View Full Version : What do you feel are the show's biggest flaws?
The Terror of Death
11-23-2009, 07:08 PM
What do you think were the biggest flaws of the show other than the dip in quality that occurred during the final three seasons?
My first pick would be the dialogue. For the most part it was fine, but there were a couple instances were the dialogue came off as being not very funny or totally redundant. Some slight rewording or a bit more silence would have fixed this. Then, I would say is the voice direction. The voice actors themselves were great but sometimes their delivery seemed a tad over dramatic. The biggest flaw imo, would be filler. Many of the filler had weak stories and forgettable characters. Generally, I enjoy the filler that are mostly action oriented such as the ones in season four. Third would be minor characters. I’m glad that a lot of them were distinct enough not to be interchangeable, but only a handful actually stood out. Lastly, is music. I liked it but some tunes were melodramatic and kiddy.
CyberCubed
11-23-2009, 07:45 PM
Mike's personality got worse over the course of the show. I remember people commenting on how Mike acted during FF and BTTS more than anything else.
Granted he was still alright at times, but the writers stupidly played him for laughs for the kids instead of making him thoughtful and understanding like he used to be.
BoggleKng
11-23-2009, 08:20 PM
Too much making fun of the OT, granted it was funny at first but it got OLD..
MrPliggins
11-23-2009, 11:18 PM
-Sometime in season 2 ("Rogue in the House"), when Ch'rell kept surviving after being defeated every arc. It was starting to get old. However in season 3, he became more interesting and didn't get "defeated" until the end of the season.
-Some arcs lasted too many episodes ("Notes from the Underground", "Turtles In Space")
Shadow_Coon
11-23-2009, 11:26 PM
For the most part, I didn't find that many flaws with this series as a whole. I was actually pleasantly surprised by how much I ended up liking it. o:
I find myself mostly in agreement with you when it comes to taking issue to some of the dialog/writing and line delivery. I loved the voice actors (they were absolutely perfect choices, truth be told), but I occasionally found myself scratching my head whenever they'd deliver a line way too over-the-top (or, in the case of some scenes from Same As It Never Was, without ENOUGH feeling). Overacting in voice acting isn't very uncommon, though, so I let it slide. After all, anime English dubs can be far worse about doing that.
John Campbell pointed out something at a panel that I was trying to word after finishing watching the series and that was that this series didn't seem to establish enough character and relationship development when it came to the brothers themselves. We got a lot of action and they worked hard to explain and develop villains, their motives, and whatnot, but there weren't enough (or any, really) episodes that focused solely on expanding upon the brothers and their interpersonal relationships. Most of the main character development we got ended up being those "and the moral of today's story is" things buried between action scenes/general dangerous plot-foiling. I would have loved to see some episodes that consisted of us getting to know the brothers better without needing the pretense of stopping some sort of impending doom. Then again, I say that as an adult and, to a degree, I can understand a studio's desire to avoid that when their target demographic seems to be 5-12 year old kids.
Of course, I think that the Ninja Tribunal season as a whole was a MASSIVE flaw, but that's an issue of personal taste. I just didn't like the overall mood of the season, nor did that whole "dragon avatar" BS sit well with me. Again, that's a preference sort of thing.
CyberCubed
11-24-2009, 12:06 AM
-Some arcs lasted too many episodes ("Notes from the Underground", "Turtles In Space")
I agree with this, some of those early arcs should have been shorter.
There is no reason, "Notes of the Underground" needed to be a 3-parter, it was just way too dragged out.
prescribeddrone
11-24-2009, 12:12 AM
Honestly besides some of the Justice Force/Turtle Superhero/goofy episodes I didn't notice any particular flaws enough to bug me. I really enjoyed this series. I can even sit back and enjoy Fast Forward and I even enjoyed most of 'the lost' season.
rayfillet101
11-24-2009, 12:41 AM
My biggest flaws with the show:
*turtle titan episodes
*Halloween episode
*Renet's voice
*fast forward's villian of the week formula for a while
*BTTS lack of arcs
Cipher
11-24-2009, 12:55 AM
The toy placements and vehicles. The self-censorship. The absuridity of some of the Turtles' physical abilities. The belief-haulting implausibility of an empty New York and night. A tendency to take itself too seriously. Ending even serious episodes on corny jokes ("The Milk Run", ruined by its ending joke).
That about covers it.
Barkworm
11-24-2009, 12:56 AM
I stopped watching the show after season three but the thing I hated the most was Veronica Taylor's voice.
Candy Kappa
11-24-2009, 04:18 AM
reuse of stock footage, they could have some more variants
Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
11-24-2009, 08:23 AM
I just have one very simple answer.
http://img98.imageshack.us/img98/6279/64090756.jpg
That is all.
Nelson
11-24-2009, 10:36 AM
What do you think were the biggest flaws of the show other than the dip in quality that occurred during the final three seasons?
My first pick would be the dialogue. For the most part it was fine, but there were a couple instances were the dialogue came off as being not very funny or totally redundant. Some slight rewording or a bit more silence would have fixed this. Then, I would say is the voice direction. The voice actors themselves were great but sometimes their delivery seemed a tad over dramatic. The biggest flaw imo, would be filler. Many of the filler had weak stories and forgettable characters. Generally, I enjoy the filler that are mostly action oriented such as the ones in season four. Third would be minor characters. I’m glad that a lot of them were distinct enough not to be interchangeable, but only a handful actually stood out. Lastly, is music. I liked it but some tunes were melodramatic and kiddy.
Agree with every point, but the music should be higher on the list in my opinion. It's very annoying that after Mikey or someone says a joke that little cue plays as to tell you to laugh. In the rare case the the joke is actually funny, the music ends up spoiling it.
Also I should add:
- Too much ripping off other propierties. Aside from having Ninja Turtles and a rat master, almost everything else gives me the feeling that I've seen it before somewhere else. And better executed (the comic is just as guilty for this one)
- Overall lack of imagination. How many plots started with the turtles sparring in a rooftop when suddenly something happens / someone appears?
Despite all this, I can't say I don't like this series. I enjoy watching it, I like the (core) characters and their interaction. But it does have some big flaws.
DrSpengler
11-24-2009, 10:40 AM
The theme songs. All of em.
Nelson
11-24-2009, 10:46 AM
The overly bright, simple backgrounds.
We could go on forever. It is interested tho that we all seem to agree in our lists (or is it just me?)
CyberCubed
11-24-2009, 10:54 AM
I just have one very simple answer.
http://img98.imageshack.us/img98/6279/64090756.jpg
That is all.
Garbageman's first episode was actually fairly decent, it was like that B:TAS episode with the homeless.
It was only his second episode that was terrible.
Shadow_Coon
11-24-2009, 03:33 PM
The theme songs. All of em.
Oh lordy, so true.
Spitfire
11-24-2009, 03:36 PM
The comic adaptation episodes.
Aztec General
11-24-2009, 03:54 PM
The comic adaptation episodes.
This I don't understand. You have such a venom for the 2K3 show and its relationship to the Mirage comics. This show did a great job, IMHO, of bringing Mirage to the small screen.
Was it EXACTLY like Mirage? No. Was it a well attempted approximation? Yes. Heck, 4Kids often even added their own flare to the Mirage stories; which often worked out quite well and gave the tales a more epic feel (Utrom angle in main story, inclusion of Baxter Stockman in RTNY, City At War's three way Hun vs. Karai vs. Stockman* dance, etc.)
*Now I'm NOT saying that 4Kids did a better job with CAW than Mirage because they didn't; not even close. But the "gang war" angle (which is all that the 4Kids show focused on from that storyline) was very well done and creative IMHO.
I still feel that seasons 1-5** of 2K3 (and Turtles Forever for closure) sit among the best action cartoons ever to grace the small screen. It belongs right up there with Batman:TAS/DCAU & X-Men from the '90s.
**Season 5 (Ninja Tribunal) was a little fantastical and less TMNT, but it still kept the overall story moving and was entertaining in it's own right.
The worst part of the series? That's easy, when the show jumped the shark with Fast Forward. Unwatchable. I watched only a little of Back to the Sewers and I didn't think much of that either.
shuriken
11-24-2009, 03:55 PM
The comic adaptation episodes.
I agree to an extent. Although I did enjoy I Monster the artoon a bit more than the comic, but everything else, not so much.
It took itself way too serious sometimes and the music seemed like it didn't fit in. But Over all I really enjoyed the series as a whole.
CyberCubed
11-24-2009, 04:25 PM
The worst part of the series? That's easy, when the show jumped the shark with Fast Forward. Unwatchable. I watched only a little of Back to the Sewers and I didn't think much of that either.
Why exactly is it "unwatchable?"
I honestly cannot understand this way of thinking.
Shadow_Coon
11-24-2009, 05:19 PM
Why exactly is it "unwatchable?"
I honestly cannot understand this way of thinking.
I mimic this guy/gal's curiosity. While Flash Forward wasn't exactly the shining example of good TMNT entertainment, I personally enjoyed the light-hearted, more comedic-centric feel of that particular season.
It was certainly a step away from the mood of earlier seasons, but, the way I see it, it was merely 4Kids/Fox/Mirage finally deciding to appeal more towards their target demographic. It was considerably more "kiddy," which is understandable because it was airing on a kids network.
Spitfire
11-24-2009, 07:05 PM
This I don't understand. You have such a venom for the 2K3 show and its relationship to the Mirage comics. This show did a great job, IMHO, of bringing Mirage to the small screen.
Was it EXACTLY like Mirage? No. Was it a well attempted approximation? Yes. Heck, 4Kids often even added their own flare to the Mirage stories; which often worked out quite well and gave the tales a more epic feel (Utrom angle in main story, inclusion of Baxter Stockman in RTNY, City At War's three way Hun vs. Karai vs. Stockman* dance, etc.)
*Now I'm NOT saying that 4Kids did a better job with CAW than Mirage because they didn't; not even close. But the "gang war" angle (which is all that the 4Kids show focused on from that storyline) was very well done and creative IMHO.
My issue with the comic episodes is they're boring. In most cases it just ends up being a toned down version of the story. In most cases they drag the story out longer then it needs to be to fit it into episode form. The biggest offender of this is "Turtles In Space". That whole arc plus "Secret Origins" was a chore to sit through. They took a 3 issue event and dragged it out 6 episodes. Granted the last two of those had their own thing going on. It was just too long.
Yet, as you mention, "City At War" gets crammed into 3 episodes. What could have been a cleaver season long story arc was just wasted. It should have been a rising tension. Early on in the season it should have been eluded to and the finale of the season should have been the arc getting resolved. Instead everything happens way too fast and the impact it has on the turtles in the comics is completely glossed over.
The adaptation of "The Unmentionables" is just pathetic. "Sons of the Silent Age" annoyed me as well. The treatment of Zog was just weak. There was no reason for them to try to split that into two mult-iparters. I'm not going to say some of the stuff they did wasn't clever but it didn't always work. I found myself enjoying the new stories a lot more.
To be honest "I,Monster" was the best adapt and one of my favorite 2K3 episodes.
I still feel that seasons 1-5** of 2K3 (and Turtles Forever for closure) sit among the best action cartoons ever to grace the small screen. It belongs right up there with Batman:TAS/DCAU & X-Men from the '90s.
It could have been up there with them but they were too tied down and limited. Batman TAS, X-men, and even Spider-man all dealt with adult themes and death. Turtles really wasn't allowed to go there. I'd say it's the best toon to come out in recent years, it did well for a Saturday morning toon. It was missing the cause and effect. Stuff happened but the ripple of that action wasn't felt through out the series. This was something I really liked about the Marvel toons and Batman. Little actions made in early episodes would cause ripples and the characters paid for them later on. "Notes From the Underground" doesn't count in my book. That was just a drug out story arc that lasted way too long and really had no cause and effect elements. They only really ever mentioned it in episodes pertaining to it.
I will say "Turtles Forever" was the perfect send off and they get props for pulling that off.
**Season 5 (Ninja Tribunal) was a little fantastical and less TMNT, but it still kept the overall story moving and was entertaining in it's own right.
I personally can't agree. This season was a mess in my opinion and I can't say I liked it at all. It seemed to me they simply went that direction to hop on the anime bandwagon since that's what 90% of the 4Kids toons are. I can live without the turtles shooting energy beams out of their weapons.
The worst part of the series? That's easy, when the show jumped the shark with Fast Forward. Unwatchable. I watched only a little of Back to the Sewers and I didn't think much of that either.
FF is great. I'll admit there are groan worthy scenes but it had much potential. I actually felt the humor they tried so hard to force feed us worked better in this season as it fit the style and tone of the series. It had hands down the best theme song, again it matched the tone of the series. It also introduced new villains I think we all liked. Sad to say it got canned before it reached it's full potential. Most fans are still begging for that second season.
BTTS is just horrid. In all fairness I have yet to give it the second chance I gave FF. Though with FF I was able to at least sit through the episodes. I was embarrassed to be watching some of the BTTS episodes. I felt like someone could walk in while I was watching them. It'd be worse then being caught masturbating.
While I talk down the 2K3 series I don't totally dislike it. To me it just doesn't have the re-watch value of series like the DCAU for example. I even enjoy watching the old toon more then 2K3. Like others mentioned it tried to take itself too seriously and that didn't work for me considering the limitations. While season 4 was my favorite season it was aguilty of this the most. Leo's Batman voice was laughable in most cases.
I'm a comic purist and that also inhibits me. I've not only read but own every turtles comic printed and with all that lore floating around you can't help but say to yourself "There's a better way they could have done that." when you're watching one of those adapt episodes.
CyberCubed
11-24-2009, 08:05 PM
Even though they were toned down, I liked most of the comic stories. "Return to New York" was done very well in the show.
I agree "Turtles in Space" should have been a little shorter, but to be fair "Secret Origins" was a totally different plot and isn't really the same arc despite being continued directly after.
They were never intended to be direct adaptions anyway. I remember Peter Laird saying in Vol. 4 that the 2k3 series, "adapts the comic stories for cartoon standards while adding new elements and twists" and that's exactly what they did.
You could nitpick every little detail but I just relax and enjoy. I'd much rather those stories happen than not. Remember, this was still a kids show.
Cipher
11-24-2009, 08:29 PM
My issue with the comic episodes is they're boring. In most cases it just ends up being a toned down version of the story. In most cases they drag the story out longer then it needs to be to fit it into episode form. The biggest offender of this is "Turtles In Space". That whole arc plus "Secret Origins" was a chore to sit through. They took a 3 issue event and dragged it out 6 episodes. Granted the last two of those had their own thing going on. It was just too long.I have to disagree here. I thought the straight-action comic adaptations came out fairly well, and occasionally better. "Turtles In Space" in particular. That was actually one of the more adult pieces in the entire series, and I feel like the pacing was actually a lot better in the cartoon than the comic.
But when it adapts any of the heavier issues, like "Sons of the Silent Age," or "City at War," everything just falls to pieces. "Return to New York" and "Shredder Strikes Back" came out decently, if rather different from their comics. They were less heavy, but at least made up for it with some amazing action sequences.
So...comic adaptations. A really mixed bag.
It could have been up there with them but they were too tied down and limited. Batman TAS, X-men, and even Spider-man all dealt with adult themes and death. Turtles really wasn't allowed to go there. I'd say it's the best toon to come out in recent years, it did well for a Saturday morning toon. It was missing the cause and effect. Stuff happened but the ripple of that action wasn't felt through out the series. This was something I really liked about the Marvel toons and Batman. Little actions made in early episodes would cause ripples and the characters paid for them later on. "Notes From the Underground" doesn't count in my book. That was just a drug out story arc that lasted way too long and really had no cause and effect elements. They only really ever mentioned it in episodes pertaining to it.I'll agree that it wasn't quite at the level of the DCAU (although I think it was unquestionably better than Spider-Man). But I'm not sure where you're coming from saing that B:TAS has any shreds of continuity. Every once in a while there'll be a little reference to an earlier episode, but that's about it.
FF is great. I'll admit there are groan worthy scenes but it had much potential. I actually felt the humor they tried so hard to force feed us worked better in this season as it fit the style and tone of the series. It had hands down the best theme song, again it matched the tone of the series. It also introduced new villains I think we all liked. Sad to say it got canned before it reached it's full potential. Most fans are still begging for that second season. I agree completely. Fast Foward was seriously firing on all cylinders by its end. It realized it was a kids' show, which prevented it from occasionally being as ludicriously angst as earlier seasons. At the same time though, it actually had one of the more intricate story arcs of the show (check how all the villains play off one another to reach their goals), and some of the most Mirage-esque episodes. I've said it before, but if an of the 4Kids shows matched the tone of the Mirage comics, "Milk Run" and "DNA is Thicker Than Water" are right up there.
And then you just have some really fun episodes like "Invasion of the Body Jacker," which I could watch over and over again.
BTTS is just horrid. In all fairness I have yet to give it the second chance I gave FF. Though with FF I was able to at least sit through the episodes. I was embarrassed to be watching some of the BTTS episodes. I felt like someone could walk in while I was watching them. It'd be worse then being caught masturbating. I first saw FF on DVD after it aired, and liked it immediately. I keep trying with BttS, and I'm still not cozy with it.
I'm a comic purist and that also inhibits me. I've not only read but own every turtles comic printed and with all that lore floating around you can't help but say to yourself "There's a better way they could have done that." when you're watching one of those adapt episodes.Again, while I still say some of the more straight-forward adaptations worked out, the show is nowhere near the same level as the comics.
And I second the comments about the theme songs. They're all terrible.
ToTheNines
11-24-2009, 09:36 PM
The belief-haulting implausibility of an empty New York and night.
That drives me ape sh*t. That was annoying in the old movie series too, but they did alright with it in the comics and TMNT 07.
Aztec General
11-25-2009, 01:57 PM
I mimic this guy/gal's curiosity. While Flash Forward wasn't exactly the shining example of good TMNT entertainment, I personally enjoyed the light-hearted, more comedic-centric feel of that particular season.
It was certainly a step away from the mood of earlier seasons, but, the way I see it, it was merely 4Kids/Fox/Mirage finally deciding to appeal more towards their target demographic. It was considerably more "kiddy,"
I think you answered your own question.
Shadow_Coon
11-25-2009, 02:43 PM
I think you answered your own question.
Not really. "Unwatchable" indicates that the season was so incredibly terrible that attempting to sit through the entirety of any given episode is the psychological equivalent of ripping out a tooth with pliers. Though it didn't mimic the same mood as the season(s) before it, Fast Forward didn't really merit that sort of disdain. It was enjoyable (at least more so than the BttS and NT seasons).
It wasn't the best season by any means, but "unwatchable?" Not so much.
Spitfire
11-25-2009, 03:48 PM
You want to see unwatchable try watching the first season of the 90's Fantastic Four series. That is unwatchable, the first season of Iron Man is as well.
MrPliggins
11-25-2009, 06:25 PM
You want to see unwatchable try watching the first season of the 90's Fantastic Four series. That is unwatchable, the first season of Iron Man is as well.
I agree..I've had the series DVD for about a year, and I've only gotten through the first four episodes of season 1.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.