PDA

View Full Version : Who is to blame for the TMNT 2k3 & Turtles Forever DVD debacle?


Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
10-08-2009, 09:10 PM
It really pisses me off that so far we still waiting on an official complete 3rd & 4th season releases of 2k3 as well as Turtles Forever on DVD. So who is the real culprit behind all of this? Who is to blame? Let's look at who we got.

1. Mirage Studios
2. 4kids Entertainment
3. Funimation Entertainment
4. Playmates

Discuss!!!

Warhorse
10-08-2009, 09:33 PM
I guess I'm going to go with Mirage. They are the core managers of the property, and hold a particular responsibility to the franchise, including going over contracts with a fine tooth comb, and make damn sure they have an indefinite say in what happens to the handling of the property.

Roseangelo
10-08-2009, 09:35 PM
The real cause for these "woes" is simply that the TMNT aren't particularly relevant at present and they don't bring the sales to warrant the costs of releasing DVDs. Who's responsible for that? There's a handful of people you could put partial blame on for seriously being asleep at the wheel and letting that happen, but you also can't force the public to like/love something no matter how much it deserves it. If the money isn't there, it's gonna go away. Simple as that. It's no different than TV shows that get canceled before their time, and I've loved many of such TV shows.

4Kids should actually get a lot of credit from all of you for following through on the production of Turtles Forever even though they knew these issues were going to exist. It's probably the one and only worthwhile thing that has come out of the 25th anniversary. Although it would be nice for it to actually come out... (IMO there's zero excuse for the theater deal falling through.)

Jester
10-08-2009, 09:46 PM
It was me...sorry guy I totally dropped the ball on this one.

Coola Yagami
10-08-2009, 10:15 PM
It was me...sorry guy I totally dropped the ball on this one.

IT'S THE FOOT I TELL YAS!!!! THE FOOT!!!! THE FOOOOOOOT!!!! The Turtles killed Shredder, but WE have to pay for it.... *cries*

XERO
10-08-2009, 11:07 PM
Blame it on the Goose (goose)
Got you feeling loose (loose)
Blame it on Petron ('tron)
Got you in the zone (zone)
Blame it on the a-a-a-a-a-alcohol
Blame it on the a-a-a-a-a-alcohol
Blame it on the Vodka
Blame it on the Henny
Blame it on the Blue Tap
Gotcha feeling dizzy
Blame it on the a-a-a-a-a-alcohol
Blame it on the alcohol (fades)

FlawedCoil82
10-09-2009, 12:58 AM
For right now, I am putting blame on Funimation. If they were still supporting TMNT, I have a pretty good feeling that they would have continued with the season sets or at very least been a distributor for the Turtles Forever movie. Without them though (or another distributor), the franchise is pretty helpless. As I said in the other thread, I also blame some of the fans for not buying the season releases or bothering enough to hunt them down online and pay the more than reasonable price for such an excellent cartoon in the format that it should have been released in from the start. But if Funimation was still in the game, then none of these current problems would be existing right now. So by all means, if someone happens to live by the Funimation headquarters office, be sure to soap all their windows extra good this coming Halloween. ;)
Jack

gobo
10-09-2009, 01:26 AM
This should be in forum games. I used to play it all the time... until I decided against becoming a lawyer. I have my theories as far as an answer, but my lips are sealed until we see that DVD release.

Candy Kappa
10-09-2009, 04:05 AM
It was me...sorry guy I totally dropped the ball on this one.

you evil puppy

Spitfire
10-09-2009, 05:30 AM
Mirage has had quality issues for awhile now. They never asserted themselves enough. All the trades are low print and a lot of them have messed up pages, which seriously pisses me off. Most stores don't even carry the comics anymore. The main reason for that is people hate the artwork.

They had many chances to bring interest back to turtles. As odd as it sounds Smash Up was a chance. Either Ubi lied about letting Mirage pick the roster or Mirage just picked a bad one. Either way a good game would have brought attention back to turtles. The toon was doing well till they decided to listen to the fans and re-format it again. BTTS was 4Kids not knowing what to do most likely because Mirage pushed for a re-format most likely due to comments on this very forum among other places. That ran the series into the ground.

Shall I get started on the toys? Playmates ran every line they had into the ground re-hashing the horrid movie figures that no one liked. They also had a nasty habit of not releasing the few figures they had to offer we did want. Now you're lucky to find turtles in the toy aisle at all. NECA started a great thing but also pissed people off by dropping the ball and not releasing the second wave featuring fan favorites everyone wanted.

So now turtles is associated with crap. Bad video game series, horrible kiddie TV series, sloppy marketing, crap toy line, and a comic with what most people consider to be poor artwork. This is general public opinion and other companies don't want to take the risks. Turtles last chance is this new movie.

This saddens me but I've come to accept the truth. So to answer your question it's everyone's fault, including us fans for being too nit picky and whiny.

odupianist
10-09-2009, 07:50 AM
Why isn't Fathom on the list? They are the jerks who set up the page, advertised it, and then pulled it with no explanation. I blame them. Mirage is on the bottom of my list of finger pointing. I would blame Fathom first, then Funimation and 4Kids at the same time, then Playmates just for being shitheads with their toy lines, then Mirage maybe just to keep going with my villianous rampage. Then I'd find all 13 monsters and send them back to their own dimension. I'd probably go after Jester since he's taking blame too lol.

X
10-09-2009, 08:51 AM
The real cause for these "woes" is simply that the TMNT aren't particularly relevant at present and they don't bring the sales to warrant the costs of releasing DVDs. Who's responsible for that? There's a handful of people you could put partial blame on for seriously being asleep at the wheel and letting that happen, but you also can't force the public to like/love something no matter how much it deserves it. If the money isn't there, it's gonna go away. Simple as that. It's no different than TV shows that get canceled before their time, and I've loved many of such TV shows.

4Kids should actually get a lot of credit from all of you for following through on the production of Turtles Forever even though they knew these issues were going to exist. It's probably the one and only worthwhile thing that has come out of the 25th anniversary. Although it would be nice for it to actually come out... (IMO there's zero excuse for the theater deal falling through.)

If that were the case, I guess Lionsgate would've stopped releasing the OT on DVD, because sales of those should be worse than 2K3 right?

Just yesterday I saw a 5-6 year old boy ask his mom for TMNT S8... Why would he want that one if he wasn't even alive then? You'd thought he'd know more about 2K3 than the old cartoon.

I would blame everyone holding a piece of the pie... They could find a way to get it to people if they really wanted. Maybe they aren't trying hard enough.

Roseangelo
10-09-2009, 12:18 PM
Either way a good game would have brought attention back to turtles. The toon was doing well till they decided to listen to the fans and re-format it again. BTTS was 4Kids not knowing what to do most likely because Mirage pushed for a re-format most likely due to comments on this very forum among other places. That ran the series into the ground.

Fast Forward was canceled because of Playmates, who pulled their third of the funding because of low toy sales. Nothing less, nothing more than that.

This saddens me but I've come to accept the truth. So to answer your question it's everyone's fault, including us fans for being too nit picky and whiny.

I wholly disagree. Mirage and 4Kids (and Playmates) may not be that bright, but it's been made clear time and time again that fans do not have that much pull.

If that were the case, I guess Lionsgate would've stopped releasing the OT on DVD, because sales of those should be worse than 2K3 right?

I don't think there are any grounds for that assumption.

Just yesterday I saw a 5-6 year old boy ask his mom for TMNT S8... Why would he want that one if he wasn't even alive then? You'd thought he'd know more about 2K3 than the old cartoon.

The kid probably just saw Ninja Turtles and wanted Ninja Turtles.

Coola Yagami
10-09-2009, 12:40 PM
Wonder how disappointed the kid was when he finds out it's not the 2K3/Fast Forward/BTTS Turtles.

Sword Slicin' Leo
10-09-2009, 01:43 PM
Honestly it does'nt matter who is to blame.. All that matters is we, the fans (longtime most of us) are getting fu**ed over.. This kind of stuff makes me want to never buy their products again....

Spitfire
10-09-2009, 01:57 PM
Fast Forward was canceled because of Playmates, who pulled their third of the funding because of low toy sales. Nothing less, nothing more than that.
I find that a tad hard to believe. If Playmates was interested in toy sales they'd have actually released toys for BTTS. The ones they did were more like movie figures and I think only the turtles came out. I never saw them once in stores. Plus when FF got canned they were still in the middle of whoring their movie figures. Maybe that's the "official" statement but I don't buy it. I'm gonna turn into that conspiracy theory guy. :lol:


I wholly disagree. Mirage and 4Kids (and Playmates) may not be that bright, but it's been made clear time and time again that fans do not have that much pull.
No we don't have any pull really. The power we seem to have however is making the creators feel extremely unappreciated. There's zero motivation to work on something when your core fan base thinks the products are crap. People, myself included unfortunately, have said some very mean things about some of the Mirage crew.

Master Splinter
10-09-2009, 02:09 PM
Wonder how disappointed the kid was when he finds out it's not the 2K3/Fast Forward/BTTS Turtles.

My nephew is 4 so he obviously wasn't around when the original toons aired but I can guareentee he has seen almost all of the DVDs multiple times because his Uncle Missouri Mobile loves the Turtles and sits and watches them with him whenever there is a chance... So the youngsters do know about the OT...

And as to who is to blame about the debacle, I wouldn't blame anyone for a couple of reasons...

1) The DVDs as far as I know haven't even been announced so without announcing a release there shouldn't be a blame that someone dropped the ball... There are several TV shows that have been off the air for years that still haven't made their way to DVD yet...

2) Turtles Forever, yes someone did jump ship and post a bunch of information that hyped a lot of people up and then squashed our hopes and dreams... Fact of the matter is though just like what I said above there isn't any official announcements for a DVD release yet so why blame someone? If I used your thinking I would be blaming Tarantino for not releasing Inglorious Basterds on DVD yet... It's already been in theaters so why isn't it on DVD yet? What about season 3 of The Big Bang Theory, the season just started so filming must be complete, why does it have to be shown on T.V. why can't I just have a DVD?

I do agree that these shows/movies should be released quickly and be in my possession shortly after :lol:, but I am not going to blame someone because they are not on DVD yet... That's just not being a good fan... Upset yes... Throw some blame around, no...

Just sayin...

-mm

ToTheNines
10-09-2009, 02:10 PM
The ones they did were more like movie figures and I think only the turtles came out. I never saw them once in stores.

That's why they had to make the characters look more like the movie versions in BttS.

1) The DVDs as far as I know haven't even been announced so without announcing a release there shouldn't be a blame that someone dropped the ball... There are several TV shows that have been off the air for years that still haven't made their way to DVD yet...

2) Turtles Forever, yes someone did jump ship and post a bunch of information that hyped a lot of people up and then squashed our hopes and dreams... Fact of the matter is though just like what I said above there isn't any official announcements for a DVD release yet so why blame someone? If I used your thinking I would be blaming Tarantino for not releasing Inglorious Basterds on DVD yet... It's already been in theaters so why isn't it on DVD yet? What about season 3 of The Big Bang Theory, the season just started so filming must be complete, why does it have to be shown on T.V. why can't I just have a DVD?

1) We know that they've been looking for a dist. and just can't find one. It's not like the distributor is just waiting till the time is right.

2) Awful comparison... it's called Direct to Video for a reason.

Roseangelo
10-09-2009, 03:18 PM
I find that a tad hard to believe.

Whether you wish to believe it or not, that's what happened. Beyond that, Playmates doesn't really have a track record of being logical.

Archon_Turtle
10-09-2009, 03:52 PM
No we don't have any pull really. The power we seem to have however is making the creators feel extremely unappreciated. There's zero motivation to work on something when your core fan base thinks the products are crap. People, myself included unfortunately, have said some very mean things about some of the Mirage crew.

Quoted for ****ing truth.

Master Splinter
10-09-2009, 05:35 PM
2) Awful comparison... it's called Direct to Video for a reason.

A direct to video that is trying to be released in theaters and shown on television before being released? Doesn't sound too direct...

I'm just saying why blame someone? Why b**** about DVD releases, movie debacles, lame toys, false promises, etc... Take a big deep breath and just be thankful TMNT even exists! If someone has issues with the companies involved buy some stock and/or write up a resume and send it in... Better yet write to the Better Business Bureau about how 4Kids won't sell you season 6 of TMNT....

These are the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles we are talking about, no matter what incarnation they get into, Fast Forward, BTTS Toys, etc, they are gonna be four green ninja fighting machines who are just plain ol'awesome! Who cares if it takes forever for something to be released, your life won't improve complaining about it...

But I must say I also think that people have the right to be upset. Denying that fact would be ludicrous. The Turtles Forever cancellation was a big let down for a lot of people and people are going to be upset, and everyone has a right to express their emotion...

I guess to put it simply it's one thing to be upset but it's completely different when ya start burning people at the stake.

However, this is the Internet...:ohwell:
My comments and thoughts can only be construed through text and interpretation, so if you (by you I mean whoever reads this), feel like I am trying to argue, I'm not... I'm the cheerleader saying "Go! Team! Go!" when it's 4th and 30 in the 4th with 2 seconds on the clock and your down by 7...

Enjoy ya'self...

-mm

Archon_Turtle
10-09-2009, 07:28 PM
I'm just saying why blame someone? Why b**** about DVD releases, movie debacles, lame toys, false promises, etc...

For some of these people that is like asking, "Why is the sky blue?"

Cipher
10-09-2009, 07:43 PM
The fact that this thread exists is kind of appalling.

Dragon Turtle
10-10-2009, 12:08 AM
The real cause for these "woes" is simply that the TMNT aren't particularly relevant at present and they don't bring the sales to warrant the costs of releasing DVDs. Who's responsible for that? There's a handful of people you could put partial blame on for seriously being asleep at the wheel and letting that happen, but you also can't force the public to like/love something no matter how much it deserves it. If the money isn't there, it's gonna go away. Simple as that. It's no different than TV shows that get canceled before their time, and I've loved many of such TV shows.


Funimation's poor handling of the season sets shouldn't be left out of the equation either, no marketing and odd release schedules are not keys for success.

ToTheNines
10-10-2009, 10:44 AM
A direct to video that is trying to be released in theaters and shown on television before being released? Doesn't sound too direct...

They're doing extra stuff for it on the way, but it's still a DTV.