PDA

View Full Version : Unresolved plotlines in the Mirage run?


CyberCubed
11-09-2009, 11:17 AM
Aside from the all the stuff going on in Volume 4, which Peter will hopefully finish some day, what other unresolved plotlines are there in the Mirage run?

I know of the woman from Tales #22 with the Shredder gauntlets, but what else?

Cipher
11-09-2009, 02:24 PM
Not counting Volume 4?

Cha Ocho's conflict with Leo. Tristan's gangland run. What exactly Complete Carnage was doing for fifty years. The infamous "murdered Splinter" vision. The rogue Foot Mystics first seen in Tales Vol 2 #2. I'm sure there's more.

I guess you could also count a general lack of information on the old Turtles. Especially Mike.

CyberCubed
11-09-2009, 02:32 PM
Cha Ocho's conflict with Leo.

Isn't that a Volume 4 plotline? We already had their past covered. Ocho and Raph also went to a bar together and fought off aliens, its not like Ocho is an enemy.

Tristan's gangland run.

Tristan should pitch his story to another comic company and become head writer.

What exactly Complete Carnage was doing for fifty years.

Is this really essential? He and Radical probably had some more confrontations with her winning, like any other superhero Vs. arch nemesis story.

The infamous "murdered Splinter" vision.

Don cut off Splinter's fur.

The rogue Foot Mystics first seen in Tales Vol 2 #2.

Yeah, I should have mentioned that.

I guess you could also count a general lack of information on the old Turtles. Especially Mike.

I think that's better left as a mystery. Everytime Mirage tries to explain something, like Rat King's backstory or what happened at the end of Vol. 2, they end up ruining it. Best to leave it to the imagination.

Cipher
11-09-2009, 02:35 PM
I wasn't saying the all need to, or even should be, expanded upon. Just that they're not entirely closed off.

And Cha Ocho's not really just a Volume 4 thing. You can tell he was being set up as a more major character who probably won't ever get his pay-off. He's peripheral in Volume 4, if anything.

oldmanwinters
11-09-2009, 03:48 PM
I think that's better left as a mystery. Everytime Mirage tries to explain something, like Rat King's backstory or what happened at the end of Vol. 2, they end up ruining it. Best to leave it to the imagination.

Ain't that the truth!:)

Roseangelo
11-09-2009, 03:50 PM
I guess you could also count a general lack of information on the old Turtles. Especially Mike.

This is the one and only thing I actually care about.

oldmanwinters
11-09-2009, 03:59 PM
Especially Mike.

Now old Mikey in particular, I do want to know about, come to think of it. That line delivered by old Raph at the end of Tales #55 was pretty cryptic.

Also, what was up with that robot "April?":o

PAAATE
11-09-2009, 04:19 PM
Tristan should pitch his story to another comic company and become head writer.

Hear hear!

TristanHuwJones
11-09-2009, 04:50 PM
Hear hear!

Problem is, I can pitch all I want, but unless a company sees that there's a market/demand for it, it won't happen. My suggestion? Let them know there's demand ;)

ToTheNines
11-09-2009, 08:03 PM
Now old Mikey in particular, I do want to know about, come to think of it. That line delivered by old Raph at the end of Tales #55 was pretty cryptic.

Also, what was up with that robot "April?":o

I remember seeing future Mike in "Swan Song", but no where else.

Problem is, I can pitch all I want, but unless a company sees that there's a market/demand for it, it won't happen. My suggestion? Let them know there's demand ;)

Could you post the links for those forums again?

oldmanwinters
11-09-2009, 10:14 PM
I remember seeing future Mike in "Swan Song", but no where else.


Wasn't that appearance actually just his hologram form?

Cipher
11-09-2009, 10:16 PM
Wasn't that appearance actually just his hologram form?You're thinking of the Tales book frontispieces.

"Swan Song" is the Leonardo-Complete Carnage vengeance issue. There is indeed a glimpse of an older Mike at Radical's funeral.

ToTheNines
11-09-2009, 10:16 PM
Wasn't that appearance actually just his hologram form?

It just showed him in the background at Rads funeral, I think.

DrSpengler
11-09-2009, 10:32 PM
So far as unresolved plotlines go, this one's sort of a Tales/Vol. 4 hybrid.

What happened to Leatherhead between Tales #61 and Vol. 4 #17?

In Tales #61 (which takes place during that 6 month gap in Vol. 4 #5), Leatherhead is a scientist working with the Utroms on Earth. In Vol. 4 #17, which takes place only a few months later, he's a mindless brute living off stolen meat in the sewers.

I know Leatherhead moodswings like crazy, but an official explanation for his fall from grace woulda been nice.

In retrospect, it's probably just discontinuity, though.

CyberCubed
11-09-2009, 10:44 PM
Leatherhead was also watching Splinter's funeral from the swamp, rather than standing there like a normal being with the rest of them.

Its pretty much because those Vol. 4 issues were written before his Tales appearances. That's what happens when you go back into the past and put stories there.

oldmanwinters
11-09-2009, 10:52 PM
Leatherhead was also watching Splinter's funeral from the swamp, rather than standing there like a normal being with the rest of them.

Its pretty much because those Vol. 4 issues were written before his Tales appearances. That's what happens when you go back into the past and put stories there.

Yeah, I always thought that was kinda weird. I never read the Vol. 4 issues where Leatherhead fights Gamera Raph. What's his personality like in those issues?

EDIT:

In Tales #61 (which takes place during that 6 month gap in Vol. 4 #5), Leatherhead is a scientist working with the Utroms on Earth. In Vol. 4 #17, which takes place only a few months later, he's a mindless brute living off stolen meat in the sewers.


Ah, I see, question answered!

funatic
11-10-2009, 03:28 AM
In Tales #61 (which takes place during that 6 month gap in Vol. 4 #5), Leatherhead is a scientist working with the Utroms on Earth.

I think you mean Tales #62, Adventures in Bunnysitting. I don't recall seeing him in #61 (and doesn't that take place in the post vol 2, pre vol 4 period?). I don't have the issues in front of me so maybe I'm wrong.

To me the most irksome unresolved plotline is the first one CyberCubed mentioned from Tales #22. That was the one that left the most ground for continuation and it's a shame they never let Ross May snag at least one more issue of Tales to give it some closure. I do vaguely recall seeing a link to what I believe was Ross May's official script for a possible sequel at some point on these forums... does anyone else remember this, or even better, have a link to this?

DrSpengler
11-10-2009, 10:25 AM
I think you mean Tales #62, Adventures in Bunnysitting. I don't recall seeing him in #61 (and doesn't that take place in the post vol 2, pre vol 4 period?). I don't have the issues in front of me so maybe I'm wrong.


Ach, yer right. #62. My bad.

Dragon Turtle
11-11-2009, 09:41 PM
I know of the woman from Tales #22 with the Shredder gauntlets, but what else?

I don't know if this was already posted, Scott Cohn has released a few pages of the unfinished follow up story to Tales of TMNT #22:


http://scottcohn.blogspot.com/2009/11/tales-of-tmnt-sequel-that-never.html

oldmanwinters
11-11-2009, 09:55 PM
I don't know if this was already posted, Scott Cohn has released a few pages of the unfinished follow up story to Tales of TMNT #22:


http://scottcohn.blogspot.com/2009/11/tales-of-tmnt-sequel-that-never.html

Wow, what great timing! I'm really sorry we didn't get to see this sequel. Man, hard to believe it could have been out as early as 2006!

DrSpengler
11-11-2009, 10:00 PM
Well damn. Some great looking art there, and from what I've read about Ross May's intended continuation of the storyline, we could've had something really cool.

A real shame the guy's at Mirage pulled the plug on it. I certainly hope Cohn got paid for all those drawings, regardless.

CyberCubed
11-11-2009, 10:14 PM
Wow, the Lady Shredder pic looks very similar to Movie 4 Karai's design, assuming that was the character from Tales #22.

DrSpengler
11-11-2009, 10:25 PM
Anyone have a link to where on Ross May's blog he says that "Lady Shredder" was going to be the sister of Tang Shen?

I'd just like to see it documented some place for posterity's sake, since I'd like to link to the evidence when I write my review of Tales #22.

I tried going through his blog archives, but I couldn't find anything. All I could find was this bit at Tristan's blog revealing her name as Tang Amaya, but no precise links to Ross May's blog with more info:

http://tristanhuwjones.blogspot.com/2009/11/untold-tales-of-tmnt-my-enemys-enemy.html

Dragon Turtle
11-11-2009, 10:54 PM
Anyone have a link to where on Ross May's blog he says that "Lady Shredder" was going to be the sister of Tang Shen?



I don't know the first time he revealed the Lady Shredder's identity, but I do remember the time I asked him over at his blog:

http://rossmay.livejournal.com/26429.html


"It's a lot of posts back, but I revealed on this blog who I intended the villain of 22 to be. She's the never-before seen younger sister of Tang Shen, who completely misunderstood the Nagi-Shen-Yoshi love triangle and thought Yoshi actually kidnapped Shen when they fled to America. Peter Laird gave this idea the thumbs up and everything (but later just never came be).

If I do get to go back to Tales I'll be following up on that character with fresh scripts so it's entirely possible that her identity may change..."

DrSpengler
11-11-2009, 11:30 PM
Ah! Thank you, sir.

Just needed some evidence so future generations reading my reviews don't accuse me of talking outta my ass.

RossMay
11-12-2009, 04:31 PM
My ears are burning.

http://rossmay.livejournal.com/?skip=80

Obviously this link won't work eventually because it's not directed at an individual post, but you can find my long and winding entries on the two stories I had planned here. Check out this page and then move forward into the next block of 20 entries.

Just so people know, because I've heard some fans assume otherwise, Mirage actually green lit and bought my next two stories "Many Deceptions" and "Night Rain." This was in around when Murph was quitting as editor and these stories were put on the temporary shelf for a while, then a year later cancelled.

I would've loved to do more, obviously. And I know quite a few people are gunning to work on TMNT again either with Nickelodeon directly or through a 3rd party comic publisher. I feel the same way, but even if I never get back to them I'm very proud that I got to work on the Ninja Turtles.

DrSpengler
11-12-2009, 06:10 PM
Thanks, man. I reviewed Tales #22 and I'll update the links in my review when I get home from work.

Hadn't read the story since '04, so I almost forgot how much I enjoyed it. Great art from Cohn and reading it again made me recall how excited I was to see where the arc was going. Real bummer we never got to see it reach its full potential.

Dragon Turtle
11-12-2009, 09:00 PM
To Ross, what were some of the ideas you were planning to use, for the possible change of identity for Lady Shredder, as you mentioned before, if you were given the chance to write a follow up to issue #22?


"There was one element particular to this story, but running throughout the three that I was sad I did not get to explore, and that is the legacy of Hamato Yoshi. It’s always taken for granted that he is a GOOD GUY, and didn’t do anything really wrong except murder Oroku Nagi for beating Tang Shen. For the Mirage universe, at least, I always found it kind of sinister that Yoshi was the Foot’s top ninja and we never find out how he earned that position. It indicates to me that he must have carried out some assassinations and/or missions, so that when he flees with Tang Shen he is also leaving behind a past of cold-blooded murders. That’s not to say he was a bad guy in the truest sense, but he must have been something of a soldier at least. This fits in perfect with TMNT #1 considering Splinter does not come across as a “good guy” at all, but a sensei asking what should never be asked, to kill."


I always wanted to see more Hamato Yoshi's life with the Foot Clan, as well as what form the Foot Clan took before being taken over by the shredder.



"Then I had an amusing thought. What if, in counterpoint to the secret crime empire of the ninja Foot Clan, there was a secret society of samurai operating as crime fighters (basically dozens, if not hundreds of Japanese-themed Batmen and Batwomen?). A silly concept, I know, but as I said it seemed amusing to me and would basically be the anti-Foot Clan. I even researched and came up with a backstory for the society, how some samurai went underground during the Meiji Restoration of the 1860s."



Even though I never thought Hattori was a particular enthralling character, I always liked the the idea of an organization of modern day samurai.

RossMay
11-13-2009, 12:18 AM
Dr. Spengler: Nice review, and boy is it ever kind to me! Nobody's mentioning here about how damned wordy much of #22 is. I'm really upset about that in what I think was otherwise a pretty good issue. You can tell that I was trying to capture some ninja intrigue much as Tristan has also been even been more interested in.

By the way, I used to read your horror film reviews at filmsy.com before it sucked!

Dragon Turtle: I've never really had any alternate plans on who "Mistress" would be other than Tang Shen's younger sister. It's just a fact of the matter that at this point she really could be anybody with a perceived grudge against Hamato Yoshi. Let's make her... a cloned alien sent from the future? (I've been reading a blog on Spider-Man's "Clone Saga" recently).

There's a big disparity between Hamato Yoshi being perceived as a good man yet him having been a member of the Foot Clan. I don't mind there not being stories about this fact or delving into his past, but I always want other readers to recognise this as well.

RossMay
11-13-2009, 12:40 AM
Almost forgot! In your review, Dr. Spengler, you mention this story as taking place just before Volume 2. I actually wrote it and exchanged notes with Peter Laird stating that it takes place after "Return to New York" but before "City at War."

There were several reasons for this. First, had the turtles known Karai during this story they might easily guess it was her right off the bat. Secondly, while other Tales have since contradicted this, I liked to think that after "City at War" the turtles had entirely stopped fighting or even interacting with the Foot until the events of Volume 4 (or Volume 3 if you want to accept those events as well). I know it makes a difference if it's NY Foot or Japanes Foot, but really CaW is a lot more poignant to me if they just didn't see the Foot again for years.

Those two reasons were important, but also important to me was that I wanted to do a little 4 page capper after Tang Amaya has abandoned the Foot and thrown away her gauntlet. In this mini-story, her gauntlet is found by a Shredder Elite who convenes a meeting with the others, and they all misunderstand it to mean that she died fighting the turtles. What they DO understand correctly, though, is that her dwindling ninja forces abandoned her. The Elite tell each other that they are the only ones still loyal to the legacy and NY empire that Shredder created, and decide to kill off all the other ninja since they are usurpers and pretenders.

So while not necessarily the DEFINING MOMENT that led to "City at War," I wanted to have the events of my stories here become one of the reasons why the Shredder Elite have it out for all the other groups. The other ninjas might be opportunists looking out for cash and saving their own hides, which is totally the opposite of the honour-driven hardcore Shredder elite who would kill themselves several times over if it would do any good for Saki's legacy.


But really, it doesn't actually matter where this story fits in the turtles' history.

DrSpengler
11-13-2009, 10:12 AM
Thanks for the clarification, man. I adjusted the timeline thread accordingly (this is my obsessive compulsive thing, I apologize) and placed it just before "Shades of Grey". Of course, that puts it just after "Masks", so Hattori seems to be bugging the Turtles a lot, but no biggie.

It compliments the "City at War" arc well, now that you mention how it would've tied in. Heck, even Casey's over-the-top reaction to Hattori makes more sense now, factoring in Casey's self-destructive drinking problems evident in "Shades of Grey" and "City at War".

It would've filled in that nice missing gap in the chronology of the Foot Clan between "Return to New York" and "City at War" so well, too. After "Return to New York", every time we see the Foot, they're loose and sloppy and disorganized and constantly being handed embarassing defeats by some times only a single Turtle ("Digital Webbing Presents", "Kung Fu Theater", "Challenges: Raphael" and so on). Knowing what finally kicked them into shape by "City at War" would've been appreciated.


And thanks for reading my stuff at Filmsy. The company got bought out in 07, so everyone who'd been working there (myself included) got fired and replaced. I never really paid attention to Filmsy after that, but they don't seem to update with reviews as much as they used to when I was on board. Ah well, I think my work on PelleCreepy has been better than my work on Filmsy, anyway.

CyberCubed
01-22-2010, 10:26 PM
So with Tales of the TMNT over, do you think its possible any of these plotlines will be finished anywhere else?