View Full Version : Steve Murphy on "The Forever War"
Andrew NDB
10-27-2009, 10:45 PM
My question:
Will "The Forever War" be completed?
His answer today:
Hi. We're still trying to figure that out but my guess right now is "no." Should know by week's end... and then I'll make sure Dan posts the final word.
My second question:
That's terrible news. What has been the challenges in getting it made?
His second answer:
Too many to mention. Writer (me) missing a few deadlines. Artist is no longer a full-time artist, so making time to draw after a full-time day job and two kids to raise has been difficult. And now Mirage no longer owns the TMNT and our comic book rights may not extend outside the "Mirage universe."
Kendamu
10-27-2009, 10:50 PM
Not a surprise at all at this point, but I'll keep my fingers crossed, anyway.
Andrew NDB
10-27-2009, 10:53 PM
No, not a surprise at all.
If anything, this is positive... because (at least until the end of the week) there apparently is still some modicum of a chance it gets made. From my understanding of things it didn't even sound like there was this until now.
CyberCubed
10-27-2009, 10:57 PM
But can't it still be released under Mirage's "18 comics a year" rule?
Only 5 issues of Tales come out in 2010, and that's it. Why can't 3 issues of "The Forever War" come out then as well?
Roseangelo
10-27-2009, 11:00 PM
But can't it still be released under Mirage's "18 comics a year" rule?
Only 5 issues of Tales come out in 2010, and that's it. Why can't 3 issues of "The Forever War" come out then as well?
My impression has been that the only thing holding back "The Forever War" from getting published is simply it getting completed. I'd assume that's still the case now.
I'm glad we're going to get a definitive answer, though.
Raph's Girl
10-27-2009, 11:01 PM
But can't it still be released under Mirage's "18 comics a year" rule?
Only 5 issues of Tales come out in 2010, and that's it. Why can't 3 issues of "The Forever War" come out then as well?
Exactly... 5 issues of Tales of the TMNT, and maybe 1 or 2 of Vol 4.... heck they could easily expand Forever War to more than 3 issues....Problem is they wouldn't be able to do a TPB....ah well
Kendamu
10-27-2009, 11:24 PM
You can always do what Andrew suggested to me: buy extra copies, hole punch, and throw 'em in a binder for your own collected "reader copies."
Exactly... 5 issues of Tales of the TMNT, and maybe 1 or 2 of Vol 4.... heck they could easily expand Forever War to more than 3 issues....Problem is they wouldn't be able to do a TPB....ah well
I doubt any issues of Volume 4 come out next year. Peter Laird said he was going to step away for awhile before deciding whether or not to continue with Vol. 4.
I think the potential problem with "The Forever War" is that it does not take place in the "Mirage continuity" and so it may not meet the conditions of Mirage's agreement with Viacom.
Andrew NDB
10-27-2009, 11:32 PM
I think the potential problem with "The Forever War" is that it does not take place in the "Mirage continuity" and so it may not meet the conditions of Mirage's agreement with Viacom.
Oh, I seriously doubt "But the 18 issues must take place in the established Mirage Universe!" is in the contractual caveat.
Coola Yagami
10-28-2009, 12:08 AM
The problem is that Mirage can still make 18 issues a year, but they don't want to. Regardless of wether or not Nick bought them, they were still gonna end Tales next year when they don't have to. I'm saying this cause some of the guy that had more ideas with Hun and King Cobra and was wondering if he was gonna have the time to finish it or not. Then Laird is burnt out and might never return to Volume 4. Ths Source book is cancelled. Forever War might take Forever to be released....
So it doesn't matter wether or not Mirage can make 18 comics a year or not.... they just don't want to. What in the god damned hell is holding them back, really????
CyberCubed
10-28-2009, 12:10 AM
I was under the impression that while Mirage closes as an employer by the end of this year, it'll still function as a company at least until May 2010.
After all, it has to so they can print copies of the 5 Tales issues coming out next year. So if they still have the printers and all the materials, Murphy could theoretically have them come out after May, assuming that they all don't disband immediately after May.
Its not like they're selling off the building or all their materials or anything.
Roseangelo
10-28-2009, 01:26 AM
Ugh, I give up with you people.
Buffy
10-28-2009, 05:25 AM
I wonder what the outcome will be. At least we will know for sure so we don't have to keep speculating.
darthsmozers
10-28-2009, 10:16 AM
I know I sound like a broken record, but I posted this elsewhere:
"The Forever War has been teased, hinted, previewed, then outright advertised over the span of the last 7 or 8 years. We bought the Future Tense reprint/lead-in hoping that those dollars would translate into a delivery on the promise of TFW. While we can't assume it won't happen, we've hung onto every word from you (PL), Murphy, Dan, and those preview write-ups for Future Tense. Please, please don't snatch it away again."
Sounds a bit desperate, I know. But from a basic "fulfill your word" point of view, it got to the point of being marketed by the Future Tense TPB, and being announced as a long-anticipated project. The sale aside, Steve Murphy's overall negative attitude about it, even making money off it by selling his Forever War preview prints on eBay, and now possibly closing it again is a very big slap in the face.
Andrew NDB
10-28-2009, 02:03 PM
More from Steve.
My second question:
That's terrible news. What has been the challenges in getting it made?
His second answer:
Too many to mention. Writer (me) missing a few deadlines. Artist is no longer a full-time artist, so making time to draw after a full-time day job and two kids to raise has been difficult. And now Mirage no longer owns the TMNT and our comic book rights may not extend outside the "Mirage universe."
darthsmozers
10-28-2009, 02:08 PM
Wow, interesting about the "Mirage Universe". Also, seemingly valid points all around. Quite a shame though. Any chance you could ask him if he would, if all else fails, be willing to post his thoughts on how he would have ended it to possibly close the story in our imagination?
Kendamu
10-28-2009, 02:51 PM
Well, if we can get Dark Horse or someone to pick it up maybe he can publish it there. That doesn't help with all the other problems holding it back, though.
If Mirage IS actually barred from the TMNTA universe, wouldn't Nick own it?
CyberCubed
10-28-2009, 03:00 PM
That's the stupidest thing I ever heard. Why would Mirage be prevented from releasing comics outside the "Mirage universe?"
Does Nick even know what the hell is part of the Mirage universe or not? If Mirage decided to re-print some old Image issues, would they be stopped from doing that?
Raph's Girl
10-28-2009, 04:33 PM
Well there's always hope that Archie does it... or maybe even IDW (who are producing several Archie TPB's in 2010)... Who knows... I just hope that SOMEDAY it'll be released.
BoggleKng
10-28-2009, 07:12 PM
I am lost... just tell me when it comes out..
More from Steve.
My second question:
That's terrible news. What has been the challenges in getting it made?
His second answer:
Too many to mention. Writer (me) missing a few deadlines. Artist is no longer a full-time artist, so making time to draw after a full-time day job and two kids to raise has been difficult. And now Mirage no longer owns the TMNT and our comic book rights may not extend outside the "Mirage universe."
HA! I was right. Wish I wasn't though.
darthsmozers
10-28-2009, 08:49 PM
That's the stupidest thing I ever heard. Why would Mirage be prevented from releasing comics outside the "Mirage universe?"
Does Nick even know what the hell is part of the Mirage universe or not? If Mirage decided to re-print some old Image issues, would they be stopped from doing that?
If a company like Nick were going to acquire the rights to a property, you can likely bet they did their homework on the history of the TMNT, including past incarnations, current contracts, and future (or in-progress) projects. Its a pretty basic part of the business.
Kendamu
10-28-2009, 09:05 PM
Well there's always hope that Archie does it... or maybe even IDW (who are producing several Archie TPB's in 2010)... Who knows... I just hope that SOMEDAY it'll be released.
Is there any word on which parts of the series will be produced in TPB?
Is there any word on which parts of the series will be produced in TPB?
IDW has a deal to make Archie reprints of Archie comics stuff (their old, old stuff from 1940's onward) if I'm not mistaken, not TMNTA. I think Raph's Girl meant the potential connection of IDW and Archie comics (and IDW's with Paramount/Nicko on Star Trek, Transformers & GI Joe movies) could lead to such possible reprints of the Archie TMNTA stuff. I can't see Archie having the rights to still do TMNTA reprints after the TMNT ownership change until they get the license/rights from Nicko to do such stuff.
raphaelprime
10-29-2009, 02:27 AM
I doubt any issues of Volume 4 come out next year. Peter Laird said he was going to step away for awhile before deciding whether or not to continue with Vol. 4.
He did say that, but(and i doubt this'll actually happen) there is a possibility of one Vol. 4 issue next year. From what i recall Peter and Jim were about half way done or so i think on the next issue, he made mention of it on his blog few months back. But how much got done, theres no clue, if anything else needs to be written by Laird for it, then i doubt it would, but if all that really needs to be done is Jim and Eric's work(And Mike's cover) then i would says it possible, very slim, but plausible.
As for Forever War, i hope they do(and can) go on with it. But this long after i won't be too disappointed if they don't, have had time since the original tease and all for my excitement on it to drop slightly. Will still suck though, but atleast the long delay will give a shrug and "eh, what can you do"
Kendamu
10-29-2009, 11:44 AM
IDW has a deal to make Archie reprints of Archie comics stuff (their old, old stuff from 1940's onward) if I'm not mistaken, not TMNTA. I think Raph's Girl meant the potential connection of IDW and Archie comics (and IDW's with Paramount/Nicko on Star Trek, Transformers & GI Joe movies) could lead to such possible reprints of the Archie TMNTA stuff. I can't see Archie having the rights to still do TMNTA reprints after the TMNT ownership change until they get the license/rights from Nicko to do such stuff.
Oh, I see. I thought by "Archie TPBs" it was in the context of "TMNTA TPBs." Well, I guess I'll still have to hunt down issues of the series.
Andrew NDB
10-29-2009, 12:05 PM
My biggest thing is... virtually none of the 25th anniversary things related to the comic books -- the only part of the franchise that is actually celebrating 25 years this year -- that were promised have been delivered on.
It's just been one great big sloppy, cross-country blow*** for the original cartoon... which Laird doesn't even like. It's puzzling, really.
Kendamu
10-29-2009, 12:25 PM
We did get that Vol. 1 TPB, but besides the Forever War I forgot what exactly was promised i nthe first place.
Andrew NDB
10-29-2009, 12:34 PM
We did get that Vol. 1 TPB, but besides the Forever War I forgot what exactly was promised i nthe first place.
The TMNT Universe book also. And while it wasn't exactly promised, there was the Imagi direct-to-DVD, panel-for-panel adaption of TMNT Vol. 1 #1 that Gary talked Peter into abandoning altogether in favor of "Turtles Forever" (which, though it does include a minor nod to the Mirage TMNT, is 95% a Fred Wolf/4Kids appreciation film).
Roseangelo
10-29-2009, 12:37 PM
We did get that Vol. 1 TPB, but besides the Forever War I forgot what exactly was promised i nthe first place.
Not much of anything was promised, really. A lot of hype for a lot of nothing.
And people got all mad at me for being "negative" by calling 'em out on it. :roll:
As for why we only saw (a bad reflection of) the old cartoon and not comic book stuff, I'd guess the most simple answer is money.
Kendamu
10-29-2009, 12:49 PM
Well, Rose, you did kinda come off at the time as, "The Turtles are dead! F*cking dead!!!! They will not survive the year and we'll never see anything out of them again!!! F*cking dead!!!!" So, of course people are gonna get all mad at you.
Gary talked Peter into abandoning that project? I thought it was some sort of money issue... But if they were able to produce Turtles Forever then I guess they did have the money for it.
Andrew NDB
10-29-2009, 12:51 PM
Gary talked Peter into abandoning that project?
Yep. The deal was in place, Peter was ponying up the money from his own pocket.
Roseangelo
10-29-2009, 12:56 PM
Well, Rose, you did kinda come off at the time as, "The Turtles are dead! F*cking dead!!!! They will not survive the year and we'll never see anything out of them again!!! F*cking dead!!!!" So, of course people are gonna get all mad at you.
Alas, I was never trying to be extreme, just realistic.
Kendamu
10-29-2009, 01:01 PM
I wasn't being literal, Rose. That's just me balling all the instances of doom and gloom up into one sentence as kind of a joke. It's not like you were the only one running around with "The end is nigh!" signs waiting for nightfall so you could go pull your black-and-white face mask out of a pile of garbage and then go break into your friend's house and eat his beans.
Wait. What was I talking about again?
Oh, right! Well, that whole thing about the Vol. 1 #1 becoming Turtles Forever and then Turtles Forever turning into something that's eluding us even after completion just kinda pisses me off now!
Andrew NDB
10-29-2009, 01:11 PM
I remember when I had the "doom and gloom" crown when the fourth movie dropped and I was the only one here saying it was crap.
Ah, the good 'ole days.
CyberCubed
10-29-2009, 01:33 PM
Well they are re-releasing issue #1 for the billionth time in full color in November. I assume that's still coming.
Kendamu
10-29-2009, 01:37 PM
If it weren't for the bookplate from P2P that's coming with the full-color, I probably wouldn't have gotten it considering how many copies of #1 there are around my apartment.
Spitfire
10-29-2009, 01:48 PM
We did get that Vol. 1 TPB
The exact same one that's been printed 3 times before. If they wanted to do something cool they'd have collected other issues that fans have been begging for in a trade.
Hmm I wonder what story arc is one of the most important in the turtles history and spans enough issues to warrant a big trade paper back?
besides the Forever War I forgot what exactly was promised i nthe first place.
Well the Forever War got sliced up. Aside from us never getting it, it was originally planned to be 5 issues and Murph decided to only do 3. If I remember correctly it was supposed to be out at the end of the year. Let's not forget the Mirage figures. We might still be getting the turtles but the rest are canceled. Also the second wave of NECA figures got canned. Andrew pretty much nailed the rest of the stuff. Kinda sad really. The whole reason turtles is 25 gets shoved aside.
Kendamu
10-29-2009, 01:55 PM
Yeah... Still never got that CaW trade. S'the only thing I regret.
Well, I wanted Wave 2 of NECA also, but apparently they don't have the money for that... even though they have the money for those weird little things and those bobble heads.
Cipher
10-29-2009, 01:56 PM
Hmm I wonder what story arc is one of the most important in the turtles history and spans enough issues to warrant a big trade paper back?(Sigh) Maybe someday... (http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3124/2868088753_dccf3cc991.jpg)
The exact same one that's been printed 3 times before. If they wanted to do something cool they'd have collected other issues that fans have been begging for in a trade.
Hmm I wonder what story arc is one of the most important in the turtles history and spans enough issues to warrant a big trade paper back?
Well the Forever War got sliced up. Aside from us never getting it, it was originally planned to be 5 issues and Murph decided to only do 3. If I remember correctly it was supposed to be out at the end of the year. Let's not forget the Mirage figures. We might still be getting the turtles but the rest are canceled. Also the second wave of NECA figures got canned. Andrew pretty much nailed the rest of the stuff. Kinda sad really. The whole reason turtles is 25 gets shoved aside.
From what I understood the 3 issues are (where?) going to be double-sized so the actual story actually should be a little longer than the originally planned 5 issues, page wise.
Andrew NDB
11-03-2009, 07:57 PM
Steve has told me that "The Forever War" is officially cancelled.
Machias Banshee
11-03-2009, 08:01 PM
I (reluctantly) hope you have something to back that up...
oldmanwinters
11-03-2009, 08:03 PM
Steve has told me that "The Forever War" is officially cancelled.
*sniff*sniff*:cry:
RIP TMNT Archie Universe.
Roseangelo
11-03-2009, 08:14 PM
Steve has told me that "The Forever War" is officially cancelled.
Aw, boo. :(
Raph's Girl
11-03-2009, 08:15 PM
Steve has told me that "The Forever War" is officially cancelled.
ARGH!!! Gosh dangit!!! :cry:
Ah well... At least I got a TPB out of it.... :ohwell:
Andrew NDB
11-03-2009, 08:18 PM
I (reluctantly) hope you have something to back that up...
I'm not on trial.
CyberCubed
11-03-2009, 08:18 PM
The sad thing is if Murphy was really serious about the project, it would have been completed last year like it was originally intended.
People forget this was supposed to come out in 2008.
Andrew NDB
11-03-2009, 08:23 PM
The sad thing is if Murphy was really serious about the project, it would have been completed last year like it was originally intended.
Not untrue...
Kendamu
11-03-2009, 08:38 PM
I (reluctantly) hope you have something to back that up...
From the Mirage Studios Twitter account (http://twitter.com/MirageStudios):
Sorry folks, the Forever War mini series has been canceled.
Raph's Girl
11-03-2009, 08:42 PM
Same message has been posted on Facebook. :cry:
Machias Banshee
11-03-2009, 08:54 PM
From the Mirage Studios Twitter account (http://twitter.com/MirageStudios):
Thank you.
Almost ten years of wondering... gone. :(
Jester
11-03-2009, 08:54 PM
Well excrement!!
Leonardo87
11-03-2009, 09:12 PM
*sigh* I was looking forward to this :(.
VaughnMichael
11-03-2009, 09:49 PM
Biggest dissapointment of the year for me comic wise is this news.
This has been a really awesome f'in' year *sarcasm*
Jester
11-03-2009, 10:03 PM
Is there any other fandom that has so much promised that never materialized?
Forever War. Scrapped.
TMNT Forever. In limbo...maybe.
Vol. 4. Unfinished.
Tales. Ending Soon.
Trades. No Dice.
Source Book. Nada.
VaughnMichael
11-03-2009, 10:06 PM
Is there any other fandom that has so much promised that never materialized?
Forever War. Scrapped.
TMNT Forever. In limbo...maybe.
Vol. 4. Unfinished.
Tales. Ending Soon.
Trades. No Dice.
Source Book. Nada.
unreleased craploads of toys
unreleased dvds
list goes on and on and on and on...
Jester
11-03-2009, 10:08 PM
Exactly...it's depressing.
VaughnMichael
11-03-2009, 10:10 PM
Exactly...it's depressing.
As if i wasn't enough already about turnign 30 this year coming up hahahah good way to usher it in with the death of mirage.
oldmanwinters
11-03-2009, 10:10 PM
Is there any other fandom that has so much promised that never materialized?
Forever War. Scrapped.
TMNT Forever. In limbo...maybe.
Vol. 4. Unfinished.
Tales. Ending Soon.
Trades. No Dice.
Source Book. Nada.
"Life at best is bittersweet."
The mantra of the Mirage Turtles.
VaughnMichael
11-03-2009, 10:11 PM
"Life at best is bittersweet."
The mantra of the Mirage Turtles.
The what now? oh yeah didn't there use to be a comic once? :P
TristanHuwJones
11-03-2009, 10:14 PM
Is there any other fandom that has so much promised that never materialized?
Forever War. Scrapped.
TMNT Forever. In limbo...maybe.
Vol. 4. Unfinished.
Tales. Ending Soon.
Trades. No Dice.
Source Book. Nada.
Hey, at least Mirage didn't take money first for any of these, unlike 88mph did with the Ghostbusters book!
I would argue that GB fans have had it way worse off than TMNT fans. :P
Jester
11-03-2009, 10:16 PM
Touche' Trist. :D
Raph's Girl
11-03-2009, 10:20 PM
Hey, at least Mirage didn't take money first for any of these, unlike 88mph did with the Ghostbusters book!
I would argue that GB fans have had it way worse off than TMNT fans. :P
Panel to panel had pre-orders available for the Sourcebook a week or so before it was cancelled.
oldmanwinters
11-03-2009, 10:20 PM
Hey, at least Mirage didn't take money first for any of these, unlike 88mph did with the Ghostbusters book!
I would argue that GB fans have had it way worse off than TMNT fans. :P
Yeah, I think I agree with that. The popularity of the Ghostbusters is still huge and the only things that have happened with that franchise are "eXtreme Ghostbusters" (probably not what most fans would have preferred), a mini-series that doesn't necessarily capture the tone of the source material (emphasis of edgy violence over clever humor), a recent set of video games, and promises,promises,promises!
Well, at least there is the Complete Series on DVD!
CyberCubed
11-03-2009, 10:56 PM
Forever War. Scrapped.
Murphy's fault entirely, cannot be blamed on Mirage or Nick or Peter Laird.
TMNT Forever. In limbo...maybe.
This will come out eventually. To think a fully animated DTV would never be released is absurd.
Vol. 4. Unfinished.
We've been getting 1 issue a year for awhile now. Peter will probably finish it eventually.
Tales. Ending Soon.
It was going to end anyway. We got 70 issues out of it, so it was a great run.
Trades. No Dice.
Source Book. Nada.
Yeah this is unfortunate, but what can you do.
plastroncafe
11-03-2009, 11:16 PM
Hey, at least Mirage didn't take money first for any of these, unlike 88mph did with the Ghostbusters book!
I would argue that GB fans have had it way worse off than TMNT fans. :P
Total threadjack, but this comment totally has me weighing the artistic merits of Bobby Brown and Vanilla Ice.
What if we somehow exchanged Lord Vigo with the Super Shredder...
Okay, sorry. I'll stop now.
Powder
11-03-2009, 11:19 PM
"Life at best is bittersweet."
The mantra of the Mirage Turtles.
I was gonna say that actually. It's honestly sad.
plastroncafe
11-03-2009, 11:22 PM
[QUOTE= Originally Posted by oldmanwinters View Post
"Life at best is bittersweet."
The mantra of the Mirage Turtles.[/QUOTE]
I've been trying to keep with, "Life is good, and life goes on."
But yeah...that line of Kirby's seems to resonate a whole lot louder.
Especially this year.
Sucks. So far nothing good has come out of the Viacom purchase. I know it's only been a couple of weeks, but everything is bad news lately.
Not a good way for the 25th anniversary to end.
TristanHuwJones
11-04-2009, 02:22 AM
Panel to panel had pre-orders available for the Sourcebook a week or so before it was cancelled.
Refunds were given. I'm still out of pocket 70 bucks to that scumbag that ran 88mph.
Powder
11-04-2009, 02:29 AM
Sucks. So far nothing good has come out of the Viacom purchase. I know it's only been a couple of weeks, but everything is bad news lately.
Not a good way for the 25th anniversary to end.
Not that it really started on a 'good' note to begin with :/
darthsmozers
11-04-2009, 09:26 AM
Steve has told me that "The Forever War" is officially cancelled.
well this is indeed a real dissapointment.
Buffy
11-04-2009, 01:13 PM
This was the one thing I was looking forward to. Do'h! :(
Cipher
11-04-2009, 02:21 PM
"Life at best is bittersweet."
The mantra of the Mirage Turtles.If Volume 4/the entire series doesn't end on this quote, I will be ... moderately disappointed.
Anyway, I'm not as big a TMNTA fan as some people here (though I like what I've read). To be honest I was always looking foward more to new Mirage issues and trades. But, I do feel for the people who won't get that proper ending they've been waiting for. It does seem like Murphy's heart was never really in it to begin with, though.
CyberCubed
11-04-2009, 02:28 PM
It does seem like Murphy's heart was never really in it to begin with, though.
This. There was really no excuse this time for Murphy to continue sitting on the project for so long.
He had what...3 years? Didn't they announce back in 2007 that "The Forever War" was greenlit again?
Master Splinter
11-04-2009, 03:12 PM
This. There was really no excuse this time for Murphy to continue sitting on the project for so long.
He had what...3 years? Didn't they announce back in 2007 that "The Forever War" was greenlit again?
I am sorry for being so clueless but I wouldn't mind some insight... I haven't read hardly any of TMNTA so I am just guessing here from what I pick up from the forum...
From what I can tell Archie stopped with TMNTA like 10 years ago or something... And the story was kinda dropped off but in a state where a "Forever War" was going to start... There have been some rumors but nothing released and then there was a greenlight but there were some technical issues and now it is canceled for good...
I apologize for not being up to speed on what's all happening in the comicverse but this strikes me as very interesting and I would like to educate myself a little more on this...
Thanks all knowledgeable ones!!!
-mm
Ninjinister
11-04-2009, 04:59 PM
This. There was really no excuse this time for Murphy to continue sitting on the project for so long.
He had what...3 years? Didn't they announce back in 2007 that "The Forever War" was greenlit again?
You don't know the man. He had many reasons - for one thing, as he publicly admitted on his blog before it went the way of the dinosaur - that he just wasn't into writing TMNT stuff anymore. Furthermore, both he and the illustrator had other things on their plates than just Forever War.
I'm very disappointed it's been canned, but like Mirage Universe, there are very good reasons it took forever to be worked on.
When I first registered here and asked about archie people told me it was the perfect time since Forever War will come out "soon". That was what nearly five years ago? So it appears this has the same fate as Duke Nukem Forever.
I also think it was entirely Murphy's fault and he deserves to get flack for it, why let the fans think about this for so long and hyping them for all this time?
Anyways I'm not a huge fan of archie and I'm kinda bummed, it would have been nice to see an ending to the series. However I also think most would have ended up being disappointed, it wouldn't have been able to live up to fans dreams. Also the whole fact that the Forever War wasn't the one that was going to be released years ago or anything, it was "forever war" in name only. It would have been a new story not really getting a lost story from back in the day. While a new story would still have been nice to have you were never going to get "the forever war". Also counting he had already lost interest in the turtles by this point even if it had come out it wouldn't have been as great as it could have when he was still "interested" in them.
CyberCubed
11-04-2009, 05:26 PM
that he just wasn't into writing TMNT stuff anymore. Furthermore, both he and the illustrator had other things on their plates than just Forever War.
Then either it should have never been promised to the fanbase again unless he had the free time to work on it, or he should have given the preliminary outline to the story to Jim Lawson or someone to do the art.
Now it just seems like a broken promise. He even reduced the issue count down from 5 issues to 3 issues which would have given him the time to do it. His heart wasn't in it.
Rooish
11-04-2009, 05:32 PM
Maybe Murphy can just tell us what was supposed to happen, to satisfy our curiosity.
Lordmylar06
11-04-2009, 05:57 PM
Maybe Murphy can just tell us what was supposed to happen, to satisfy our curiosity.
I'll second that thought. Maybe a script? I'd love to take a crack at drawing a page or 2 from the story. That would be a cool fan project...
TristanHuwJones
11-04-2009, 07:30 PM
Then either it should have never been promised to the fanbase again unless he had the free time to work on it, or he should have given the preliminary outline to the story to Jim Lawson or someone to do the art.
Now it just seems like a broken promise. He even reduced the issue count down from 5 issues to 3 issues which would have given him the time to do it. His heart wasn't in it.
Just out of curiosity, were are all these promises people keep making mention of. I don't remember anyone promising anything.
ToTheNines
11-04-2009, 07:54 PM
It was advertised in at least one TMNT comic.
CyberCubed
11-04-2009, 08:56 PM
Just out of curiosity, were are all these promises people keep making mention of. I don't remember anyone promising anything.
Isn't that what the whole TPB "Future Tense" was for? It collected issues from the Archie run about Armaggon and the future Cyber Turtles...for what?
I bought that TPB and I liked seeing Archie stories re-printed, but now it feels like it led up to nothing.
TristanHuwJones
11-04-2009, 09:11 PM
There's a massive difference between promising something and preparing for something. The only officially announced book that's been canceled is the Mirage Sourcebook.
Roseangelo
11-04-2009, 09:16 PM
There's a massive difference between promising something and preparing for something. The only officially announced book that's been canceled is the Mirage Sourcebook.
The Forever War was officially announced (http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_o-v2tRqWXY8/SeqEw3BkDyI/AAAAAAAABiA/sMX8mApfJsY/s1600-h/forever-war-ad.jpg), it just didn't get to the point of being solicited in Previews.
oldmanwinters
11-04-2009, 09:38 PM
The Forever War was officially announced (http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_o-v2tRqWXY8/SeqEw3BkDyI/AAAAAAAABiA/sMX8mApfJsY/s1600-h/forever-war-ad.jpg), it just didn't get to the point of being solicited in Previews.
Oh man, I would like to know how much of the storyline is at least written down or in artistic form. It might make me feel better if Murph released his rough draft or something like that.
I am sad. :cry:
TristanHuwJones
11-04-2009, 11:01 PM
The Forever War was officially announced (http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_o-v2tRqWXY8/SeqEw3BkDyI/AAAAAAAABiA/sMX8mApfJsY/s1600-h/forever-war-ad.jpg), it just didn't get to the point of being solicited in Previews.
Okay, the only officiall SOLICITED book that has been canceled was the Universe book.
Andrew NDB
11-04-2009, 11:51 PM
Okay, the only officiall SOLICITED book that has been canceled was the Universe book.
It was officially solicited to readers of Tales of the TMNT.
Venom
11-05-2009, 12:28 AM
Hehe, now you're just nitpicking.
Roseangelo
11-05-2009, 12:40 AM
Hehe, now you're just nitpicking.
Well, trying to say that we weren't promised the Forever War also seems to be nitpicking.
Spitfire
11-05-2009, 03:32 AM
Why is it things with "Forever" in the title appear to be doomed to failure?
TristanHuwJones
11-05-2009, 03:53 AM
Well, it might just be me, but offering and promising are two completely different things, so it's not nitpicking. A lot of people have been saying that things were promised when they never were, and promise incites a more emotional response because it's a far deeper word than offer or attempt (not quite words I'm after but you'll get the idea). It's an oath of commitment to something. If someone offered to do something, but ultimately didn't I wouldn't be anywhere near as bugged by it as I would be if someone promised me they'd do something and didn't. I don't remember anything being promised, and an add or teaser poster or image doesn't constitute a promise as far as I'm concerned. The NECA series 2 figures, and the Playmates comics figures fall into the same category as the Forever War -- something that could have happened, and something that should have happened, but didn't and likely won't, and because there was no promise that these things would happen, it doesn't bother me (much).
Spitfire
11-05-2009, 04:25 AM
Well, it might just be me, but offering and promising are two completely different things, so it's not nitpicking. A lot of people have been saying that things were promised when they never were, and promise incites a more emotional response because it's a far deeper word than offer or attempt (not quite words I'm after but you'll get the idea). It's an oath of commitment to something. If someone offered to do something, but ultimately didn't I wouldn't be anywhere near as bugged by it as I would be if someone promised me they'd do something and didn't. I don't remember anything being promised, and an add or teaser poster or image doesn't constitute a promise as far as I'm concerned. The NECA series 2 figures, and the Playmates comics figures fall into the same category as the Forever War -- something that could have happened, and something that should have happened, but didn't and likely won't, and because there was no promise that these things would happen, it doesn't bother me (much).
This along with everything you've just mentioned falls under "**** tease" in my book. Even if it wasn't a promise it evokes emotion in me. That emotion is disappointment and anger. I see companies complaining about not making enough money off turtles when they refuse to make good on products they advertise. That's a great way to lose customers.
If NECA hadn't released pictures of the 2nd wave, especially ones where they appear completed, people wouldn't be so mad they were never released. If Ubisoft didn't tell us in every interview that Smash Up was gonna be the second coming for turtles fans we wouldn't be so mad about the roster. Lastly if Mirage hadn't told us they were dusting off Forever War we wouldn't be so disappointed. They advertised it, released a trade to promote sales and catch up readers, and told us a exact date it was coming. The fact it just never happened is just really poor business. If Marvel pulled crap like that people would be rioting. These companies are lucky turtles isn't bigger then it is. I believe it's because of this the fanbase is more tightly nit and we take it more personally when stuff like this happens. It's like a punch in the face. You're loyal to a brand for years and the only reward you get is a cancellation of everything you were looking forward to.
TristanHuwJones
11-05-2009, 07:54 AM
Yeah but my point is that you weren't promised any of those things. Take the emotion that you're feeling now and then imagine how much worse things'd be if you HAD been promised them.
Marvel has done it too. Kevin Smith's Bullseye: Target? Favs' Iron Man: Viva Las Vegas? I'm sure there are more.
You're not trying to tell me that you've been loyal to the brand ONLY because you wanted the Forever War to come out, are you? Or the NECA Turtles latter series to come out? Nobody even knew about them prior to 2008 or late 2007, and same with the Forever War. It was only when Murph said he'd been given the greenlight on it that people got all excited.
Did the animated series, the movie, the good issues of the comics, the original NECA figures, the good Playmates figures, TMNT Forever, etc., etc., etc. all mean absolutely nothing?
Coola Yagami
11-05-2009, 08:51 AM
Yeah but my point is that you weren't promised any of those things. Take the emotion that you're feeling now and then imagine how much worse things'd be if you HAD been promised them.
Marvel has done it too. Kevin Smith's Bullseye: Target? Favs' Iron Man: Viva Las Vegas? I'm sure there are more.
You're not trying to tell me that you've been loyal to the brand ONLY because you wanted the Forever War to come out, are you? Or the NECA Turtles latter series to come out? Nobody even knew about them prior to 2008 or late 2007, and same with the Forever War. It was only when Murph said he'd been given the greenlight on it that people got all excited.
Did the animated series, the movie, the good issues of the comics, the original NECA figures, the good Playmates figures, TMNT Forever, etc., etc., etc. all mean absolutely nothing?
There were..... GOOD Playmates figures...?
Spitfire
11-05-2009, 01:05 PM
Yeah but my point is that you weren't promised any of those things. Take the emotion that you're feeling now and then imagine how much worse things'd be if you HAD been promised them.
No I wasn't promised but advertising typically means a product is either finished or close to it and you will be seeing it soon. If your stuff isn't done then don't advertise it. That's just bad business. That is what pisses me off.
Marvel has done it too. Kevin Smith's Bullseye: Target? Favs' Iron Man: Viva Las Vegas? I'm sure there are more.
Where those 15 years in the making and highly desired by virtually the entire fanbase? I'm asking cause I don't follow either character.
You're not trying to tell me that you've been loyal to the brand ONLY because you wanted the Forever War to come out, are you? Or the NECA Turtles latter series to come out? Nobody even knew about them prior to 2008 or late 2007, and same with the Forever War. It was only when Murph said he'd been given the greenlight on it that people got all excited.
Did the animated series, the movie, the good issues of the comics, the original NECA figures, the good Playmates figures, TMNT Forever, etc., etc., etc. all mean absolutely nothing?
Not at all but I feel like the things I do want the most happen to be the canceled ones. This is the 25th anniversary and it's a pretty poor one.
Canceled
NECA Wave 2
Forever War
Sourcebook
Issue #1 animation
The Playmates figures I'd have actually bought
2011 movie*This was due to the buy out however*
The animated series didn't do much for me. To be honest I almost I never watch it and the last season was embarrassingly bad. I'm grateful it was made and there are some good episodes but all in all I can't say I'd rather have more TV show over the listed things above. I hated "TMNT". I hated the designs, most of the animation, and the plot. The 2011 is what should have been made to begin with. I know they did their best with what they had though. Good Playmates figures does not compute. The only PM stuff I've bought all year are the re-issues just for decoration.
Turtles Forever I've yet to see but I'm sure it's awesome. NECA line 1 was also indeed awesome. We finally got the turtles figures we always wanted. Too bad none of the others got the treatment, except April...
So yes you're right. There are some great things we've got, over the past 6 years. Lately though we've been getting screwed left and right. What I do like of what's been released this year is dwarfed by what was supposed to come out, because as I said all the things I really looked forward to were canceled. I actually like Archie better then Mirage.
darthsmozers
11-05-2009, 01:33 PM
Yeah but my point is that you weren't promised any of those things. Take the emotion that you're feeling now and then imagine how much worse things'd be if you HAD been promised them.
Marvel has done it too. Kevin Smith's Bullseye: Target? Favs' Iron Man: Viva Las Vegas? I'm sure there are more.
You're not trying to tell me that you've been loyal to the brand ONLY because you wanted the Forever War to come out, are you? Or the NECA Turtles latter series to come out? Nobody even knew about them prior to 2008 or late 2007, and same with the Forever War. It was only when Murph said he'd been given the greenlight on it that people got all excited.
Did the animated series, the movie, the good issues of the comics, the original NECA figures, the good Playmates figures, TMNT Forever, etc., etc., etc. all mean absolutely nothing?
You're missing the point.
Look at it from the order of events. Back in the early 2000s, a couple of issues of either TMNT or Tales mentioned in the letters columns that the project was being discussed, and eventually was set to be published in the next year or two. That got everyone excited.
Then while still waiting year after year, SM posted some backstory, early cover art, and early interior pencils in his blog. While not an official solicit from Mirage, it obviously built everyone's excitement further.
SM then posted new/unseen cover art concepts on his blog. Even more excitement, as evidence that some ideas were being played around with between he and the artist. More excitement!
The Forever War gets labeled as an upcoming 25th Anniversary Project. Looking good! Excitement!
Its mentioned the number of issues wasn't final, but that indicated the project was still being retooled. Not much of an advance, but still excitement to know it was being worked on.
Future Tense is officially promoted with banner ads and solicits, with it meant to be a lead-in to The Forever War. Here, to answer your question if anyone's support of Mirage was only for TFW, I will say no, BUT support for Future Tense was, in part, to directly show support for TFW, with the thought that "if this sells well, maybe something good will happen", in this case that something good being something that was dangled like a carrot on a string for years, not on blind faith but on the words of Mirage, that it was coming. Future Tense = Excitement and anticipation for TFW, no doubt!
SM releases TFW promo prints at a comic con and online - a direct promotion for the project.
More talk of retooling the script and issue count = still being worked on = hope, excitement, anticipation.
And then..... it all falls flat. Nothing.
How can you nitpick the word promise, after a build-up like that, something thats been that "unfinished ending" to a great series, that was already cancelled once?
Yes, those other elements of the franchise mean something. But its something like this that not only causes a bad taste in the mouth, but a bit of a smack in the face.
Not trying to pick on you but for goodness' sakes, its easy to see how its such a dissapointing turn of events.
TristanHuwJones
11-05-2009, 03:14 PM
You're missing the point.
No, I'm not, I completely understand where you and everyone else are coming from, but the fact is people keep saying and implying that they were promised something, which was never the case.
Yes, it did look like TFW was going to happen. There was so much stuff there indicating this, but my point is that NOTHING was promised, and that there's a difference between promising something and indicating that something would eventually come out.
How can you nitpick the word promise, after a build-up like that, something thats been that "unfinished ending" to a great series, that was already cancelled once?
Because nobody was promised! Like I said before, imagine if he actually had promised it would happen? There'd be reason to get up in arms about it because it was promised, and a promise is something that is sworn to be fulfilled.
Yes, I agree that it's a bitch certain very cool things never eventuated, but some of the responses I've seen to this have just been mystifying. I can understand people being pissed off, but to cry foul about something being promised when it wasn't, and to say that the past X years of fandom have been for nothing (which a number of people -- not necessarily here -- have been saying), seems over the top to me.
There's every possibility that whoever picks up the license to the comics may finish things off. ****, Archie could get the license back, reprint all their classic material and then pick up where Murph left off! I'm not saying it will (certainly not promising anything), but it's a possibility. Just because Mirage can no longer finish the book legally, doesn't mean somebody else can't. It all depends on the license.
Not trying to pick on you but for goodness' sakes, its easy to see how its such a dissapointing turn of events.
I realise that, and as I said, I understand where the disappointment comes from, but I stand by what I've said. If we actually were promised these books, then I would understand why there has been such a vehement backlash, but really this is no different to what happened with NECA.
Roseangelo
11-05-2009, 03:19 PM
Tristan, now you're just sounding silly. :blanksta:
CyberCubed
11-05-2009, 03:25 PM
Did Murphy ever explain why he couldn't be bothered to get this out?
You know, aside from him constantly saying he lost interest in the TMNT as characters, and taking shots at both Gary Richardson and Peter Laird on his blog.
If Muphy was so fed up with Mirage and TMNT, he should have never "promised" us that he would get out the Forever War. But now that Mirage is closing down, Murphy never has to work on another TMNT project again.
I hope he's happy he left the fans feeling empty inside.
Archon_Turtle
11-05-2009, 03:33 PM
Did Murphy ever explain why he couldn't be bothered to get this out?
You know, aside from him constantly saying he lost interest in the TMNT as characters, and taking shots at both Gary Richardson and Peter Laird on his blog.
If Muphy was so fed up with Mirage and TMNT, he should have never "promised" us that he would get out the Forever War. But now that Mirage is closing down, Murphy never has to work on another TMNT project again.
I hope he's happy he left the fans feeling empty inside.
Are you saying you would rather he churn out something he has absolutely NO creative interest in? Cause...you know...that always leads to quality products. Personally, I'd rather use my imagination .
Andrew NDB
11-05-2009, 03:44 PM
Are you saying you would rather he churn out something he has absolutely NO creative interest in?
I'd be OK with that over nothing. You guys? Yep. I think most of us would be OK with that. :)
Seriously, though, I think he'd be lying if he ever said he had no invested interest in the project whatsoever, creative or otherwise.
Archon_Turtle
11-05-2009, 04:09 PM
I'd be OK with that over nothing. You guys? Yep. I think most of us would be OK with that. :)
Jerkface. :-P
Seriously, though, I think he'd be lying if he ever said he had no invested interest in the project whatsoever, creative or otherwise.
Without trying to be argumentative, I honestly don't know about that. I mean...I dunno...I talk to the guy all the time (as I'm pretty sure you do as well). Love him to death, like any other of the Mirage gang. But damn if he isn't burnt out...badly. I really just don't think his heart is in it anymore. I think he would rather undergo discount brain surgery than work on that book.
Lordmylar06
11-05-2009, 04:17 PM
I really like Mr. Murphy, he's always been very polite and understanding to me. I recently bought something from him on ebay and when he realized that I was a fan of his work he expressed gratitude. He may have been burned out, and he may have lost interest, but he hid it well in the few emails I read. I know Forever War was advertised and hyped quite a bit, and I was dissapointed too when I found out it wasn't going to drop, but I think that we(fanbase in general) give these guys too much grief over trivial shortcomings. They're only HUMAN. This story was highly anticipated by alot of us, but it was NOT dire in any way. Forgive and forget.
TristanHuwJones
11-05-2009, 04:18 PM
I would agree with this now, but it might not have been the case back when he first announced it on his blog.
Without trying to be argumentative, I honestly don't know about that. I mean...I dunno...I talk to the guy all the time (as I'm pretty sure you do as well). Love him to death, like any other of the Mirage gang. But damn if he isn't burnt out...badly. I really just don't think his heart is in it anymore. I think he would rather undergo discount brain surgery than work on that book.
Andrew NDB
11-05-2009, 04:29 PM
I don't understand. What did Steve have to be upset about? He was promoted at Mirage, I thought. :)
Ninjinister
11-05-2009, 04:52 PM
Well, among other things, I know the state of the environment depressed him something awful...
Master Splinter
11-05-2009, 05:03 PM
Well, among other things, I know the state of the environment depressed him something awful...
I know everyone is a little busy bickering about false promises and the technicality of a promise... I am just wondering if someone can fill me in on the timeline of events here???? I asked a couple pages back but nobody seemed to respond... Show some knowledge and educate someone who is very interested in the "Forever War" but really has no idea about it at all...
I admit that I don't really get into the TMNT comics too much, I am more of a cartoon, toy, fan art kinda guy and never had the money to get into the comics and all of the hype of the Forever War has got me intrigued like I missed something incredible and whatnot...
Soooo... let's take a breath for a moment and someone just fill me in on what is going on here... How long has this been promised? What is the actual "Forever War" suppose to be? When was it suppose to come out? Because from what I am picking up here and there is that this has been promised for a long time but is canceled completely now... I just want to know the full story of what this is all about etc... Or do I just not have enough street cred to get some answers from what appears to me to be some of the most knowledgeable TMNT fans out there... Help me learn, puh puh purrty please... :evilgrin:
-mm
Master Splinter
11-05-2009, 05:09 PM
You're missing the point.
Look at it from the order of events. Back in the early 2000s, a couple of issues of either TMNT or Tales mentioned in the letters columns that the project was being discussed, and eventually was set to be published in the next year or two. That got everyone excited.
Then while still waiting year after year, SM posted some backstory, early cover art, and early interior pencils in his blog. While not an official solicit from Mirage, it obviously built everyone's excitement further.
SM then posted new/unseen cover art concepts on his blog. Even more excitement, as evidence that some ideas were being played around with between he and the artist. More excitement!
The Forever War gets labeled as an upcoming 25th Anniversary Project. Looking good! Excitement!
Its mentioned the number of issues wasn't final, but that indicated the project was still being retooled. Not much of an advance, but still excitement to know it was being worked on.
Future Tense is officially promoted with banner ads and solicits, with it meant to be a lead-in to The Forever War. Here, to answer your question if anyone's support of Mirage was only for TFW, I will say no, BUT support for Future Tense was, in part, to directly show support for TFW, with the thought that "if this sells well, maybe something good will happen", in this case that something good being something that was dangled like a carrot on a string for years, not on blind faith but on the words of Mirage, that it was coming. Future Tense = Excitement and anticipation for TFW, no doubt!
SM releases TFW promo prints at a comic con and online - a direct promotion for the project.
More talk of retooling the script and issue count = still being worked on = hope, excitement, anticipation.
And then..... it all falls flat. Nothing.
How can you nitpick the word promise, after a build-up like that, something thats been that "unfinished ending" to a great series, that was already cancelled once?
Yes, those other elements of the franchise mean something. But its something like this that not only causes a bad taste in the mouth, but a bit of a smack in the face.
Not trying to pick on you but for goodness' sakes, its easy to see how its such a dissapointing turn of events.
Sorry for double posting but I didn't see this post on page 5... This helps answer a few of my questions...
So here is my other question... Does anyone know what the story was suppose to be?
THANKS!!!
Oh and if anyone has anything to include in the timeline of events to lead up to this cancellation let me know... This is interesting stuff...
oldmanwinters
11-05-2009, 05:17 PM
Are you saying you would rather he churn out something he has absolutely NO creative interest in? Cause...you know...that always leads to quality products. Personally, I'd rather use my imagination .
I would. For me, one more go-around with the Archie TMNT would be worth it regardless of story quality. Plus, I figured Murphy knew those characters so well that even if he was just going through the motions it would have been a solid effort out of sheer "muscle memory.":)
DrSpengler
11-05-2009, 07:24 PM
Going by a lot of Murphy's older blog posts, he apparently suffers from very serious, if possibly clinical levels of debilitating depression. I don't know the specifics, it's his personal life, none of my business.
My point is, with that sort of health issue in mind, I can easily see him getting very fed up or burned out or sick of or WHATEVER, regarding the Turtles and not wanting to do them anymore.
I've dealt with people who have issues with clinical depression (my mother was a very serious level of bipolar). It may not seem possible to us, but for people with those sorts of issues it can happen and at the drop of a hat without any notice or minimal build-up.
So far as "promises" go, I suppose I'd only consider it a true blue "promise" if The Forever War had been properly solicited by Mirage or Diamond or what have you. If it never got that far, then it wasn't a promise at least on a professional level.
But yeah, I am VERY bummed out that we won't be getting the book. It seems that of all the TMNT media, the comics have been getting the shaft via this deal. I know that there are possibilities on the horizon if Viacom licenses the franchise out to Dark Horse or IDW or whoever, but with nothing concrete to ease our sorrows, "future possibilities" don't really satisfy.
I mean, Forever War was a "future possibility" for five years and look what happened...
Spitfire
11-05-2009, 08:09 PM
Are you saying you would rather he churn out something he has absolutely NO creative interest in? Cause...you know...that always leads to quality products. Personally, I'd rather use my imagination .
Someone else could write it. The scripts are there let someone else study the source material and finish it. Sometimes bringing in fresh blood is not only a good way to advance the story but it helps you get out of creative blocks. There's at least 10 turtles fans who are capable of writing a good story and already know all the back story. Not saying it should just be a fan but you get what I mean.
darthsmozers
11-05-2009, 08:27 PM
Going by a lot of Murphy's older blog posts, he apparently suffers from very serious, if possibly clinical levels of debilitating depression. I don't know the specifics, it's his personal life, none of my business.
My point is, with that sort of health issue in mind, I can easily see him getting very fed up or burned out or sick of or WHATEVER, regarding the Turtles and not wanting to do them anymore.
I've dealt with people who have issues with clinical depression (my mother was a very serious level of bipolar). It may not seem possible to us, but for people with those sorts of issues it can happen and at the drop of a hat without any notice or minimal build-up.
So far as "promises" go, I suppose I'd only consider it a true blue "promise" if The Forever War had been properly solicited by Mirage or Diamond or what have you. If it never got that far, then it wasn't a promise at least on a professional level.
But yeah, I am VERY bummed out that we won't be getting the book. It seems that of all the TMNT media, the comics have been getting the shaft via this deal. I know that there are possibilities on the horizon if Viacom licenses the franchise out to Dark Horse or IDW or whoever, but with nothing concrete to ease our sorrows, "future possibilities" don't really satisfy.
I mean, Forever War was a "future possibility" for five years and look what happened...
This is very true, and good of you to point out (re: the depression). And I hope no opinions here turn into something against the man himself. I don't think thats the case. I think its general frustration overall.
Because nobody was promised! Like I said before, imagine if he actually had promised it would happen? There'd be reason to get up in arms about it because it was promised, and a promise is something that is sworn to be fulfilled.
Tristan, i hear what youre saying. But while it may not have been spelled out as "I, Steve Murphy, promise fans that they will get the Forever War", the number of times it was said by the staff that it was coming, it received the green light, it was on the schedule, it would be part of the anniversary, it was being worked on, and 'hey here's a lead-in book purposely put together as a prelude to the new story', that's promise enough. It may have not reached the solicit stage, but it was promise enough. the splitting of hairs over the word promise is really not much to stand on. its a sad excuse. otherwise anyone in entertainement can talk about upcoming movies, books, games, projects, etc, and if something goes wrong say "well, i never actually said 'i promise' so it doesn't count". you see? poor excuse.
anyway, again, not picking on you or anything. just trying to articulate some things.
in short, it was bad business, it got cancelled with hardly any care for the long and drawn out excitement and anticipation we've had, and it just leaves a bad taste. true, lots of factors to consider, personal and otherwise i'm sure, but it was still bad business and done poorly.
darthsmozers
11-05-2009, 08:29 PM
Sorry for double posting but I didn't see this post on page 5... This helps answer a few of my questions...
So here is my other question... Does anyone know what the story was suppose to be?
THANKS!!!
Oh and if anyone has anything to include in the timeline of events to lead up to this cancellation let me know... This is interesting stuff...
well, nothing was ever really produced other than some mockups and rough drafts. we could have assumed the future turtles, and heroes and villains throughout the time line of the archie turtles universe. if youre new to the TMNT archie universe, i definitely suggest reading the series, despite this dissapointing turn of events. still an awesome read.
TristanHuwJones
11-05-2009, 09:34 PM
anyway, again, not picking on you or anything. just trying to articulate some things.
No, I know, I know, and I'm not swiping back at you, what I'm trying to get across is that there are people out there bandying the word around and treating the whole thing like some kind of stolen birth rite. Some of the emails I've got, private messages and responses I saw on the Mirage facebook and twitter were just ridiculous in how unnecessarily down they were because of this... and I'm seeing similar things being said here. This is all I'm saying. I completely understand why people are pissed off, but there is absolutely nothing that can, or will be done about it. Murph has to help with the final handover of everything, and I'm pretty sure that once that's done, he'll be done with the Turtles for good.
oldmanwinters
11-05-2009, 10:14 PM
No, I know, I know, and I'm not swiping back at you, what I'm trying to get across is that there are people out there bandying the word around and treating the whole thing like some kind of stolen birth rite. Some of the emails I've got, private messages and responses I saw on the Mirage facebook and twitter were just ridiculous in how unnecessarily down they were because of this... and I'm seeing similar things being said here. This is all I'm saying. I completely understand why people are pissed off, but there is absolutely nothing that can, or will be done about it. Murph has to help with the final handover of everything, and I'm pretty sure that once that's done, he'll be done with the Turtles for good.
I wonder if there is any chance he hands his Forever War story notes onto someone else?
TristanHuwJones
11-05-2009, 10:47 PM
I wonder if there is any chance he hands his Forever War story notes onto someone else?
I don't think it would do any good. Unless we could get a writer that could do it over night, and an artist that could bang the whole thing out before December 15, then it would miss the End-of-Year Deadline.
CyberCubed
11-05-2009, 10:53 PM
I don't think it would do any good. Unless we could get a writer that could do it over night, and an artist that could bang the whole thing out before December 15, then it would miss the End-of-Year Deadline.
Is there any reason it can't be worked on till May 2010?
Let me get this straight, Mirage isn't allowed to print comics outside the Mirage universe? Mirage can no longer do anything with the Archie universe?
That seems really strange to me. Its still a comic book.
TristanHuwJones
11-05-2009, 10:57 PM
Is there any reason it can't be worked on till May 2010?
Let me get this straight, Mirage isn't allowed to print comics outside the Mirage universe? Mirage can no longer do anything with the Archie universe?
That seems really strange to me. Its still a comic book.
Dude, it's been stated plenty of times now why this can't happen. Nick owns everything, but they've allowed Peter to continue publishing HIS stories to very specific guidelines. Tales is being allowed to run until #70, because that was something already in place, much like the other contracts Viacom are honoring until they need to be renewed.
CyberCubed
11-05-2009, 10:59 PM
And if, for some reason, Peter wants to do another comic that is not part of Volume 4, a one-issue special if you will, it wouldn't be allowed?
oldmanwinters
11-05-2009, 11:00 PM
I don't think it would do any good. Unless we could get a writer that could do it over night, and an artist that could bang the whole thing out before December 15, then it would miss the End-of-Year Deadline.
I was thinking more along the lines of a Nick/Viacom approved project, but it really wouldn't be the same without Chris Allan's art.
If nothing else, I'd just love to know where Murphy was intending to go with the plot.
TristanHuwJones
11-05-2009, 11:02 PM
That I'm not so sure about. It might have to be something set exclusively in the Mirage U... I'll see what I can find out.
Andrew NDB
11-06-2009, 12:54 AM
And if, for some reason, Peter wants to do another comic that is not part of Volume 4, a one-issue special if you will, it wouldn't be allowed?
As long as it's Mirage Universe and it meets the page # limit it would be allowed, from my understanding.
Though I do bet there's another layer to the clause that is something like, "Even though Peter Laird/Mirage can publish 18 Mirage TMNT books a year, they'll still kind of need to give us a rough, brief heads up as to what those contain and we'll need to skim'em over."
darthsmozers
11-06-2009, 07:07 AM
That I'm not so sure about. It might have to be something set exclusively in the Mirage U... I'll see what I can find out.
well, since that issue of Tales showed a sort of multiverse, then I guess all TMNT universes are fair game :P I KID!!
darthsmozers
11-06-2009, 07:08 AM
I was thinking more along the lines of a Nick/Viacom approved project, but it really wouldn't be the same without Chris Allan's art.
I dont know if he even knows, since he recently scrapped his ideas and wanted to start over again.
and i think if we go down the path of another writer and artist, it opens the door to heavy criticism, like "so and so wouldn't have done it that way", etc.
Lieutenant Granitor
11-06-2009, 12:51 PM
Is Forever War based on Turtles Forever, or is it some comics remix or something? I would love that to come out, if Murphy doesn't do it, I'll make him do it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Mythril_7
11-06-2009, 01:18 PM
Whether Murphy gets blamed or not, doesn't make me any less upset that I don't get to see an attempt at closure. :x
Andrew NDB
11-06-2009, 01:18 PM
Is Forever War based on Turtles Forever
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA...
No.
ZariusTwo
11-07-2009, 03:17 AM
Is Forever War based on Turtles Forever, or is it some comics remix or something? I would love that to come out, if Murphy doesn't do it, I'll make him do it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Will you skip school on that occasion too?:roll:
Powder
11-07-2009, 03:38 AM
ban ban ban :D I'm done.
DMC362
11-07-2009, 06:42 AM
Correct me if I am wrong but I remembering reading an interview with Chris Allan (late 90s early 00s) that said the story was about Shredder going back in time stopping the turtles mutation. Before they were erased from time Future Don with his dying breath pulled the guys out of the time line. The rest of the story was about them fighting Shredder in the new time line that was created. Some part of this was implied when Murphy posted some old pages on his blog.
The interview also had the proposed cover art for the series also. Which has been re-posted many times since then.
I posted this because some asked what the orginal story was so I though I would share the little info I remember.
Tuxedo Moroboshi
11-07-2009, 07:59 AM
Is Forever War based on Turtles Forever, or is it some comics remix or something?
What? Ugh, no. Not even close. The Forever War is the ending story to the Archie TMNT universe.
CyberCubed
11-07-2009, 10:52 PM
I guess I will have to continue to use "Year of the Turtle" as the end of the Archie run.
Even though it was done by different people, it was more of an ending to the Archie run than anything else.
TristanHuwJones
11-07-2009, 11:08 PM
That was actually written by one of my favourite comics writers.
oldmanwinters
11-07-2009, 11:24 PM
I guess I will have to continue to use "Year of the Turtle" as the end of the Archie run.
Even though it was done by different people, it was more of an ending to the Archie run than anything else.
I figured even back in the day that "Year of the Turtle" was Archie's Plan B for ending the series. Even still, it satisfied me as an ending to the series in spite of some discontinuity issues with the established canon up to that point.
I really liked Yoshi's line to Mikey at the end:
"That was the last Turtles story. Now you know them all."
Except the one epic tale that never got approved nor finished, yo!:lol:
That was actually written by one of my favourite comics writers.
I would also add: "well illustrated!"
Roseangelo
11-07-2009, 11:25 PM
I figured even back in the day that "Year of the Turtle" was Archie's Plan B for ending the series.
No, it wasn't.
oldmanwinters
11-07-2009, 11:29 PM
No, it wasn't.
Um, Plan C then? :-D
Or were they looking to jumpstart a whole new continuity if the sales were good enough?
Roseangelo
11-07-2009, 11:32 PM
Or were they looking to jumpstart a whole new continuity if the sales were good enough?
At best this is what they planned. I mean, if sales were huge they very well could have continued, but I just always saw it as three stand-alone issues with no relation to the previous 72. And, unlike how The Forever War was expected to have finished the series, there was no indication to expect anything beyond those three issues.
Andrew NDB
11-07-2009, 11:50 PM
At best this is what they planned. I mean, if sales were huge they very well could have continued, but I just always saw it as three stand-alone issues with no relation to the previous 72. And, unlike how The Forever War was expected to have finished the series, there was no indication to expect anything beyond those three issues.
Until "Year of the Turtle" was intended to "feel out" if there was public interest in a new start. There wasn't.
CyberCubed
11-08-2009, 12:13 AM
It really doesn't matter at this point if "Year of the Turtle" was going to spin a new set of comics or not.
It was the last Archie story printed. It had a final battle with the Turtles Vs. Shredder. Splinter had his human origin of Hamato Yoshi (rather than being a rat), and Shredder loses his mind at the end.
Splinter's line, "This is the last Turtle story. After this one you'll have heard them all" always made it sound like they were aware this was the final story.
I don't care that it wasn't written by Murphy, now that The Forever War is never coming, I'd rather use that as the ending than issue 72, which had a story about the Turtles as 8 year olds discovering their weapons.
Andrew NDB
11-08-2009, 01:11 AM
Splinter's line, "This is the last Turtle story. After this one you'll have heard them all" always made it sound like they were aware this was the final story.
But they weren't and it wasn't intended to be. Full page ads appeared all over Archie Comics at the time talking about the "New Beginning!" that "Year of the Turtle" was to be.
It just didn't click.
oldmanwinters
11-09-2009, 10:16 PM
Full page ads appeared all over Archie Comics at the time talking about the "New Beginning!" that "Year of the Turtle" was to be.
Ah, I do remember that campaign now. But I kinda doubted I'd be seeing any new comics after the third issue.
TheShowstoppa
11-12-2009, 01:50 AM
I had to e-mail Dan because I had this exact topic on my mind today. He said, and I quote, "The Deadline was not met, so it may never see the light of day. However, never say never."
I was really looking forward to this, because I hunted down the last few issues to read of Adventures because I was pumped at the thought.
Now... It'll never be completed....
...But never say never, right?
Andrew NDB
11-12-2009, 02:59 AM
I had to e-mail Dan because I had this exact topic on my mind today. He said, and I quote, "The Deadline was not met, so it may never see the light of day. However, never say never."
Dan will always put a positive spin on anything inherently negative, bless his heart.
Powder
11-12-2009, 03:29 AM
You can say that again.
Time Mistress
11-21-2009, 02:30 PM
Sad it hear it won't see the light of day, as I finally found the Future Shark trade. But the update is apreciated so we at least know why its not coming.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.