PDA

View Full Version : Do you wish Oroku Saki had returned from the grave for Round 3?


Andrew NDB
11-20-2009, 06:19 PM
Yes, I'm aware of the Shredder Shark. But I'm talking about returning to life proper.

Archon_Turtle
11-20-2009, 06:32 PM
I'd be game for a good ol' fashioned Zombie plotline.

He could shamble around groaning "Kraaaaaaaangs!"

hehe...get it?

CyberCubed
11-20-2009, 07:19 PM
Nah.

To be honest I wasn't too fond of the Shredder shark story. I know it was mostly an abomination of worms that mixed with other animals, but the dialogue during the issue had it think it was Shredder, and the Turtles wanting to kill him a third time.

It just seemed to go against everything Pete wanted for the series, where his villains stay dead.

Archon_Turtle
11-20-2009, 07:42 PM
"kraaaaaannnnnnnnngs!!!!!"

PAAATE
11-20-2009, 09:04 PM
It's been a while since I read it, but from what I remember I liked the Shredder Shark.

But the real deal a third time? No thanks, I feel that... that would kinda cheapen the impact of RtNY and CaW

Ninjinister
11-20-2009, 09:20 PM
Original Shredder versus Wormclone Shredder! FIGHT!

Andrew NDB
11-21-2009, 12:21 AM
Original Shredder versus Wormclone Shredder! FIGHT!

In theory they'd be exactly evenly matched. If anything, the worm clone Shredder would be better, because he'd had 2 or so years of more training.

Cipher
11-21-2009, 12:32 AM
Uh...no. Thematic inconsistancy for the loss.

Shredder Shark made for a decent, supervillainous side-story though.

In theory they'd be exactly evenly matched. If anything, the worm clone Shredder would be better, because he'd had 2 or so years of more training.Worm clone Shredder, hands down. He wasn't human. I think he actually meant it when he told Leonardo, "I cannot be killed!". It seemed to be heavily implied that, short of something drastic like decapitation, he was capable of surviving/regenerating most lethal injuries. Leo stabbed his kidney for goodness' sake, and he kept chugging along like it was nothing.

Also, this is unrelated, but it's always bothered me. Eastman's inking makes it very unclear, but is he supposed to have visible scarring/possibly writhing worms under his skin? Rick Remender, the only other artist to draw him sans armor, gave him clean skin, but it definitely looks like there's something freaky going on in "Return to New York."

Ninjinister
11-21-2009, 01:40 AM
In theory they'd be exactly evenly matched. If anything, the worm clone Shredder would be better, because he'd had 2 or so years of more training.

You know I wasn't serious, right?

Kendamu
11-21-2009, 02:52 AM
Uh...no. Thematic inconsistancy for the loss.

Shredder Shark made for a decent, supervillainous side-story though.

Worm clone Shredder, hands down. He wasn't human. I think he actually meant it when he told Leonardo, "I cannot be killed!". It seemed to be heavily implied that, short of something drastic like decapitation, he was capable of surviving/regenerating most lethal injuries. Leo stabbed his kidney for goodness' sake, and he kept chugging along like it was nothing.

Also, this is unrelated, but it's always bothered me. Eastman's inking makes it very unclear, but is he supposed to have visible scarring/possibly writhing worms under his skin? Rick Remender, the only other artist to draw him sans armor, gave him clean skin, but it definitely looks like there's something freaky going on in "Return to New York."
I was reading that today. Seemed to me that he looked kinda like he has skin similar to Deadpool.

http://i21.photobucket.com/albums/b281/kendamu/RyanDeadpool.jpg

DrSpengler
11-21-2009, 08:43 AM
Nah, I'm glad that they kept the Shredder dead after TMNT #21 and haven't flinched on that. Maintains the integrity of the character.

Personally, I always viewed Shark Shredder as being as much as the "real" Shredder as, say, the four arm, midget or lobster clones from TMNT #20. The ending to his first story seemed to affirm that, too.

Time Mistress
11-21-2009, 02:06 PM
Ditto. A comic book villain that actually stayed dead. I've always admired Mirage for their integrity on this. The Shark is a copy of a copy at best.

Besides we all know the "one true Shredder" is Ch'rell.;)

Andrew NDB
11-21-2009, 04:22 PM
Also, this is unrelated, but it's always bothered me. Eastman's inking makes it very unclear, but is he supposed to have visible scarring/possibly writhing worms under his skin?

Yeah, like little craters and such in his skin.

And there's also the line, "I stood grotesque... alive!"

DrSpengler
11-21-2009, 05:27 PM
He basically looked like he was made out of ground beef.

Which was awesome.

Andrew NDB
11-21-2009, 06:50 PM
I don't think Saki in #21 was literally supposed to be comprised of worms, though. The Shredder Shark saga seems to retcon that a little, with worms coming out of his neck and all that.

Like, when Saki got cut in #21, he was visibly bleeding and audibly seemed to feel pain. He wasn't just like a walking colony of worms but rather a thing that they merged to come together/transmute into and form from the essence of Oroku Saki.

Got to give Eastman and Laird credit for a fairly original way to bring a bad guy back to life. Unless they ripped it off of something else (it's possible).

ToTheNines
11-21-2009, 06:56 PM
I always thought it was just the worms under his skin.

DrSpengler
11-21-2009, 07:40 PM
Got to give Eastman and Laird credit for a fairly original way to bring a bad guy back to life. Unless they ripped it off of something else (it's possible).

I want to say the idea was likely inspired by fluke worms. In the 80s, scientists discovered that fluke worms were capable of learning things by consuming other fluke worms. For instance, when scientists taught a fluke worm how to navigate a maze, then ground that fluke worm up and fed it to another fluke worm, that worm would instinctively know how to navigate the maze.

That idea was used in Alan Moore's Saga of the Swamp Thing as a way of explaining how Swamp Thing had Alec Holland's consciousness without actually being Alec Holland.


I'm not going to say Eastman and Laird learned about fluke worms by reading Saga of the Swamp Thing, which was a contemporary title at the time, but it's a theory.

Cipher
11-21-2009, 08:30 PM
Like, when Saki got cut in #21, he was visibly bleeding and audibly seemed to feel pain. He wasn't just like a walking colony of worms but rather a thing that they merged to come together/transmute into and form from the essence of Oroku Saki.He definitely wasn't normal, though. Like I said, Leo's kidney stab was a fatal blow. Instead, Saki just brushed it off and shouted about how he couldn't be killed.

I don't think Saki in #21 was literally supposed to be comprised of worms, though. The Shredder Shark saga seems to retcon that a little, with worms coming out of his neck and all that.I don't see how that's a retcon. The four-armed clone bled worms when Leo cut its arm off. I don't think Saki would be any different.

I always thought it was just the worms under his skin.That's what I'm more inclined to believe. Again, Lawson's style and Eastman's inking make it hard to tell, but the little "craters" look almost exactly like the short, stubby worms drawn elsewhere in "Return to New York."

My problems are that Shredder appears not to be mutilated at all in "Silent Partner" (where he's presumably bare-armed), and "Worms of Madness." The other clones and the shark mutant are also unmarred.

I guess the real question is, what exactly is worm-clone Saki? We know almost nothing about the process.

shuriken
11-29-2009, 03:39 PM
Well I always thought that Worm Clone Saki had a thin layer of skin with a bunch of worms writhing about under it.
But it is very hard to tell with the inking.

Galactus
11-29-2009, 08:02 PM
It may be shallow but yes. When I first started to collect the comics I had both Return to New York and City at War and always assumed their had been a third round with the Shredder inbetween those two stories.

Maybe it was the movies and the cartoon colouring my judgement on this. Although when Image was publishing the comic I remember Erik Larsen answering a letter that he didn't know how Shredder came back and died finaly after Leo cut his head off so I was obviously not alone.

I don't count the Worms of Madness story, though before then I'd aways felt the Shredder in RtNY was the real Shredder. That even though he/it wasn't strictly human it was made out his body parts and his soul was in there. Obviously the turtles all viewed him as being the real deal. Interestingly when it was brought up in Vol.4 letter pages Peter answered along the lines of..."I suppose you're right. I guess the turtles have only actualy fought Oroku Saki once" suggesting that before that he'd viewed post #1 shredder as the real thing too, not a clone.

I wouldn't mind a third battle with a human-like Shredder but set between RtNY and CaW. Then again for a while now I've thought that he'd be in Vol.4. It's been hinted that Karai is controled or coerced. I'd had a theory that it Saki from beyond the grave influencing her. (Then again I also thought that the Ninja trained Triceratons would be taking part in the Battle Nexus Tournament and take Mike with them thus reuniting him with Leo so I guess my track record of guessing these things isn't too good)

Andrew NDB
12-01-2009, 01:10 PM
Maybe it was the movies and the cartoon colouring my judgement on this. Although when Image was publishing the comic I remember Erik Larsen answering a letter that he didn't know how Shredder came back and died finaly after Leo cut his head off so I was obviously not alone.

Erik might not be the best example. He's never even read any Mirage TMNT comics aside from #1. Ever.

I don't count the Worms of Madness story, though before then I'd aways felt the Shredder in RtNY was the real Shredder. That even though he/it wasn't strictly human it was made out his body parts and his soul was in there.

I've always felt the same.

Obviously the turtles all viewed him as being the real deal. Interestingly when it was brought up in Vol.4 letter pages Peter answered along the lines of..."I suppose you're right. I guess the turtles have only actualy fought Oroku Saki once" suggesting that before that he'd viewed post #1 shredder as the real thing too, not a clone.

I also kind of have a problem with calling the resurrected Saki a "clone." He's not, in even a loose sense of the word.

I mean, if I blew you up into chunks, but then used nanites to put the chunks back together and bring you back to life -- memories intact and everything -- is that cloning you? Rebuilding and resurrecting, sure, but cloning? That implies a duplicate where in Saki's case, there is none.

Well I always thought that Worm Clone Saki had a thin layer of skin with a bunch of worms writhing about under it.

I never thought that at all until the Tales arc with Mashima.

But it is very hard to tell with the inking.

Might be worth a question to Lawson on his blog, if he remembers. "When you drew Saki, were you trying to draw him with worms wriggling under the skin?"

It just seems absurd. This idea that like the skin would just be like a bag and he'd just be chock full of worms. It's comical. Until the Shredder Shark business I'd always assumed the worms just sort of coalesced into the reconstructed matter of Saki when they were done with their job.

And do worms bleed blood? Because Saki did in #21. Not worm guts.

Coola Yagami
12-01-2009, 02:44 PM
All that depends on if you believe in the soul. I mean the real Saki would be in hell. This new Saki would be some sort of weird zombie with the memories of the original. It's like the real Saki would be burning in hell watching this other Shredder wrecking havok in his absence.

The idea of Saki still being a bunch of worms clumped together reminds me of those leeches from Resident Evil 0. They'd clump together to become a huge worm like creature, but if they clumped together hard enough, they'd eventually resemble a human. But they could still fall apart into a huge cluster of leeches if neccesary.

Andrew NDB
12-01-2009, 03:00 PM
All that depends on if you believe in the soul. I mean the real Saki would be in hell.

What makes you think the moment the worms reconstituted him his "soul" wouldn't just zip back into his body? Like some kind of extended near death experience?

DrSpengler
12-01-2009, 05:44 PM
And what really matters is if the idea of the soul exists within the TMNT comic universe.

And with all the ghosts and astral projections and spirit switching we've gotten, I'd say that the soul definately *does* exist within the fictional universe of the comics.

Coola Yagami
12-01-2009, 11:04 PM
Yeah, didn't Splinter like.. switch souls with some dying old guy in an early issue?

Andrew NDB
12-01-2009, 11:06 PM
Whether souls are confirmed in the TMNT universe or not... I'll ask again, how can we be sure Saki's soul didn't get whisked back into the worm-reconstructed body when it came to "life"?

Cipher
12-02-2009, 12:29 AM
And do worms bleed blood? Because Saki did in #21. Not worm guts. Rick Remender showed both blood and worms coming out of the decapitated Saki. It's not a stretch, especially since that's what all the other Shredder clones did in "Return to New York."

As for the "Was it a clone or Saki resurrected?" debate, it's a difficult question. I think it depends on the process. Did the worms actually re-assemble Saki, albeit with some dis-figuration, from his remains? As in, actually reconnect his tissue? Because then, sure, I'd say it's truly him. And as souls definitely exist within the fictional comic universe (the real world debate doesn't apply), I'd be all for the "soul zapping back in" theory.

Now, I've always read Shredder's description as implying that the worms fed on his remains, and then used that data to coalesce into a sentient structure that resembled Saki. A new creature, consisting of merged worms and containing Saki's memories. The shark was imbued with Saki's memories as well, so I think it's plausible.

I think this actually does warrant a question to the creative powers that be. It's so nit-picky, and I'm sure they haven't scrutinized it like this, but I'm curious. Ditto for asking Lawson about his original intent with the drawings.

PAAATE
12-02-2009, 05:55 AM
All that depends on if you believe in the soul. I mean the real Saki would be in hell.

I doubt the real Saki was a Christian :P

I think his soul is in the "clone"-thingie... It's not like his memories are part of his DNA... And I can't accept worms who reads memories by crawling around on a brain :P

Now, I've always read Shredder's description as implying that the worms fed on his remains, and then used that data to coalesce into a sentient structure that resembled Saki. A new creature, consisting of merged worms and containing Saki's memories.

This is what I always thought too, but with a soul explaining the memories and all that the worms IN NO WAY can find out by eating off of him :P

Ninjinister
12-02-2009, 09:03 AM
I doubt the real Saki was a Christian :P


The concept of hell is hardly exclusive to Christianity.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
12-02-2009, 01:25 PM
I doubt the real Saki was a Christian :P

I doubt he was ever even introduced to Christian Ideology. I don't necessarily know that he was bad enough to end up in hell, if you think of him in the context of his culture and its values. Zulli portrayed Saki as having honor in Soul's Winter (I know those books aren't canon, but still...he's Michael Zulli). His coming back via worms seems to be a nod to his culture's belief in reincarnation. His reappearance in the 2K3/4Kids cartoon is also a reincarnation of sorts, with Saki coming back from the grave as a slug. Not a literal reincarnation, since Ch'rell simply stole the original Tengu Shredder's identity...but a metaphorical reincarnation, since "Shredder" is more of a persona/ideology than an actual person.

Cipher
12-02-2009, 03:50 PM
This is what I always thought too, but with a soul explaining the memories and all that the worms IN NO WAY can find out by eating off of him :PBut the shark mutant most certainly had his memories - if not an exact copy of his personality - just by consuming the worm colony. And in a comic full of ninjas, mutants, aliens, ghosts, Cthulu monsters, super villains, parallel dimensions, psychics, etc, I don't think we're really in any position to say what things can "IN NO WAY" do.

This is probably one of the most pointless but weirdly interesting TMNT debates ever.

PAAATE
12-03-2009, 07:12 AM
The concept of hell is hardly exclusive to Christianity.

Oups, of course not, my wrong :(

I don't think we're really in any position to say what things can "IN NO WAY" do.

No, I just meant that I couldn't wrap my mind around it. I guess I could accept it, but I can't understand it.

But the shark mutant most certainly had his memories - if not an exact copy of his personality - just by consuming the worm colony.

Hm... I can't argue that :P Guess I'll have to accept it :P

His coming back via worms seems to be a nod to his culture's belief in reincarnation.

Well, reincarnation is WAY more complicated than that, but I've never thought about it that way and it is an interesting thought :P

shuriken
12-03-2009, 09:45 AM
It just seems absurd. This idea that like the skin would just be like a bag and he'd just be chock full of worms. It's comical. Until the Shredder Shark business I'd always assumed the worms just sort of coalesced into the reconstructed matter of Saki when they were done with their job.

And do worms bleed blood? Because Saki did in #21. Not worm guts.

Not so Much Like a bag holding in Worms, but The worms themselves became his Body. With worms writhing about underneath just in case he were to get some sort of injury. Strange and comical? Yes to a degree but this is TMNT, wierd and or comical stuff happens all the time.
And yes worms do in fact bleed.
But I guess we'll have to ask Lawson what he wanted to portray in his artwork, be it a worm covered saki, a thin skinned saki with worms writhing about, or Saki having skin like Deadpool.

veemonjosh
12-05-2009, 07:47 PM
It just seems absurd. This idea that like the skin would just be like a bag and he'd just be chock full of worms. It's comical.

And this is how Oogie Boogie became a Shredder. :lol:

Oculus Orbus
12-06-2009, 06:29 AM
For me, it's good that they kept him dead. I wouldn't like a Green Goblin sort of thing, where the bad guys never really die.

Kendamu
12-07-2009, 06:10 PM
If Saki were brought back in some sort of Mirage What-If one-shot that was out-of-continuity while keeping all characterizations in-tact, that would be cool. I like seeing the Turtles and Shredder fight. However, in-continuity I wouldn't want to see RtNY's resolution ruined... hence why I didn't like the Shredder Shark too much...

Dragon Turtle
12-08-2009, 12:00 AM
Yes, I'm aware of the Shredder Shark. But I'm talking about returning to life proper.

I would only like to see Saki reborn if he actually was developed into an interesting character with interesting motivations, not just as an "I'm back! And I will have my revenge MUAHAHAHAHA!" pantomime villain.




It just seems absurd. This idea that like the skin would just be like a bag and he'd just be chock full of worms. It's comical. Until the Shredder Shark business I'd always assumed the worms just sort of coalesced into the reconstructed matter of Saki when they were done with their job.

And do worms bleed blood? Because Saki did in #21. Not worm guts.

The worms always remind me of the the Kessen-Chu, bloodworms, from "Blade of the Immortal", the worms would grant their host incredible regenerative powers as well as immortality, a direction I was hoping the 2k3 cartoon might have taken.

turkishproverb
12-08-2009, 01:15 AM
The worms always remind me of the the Kessen-Chu, bloodworms, from "Blade of the Immortal", the worms would grant their host incredible regenerative powers as well as immortality, a direction I was hoping the 2k3 cartoon might have taken.

YOu know, the funny thing is I read RTNY first, so I always had the Kessen-Chu remind me of the worms from turtles.

Dragon Turtle
12-11-2009, 01:38 PM
YOu know, the funny thing is I read RTNY first, so I always had the Kessen-Chu remind me of the worms from turtles.


I actually read RTNY first as well, though the Kessen-Chu just seem to be much more important to Blade of the Immortal, then the worms in TMNT.

Coola Yagami
12-11-2009, 08:29 PM
I would only like to see Saki reborn if he actually was developed into an interesting character with interesting motivations, not just as an "I'm back! And I will have my revenge MUAHAHAHAHA!" pantomime villain.

That would be kinda hard to do, considering the Turtles killed him twice, of course the first thing on his mind would be revenge. Now, if Saki would somehow survive their next fight and had time to plan stuff, he might have time to develop other things, like for example, trying to take the city back from Hun and the Purple Dragons, and dealing with Karai and the Foot truce.

After all, even Hun woulda just been some 'big bad mob guy that beat the crap out of Casey' if the Turtles have killed him off in his first comic appearance. He survived their first encounter and has been given time to be fleshed out.

Dragon Turtle
12-12-2009, 12:03 AM
That would be kinda hard to do, considering the Turtles killed him twice, of course the first thing on his mind would be revenge. Now, if Saki would somehow survive their next fight and had time to plan stuff, he might have time to develop other things, like for example, trying to take the city back from Hun and the Purple Dragons, and dealing with Karai and the Foot truce.

After all, even Hun woulda just been some 'big bad mob guy that beat the crap out of Casey' if the Turtles have killed him off in his first comic appearance. He survived their first encounter and has been given time to be fleshed out.

I believe, even in the confines of simple revenge storyline, Saki could be made into a more multidimensional character, it's all in the execution.

Coola Yagami
12-12-2009, 12:56 AM
I believe, even in the confines of simple revenge storyline, Saki could be made into a more multidimensional character, it's all in the execution.

I still wonder how Saki would react towards Karai and knowing all the events of City and War and Hun's gang wars took place because of his and during his death. Interesting angle.

Dragon Turtle
12-13-2009, 04:18 AM
I still wonder how Saki would react towards Karai and knowing all the events of City and War and Hun's gang wars took place because of his and during his death. Interesting angle.


It may depend on his motivations prior to his second death, was he loyal to the Foot Clan, or was he planning on taking the US branch of the Foot Clan and secede from the rest of the Foot Clan, perhaps the motives for the actions of the Elite Foot Ninjas during CaW were based on the Shredder's final wishes.

Godzilla
12-13-2009, 07:56 AM
Although I do admire the fact that the Shredder actually stayed dead in the Mirage comics rather than continually returning, I also wouldn't have objected to the idea of him coming back for round 3. Actually, I think a storyline of Saki returning, with his motivations being much more grand than simple revenge, and the turtles eventually facing him would have made a great book end to the TMNT Mirage comic book universe.

Coola Yagami
12-13-2009, 08:46 AM
Although I do admire the fact that the Shredder actually stayed dead in the Mirage comics rather than continually returning, I also wouldn't have objected to the idea of him coming back for round 3. Actually, I think a storyline of Saki returning, with his motivations being much more grand than simple revenge, and the turtles eventually facing him would have made a great book end to the TMNT Mirage comic book universe.

Damn... you're right... I mean, maybe the mysterious force killing off all of Karai's Foot in Volume 4 is the Shredder's Foot? I mean, they still can't get rid of the guy. They even had a good guy version of him with 2K3 style armor in the Battle Nexus in Volume 4.