PDA

View Full Version : What if the NT Turtles met the OT Red Sky Turtles?


Luke795
12-11-2009, 07:11 PM
Any thoughts?

Icebot
12-11-2009, 07:45 PM
For sure, the OT turtles wouldn't be as childish as they were in Turtles Forever. And they probably wouldn't talk about pizza so much either, there wasn't that much pizza talk in the red sky episodes. I wonder if the OT turtles would have been able to take on Ch'rell with their super mutations from seasons 9 and 10. It would've been cool to see that. Or if Ch'rell took on Doomquest from the end of Season 9. Doomquest was incredibly powerful.

Coola Yagami
12-11-2009, 08:14 PM
Yeah, those Super Mutations would have confused the hell out of the NT Turtles.

TurtleGuy
12-12-2009, 02:03 AM
NT Raph would probably be the one on the recieving end of the turtles' super mutation.

I could see it happening. He'd be chastising the other turtles, criticising them over everything and stressing it until -WHAM- super mutant rampage.

It would've been interesting to see.

Powder
12-12-2009, 03:06 AM
How about next mutation meet coming out of their shells that would be liek soo kewl.

sdp
12-12-2009, 08:55 AM
What if the NT Turtles had met the REAL 87 turtles and not that mean spirited parody?

gobo
12-12-2009, 10:41 AM
How about next mutation meet coming out of their shells
Then the multiverse would collapse on itself. :P
What if the NT Turtles had met the REAL 87 turtles and not that mean spirited parody?
Then Fred Wolf would have sued for likeness. :P

Icebot
12-12-2009, 05:08 PM
Near the end of Season 4 of the NT, Donnatello mutated out of control the same way Leonardo did in Season 10 of the OT. For the NT, I remember Leonardo narrating about Don's mutation: Had it been one of us, we would've turned to Donnatello to figure it out. That immediately reminded of the OT and that was exactly the case in that show. Donnatello was working with Carter to cure Leonardo's mutation.

It would've been cool to see the 8 turtles to talk about both those experiences simultaneously.

Gyt Kaliba
12-12-2009, 06:45 PM
Can I get some clarification on these Super Mutations? I never saw the later episodes of the old toon - it sounds like you mean something different from the 'SUPA MUTATION!' of the anime anyway.

I have a hunch about what it might be, a very VERY vague memory from my childhood that I thought I'd made up or something...so I'm very curious.

Icebot
12-12-2009, 07:13 PM
Can I get some clarification on these Super Mutations? I never saw the later episodes of the old toon - it sounds like you mean something different from the 'SUPA MUTATION!' of the anime anyway.

I have a hunch about what it might be, a very VERY vague memory from my childhood that I thought I'd made up or something...so I'm very curious.

In Season 9 of the OT, Donnatello discovers that the mutagen that originally mutated the turtles in Season 1 was becoming unstable and their mutations were reaching a second stage. This usually happens to the turtles when they deal with stress. When they mutate, their voices sound like tough guys, and they usually like to cause damage and stuff. And their new friend Carter is also exposed to the mutagen as well and he temporarily mutates into a big tough yellow guy. Carter never talks when he mutates.

In Season 10, Carter and Leonardo are the only ones who mutate. Leonardo's mutation gets worse, he no longer talks when he mutates, it's very similar to what happened to Donnatello of the NT in Adventures in Turtle Sitting and Good Genes.

Gyt Kaliba
12-12-2009, 07:21 PM
Oh man! That IS exactly what I remember then! I always vaguely remembered seeing part of that on TV (so I guess a channel near me did air the later seasons and I missed it? ...well that sucks!) way back when I was a kid. I always assumed I'd just imagined it or something.

Anywhere I can see a screenshot of these second stage mutations?

ryukenden
12-13-2009, 04:20 AM
During the red sky seasons, the OT Turtles were definitely more serious and the NT would have appreciated them more.

If the Coming out of their Shells and The Next Mutation Turtles have been encountered, they would really get on the nerves of both the OT and the NT Turtles.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
12-13-2009, 08:51 AM
What if the NT Turtles had met the REAL 87 turtles and not that mean spirited parody?

Even if you think the OT Turtles were exaggerated (and I honestly don't think the exaggeration was that big, unless you're strictly going by the first season), I don't see what was so "mean spirited" about it. All of them had their own distinctive personalities, too, though I'll admit that Leonardo could have been handled a little better.

ToTheNines
12-13-2009, 11:41 AM
To answer the question of the thread title: No one woulda liked it as well.

hadoolket
12-13-2009, 09:01 PM
did somebody say carter (http://www.thatchickensite.com/?p=1008)

Whitewolf89
12-14-2009, 02:01 PM
Quite honestly, as much as I love the 1988 OT TMNT (and always will!), I really DO wish that they'd USED the Red Sky TMNT, rather than the ones that they did for Turtles Forever. Mainly because they WERE more serious (AND the animation style was a bit cooler (read: darker-natured...more like the 2K3 TMNT), Raph didn't talk to the audience so much, the villians were better (AND more varied), and...well, in general, they no longer acted like they all KNEW that they were in a cartoon!

And I think they FINALLY let Mikey get rid of that stupid grappling hook and use his 'chuks during the Red Sky eps. Which was cool.

Or am I way WRONG about that? Wouldn't be the FIRST time!:lol:

To answer the question of the thread title: No one woulda liked it as well.
Um, why? They would have been a bit more in tune with the NT Turtles, and not QUITE so (sadly-annoyingly) goofy. Which, as I'VE said above, I would've LIKED better.

gobo
12-14-2009, 02:30 PM
And I think they FINALLY let Mikey get rid of that stupid grappling hook and use his 'chuks during the Red Sky eps. Which was cool.

Or am I way WRONG about that? Wouldn't be the FIRST time!:lol:
Have you broken a million yet? :P

hadoolket
12-15-2009, 03:16 AM
Um, why? They would have been a bit more in tune with the NT Turtles, and not QUITE so (sadly-annoyingly) goofy. Which, as I'VE said above, I would've LIKED better.

so what you're saying is you'd want them to be pretty much carbon copies of the NT turtles but with "different art style"? why even make that happen except to fulfill someone's self-seriousness issues and preference for the art style?

gobo
12-15-2009, 07:45 AM
What if the NT Turtles met the OT Red Sky Turtles?
If that had been the case, I imagine the potshots at the '88 Turtles would all revolve around how boring they were. The way I see it, their individualities were pretty well erased for those eps to the point that they seemed like generic, uninspired characters.
self-seriousness
Awkward wording much? :P What did you mean to say there? I don't quite follow.

Kendamu
12-15-2009, 07:55 PM
What if the NT Turtles had met the REAL 87 turtles and not that mean spirited parody?

Through the main bulk of the series, recent memory from watching the DVDs shows me that the Turtles were really goofy. Turtles Forever exaggerated it, but only a little bit.

Sure, I'd have rather seen Season 1 OT Turtles meet the 2k3 Turtles, but that wouldn't have really been accurate. For the most part, they were nothing like their Season 1 counterparts.

Blade Raider
12-15-2009, 09:27 PM
I think 4kids would've treated them the same except the sky would've been red.

hadoolket
12-16-2009, 04:11 AM
Awkward wording much? :P What did you mean to say there? I don't quite follow.
it means that people get too wrapped up in something like how the turtles weren't treated seriously enough, as the fanbase itself is overseriously passionate about getting these turtles the "respect they deserve"--this is a vicarious "respect" for the very fanbase attached to these versions of turtles. these fans don't wanna be looked at as the joke of a community just because they appreciate something that, at the core, was perceivingly goofy, but THEY don't see it that way, and they don't see themselves as goofy, AND they get very serious! and it's a little too much about respect for something that is just a cartoon. meanwhile, people joke readily about people getting blown up in afghanistan as if it meant nothing but humor.

therefore, the red sky turtles seem like a viable alternative simply because they were "more serious" and that's the only version they see in their everything's-gotta-be-serious eyes. (if you've ever actually watched these episodes even today however, you'll laugh your butt off at how stupid a lot of the ideas in them were)

it's like on mtv where everything is serious and EXTREEEEEEEEEEEME--they don't have room for clowns and jokes! even stupid dance-offs and reality dramas are serious and full of themselves and their music (music on mtv? :P ) when a normal non-teenaged-mentality person would otherwise laugh it off at how corny it all really is. but they're like "don't laugh at me, dancing is a TRUE sport, and i'll show you all! blah blah" and next we'll see EXTREEEEEEME chess

i know i'm serious, but that has nothing to do with what i like, and even i'm able to loosen up and not let the 88-turtles-being-made-fun-of bother me as if peter laird was telling me i cry to bigger ninja turtles, but the fans themselves seem to take it in as being called crybabies themselves like it was some kind of social commentary made through the 88 ninja turtles' characterization, and that seems to upset them greatly; like, "i'm no crybaby! i'll show you that my dancing is superior to yours! on mtv!"

back to your regularly scheduled thread

Coola Yagami
12-17-2009, 07:46 PM
Yeah the Red Sky eps weren't all that awesome. The fighting was still pretty tame and they still fought stupid-lookin cartoony monsters. They did stop the pizza references and sillier humor, but their new 'quips' during fighting wasn't any better.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
12-18-2009, 03:57 AM
Yeah the Red Sky eps weren't all that awesome. The fighting was still pretty tame and they still fought stupid-lookin cartoony monsters. They did stop the pizza references and sillier humor, but their new 'quips' during fighting wasn't any better.

I think that was why Red Sky was such a bore. They were supposedly more serious and hardcore, but the way they fought was still tame and the action was still rather unimpressive, only now they had cheesy rock music playing and it was always night, plus they never cracked jokes or acted silly. Essentially, it was a mess of a product that was unenjoyable to either side (unenjoyable to those that like comedy and unenjoyable to those that like action).

Leonardo_
12-20-2009, 07:35 AM
Through the main bulk of the series, recent memory from watching the DVDs shows me that the Turtles were really goofy. Turtles Forever exaggerated it, but only a little bit.


I dont understand....what is that terrible with the OT turtles beeing more funnier than the others? Is it really THAT bad?
I dont know....I myself think that some variety is important for the turtles show not to get boring or even unrealistic. I thought they are "only" teenagers. Shouldnt they get the accreditation to goof around as well as they fight?

I think that was one of the reasons why the 2k3 toon ended here in germany after the the first seasons.

RskimB
12-20-2009, 12:21 PM
anyone have pics of the Red Sky tmnt mutations? its been so long since i've seen them