PDA

View Full Version : What was more worth it: Turtles Forever or TMNT #1 CGI adaptation?


DK2
01-12-2010, 10:51 PM
Sorry I didn't know how to make a poll on this, but I'm just wondering what everyones thoughts are on the 25th anniversary video movies that were planned/made.
So what was more worth it: Turtles Forever or TMNT #1 CGI adaptation?
Remember Imagi of the CGI TMNT '07 movie was gonna adapt a CGI adaptation of TMNT #1, but fell apart as the budget and timing of release couldn't make it happen IIRC. The back up plan was Turtles Forever, which we all know happened.

My opinion, I think Turtles Forever was more worth it. We all know TMNT #1 so well. But to me I can't even concieve how long this woulda been had an adapted movie been made. Like at best it coulda been anywhere from 30-40 mins or so (maybe alot of padded out background shots). I just can't see how it coulda been stretched to be the length Turtles Forever turned out to be (68-78 mins).
Turtles Forever was way better with the meeting of the three best known incarnations of the TMNT. The humor and teaming between the two toon turtles was funny and priceless. The bittersweet ending with Eastman & Laird at work on TMNT #1 can't be beaten and puts closure ironically on the whole Mirage era of the TMNT after the sale occured. To see the Mirage U TMNT come to life was a kodak moment (a CGI TMNT #1 woulda done this too). These we would never have seen from a TMNT #1 movie. It still would've been great to see Imagi do the Turtles again, thats the only loss.
Thumbs up to Turtles Forever.

gobo
01-12-2010, 11:24 PM
Turtles Forever was the better choice. A CGI adaptation of a single comic issue would have been quite boring.

Venom
01-13-2010, 12:23 AM
Turtles Forever, but I'm intrigued by how the #1 CG adaptation would have turned out.

*imagines an '07 version of the first comic*

Hmm...

Powder
01-13-2010, 01:31 AM
I hadn't even heard of the CGI thing till now. Of course I, like many others I suspect, say Turtles Forever. It HAD the mirage turtles (& referances to issue one) & everything else so it's obviously better. Maybe I'm speaking for too broad of an audience here, but I think alot of folks aren't thrilled with CGI turtles anyway.

gobo
01-13-2010, 03:57 AM
I hadn't even heard of the CGI thing till now.
IIRC, it was back in the summer of 2008... while we were still waiting on official confirmation of the 2008 season anyway, there was an update on .com that said that 2009's shellebration would include a movie by Imagi and videogame by Ubisoft both based on Vol. 1 #1. Read more here (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=23476).

Fact: Turtles Forever spent only 15 minutes depicting the Mirage universe.

Scandia
01-13-2010, 06:46 AM
Turtles Forever was totally worth it. I wonder if a CGI adaptation of the first one would have been all style and no substance.

Oculus Orbus
01-13-2010, 08:08 AM
Turtles Forever, no doubt. CGI would have ruined the Mirage look.

syk_skillz
01-13-2010, 08:09 AM
IIRC, it was back in the summer of 2008... while we were still waiting on official confirmation of the 2008 season anyway, there was an update on .com that said that 2009's shellebration would include a movie by Imagi and videogame by Ubisoft both based on Vol. 1 #1. Read more here (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=23476).

Fact: Turtles Forever spent only 16 minutes depicting the Mirage universe.

So I assume the game was canned also? :(

Venom
01-13-2010, 08:38 AM
Not exactly, the game evolved into TMNT Smash-Up.

ToTheNines
01-13-2010, 09:34 AM
How many times have the events of Volume 1 issue 1 been told and retold?

Nelson
01-13-2010, 10:37 AM
It's a little unfair to make a choice, as we never saw what the CGI movie would have been like. However I can say that, comparing Turtles Forever with the idea of a CGI issue 1, Turtles Forever wins. I'm not a big fan of the first issue, it's not a really good story, and the Turtles didn't even have distinct personalities by that time. It would have been style over substance as Scandia said.

However, it would have been interesting to see the consecuences of the CGI movie. It would have raised awareness of the comic style (remember what the NECA figures acomplished in this regard), and, if it was succesful, could open the posibility of more properties based on, or similar in tone to, the original Mirage comics... theatrical movies, TV series...

We'll never know, though. But whith what we do know, I pick Turtles Forever.

Gyt Kaliba
01-13-2010, 12:44 PM
It definitely would have been nice if we could have had both happen, but I think I'd still definitely pick Forever.

Andrew NDB
01-13-2010, 12:49 PM
Adaption of TMNT #1, easily. Would have been the single most positive stride in awakening the potential of the TMNT in the mainstream that would've ever been made.

Turtles Forever is just primarily fanwank for nostalgiacs of the cartoons and such. Fortunately it's good fanwank for nostalgiacs of the cartoons, and it's also a great deal of fun. But let's call a duck a duck.

ToTheNines
01-13-2010, 03:43 PM
Adaption of TMNT #1, easily. Would have been the single most positive stride in awakening the potential of the TMNT in the mainstream that would've ever been made.

They were just gonna use the 2007 Munroe models... and it probably would have been watered down and alot less violent.

Andrew NDB
01-13-2010, 04:00 PM
They were just gonna use the 2007 Munroe models...

True. I think. With red bandannas on all of them, though.

and it probably would have been watered down and alot less violent.

Not true. Though that was my first concern about it I was told with 100% assurance that it was literally to be a word-for-word adaption with nothing censored.

Icebot
01-13-2010, 04:35 PM
I'd say Turtles Forever. I really liked seeing the turtles from both cartoons meet each other.

Andrew NDB
01-13-2010, 04:36 PM
I'd say Turtles Forever. I really liked seeing the turtles from both cartoons meet each other.

That doesn't address the topic of the thread.

Gyt Kaliba
01-13-2010, 05:03 PM
True. I think. With red bandannas on all of them, though.

Would it have been the short tied bandanas like in the comics then? Or just all red longer flowing ones like the films and 2003 series had.

Cipher
01-13-2010, 05:10 PM
I'm torn. As far as what I would've enjoyed, probably Turtles Forever. It was a great cap to the entire Mirage era, and a weirdly meta ending to the 4Kids cartoon that I would have never predicted six years ago.

But as far as the ramifications go, the #1 adaptation no doubt. If it was what they said it would be (a straight, red-masked adaptation), that could've helped pull the comics out of the water and made at least other movie and comic fans take another look at the Turtles.

Andrew NDB
01-13-2010, 05:34 PM
But as far as the ramifications go, the #1 adaptation no doubt. If it was what they said it would be (a straight, red-masked adaptation), that could've helped pull the comics out of the water and made at least other movie and comic fans take another look at the Turtles.

And, more importantly, studios. And not just to take a look at the Turtles, but to take a look at the Turtles in a completely different light than ever before.

Roseangelo
01-13-2010, 05:48 PM
And, more importantly, studios. And not just to take a look at the Turtles, but to take a look at the Turtles in a completely different light than ever before.

I honestly don't think this wouldn't have happened. The story in #1 alone isn't strong enough to garner such attention and, let's face it, the marketing for this would have been anywhere from minimal to pathetic, leaving it to just flail on store shelves same as the comics do.

Personally, I'm glad they went with something 100% new instead of rehashing #1 yet again.

Andrew NDB
01-13-2010, 05:50 PM
I honestly don't think this wouldn't have happened. The story in #1 alone isn't strong enough to garner such attention and, let's face it, the marketing for this would have been anywhere from minimal to pathetic, leaving it to just flail on store shelves same as the comics do.

But at least there would be something to point a finger to other than just, "Read the comics" when someone(s) would be trying to illustrate to a committee how there might be a direction to go with the TMNT other than the lowest common denominator route.

plastroncafe
01-13-2010, 07:54 PM
I honestly don't think this wouldn't have happened. The story in #1 alone isn't strong enough to garner such attention and, let's face it, the marketing for this would have been anywhere from minimal to pathetic, leaving it to just flail on store shelves same as the comics do.


Over looking the fact that clearly the story of #1 was strong enough for us to be on this forum having this discussion a full 25 years after the story was written...

I was really under the assumption that the cgi movie was going to be a fan service thing, and nothing more. That it was going to be paid out of pocket by Peter, and that the reason it was canned was because it was hard to get a good adaptation from #1 to screen.

Specifically I remember something about how the inner monologue/narration of Raphael during his mission was something that only really worked on the page, and not so much on the screen.

I just can't for the life of me remember any sources for these memories....
*sigh*

Vivi
01-13-2010, 08:16 PM
A CGI adaptation would've been the clincher for me...with a little tweaking to the original story. I'll probably be shunned for saying this, but something similar to the 2k3 version where the Shredder was actually a psychopathic alien would make for a very good movie. I think you could still keep dark and gritty themes with this kind of twist. Plus it ties in other elements of the comics in nicely, and let's be honest here, many issues aren't grounded in hyper realism.

Plus I liked Turtles Forever what it was - as an homage to the different universes - rather than the story itself.

norinrad2
01-13-2010, 08:32 PM
Turtles Forever was amazing!! I agree w/ you that it was more of an homage to the tmnt universe & long time fans. It's almost sad though because it feels like the end of an era but I suppose it really is. I mean w/ Mirage Studios selling the property & all. :ohwell:

Venom
01-13-2010, 08:34 PM
I just can't for the life of me remember any sources for these memories....*sigh*

Murph's 5th Turtle blog.

Roseangelo
01-13-2010, 09:05 PM
Over looking the fact that clearly the story of #1 was strong enough for us to be on this forum having this discussion a full 25 years after the story was written...

Oh, I'm not saying #1 is bad in any sense. Hardly. And it obviously served as a great launching platform for what was to come. But for the audience at large, #1 isn't much more than the origin story they already know and the Turtles have little to no individual characterization. I'm just saying that a broader story scope would have worked better. But it really doesn't matter, since they didn't do this anyways.

Cipher
01-13-2010, 09:30 PM
I honestly don't think this wouldn't have happened. The story in #1 alone isn't strong enough to garner such attention and, let's face it, the marketing for this would have been anywhere from minimal to pathetic, leaving it to just flail on store shelves same as the comics do.You know that just by being an animated film it would already cater to a larger audience than any comic.

And the major difference is it would have been a presentation of the Mirage Turtles that would be readily available. That has always been, as far as I'm concerned, one of the comic series' biggest weaknesses. If you can't walk in to a Barnes and Noble or a Target and find it, no one's going to give a sh*t.

Dragon Turtle
01-14-2010, 12:45 AM
Sorry I didn't know how to make a poll on this, but I'm just wondering what everyones thoughts are on the 25th anniversary video movies that were planned/made.
So what was more worth it: Turtles Forever or TMNT #1 CGI adaptation?
Remember Imagi of the CGI TMNT '07 movie was gonna adapt a CGI adaptation of TMNT #1, but fell apart as the budget and timing of release couldn't make it happen IIRC. The back up plan was Turtles Forever, which we all know happened.

We should have had both, to be honest.


Turtles Forever, no doubt. CGI would have ruined the Mirage look.

Without seeing how the movie would have looked, I don't see how you could come to this conclusion, (unless this is just a general "I hate CGI" statement).


Adaption of TMNT #1, easily. Would have been the single most positive stride in awakening the potential of the TMNT in the mainstream that would've ever been made.


Given the impact direct to dvd comic book movies have had in general, I doubt that an adaption of TMNT #1 would have made any major impact with the mainstream.


Oh, I'm not saying #1 is bad in any sense. Hardly. And it obviously served as a great launching platform for what was to come. But for the audience at large, #1 isn't much more than the origin story they already know and the Turtles have little to no individual characterization. I'm just saying that a broader story scope would have worked better. But it really doesn't matter, since they didn't do this anyways.

I believe there was more to the proposed CGI movie then a straight forward adaption, Don and Mikey were to have a somewhat bigger role, it would have been nice to see how Murphy's script had added to the original story.

sdp
01-14-2010, 10:00 AM
I remember Kevin Munroe posting information about it and he said it was a DTV adaptation of TMNT #1 to serve as a "prequel" to the movie. It wasn't going to be grimdark like the comic, it would have been done in the same style as the movie. I don't remember why it was canned but one of them was obviously they didn't have the money.

Anyways, Turtles Forever is a totally different beast, it had nothing to do whether the DTV came out or not.

TMNT #1 wouldn't have been any more "adult" than the movie was, if it had been it would have only been fan wank for a very small niche audience.

Oculus Orbus
01-14-2010, 11:03 AM
Without seeing how the movie would have looked, I don't see how you could come to this conclusion, (unless this is just a general "I hate CGI" statement).

I just base my conclusion in the little information we have. We know that it was gonna use the Munroe's models for the Turtles, and that it was gonna be made as some sort of prequel for the 2007 film, wich I guess means it would have been toned somehow for it to match with the film. For me, given that, it would've been completely annoying.

I hate it when something is meant to be an adaptation and comes out as something completely different to the original, specially when the original is so important to me. If you think about it, issue 1 (being one my favourite comics ever), doesn't stand out for its story. In my opinion, it's more about the gritty look, and the kind of art and storytelling it had, specially considering the moment when it came out. For me, that comic is just a classic itself, but I just don't think it would adapt well if you take out all the other elements (its specific art, mainly).

I really enjoyed Turtles Forever, specially the last part, and I think that, in the long term, it's gonna be something that we'll remember, and that was made in the right moment. I really hope an adaption of Issue 1 is made sometime, but only if it's done right.

A prequel for a film that was so bad doesn't sound good to me, if this comic is ever adapted it worths a lot more. Also, I hate CGI most of the time. But you know, it's just my opinion, and I can perfectly see why some people here would have liked an Issue 1 adaptation better than Turtles Forever.

Andrew NDB
01-14-2010, 11:06 AM
and that it was gonna be made as some sort of prequel for the 2007 film, wich I guess means it would have been toned somehow for it to match with the film

Well if that's true, then F it... but everything I've heard from Dan and Steve was that it'd be 100% true to the comic.

I don't remember why it was canned but one of them was obviously they didn't have the money.

Not true. Peter Laird was willing and able to pony up the money... but Richardson talked him out of it, and into Turtles Forever instead.

plastroncafe
01-14-2010, 11:32 AM
Murph's 5th Turtle blog.

Hooray! I'm not crazy!
Thanks.

Dragon Turtle
01-14-2010, 01:13 PM
I just base my conclusion in the little information we have. We know that it was gonna use the Munroe's models for the Turtles, and that it was gonna be made as some sort of prequel for the 2007 film, wich I guess means it would have been toned somehow for it to match with the film. For me, given that, it would've been completely annoying.


Other then being produce by Imagi, the dvd movie had no relation to the 2007 movie, it was certainly not a prequel.

gobo
01-14-2010, 02:04 PM
I remember Kevin Munroe posting information about it and he said it was a DTV adaptation of TMNT #1 to serve as a "prequel" to the movie.
Munroe never mentioned anything TMNT-related aside from his movie. I'm afraid this must be a false memory you've thrown together. Happens to me too from time to time...

Andrew NDB
01-14-2010, 02:08 PM
Munroe never mentioned anything TMNT-related aside from his movie.

Or his almost-sequel: "TMNT Part 5: Karai vs. April, the Rematch!"

Dragon Turtle
01-14-2010, 02:29 PM
Or his almost-sequel: "TMNT Part 5: Karai vs. April, the Rematch!"

There would have had to be an actual fight in the first movie in order for there to be a rematch.

Oculus Orbus
01-14-2010, 02:44 PM
Sorry I might be explaining myself badly, but it's just a bit hard for me to write english sometimes.

When I say prequel, I don't mean it as "a story that drives to the events told in the film", wich would be more or less what a prequel actually is. As far as I know (sorry I don't remember sources, 2007 seems like ages ago), the film was gonna be made in the way of TMNT 2007. That said, even if they did adapt the comic word by word, that would only be a small side of the thing. Being produced by Imagi, I assumed (and maybe I'm wrong here) that they would be using the same models for the Turtles, and that they'd be trying to warm up the audiences for the big thing, the Munroe's film.

Honestly, I hated that film. I'm glad that Imagi didn't make any adaptation of Issue 1, or this sequel Andrew pointed out.

Even if, as gobo said, Munroe never mentioned anything related to this "prequel", Imagi was still involved, and in my opinion it still would have been more similar to their film than to the comic itself.

gobo
01-14-2010, 03:43 PM
There would have had to be an actual fight in the first movie in order for there to be a rematch.
You don't remember the scene where April punk'd Karai and lived to tell the tale?
Imagi was still involved, and in my opinion it still would have been more similar to their film than to the comic itself.
That's exactly why I couldn't get behind this project. Even if they had blood shed in it, it would still remind of the 2007 movie. Yes, they were planning to use the same models to save money. You have the correct definition for the word, "prequel", but this adaptation wasn't publicly heard of until after the 2007 movie was out.

Dragon Turtle
01-14-2010, 07:15 PM
Even if, as gobo said, Munroe never mentioned anything related to this "prequel", Imagi was still involved, and in my opinion it still would have been more similar to their film than to the comic itself.

Other then the look, probably, but I personally didn't have problem with the look of the 2007 movie.


You don't remember the scene where April punk'd Karai and lived to tell the tale?



The brief three second scuffle was hardly anything to get riled up over.

oldmanwinters
01-14-2010, 08:08 PM
Or his almost-sequel: "TMNT Part 5: Karai vs. April, the Rematch!"

They saved that for Mission #27 of TMNT Smash-Up.:tlol:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eQKD46QLxyc#t=08m29s

sdp
01-14-2010, 09:53 PM
Munroe never mentioned anything TMNT-related aside from his movie. I'm afraid this must be a false memory you've thrown together. Happens to me too from time to time...


I guess its possible that it could be a false memory but I doubt it, I remember it pretty clearly. Its not like I visit other turtle blogs or anything or even post regularly on this forum. I do remember really well how it was Munroe who mentioned it.

gobo
01-14-2010, 10:23 PM
The brief three second scuffle was hardly anything to get riled up over.
I know, but try convincing Andrew of that. WAY easier said than done... ^_^

***First of Two Latin Kings***
01-14-2010, 11:37 PM
That's your problem. You shouldn't be trying to convince Andrew of ANYTHING.

And I mean that in the nicest possible way. :twink:

Dragon Turtle
01-15-2010, 01:08 AM
I guess its possible that it could be a false memory but I doubt it, I remember it pretty clearly. Its not like I visit other turtle blogs or anything or even post regularly on this forum. I do remember really well how it was Munroe who mentioned it.


The only real mention of the proposed CGI adaption came from Steve Murphy who wrote the script(s) for it, and only after the project had already been canceled. And Murphy went on to say it was going to be true to the original source material.

Andrew NDB
01-15-2010, 01:25 AM
I know, but try convincing Andrew of that. WAY easier said than done... ^_^

April ****in' O'Neil was able to knock down with sheer skill (we're not talking about some sucker punch here) not a random Foot Soldier, or a goon, or a henchman, or even the leader of a single branch of the Foot... but the leader of the entire Foot Clan! Am I the only one that has a problem with that?

Absurdity personified, and I'd say the movie jumped the shark at that moment if it hadn't already done it about thirty times by that point.

Dragon Turtle
01-15-2010, 02:11 AM
April ****in' O'Neil was able to knock down with sheer skill (we're not talking about some sucker punch here) not a random Foot Soldier, or a goon, or a henchman, or even the leader of a single branch of the Foot... but the leader of the entire Foot Clan! Am I the only one that has a problem with that?

Absurdity personified, and I'd say the movie jumped the shark at that moment if it hadn't already done it about thirty times by that point.


A few sword blocks and kick that pushed Karai back, before April turned tail and ran, hardly rates as the fight of the century, or any real measuring stick for April's skills. A prolonged one on one fight between Karai and April, with April beating Karai, would have been absurd. What April did to Karai in the movie was nothing for someone trained by Splinter.

Ninjinister
01-15-2010, 02:21 AM
April ****in' O'Neil was able to knock down with sheer skill (we're not talking about some sucker punch here) not a random Foot Soldier, or a goon, or a henchman, or even the leader of a single branch of the Foot... but the leader of the entire Foot Clan! Am I the only one that has a problem with that?


YES.

I mean, it wasn't as if it was an actual fight. It was the equivalent of third grader getting in one clean hit on a high school student and running.

And besides, I don't know what you know about the martial arts, but luck does play a factor.

Oculus Orbus
01-15-2010, 07:09 AM
April ****in' O'Neil was able to knock down with sheer skill (we're not talking about some sucker punch here) not a random Foot Soldier, or a goon, or a henchman, or even the leader of a single branch of the Foot... but the leader of the entire Foot Clan! Am I the only one that has a problem with that?

Absurdity personified, and I'd say the movie jumped the shark at that moment if it hadn't already done it about thirty times by that point.

No, I have a problem with that too.

But for me, at that moment of the film, I had already given up long ago.

gobo
01-15-2010, 07:57 AM
April ****in' O'Neil was able to knock down with sheer skill (we're not talking about some sucker punch here) not a random Foot Soldier, or a goon, or a henchman, or even the leader of a single branch of the Foot... but the leader of the entire Foot Clan! Am I the only one that has a problem with that?

Absurdity personified, and I'd say the movie jumped the shark at that moment if it hadn't already done it about thirty times by that point.
Valid argument, yes. Petty argument too though. I'm just saying, "why harp on it?" It accomplishes nothing. But, if it makes you feel better, have fun making fun of it. I was just teasing ya in the first place anyway.

oldmanwinters
01-15-2010, 08:47 AM
And besides, I don't know what you know about the martial arts, but luck does play a factor.

"The best swordsman in the world doesn't need to fear the second best swordsman in the world; no, the person for him to be afraid of is some ignorant antagonist who has never had a sword in his hand before; he doesn't do the thing he ought to do, and so the expert isn't prepared for him; he does the thing he ought not to do; and often it catches the expert out and ends him on the spot."
-Mark Twain, A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court

But, yeah, April really was overpowered in that movie. Unless, of course, she shares some of her heritage with the Archie-verse April.

EDIT: Wait, wasn't this thread supposed to be about Turtles Forever vs. TMNT #1 CGI adaptation?

Dragon Turtle
01-15-2010, 11:05 PM
But, yeah, April really was overpowered in that movie. Unless, of course, she shares some of her heritage with the Archie-verse April.


Or they developed her into an actual competent fighter in this particular continuity.



EDIT: Wait, wasn't this thread supposed to be about Turtles Forever vs. TMNT #1 CGI adaptation?

Yes, should have had both.

Coola Yagami
01-16-2010, 09:22 PM
That whole fight should have been done alot better. Why did the movie have to be so short? A fight between the TMNT, Splinter, April, Casey and the entire $&%#&% Foot Clan shoulda been a good 20 or so minutes long.

Koi
01-17-2010, 10:31 AM
April ****in' O'Neil was able to knock down with sheer skill (we're not talking about some sucker punch here) not a random Foot Soldier, or a goon, or a henchman, or even the leader of a single branch of the Foot... but the leader of the entire Foot Clan! Am I the only one that has a problem with that?

Absurdity personified, and I'd say the movie jumped the shark at that moment if it hadn't already done it about thirty times by that point.

I had a problem with that too. Kinda used to the DiD April from the older toons so it was really odd seeing that all the sudden she could kick some serious butt.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
01-18-2010, 10:54 AM
I had a problem with that too. Kinda used to the DiD April from the older toons so it was really odd seeing that all the sudden she could kick some serious butt.

She kicked serious butt in Archie too, and that was almost fifteen years ago. When you were still a baby :)

Coola Yagami
01-18-2010, 07:48 PM
I wonder how the sequel woulda turned out... the one bout Shredder returning, the TMNT and Splinter being de-mutated and Mikey being the hero.

Dragon Turtle
01-19-2010, 03:15 PM
That whole fight should have been done alot better. Why did the movie have to be so short? A fight between the TMNT, Splinter, April, Casey and the entire $&%#&% Foot Clan shoulda been a good 20 or so minutes long.

Time, money, and rating constraints most likely. The courtyard fight was more detailed in the Mirage approved script.


Since Paramount/Viacom currently have possession of Murphy's script, there's still the possibility of it getting made in some form as way to promote the upcoming movie.

The Stryker
01-19-2010, 08:23 PM
I wonder how the sequel woulda turned out... the one bout Shredder returning, the TMNT and Splinter being de-mutated and Mikey being the hero.

It would've been terrible just like the first movie.