View Full Version : Donatello: The Brain Thief #4 (already out)
DrSpengler
12-09-2009, 12:01 PM
My review. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2009/12/donatello-brain-thief-4.html)
I don't like being a douche about things, but this series did not have even remotely enough content to warrant $13 bucks.
odupianist
12-09-2009, 12:19 PM
Hah you actually counted the words, good form. That's a shame about this series. It had a lot of potential with the Don vs. Baxter discussions. I wonder if it got the shaft because of the sale to Nick/Viacom. I had very high hopes for this because Don is PL's favorite turtle and the previously mentioned Don/Baxter conversations that could have happened.
Oculus Orbus
12-09-2009, 01:16 PM
This is weird. Mycomicshop (http://www.mycomicshop.com/search?TID=19542408) says that this whole series (all four isues) have been published by IDW.
Fast Forward?
That's very weird. It's probably just a mistake on the website's part. Though it might mean something else...
turkishproverb
12-09-2009, 08:29 PM
Please be a prophetic sign. Please be a prophetic sign...
oldmanwinters
12-10-2009, 09:45 PM
Well, what can I say?...
I was soooo excited for the buildup on this series but at the end of the day, I feel like somebody forgot to write the story, leaving us with just panels of Donatello running around illustrated by Lawson. Big hype, big letdown.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
12-11-2009, 10:56 AM
Would someone care to explain this issue to me? I didn't exactly see Don's "dark side." Use spoiler tags if posting in thread (duh).
Heck, while you're at it, explain this entire series to me. Maybe I'm just an idiot.
oldmanwinters
12-11-2009, 10:58 AM
Would someone care to explain this issue to me? I didn't exactly see Don's "dark side." Use spoiler tags if posting in thread (duh).
Heck, while you're at it, explain this entire series to me. Maybe I'm just an idiot.
Donatello...
reluctantly sacrificed a dog in order to stop the nanobots. :o:ohwell:
Andrew NDB
12-11-2009, 11:16 AM
Whuh? It came out this past Wednesday?
DrSpengler
12-11-2009, 11:28 AM
Whuh? It came out this past Wednesday?
Yeah, I wasn't expecting it either.
I got #3 Thursday before last (Thanksgiving delay), though it wasn't listed by Diamond to be out that week.
Diamond had #3 listed to be out LAST Wednesday, but then #4 came out that day. So I'm expecting Diamond to list it for NEXT Wednesday.
From my experiences, Mirage's release schedules and Diamond's listings have never, ever synced up. TMNT books either come out a week before or a week after the Diamond listing.
Go Mirage. Wooo.
Andrew NDB
12-11-2009, 12:07 PM
How weird they would squeeze this issue out so quickly. It's like a firesale.
Powder
12-14-2009, 02:58 AM
I was glad to have gotten them so closetogether, but sadly the whole thing was a dissapointment.
Cipher
12-14-2009, 11:51 AM
Would someone care to explain this issue to me? I didn't exactly see Don's "dark side."Don's "dark side" is that he resorted to fire-arms again and kept a sentient cyborg locked in a secret room for decades.
Unfortunately, neither one was given a passing thought in this mini-series.
I just got the first two issues of this in the post. Can anyone explain why the issues are bookended by plain black pages and why there's no editorial page?
DrSpengler
12-14-2009, 12:59 PM
I just got the first two issues of this in the post. Can anyone explain why the issues are bookended by plain black pages and why there's no editorial page?
The entire thing seemed pretty rushed. #3 doesn't even have a credits page. #4 has to make up for it by including a credits page for all 4 issues just so you can know who inked what.
Andrew NDB
12-17-2009, 12:31 AM
I was somewhat impressed by #4. I mean, if you were to boil all 4 issues down into about 1 normal-sized issue... you'd end up with a fairly compelling little tale.
Yeah, I was disapointed with this mini series. It seemed it would be up there with the Mike and Leo series as being potentially good. But its just above the horrible Ralph mini. Don very quiet and secretive about the whole Baxterbot body he kept, all to himself. Realizes he can't really stop this thing and has to resort to a sacrifice of a dog, which I didn't know he had. Was the dog bot crushed or just left in this tight sealed room (I just ain't sure)? We want to learn why Don kept Baxter but we don't. It was all about this spinoff of the nanobots from Baxterbot, IIRC. Just no depth to this story. Just running around and chasing and brief fight bits. No words and text really for 95% of the story. It should've been better and it wasn't. It sure leaves Don to be with his own dark secrets. I was surprised it never involved the other turtles, which I actually thought might be the case with issue #3's ending, but why would they be in a locked door? Was it Baxter he was talking to? Just to me you can never tell what room is what. Oh and I think Jim Lawsons art is just a wee bit better when he inks it himself. Jim and Eric Talbot aren't good together. Its just lines with so much white space from the pages. Jim at least embellishes his art with a tone of black inks and white art that at least stands out on the panels and pages.
Daniel Orduna
12-30-2009, 05:43 AM
is really that bad¿
Oculus Orbus
01-06-2010, 05:06 AM
Well, I loved this series. I had read all the comments here before (and the review by DrSpengler), so I had pretty low expectations for it, but I have to say that it actually surprised me. I find Lawson's storytellig amazing, and I pay a lot of attention to that when reading a comic. I loved Eric Talbot's inks (can't say who I prefer tho), and I think Lawson did a specially good job here.
I can see what you guys mean with the lack of story, but I thought the whole thing was pretty deep. Ok, it's not like it revealed much of Donnie's dark side, but still, it had a strong felling (for me at least). Also, I really enjoyed the atmosphere. It's a quick read, that's for sure, but i think that all four issues put together work very well (maybe it loses too much when you have to wait to read the next issue).
discordiatookie
01-06-2010, 12:10 PM
I too enjoyed it. Perhaps a bit of a fast read, with alot of sewer-sprinting, however it contained some cool moments, and some good art. The only thing is, it could have been better. Donatello and the Stockmanbot? Shoulda been some darker and more memorable moments than what there was.
DrSpengler
01-06-2010, 01:15 PM
It was just too decompressed. Lawson tried to take two issues-worth of story and stretch it to fill four, and it just didn't work.
There were MUCH better ways to pad the thing out than what we got, least of all being more interaction between Don and Baxter. Instead, it just filled the extra page space with panel after panel of empty sewer tunnels or Don running and running and running.
The premise of the story wasn't bad, it's just that there was only two issues plot at BEST and that's not even factoring in the wasted potential in regards to Don and Baxter.
It would've been fine as a one-shot issue of Tales, but it didn't have enough meat for a four issue miniseries.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
01-06-2010, 02:24 PM
It was just too decompressed. Lawson tried to take two issues-worth of story and stretch it to fill four, and it just didn't work.
The premise of the story wasn't bad, it's just that there was only two issues plot at BEST and that's not even factoring in the wasted potential in regards to Don and Baxter.
It would've been fine as a one-shot issue of Tales, but it didn't have enough meat for a four issue miniseries.
All of your points are valid (I clipped a paragraph merely to save space), but you're not really telling us anything we don't know. Why don't you tell us WHY you think this might be?
Edit: Nevermind, just saw the beginning of the thread. YOU'RE the guy behind TMNT Entity? Wow.
CyberCubed
01-22-2010, 06:39 PM
I still don't get why Don kept Baxter active for the 15 or so years until Volume 4.
Wasn't this mini-series supposed to explain that?
Venom
01-22-2010, 08:25 PM
First off, I liked the series. It wasn't groundbreaking but really, how many Turtle stories are. It's a very "normal" title in that the overarcing theme was the development of the four Turtles' personalities and how they interact with life.
Okay, with that said I agree with Spengler in that the series took a sharp left turn with the nanosymbiote story. That should have been a background sub-plot for a larger story, one which was hinted at right in the first book: "Now tell me where my brother is."
That single line could have been the start of a powerful story of conflicting ideologies who find commonality within each other's own intellect. Baxter would mockingly talk down to Don and berate him for being a lower life-form, to which Don would remind him of who was occupying a burnt-out metal shell and living by the aide of electrical currents provided by said life-form.
We should have heard Baxter give Don a location, seen Don be sent out to only to be ambushed by the nanosymbiote (who Baxter has a semi-telepathic connection with), and Don's fury erupt as he becomes frustrated with Baxter's not complying and using less than humane techniques to try and unwillingly force him to stop and give up Raph's location.
We should have been allowed to see Baxter get under Don's skin, literally and figuratively, as some of the symbiotic nanomachines invade a wound in Don's skin (harking back to Image's Cyborg Don) and his mad rush to deactivate the particles before Baxter links a connection with Don's own neural network in hijack his mind and ultimately his body.
Later, we should have seen Don finally realize the key to getting Baxter to comply by realizing he was using tactics Baxter would use and see them both engage in a conversation as unrelenting equals, one dark, one light, both shades of grey to varying degrees. There's a word I want to use to describe the situation, but it escapes me at the moment...Anyway, that conversation would have led to Baxter revealing the true location of Raph and the series should have ended with Don saying "Hey guys, I know where to find Raph." and Mike asks "How?" and Don gives and ambiguous answer "I have good intel." or something and have it lead into the Volume 2 story that follows.
I dunno, but while I did enjoy "Don: The Brain Thief" I also felt the potential that could have been.
VaughnMichael
02-21-2010, 05:16 AM
I only like this series because it gives us more of Baxter.
But besides that this was complete crap and the last issue was the worst.
I was 100% dissapointed.
Powder
02-21-2010, 06:05 AM
Meh. There are alot of things like this that we'll look back at & say 'being that "------" was the last of the "-------'s" really sucks. Like, yakno, this was the last mini-series, & wasn't too great. Or when we look back @ the last of the tales issues & think of how many loose ends they could've tied but instead used crappy plots & less then impressing artists. F*** it.
VaughnMichael
02-21-2010, 06:24 AM
Meh. There are alot of things like this that we'll look back at & say 'being that "------" was the last of the "-------'s" really sucks. Like, yakno, this was the last mini-series, & wasn't too great. Or when we look back @ the last of the tales issues & think of how many loose ends they could've tied but instead used crappy plots & less then impressing artists. F*** it.
Exactly it's all wasted space.
Powder
02-21-2010, 07:44 AM
Laziness I say! Either that or a general lack of creativity...
VaughnMichael
02-21-2010, 07:57 AM
Laziness I say! Either that or a general lack of creativity...
eh I think they are being creative, it's just that I think the fans would rather see things closed up in the short time that's left for them to do things rahter than add more stories.
odupianist
02-22-2010, 08:13 AM
eh I think they are being creative, it's just that I think the fans would rather see things closed up in the short time that's left for them to do things rahter than add more stories.
I don't know. This Don series had potential to be better than the Leo one. Overall it was a let down. It could have been really deep and thought provoking and one hell of a mind f*ck for Don, but it didn't happen :(
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.