PDA

View Full Version : Should the new Turtles


turtle83
08-03-2009, 10:04 PM
look like the originals from the 1990 movie? What I mean is that they should use their faces (Masks) as a base for the CG movie and somehow make them even more realistic instead of using brand new faces.

just my opinion.

Raph
08-04-2009, 12:03 AM
look like the originals from the 1990 movie? What I mean is that they should use their faces (Masks) as a base for the CG movie and somehow make them even more realistic instead of using brand new faces.

just my opinion.

Its not gonna be a CG movie, It'll be live action!
But I say yes and no, they should stick closely to the comics, but thats what the first movie did too. I just hope they dont get too BTTS stylish :P

Slap-Happy
08-04-2009, 01:36 PM
I say, a mix of the first issue look and first movie look would be best.

The Shelf
08-04-2009, 01:44 PM
I'm fond of this look, but it may not transfer well to film:

http://image.com.com/gamespot/images/2009/201/957018_20090721_screen008.jpg

Buslady
08-04-2009, 02:10 PM
achoo! dang...ugh...

Canadian Turtle
08-04-2009, 08:35 PM
I say they go as realistic as possible. This is a live action movie that most of you want to see done dark and gritty. If the TMNT were going to be real they would look like big dirty mutated Turtles that live in a sewer. My favorite look would be something like the Michael Zulli style done live action with a little touch of old school turtle character style.

odupianist
08-05-2009, 11:47 AM
I think Dooney's style would be more realistic looking personally.

TMNTD
08-05-2009, 02:37 PM
I say they go as realistic as possible. This is a live action movie that most of you want to see done dark and gritty. If the TMNT were going to be real they would look like big dirty mutated Turtles that live in a sewer. My favorite look would be something like the Michael Zulli style done live action with a little touch of old school turtle character style.

Oh MAN !! Zulli's turtles are probably the most realistic looking mutant turtles I've ever seen. But they would probably scare children.

turtle83
08-05-2009, 07:19 PM
Zulli's Turtles look pretty messed up and would make the new movie unbearable to most fans including myself.


I'm wondering if they will be the same height as the original turtles from 1990-91. It seems that the comics had the turtles listed around 4 feet tall. Movie Leo was about 5'7''.

At least the bodies won't be CGI

R-iZZy
08-06-2009, 04:20 AM
Honestly, I wouldn't mind them taking on this look (http://nebezial.deviantart.com/art/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-121465691).

The Shelf
08-06-2009, 08:01 AM
Zulli's Turtles look pretty messed up and would make the new movie unbearable to most fans including myself.

Zulli's turtles kind of resemble Tokka without all the spikes. I think they could make it work if they wanted to.

Warhorse
08-06-2009, 07:09 PM
Zulli's turtles kind of resemble Tokka without all the spikes. I think they could make it work if they wanted to.

No it won't. I hate to say it, but they're going to have to keep the Turtles "cute" looking to some extent in order to be well received by the regular movie going audience. You make them revolting, the movie will seriously flop.

Keep in line with the look of the first live action movie is the best course to go.

turtle83
08-06-2009, 08:35 PM
Donatello from the first movie had the most aggressive/dark/serious looking face. Anything uglier than that would just be a little too much for the average moviegoer.

Here he is and should not get any uglier than this.


http://img517.imageshack.us/img517/8619/don.jpg (http://img517.imageshack.us/i/don.jpg/)

Warhorse
08-06-2009, 09:57 PM
They could always go for the look they had in TMNT 2. I'd prefer it if they used CGI turtles though, like LOTR did Gollum, and use a mixture of the 2007 movie and the first movie look.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
08-06-2009, 10:44 PM
You make them revolting, the movie will seriously flop.

Yet that didn't stop the absolutely hideous looking Transformers from being a hit in their movies... which weren't very good movies to begin with, either.

But, I do think you're right. It's better to try and keep the Turtles' looks faithful rather than make them look too realistic (which in turn would make them look like monsters, even if that is what they are).

I wouldn't mind it if the Turtles looked more realistic, but I definitely wouldn't want them to go overboard with it like what happened in Bayformers.

Billbeaux
08-06-2009, 11:33 PM
What if, instead of being uniformly green all over, their bodies were actually colored like real sliders (i.e. yellow "lines," the trademark red stripe on the side of the head, etc). If nothing else, that would provide one more way to tell the Turtles apart; especially if this director actually decided to go with all red masks.

turtle83
08-07-2009, 12:16 AM
Yet that didn't stop the absolutely hideous looking Transformers from being a hit in their movies... which weren't very good movies to begin with, either.

But, I do think you're right. It's better to try and keep the Turtles' looks faithful rather than make them look too realistic (which in turn would make them look like monsters, even if that is what they are).

I wouldn't mind it if the Turtles looked more realistic, but I definitely wouldn't want them to go overboard with it like what happened in Bayformers.

Not much of a fan of the second Transformers film, but you are right about the robots being a bit ugly. All of them are look bad EXCEPT bumblebee and Prime. They actually looked decent.

turtle83
08-07-2009, 12:18 AM
What if, instead of being uniformly green all over, their bodies were actually colored like real sliders (i.e. yellow "lines," the trademark red stripe on the side of the head, etc). If nothing else, that would provide one more way to tell the Turtles apart; especially if this director actually decided to go with all red masks.

Nah, UNLESS they looked a lot like the original ones from the first movie. That would be freakin awesome. I'm not so excited of the excessive use of SPOTS on the their bodies (movie 2 and 3).

TMNTD
08-07-2009, 12:45 AM
Yeah, I wondering about the height thing too. I know the Mirage turtles were between 4'6-4'9, and Archie turtles were 5'8 .

TMNTD
08-07-2009, 01:25 AM
How would u guys feel if the turtles looked like this in the new movie

johnnyblaze
08-07-2009, 01:44 AM
I absolutely loved the fact that in TMNT all he turtles actually looked young. They were small, thin, big hands, big feet...it truly captured the teenager aspect of the turtles IMO and I hope they find a way to bring that over into the new film.

Billbeaux
08-07-2009, 07:25 AM
While we're at it, here's one that's been bugging me since I was seven...turtles don't have teeth :D

johnnyblaze
08-07-2009, 08:41 AM
but mutated ninja turtles do :p

Canadian Turtle
08-07-2009, 09:48 AM
Honestly, I wouldn't mind them taking on this look (http://nebezial.deviantart.com/art/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-121465691).

Personally I agree with this post. This is actually more what I was thinking. I would have to disagree with most of you in keeping the first movie look. For one thing they need to let go of the first movie, this is not a remake. Second if they want this movie to be realistic they are going to have to adjust the look. And third I would say a mass audience would appeal to a more badass looking Turtle now, because that is what they want to see. Take Hellboy for instance think in that realm of look. If the Turtles had a cameo on Hellboy what would they look like? I think that is where they should go, not to mention the company that did the Hellboy effects are geniuses and they should get them on this film for sure!

Children are not stupid, they will appeal to darker looking roll models, and this film is for a three generation audience I don't think the older audience wants to see pizza eating round faces smiley Turtles anymore, they want to see four ninja assassins trained for one deadly purpose, to avenge their father. Also you have to think outside the fandom. If everyone of us on the drome went to this movie they wouldn't make a cent back, the hardcore fans of this franchise make up a very small percentage of the overall potential fan base, so again people want to see something new.

The Shelf
08-07-2009, 11:47 AM
I agree with you on wanting realistic-looking turtles, Canadian Turtle, but I have to disagree with your assessment of the overall fanbase. The "hardcore" fanbase are the ones who want something new and more realistic. Most fans prefer the old cartoon and old movies. A lot of casual TMNT fans didn't like the 2007 movie because it was too dark and serious. They're the ones who want round-faced, goofy turtles.

The way I see it, there are really 3 groups of people the folks making the movie will have to take into account. There are the casual fans I described above who will only accept goofy, campy, fun turtles; they make up most of the TMNT fans in the world. Then there is the core fanbase like most of us here who prefer the comics, 2003 series, etc. and want a serious, realistic turtles movie with about as much humor as the comics had; this group is definitely a minority. But then we have the untapped potential fanbase; these are the people who have always had a passing interest in TMNT but they don't really become fans because of the goofy nature of the franchise and because they don't really read comics. I think this group could be huge, but we've never had a chance to find out because a movie has never been made that would cater to these people and the "hardcore" TMNT fanbase. You can't really please all three groups. The 2007 movie tried to please the casual crowd and the "hardcore" crowd while kinda leaving the potential crowd out to dry. What I want to see is a movie that finally caters to the "hardcore" crowd and the potential crowd and leaves the casual crowd out to dry. Having realistic-looking turtles would be a huge factor in accomplishing that goal as I'm sure many of you here would agree.

turtle83
08-07-2009, 08:26 PM
I agree with you on wanting realistic-looking turtles, Canadian Turtle, but I have to disagree with your assessment of the overall fanbase. The "hardcore" fanbase are the ones who want something new and more realistic. Most fans prefer the old cartoon and old movies. A lot of casual TMNT fans didn't like the 2007 movie because it was too dark and serious. They're the ones who want round-faced, goofy turtles.

The way I see it, there are really 3 groups of people the folks making the movie will have to take into account. There are the casual fans I described above who will only accept goofy, campy, fun turtles; they make up most of the TMNT fans in the world. Then there is the core fanbase like most of us here who prefer the comics, 2003 series, etc. and want a serious, realistic turtles movie with about as much humor as the comics had; this group is definitely a minority. But then we have the untapped potential fanbase; these are the people who have always had a passing interest in TMNT but they don't really become fans because of the goofy nature of the franchise and because they don't really read comics. I think this group could be huge, but we've never had a chance to find out because a movie has never been made that would cater to these people and the "hardcore" TMNT fanbase. You can't really please all three groups. The 2007 movie tried to please the casual crowd and the "hardcore" crowd while kinda leaving the potential crowd out to dry. What I want to see is a movie that finally caters to the "hardcore" crowd and the potential crowd and leaves the casual crowd out to dry. Having realistic-looking turtles would be a huge factor in accomplishing that goal as I'm sure many of you here would agree.


100% agreed

turtle83
08-07-2009, 08:41 PM
Personally I agree with this post. This is actually more what I was thinking. I would have to disagree with most of you in keeping the first movie look. For one thing they need to let go of the first movie, this is not a remake. Second if they want this movie to be realistic they are going to have to adjust the look. And third I would say a mass audience would appeal to a more badass looking Turtle now, because that is what they want to see. Take Hellboy for instance think in that realm of look. If the Turtles had a cameo on Hellboy what would they look like? I think that is where they should go, not to mention the company that did the Hellboy effects are geniuses and they should get them on this film for sure!

Children are not stupid, they will appeal to darker looking roll models, and this film is for a three generation audience I don't think the older audience wants to see pizza eating round faces smiley Turtles anymore, they want to see four ninja assassins trained for one deadly purpose, to avenge their father. Also you have to think outside the fandom. If everyone of us on the drome went to this movie they wouldn't make a cent back, the hardcore fans of this franchise make up a very small percentage of the overall potential fan base, so again people want to see something new.


The 1990 turtles WOULD NOT look out of place with Hellboy whatsoever (Well except maybe three of them:P). Take Michelangelo for example, I thought the fellas at Jim Henson's creature shop really took their time on his the overall facial design. His expressions were far more superior than Leo, Don, and Raph COMBINED.

Now imagine using that same face and mixing it with the most advance CGI.

You have major success right their.

Warhorse
08-08-2009, 12:36 AM
Yet that didn't stop the absolutely hideous looking Transformers from being a hit in their movies... which weren't very good movies to begin with, either.

But, I do think you're right. It's better to try and keep the Turtles' looks faithful rather than make them look too realistic (which in turn would make them look like monsters, even if that is what they are).

I wouldn't mind it if the Turtles looked more realistic, but I definitely wouldn't want them to go overboard with it like what happened in Bayformers.

Well, I beg to differ, I'm actually a huge fan of both movies and think the Transformers look fantastic, so, your POV is mute IMHO.

But you also have to look at it that the Transformers are robots, not creatures of flesh and blood, and to boot, we have already seen the Turtles on the big screen in both live action and in CGI. It's not going to be something new and never done before.

Not much of a fan of the second Transformers film, but you are right about the robots being a bit ugly. All of them are look bad EXCEPT bumblebee and Prime. They actually looked decent.

Funny, people are talking about the look of Sideswipe, and think he's the best looking Transformer of them all.

Personally I agree with this post. This is actually more what I was thinking. I would have to disagree with most of you in keeping the first movie look. For one thing they need to let go of the first movie, this is not a remake. Second if they want this movie to be realistic they are going to have to adjust the look. And third I would say a mass audience would appeal to a more badass looking Turtle now, because that is what they want to see. Take Hellboy for instance think in that realm of look. If the Turtles had a cameo on Hellboy what would they look like? I think that is where they should go, not to mention the company that did the Hellboy effects are geniuses and they should get them on this film for sure!

Children are not stupid, they will appeal to darker looking roll models, and this film is for a three generation audience I don't think the older audience wants to see pizza eating round faces smiley Turtles anymore, they want to see four ninja assassins trained for one deadly purpose, to avenge their father. Also you have to think outside the fandom. If everyone of us on the drome went to this movie they wouldn't make a cent back, the hardcore fans of this franchise make up a very small percentage of the overall potential fan base, so again people want to see something new.

There's a difference from bad ass looking to ugly ass looking, and trust me, about as much of the general audience will flock to see grotesque looking Turtles as the flocked to see the Toxic Avenger.

Also, I grew up on the cartoon, and while I'm all for realistic settings, but the heart of the Turtles for me was their humor, their fun personalities, their quirks. If they take all of that out and make this movie into some serious, dark, suicide gothic style crap, I don't think I'm going to watch it. If me, a TMNT fan of the cartoons and movies, a little of the comics, thinks this way, then I can assure you, I'm not the only one.

Like I said, keep their look between the CGI and the live action films. If I could pin point, I'd like to see characteristics of Leo like he is in the 2k3 toon, Donny like he is in the 2k3/2007 film, Mikey like he was in the 1990 film (best adaptation I've seen of him IMO) and Raph can be juggled up between his 1990 film, 2k3 and 2007 film counterparts.

TMNTD
08-10-2009, 12:21 PM
I agree with you on wanting realistic-looking turtles, Canadian Turtle, but I have to disagree with your assessment of the overall fanbase. The "hardcore" fanbase are the ones who want something new and more realistic. Most fans prefer the old cartoon and old movies. A lot of casual TMNT fans didn't like the 2007 movie because it was too dark and serious. They're the ones who want round-faced, goofy turtles.

The way I see it, there are really 3 groups of people the folks making the movie will have to take into account. There are the casual fans I described above who will only accept goofy, campy, fun turtles; they make up most of the TMNT fans in the world. Then there is the core fanbase like most of us here who prefer the comics, 2003 series, etc. and want a serious, realistic turtles movie with about as much humor as the comics had; this group is definitely a minority. But then we have the untapped potential fanbase; these are the people who have always had a passing interest in TMNT but they don't really become fans because of the goofy nature of the franchise and because they don't really read comics. I think this group could be huge, but we've never had a chance to find out because a movie has never been made that would cater to these people and the "hardcore" TMNT fanbase. You can't really please all three groups. The 2007 movie tried to please the casual crowd and the "hardcore" crowd while kinda leaving the potential crowd out to dry. What I want to see is a movie that finally caters to the "hardcore" crowd and the potential crowd and leaves the casual crowd out to dry. Having realistic-looking turtles would be a huge factor in accomplishing that goal as I'm sure many of you here would agree.

Since when did the 2007 " TMNT " movie become too dark and serious ? You're joking right ?

The Shelf
08-10-2009, 12:37 PM
Since when did the 2007 " TMNT " movie become too dark and serious ? You're joking right ?

Absolutely not. As I said, there are two main groups of turtle fans out there. Those that only like campy, goofy, fun turtles; and those that prefer the "dark and gritty" turtles. One group complained that the movie was too dark and serious while the other complained that it was too silly. That's why the movie didn't do very well. It tried to appeal to both audiences by offering something that each could like, but instead, each group just complained about the parts that didn't fit with what they liked.

TMNTD
08-10-2009, 12:50 PM
Ok, gotcha.

Cipher
08-10-2009, 01:14 PM
I honestly don't put much stock into the Turtles' designs. I've been exposed to so many varying styles through the comics that I'm game for anything. I could see a cartoonier design being chosen for relatability, and I could see a more realistic/ugly style to sell a reboot. I'll take skinny, agile Turtles, or hyper-muscular Turtles. It's all good. The only issue I really give a damn about is bandana color, and we already know that red will (sadly) be unlikely.

I will say that I'm not too fond of that "realistic" fanart that seems to have caught on recently. I don't see why everyone's freaking out about it. There have been much better realistic Turtles.

Absolutely not. As I said, there are two main groups of turtle fans out there. Those that only like campy, goofy, fun turtles; and those that prefer the "dark and gritty" turtles. One group complained that the movie was too dark and serious while the other complained that it was too silly. That's why the movie didn't do very well. It tried to appeal to both audiences by offering something that each could like, but instead, each group just complained about the parts that didn't fit with what they liked. I think that's a pretty succinct summary of the movie's failings. Tried to please everyone and, in doing so, ended up pleasing no one.

The Shelf
08-10-2009, 01:20 PM
I will say that I'm not too fond of that "realistic" fanart that seems to have caught on recently. I don't see why everyone's freaking out about it. There have been much better realistic Turtles.

I agree, but I can't seem to find any of the others. Please, do share, if you have some links handy. :)

Candy Kappa
08-10-2009, 03:15 PM
This is a cool looking style (http://aracubus.deviantart.com/art/turttle-power-102096723)
but it's a bit too much tortoise than turtle thought.

And they can't be too much realistic due to showing human emotion and being able to relate to them.

I think many people who don't like the idea of realistic turtles think about that.

they still have to have a fleshy snout rather then a hard beak to have facial expressions

The Stryker
08-10-2009, 03:42 PM
I think realistic looking turtles would be creepy as ****.

Turtles are not cute animals.

Candy Kappa
08-10-2009, 03:54 PM
Ain't he a cute Turtle (http://static-p4.fotolia.com/jpg/00/03/57/81/400_F_3578167_Ev00I7K6nK0iciWRD13De9N8ZMN3rXGv.jpg )

The Stryker
08-10-2009, 04:03 PM
Ain't he a cute Turtle (http://static-p4.fotolia.com/jpg/00/03/57/81/400_F_3578167_Ev00I7K6nK0iciWRD13De9N8ZMN3rXGv.jpg )

Ugh...

No.

ToTheNines
08-10-2009, 04:14 PM
http://www.hillcity-comics.com/graphic_novels_2007/new_graphic_novel8227.jpg

No.

Warhorse
08-10-2009, 04:16 PM
http://www.hillcity-comics.com/graphic_novels_2007/new_graphic_novel8227.jpg

No.

:oOMG:o, they look like something from the V TV show! That show creeped me the f**ck out when I was kid!

The Shelf
08-10-2009, 05:31 PM
Ugh...

No.

You're just saying that.

Canadian Turtle
08-11-2009, 10:41 AM
hahaha This is so great!

I love how diverse this franchise is! So many people are so specific when it comes to exact ideas and opinions and they feel so attached to the subject matter, this is what makes TMNT great!

As I love to stir the pot I threw out a very one sided and pointed opinion there. In actual fact I would lean more to 'Ciphers' opinion. I am just happy with what ever they come up with and that there will be a new Turtle movie!!! The kid in me would love to see the happy faces of movie 1 turtles, and DON'T get me wrong here, Turtles 1 is one of my all time favorite movies ever! From a purely film making perspective even. The action lover in me would say maybe the zulli turtles are a bit extreme, but I think you could still get a ton of emotion out of some pretty badass real looking Turtles and totally appeal to a broad audience of movie goers regardless of their history with the Turtles. Maybe one needs to dissociate a little bit when approaching this re-boot while still enjoying all the throw backs to what we loved about these stories as kids. I think regardless of the look or outcome what is important to these film makers is the heart of the Turtles story, that won't be lost.

I hope we can help shed some light on the story behind the 2007 movie in the up coming Turtle Doc. Scott talks at length about what went on behind that movie in our interviews. The overall feedback on that film is planted in a few different problems that are very common in the movie business. And yet how do you ever actually put a finger on what makes a movie good or bad?

The Stryker
08-11-2009, 12:29 PM
You're just saying that.

I know I'm saying that. Because turtles are ugly ass creatures.

Vincent
08-11-2009, 01:05 PM
What I'd suggest is a happy medium:
Realistic texture and detail, short and lean (but fit) TMNT07-ish bodytypes (with variations), slightly wide heads (but not so much that it's distracting), slight hint of pointed beaks (but not so much that they can't emote or lipsync), slightly varied skin tones.
Red masks, possibly introduce multicolored masks at the end just to shut people up (perhaps prompted by April's confusion over who's who).
But all this will be meaningless without a good script with good characterizations and character depth.

Cipher
08-12-2009, 06:02 PM
I hope we can help shed some light on the story behind the 2007 movie in the up coming Turtle Doc. Scott talks at length about what went on behind that movie in our interviews. The overall feedback on that film is planted in a few different problems that are very common in the movie business. And yet how do you ever actually put a finger on what makes a movie good or bad?Not to derail the topic, but I'm really looking foward to seeing something like that. I've always had the impression that there were a lot of conflicting mandates going on over the 2007 movie. It just feels...rushed and unsure in a way that no singular vision, no matter how good or bad, would create.

Leonardo15
08-16-2009, 06:45 PM
I found this while browsing the web, anyone here do this?

This is how realistic I'd like to see the new movie TMNT.
Too realistic would be ugly and creepy.

Don looks serious, but, not ugly. I hope the design for costumes would be something along like this mixed with Mirage TMNT looks.

http://saturdaymorningcentral.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/tmnt_wallpaper_thumb.jpg

Cure
08-16-2009, 08:13 PM
That's pretty cool.

Coola Yagami
08-16-2009, 08:53 PM
REAL mutant turtles would look more like Tokka than anything else... and I doubt the audience wants to see 4 Tokkas running around.

Cure
08-16-2009, 08:54 PM
REAL mutant turtles

My head hurts.

FearlessLeader
08-16-2009, 08:57 PM
REAL mutant turtles would look more like Tokka than anything else... and I doubt the audience wants to see 4 Tokkas running around.

Tokka was a completely different breed of Turtle then the guys though. Somehow I doubt they would look exactly the same mutated, anymore then a regular snapping turtle looks just like a red-eared slider.

TMNTD
08-16-2009, 11:38 PM
I found this while browsing the web, anyone here do this?

This is how realistic I'd like to see the new movie TMNT.
Too realistic would be ugly and creepy.

Don looks serious, but, not ugly. I hope the design for costumes would be something along like this mixed with Mirage TMNT looks.

http://saturdaymorningcentral.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/tmnt_wallpaper_thumb.jpg

Yeah, I can deal with that look. But to be honest, a realistic ugly and creepy TMNT would be interesting to see.

Andrew NDB
08-16-2009, 11:38 PM
I've always felt A.C. Farley's TMNT look would translate perfectly to screen.

http://www.ninjaturtles.com/order/posterac.jpg

http://www.ninjaturtles.com/comics/books/voltwo.jpg

http://www.ninjaturtles.com/comics/books/volsix.jpg

TMNTD
08-16-2009, 11:41 PM
I agree Andrew. After all, mutant turtles aren't suppose to be cute, and Farley's turtles are pretty ugly,but still retain just enough human qualities to not totally freak you out.

Andrew NDB
08-16-2009, 11:43 PM
I agree Andrew. After all, mutant turtles aren't suppose to be cute, and Farley's turtles are pretty ugly

I wouldn't call them ugly. I would even say they're more cutesy than the Eastman/Laird, or even the Lawson variety. But they look real... and they have these great big huge pupils that give their eyes/faces this strong look of wonder at times.

Canadian Turtle
08-17-2009, 08:38 AM
I wouldn't call them ugly. I would even say they're more cutesy than the Eastman/Laird, or even the Lawson variety. But they look real... and they have these great big huge pupils that give their eyes/faces this strong look of wonder at times.

Dude! Totally agreeing with that! Always loved his look! Also as a tid bit of cool fact Farley is one of the most gifted painters I've ever seen. There is an original painting That I have seen which is also a poster. His paint layering in that piece is so amazing that in the original if you fade the light falling on it the Turtles glow and the colors seem to come to life almost as if they were realy standing in that forest. If I am not mistaken I believe I have a shot of this occurrence, I hope it appears somewhere in the doc, if not it will be just another one of those cool little things that maybe I can share someday.

PS Its this one I am talking about:
http://www.ninjaturtles.com/comics/books/shellshock/cover.jpg

Cowabunga Carl
08-31-2009, 09:17 PM
I've really thought about this before posting. It is something that has made me stop and think as I've done a marathon of Turtles the last week. All the different looks really do help keep the worlds apart I've noticed. I think if this is a true reboot of the franchise and the first movie in a new line to come that the turtles should look different then they have before.

Now I'm not talking all super realistic though I can see the appeal. But I'm talking almost realistic. So as not to give the little ones nightmares. Because we wont get a bloody dark movie. It wont happen because Turtles has forever been launched into kiddies minds and hearts.

Dragon Turtle
09-01-2009, 12:58 AM
In terms of body type, I would like to see something along the lines such as this;

http://fichtenfoo.net/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/leo-paint-06.jpghttp://fichtenfoo.net/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/leo-paint-07.jpg


In terms of texture, it may not need to be as detailed as these sculpts however.

The Stryker
09-01-2009, 06:41 AM
That thing is disgusting looking.

Cipher
09-01-2009, 12:38 PM
That thing is disgusting looking.Of course. A humanoid Turtle would be nothing less than hideous.

The only thing I don't dig about that sculpture is the rippling muscle tone on the plastron. What the hell is that?

The Stryker
09-01-2009, 02:49 PM
Of course. A humanoid Turtle would be nothing less than hideous.

And I'm supposed to care about and root for something disgusting like that?

XERO
09-01-2009, 04:38 PM
They look like they came out of Resident Evil.

Lordmylar06
09-01-2009, 04:44 PM
Of course. A humanoid Turtle would be nothing less than hideous.

The only thing I don't dig about that sculpture is the rippling muscle tone on the plastron. What the hell is that?
I'm with Cipher on this. Fix the plastron (and crotch bulge) and I dig this design. It's hideous, but close to the look of a red eared slider.
edit: the face could look more friendly though.

Cipher
09-01-2009, 06:39 PM
And I'm supposed to care about and root for something disgusting like that?I don't know, I've always dug the tragic and surreal quality to the Turtles. That sort of design conveys both fairly well.

It's that whole Frankenstein's monster angle, you know?

Revan
09-01-2009, 06:50 PM
I absolutely love this.
http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/untitled-3.jpg

Dragon Turtle
09-01-2009, 09:03 PM
Of course. A humanoid Turtle would be nothing less than hideous.

The only thing I don't dig about that sculpture is the rippling muscle tone on the plastron. What the hell is that?


Much of the wrinkles and skin texture will probably be nixed in favor of something closer to the 2007 movie, which I would definitely not mind.

Here are a few more alternative colored versions.

http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y39/saul62/100_0101.jpghttp://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y39/saul62/100_0094_2.jpg

Here's another "realistic" take of the TMNT.

http://fc03.deviantart.com/fs24/f/2007/313/5/1/5194d7cb2155da6f.jpg

cartoonistaaron
09-01-2009, 09:38 PM
That last image is absolutely going to give me nightmares.

Cowabunga Carl
09-02-2009, 09:14 AM
http://fc03.deviantart.com/fs24/f/2007/313/5/1/5194d7cb2155da6f.jpg

I like this. I really hope that something like this will be what we get. I don't want a goofy look.

Doc_ock_4mugen
09-02-2009, 09:29 AM
I like that last one.

The Stryker
09-02-2009, 01:57 PM
Totally doesn't look like a kid with down syndrome forced to live in the sewer.

/Sarcasm

I really don't know what's wrong with the original movie designs. Why can't we just keep those?

Warhorse
09-02-2009, 06:23 PM
I really don't know what's wrong with the original movie designs. Why can't we just keep those?

Absolutely nothing. I prefer to keep the look that way. And while I was visioning something where the action sequences were CGI, the rest costumes, I suppose the technology has come a long way to make the suits easier to manuever in than they were in the past.

ToTheNines
09-02-2009, 08:16 PM
I printed that picture out just to wipe my ass with it.

Cure
09-02-2009, 09:51 PM
I printed that picture out just to wipe my ass with it.

That's one way to make it look better.

Buslady
09-02-2009, 10:27 PM
personally i want tmnt1 again...same looks voices and the creature shop...but i know im not getting that.

soooo....no

make it it's own, dont copy tmnt1

That's Bess's Leonardo art, personally I like the one she did of Raph:
http://fc08.deviantart.com/fs22/f/2007/315/b/8/b828695b22dde802.jpg
(before anyone says thats the lower edge of his plastron!)

Dragon Turtle
09-03-2009, 12:05 AM
I printed that picture out just to wipe my ass with it.

Heh, watch out for paper cuts.:)

Powder
09-03-2009, 05:01 AM
id really dig it if they went the route of making them somewhat ugly/disgusting.. if such a thing as tmnt were possible in real life id want the movie incarnation.. either that or a very very very similar look to that of the first movie

Doc_ock_4mugen
09-03-2009, 06:09 AM
I really don't know what's wrong with the original movie designs. Why can't we just keep those?

Because they're going for a reboot. Usually when there is one of those involved EVERYTHING CHANGES!
Look at Batman. When Tim Burton made the 89 flick he didn't use the established costume from the 60s movie. When Nolan took over he didn't use the designs from the previous movies. If the TMNT get a Reboot their style and appearance will change. Not saying that all changes are good (Batman forever/Batman and Robin had cringeworthy changes.) but they WILL come. It would be nice to have a slight channge on the Turtles. This "realistic" approach can redefine the turtles as no longer the campy kids adventure/comedy stigma from the past.

The Stryker
09-03-2009, 09:28 AM
Because they're going for a reboot. Usually when there is one of those involved EVERYTHING CHANGES!
Look at Batman. When Tim Burton made the 89 flick he didn't use the established costume from the 60s movie. When Nolan took over he didn't use the designs from the previous movies. If the TMNT get a Reboot their style and appearance will change. Not saying that all changes are good (Batman forever/Batman and Robin had cringeworthy changes.) but they WILL come. It would be nice to have a slight channge on the Turtles. This "realistic" approach can redefine the turtles as no longer the campy kids adventure/comedy stigma from the past.

Yeah, they'll change from lovable characters that people want to see to disgusting creatures that are unpleasant to look at.

That'll work.

Doc_ock_4mugen
09-03-2009, 12:01 PM
Yeah, they'll change from lovable characters that people want to see to disgusting creatures that are unpleasant to look at.

That'll work.

I didn't say that all changes are good. But since they're going for a "darker, gritty and edgy" TMNT maybe the Turtles should reflect that a bit in their physical appearance.
Part of the problem with the TMNT and the way the media sees them is because they look too lovable. Somehow Lovable = Kiddie (I don't know why but people associate cute things with children even if it isn't intended for kids... I love angry parents reacting to Happy Tree Friends.)

If the Turtles look too Adorable (like in the first film. I'm not saying that the designs suck.) they might influence the tone.
Also they can't go too hyper realistic mode (as realistic as one can go with antropomorphic turtles) because they'd look Too Ugly. The TMNT are freaks, they should look a little bit freaky, yet kinda adorable. Even Tokka and Rhazar looked Adorable... (well maybe Rhazar looked more adorable) and they're supposed to be the ugly disgusting creatures that are unpleasant to look at.

The Stryker
09-03-2009, 01:13 PM
I think being GIANT TALKING TURTLES is freakish enough.

Buslady
09-03-2009, 02:33 PM
I'm soooo holding back on defending one of my most treasured and favorite animals....but people have rights to express their opinions.

I like that Leo statue but it's got so many inaccuracies if it was going for realism. Tail's not long enough for a male, should have 5 fingers & 4 toes, no opposable thumb hehe...*shuts up* The shell looks more tortoise than streamlined water turtle too. *shuts up again* :P

Warhorse
09-03-2009, 07:51 PM
I didn't say that all changes are good. But since they're going for a "darker, gritty and edgy" TMNT maybe the Turtles should reflect that a bit in their physical appearance.
Part of the problem with the TMNT and the way the media sees them is because they look too lovable. Somehow Lovable = Kiddie (I don't know why but people associate cute things with children even if it isn't intended for kids... I love angry parents reacting to Happy Tree Friends.)

If the Turtles look too Adorable (like in the first film. I'm not saying that the designs suck.) they might influence the tone.
Also they can't go too hyper realistic mode (as realistic as one can go with antropomorphic turtles) because they'd look Too Ugly. The TMNT are freaks, they should look a little bit freaky, yet kinda adorable. Even Tokka and Rhazar looked Adorable... (well maybe Rhazar looked more adorable) and they're supposed to be the ugly disgusting creatures that are unpleasant to look at.

Damn, and I was hoping that maybe they can follow a similar arc that the 2k3 series did and put in some more of the totally cute Turtle tots.

Newton Gimmick
09-03-2009, 10:48 PM
I think we're going to get an improved version of the 90's designs. More details and stuff, but not like an actual turtle turned into a humanoid. The designs have NEVER looked like that in any form, so why would they start now?

Doc_ock_4mugen
09-04-2009, 07:44 AM
Well we never know what's on Hollywood's* mind
But the best design for the TMNT should be a middle ground between the "Hyper Realistic" Fan art and the classic design.


*=The suits invlved in said project

Cowabunga Carl
09-04-2009, 11:24 AM
You know maybe the best thing to do would just be to make them look like they did in the orginal comics. I mean think about it. They look like the idea of an upright turtle and seeing them be all bad ass would be amazing and not something the average movie goer would expect.

indy1936
09-06-2009, 02:14 AM
That last image is absolutely going to give me nightmares.

I was thinking the same thing before I saw your post. Looks like some sort of alien/sickly child/creature from hell. Where are the muscles? They look like emaciated people with turtle shells on. Totally creeping me out!

Warhorse
09-06-2009, 12:41 PM
You know maybe the best thing to do would just be to make them look like they did in the orginal comics. I mean think about it. They look like the idea of an upright turtle and seeing them be all bad ass would be amazing and not something the average movie goer would expect.

Nope. Their best bet is to keep a look like the live action films/2007 film. I showed some of the comic looks to some friends, and they didn't like them at all. They won't even watch the 2k3 toon because the Turtles don't have the pupils. I've tried repeatedly to get them to watch the show, but their simple response would be (when the animators go back and add pupils to their eyes, then we'll watch, until then, we're not interested) It's aggravating to see people irked by a such a simple thing, but sometimes, if we want a future with the Turtles, the producers and designers are going to have to keep a certain accepted familiarity with the look in order to keep the majority of fans interested. Due to the first cartoon and the first movie (the first movie did an excellent job of combining the core elements of the cartoon and the comics IMO) being the main thing that struck a fanship across the nation, you'd be surprised at how many people didn't like it that April wasn't a reporter.

ToTheNines
09-06-2009, 12:53 PM
Nope. Their best bet is to keep a look like the live action films/2007 film.

How can you group those two looks together?

Cowabunga Carl
09-09-2009, 08:42 AM
I had a friend who refussed to watch the 2003 toon too because they didn't look like the turtles he knew. Then he found his Dad watching them when he moved back home. Guess who called and told me I was right? Anyway people who are so closed minded that they can't except change really bother me. These are the same people who where getting up set that Joker would have makeup on instead of being permaclown. If you cling so hard to the past how is anything suppoused to get better?

Warhorse
09-12-2009, 12:49 AM
I had a friend who refussed to watch the 2003 toon too because they didn't look like the turtles he knew. Then he found his Dad watching them when he moved back home. Guess who called and told me I was right? Anyway people who are so closed minded that they can't except change really bother me. These are the same people who where getting up set that Joker would have makeup on instead of being permaclown. If you cling so hard to the past how is anything suppoused to get better?

Agree with you, but you're preaching to the choir here. I'm just seeing it from both sides of the aisle. Our boys in green are having a tough time as it is in securing a new fan base like they had in the late 80's/90's. I'd love to evolve the Turtles into the ideal scope eventually, but think we should take it a few steps at a time. First, is to get a more adult oriented Turtles on the big screen. This has been our biggest hurdle. We have seen what a good non kiddy Turtle film can do with the debut of the first live action film. It was a big hit, and to this day, a top favorite. After we get through this crap on how the studios want to market this film, then maybe they can then go for a different look for the Turtles.

Well, I'm getting my cousin to slowly turn around about her POV of the 2k3 show. She still b!tches nonstop about the no pupils, so I showed her The Christmas Aliens and The Golden Puck, and it seemed to get that edge off for her. She's now getting into the City at War arc. It would be nice to have a more drawn out characterization and proper introduction to Karai. Now that's a character that can have unlimited potential in the movie verse. Everyone likes their bad ass women in their films since Sigorney Weaver and Linda Hamilton had their debuts in Aliens and Terminator flicks.

The Stryker
09-12-2009, 01:11 AM
Ugh. No thanks. Karai has the potential for ONE uninteresting storyline. Just because she's a chick doesn't mean she'll just hit with everyone. She's such a cardboard cut-out of a character.

Also, Heath Joker is NOT better than the Real Joker.

Vivi
09-12-2009, 03:05 AM
I love the Lawson/original movie look of the turtles, even some aspects of the 2K7 design. That sculpt of Leo is pretty rad, too. But when they start looking too...I don't know, human, they just look weird and kill a bit of the suspension of disbelief. As if you can't help but see a person in costume more than a mutant turtle. (That, and they need beaks.)

Cure
09-12-2009, 04:43 PM
Everyone likes their bad ass women in their films since Sigorney Weaver and Linda Hamilton had their debuts in Aliens and Terminator flicks.

Uh...it's not just cuz they were women, you know. It's cuz they were interesting characters. Learn a thing or two.

Warhorse
09-12-2009, 05:22 PM
Uh...it's not just cuz they were women, you know. It's cuz they were interesting characters. Learn a thing or two.

You could learn a thing or two yourself, like reading between the lines. That's why I wrote she has potential to be an alternate villain for the Turtles without the Shredder while still maintaining a plot for The Foot.

The Stryker
09-12-2009, 06:21 PM
Because that worked so well in the last movie afterall.

Cipher
09-12-2009, 07:09 PM
Because that worked so well in the last movie afterall.That's because the last movie used her in a sh*tty way. She basically had a serious of quick cameos.

But I'm basically with Stryker on Karai as a main villain. She shouldn't be. She's only worked really well in the comics where she's a peripheral character, and even then only especially well in "City at War."

Coola Yagami
09-12-2009, 10:13 PM
Karai needed more explanation, a deadly one-on-one fight against Leo yelling out stuff like 'YOU KILLED OUR MASTER!!! NOW YOU DIE!!!'

C'mon, in the movie she was hired to capture the monsters... then when the Generals were there, they were better at it, so the Foot took a backseat. It's like when Karai asked 'so, then what do we do?', Winters should have answered '"Nothing, but stick around so that there's still something remotely resembling a TMNT-related plot in this movie.

I swear they could have used Shredder in the exact same way and somehow gotten away with it cause he was more well-knwon.. It was horrible. It didn't even had to waste an awesome character like Karai, if they were gonna use the Foot as some random throwaway thing, they should have just had random nameless Foot Elite or whatever.

Cure
09-12-2009, 10:23 PM
You could learn a thing or two yourself, like reading between the lines. That's why I wrote she has potential to be an alternate villain for the Turtles without the Shredder while still maintaining a plot for The Foot.

I didn't even say anything about Karai. I mean not everyone likes kickass women just cuz they're kickass women. If that was the case, Chun-Li woulda been a smash.

Warhorse
09-13-2009, 12:34 PM
Because that worked so well in the last movie afterall.

That's why I also wrote that she could have unlimited potential with a proper introduction!

I didn't even say anything about Karai. I mean not everyone likes kickass women just cuz they're kickass women. If that was the case, Chun-Li woulda been a smash.

Well, when you stated about "interesting characters" I thought you implied that Karai was not an interesting character. She started interesting, but then she just got boring. I just think that with a proper introduction and some key fleshing out, she could be a thrilling addition to the TMNT cast of live action movie characters.

And no, people didn't care for Chun-Li, but they do like Lady Death Strike, Mystique, Ripley, Vasquez, Sarah Connor, Eowyn, Selene, Lara Croft, Yu Shu Lien , Jen Yu, Beatrix Kiddo, Miho, and as corny as it sounds, multiple tough girl characters played by Milla Jovovich. Perhaps Karai could be perceived as one of the latter bad ass women.

Kendamu
09-14-2009, 12:53 AM
Also, Heath Joker is NOT better than the Real Joker.

You're right. Despite Heath's unforgettable performance in The Dark Knight, Mark Hamill is better than Heath Ledger.

The Stryker
09-14-2009, 01:25 AM
And no, people didn't care for Chun-Li, but they do like Lady Death Strike, Mystique, Ripley, Vasquez, Sarah Connor, Eowyn, Selene, Lara Croft, Yu Shu Lien , Jen Yu, Beatrix Kiddo, Miho, and as corny as it sounds, multiple tough girl characters played by Milla Jovovich. Perhaps Karai could be perceived as one of the latter bad ass women.

Nobody cares about Lady DeathStrike and Mystique. Who the hell are the other people on that list?

Spitfire
09-14-2009, 03:40 AM
Who the hell are the other people on that list?

You don't know who Ripley and Sarah Connor are? Quite possibly the most iconic female characters. Sigourney Weaver won an Oscar for best actress for Aliens. James Cameron knows how to make'em that's for sure.

The Stryker
09-14-2009, 04:38 AM
I know those. I was more referring to the crazy names.

Brodie
09-14-2009, 09:44 AM
Who the HELL cares about Miho?


When you say "people care about..." who the hell did you poll? Maybe 3 of those characters are interesting enough to hold people's attention in more than one movie/installment/game. (Ripley, Sarah Connor, Lara Croft-game version-)

Coola Yagami
09-14-2009, 09:24 PM
Another thing is the times. Back then the TMNT were AWESOME. So even if they made a crappy movie, the idea of a live-action movie with the TMNT and Shredder fighting it out would have made it big no matter what.

Nowadays it's alot tougher to do that. Hate to say it, but maybe TMNT would have made it if they did have Shredder in it, or at least expand Karai and the Foot more instead of making them something of an after-thought.

turtle83
09-16-2009, 10:43 PM
Never knew my thread would get so many responses!

shuriken
09-17-2009, 03:40 PM
Another thing is the times. Back then the TMNT were AWESOME. So even if they made a crappy movie, the idea of a live-action movie with the TMNT and Shredder fighting it out would have made it big no matter what.

Nowadays it's alot tougher to do that. Hate to say it, but maybe TMNT would have made it if they did have Shredder in it, or at least expand Karai and the Foot more instead of making them something of an after-thought.

I agreee. If they put clips of the TMNT vs Shredder in their tralier, THAT would generate some interest in the movie.
Karai and the Foot should have been the villains of the last movie. But they were just thrown aside and for what? Four stones, an immortal and 13 monsters. Which sounds pretty cool, but once you see it you're like wtf?
I think there should be some middle ground in terms of the TMNT looking like they did in the comics and how they did in the 1990 movie.

Coola Yagami
09-17-2009, 06:27 PM
karai and the foot should have been the villains of the last movie. But they were just thrown aside and for what? Four stones, an immortal and 13 monsters.


exactly!!!!!!!

CJStyles
09-25-2009, 10:24 PM
Also, Heath Joker is NOT better than the Real Joker.

Sorry to get off topic



BUUUUUUUTTTTTTTTT


Seriously?! Heath Ledger was ****in' brilliant at the Joker. The end all be all Joker in my honest to blog opinion.


Back on topic now....


I'd much rather see AC's version of the turtles on the big screen

The Stryker
09-29-2009, 04:48 PM
Sorry to get off topic



BUUUUUUUTTTTTTTTT


Seriously?! Heath Ledger was ****in' brilliant at the Joker. The end all be all Joker in my honest to blog opinion.

He would've been a good joker if he actually played the Joker in the damn movie and wasn't a rip from Clockwork Orange.

Best to stay on topic here. PM if you really want to argue.

louiebling$
12-10-2009, 01:52 AM
Honestly, I wouldn't mind them taking on this look (http://nebezial.deviantart.com/art/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-121465691).
I would totally like to see this in live action... especially Raph... he looks BADASS

Also that pic has been my wallpaper for a while now :thumbsup:

Oculus Orbus
12-10-2009, 03:52 AM
I would love them to look like in the first comic. For me, that's the best look they have ever had in any of their incarnations. I really like how they were in the first movie too, but I guess that would seem too cartoony this days if the film is meant to bee dark. So I would go for a realistic look based on the first comic. With realistic I don't mean horrible creepy monsters, just maybe some tiny textures in their skin, and that kind of things. And I would love them to be short.

I've said the same thing in other threads, but also I feel like the best way to make them is like what they've done with "Where the Wild Things Are", mixing costumes with CGI to animate their faces. This way, they would look alive and real at the same time. I really don't like CGI characters in live action movies, they never seem to truly be inside the film, and become old too quickly.

jaymq
12-10-2009, 08:03 AM
....So, you guys pick out the most butt ass ugly turtles you can find and expect the movie to do well... lol. Nothing against the artists, they're well done for the style, but I'd never wanna see it on something official unless it was intended to be obscure.

Seriously. You want a movie to do well, you can't be up and changing the look to extremities . Just no. They're gonna have to stick to the same theme they've had for animated (or animatronics in some cases) turtles that they've had all these years.

Koi
12-10-2009, 08:35 AM
I really don't care for what they create as long as they have moremuscle then the CGI.... I prefer my turtles burley.
I wouldn't mind a realistic look, ugly or not it still would look good on the big screen and probably create new genre of fans.

ryukenden
12-10-2009, 04:33 PM
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.

As long as they emphasize on the "Ninja" part. Show more abilities as "Turtles" such as using water as an advantage. "Teenage" and "Mutant" have already been greatly explored and I can't think of anything else than what has already been shown over the years.

Dejablue
12-10-2009, 05:16 PM
Some of you have lost me with this more realistic thing. I mean the images I've seen aren't realistic at all. Realistic would be like taking that turtle from Finding Nemo, make his eyes look less pixar-ish, putting him in a bandana and giving him a katana.

Besides the Turtles didn't look realistic in the comic book. So how does hyper realism equate to hardcore fans? Wouldn't you want them to look how they do in the comic? And I know CG has gotten much better but I can't help but wonder that if you try and push it too far you might end up with 4 green trolls instead of 4 green turtles. There's gotta be a middle ground in there somewhere though.

Luzmagica
12-11-2009, 04:52 AM
Some of you have lost me with this more realistic thing. I mean the images I've seen aren't realistic at all. Realistic would be like taking that turtle from Finding Nemo, make his eyes look less pixar-ish, putting him in a bandana and giving him a katana.

Besides the Turtles didn't look realistic in the comic book. So how does hyper realism equate to hardcore fans? Wouldn't you want them to look how they do in the comic? And I know CG has gotten much better but I can't help but wonder that if you try and push it too far you might end up with 4 green trolls instead of 4 green turtles. There's gotta be a middle ground in there somewhere though.


Yes...Im agree with that! ...just "the middle ground" is what we like to talk/argue about!!!! ;)

Newton Gimmick
12-11-2009, 04:37 PM
They shouldn't look anymore realistic than they've always looked. Too much "turtle" detail and it'll turn people off.

Dejablue
12-11-2009, 04:54 PM
In terms of body type, I would like to see something along the lines such as this;

http://fichtenfoo.net/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/leo-paint-06.jpghttp://fichtenfoo.net/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/leo-paint-07.jpg


In terms of texture, it may not need to be as detailed as these sculpts however.


I could actually deal with this if not for the weird ripple effect on the plastron. I don't think there should be any muscle tone under that part. Also I wish he had EYES!

Oculus Orbus
12-11-2009, 06:26 PM
I love the sculpture for itself, but I would hate to see something like that in the film. They looked awesome in the first comic. Take that and a little texture, and they'll look amazing in real life.

Captain
12-12-2009, 01:15 AM
Now thats cool!! Who made that?

jalexbrown
03-08-2010, 10:48 PM
I hate to sound hyper-critical, but I think anyone who is that worried about how they're going to look is missing the big picture. I'm much more concerned with how they act and what story they're given than how they look.

Koi
04-16-2010, 09:54 PM
I would like clothing on them. They are super creepers! They wear just a stinking trench coat which makes them look like a flasher. People are running away from the turtles for a reason, and it is not their looks.