning they really did need Splinter to come save their shells.
That's the thing... The scene oozed coolness and lameness at the same time... Unfortunatley Lame has a stronger aftertaste...
It seems as if the Turtles and Shredder weren't really trying... and then Splinter didn't really try either... Having Splinter there kinda diminishes the need for the Turtles. Cause Splinter trianed the Turtles to carry on the mission of Avenging Yoshi. (Cause he's like too old or something) They also made Casey a Murderer. (Shredder came back, but there were LOTS of Witnesses and no one said anything!?)
Cipher
07-16-2009, 04:04 PM
Cause Splinter trianed the Turtles to carry on the mission of Avenging Yoshi.That's something that has unfortunately never been true outside of the comics. Hopefully the new movie maintains that, since it's pretty damn essential to the entire theme of the Turtles.
They also made Casey a Murderer. (Shredder came back, but there were LOTS of Witnesses and no one said anything!?)I can't say that aspect ever bothered me in the least. It's not like Casey was going on a killing spree, he just put the final nail in Shredder's coffin.
ToTheNines
07-16-2009, 04:17 PM
Right, if it weren't for the truck being right there he would have died for sure anyways.
Slap-Happy
07-16-2009, 04:28 PM
I can't say that aspect ever bothered me in the least. It's not like Casey was going on a killing spree, he just put the final nail in Shredder's coffin.
Who knows, it could have been a genuine accident. He did say "Oops!".:lol:
Candy Kappa
07-16-2009, 06:18 PM
isnt that also somewhat of a ninja code too? like.. dont strike those with their gaurd down lol
There is no such thing as a ninja code, unless you count get the job done by any means.
ninja are assassins and messengers, assassinate people in their sleep. Using poison, cheap weapons and psychology to lure a more combat advanced enemy.
code of honor among ninja are just as a fairly tale from children cartoons as the knights chivalry are in stories.
Andrew NDB
07-16-2009, 09:52 PM
Yes. The "ninja code" is something the children's cartoons invented to make the TMNT more inherently heroic... even though they're not supposed to be either superheroes or vigilantes.
Andrew NDB
07-16-2009, 10:08 PM
Off the bat I have to admit that I'm not pleased with the whole "Men in Suits" aspect of this movie. Until such time as I'm proven wrong, I'm sticking to the notion that you can't get the mobility the turtles are supposed to have with a guy in a suit. If there's one thing the CGI movie got right, it was that.
Don't forget they're using CGI assists. And no one's ruled out all-CGI Turtles for some of the more intense sequences.
plastroncafe
07-16-2009, 10:59 PM
Don't forget they're using CGI assists. And no one's ruled out all-CGI Turtles for some of the more intense sequences.
True enough.
I mean...either way I'm there. I just...have my fingers crossed until then.
The Shelf
07-16-2009, 11:55 PM
Off the bat I have to admit that I'm not pleased with the whole "Men in Suits" aspect of this movie.
Wait... Your avatar is a turtle in a suit... Hmmm...
Fledermaus
07-16-2009, 11:57 PM
I want everything the creator of the thread stated... and I mostly agree with Andrew NDB. It would take some real cojones to get the job done right. Aside from a good story, good script, pacing, camera work, acting, tone, and message -- my realm of expertise is the visual, so that is what I will elaborate on.
1. Motion capture suits will be much more flexible than a rubber or foam-latex suit, thus enabling the stuntmen to perform at their maximum. However quality motion capture (CG animation and cleanup) is horrendously expensive and I can't imagine any producer worth his/her salt who would provide the funds for any TMNT movie.
2. While it is more realistic for the turtles to have non-distinctive (identical) masks, it is not useful in the realm if CINEMA. In movies, silly or serious, one must often take liberties for the sake of making the story/characters clearer to the audience. The only way this can possibly be bypassed is if:
3. Each turtle has a distinctive face and body type, not reliant on skin color -- as Andrew NDB stated, they were originally pet turtles. Nearly all pet turtles are Red Eared Sliders.
4. Create effective, convincing, and APPEALING turtle and splinter designs based off of REAL SPECIES. It's not that hard, folks. If a first-year animation student can do it, so can you.
Since I doubt I'll have any lucrative future involving the TMNT franchise, I'll dig up concept work from my paused fan comic. Masked Ninja and a few others may remember some earlier versions I had. I later developed head-to-toe renditions of mutated Red-Eared Slider TMNT that had separate personalities, faces, and character appeal (which my earliest designs lacked.)
5. Again, money talks, but I wish the fight choreography were Jackie-Chan worthy. Hell, all they need to do is hire THE NINJAI GANG -- a group of stuntmen and women who are also filmmakers and animators. Karma Kula, one of their series, is filmed on a fairly low budget but the fight choreography is beautiful. Hell, everything they make is beautiful. A perfect union of violence, beauty and peaceful serenity.
I know Ninjai Gang's work is very bloody, but if we could get something as beautiful as the work we see from them, minus the blood -- I would die a happy TMNT fan.
plastroncafe
07-17-2009, 11:56 AM
Wait... Your avatar is a turtle in a suit... Hmmm...
....ACK!
*hangs head in shame.*
ToTheNines
07-17-2009, 03:30 PM
Also, I think it'd be cool if the Foot was a branch of a Yakuza gang.
Colliwog
07-18-2009, 03:35 PM
I'm just curious. What does purple speak about Donatello?
Some descriptions I found for Purple:
"A mysterious color, purple is associated with both nobility and spirituality.
"Purple has a special, almost sacred place in nature: lavender, orchid, lilac, and violet flowers are often delicate and considered precious. Because purple is derived from the mixing of a strong warm and strong cool color it has both warm and cool properties. A purple room can boost a child's imagination or an artist's creativity."
"Purple is the color of good judgment."
"Intuitive, visionary, futuristic, idealistic, artistic."
TMNTD
07-19-2009, 04:07 PM
The turtles actually killing people.
Raven
07-19-2009, 04:16 PM
For me, personally I would like to see them ditch the idea that the Turtles are strictly for kids. When in fact the turtles have a very wide range of fan ages they can hit across.
I would think that after the dark knight hit, they would be compelled to look at the franchise in a different light. Instead of looking at how they can sell it again as a giant toy commercial, lets look into some real directors. Maybe not big block buster guys but artsy film makers who can look at the franchise and see what we are missing.
When I watch a comic based film, I want something new. Not just a rehash of an old story told again. Give me some new insight that no one has touched upon.
Also, I would love this to be grounded more in reality. Lets get the gangs in there more, the turtles should be more like assassins.
But lets see something of a pg-13 nature, TDK got it down. So why cant the turtles?
Warhorse
07-21-2009, 12:33 AM
Only thing I really want is a PG-13 film. There's so much potential with that rating.
I also prefer the Turtles to keep their colored masks. I grew up on the 1980's cartoons and 90's movies, not the comics, so have associated each Turtle with it's respective bandanna color, weapon of choice and their voices.
Andrew NDB
07-21-2009, 02:10 AM
Only thing I really want is a PG-13 film. There's so much potential with that rating.
I don't see why bothering with anything short of that is worth the time or effort.
I also prefer the Turtles to keep their colored masks. I grew up on the 1980's cartoons and 90's movies, not the comics, so have associated each Turtle with it's respective bandanna color, weapon of choice and their voices.
As long as you admit/are conscious of your wanting that just for nostalgia reasons, not practical ones. I can respect that.
There is no practical reason for a gang of giant turtles to wear masks.
I disagree with the common assumption that a kids' movie can't be good -- or that a kids' movie must necessarily have juvenile belching humor and an excessively goofy story. The 1990 flick was perfectly fine with me, as was the 2K3 'toon (well, Mikey did annoy me, but it'd be easy to tone him down) with its Y-7 rating. So as long as the film is done well, a PG rating wouldn't disappoint me in the least.
I'd really just like to see a great children's movie for the next TMNT film. A darker flick with omgz killing and blood and red masks might satisfy the hardcore Mirage fans, but few others (myself included) would really care for a (non-horror) film about subterranean murderers. I mostly thought the Mirage comics were boring as hell -- give me the Archie books anyday. :P
plastroncafe
07-21-2009, 07:47 AM
There is no practical reason for a gang of giant turtles to wear masks.
Sure it does! Without the masks everyone would know that they are turtles!
(Actually, I've kind of always figured the masks were there because they don't have eyebrows to keep the sweat out of their eyes.)
Slap-Happy
07-21-2009, 08:05 AM
I will always long for the turtles to have the red bandanas in a movie. But, I'll be fine with colored. I mean, haven't we been fine with them since 1987?
The Shelf
07-21-2009, 11:30 AM
Sure it does! Without the masks everyone would know that they are turtles!
(Actually, I've kind of always figured the masks were there because they don't have eyebrows to keep the sweat out of their eyes.)
Wait, do turtles sweat? I guess mutant turtles must.
I'd really just like to see a great children's movie for the next TMNT film. A darker flick with omgz killing and blood and red masks might satisfy the hardcore Mirage fans, but few others (myself included) would really care for a (non-horror) film about subterranean murderers. I mostly thought the Mirage comics were boring as hell -- give me the Archie books anyday. :P
Actually, just about every college-age person I talked to was disappointed that the '07 movie was still pretty kiddie -- and most of them didn't even know the Mirage comics existed.
Sure it does! Without the masks everyone would know that they are turtles!
(Actually, I've kind of always figured the masks were there because they don't have eyebrows to keep the sweat out of their eyes.)
:D I was just pointing out that Andrew likes to argue that the red masks are somehow more practical than different-colored ones... and that doesn't make any sense because we're talking about a gang of mutant turtles. The multicolored masks would keep the sweat out of their eyes just as well!
...Assuming that mutant reptiles sweat, anyway. ;)
The Shelf: I wasn't saying that an overly kiddie movie would be widely accepted, I just think an overly dark one with the Turtles murdering people wholesale (even bad guys) would be frowned upon. I also don't think that anyone would have cared about Mikey burping if TMNT 2007 hadn't been so lacking in other respects. Frex, I don't know of any people who complained that The Incredibles was too juvenile -- yet that was PG. It is possible for a PG movie to be fantastic (I maintain that the 1990 TMNT flick was and is), and it is possible for a dark PG-13 flick to be less than stellar. (I still fail to see what was so great about TDK, and I hardly think it would have been as well received had Ledger not died.)
I do think it'd be interesting to watch a darker TMNT flick, mind you -- if only because we haven't gotten one yet. I just don't think I'd care for it, so it's not the movie I want to see.
^^agreed. I don't think four mutant turtles would have any trouble recognising whom is in their clan...if anything, wearing a mask would seem more cumbersome to fight in, thus negating its requirement at all. Not that I would suggest that they ditch them! That said, I wouldn't mind either way if the masks were all red or not. Although, I always liked the 2k3 explanation where the turtles were gifted their masks/colours by their master's master, as if he had some kind of eerie prescience into the paths they would take (if you hold much weight to colour and its meaning)
Also would like to see:
- the human characters to be decently cast (especially April and Casey)
- more identifiable characters in the foot.
- a non-exaggeration of the turtles personalities
- more even screen time for each of the turtles
- and of course a well written, well executed story
- and lastly, for something better than the Dark Knight
ThirdMarioBro
07-23-2009, 09:41 AM
We all know that in the end, the toy companies and 4Kids are going to run this bastard right into the ground. Why torture yourselves trying to hype it up?
Aztec General
07-23-2009, 10:09 AM
- and lastly, for something better than the Dark Knight
LOL. Good luck with that. :lol:
I don't understand you Dark Knight haters. We got the fandom equivalent of the Godfather and some of you are just dying to yell "It sucks!". Stupid snarky generation we live in...
On topic:
I see zero reason why an Iron Man style movie (humor to action ratio wise) can't be created for a Batman Begins style origin story. Of course it would have to be PG-13, and that may be a stumbling block for the toy pimps, but if they have an ounce of sense (and that's highly debatable) they'd let it go through.
ToTheNines
07-23-2009, 03:44 PM
We all know that in the end, the toy companies and 4Kids are going to run this bastard right into the ground. Why torture yourselves trying to hype it up?
You're probably right, just because you know there's probably no director out there who cares enough about TMNT to fight the toy company/4kids.
Buuuut, I'm still staying positive for now.
ToTheNines
07-24-2009, 10:23 PM
The Ninja Pizza twitter has reported that statements made at a comic con panel were most likely meant to convey that this movie will be another PG rated production...
F*ck the world.
F*ck it.
F*ck.
What statements are you talking about?
Slap-Happy
07-26-2009, 04:51 PM
I see zero reason why an Iron Man style movie (humor to action ratio wise) can't be created for a Batman Begins style origin story.
An Iron Man type of movie is just what the Turtles need. An Iron man type of movie, with the dark and gritty look of Batman Begins.
Samurai Usagi
07-26-2009, 05:37 PM
I expect Leo and Raph to draw blood from their enemies with their BLADED weapons.
The Shelf
07-26-2009, 08:18 PM
What statements are you talking about?
He's probably referring to the statements that PG movies like Harry Potter have gotten away with a lot, and they seem to think that a TMNT movie could too. However, I think the reason Harry Potter is allowed to get away with stuff is because it's all magic. I mean, the most recent Potter movie had a lot of blood in it for a PG movie, but no one is getting stabbed or sliced open with a bladed weapon -- it's just magic. I think they'll have to go to PG-13 in order to do what they keep saying they want to do.
Dragon Turtle
07-26-2009, 10:08 PM
He's probably referring to the statements that PG movies like Harry Potter have gotten away with a lot, and they seem to think that a TMNT movie could too. However, I think the reason Harry Potter is allowed to get away with stuff is because it's all magic. I mean, the most recent Potter movie had a lot of blood in it for a PG movie, but no one is getting stabbed or sliced open with a bladed weapon -- it's just magic. I think they'll have to go to PG-13 in order to do what they keep saying they want to do.
Harry Potter 4 and 5 were PG-13 movies, although the MPAA tends to be more forgiving to big budget, high profile movies.
ToTheNines
07-27-2009, 03:25 PM
As flawed as they were, The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones were both PG with some badass light sabre duels. But Episode III was PG-13 and I know alot of kids saw and loved that.
Jephael
07-28-2009, 09:44 PM
I gotta admit, as accustomed as I've been with the multi-colored bandanas, I'd love to see the guys all wearing red in the next movie adaptation. As Andrew said previously it would make a great statement to it being a complete reboot of the movie universe.
Andrew NDB
07-28-2009, 10:04 PM
As Andrew said previously it would make a great statement to it being a complete reboot of the movie universe.
Something's gotta.
Cipher
07-28-2009, 11:27 PM
Nothing could bring my hopes to a screeching halt like this film being mentioned in the same breath Harry Potter. TMNT isn't some kiddy franchise that they could reasonably kick up to a PG-13 level. It is PG-13 to begin with. And if this film doesn't represent that, I will...really not make a dent in its profits at all, but I can honestly say I won't patron it.
Lordmylar06
07-28-2009, 11:51 PM
I really just want this movie to not make me blush when I'm the only 26 yr old guy in the theater without a son or daughter...
Warhorse
07-29-2009, 12:01 AM
I don't see why bothering with anything short of that is worth the time or effort.
It's beyond me why the studios keep dicking around with PG rating. Sometimes it can work, but as for the TMNT, I felt it's cut off some of the potential in the fight scenes we see, the mature subject matter that could be brought up, and the potential of a strong box office because the curiosity a PG-13 TMNT film could generate.
As long as you admit/are conscious of your wanting that just for nostalgia reasons, not practical ones. I can respect that.
It's definitely nostalgia more than anything. If they keep in line of the previous movies of giving each Turtle it's own unique facial features and skin tones, I see no reason why anyone wouldn't be able to tell them apart with the masks off altogether. Even then, I'm sure a well orchestrated movie would have had no problem setting the Turtles apart from their voices and way of movement, and if that still doesn't help particular viewers, the weapons should be the icing of the cake. If you can't tell Raphael from Leonardo by the weapons they wield, can't say you were much of a TMNT fan to begin with.
On a side note, I would like to see one of them use a sibling's weapon for a fight scene. I always assumed that while they have their favorite weapons, Splinter taught them well and honed their skills to adapt to any Ninja weapon with an effective outcome.
Roseangelo
07-29-2009, 12:14 AM
So long as Gary can't see past fast food tie-ins and pajama licensing opportunities, I think it's safe to say we're stuck with PG.
Cipher
07-29-2009, 01:02 AM
So long as Gary can't see past fast food tie-ins and pajama licensing opportunities, I think it's safe to say we're stuck with PG.None of the PG-13 comic book movies have suffered from a lack of these.
Roseangelo
07-29-2009, 01:15 AM
None of the PG-13 comic book movies have suffered from a lack of these.
Right, but none of those movies had Gary in charge.
Basically, the new TMNT movie is likely to be made around all of the licensing tie-ins, whereas all of the good comic book movies have the tie-ins made around the movie.
If they wanted to make the best movie possible, they would make that movie and let it be rated whatever it ends up being rated, be it PG or PG-13. The Harry Potter comment during the panel makes me think that's not going to be the case, and the script isn't even written yet.
Cipher
07-29-2009, 01:19 AM
Basically, the new TMNT movie is likely to be made around all of the licensing tie-ins, whereas all of the good comic book movies have the tie-ins made around the movie.I meant that even PG-13 movies have gotten toy and pajama deals. They can have their cake and eat it too. Kids will see a PG-13 Turtles movie. The difference is, so will teens and adults.
Roseangelo
07-29-2009, 01:23 AM
I meant that even PG-13 movies have gotten toy and pajama deals. They can have their cake and eat it too. Kids will see a PG-13 Turtles movie. The difference is, so will teens and adults.
I realize what you were saying. Read carefully what I was saying and hopefully you'll see what I mean.
Andrew NDB
07-29-2009, 01:53 AM
I realize what you were saying. Read carefully what I was saying and hopefully you'll see what I mean.
I love watching you work.
Doc_ock_4mugen
07-29-2009, 06:29 AM
C'mon even Spider-Man was PG-13!! The tamest of Superheroes... Doesn't kill, just mopes around thinking of a gril and ties criminals with silly string, yet he gets a pg-13... How the *Bleep* NINJAS... (As in stealthy assassins) get PG!?
The Stryker
07-29-2009, 12:25 PM
C'mon even Spider-Man was PG-13!! The tamest of Superheroes... Doesn't kill, just mopes around thinking of a gril and ties criminals with silly string, yet he gets a pg-13... How the *Bleep* NINJAS... (As in stealthy assassins) get PG!?
Because they're giant turtle ninjas.
Sage Ninja
07-29-2009, 12:37 PM
if this is PG, I'm done. I'm done with being jerked around. Stop dicking around with PG ratings for the turtles franchise. Damn!
The Stryker
07-29-2009, 12:52 PM
Was anyone seriously expecting the movie to be rated PG-13?
I mean come on. You're lucky you're getting a movie PERIOD.
Sage Ninja
07-29-2009, 01:06 PM
:roll: seriously now. We don't need a patronized.
The Stryker
07-29-2009, 01:08 PM
Well it's true.
Wasn't the franchise ready to be taken behind the woodshed not too long ago?
Roseangelo
07-29-2009, 01:10 PM
I mean come on. You're lucky you're getting a movie PERIOD.
I am not in desperate need of another movie, so I find the "something is better than nothing" argument to be extremely weak.
The Stryker
07-29-2009, 01:46 PM
Still, The franchise could be DEAD right now but there's a new movie on the way and you complain.
Take what you can get.
Brodie
07-29-2009, 02:03 PM
For all those complaining about the PG rating....Do you not remember that films like Jaws were rated PG?
You're not going to get a PG-13 TMNT, and if a PG Turtles movie means you're done? You could probably leave now.
zkarlette
07-29-2009, 02:30 PM
I don't know much about transformers besides the cartoon and comics and toys stuff which you would think is directed to kids... I saw the second movie and it wasn't by any means child oriented .
Now.... if the TMNT started as a not so kid friendly comic why does it have to be more child oriented than transformers on their movies.
Doc_ock_4mugen
07-29-2009, 02:58 PM
Was anyone seriously expecting the movie to be rated PG-13?
Well, If they are "rebooting" The franchise in order to have this movie be a "back to basics, closer to source material, a Batman Begins version of the TMNT" then we should expect it at PG-13... Since the comic is kinda gritty and violent, PG-13 seems to be the tamest they can go...
I mean come on. You're lucky you're getting a movie PERIOD.
The bad aftertaste left after TMNT (2007) says: "I'd rather have no movie than a crappy one..." (This could also be applied to bad adaptations like DB:E, SF:TLoChL, etc.)
Why is it too much to ask for a movie that reflects the gritty world of the comics...
Still, The franchise could be DEAD right now but there's a new movie on the way and you complain. The near death of the franchise is precisely because of the mismanagement of the franchise... (Comics possible end is coming. Disputes between the toy companies and the TMNT lines. Cartoon cancellations on the 25th Anniversary.) With all of this negativity, the movie IS a small beam of hope. But with tMNT lately they give us false hopes and then they take our hopes behind the woodshed, but they are carrying a RPG.
Take what you can get.
What if all that we can get is crap? Do we take the crap and pretend we like it?
We don't want crap. We all want the Best TMNT movie ever...
For all those complaining about the PG rating....Do you not remember that films like Jaws were rated PG?But That was before the PG-13 rating was invented. If PG-13 would have exsisted; it would've gotten it.
Blade Raider
07-29-2009, 03:07 PM
For all those complaining about the PG rating....Do you not remember that films like Jaws were rated PG?
You're not going to get a PG-13 TMNT, and if a PG Turtles movie means you're done? You could probably leave now.
PG-13 wasn't a rating until 1984. Jaws was released in 1975. It's not a PG-13 movie because PG-13 simply didn't exist when it was rated by the MPAA.
EDIT: Looks like Doc_ock beat me to it :P
The Stryker
07-29-2009, 03:10 PM
Why does a PG rating mean the movie is going to be sh*t no matter what? I'm not getting that at all.
The last TMNT movie had way more problems than a PG rating. I really don't think putting some blood on the swords and having Raphael mope about society is going to make much of a difference.
ToTheNines
07-29-2009, 03:37 PM
Why does a PG rating mean the movie is going to be sh*t no matter what? I'm not getting that at all.
For me, it's just the fact that we've had 4 PG movies already. Let's try something new.
Brodie
07-29-2009, 05:15 PM
For me, it's just the fact that we've had 4 PG movies already. Let's try something new.
Good ****ing luck.
That's not against you, but its just not going to happen.
Yeah, I never got the bitching about the rating, either. How about we, you know, wait to see the movie first?
GK Punk
07-29-2009, 05:35 PM
Didn't you know? You can't tell a good story unless it's at least PG-13.
Cipher
07-29-2009, 05:35 PM
Was anyone seriously expecting the movie to be rated PG-13?Since every current trend and bit of common sense dictate that it should be, yes.
I mean come on. You're lucky you're getting a movie PERIOD.Not on board with this at all. I would, with complete sincerity, rather have no new movie at all than have a PG movie. At this point, anything that doesn't push the Turtles image beyond recycled kiddie fare hurts it. Not "maintains the status quo." Hurts it.
Still, The franchise could be DEAD right now but there's a new movie on the way and you complain.
The franchise will never die. It's just going to be put in that constant undead cycle of "fade away, renew for kiddies," that it's already stuck in. A new, serious movie is a chance to reach out to a larger audience and say, "Hey, it's okay to like these guys", to get it out of that cycle and have it become more of a staple. To do otherwise would be such a f*cking waste I can't comprehend it. Don't we want it to be able to survive as a respected comic, various incarnations of cartoons, etc, without having to wait for whatever new toyline is on the way? If no one wants to get behind that, maybe it is time to put this puppy down.
Can they make a decent PG TMNT movie? Sure, maybe. (Though probably not, since the action and themes of TMNT that I like are definately not PG fare). But John Q. Moviegoer, age 12 - 25 doesn't think so. And without him, we're never going to get that solid respect for the franchise that keeps the Batmen and Supermen afloat during slow times.
ToTheNines
07-29-2009, 05:48 PM
Yeah, I never got the bitching about the rating, either. How about we, you know, wait to see the movie first?
I just said it'd be nice to see something new.
Didn't you know? You can't tell a good story unless it's at least PG-13.
It's not that either, it's just that I think they'd get alot more attention by going PG13. They need to hook people by showing off some serious ass-kicking in the previews, and then hit 'em with a good story.
I will probably love a PG movie if done right, but the general audience is used to PG13 comic book/80's toon revival movies by now so I doubt they'll settle for less.
Rise of the Silver Surfer was PG and made a buttload of money. Not as much as the big contenders, but a lot. Point being, I've never seen anyone go "What's the movie's rating? PG? No, never mind, I'll see something else".
Except for you people, of course.
Cipher
07-29-2009, 06:03 PM
Rise of the Silver Surfer was PG and made a buttload of money. Not as much as the big contenders, but a lot.A moderate (on this scale) success and panned by critics for trying to pander too much to both kids and adults.
And the Fantastic Four can do whatever the hell they want. They've been an established comic book property for years, independant of any toyline or child-oriented revivals. There could be a PG-13 Fantastic Four movie tomorrow and people would accept it. The Turtles still need to get there, and a hard hitting movie is the chance to do that.
I don't care if I'm the Cybercubed of PG-13 supporters. This would be such a painful opportunity to miss.
A moderate (on this scale) success and panned by critics for trying to pander too much to both kids and adults.
Wait. You want the new movie to not only be PG-13 but loved by critics, too?
Hahahaha, oh my God.
ToTheNines
07-29-2009, 06:33 PM
Rise of the Silver Surfer was PG and made a buttload of money. Not as much as the big contenders, but a lot. Point being, I've never seen anyone go "What's the movie's rating? PG? No, never mind, I'll see something else".
Good point. But that's just one movie, and it's Marvel.
Plus it pulled a Spider-Man 3, the trailers looked pretty frickin sweet but it turned out to be not that great. I still liked it though.
Dragon Turtle
07-29-2009, 06:48 PM
Was anyone seriously expecting the movie to be rated PG-13?
Why not? It's not that hard to push a PG movie into the lighter end or even the mid-level of PG-13 territory.
Didn't you know? You can't tell a good story unless it's at least PG-13.
That certainly isn't true, you can tell an excellent story without the movie being PG-13, you just can't have much fighting or violence, especially in the case of TMNT, which the MPAA is going to scrutinize a lot more then another property.
PG-13 doesn't necessarily guarantee a good movie either, I would rather see another PG TMNT, then a PG-13 TMNT as bad as Transformers.
Rise of the Silver Surfer was PG and made a buttload of money. Not as much as the big contenders, but a lot. Point being, I've never seen anyone go "What's the movie's rating? PG? No, never mind, I'll see something else".
Except for you people, of course.
In terms of boxoffice, Rise of the Silver Surfer barely broke even, and was a sequel to an already established PG-13 movie. If your going to try and entice an older audience to go out and watch a movie based on a property largely perceived as a kids franchise, then you actually have to put something in it that is going to make them want to go out and see it, and generally, for a movie like TMNT, it's going to be the action.
Wait. You want the new movie to not only be PG-13 but loved by critics, too?
Hahahaha, oh my God.
Why not?
GK Punk
07-29-2009, 06:55 PM
That certainly isn't true, you can tell an excellent story without the movie being PG-13, you just can't have much fighting or violence, especially in the case of TMNT, which the MPAA is going to scrutinize a lot more then another property.
PG-13 doesn't necessarily guarantee a good movie either, I would rather see another PG TMNT, then a PG-13 TMNT as bad as Transformers.
Yeah.. that was sarcasm ;)
Doc_ock_4mugen
07-29-2009, 07:06 PM
Just because it's PG does not mean it will be bad.
BUT The trend for action packed comic book movies is to be PG-13. Usually PG movies that contain "Martial Arts" suffer in the Martial Arts department because they're PG... Example, The Previous Live Action TMNT Movies, Dragon Ball: Evolution.
Having a PG-13 TMNT is not a ludicrous dream...
I mean Batman was Revamped with the Tim Burton movie back in '89... It was PG-13, not the PG rating from the '60s Batman Movie...
Batman could recover from it's POW! BAM! BIFF! Bat Shark Repellant campiness...
It's time for the TMNT to recover from the Cowabunga dudes, Pizza time, Go ninja go ninja go! campiness.
As long as there's no Venus...
That certainly isn't true, you can tell an excellent story without the movie being PG-13, you just can't have much fighting or violence, especially in the case of TMNT, which the MPAA is going to scrutinize a lot more then another property. Actually you can have a lot of fighing and violence have you seen Prince Caspian? Though I don't see a reason not to make it PG-13. Why do you think they would scrutinize it a lot more then another property?
Brodie
07-29-2009, 08:49 PM
A movie can still be dark or gritty and not be PG-13. The first movie was dark enough for the subject material (...giant...talking...turtles..), you remember Shredder getting crushed in a garbage truck? Its not even implied! It happens. PG rating.
****, even stuff made for tv is dark enough, do people not remember Leonardo decapitating the Shredder? They didn't show he was a god damned alien until well afterwards. It was a children's cartoon. And wouldn't have been pg-13.
If newer movies have taught us anything, its that parameters in specific rating groups are far more lenient/darker. Dark Knight is a SEVERELY dark pg-13, Drag Me To Hell is Bloody, gorey, gross, and violent, and PG-13. If those parameters are getting pushed, the qualifications of PG are also getting darker.
PAAATE
07-29-2009, 10:22 PM
Quote from Twitter, for those who haven't read it:
"The Mirage Volume One Collected Book hit stores today! If you're new to the Turtles and want to get into the comics CHECK IT OUT!
It collects the first 15 original Eastman and Laird comic books that will provide the basis for the 2011 live action movie...
...which is being brought to you by the people responsible for films like Batman Begins, The Dark Knight, 300 and Superman returns!"
Batman Begins and The Dark Knight? No? Or have I missed something :-?
Dragon Turtle
07-29-2009, 11:39 PM
Actually you can have a lot of fighing and violence have you seen Prince Caspian? Though I don't see a reason not to make it PG-13. Why do you think they would scrutinize it a lot more then another property?
Big budget, high profile movies such as Prince Caspian tend to get special consideration when it comes to ratings, even Thomas Gray, the producer of all four TMNT movies, commented on the separate rules for TMNT and Narnia:
"Again, we've had some preliminary talks with the rating board. You know it's funny. You can go and see "Narnia" and it's really violent. They have different standards for us than they do for "Narnia" or any other PG."
TMNT is still widely viewed as kid's property, which naturally draws Kids and their parents to the theaters, and the last thing the MPAA wants to deal with are angry watchdog groups complaining about how the MPAA aren't doing their jobs, in the turtles case in particular, I believe the MPAA took heat over giving the first movie a PG rating and are probably not going to let themselves be put in that position again, and will keep a closer eye on a franchise that burned them in the past.
As to why they may not make a PG-13 movie, as Rose mentioned, some of the companies that Mirage licenses the TMNT to, will not support a PG-13 TMNT movie, Mirage could find other partners, but they probably don't pay as well.
****, even stuff made for tv is dark enough, do people not remember Leonardo decapitating the Shredder? They didn't show he was a god damned alien until well afterwards. It was a children's cartoon. And wouldn't have been pg-13.
The censors for tv are not the MPAA, the cartoon was subject to different standards. I could think of a few other things from the cartoon series that could have gotten a PG-13 rating, Mikey actually hitting people with his nunchucks being one of them.
...which is being brought to you by the people responsible for films like Batman Begins, The Dark Knight, 300 and Superman returns!"
Batman Begins and The Dark Knight? No? Or have I missed something :-?
Isn't Legendary Pictures involved in the production?
Peanut
07-30-2009, 01:20 AM
Why does this surprise ANYBODY!?
The Ninja Turtles have never had any kind of money-making success as anything but a children's property, why in the HELL are they going to change now? To satisfy a few thousand rabid 20-30 year old turtle jerkers?
Face facts and shut up about it.
Andrew NDB
07-30-2009, 01:30 AM
The point where PG apologists come into the conversation about a new Turtle movie is where I promptly exit stage.
Cipher
07-30-2009, 01:39 AM
Why does this surprise ANYBODY!?
The Ninja Turtles have never had any kind of money-making success as anything but a children's property, why in the HELL are they going to change now? To satisfy a few thousand rabid 20-30 year old turtle jerkers?
Face facts and shut up about it.Nobody's expecting it to change without a major event to bring public opinion around. And this movie could be it, if everything pans out right. I won't be shocked if it doesn't, but I'm not going to shell out the price of a ticket to support it.
The Batman similie is tired, but a few decades back you know someone was telling Tim Burton that the property had never made any money except as a camp sitcom.
And....I just really want to believe in fairies.
A movie can still be dark or gritty and not be PG-13. The first movie was dark enough for the subject material (...giant...talking...turtles..), you remember Shredder getting crushed in a garbage truck? Its not even implied! It happens. PG rating.
I also remember a fight that involved hitting Foot Ninja with symbols and squirting water. So...yeah.
The Stryker
07-30-2009, 02:00 AM
The point where PG apologists come into the conversation about a new Turtle movie is where I promptly exit stage.
Thank god. The last thing anyone needs is you challenging someone to a fight at the premiere of the movie.
I think making a super serious, super gritty movie would make the turtles even more of a joke than they are now.
No, I bet nobody told Tim Burton that Batman hadn't made any money outside of camp sitcoms because Dark Knight Returns had just changed the entire comic landscape. Ninja Turtles is not in that position. At all.
GK Punk
07-30-2009, 02:01 AM
The point I think worth mentioning is you can do more in a PG Movie these days than you could do back in the 80s/90s. Stuff that would have been Rated R 10 years ago, gets rated PG13 these days. That's why I think they could pull it off just fine as PG.
Slap-Happy
07-30-2009, 05:54 AM
I think making a super serious, super gritty movie would make the turtles even more of a joke than they are now.
This is completly true. It has to NOT take itself to seriously. Iron MAn, again was a perfect mix of action and humor. Just what a turtles movie SHOULD be.
Peanut
07-30-2009, 07:03 AM
The point where PG apologists come into the conversation about a new Turtle movie is where I promptly exit stage.
Hahaha. PG apologists.
[QUOTE=Dragon Turtle;711508]
"Again, we've had some preliminary talks with the rating board. You know it's funny. You can go and see "Narnia" and it's really violent. They have different standards for us than they do for "Narnia" or any other PG." But why? Narnia was based off kids books TMNT wasn't.
Brodie
07-30-2009, 12:11 PM
The point I think worth mentioning is you can do more in a PG Movie these days than you could do back in the 80s/90s. Stuff that would have been Rated R 10 years ago, gets rated PG13 these days. That's why I think they could pull it off just fine as PG.
Thats what I was trying to say, but nooooo one listens.
Jester
07-30-2009, 12:35 PM
Then why was TMNT almost a hard G film? If they could get away with so much more, why didbn't TMNT try? To afraid to rock the boat?
johnnyblaze
07-30-2009, 01:21 PM
Munroe had to deliver a certain style film to the studio so at the end of the day he simply couldn't do everything he wanted to do because it wasn't entirely up to him.
FearlessLeader
07-30-2009, 01:25 PM
Then why was TMNT almost a hard G film? If they could get away with so much more, why didbn't TMNT try? To afraid to rock the boat?
Try writing a letter to Warner Brothers as I have the feeling they are the only ones that can really answer this.
Aztec General
07-30-2009, 01:26 PM
Munroe had to deliver a certain style film to the studio so at the end of the day he simply couldn't do everything he wanted to do because it wasn't entirely up to him.
Don't try to take the heat off of him. He wrote the story for the film and it was AWFUL. As nice of a guy as he was to the fans, he is a terrible story writer.
GK Punk
07-30-2009, 05:44 PM
Then why was TMNT almost a hard G film? If they could get away with so much more, why didbn't TMNT try? To afraid to rock the boat?
He was most likely given guidelines he HAD to meet and not given as much freedom as everyone thinks.
Samurai Usagi
07-30-2009, 05:51 PM
I want Leo and Raph to draw BLOOD from enemies with their BLADES,
GK Punk
07-30-2009, 05:51 PM
But Raph uses Sai... they don't have blades.
ToTheNines
07-30-2009, 05:58 PM
The point I think worth mentioning is you can do more in a PG Movie these days than you could do back in the 80s/90s. Stuff that would have been Rated R 10 years ago, gets rated PG13 these days. That's why I think they could pull it off just fine as PG.
You're right, but there's two ends of the spectrum for PG movies.... and I'd much rather it be PG-13 than a soft PG.
Iron MAn, again was a perfect mix of action and humor. Just what a turtles movie SHOULD be.
It was rated PG-13.
Dragon Turtle
07-31-2009, 02:56 AM
But why? Narnia was based off kids books TMNT wasn't.
TMNT already had preexisting kid movies, and its the movies the MPAA cares about, the fantasy setting and types of weapons used also play a part in judging these two movies. And of course Narnia was a bigger movie then TMNT.
The point I think worth mentioning is you can do more in a PG Movie these days than you could do back in the 80s/90s. Stuff that would have been Rated R 10 years ago, gets rated PG13 these days. That's why I think they could pull it off just fine as PG.
While it may be true that you can do a bit more in PG today then 10 years ago, TMNT has its own set of rules to follow when working in the realm of PG, what is OK for another PG movie doesn't necessarily apply to a PG turtles movie. And then there is the international market to consider, who have even stricter guidelines concerning violence, just because it's PG in the US doesn't
mean it's PG in another country.
Of course this mostly applies to the level action/fighting, you can still write some mature material a PG movie.
Then why was TMNT almost a hard G film? If they could get away with so much more, why didbn't TMNT try? To afraid to rock the boat?
When the MPAA tells you, "You guys are walking on a tightrope here; pull back a little bit." , TMNT 4 is basically what you're going to get in terms of action for a PG TMNT movie.
The Stryker
07-31-2009, 11:30 AM
I still say having Leonardo running around cutting people into ribbons would do more harm than good. The subject matter is still giant talking turtles after all.
You can do a darker story without having blood and extreme violence.
Roseangelo
07-31-2009, 12:28 PM
I'll just reiterate what I've already said: I just hope they make the best Turtles movie possible, and whatever that ends up being rated, that's what it's rated. Be it PG or PG-13 (I do think R would be too extreme).
But whatever it's rated, Michaelangelo has to be able to use his nunchucks.
R or Bust.
I want all turtles to wear red bandanas, the movie to be very violent, no comedy, film it in black and white, kill shredder in the first 10 minues, 3 hour epic movie with a 4 hour directors cut
The Stryker
07-31-2009, 12:50 PM
R or Bust.
I want all turtles to wear red bandanas, the movie to be very violent, no comedy, film it in black and white, kill shredder in the first 10 minues, 3 hour epic movie with a 4 hour directors cut
I really hope you were joking.
Because that's an awesome joke.
Peanut
07-31-2009, 12:57 PM
R or Bust.
I want all turtles to wear red bandanas, the movie to be very violent, no comedy, film it in black and white, kill shredder in the first 10 minues, 3 hour epic movie with a 4 hour directors cut
So, 2 hours and 50 minutes of? Stockman and Mousers? Sounds super epic.
Andrew NDB
07-31-2009, 01:15 PM
I still say having Leonardo running around cutting people into ribbons would do more harm than good. The subject matter is still giant talking turtles after all.
You can do a darker story without having blood and extreme violence.
You're talking in absolutes -- it looks like from your post it's either no "blood and extreme violence" or it's "cutting people into ribbons." The reality ought to be somewhere in between.
And if it's not at least PG-13 they really shouldn't even bother... and all it will serve to do is deepen/expand the already wide kiddy wound that the last movie reinforced.
Peanut
07-31-2009, 01:28 PM
And if it's not at least PG-13 they really shouldn't even bother... and all it will serve to do is deepen/expand the already wide kiddy wound that the last movie reinforced.
Why? There hasn't been a good TMNT movie for years. Why is it so bad if we get something along the same lines as the first movie? That's a really fun movie, and it's totally what I want from the franchise. You guys need to start realizing that outside of the hardcore TMNT fan community, NOBODY wants a mature turtles. Nobody. Not the mass public, not the studios, no one. It's time to let it go.
I'll say it again - the whole "dark and gritty" thing needs to be done as an animated mini-series. Adult Swim, 11-minute episodes, Mirage-style, black and white. Get a group of slick animators on it and let them go nuts.
The Stryker
07-31-2009, 01:29 PM
I would be happy with the movie being the same tone as the first.
I feel that was as far as you can go without getting ridiculous.
ToTheNines
07-31-2009, 02:05 PM
Nobody. Not the mass public, not the studios, no one. It's time to let it go.
Because they've never seen one. Why not try something new?
Peanut
07-31-2009, 02:07 PM
Because they've never seen one. Why not try something new?
They don't want to see it! Do you know how many times I shown the Mirage comics to people outside of this fandom? People who loved the Turtles growing up as much as we all did? They think it's stupid!
And listen, I'm not trying to say I wouldn't watch a balls-to-the-wall brutal TMNT movie, I would love to. I'm just being realistic with my expectations. As a fans, we've been abused for Christ knows how long. We had a decent cartoon in 2K turn into utter sh*t, we've had to deal with the absolute trash that is Mirage vol 4., the garbage CG movie, and horrible video games. If they can pull this movie off on the level of the first film, even if it isn't a "gritty" take on the source material, I'll be happy as f*ck.
You all need to stop complaining and try to be thankful that we're getting another movie at all. This franchise should have died with the 90's, and I'm surprised anyone is willing to take another change after that CG sh*t-fest.
ToTheNines
07-31-2009, 02:19 PM
They don't want to see it! Do you know how many times I shown the Mirage comics to people outside of this fandom? People who loved the Turtles growing up as much as we all did? They think it's stupid!
I'm not too far to the Mirage side on this spectrum, I just think it needs to be PG-13 for action purposes.
The Stryker
07-31-2009, 02:23 PM
The CG movie had decent fight scenes and that was PG.
ToTheNines
07-31-2009, 02:26 PM
The CG movie had decent fight scenes and that was PG.
That's true, but I'd still like better. I don't want it looking like a Tarantino movie, but i'd like to see a little bit of blood from hard hits and at least a cut when Leo hacks at a ninja.
And this nunchuck embargo has got to f*ck off.
Spike Spiegel
07-31-2009, 02:35 PM
You all need to stop complaining and try to be thankful that we're getting another movie at all. This franchise should have died with the 90's, and I'm surprised anyone is willing to take another change after that CG sh*t-fest.
After the 2007 film, I was pretty sure that any sequel resulting from it would be even more "kiddy" than its predecessor. If this is a complete reboot, that will be great; a blank slate for (hopefully) open minded fans and moviegoers. Maybe this could regenerate the franchise as a whole...
The Stryker
07-31-2009, 02:43 PM
After the 2007 film, I was pretty sure that any sequel resulting from it would be even more "kiddy" than its predecessor. If this is a complete reboot, that will be great; a blank slate for (hopefully) open minded fans and moviegoers. Maybe this could regenerate the franchise as a whole...
You do realize that the CG movie was released not too long ago right?
The Incredible Hulk was hurt because of the Ang Lee movie and Hulk is a WAAAAYYYYY bigger property than the Ninja Turtles.
Dragon Turtle
07-31-2009, 02:59 PM
I still say having Leonardo running around cutting people into ribbons would do more harm than good. The subject matter is still giant talking turtles after all.
You can do a darker story without having blood and extreme violence.
The chances of getting much in the way of blood or extreme violence in a mainstream TMNT project was always mote. But to get people to go see a TMNT movie you need action at least in the PG-13 range, at least on the same level of Marvel and DC comic adaptions. PG will keep the movie focused on the kids market, which today seems far riskier then going mid-level PG-13.
I'll say it again - the whole "dark and gritty" thing needs to be done as an animated mini-series. Adult Swim, 11-minute episodes, Mirage-style, black and white. Get a group of slick animators on it and let them go nuts.
Or DTV or a regular series.
I would be happy with the movie being the same tone as the first.
I feel that was as far as you can go without getting ridiculous.
The 2k3 series prove you could do more serious tone turtle stories, even the fourth TMNT movie had a more consistent serious tone then the first one.
The CG movie had decent fight scenes and that was PG.
Decent, but nothing that would wow the public, nothing to give the public the impression "you have to go out and see this movie now!".
Peanut
07-31-2009, 03:05 PM
Or DTV or a regular series.
See...no. You don't need it to be as long as a DTV, which no one will buy, and you don't need a regular series, because it'll wear out its welcome. 11-minute episode mini-series on Adult Swim is perfect for what the Turtles have to offer. If it's popular, you give it another small series, like the Clone Wars shorts.
The Stryker
07-31-2009, 03:08 PM
The 2k3 series prove you could do more serious tone turtle stories, even the fourth TMNT movie had a more consistent serious tone then the first one.
I hated the 2k3 series after the first season.
Dragon Turtle
07-31-2009, 03:29 PM
See...no. You don't need it to be as long as a DTV, which no one will buy, and you don't need a regular series, because it'll wear out its welcome. 11-minute episode mini-series on Adult Swim is perfect for what the Turtles have to offer. If it's popular, you give it another small series, like the Clone Wars shorts.
In general, DTVs are not huge money makers, or else Mirage would have produced one by now (especially considering they already had a script completed for one), but as an avenue for producing a truly faithful adaption of the Mirage comic a DTV is a practical way to go. As for a regular series, if it is well written and produced, why would it wear out its welcome? Especially if the series evolves or advances the story beyond the source material?
I hated the 2k3 series after the first season.
What did you like about the first season and what put you off of the subsequent seasons, if you don't mind me asking.
The Stryker
07-31-2009, 03:30 PM
It just got really stupid really fast.
ToTheNines
07-31-2009, 03:33 PM
It just got really stupid really fast.
Every season, including season 1, had stupid episodes. But other than the music decline, I'd say the show kept the same quality until season 5.
Dragon Turtle
07-31-2009, 03:34 PM
It just got really stupid really fast.
Anything in particular, I just ask to get a better understanding about how people feel about different aspects of the TMNT franchise.
Andrew NDB
07-31-2009, 04:36 PM
After the 2007 film, I was pretty sure that any sequel resulting from it would be even more "kiddy" than its predecessor. If this is a complete reboot, that will be great; a blank slate for (hopefully) open minded fans and moviegoers. Maybe this could regenerate the franchise as a whole...
Would I get any flak for using the "Battered Wife Syndrome" metaphor again?
"He'll change, he'll get better one of these days!" But he doesn't. He just keeps on beatin'.
Two of the Harry Potter films were PG-13 I don't see why TMNT can't be held up to the same standard.
Andrew NDB
07-31-2009, 05:22 PM
Two of the Harry Potter films were PG-13 I don't see why TMNT can't be held up to the same standard.
The point they were trying to raise at the 25th Panel was that, "The last Harry Potter movie was PG... look how dark that was!"
And that's... not apples to apples at all. You add guys with swords and martial arts with "Ninja" in the title and it's not quite the same as some children with magic in the MPAA eyes.
There's also the fact that the last Harry Potter had almost no action in it. Though I guess they feel the TMNT audience isn't as mature as the Harry Potter audience .
Then why was TMNT almost a hard G film? If they could get away with so much more, why didbn't TMNT try? To afraid to rock the boat?
This article explains why they didn't.
http://www.reelzchannel.com/article/179/reelzchannel-com-enters-the-world-of-tmnt-
Warhorse
07-31-2009, 06:45 PM
I'll just reiterate what I've already said: I just hope they make the best Turtles movie possible, and whatever that ends up being rated, that's what it's rated. Be it PG or PG-13 (I do think R would be too extreme).
But whatever it's rated, Michaelangelo has to be able to use his nunchucks.
At least this should be a reasonable request.
Brodie
07-31-2009, 06:48 PM
Yeah, I also want to be on record for supporting a PG-13 movie. My arguement is just that I don't think it'll ever happen, which isn't the same as not wanting one.
I don't see the point in fighting for a pg-13 film, or for the franchise to head in a better direction when we've seen how well studios and Laird have listened in the past.
Laird is a driving force to the property, and he can only drive it one way: Into the ****ing ground.
So, yeah, I'd love a violent film too...but it won't happen. There;s no point in threatening to not see the movie if it isn't PG-13, because no one is listening.
Warhorse
07-31-2009, 06:59 PM
Yeah, I support a PG-13 rating, but it won't be the end of the world for me if it isn't, nor am I going to boycott the new movie if it's not. In the end, it was never the action or violence that drew me to the Turtles, but their personalities, characters and the way they interact with each other.
But still, a nice, well choreographed fight scene or two would be a nice bonus. I just think with a PG-13 film, it could amp up the intensity of the fight scenes. Also, they're still teenagers. It's been a while since I heard them swear. I miss Raphael's "damn" from the first movie.
Look what Munroe said about the 2007 film I think if it does work, then I think we will go back to Peter and say, 'Where do we take it next time?' Clearly we'd like to try to maybe move it up a little bit into the PG-13. That seems to be the traffic we're getting on the web is, 'Why can't we see a PG-13?' We would really like to do a PG-13. Hey it's always possible especially after the success of the Transformers films and hopefully the G.I. Joe film.
Doc_ock_4mugen
07-31-2009, 07:15 PM
My reasons for wanting a PG-13 (Moderate PG-13 not borderline R) TMNT Movie are:
-It allows more gritty elements that can't be used on a PG movie... (Violence, language,etc, themes. I Mean Vengeance is kinda hard to work it on a Live Action PG Movie...)
-Fighting. The Turtles are NINJAS... Great fighters/assassins. They carry deadly weapons, yet they forsake them for cymbals, yo-yos, spitting water, sausages, etc. (C'mon Mike, use your fricking chucks!!)
But If they go PG-13 I don't want them to take inspiration from the Bayformers... (No mousers trying to get it on with April's leg or Raphael peeing Casey's mask)
Sage Ninja
07-31-2009, 10:02 PM
jeez, this thread degenerated real fast...
Jephael
07-31-2009, 10:41 PM
I'm surprised it didn't happen sooner. I mean what's all this whining and moaning going to accomplish? Lets face it, everyone wants something different. Some want it dark like The Dark Knight and others want it light-hearted like the Spider-Man movies. We're gonna have to find a comprimise at some point or everyone's head are going to explode!!!
Warhorse
07-31-2009, 11:02 PM
Hey, with all the talking about the ratings and stuff, nobody hasn't mentioned the physique that you all would like for the Turtles. Do you want them on the leaner side like in the 2007 film, or beefier side like the live action films?
What other physical characteristics would you all prefer. Would you prefer them to look appealing to the eye, or unappealing? What about their eyes. Pupils or no pupils? Would you like to see up close shots of showing different colors for each of the Turtle's eyes if you prefer pupils?
Andrew NDB
07-31-2009, 11:56 PM
I'm surprised it didn't happen sooner. I mean what's all this whining and moaning going to accomplish? Lets face it, everyone wants something different. Some want it dark like The Dark Knight and others want it light-hearted like the Spider-Man movies. We're gonna have to find a comprimise at some point or everyone's head are going to explode!!!
Couldn't disagree more. A "Let's try and please everybody!" movie is doomed to either failure or mediocrity... or both.
ToTheNines
08-01-2009, 07:30 AM
We're gonna have to find a comprimise at some point or everyone's head are going to explode!!!
Not to sound mean, but: we're not the ones who have to do anything, that's for the people who make the movie.
Fledermaus
08-01-2009, 12:58 PM
Not to sound mean, but: we're not the ones who have to do anything, that's for the people who make the movie.
No one here can have any say in a TMNT movie until:
1) Around twenty-thirty years from now the franchise is as dead as a doornail
2) Around twenty-thirty years from now all critics and censors who had a bone to pick with the TMNT franchise are dead
3) Peter Laird is dead and no one with power cares enough to continue his lousy mismanagement habits or to steer any future films to pander to four-year-olds
4) Those of us who are going into film-making for a living have actually established ourselves as being skilled, tenacious directors, producers and/or scriptwriters.
What we need are filmmakers who love the TMNT enough to finance, direct, write a movie about them, who have the ability to make great films if they want to, and neither approve of nor blind themselves to the fact that all cinematic incarnations of TMNT have been jokes -- but they were never truly funny, just idiotic, (except to the nostalgia-crazed zealots and die-hard TMNT junkies who like the Proletariat will accept whatever sh1t the Party gives them), nor was it cool, or timeless, or something that martial artists or any filmmaker worth their salt could watch without vomiting.
So go to film school. Or animation school, acting -- however you can worm your way into directing movies. If you have talent and your passion for TMNT does not dwindle, you just might not only succeed in making a TMNT movie, but a good movie.
The more you say it can't be done, the more you give power to that idea, whether you claim to support it or not. :)
The Deadman
08-01-2009, 01:10 PM
I expect Krang and Shredder.
Cowabungas and Pizzas!
Technodrome, Rocksteady and Beebop too.
Slash/Rat King and Baxter Stockman as a fly in a sequel.
Krang? **** YES....dont make him a CGI Krang either....make that bastard lifelike
Mr._Mutant_Man
08-01-2009, 02:49 PM
What I'd love but do not expect: Red masks.
I like the idea of having both the red and the multi-colored masks. Like having them start with the red masks, then because April and/or Casey keep getting confused they change it to multi-colored bandannas, but Raphael insists on keeping the red bandanna.
I'd really like to see the utroms, but I'd settle for some mousers.
ToTheNines
08-01-2009, 06:24 PM
I like the idea of having both the red and the multi-colored masks. Like having them start with the red masks, then because April and/or Casey keep getting confused they change it to multi-colored bandannas, but Raphael insists on keeping the red bandanna.
Or have them meet up with turtles from another dimension that already have multi-colored bandanas, and they'll get their idea from that lol
What if they all wore black masks?
PAAATE
08-02-2009, 12:04 PM
What if they all wore black masks?
As cool as it might be; no thanks
Preferably all red, but since that... Yeah, it won't happen... I'd prefer blue/red/orange/purple over all black
ToTheNines
08-02-2009, 12:04 PM
What if they all wore black masks?
Dumb, that would piss off all kinds of fans. It's not red like Mirage, it's not multi like the rest, it's the same color as Slash, and it's not marketable.
Doc_ock_4mugen
08-02-2009, 03:33 PM
blonde wigs?
Andrew NDB
08-02-2009, 03:40 PM
I think all four Turtles should all appear in blackface.
Dragon Turtle
08-02-2009, 04:00 PM
Some want it dark like The Dark Knight and others want it light-hearted like the Spider-Man movies. We're gonna have to find a comprimise at some point or everyone's head are going to explode!!!
I thought a Spider-Man level movie would be a compromise.
Hey, with all the talking about the ratings and stuff, nobody hasn't mentioned the physique that you all would like for the Turtles. Do you want them on the leaner side like in the 2007 film, or beefier side like the live action films?
The turtles physiques will be limited by how they construct the suits for the actors and how much mobility they wish the turtles to have, I would prefer the turtles physiques to be somewhere between the 2007 movie and the 2k3 cartoon, perhaps leaning more toward the muscular side.
What other physical characteristics would you all prefer. Would you prefer them to look appealing to the eye, or unappealing? What about their eyes. Pupils or no pupils? Would you like to see up close shots of showing different colors for each of the Turtle's eyes if you prefer pupils?
In live action, having no pupils might be difficult to pull off, making them look blind and creepy.
I think all four Turtles should all appear in blackface.
Is Michael Bay directing?
Dumb, that would piss off all kinds of fans. It's not red like Mirage, it's not multi like the rest, it's the same color as Slash, and it's not marketable. But it seems to be something studios do look at X-Men, G.I. Joe.
ToTheNines
08-02-2009, 07:17 PM
But it seems to be something studios do look at X-Men, G.I. Joe.
So? I understand your idea is to make them look more bad ass, but what's not bad ass about dark red?
Plus that's not a great comparison. If you put those guys in their comic/animated series threads, it'll look like cosplay at a Con. With the turtles, it's simply the color of the head band we're talkin here.
Andrew NDB
08-02-2009, 07:30 PM
I thought a Spider-Man level movie would be a compromise.
Yep. Spider-Man at least had people getting cut, bloody, crushed and killed, and at one point you even see a guy getting impaled.
Doc_ock_4mugen
08-02-2009, 07:55 PM
Yep. Spider-Man at least had people getting cut, bloody, crushed and killed, and at one point you even see a guy getting impaled. ...in the crotch... Two movies later that guy's son gets impaled and an explosive chars half of his face...
ToTheNines
08-02-2009, 08:25 PM
...in the crotch... Two movies later that guy's son gets impaled and an explosive chars half of his face...
And even worse... his best friend dances around the streets of New York, busting out piano solos and beating women.
Wait what? I don't remember piano solos or beating women.
ToTheNines
08-02-2009, 08:48 PM
Wait what? I don't remember piano solos or beating women.
In the jazz club scene... He's like "this is for you Mary Jane" and plays some dumb song, then he punches her lol
Doc_ock_4mugen
08-03-2009, 05:45 AM
The Dancing Pete was bad but, a similar scene happened in Tobey-man 2... (♪Raindrops keep falling on my head♫ anyone?) But worse than Dancing Pete... The Highschool Musical Omelet making with Harry and Mary Jane... It made the Ninja rap look cool.
Andrew NDB
08-03-2009, 10:57 AM
I never really understood people's hatred of the Peter dancing scene in SM3 -- it served a specific narrative purpose and was really quite effective. I think that people just tend to hone in on this scene because the rest of the movie suffers from a shoddy script.
And the "Raindrops Keep Fallin' on my Head" had the audience in hysterics both times I went to the theatre to see it. That was great.
Doc_ock_4mugen
08-03-2009, 12:26 PM
It served its purpose and it isn't as farfetched as people think, that's why I mentioned the Raindrops from S-M2... The Dorkiness of Peter Parker was shown in the previous movie... Maybe its the pride that Peter had in his dorkyness that makes it cringeworthy... Kinda like a traffic accident.
Jephael
08-03-2009, 08:57 PM
And the "Raindrops Keep Fallin' on my Head" had the audience in hysterics both times I went to the theatre to see it. That was great.
That part still makes me chuckle whenever I watch it.
Warhorse
08-04-2009, 09:39 PM
Would you guys like to keep the voice actors from the 2007 TMNT movie, or change them for other voice actors?
ToTheNines
08-04-2009, 10:45 PM
Who ever's best for the job. I'm sure they'll recast, this is a reboot.
Andrew NDB
08-04-2009, 10:49 PM
Would you guys like to keep the voice actors from the 2007 TMNT movie, or change them for other voice actors?
Completely indifferent to the other three, but Mikey's voice actor's gotta go. Or has to approach the part with a Page One rewrite on his take of it.
Slap-Happy
08-05-2009, 03:48 PM
I really hope they get new actors. All of them were over the top, except maybe Leo.
Spike Spiegel
08-05-2009, 04:44 PM
All of them were over the top, except maybe Leo.
To be honest, Leo ended up being the main reason I even bother to watch that movie again. His characterization and voice actor are great; it's just that everyone else seems to get shafted in this area.
Slap-Happy
08-06-2009, 02:41 PM
everyone else seems to get shafted in this area. More Mike and Don than Raph and Leo.
PAAATE
08-06-2009, 03:45 PM
More Mike and Don than Raph and Leo.
No, roughly equal amount of screen time and importance would be preferable :)
The Shelf
08-06-2009, 03:58 PM
I really hope they get new actors. All of them were over the top, except maybe Leo.
What was wrong with the turtle voice actors in TMNT '07? I can see maybe replacing Mike just because he was so goofy, but that's more of a writing and directing issue than an acting issue.
Gokhan
08-06-2009, 05:17 PM
i want bad ass nija moves an brotherly teamwork doing it. things that show they have been training 2gether for 15 years an know 1 another like a book
Warhorse
08-06-2009, 05:50 PM
i want bad ass nija moves an brotherly teamwork doing it. things that show they have been training 2gether for 15 years an know 1 another like a book
I'd like some fighting scenes focusing on each of the brothers and their skill with their chosen weapons. TMNT 07 was a treat, because it did show a nice scene via the Raph and Leo fight with the weapons. The first TMNT 90 showed some brief weapon use that I miss as well. Especially Michelangelo. The Secret of the Ooze also showed a little of Donny, but why not have a movie that focuses on all four?
Slap-Happy
08-06-2009, 09:37 PM
No, roughly equal amount of screen time and importance would be preferable :) I think you've misunderstood, I was refering to the "everyone else gets shafted" comment by Spike Speigel.
PAAATE
08-07-2009, 07:16 AM
I think you've misunderstood, I was refering to the "everyone else gets shafted" comment by Spike Speigel.
Oups xO
That's what happens when you don't read everything... :P
Live and learn! :cry:
Vincent
08-11-2009, 03:50 PM
What was wrong with the turtle voice actors in TMNT '07?
Their yelling didn't feel natural. Any time Leo or Raph raises their voices in that movie, I can't help but picture a couple of voice actors in my head, reading aloud from a script they haven't quite memorized, as characters they haven't quite gotten into, with emotions they're not quite comfortable playing. Could be due to insufficient rehearsal time, though.
NameGoesHere1066
08-11-2009, 04:08 PM
I thought all four did a good job in the voices they gave their characters. Even Kelly's take on Mikey. I wouldn't mind if they all came back; I especially loved Nolan's Raphael **melts**
Nolan just freaked my freak baby. But I do some what agree with the artifical sounding "yelling". It did seemed kind of forced. But I think that had more to do with not getting enough back ground on just why Raph and Leo where so pissed with each other than the actors not being prepared enough. I dunno. o.O
I wouldn't mind other actors coming in to voice the turtles, so long as they aren't bog name celeberties. I think having celeberty voices would over shadow the fim and turtles.
Warhorse
08-12-2009, 08:47 PM
If they do this live action, what's the chance of getting Ray Park to do the stunts for Leonardo? I know he's about 8 inches taller than the ideal Leo should be, but with good camera tricks and casting taller than average actors, it shouldn't look too out of place.
Oh, I agree with the person above. No more celebrity voices for the Turtles. Corey Feldman was enough (and he really was one of my favorites in the 80's) but it would over shadow the Turtles.
Sage Ninja
08-13-2009, 10:31 PM
I wouldn't mind the the actors who voiced the the turtles back as well. One thing I believed the 07 movie did really right was the potrayals of the turtles.
Especially in Leo and Don's department. I think 07 Don and Leo was a huge upgrade from how they where presented in the live action movies. Don was doctored up to be some clone of Michelangelo, and Leo was this prepubesant sounding wimp, who I really couldn't take seriously as an authorative figure that would heckle Raph. And Jame Arnold Taylor brought that presence to Leo and Mitchell brought that cynical, yet sophisticated techy guy to us. And yes Nolan was a great Raph, I would love to him again.
Heck even Mikey Kelly did good performance. And even though I don't want to see any more dorky air headish, little bother Mikey any more. I think with good direction and resepct from the writers and powers that be, that Mikey Kelly could pull off a sensitve, soft spoken, yet serious Michelangelo. But I still wouldn't mind getting some one else to voice Michelangelo.
and I agree with the rest with no celeberty voices for the turtles. I think they would over shadow the character their playing.
Warhorse
08-15-2009, 12:14 AM
So, you think they might add tails to the Turtles like they have in the comics, or stay away from that, afraid over paranoid parents might think it's something else?
Cipher
08-15-2009, 12:28 AM
So, you think they might add tails to the Turtles like they have in the comics, or stay away from that, afraid over paranoid parents might think it's something else?I couldn't care less about tails. And, let's face it, sometimes they do look like penises in the comics.
Jephael
08-15-2009, 10:36 AM
I couldn't care less about tails. And, let's face it, sometimes they do look like penises in the comics.
CASEY: "Yo Raph, is that your shlong sticking out from under your shell?"
RAPHAEL: "That's my tail, you idjit!"
:tlol:
turkishproverb
08-17-2009, 05:09 AM
Thank god. The last thing anyone needs is you challenging someone to a fight at the premiere of the movie.
I think making a super serious, super gritty movie would make the turtles even more of a joke than they are now.
No, I bet nobody told Tim Burton that Batman hadn't made any money outside of camp sitcoms because Dark Knight Returns had just changed the entire comic landscape. Ninja Turtles is not in that position. At all.
....
Erm... I know this is a little late...but...
Batman (1989) Directed by Tim Burton. Changed the game for the franchise.
And Ulson, whom first wanted a serious batman film, got turned down several times, as did others on making a serious batman film. His film changed the game. It was only when warner brothers was shown dark, high quality source material that they considered the approache valid. Do you honestly think Mirage is showing anyone the darker/higher quality turtles stuff when discussing the films anymore?
As to the DKR allowing it comment, you do realise the film with an agreed tone at least as serious as Superman 1, had been green lit for preproduction by Warner Brothers Years (I think 5) before DKR began to release, right?
or another I basically just brought up:
Superman Directed by Richard Donner. Once again, changed the game. This time though, it was one of the first to take SUPERHERO FILMS PERIOD seriously.
Sage Ninja
08-17-2009, 11:21 AM
f*ck, why'd you have to bring up that debate again...
CJStyles
08-26-2009, 12:02 AM
Honestly, I just don't want this movie to suck. I'd really like lots of action, character development, and true gritty dark images...and not that kiddy ******** you hyped up for months that was going to be "dark and gritty"
jalexbrown
09-04-2009, 01:11 PM
Why is it that all the fans have this 'Ignore all the fans, except the fans who like ___ medium' mentality? The comic fans feel that the movie execs should only care what the comic fans want. Likewise, fans of the old movies feel that the movie is doomed unless the execs try to repeat that success. I'm *so* glad to see that this fandom is so divided. I don't know who does and doesn't realize this, but we ALL stand to gain or lose something here. Everyone's so caught up in the 'Comic or cartoon style' and 'PG or PG-13' debates that they're forgetting the real, most essential need here is a movie that will allow the franchise to breed new success. And when the question of how to do that arises, we should take our fanboy glasses off, because I think we all know that fanboys are the worst judges of character. I think the best thing for everyone to do here is take a step back, forget you're a fan of these characters, and then ask the same questions. A lot of people, I think, might find the answers are different then.
Dragon Turtle
09-09-2009, 12:43 AM
most essential need here is a movie that will allow the franchise to breed new success. And when the question of how to do that arises, we should take our fanboy glasses off, because I think we all know that fanboys are the worst judges of character. I think the best thing for everyone to do here is take a step back, forget you're a fan of these characters, and then ask the same questions. A lot of people, I think, might find the answers are different then.
A well written PG-13 movie should allow the franchise to grow.
The Stryker
09-09-2009, 03:02 AM
A well written PG movie would allow the franchise to grow.
Hell, a well written movie PERIOD would be a step in the right direction. Enough with the rating bullsh*t. A movie can be good regardless of the damn rating.
Doc_ock_4mugen
09-09-2009, 07:34 AM
A well written PG movie would allow the franchise to grow.
Hell, a well written movie PERIOD would be a step in the right direction. Enough with the rating bullsh*t. A movie can be good regardless of the damn rating.
How will it grow when they're staying in a comfort zone and not moving forward. There is a de-evolution in the action from the first film to the third. (Not counting TMNT because it is an animated feature.) The rating thing is not BS. True that a well written movie is a step in the right direction, but we're talking about the TMNT here. The toning down of the action on the sequels was because some parent watchdog groups went breserk on the "high-level of violence" in a PG movie. If the movie is PG-13 we can have the same level of action from the first movie or maybe they can push it a bit further. (not asking for dismemberment and buckets of blood. I just want the turtles to be able to use their weapons and not resort to sausage chucks, cymbals, etc.)
The Stryker
09-09-2009, 02:24 PM
But how does using their weapons make for a better movie, exactly? You can have the best action in the world with violence up the ass but if the movie isn't worth a damn anywhere else, who gives a sh*t?
Cipher
09-09-2009, 02:50 PM
But how does using their weapons make for a better movie, exactly? You can have the best action in the world with violence up the ass but if the movie isn't worth a damn anywhere else, who gives a sh*t?I'm staunchly in the PG-13 crowd, but not for violence. Obviously, it does take you out of a film to have sword-weilding Turtles not be able to use their weapons, but what would hurt it more are the strange quality restrictions that studios and audiences exect from PG movies. There's an unwritten rule that the script has to be dumbed down as well. The Turtles' best moments in the comics haven't been kick-ass ninja fights. They've been character moments, like the Turtles dealing with isolation and vengeance, Casey losing his girlfriend and having to accept his responsibilities, Splinter learning to disregard the sense of justice he'd instilled in his sons. And generally surreal and otherwise abstract writing.
That is what wouldn't translate to a PG film. Yes, you can have deeper writing in a PG movie, but no one would be willing to fund it and few people would watch it expecting those qualities. PG-13 allows for the necessary violence (but nothing over the top) and the level of writing that could make "worth a damn" everywhere else.
Doc_ock_4mugen
09-09-2009, 03:19 PM
But how does using their weapons make for a better movie, exactly? You can have the best action in the world with violence up the ass but if the movie isn't worth a damn anywhere else, who gives a sh*t?
True that a well written movie is a step in the right direction, but we're talking about the TMNT here. (not asking for dismemberment and buckets of blood. I just want the turtles to be able to use their weapons and not resort to sausage chucks, cymbals, etc.)
I said that in a previous post which prompted your reply. I did agree with you that a well written movie is important, but we're talking about the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. the fighting is pretty important considering that this is a Ninja movie. I do not want an exaggerated movie with tons of blood and all that crap. I just want a movie that does the Turtles Justice in the action Department as well as in story. Staying in the PG corner in Live Action would be bad for the TMNT.
The Leo/Raph fight from the animated TMNT is awesome. In Live action it would translate to mild PG-13, which is what the movie needs in terms of action. If that is combined with great writing; it would be freaking sweet!
You talked about how the TMNT need to grow, yet staying in the PG "comfort zone". The fights are "campfests" because of previous problems with Watchdog Groups. They're not the Teenage Mutant Slapstick Turtles. Sausage Chucks, Water Squirts, cymbals all of those are slapstick weapons/attacks. They aid in the "Bad name" that the Turtles have in people's minds.
We've had enough of the Adam West Batman-esque Turtles... It's time for the Turtles to be more like their comic book counterparts.
Katie
09-09-2009, 08:43 PM
I read through some of this and here are my thoughts:
1) Its ok if they do a re-boot but really, we haven't had an origin movie in awhile. if they are going to grow the fan base...and breathe some life into the franchise, you have to do this. Yes, we all know the story....but if you want to grow the franchise you have to make sure everyone knows the story. I saw the 2007 movie and remember thinking. Sh*t. people who don't know the story will be so lost. That is no way to grow the franchise.
2) As unpopular as it may be to some on this forum, you have to appeal to children. if you never bring in new young fans the franchise eventually dies. Plus you have to think business on this. Kids have a TON of disposable income. They will buy most of the merchandise and they represent the biggest portion of the dollar signs the execs see. Also, think of this from the perspective of an adult who was a fan of the 80's toon as a child. (we all know that this is by far the most well known incarnation of the TMNT, and no, I am not a fan of the old toon at all.) These people are parents now and if their kids want to see the movie they will be thinking of that. any of those folks who went to the 2007 movie were very surprised and probably disappointed. They will not go to the new movie because of this. If I had kids, I would not want them to see anything like the 2007 movie was. they will watch the old toon.
3) here is nothing wrong with PG. as I said above, you MUST appeal to younger audiences to make this franchise live. It can be done in a way that we will appreciate as adults. (subtle humor, etc.) but you MUST appeal to the kids. PG will achieve a wider audience. Violence =/= greatness in a movie.
4) I love the comics. That was my first introduction to the Turtles. But as much as I think a comic based movie could be cool, the sci-fi elements with triceratons and stuff is too much. any movie that incorporates this stuff is going to alienate a HUGE potential fan base because most of them would have NO idea that this was even part of the turtles canon. they would be lost and therefore not appreciate the movie. th 1st movie is as good as it wil get for people who want a comic based movie.
5) Shredder must be included. he is THE villain to most layman turtle fans. you ask people on the street who the turtles fight and it won't be Bishop or Hun or Karai or Baxter or Rat king or any of those. its the big pointy metal guy and the brain guy. period.
6) be open minded. Any GOOD turtle movie is better than none. but none is better than a bad one. right?
Cipher
09-09-2009, 10:44 PM
3) here is nothing wrong with PG. as I said above, you MUST appeal to younger audiences to make this franchise live. It can be done in a way that we will appreciate as adults. (subtle humor, etc.) but you MUST appeal to the kids. PG will achieve a wider audience.That hasn't been true for the last decade. Spider-Man, Batman, Iron Man, Transformers, all PG-13 and all still have toy deals, birthday party favors, etc. They still bring in the kids and all the lisencing that comes with them. The difference is that an older, teenage-adult crowd is also willing to see them, whereas PG is an instant turn off for most of that audience. A "kiddy film." In terms of marketability, PG-13 is the new PG.
Violence =/= greatness in a movie.Couldn't agree more. Too bad PG-13 also gets better writing than PG movies because there aren't as many watchdog groups for that sort of thing. If you want to do something interesting or even remotely deep, the studios will be more comfortable allowing a PG-13 film to do that.
6) be open minded. Any GOOD turtle movie is better than none. but none is better than a bad one. right?That depends on what you want as a fan. If you want the franchise to continue, then yes. But it will always do that. It's infinitely re-marketable as long as they keep up the slew of cartoon, toys, and kiddy film reboots.
If you want it to be able to stand up as a comic in its own right, even in the absence of other lisencing like a Marvel or DC property, then no. A bad movie would be one step forward, eight steps back. Anything that doesn't promote the legitimacy of the franchise hurts it.
Dragon Turtle
09-09-2009, 11:38 PM
A well written PG movie would allow the franchise to grow.
Hell, a well written movie PERIOD would be a step in the right direction. Enough with the rating bullsh*t. A movie can be good regardless of the damn rating.
2) As unpopular as it may be to some on this forum, you have to appeal to children. if you never bring in new young fans the franchise eventually dies. Plus you have to think business on this. Kids have a TON of disposable income. They will buy most of the merchandise and they represent the biggest portion of the dollar signs the execs see. Also, think of this from the perspective of an adult who was a fan of the 80's toon as a child. (we all know that this is by far the most well known incarnation of the TMNT, and no, I am not a fan of the old toon at all.) These people are parents now and if their kids want to see the movie they will be thinking of that. any of those folks who went to the 2007 movie were very surprised and probably disappointed. They will not go to the new movie because of this. If I had kids, I would not want them to see anything like the 2007 movie was. they will watch the old toon.
3) here is nothing wrong with PG. as I said above, you MUST appeal to younger audiences to make this franchise live. It can be done in a way that we will appreciate as adults. (subtle humor, etc.) but you MUST appeal to the kids. PG will achieve a wider audience. Violence =/= greatness in a movie.
I do not understand the anti PG-13 sentiment that some people seem to have, I have no idea what people assume a PG-13 TMNT movie will include but it will not include graphic depictions of violence as Mirage will not allow such a thing, as it would hurt the biggest money producing side of TMNT, TMNT as a kid franchise.
A PG-13 rating puts it on the same level as any other "kid-friendly" comic book/martial arts/action movies currently out there. Not many people I know will say that movies such as "Spider-man", "Iron-Man", or any non "Rush Hour" Jackie Chan movie is inappropriate and/or will not appeal to kids. Even movies such as the "Dark Knight", "Transformers", and "Star Wars" all saw significant kid attendance backed by a truckload kid friendly merchandise and tie-ins.
When you are dealing with a more realistic setting, with the type of weapons the TMNT use, and the past kid friendly movie track record, you need a PG-13 rating just to get back at the level of the 1990 movie (which I guarantee you would be PG-13 if released today).
Whether a movie is rated G,PG,PG-13, or R, has nothing to do with the quality of the writing of the movie, for all its faults, TMNT 2007 looks like "Citizen Kane" when compared to some of the recent big budget PG-13 summer popcorn movies, so the wanting of a PG-13 movie is not an indictment against the quality of PG or the other movie rating.
And as awful as movies such as Transformers were, no one can deny the overall impact those movies had on the franchise, such movies went beyond their fan base. You need to bring in people who aren't fans of the TMNT franchise, but wouldn't object to actually going to see a movie based on the TMNT. You will not succeed just by going after any single faction of the TMNT franchise, not the OT, NT, or comics. And whether anyone likes it or not, the best way to get people, who are not TMNT fans in general, to spend their money and time watching a TMNT movie, is with the promise of actually going to the movie theater and seeing something thats going to wow them, and the weak action of the 2007 movie (which is about as good as it's going to get for a PG TMNT movie), is not it.
Doc_ock_4mugen
09-10-2009, 05:43 AM
2) As unpopular as it may be to some on this forum, you have to appeal to children. if you never bring in new young fans the franchise eventually dies. Plus you have to think business on this. Kids have a TON of disposable income. They will buy most of the merchandise and they represent the biggest portion of the dollar signs the execs see. Also, think of this from the perspective of an adult who was a fan of the 80's toon as a child. (we all know that this is by far the most well known incarnation of the TMNT, and no, I am not a fan of the old toon at all.) These people are parents now and if their kids want to see the movie they will be thinking of that. any of those folks who went to the 2007 movie were very surprised and probably disappointed. They will not go to the new movie because of this. If I had kids, I would not want them to see anything like the 2007 movie was. they will watch the old toon. Dark Knight wasn't exactly kid firendly, yet it had a lot of merchandise that kids ate up.
3) here is nothing wrong with PG. as I said above, you MUST appeal to younger audiences to make this franchise live. It can be done in a way that we will appreciate as adults. (subtle humor, etc.) but you MUST appeal to the kids. PG will achieve a wider audience. Violence =/= greatness in a movie. Appealing the younger audiences can be done with PG-13... Spider-Man, X-men, Ironman, etc. true that Violence does not equal great movie, but too much appeal to the younger audiences might turn off the over 12yo. crowd.
4) I love the comics. That was my first introduction to the Turtles. But as much as I think a comic based movie could be cool, the sci-fi elements with triceratons and stuff is too much. any movie that incorporates this stuff is going to alienate a HUGE potential fan base because most of them would have NO idea that this was even part of the turtles canon. they would be lost and therefore not appreciate the movie. th 1st movie is as good as it wil get for people who want a comic based movie. Luckily the Triceratons wouldn't show up in the first... IF they were to show it should be on the third... with plenty of time on the second movie to reveal the Utroms... and some more sci-fi stuff. Baxter's importance on the first film is to show the more sci-fi world of the TMNT... I mean people can swallow the idea of four Turtles becoming humanlike after wading in ooze, yet an Alien Triceratops is too much?
But wasn't the 4th movie dealing with weird sci-fi elements... got to catch all 13 monsters, planets aligning, etc.?
5) Shredder must be included. he is THE villain to most layman turtle fans. you ask people on the street who the turtles fight and it won't be Bishop or Hun or Karai or Baxter or Rat king or any of those. its the big pointy metal guy and the brain guy. period. Shredder should be in the first movie, BUT it would be funny if they dealt with him in the same way as the comics. (That would turn off people, so that's why they probably won't do it. Also the two least liked TMNT are Shredderless.)
6) be open minded. Any GOOD turtle movie is better than none. but none is better than a bad one. right? We need a TMNT movie that catches people by surprise. It needs a gripping story and kickass action scenes to catch the low attention span movie goers. But if we're going to get a half-assed movie; I'd rather have none. The least I expect of a good TMNT movie is to be on par with the first one. I want to see a TMNT movie that surpasses the first one.
shuriken
09-17-2009, 03:15 PM
Appealing the younger audiences can be done with PG-13... Spider-Man, X-men, Ironman, etc. true that Violence does not equal great movie, but too much appeal to the younger audiences might turn off the over 12yo. crowd.
Yeah and all of those movies were very successful blockbusters. If they do a pg movie i think a lot of people might be turned off by it, just like many were turned off by Speed Racer, which go pretty good reviews but it just didn't get the same audience as Ironman or X-men ect.
Doc_ock_4mugen
09-17-2009, 03:50 PM
Speed Racer was AWESOME!! Yet people were turned off by a couple of things, lenght style and PG.
The Stryker
09-17-2009, 05:01 PM
No. Speed Racer didn't get good box office returns because most people didn't know what the hell Speed Racer was and the movie itself didn't look all that appealing.
Spider-Man, Iron Man and Hulk are iconic characters that appeal to everyone and have been relevant for decades. Those movies would have made money regardless of rating.
TMNT is only relevant as a nostalgia trip right now. Comparing them to timeless characters like Spider-man and Batman in terms of box office draw is f*cking stupid.
Cipher
09-17-2009, 05:05 PM
TMNT is only relevant as a nostalgia trip right now.That's not going to change without something seriously high-profile (say, a movie) and something seriously different than what's come before (say, a PG-13 movie). If the public is ever going to take TMNT seriously as a comic franchise like they do with Iron-Man, Spider-Man, Batman, etc, those in charge have to do so as well, and this is their chance.
The Stryker
09-17-2009, 05:23 PM
But with that you also run the risk of making it ridiculous.
Imagine if the GI Joe movie came out and was a serious gritty war drama?
Imagine if the GI Joe movie came out and was a serious gritty war drama?
Then it'd be Saving Private Ryan with ninjas.
PAAATE
09-17-2009, 06:45 PM
But with that you also run the risk of making it ridiculous.
So? If you don't take risks you can't win
Playing it safe with this movie will just kill it
It's like if you have a terminal disease, but the operation could potentially kill you
If they don't take risks with this movie, it will be like the movie's just giving up and committing suicide
Doc_ock_4mugen
09-17-2009, 10:18 PM
No. Speed Racer didn't get good box office returns because most people didn't know what the hell Speed Racer was and the movie itself didn't look all that appealing.
Poster with the Miley avatar SAY WHAT?
We're getting a Candy Land movie, a Stretch Armstrong and a View Master movie. Now that's more of a what the Hell factor than Speed Racer, (which was on air up until the mid-late 90s and ended up on Boomerang until a few years ago.) It wasn't a mainstream toon like say TMNT in the early 90s, but it was still there. VW ad, and most recently the Geico ad. (a few years old but you get the point.)
People that hated it were expecting the Next Matrix (Everytime someone mentions Wachowski Brothers people expect the Matrix or something along that line.) The biggest turn offs were:
Lenght. 2 hours 15 minutes is rather long. The style (Real life cartoon) for 2 hours 15 minutes is a bit too much on the eyes ('seizure inducing'). Also many people dissed it because it was PG. The same people who expected Matrix-esque combat complain about it being too childish (and point out the scenes with Spritle and Chim Chim, especially the one where they're LARPing the 'anime' they're watching).
Incredibly enough the very same reasons why people hate it is why I love it. They went out of their way to be as faithful as possible. My dislikes are mostly nitpicks over small details(Mach 5 abilities assigned to the Wrong buttons, the Mach 6)
Spider-Man, Iron Man and Hulk are iconic characters that appeal to everyone and have been relevant for decades. Those movies would have made money regardless of rating. An R-Rated Spidey wouldn't work. Hulk and Ironman could work as R-Rated movies, but PG-13 is the highest they can go and cater to everyone. (The darker comic book conflicts that appease the CB Geeks) and lighter elements to cater to the Toy companies and Watchdog Groups. Also Hulk wasn't entirely successful.
TMNT is only relevant as a nostalgia trip right now. Comparing them to timeless characters like Spider-man and Batman in terms of box office draw is f*cking stupid. Nostalgia trip? They had a movie two years ago! A cartoon that ended this year. How can they be in a nostalgia Trip.
He-Man is on a nostalgia trip. He-man's considered relevant right now because They've made a pair of Transformers movies and a GI Joe Movie. 2 of the big 3 toy franchises of the 80s. He-man's been a couple of years now without a cartoon, 22 years since the last movie was shown. The TMNT NEED to be treated with respect and taken seriously in order to be a success.
But with that you also run the risk of making it ridiculous. How is making a PG-13 movie of the TMNT ridiculous? They've tried the PG movie approach. The last attempt didn't work. What are they gonna do try again with ANOTHER PG movie and expect different results? (They've done live action and cgi so they've already walked that path.)
The Turtles fighting against ninja yet they cannot use their weapons. That's ridiculous. Fighting Shredder yet they cannot get any cut or scrape... Ridiculous. Using linked sausage or goofy toys in acts of slapstick violence. Ridiculous. Having th eheir of the Shredder and the Foot take the backseat for a Pokémon-esque "Gotta catch 'em all plot... Ridiculous.
Yes the dark and gritty almighty comics have their ridiculous* moments too. (I'd say Fugitoid and everything that happens in outer space or is not TMNT/Foot related. Even the Foot have some Ridiculous stuff. Cloning Worms) But the difference is that they're part of the source material.
*=Ridiculous from a movie making perspective (Same reason why the TRUE Phoenix Saga didn't make it on the X-men movies.)
Imagine if the GI Joe movie came out and was a serious gritty war drama? It would've been closer to my Dad's era of GI JOES... He calls my Era's Joes (A Real American Hero, The series made by Sunbow not the ones by Dic) a Travesty... an abomination... I haven't shown him GI Joe Extreme yet... (Which I think is a travesty... Even bigger than Cobra-La.)
Bourne movies meet Platoon, Saving Private Ryan and the second Half of Full Metal Jacket, with sprinklings of Pearl Harbor's action scenes and American Ninja now that would be one crazy GI Joe movie... but it would be R... not too good for selling toys.
Cipher
09-18-2009, 12:56 AM
But with that you also run the risk of making it ridiculous.
Imagine if the GI Joe movie came out and was a serious gritty war drama?I'd never ask for anything to be something it shouldn't. Gritty-war-drama was never GI Joe's schtick, and I have no reason to believe it would work without betraying everything that GI Joe is.
But Turtles, we know that works with more mature plotlines. We've seen it issue after issue. It's been done, it just hasn't been brought to the public eye in the way that it needs to be.
The Stryker
09-18-2009, 03:32 PM
But Turtles, we know that works with more mature plotlines. We've seen it issue after issue. It's been done, it just hasn't been brought to the public eye in the way that it needs to be.
Who knows?
I've read the damn comics and 90% of it is bullsh*t that takes itself way too seriously.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.