PDA

View Full Version : Mirage still allowed to publish TMNT comics


Andrew NDB
10-22-2009, 10:57 AM
Sounds like they're still allowed to publish up to 18 TMNT comics a year. Though only Volume 4 is on the table, apparently... and Mirage is still closing its doors as an employer on December 31st.

Roseangelo
10-22-2009, 11:00 AM
...Source?

CyberCubed
10-22-2009, 11:00 AM
Well this is good news, but for how long will Viacom remain friendly with Mirage before they sever all ties?

I see this as merely an act of good faith, but I doubt it'll last as we get a few years into Nick's owning of the franchise.

Now that Peter is no longer running the franchise, he can now concentrate on finished Volume 4. Hopefully.

Andrew NDB
10-22-2009, 11:04 AM
...Source?

His name rhymes with "Pan."

Well this is good news, but for how long will Viacom remain friendly with Mirage before they sever all ties?

If it was part of the contract then they don't have the luxury of severing that tie.

I see this as merely an act of good faith, but I doubt it'll last as we get a few years into Nick's owning of the franchise.

Again, if it was part of the contractual deal between Mirage and Nick then Nick has no choice but to honor it -- they can't just decide to renege on a contractual agreement on a whim one day.

But it all seems a little moot. Who's going to publish the 18 comics a year at Mirage if no one works there anymore after December?

Archon_Turtle
10-22-2009, 12:03 PM
But it all seems a little moot. Who's going to publish the 18 comics a year at Mirage if no one works there anymore after December?

Well in all fairness, the artists are allowed to keep their office space as Pete owns the Mirage building, and Pete is encouraging them to continue to work together. He will probably freelance them all like he does certain artists currently like Steve Lavigne. Thats my guess anyway.

Kendamu
10-22-2009, 12:04 PM
I'm seeing 17 re-prints and one new issue of Vol. 4 per year. :P

Buffy
10-22-2009, 01:01 PM
I wrote to Jim Lawson this morning and he also said that Peter can publish up to 18 TMNT issues a year.
I think it's good news: now we might be able to see the end of volume 4 and even the forever war.

Cipher
10-22-2009, 01:04 PM
Ideal scenario: This gives Pete a chance to finish up Volume 4 and give the series a complete ending. (Oh man, please give it a real ending.)

After that, I'd really like to see Nick or a farmed-out company handle reprints and trades, since Mirage has consistantly dropped the ball with that.

ToTheNines
10-22-2009, 01:08 PM
Yes!

So this means volume 4 can get finished, and leaves room for the Forever War (if Stean Murphian wants to) and maybe few issues of Tales per year.

CyberCubed
10-22-2009, 01:30 PM
Dan said that Tales is definitely ending at #70 in May 2010.

Tales is canceled, but at least we got 70 issues and 4 mini-series out of the deal.

Dragon Turtle
10-22-2009, 01:31 PM
But it all seems a little moot. Who's going to publish the 18 comics a year at Mirage if no one works there anymore after December?

I believe Laird may have the right to have another comic book company publish new TMNT books.

Andrew NDB
10-22-2009, 01:32 PM
I believe Laird may have the right to have another comic book company publish new TMNT books.

That doesn't seem to be the case at all.

PAAATE
10-22-2009, 01:37 PM
Any word on how long he will have these rights?

This could just mean a future vol. 5 in a few years

Like... why not?

But after vol.4 is finished of course

I like this :):):)

***First of Two Latin Kings***
10-22-2009, 01:58 PM
I just stumbled across this thread and have NO frickin' clue what you guys are talking about. Pete did what? Mirage is now limited on how many TMNT books they can put out a year?

Andrew NDB
10-22-2009, 02:04 PM
Any word on how long he will have these rights?

Indefinitely.

Kendamu
10-22-2009, 02:35 PM
I just stumbled across this thread and have NO frickin' clue what you guys are talking about. Pete did what? Mirage is now limited on how many TMNT books they can put out a year?
Does Mirage even normally put out 18 or more TMNT books in a year?

CyberCubed
10-22-2009, 02:54 PM
Does Mirage even normally put out 18 or more TMNT books in a year?

12 issues of Tales and a few specials (like the Don mini-series) means yes.

But Tales is ending as are the specials. All that's left is Volume 4.

gobo
10-22-2009, 03:37 PM
I believe Laird may have the right to have another comic book company publish new TMNT books.
That doesn't seem to be the case at all.
So, Mirage is closing as an employer, but Pete will still publish 18 issues a year WITHOUT ANY HELP? I don't think so. This is making no sense to me as it seems people are contradicting one another here.

Vegita-San
10-22-2009, 03:41 PM
Especially when tristan announced on his facebook that the mirage universe source book is now canceled.

That makes even less sense to me. Why The F would you tell a guy to start putting time and effort into something only to yank it out from him a week or two later?

I know I don't know how things work over there, but from a purely outsider perspective... It's amazing Mirage lasted this long

oldmanwinters
10-22-2009, 03:50 PM
I wrote to Jim Lawson this morning and he also said that Peter can publish up to 18 TMNT issues a year.
I think it's good news: now we might be able to see the end of volume 4 and even the forever war.

Well, at least there is still hope for Forever War. :) That was actually the first thing that went through my mind when I heard the franchise got sold.

Still, I'll only believe it when I see it, if you know what I mean.:roll:

Lieutenant Granitor
10-22-2009, 03:52 PM
I personally think Nick will help sell comics! They can make soooo much money of it! All they need to do is commercial! There are millions of people watching Nick every second! Comics can become EXTREAMLY POPULAR!

The Stryker
10-22-2009, 03:55 PM
Gotta love all these stories without any source listed.

Roseangelo
10-22-2009, 04:00 PM
If anyone cares to read, I've gathered all the questions and answers I've been able to get into a single blog post @ Ninja Pizza (http://ninja-pizza.blogspot.com/2009/10/what-happens-now-questions-and-some.html).

Gotta love all these stories without any source listed.

I have sources for everything at the above link.

Lieutenant Granitor
10-22-2009, 04:08 PM
If anyone cares to read, I've gathered all the questions and answers I've been able to get into a single blog post @ Ninja Pizza (http://ninja-pizza.blogspot.com/2009/10/what-happens-now-questions-and-some.html).



I have sources for everything at the above link.
Just copy and paste me the quate from that! I'm too lazy to find answers!:sleep:

Andrew NDB
10-22-2009, 04:09 PM
So, Mirage is closing as an employer, but Pete will still publish 18 issues a year WITHOUT ANY HELP? I don't think so. This is making no sense to me as it seems people are contradicting one another here.

It's fairly simple.

The facts:

* Mirage is contactually able to independently publish 18 issues of TMNT material up to 48 pages an issue during any calendar year going forward without having to get Nickelodeon's blessing or approval.

* Mirage is not currently planning to publish any TMNT comics beyond the completion of Tales of the TMNT V2 in May of 2010. That can change, but right now there's nothing else in the pipes.

* Mirage will cease being an employer on December 31st of this year. The Mirage staff will stay aboard until May as independent contractors. If they want to publish any comics after then (beyond the end of Tales in May) they would need to rehire or contract new staff.

* TMNT Volume 4 may continue. Or it may not. No one is sure, even Peter himself. Though this could change, it is currently the only project being talked about at all as being potentially published beyond the end of Tales of the TMNT V2.

Lieutenant Granitor
10-22-2009, 04:15 PM
It's fairly simple.

The facts:

* Mirage is contactually able to independently publish 18 issues of TMNT material up to 48 pages an issue during any calendar year going forward without having to get Nickelodeon's blessing or approval.

* Mirage is not currently planning to publish any TMNT comics beyond the completion of Tales of the TMNT V2 in May of 2010. That can change, but right now there's nothing else in the pipes.

* Mirage will cease being an employer on December 31st of this year. The Mirage staff will stay aboard until May as independent contractors. If they want to publish any comics after then (beyond the end of Tales in May) they would need to rehire or contract new staff.

* TMNT Volume 4 may continue. Or it may not. No one is sure, even Peter himself. Though this could change, it is currently the only project being talked about at all as being potentially published beyond the end of Tales of the TMNT V2.
English please ( I am from Ukraine by the way, well the portal to Dimension X is in it)! PRUVET to all UKRAINIANS!

ToTheNines
10-22-2009, 05:07 PM
Dude, shut the f**k up if you're going to post non-sense.

Lieutenant Granitor
10-22-2009, 05:09 PM
dude, shut the f**k up if you're going to post non-sense.

turtle power!

Kendamu
10-22-2009, 05:24 PM
If anyone cares to read, I've gathered all the questions and answers I've been able to get into a single blog post @ Ninja Pizza (http://ninja-pizza.blogspot.com/2009/10/what-happens-now-questions-and-some.html).



I have sources for everything at the above link.
Thanks. If you could keep doing that, it would make things a lot simpler so people can be referred to one source for information on the matter.

GK Punk
10-22-2009, 05:25 PM
Lieutenant Granitor, stop spamming the forums. Consider it an official verbal warning.

BoggleKng
10-22-2009, 07:04 PM
If anyone cares to read, I've gathered all the questions and answers I've been able to get into a single blog post @ Ninja Pizza (http://ninja-pizza.blogspot.com/2009/10/what-happens-now-questions-and-some.html).



I have sources for everything at the above link.


Thanks, Rose.. Keep updating as you talk to Dan, Jim and Murph, etc.. I would myself but I think they have enough work and questions on their plates at the moment... don't need one more crazy fan buggin' them..

Mr._Mutant_Man
10-22-2009, 09:17 PM
I'm seeing 17 re-prints and one new issue of Vol. 4 per year. :P

That would be better than nothing at all. I'm not as saddened by the current comics ending as much as I am the possibility of the classic Mirage comics never seeing the light of day again.

Spitfire
10-23-2009, 01:12 AM
Why is the Source Book being canceled? This is so retarded. That was probably the last cool thing we were gonna get. The last hooray to the comic world.

Ninjinister
10-23-2009, 02:53 AM
Why is the Source Book being canceled? This is so retarded. That was probably the last cool thing we were gonna get. The last hooray to the comic world.

Yeah, that made me sadder than anything we've seen thus far... even the canning of Turtles Forever's theater appearance.

darthsmozers
10-23-2009, 07:32 AM
After that, I'd really like to see Nick or a farmed-out company handle reprints and trades, since Mirage has consistantly dropped the ball with that.

Amen! :)

Hmm, I wonder, could Archie print TMNTA trades or would that now fall under Nick?

CyberCubed
10-23-2009, 11:10 AM
Has Nick ever been in the comic industry for any of its other properties? I've never followed the company.

Spitfire
10-23-2009, 01:39 PM
Has Nick ever been in the comic industry for any of its other properties? I've never followed the company.

I looked online from what I can tell this is the closest they have to it.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nickelodeon_Magazine

ToTheNines
10-23-2009, 04:44 PM
Off topic, but: Anyone see Jakes Facebook today?

"Perhaps I can now discuss that a year ago there were discussions (albeit brief) between Mirage and Marvel for a TMNT/Marvel crossover."

Jephael
10-23-2009, 10:34 PM
Has Nick ever been in the comic industry for any of its other properties? I've never followed the company.

Marvel used to produce Ren and Stimpy comics.

odupianist
10-26-2009, 07:58 AM
Especially when tristan announced on his facebook that the mirage universe source book is now canceled.

Now that's just plain stupid. I was really looking forward to that.

plastroncafe
10-26-2009, 10:38 AM
I looked online from what I can tell this is the closest they have to it.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nickelodeon_Magazine

And if memory serves they just recently discontinued that magazine.
(I know a woman who used to do their Avatar comics.)

/by "know" I mean, "I read her livejournal."

Kendamu
10-26-2009, 12:51 PM
Why is the Source Book being canceled? This is so retarded. That was probably the last cool thing we were gonna get. The last hooray to the comic world.
Because it exceeded the number of pages allowed in the "Pete still gets to make comics" part of the deal.

Roseangelo
10-26-2009, 12:55 PM
Because it exceeded the number of pages allowed in the "Pete still gets to make comics" part of the deal.

It's also not a comic book. The "Pete still gets to make comics" part is exactly that: Comics. Not "Publish anything you damn well want inside a book that looks like a comic book." (For those who were saying it should be split up into multiple "issues.")

Kendamu
10-26-2009, 12:56 PM
I hadn't personally put that much thought into it because the Mirage Universe book wasn't at the tip top of my list of stuff to buy. It was more of a "I'll get around to it in a few months" sort of thing. But, yeah. That, too!

Spitfire
10-26-2009, 01:04 PM
I was under the impression the buy out doesn't effect Mirage's publishing until the end of the year. And anyway if that was the reason you'd think Laird would find a way to get 3 years of hard work published. If he can't at least manage that then he could put the would be pages up online for free. He made a poor choice on that deal in my opinion. He should have requested the right to publish anything he wanted, be it books or whatever.

CyberCubed
10-26-2009, 01:06 PM
Does Nick actually get any of the profit now from the Mirage comics that sell? If not, why do they care if Mirage prints collected books? Wouldn't Mirage be paying for those books to be produced, such as the paper and the printing...and it have nothing to do with Nick?

Or does Nick now get a small percentage of the profits that Mirage makes from the comics?

plastroncafe
10-26-2009, 01:08 PM
Does Nick actually get any of the profit now from the Mirage comics that sell? If not, why do they care if Mirage prints collected books? Wouldn't Mirage be paying for those books to be produced, such as the paper and the printing...and it have nothing to do with Nick?

Or does Nick now get a small percentage of the profits that Mirage makes from the comics?

I don't think it has anything to do with money, but rather name recognition. Allowing something "off brand" to be produced could possibly hurt their bottom line.

Kendamu
10-26-2009, 01:14 PM
Considering that Peter Laird's heart isn't really in it anymore and what just happened is a big sigh of relief for him, I don't think he really cares as long as he's able to publish a normal length comic once in awhile to finish Vol. 4 or if just on a whim.

Hopefully, though, he'll pull an Akira Toriyama (the guy who wrote Dragonball) and give us some random one-shots once in awhile.

Roseangelo
10-26-2009, 01:27 PM
Look people, it's this simple: Nickelodeon owns the TMNT. They don't have to have a good reason to do anything. They get to do what they want, period. Mirage does not own the right to produce trade paperbacks. Period.

The right given to Peter to still publish comics is probably more like a favor that sealed the deal than anything else. We all know there aren't going to be 18 books a year. After Tales concludes (and it was likely to end at issue #70 even before this deal happened), we'll be lucky to see one new issue a year, maybe two.

I was under the impression the buy out doesn't effect Mirage's publishing until the end of the year.

No, everything changed the moment the press release was sent out last Wednesday. Nick owns everything now.

Spitfire
10-26-2009, 03:11 PM
He could still print it in multiple volumes. I'm aware you seem to think he can't but I've seen several, and own several. source books that are printed in multiple volumes and meet that page limit. A comic book full of bios still counts as a comic book. A comic book full of pin ups still counts as a comic book. If it's a rectangle stack of paper held together by staples with a cover it's a comic book. Hell I own an X-men book that's all pin ups.

I know it'll never happen and arguing about it is completely pointless but fact of the matter is it could be done.

Roseangelo
10-26-2009, 03:15 PM
I know it'll never happen and arguing about it is completely pointless but fact of the matter is it could be done.

Yes, arguing is completely pointless because you don't get it. A book of prose, which is what "Mirage Universe" is, packaged to look like a comic book, is NOT a comic book in the terms that Mirage is still allowed to publish comic books.

Ninjinister
10-26-2009, 03:15 PM
He could still print it in multiple volumes. I'm aware you seem to think he can't but I've seen several, and own several. source books that are printed in multiple volumes and meet that page limit. A comic book full of bios still counts as a comic book. A comic book full of pin ups still counts as a comic book. If it's a rectangle stack of paper held together by staples with a cover it's a comic book. Hell I own an X-men book that's all pin ups.

I know it'll never happen and arguing about it is completely pointless but fact of the matter is it could be done.

Jake Black says no.

Why the "Mirage Universe" book can't be divided into separate issues and published: b/c it's not a comic. It's prose. Length isn't the issue

Raph's Girl
10-26-2009, 03:18 PM
Jake also says that initially the Sourcebook was gonna be an online resource guide. Perhaps that's what's gonna happen now?

Kendamu
10-26-2009, 03:24 PM
http://plairdblog.blogspot.com/2009/10/some-thoughts-on-future.html

Although I do have the right to publish up to eighteen issues of TMNT comics per year, it is highly unlikely that I will do that right away. In all honesty, the idea of doing ANY new Turtle stuff right now leaves me cold.

I need to get away from it.

It doesn't matter, anyway. Like a lot of us have guessed, after May we're not getting anything new for at least a little while.

Spitfire
10-26-2009, 03:30 PM
Jake Black says no.

Yeah that makes sense I guess. I didn't really think about it that way. I always viewed a comic as a comic.

Jake also says that initially the Sourcebook was gonna be an online resource guide. Perhaps that's what's gonna happen now?
That's what I was figuring they would do at this point. I can't see them wasting all that time they put into it.

TristanHuwJones
10-26-2009, 03:45 PM
That's what I was figuring they would do at this point. I can't see them wasting all that time they put into it.

Books go unpublished all the time. It's like the remake of Vol.1 #8... only appeared in Spanish language reprints.

I was about halfway through my work on it at the time the call was made. If it goes anywhere, there's still a lot of work that needs doing. There were a few entries that were really off the mark and a number of characters were missing. It's nothing like the Marvel handbooks or anything like that. It's a great book if you don't know anything about the Turtles, as the entries are written in a way that allows people to be be brought up to date, giving them all the info they need to start reading the comics, but without going into any great depth.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
10-26-2009, 04:04 PM
It's a great book if you don't know anything about the Turtles, as the entries are written in a way that allows people to be be brought up to date, giving them all the info they need to start reading the comics, but without going into any great depth.

Translation: It's nothing any of us really needed anyway. :P

Ninjinister
10-26-2009, 04:06 PM
My suggestion on Jake's page was maybe integrate any materials that can be done so to the TMNT Wiki (http://www.tmnt.wikia.com/). All the info would've shown up there eventually, anyway.

TristanHuwJones
10-26-2009, 04:18 PM
Translation: It's nothing any of us really needed anyway. :P

To be honest, no. The artwork would've been worth it, and I tried to get in touch with Pete and the others to add bits and pieces in there to give answers to some looming questions, but it really would've been far more beneficial to newcomers than long-time fans.

My suggestion on Jake's page was maybe integrate any materials that can be done so to the TMNT Wiki. All the info would've shown up there eventually, anyway.

Again, to be honest, a lot more could be done. Many of the entries only dealt with Volume 4 related events, and while I had started expanding on many of them, I think the wiki could probably do with more in depth entries.

Mr._Mutant_Man
10-26-2009, 08:09 PM
It's also not a comic book. The "Pete still gets to make comics" part is exactly that: Comics. Not "Publish anything you damn well want inside a book that looks like a comic book." (For those who were saying it should be split up into multiple "issues.")

Sure it's a comic. It's a comic completely made up of splash pages...with text describing the character in the splash page on the side. The plot? Well...some character, let's say Splinter, is going around describing everyone.

Roseangelo
10-26-2009, 08:17 PM
Oh just give it up, people. You might as well start dealing with it now, because the TMNT as you know 'em are dead.

Cipher
10-26-2009, 09:28 PM
Oh just give it up, people. You might as well start dealing with it now, because the TMNT as you know 'em are dead.I don't think the slow, slow, conclusion to Volume 4 is out of the question.

After that, though. Yes. But if the story's actually told to its conclusion, then it's no tragedy.

CyberCubed
10-26-2009, 09:46 PM
You mean aside from the fact that for the first time in history, the Mirage universe won't exist anymore?

Even when they took breaks in the past, we always knew they were going back to it, and even Image was originally intended to be a continuation of the Mirage universe, so we had that inbetween Volume 2 and 4.

This time there's nothing to look forward to after Volume 4 wraps for the comics. The Turtles roots will be forgotten and given trades can't be released, the comics will become more and more obscure and the only people who will care about them is old 20-30+ year olds.

It really is the end of the Mirage universe. Granted it'll be dragged out a bit since Pete won't get new Vol. 4 issues out anytime soon, but its pretty much it.

Cipher
10-26-2009, 09:57 PM
You mean aside from the fact that for the first time in history, the Mirage universe won't exist anymore?

Even when they took breaks in the past, we always knew they were going back to it, and even Image was originally intended to be a continuation of the Mirage universe, so we had that inbetween Volume 2 and 4.Stories end. From a writing perspective, it's actually sh*tty when they don't.

And yeah, it may be the end for the older audience's Turtles. That's a shame, since I would have liked to have seen future reboots target this audience. But c'est la vie. If you can dig future kids' cartoons on their own, good for you. If you can't, then maybe it's time to just enjoy the series you have for 25 years and leave the new stuff alone. That's the position I'm looking at being in.

This time there's nothing to look forward to after Volume 4 wraps for the comics. The Turtles roots will be forgotten and given trades can't be released, the comics will become more and more obscure and the only people who will care about them is old 20-30+ year olds.Now this is annoying. I'd at least like it not to fade into even more obscurity. I hope that, somewhere down the line, someone can get some trades out there. Just because Mirage can't do it right now doesn't mean that all hope is lost.

odupianist
10-27-2009, 07:48 AM
After reading Pete's blog, it appears he wants to give Volume 4 a conclusion. Honestly, I don't see it happening any faster than it's going now. So what's the difference? I have faith that he'll give us a conclusion. It will just be awhile...

Billbeaux
10-30-2009, 07:47 AM
Opinions on vol. 4 may run hot and cold, but nonetheless, count me in with those who would like to see it get a proper conclusion. Speaking of which...

I realize this has NO CHANCE UNDER THE SUN of happening, but how cool would it be if at some point Laird invited the vol. 3 creative team to come back and give their series a proper ending? Anybody want to take turns holding their breath with me? :dead:

PAAATE
10-30-2009, 09:09 AM
I realize this has NO CHANCE UNDER THE SUN of happening, but how cool would it be if at some point Laird invited the vol. 3 creative team to come back and give their series a proper ending? Anybody want to take turns holding their breath with me? :dead:

Am I retarded, or wasn't that considered at one point? I remember reading that Laird was gonna read through vol 3 and see if he liked it enough for trying to get those guys back together?

Andrew NDB
10-30-2009, 12:02 PM
Opinions on vol. 4 may run hot and cold, but nonetheless, count me in with those who would like to see it get a proper conclusion. Speaking of which...

I realize this has NO CHANCE UNDER THE SUN of happening, but how cool would it be if at some point Laird invited the vol. 3 creative team to come back and give their series a proper ending? Anybody want to take turns holding their breath with me? :dead:

Gary (Carlson, that is) would love to do it. I don't know what Frank Fosco is up to these days.

The sad part is, you just know if Peter/Mirage had reached out to Gary, Gary could've wrapped up the Vol. 3 story in one or two issues in Tales of the TMNT. They could've even made sure to slap a, "This story is not in continuity!" banner on the inside if they just had to.

It would've been a classy move.

traf
10-30-2009, 04:18 PM
You know, for me, the great thing about Tales of the TMNT (and TMNT comics in general, really) is the variation in storytelling techniques. One issue would have a sort of dark and gritty tone while the next might have a more humorous, light-hearted one. You don't get that in most comics (especially the mainstream stuff) which is why I think it is a shame that Tales is ending. It would be cool if Mirage would put out a TMNT anthology series that was "continuity-free" and just let different people tell there own TMNT stories like they did with the Vol. 1 fill-ins. That way Peter Laird wouldn't have to worry about overseeing it. Of course, if Viacom won't allow the release of "The Forever War" then they probably wouldn't allow that either.

Billbeaux
10-30-2009, 05:03 PM
I don't have every issue of Tales, but I'm versed enough to know that there are a couple of story lines that were left dangling (*coughTristancough*), many of which could have been sufficiently wrapped up with one more issue (*coughnotTristancough*). If we ever do start seeing eighteen issues a year--or even a third of that--I hope a lot of those holes get patched up.

DrSpengler
10-30-2009, 05:17 PM
Tristan's gang war arc is scheduled to be completed before the last issue.

Its that other arc, with the Foot Mystics and the Lady Shredder that's really bugging me, because even IF the series weren't getting cancelled, we were told that it was never going to be completed.

Which...sucks.

PAAATE
10-30-2009, 06:55 PM
Tristan's gang war arc is scheduled to be completed before the last issue.

When did that happen? And how will it happen?

I'm not doubting you or anything, but this just made my day. :D

CyberCubed
10-30-2009, 06:55 PM
Its that other arc, with the Foot Mystics and the Lady Shredder that's really bugging me, because even IF the series weren't getting cancelled, we were told that it was never going to be completed.

Which...sucks.

The Foot Mystic storyline isn't that big a deal, we saw their plans defeated twice. The Lady Shredder arc should have had an ending, but oh well.

DrSpengler
10-30-2009, 07:33 PM
When did that happen? And how will it happen?

I'm not doubting you or anything, but this just made my day. :D

Hm, looks like I was mistaken. I knew Tristan had one issue left, but reading the synopsis it doesn't appear to be part of his Gang War arc.

Guess maybe it isn't getting completed, then?

Coola Yagami
10-30-2009, 08:27 PM
Lady Shredder was in the Mirage canon? I thought that was only in the Image comics. Which Tales issues featured her?

DrSpengler
10-30-2009, 08:34 PM
Lady Shredder was in the Mirage canon? I thought that was only in the Image comics. Which Tales issues featured her?

Different Lady Shredder. And "Lady Shredder" might be a disingenuous name, come to think of it, as she only wears Shredder's gauntlets. But she does lead a sect of the Foot Clan, but their relation to the rest of the Foot Clan is a bit of a mystery.

"Change of Power" (http://www.ninjaturtles.com/comics/mirage/talesvol2/22/22.htm)

We still don't know who she is or what her deal is. She was introduced as the next OMG Amazing Super World Shattering Villain that will Shake Up the TMNT Unvierse as We Know It.

Then she was promptly forgotten and never spoken of again.

Not my idea of "quality story telling".

Dragon Turtle
10-30-2009, 09:01 PM
We still don't know who she is or what her deal is. She was introduced as the next OMG Amazing Super World Shattering Villain that will Shake Up the TMNT Unvierse as We Know It.



According to Ross May, she was going to revealed as Tang Shen's sister, who was seeking revenge against Hamato Yoshi/Turtles whom she blamed for the death of he sister.

TristanHuwJones
10-30-2009, 10:10 PM
That one issue won't complete the gang war arc. Actually, it's where it kicks into high gear unfortunately :( Burning Man is kind of the straw that breaks the camel's back.

Regarding those other storylines... Change of Power's continuation was one of the pitches I'd made for next year, should the comics continue past May (don't read into it, it was before the deal went through). It revolves around the fact that Hun has it in for the Foot Clan in a major way, and the Shredder Loyalists are making their big push for control. That issue was also going to answer the question "Who was that watching April's apt. through the telescope?" back in Vol.1. The basic idea of what Ross was putting into that arc he put up on his blog was still there, but with the big reveal already put up online, the twist was going to be substantially different.

The Foot Mystic arc was also going to play into it, eventually, as I knew that Murph wasn't going to finish it.

I keep saying it, but if you want to see these arc's finished, you really need to stop hoping Mirage will do it, because if they do, it'll likely be a long way off. There's every possibility that these storylines can be completed with whoever decides to pick up the license. It just comes down to you guys letting the comic groups out there who may be interested in doing it know what you want to see. IDW and Dark Horse both go to those associated with particular brands, so if either property lands there, there's a chance I can continue doing these things over there. It's slim, but it's better than nothing :)

DrSpengler
10-30-2009, 10:19 PM
Man, bummer. So that's THREE story arcs that Tales started and couldn't finish within the span of 70 issues. Jeez.


But yeah, if/when we find who Nick farms the publishing of TMNT comics out to, you better believe we'll drop em a line. They may or may not pay us any mind, but it's worth a shot.

Venom
10-30-2009, 10:25 PM
Dude, Trist, you're a mind reader man. IDW and Dark Horse have always been the two companies I would like to see the Turtles's story continue with!!

DK2
10-30-2009, 10:26 PM
I posted this up on the Vol.4 #30 thread but it applies here too.
Again Peters gone off the radar with Vol. 4. Now that he's sold the Turtles, this series may never ever be done. Yet he seemed more determined to get this book on the go earlier this year. You'd think we woulda had #31 by now and that was gonna be in the duo shade tones applied by Peter. Yet last we knew Peter also wanted Jim going about on #32. So you gotta wonder if Jim has finished this issue as of now in the pencils? To think there could at least be 2 issues of Vol. 4 sitting around Peter and Jim's tables near completion.
I hate and agree about the loss of the Mirage Uinverse book. All that effort is gone?! Peter made a cover, everyone elses efforts wasted. Why didn't Peter at least allow this to be published?
The other thing a I hate too is that not only is the Mirage comics era all over, but we'll never see a Kevin and Peter team up ever again. This solidifies that possiblity of never ever happening (although it was this anyway). You really wonder how Kevin feels? Sure he gave up his rights and co-ownership in the past 9 years, but now he can never go back to it neither. I always wished the two made that "middle aged TMNT" graphic novel they'd mentioned back in the early '90's. Then Peter reneged on asking Kevin to work together on something for the 25th anniversary due to Kevin's comments in an interview. It really is the end of Mirage and one of indy comics' biggest successes. No more TMNT after Tales ends next year and if, any random TMNT Vol. 4 issues.

Andrew NDB
10-30-2009, 10:48 PM
The other thing a I hate too is that not only is the Mirage comics era all over, but we'll never see a Kevin and Peter team up ever again.

Technically, nothing is preventing Peter (legally or otherwise) from one day saying, "I want to publish an issue of TMNT with Kevin Eastman" and then just doing it. If Eastman wanted to do that as well, of course.

And as jaded as you or I might be right about now, how cool would it be if Peter reached out to Kevin to do the last issue of Vol. 4 with him? Pretty damn cool.

Here's a random thought... would Nickelodeon have rights to any comics Peter publishes post-sale under the "you can publish 18 TMNT comics a year" clause?

Venom
10-30-2009, 10:54 PM
Well, they are facebook friends lol! I commented the other night on Kevin's page "That makes me smile :)". Hopefully that will be one bright spot in this whole thing.

Coola Yagami
10-30-2009, 11:34 PM
That one issue won't complete the gang war arc. Actually, it's where it kicks into high gear unfortunately :( Burning Man is kind of the straw that breaks the camel's back.

Regarding those other storylines... Change of Power's continuation was one of the pitches I'd made for next year, should the comics continue past May (don't read into it, it was before the deal went through). It revolves around the fact that Hun has it in for the Foot Clan in a major way, and the Shredder Loyalists are making their big push for control. That issue was also going to answer the question "Who was that watching April's apt. through the telescope?" back in Vol.1. The basic idea of what Ross was putting into that arc he put up on his blog was still there, but with the big reveal already put up online, the twist was going to be substantially different.

The Foot Mystic arc was also going to play into it, eventually, as I knew that Murph wasn't going to finish it.

I keep saying it, but if you want to see these arc's finished, you really need to stop hoping Mirage will do it, because if they do, it'll likely be a long way off. There's every possibility that these storylines can be completed with whoever decides to pick up the license. It just comes down to you guys letting the comic groups out there who may be interested in doing it know what you want to see. IDW and Dark Horse both go to those associated with particular brands, so if either property lands there, there's a chance I can continue doing these things over there. It's slim, but it's better than nothing :)

Tristan dude.... how come Mirage is so deadset on cancelling Tales so soon even if they can now do 18 issues a year??? Why are they completely ignoring that and cancelling the series regardless? That part I don't understand.

Andrew NDB
10-30-2009, 11:59 PM
Tristan dude.... how come Mirage is so deadset on cancelling Tales so soon even if they can now do 18 issues a year??? Why are they completely ignoring that and cancelling the series regardless? That part I don't understand.

Because it doesn't sell?

Though it's a little bit odd if they've gone this long, they wouldn't leave the lights on at least long enough to tie up loose ends.

TristanHuwJones
11-01-2009, 08:08 PM
Dude, Trist, you're a mind reader man. IDW and Dark Horse have always been the two companies I would like to see the Turtles's story continue with!!

Even if I didn't get to write for it anymore, these are my two top preferences as a fan. I think IDW could/would do the most with it to satisfy fans across the board.

Tristan dude.... how come Mirage is so deadset on cancelling Tales so soon even if they can now do 18 issues a year??? Why are they completely ignoring that and cancelling the series regardless? That part I don't understand.

Because I'm 99% sure that's just in case Peter ever decides he wants to do more Turtles books his way. As I said, and as Peter said, I think it'll be a little while before we see any more Turtles out of Mirage, and I'm pretty sure it'll be so he can wrap up Volume 4 and/or continue his story. I think we may need to wait and see what actually happens to the Turtles in comics from here on out, as that may make things a little clearer.

As Andrew said, it's also running at a loss, and has been for a long time. With the money coming in from licensing (which is essentially what kept the TMNT alive) now going into another company, Mirage as a company can't really afford to keep running books that are going to run at a loss. Not on a monthly basis anyway.

traf
11-02-2009, 02:53 AM
With the money coming in from licensing (which is essentially what kept the TMNT alive) now going into another company, Mirage as a company can't really afford to keep running books that are going to run at a loss. Not on a monthly basis anyway.

That's understandable. Thanks for clearing some of this stuff up. It would be nice if we could get a TMNT annual or something every year, but I don't think that's likely. Do you think there's a chance that Viacom/Nick won't license the comic book rights at all? They may be interested in publishing Manga-style books or some other format that they think kids are into. I fear they may not have any desire to do anything in the traditional comic format. What do you guys think?

TristanHuwJones
11-02-2009, 03:00 AM
I had heard (and I'm not sure how serious it is) that Nick were sending out feelers and that they'd been in touch with IDW, and I have it on good authority that both Dark Horse and IDW are interested in the property, but I can't say 100%. I think we'll have a better idea in a few weeks time (hopefully), but I think Nick would be silly not to. They've licensed everything else out to comics so far, and with the Turtles being such a big property, I'd be very surprised if they didn't.

Buffy
11-02-2009, 04:27 AM
Nice: Dark horse! Maybe we will see a crossover between Usagi and the turtles again. :)

TristanHuwJones
11-02-2009, 04:36 AM
Don't read too much into it, it's all just rumor and hearsay. I wouldn't count on anything until there's a press release. I say make some noise. If you want a company to pick it up, tell them!

odupianist
11-02-2009, 08:13 AM
As Andrew said, it's also running at a loss, and has been for a long time. With the money coming in from licensing (which is essentially what kept the TMNT alive) now going into another company, Mirage as a company can't really afford to keep running books that are going to run at a loss. Not on a monthly basis anyway.

Didn't PL just get a nice retirement check from Nickelodeon? Money problem for Tales solved :D

CyberCubed
11-02-2009, 10:33 AM
Don't read too much into it, it's all just rumor and hearsay. I wouldn't count on anything until there's a press release. I say make some noise. If you want a company to pick it up, tell them!

If they do get the license, make sure you get on board there as a writer. Not only for your story, but you probably know the Mirage universe better than any of them do.

I'd hate to see the Mirage universe get destroyed by incompetent writers and a lack of continuity, and everything needs to take place before Volume 4 as well.

TristanHuwJones
11-02-2009, 03:07 PM
If they do get the license, make sure you get on board there as a writer. Not only for your story, but you probably know the Mirage universe better than any of them do.

I'd hate to see the Mirage universe get destroyed by incompetent writers and a lack of continuity, and everything needs to take place before Volume 4 as well.

Well, ultimately, that's up to you guys as much as it's up to me. I can put my stuff forward and say "Please look/Please hire me!" until the cows come home, but without fan support, it doesn't really mean much to bigger companies.

I appreciate your faith in my abilities though! Hopefully whoever gets the TMNT's will catch on ;)

traf
12-04-2009, 01:41 PM
Do you guys think that BOOM! Studios would do a good job with the Turtles? They might be interested, especially if they end up losing the Disney license to Marvel.

I don't think they should be part of the Boom! Kids line though. That would be too restrictive.

prescribeddrone
12-06-2009, 01:27 AM
Nice: Dark horse! Maybe we will see a crossover between Usagi and the turtles again. :)

And Hellboy!

TMNT+Hellboy = Win

Ninjinister
12-06-2009, 02:22 AM
And Hellboy!

TMNT+Hellboy = Win

Hell yeah! (pun intended)

Chris
12-06-2009, 07:18 AM
IF Nick does license out TMNT comics to someone like IDW or Dark Horse, which versions do you think they'd license out?

Does their agreement with Peter Laird allow them to license out the Mirage Universe? And even if it does would anyone take it? Image's Volume 3 ended due to poor sales, Tales Vol. 2 is ending due to poor sales, PL is making a loss on Volume 4.

I can see them licensing out the new 2012 movie and TV universes, and almost certainly something based on the old toon (and maybe the 2k3 toon at a push). But I just can't see us getting any more Mirage TMNT unless Peter does them. And if they did, how would they treat previous continuity? Especially the unfinished Volume 4 which Peter may still finish at some point in the future.

Ash
12-06-2009, 10:02 AM
I think it would get quite confusing if you had two publishers both writing their own continuations to Vol4.

The licensee would probably be better off either starting afresh or using the upcoming cartoon/film as their foundation.

Oculus Orbus
12-06-2009, 10:49 AM
I think it would get quite confusing if you had two publishers both writing their own continuations to Vol4.

The licensee would probably be better off either starting afresh or using the upcoming cartoon/film as their foundation.

If Nick licenses the comics, that's what will happen. The new publisher will not continue from Volume 4.

CyberCubed
12-06-2009, 11:01 AM
If there's any new comic, it'll likely be based on the cartoon like Archie and Dreamwave were based on their respective cartoons.

I don't think anything will be done with the Mirage universe.

prescribeddrone
12-06-2009, 02:02 PM
The Turtles have been around in comics for 25 years, I think it would sell more if more people knew about the comics.

Maybe some viral marketing will help sales?

Hamel
12-06-2009, 04:41 PM
If a large company like DH will publish it you may see it in bookstores and that will boost sales

Ash
12-06-2009, 05:16 PM
I think the only way they can boost sales is with really good PR and brand awareness. Whenever a comic book film is released (like Watchmen, for example) they always make a really big deal about the origins of the property and then you start to see shops putting out graphic novels front and centre in order to cash in on the movie. Audiences seem to take an interest in the comics if they like the film but this never seemed to happen with the TMNT, largely because most people associate the property with the 87 cartoon and have no idea that it originated in comic form.

In short, they need to draw in new readers and that will only happen once people realise that a) the comics exist, and b) they're actually very credible.

DrSpengler
12-06-2009, 05:22 PM
It's always been my belief that if trade paperback collections of the Mirage comics were made available in mainstream book stores like Borders and Barnes & Noble, brand awareness and comic sales would inevitably skyrocket.

Now that Laird is out of the picture and can no longer hold distribution back by refusing to do business with mainstream book stores, the possibility of more collections reaching more potential customers is finally...um...possible.


Really, I think that was always my greatest annoyance. Most people don't buy graphic novels and trade paperbacks from comic shops. They get them from major book retailers. Refusing to do business with them was one of Mirage's most boneheaded financial blunders.

Andrew NDB
12-06-2009, 05:22 PM
I think the only way they can boost sales is with really good PR and brand awareness. Whenever a comic book film is released (like Watchmen, for example) they always make a really big deal about the origins of the property and then you start to see shops putting out graphic novels front and centre in order to cash in on the movie.

But people don't tend to just wander into the increasingly dwindling number of comic book stores out there by chance. They do wander into Borders. They do wander into Barnes & Noble. You'll find plenty of Watchmen graphic novels there but nary a TMNT one... because Mirage doesn't ship to them.

Audiences seem to take an interest in the comics if they like the film but this never seemed to happen with the TMNT

There hasn't been any good TMNT movies. Not that that's the only reason for what you say.

And what you say isn't even entirely true. I remember finding a TMNT collected book after seeing TMNT II in theatres, the same day. I think it was the second one. I had my parents buy it and I became very interested in the comic book TMNT.

Oculus Orbus
12-06-2009, 07:15 PM
Speaking of trade paperbacks collections, and now that Mirage can't do them anymore, does Nick have the rights to do them or license them to other companies?

I mean all the old Mirage stuff, like Volume 1 and 2. Who owns that now?

Roseangelo
12-06-2009, 07:24 PM
Speaking of trade paperbacks collections, and now that Mirage can't do them anymore, does Nick have the rights to do them or license them to other companies?

I mean all the old Mirage stuff, like Volume 1 and 2. Who owns that now?

Nick owns everything.

Cipher
12-06-2009, 08:10 PM
Really, I think that was always my greatest annoyance. Most people don't buy graphic novels and trade paperbacks from comic shops. They get them from major book retailers. Refusing to do business with them was one of Mirage's most boneheaded financial blunders.I'd venture to say that was unquestionably the single most boneheaded financial blunder. It's personally been an incredibly frustrating fact for me, and if you look back through my posts, I've railed against the lack of bookstore availability many times. Others have too.

Maybe Nick will actually have the good sense to republish the material in readily available quantities and sources. Then again, I worry that they may try to slap the brand with a single image, ruling out the more adult material. We'll find out, I guess.

Oculus Orbus
12-07-2009, 05:56 AM
Nick owns everything.

Thanks Roseangelo. Well, at least there's a chance for the old stuff to see the light of day again at some point.

Ash
12-07-2009, 07:41 AM
But people don't tend to just wander into the increasingly dwindling number of comic book stores out there by chance. They do wander into Borders. They do wander into Barnes & Noble. You'll find plenty of Watchmen graphic novels there but nary a TMNT one... because Mirage doesn't ship to them.


That's exactly my point. There needs to be a concerted effort between the brand owners to make sure that each permutation of that brand can help promote the other. I get the feeling this will be exactly what happens under Nick... Though we might not care at that stage if the comics are just cartoon adaptations rather than collected Mirage stories. Which isn't entirely out of the question.

CyberCubed
12-10-2009, 04:10 PM
If Nick has no interest in promoting the comic brand of TMNT, and only want their cartoon to be the face of the franchise, then that's what exactly is going to happen.

There's a strong possibility that after Tales wraps up in May, there won't be any TMNT comics for a long, long time, aside from the occasional Vol. 4 issue depending on how PL feels.