PDA

View Full Version : No Shredder origin story in Tales, a missed opportunity?


CyberCubed
02-04-2010, 03:20 PM
We know very little about the Mirage Shredder, simply because, he died in the first issue.

Does anyone think it was a missed opportunity for them to give us a Tales issue about Shredder's youth, or how Shredder organized his criminal organization prior to #1?

We did see some small scenes about him as a kid crying when his brother died, but overall, not much was ever delved into. I think its a shame, since Tales is a "flashback" series and now that its over I doubt they'll ever delve into Oroku Saki's past in any future comics.

DrSpengler
02-04-2010, 03:28 PM
A very good point and yes, a missed opportunity.

Tales (Vol. 2) was never afraid to put the spotlight on non-Turtle characters for full issues. April, Casey and Karai all received complete issues dedicated solely to themselves without a Turtle to speak of.

I think Shredder could've benefitted from one of those.

Mirage Shredder is almost a blank slate. There's next to nothing known about him and he has very little depth as a character. Inthe Mirage universe, he's little more than a generic overlord villain archetype whom the Turtles toppled early in their career and have been suffering the backlash ever since.

There's certainly a lot of potential for his character to be explored. Big Bang Comics #10 gave us a rare glimpse of him, albeit it he was a tad contradictory to how he behaved in TMNT (Vol. 1) #1 (in Big Bang he was a slave to honor, whereas in TMNT #1 he couldn't give a damn).

"Cold, Cold Ice" only made me more curious with the reveal of the Oroku family still existing (I'd forgotten all about them).

His background in TMNT #1 said that the Foot Council manipulated his anger when he was just a boy and groomed him into a ruthless leader. There's a LOT in there that begs to be explored and potential to flesh out his two-dimensional character.

I mean, really, all he wanted was a misguided sense of vengeance for the death of his brother (possibly lead by the Council to believe that Nagi was killed by Yoshi in cold blood rather than to save an innocent woman). That's not so different from Splinter ordering the Turtles to execute Saki in order to avenge the death of Yoshi.


Yeah, there's a lot of stuff in there that could've made for a great spotlight issue. A real shame we never got anything like it.

Oh well, back to stories about gangsters kidnapping dogs for reward money and other thrilling adventures...

ToTheNines
02-04-2010, 03:37 PM
Wow never thought of this one...

I now consider this the biggest missed opportunity of Tales, just ahead of an Usagi story.

Andrew NDB
02-04-2010, 03:40 PM
At one point I was thinking about pitching a "Shredder Origins" type story but I was pretty much told not to bother (Pete not so much receptive to these kind of stories).

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-04-2010, 03:47 PM
There's certainly a lot of potential for his character to be explored. Big Bang Comics #10 gave us a rare glimpse of him, albeit it he was a tad contradictory to how he behaved in TMNT (Vol. 1) #1 (in Big Bang he was a slave to honor, whereas in TMNT #1 he couldn't give a damn).

I've never read the Big Bang Comics #10 Shredder story, so I can't speak to that. I never thought that Mirage Shredder was COMPLETELY without honor, you can say that about Movie Shredder if you want, since he was a hybrid between Nagi AND Saki (ugh :sick:), but to me, Mirage Shredder is more a victim of circumstances and some poor choices, sort of like Anakin Skywalker.

Splinter got a solo issue (correct me if I'm wrong), and I agree, it's too bad Ol' Shredder didn't get one.

Cipher
02-04-2010, 04:15 PM
Part of me feels like, yes, that would've been really cool.

The other part of me doesn't want to ruin what the Shredder is in the comics: simply an enciting incident to the rest of their adventures. You could start the series just after they killed Shredder and it would all work just as well.

oldmanwinters
02-04-2010, 05:00 PM
His background in TMNT #1 said that the Foot Council manipulated his anger when he was just a boy and groomed him into a ruthless leader. There's a LOT in there that begs to be explored and potential to flesh out his two-dimensional character.

I mean, really, all he wanted was a misguided sense of vengeance for the death of his brother (possibly lead by the Council to believe that Nagi was killed by Yoshi in cold blood rather than to save an innocent woman). That's not so different from Splinter ordering the Turtles to execute Saki in order to avenge the death of Yoshi.

I usually hate it when mysterious characters have their origins "fleshed out" (i.e., contrived for the sake of publicity) decades after their introduction, but when you describe it like this it really makes me curious about what could have been.

I never thought about the parallels between Saki's honor quest and Splinter's training of the TMNT. It certainly makes you wonder...

And what does it say about Hamato Yoshi to be involved with such an organization that would manipulate a young boy in such a manner?

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-04-2010, 05:04 PM
And what does it say about Hamato Yoshi to be involved with such an organization that would manipulate a young boy in such a manner?

Eh...not really sure there is a connection.

oldmanwinters
02-04-2010, 05:05 PM
Eh...not really sure there is a connection.

Was he not part of the Foot Clan? :?:

EDIT--checking my Free Comic Book Day reprint (still being given away at my local shop ;-D):

Yeah, I was just thinking how tainted Yoshi's legacy must have been to be "the greatest shadow warrior of ... the famous Foot Clan, the most feared warriors and assassins in all Japan." Not only do the Foot engage in assassinations but they also manipulate children and turn on their own members for defending their loved ones. And yet Yoshi held the most prestigious status among their warriors. Certainly not the heroic image that both cartoons have attributed to him, eh?

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-04-2010, 05:10 PM
The fact that he associated himself with the Foot Clan doesn't necessarily mean there was something shady about him. People are multi-dimensional. He might not have even been aware that there was corruption in the clan. Besides, he left when they wanted him to commit hari kari or seppuku or whatever because he defended the virtue of a woman. So it isn't like his allegiance to the Foot knew no bounds. Yoshi was a man of honor.

I wonder what happened in the timeline that Oroku Yoshi comes from... :tconfuse:

discordiatookie
02-04-2010, 05:41 PM
That woulda been a neat idea. However, we may very well have gotten another 'Pantheon'.

Oculus Orbus
02-04-2010, 05:45 PM
The fact that he associated himself with the Foot Clan doesn't necessarily mean there was something shady about him. People are multi-dimensional. He might not have even been aware that there was corruption in the clan.

Yeah I always saw it like that. But still, those similarities between Splinter and Shredder that DrSpengler pointed out would have made a really good point for a story.

But somehow, I think I prefer Shredder's origins to stay unclear. To me, it adds a lot to the character. That doesn't mean I wouldn't have loved to see him used in Tales, but he would have probably worked better as a figure, not as a character to be explained.

Venom
02-04-2010, 08:34 PM
I'm glad someone brought this up. I had an idea for a "Tales of the Shredder" story and asked Murph about submitting it but at the time there was a freeze on Tales submissions until around issue 40.

Also, Tristan had a Shredder tale. Neither of us went into great detail regarding either's story, but the idea of focusing on Saki was certainly there.

What we do know is he was a rather successful businessman and contracted the Foot out as security detail for others by day.

Another point, back when the Turtles were in a lull ther old Turtles Letters on the Mirage site sort of continued the story in bite sized morsels (and blending all the universes); one that always struck with me was around the time Peter announced Volume 4 the Turtles were gearing up to investigate a resurgence of the Foot presence in the NYC underground headed up by a young man calling himself the son of Oroku Saki.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-04-2010, 11:16 PM
Another point, back when the Turtles were in a lull ther old Turtles Letters on the Mirage site sort of continued the story in bite sized morsels (and blending all the universes); one that always struck with me was around the time Peter announced Volume 4 the Turtles were gearing up to investigate a resurgence of the Foot presence in the NYC underground headed up by a young man calling himself the son of Oroku Saki.

I do that too. :tlol:

prescribeddrone
02-04-2010, 11:34 PM
I'd like it but the writer has to be someone like... Ed Brubaker or Andy Diggle. They could pull off stuff like that flawlessly. Give Shredder a nice 8 issue mini.

It won't happen so why not list writers that wouldn't do it (unless of course a deal was made, but very unlikely)

Venom
02-04-2010, 11:47 PM
Mark Millar, Frank Miller, Joe Quesada, JMS, Bendis, Peter David, Kevin Eastman, etc.

Andrew NDB
02-05-2010, 12:15 AM
While we're throwing around dream names to do such a story, I guess I'd like to see Paul Jenkins write such a thing. He wrote TMNT's "The Halls of Lost Legends" and also "Origin" for Marvel (Wolverine's origin), so it seems like it'd be up his alley.

shuriken
02-05-2010, 12:26 AM
That defenitely was a missed opportunity if there ever was one. But as stated before they would probably screw it up with another pantheon...

ToTheNines
03-06-2010, 08:40 PM
I don't think many of you saw this post:

Ha! Me too. I've been sitting on a Shredder origin story for a while, one that explains why he's called the Shredder and where he got his armor. It would have been awesome (in my humble opinion), but hey, you can't always get what you want I guess.

Powder
03-06-2010, 09:05 PM
I'm indifferent actually.. I'll agree that it was DEFFINATELY a huge opportunity that they could've taken but oh well. Maybe its cliche, but its kinda cool that theres so much mystery to him, & that they don't point it out either.

CyberCubed
03-07-2010, 05:38 PM
This is one of the things where if they did it, it has to be PERFECT, or else it would be a disgrace.

Shredder is the one character they should not mess up in the Mirage universe. We don't need to see him acting like a supervillain or talking about world domination like he does in every other Turtle universe.

Mirage Shredder should be handled more realistically.

Venom
03-07-2010, 07:19 PM
Saki was a character of circumstance. The Foot wanted to become more powerful in the underworld and when Nagi was slain the elders used Saki's rage and frustration to channel that energy into creating a ruthless, powerful leader. However they didn't realize his cunning and intelligence as he apparently became either power-hungry or saw no need to follow Japan's orders and decided to take the New York (and possibly the entire American) branch and use it for his own personal gain to build an underground criminal organization.

I always sort of saw the Japanese Foot as evolving into third-party contractors that private corporations turned to whenever they wanted something done various governments could enlist if they wanted an assassination performed that could endanger international treaties.