PDA

View Full Version : Weird Realization about TMNT Comic Universes


***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-04-2010, 03:34 PM
Last night it occurred to me that thus far, no TMNT comic book universe has had what most of us would consider "a proper ending." I know none of them have as far as I'm concerned.

Some of you may be wondering about the logic behind this statement.

Mirage Universe: Volume 4 still incomplete, may never get an "official" ending.

Image Universe: At this point, Andrew and several others are working on this, and it MAY get an official ending...but since the project exists for the purpose of branching the Image universe to the Mirage universe, the Image universe will then become part of a universe that remains "incomplete" (Mirage).

Archie Adventure Series: This one is really ironic, considering that most people probably would have been okay with the series ending at #70, but the possibility of "The Forever War" (cancelled HOW many times now?) made it so that most people won't ever want to just let that series die. Issues #71 and #72 felt more like they should have been issues #1 and #2 of some sort of weird Archie version of Tales of the TMNT Vol. 1.

DreamWave: T4/Turtlenator story was in the works when the series got cancelled. What a waste. Peter David was DreamWave's answer to Stephen Murphy, who, unfortunately, seems as if he doesn't want any part of TMNT ever again. D@mn shame.

Andrew NDB
02-04-2010, 03:41 PM
but since the project exists for the purpose of branching the Image universe to the Mirage universe

Let's be clear: we're branching it back to the Mirage universe. And that's a secondary purpose, not the primary.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-04-2010, 03:49 PM
First off, I hope I didn't offend you...I'm just as excited about your project as anyone else.

I don't really see the difference between what I said and what you said, though. I know your primary purpose isn't to make Image "canon" or anything like that, now that Peter's out the picture canonicity isn't really an issue. All I am saying is that Image getting a proper ending will make a "part" of Mirage, which may never get a proper ending in and of itself.

ToTheNines
02-04-2010, 03:50 PM
I disagree. City at War was a proper ending, as was the last issue of volume 2. They were both continued, but they still could have ended right then or there.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-04-2010, 03:55 PM
I disagree. City at War was a proper ending, as was the last issue of volume 2. They were both continued, but they still could have ended right then or there.

City at War and Vol. 2 both got proper endings, but they're still both parts of a continuity that never got a proper ending.

Roseangelo
02-04-2010, 04:00 PM
No TMNT universe has ever received a proper ending. Comics or TV or, hell, even movies. I have been making note of this and it has been collectively bothering me for at least 15 years.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-04-2010, 04:02 PM
Well, I can see why you would say that about the movies and TV series, but those just never concerned me in that sense the way the comics do.

Andrew NDB
02-04-2010, 04:02 PM
First off, I hope I didn't offend you...I'm just as excited about your project as anyone else.

Oh, I know. No worries, man... I just get a little touchy when it's implied that Vol. 3 (Image) was kind of perpetually always not in Mirage canon... it's simply not true. It was part of the Mirage universe until the middle of Volume 4 when Laird said it wasn't any longer.

Which in itself is even odd because Peter himself was approving every Vol. 3 story and issue and even contributed a great many ideas himself to the mix.

I don't really see the difference between what I said and what you said, though.

Only that your wording implies that being part of the Mirage universe would be something new to the Image series/Vol. 3. It's not.

And about Mirage endings, if all Mirage universe comics had ended at Vol. 1, #62 and there had never been a Vol. 2 or anything else... that would have been a great ending. But since then... just a series of truncated endings.

Vol. 2? Interrupted and cancelled at #13. No ending received.

Vol. 3? Interrupted and cancelled at #23. No ending received.

Vol. 4? Put on hiatus at #28 in June, 2006 for 2 years. Put back on hiatus at #29 in April, 2008 for another year. Put back on hiatus at #30 in May, 2009 indefinitely. No ending received.

Things like Tales of the TMNT can be overlooked because it's not like there's one over-arching story that needs resolving... those issues are all over the map chronologically and story-wise and a trip back to "Return to New York" is as good a place as any to end it.

ToTheNines
02-04-2010, 04:03 PM
No TMNT universe has ever received a proper ending. Comics or TV or, hell, even movies. I have been making note of this and it has been collectively bothering me for at least 15 years.

Are you referring to a "this is it" moment, or actually tying up loose ends?

Master Splinter
02-04-2010, 04:07 PM
Are you referring to a "this is it" moment, or actually tying up loose ends?

Was wondering the same thing myself... I thought the ending on the first movie and Turtles Forever was pretty good... But I can see your point if you are referring to tying up loose ends...

-ms

Cipher
02-04-2010, 04:08 PM
No TMNT universe has ever received a proper ending. Comics or TV or, hell, even movies.The Fred-Wolf series got what was at least clearly intended to be a concluding episode. And the 4Kids cartoon had possibly the best ending of any Turtles universe yet.

But yes, the comics thing has bothered me for quite some time. Laird really needs to wrap up Volume 4. Forget Volume 2. The Mirage Turtles haven't had a decent conclusion since "City at War."

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-04-2010, 04:10 PM
Oh, I know. I just get a little touchy when it's implied that Vol. 3 (Image) was perpetually always not in Mirage canon... it's simply not true. It was part of the Mirage universe until the middle of Volume 4 when Laird said it wasn't any longer.

Which in itself is even odd because Peter himself was approving every Vol. 3 story and issue and even contributed a great many ideas himself to the mix.

Only that your wording implies that being part of the Mirage universe would be something new to the Image series/Vol. 3. It's not.

I didn't mean to imply that Peter never considered Image "canon," I knew even back then that it was part of the canon until one day he woke up and just decided for whatever reason that he didn't like it. I always thought that it got cut from the canon around the time he began Vol. 4, and became one of several of the topics of discussion in the letter columns of Vol. 4 that made him irate. I mean, he didn't like Bebop and Rocksteady either-- imagine how f**kin' surprised I was when I learned recently that he had a hand in designing them!

For me personally, Image will be canon YET AGAIN when it gets a proper conclusion that ties it in to the Mirage universe--it was originally canon, then Peter started saying it wasn't (so it wasn't, since Peter had final say over that at the time), then Peter sells turtles, so now anyone who wants can consider Image canon, and you're working on a project that will not only bridge the gap, but will make the Image-verse "forever canon." There won't be any room for debate after that gap is filled, THAT is what I was trying to get at. Right now it could be argued that Image "isn't canon" because Donatello isn't a cyborg in the Mirage-verse. But if the stories being worked on right now are going to explain that and provide a transition... then there is absolutely NO REASON that this fan community should no longer consider Image "canon."

CyberCubed
02-04-2010, 04:12 PM
No TMNT universe has ever received a proper ending. Comics or TV or, hell, even movies. I have been making note of this and it has been collectively bothering me for at least 15 years.

Both cartoons got a final ending. The original cartoons last episode felt pretty final to me, and the "Turtles Forever" movie wrapped up the 2k3 universe perfectly.

The movies, whether you count 3 or 4 as the final one, were pretty wrapped up.

Image continues into Mirage now, and I'm sure Volume 4 will get an ending eventually. So it's really just the Archie series that never got its ending.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-04-2010, 04:20 PM
Both cartoons got a final ending. The original cartoons last episode felt pretty final to me, and the "Turtles Forever" movie wrapped up the 2k3 universe perfectly.

The movies, whether you count 3 or 4 as the final one, were pretty wrapped up.

Image continues into Mirage now, and I'm sure Volume 4 will get an ending eventually. So it's really just the Archie series that never got its ending.

Well, even if something goes wrong, my impression is that Andrew is still planning to bridge that gap. I wonder, if a group of fans started collaborating and planning to finish "The Forever War," would Viacom consider making that an official project as well? I don't think Lawson would jump on board a Vol. 4 fan project anytime soon, simply out of respect for Peter Laird, even though there's no reason that we couldn't come up with our own ending to that series as well (which Lawson or a fan-artist would draw). If Lawson wanted to do the art, it isn't like anyone could stop him. Mirage isn't allowed to publish stuff that doesn't take place within the Mirage Universe, but I'm thinking Viacom can do what they please. Potentially there could be wind up being TWO endings to Vol. 4, a fan-written ending/Viacom ending AND a Peter Laird ending.

CyberCubed
02-04-2010, 04:23 PM
Potentially there could be wind up being TWO endings to Vol. 4, a fan-written ending/Viacom ending AND a Peter Laird ending.

I'd rather just wait that out until Peter Laird himself finishes it. Give him a year off to relax (he did just sell TMNT after all), and after that see if he comes back to Volume 4.

I really don't understand why some people think Vol. 4 won't be wrapped up. He'll get around to it when he does, and he'll likely hire Jim Lawson as a freelancer to do the art.

Roseangelo
02-04-2010, 04:26 PM
Are you referring to a "this is it" moment, or actually tying up loose ends?

Mostly a "This is it" moment, but I think of it more like a, "This is it, and life goes on," kind of thing. It's not an easy thing to do, for sure, and most TV series finales end up blowing it. Two TV shows that completely nailed it, IMO, were Star Trek TNG and Cheers. I expect Lost to nail it this year.

Tying up loose ends doesn't really bother me depending on what it is. I honestly don't care that there are so many incomplete plots/stories in the Mirage universe, but I do care that there were so many hints dropped at the future of the Turtles and it was never, ever explored in depth. Unfortunately, unlike a comic like Usagi Yojimbo, Cerebus, or Bone, Mirage had a bit of ADHD and could only ever treat TMNT as a continuing story in bits and pieces.

I thought the ending on the first movie and Turtles Forever was pretty good... But I can see your point if you are referring to tying up loose ends...

-ms

Turtles Forever was certainly the closest thing to an ending that there's been, but it wasn't so much an ending as it was a period at the end of a sentence. If you look at Wedding Bells and Bytes as being an ending... ugh. We're just really lucky they had Turtles Forever in the pipeline. I'm content with it being the ending of the 2K3 series, but I don't believe it was written to be the ending. Just once, I would like something to be written as an intended ending. Not just something that ends up being a last episode or a last issue.

Potentially there could be wind up being TWO endings to Vol. 4, a fan-written ending/Viacom ending AND a Peter Laird ending.

Vol. 4 is one of those things I don't care about. At all. It doesn't exist as far as I'm concerned, so I couldn't care less if it never ends.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-04-2010, 04:50 PM
Vol. 4 is one of those things I don't care about. At all. It doesn't exist as far as I'm concerned, so I couldn't care less if it never ends.

Which is fine, nobody is forcing you to read it. But a lot of us DO care about that series.

Oculus Orbus
02-04-2010, 06:09 PM
Potentially there could be wind up being TWO endings to Vol. 4, a fan-written ending/Viacom ending AND a Peter Laird ending.

I liked Volume 4. I loved it sometimes. And I want it to have an ending, by Peter Laird. At this point, for me it wouldn't make any sense to have a fan-written ending.

This is not, by any chance, like what Andrew is doing with the Image series. He's working with the people that made those comics, and if we're lucky, they'll just give us what we should have had back then.

That's not the case with Volume 4. Not yet, at least.

discordiatookie
02-04-2010, 06:10 PM
Which is fine, nobody is forcing you to read it. But a lot of us DO care about that series.

Agreed. I really dig them issues, and just hope Laird does finally get round to finishing it.

Wasn't issue 31 pretty much done and ready to print? I even remember seeing the covers for both 31 & 32 on Lawson's blog.

Andrew NDB
02-04-2010, 06:32 PM
Don't count out a proper Forever War conclusion yet. You folks just have to be patient (unless you'd rather folks fan-fictionize their own version of it and draw it... I don't know about you, but I'm not interested in that)... there are plans afoot.

CyberCubed
02-04-2010, 06:37 PM
Wasn't issue 31 pretty much done and ready to print? I even remember seeing the covers for both 31 & 32 on Lawson's blog.

He probably wants to release a batch of them together.

It makes more sense say, to have 6 issues of Volume 4 ready to be printed for 6 straight months, rather than give us an issue about once a year or so.

I just wish he'd lower the price of Vol. 4 issues, even though I know that won't happen. 6 more issues of Volume 4 costs $60 out of our pocket. :/

ToTheNines
02-04-2010, 08:17 PM
I just wish he'd lower the price of Vol. 4 issues, even though I know that won't happen. 6 more issues of Volume 4 costs $60 out of our pocket. :/

Plus shipping :)

Venom
02-04-2010, 08:51 PM
Not making a snide remark, but there isn't many comic properties that get true "endings". Marvel and DC have published "final" stories for many characters, but later on down the road those will either be retconned out of continuity or pushed to a pocket universe where the story was the final ending.

I don't think Peter or Kevin either one had an ending to the comic Turtles. Sure, it was shown to be seemingly bleak but we all know how the comic Turtles will end: they die. That's as real as it comes.

Now that the Turtles as a whole belong to a major corporate entity you can be assured they will never see an "end" per se, other than possibily becoming shelved when the property stagnates.

Cipher
02-04-2010, 09:25 PM
Not making a snide remark, but there isn't many comic properties that get true "endings". Marvel and DC have published "final" stories for many characters, but later on down the road those will either be retconned out of continuity or pushed to a pocket universe where the story was the final ending.But unlike the never-aging, constantly retconned Batman or Superman, the Turtles have a very specific continuity. We know when they were born. We know when they get old. And Peter Laird obviously intended Volume 4 as its own narrative.

It needs an ending. You don't start a plot without intending an ending.

I don't think Peter or Kevin either one had an ending to the comic Turtles. Sure, it was shown to be seemingly bleak but we all know how the comic Turtles will end: they die. That's as real as it comes.We know this. We just need a thematic ending. A little send-off that feels like closure. It could be something as existential as the old man in the hospital at the end of "City at War." It could be a final glimpse of the future Turtles. But somehow you need to walk away feeling satisfied.

Now that the Turtles as a whole belong to a major corporate entity you can be assured they will never see an "end" per se, other than possibily becoming shelved when the property stagnates.No one's talking about wrapping up the entire franchise. But it's not unreasonable to expect each version to have its own conclusion.

CyberCubed
02-04-2010, 09:32 PM
It doesn't really matter if TMNT gets a "climatic ending" someday.

After Volume 4 closes we still know the TMNT live on for another 60 years thanks to the stories that take place in the future, where we've seen old Leo, old Raph, and old Don.

We're never going to see all the adventures they went on after Volume 4 ends (most likely), but it doesn't matter. As said above, they continue to live until they get old, then they die.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-04-2010, 11:13 PM
Don't count out a proper Forever War conclusion yet. You folks just have to be patient (unless you'd rather folks fan-fictionize their own version of it and draw it... I don't know about you, but I'm not interested in that)... there are plans afoot.

What? How is that nobody has replied to this specific post yet?

I have a feeling you've already saved me a LOT of work, Andrew... :tlol:

Venom
02-04-2010, 11:51 PM
Probably because most of us know Buffy is working on this and in contact with Murph.

Unless he meant something a little more official. :O

CyberCubed
02-04-2010, 11:58 PM
Who is doing the art for that project, btw?

PAAATE
02-05-2010, 01:24 PM
It doesn't really matter if TMNT gets a "climatic ending" someday.

After Volume 4 closes we still know the TMNT live on for another 60 years thanks to the stories that take place in the future, where we've seen old Leo, old Raph, and old Don.

We're never going to see all the adventures they went on after Volume 4 ends (most likely), but it doesn't matter. As said above, they continue to live until they get old, then they die.

Yeah, but a story structurally NEEDS an ending, that feels like an ending, for it to be a complete story. Even if we know something will happen in the future, it needs a proper ending here and now.

At least, that's what I think.

discordiatookie
02-05-2010, 01:28 PM
He probably wants to release a batch of them together.

It makes more sense say, to have 6 issues of Volume 4 ready to be printed for 6 straight months, rather than give us an issue about once a year or so.


Yeah, that went through my head also.

Andrew NDB
02-05-2010, 01:35 PM
Not making a snide remark, but there isn't many comic properties that get true "endings". Marvel and DC have published "final" stories for many characters, but later on down the road those will either be retconned out of continuity or pushed to a pocket universe where the story was the final ending.

I don't think Marvel and DC properties are comparable to TMNT. I think of TMNT in the Mirage comics in the same way I'd think of something like Cerberus, or Groo... I don't see the existing comic universe going on forever like Batman or Superman. I don't think that was ever the intention.

I'd imagine at some point there'd be a planned ending, and then that'd pretty much be the curtain call (barring "fill-in-the-blanks" type stuff like Tales of the TMNT).

It'd be strange if "The Final TMNT Story" didn't touch on or at least feature as a coda the elderly Ninja Turtles and what's going on there.

CyberCubed
02-05-2010, 02:15 PM
Yeah, but a story structurally NEEDS an ending, that feels like an ending, for it to be a complete story. Even if we know something will happen in the future, it needs a proper ending here and now.

That's what I agree with.

Volume 4 will likely get some ending someday, where the group returns together (similar to the end of City at War), and the storyline ends.

Even after Volume 4 gets a conclusive ending, and even if another TMNT comic is never made after that, we STILL know the TMNT continue to live on through the year 2060 and beyond. Didn't Tales #41 take place in the year 2099 or something?

The Turtles live for for another 60 something years afterward. We're never going to get to see every little adventure they went on. That's what I like though, we see them grow old naturally and that's that.

Andrew NDB
02-05-2010, 02:56 PM
Even after Volume 4 gets a conclusive ending, and even if another TMNT comic is never made after that, we STILL know the TMNT continue to live on through the year 2060 and beyond. Didn't Tales #41 take place in the year 2099 or something?

The Turtles live for for another 60 something years afterward. We're never going to get to see every little adventure they went on. That's what I like though, we see them grow old naturally and that's that.

You're dismissing the possibility that the end of Volume 4 could say "90 years later" and have an epilogue with the elderly Turtles.

Which is a strong possibility.

Cipher
02-05-2010, 08:20 PM
You're dismissing the possibility that the end of Volume 4 could say "90 years later" and have an epilogue with the elderly Turtles.

Which is a strong possibility.That's exactly what I expect/want to see.

There's really no other way to do it.

CyberCubed
02-05-2010, 10:30 PM
I wouldn't mind the Mirage universe having a definite ending after Volume 4 wraps.

I don't want it to be the end of TMNT comics in general though. But I suppose that's very possible at some point due to where the franchise is now.

Venom
02-05-2010, 10:57 PM
So how would you like to see the series wrap up? With a one page glimpse or an actual story featuring the elder Turtles?

What do we honestly know about the future Turtles?

We know nothing of Mikey so perhaps he's offworld (being optimistic), Raph lives in self-imposed exile, Leo lives in a tree in Neo-NYC and Don lives in some futuristic house overlooking the ocean.

Would the "last" Turtle tale be about the guys getting together "one last time" to find their lost brother? Don, being the most technically oriented, probably has the means to locate Raph and Leo at short notice. I could see him appearing at the doorway of Leo's tree hut and telling him, "I know where he is."

The two of them then trek to the swampy regions (old New York? Help me out, I've not went thru my issues to clarify, has this been defined other than Archie) and having to fight Raph briefly because he believes his mind is playing tricks on him after all the years of isolation after leaving Neo-Tokyo [X number] of years ago. Throw in a couple of sprites and a flying manta in the background for nice nods.

After going back to Don's place and reiterating that Mike's been missing for [insert X number here] years (flashback sequence of epic Mikey battle as it's being explained?) and explaining how Don managed to finally get a track on Mike's location Raph says he's ready to go get his best pal back.

Then after the three get geared up the quest begins and through many perilous dangers and tribulations they finally find Mike and bring him home. The last panel is a splash of the four of them overlooking some beautiful nighttime landscape, Raph's arm around Mike, and Michelangelo says "like old times, huh?"

Or would you prefer something a bit more bleak, such as them finding his grave? That would certainly drive home the point that "life at best, is bittersweet."

ToTheNines
02-05-2010, 11:26 PM
Umm... we see future Mike for one panel in "Swan Song", he's ok.

Cipher
02-05-2010, 11:48 PM
(A lot of stuff)I was thinking alot less melodrama. Just wrap up the main plot of Volume 4 and give us a page or two of the four old Turtles together, or maybe the last remaining Turtle reflecting quitetly, turning off the lights, and walking out of the bar. So to speak. (No, I don't mean dying.)

At this point we just need something to tie up the existing plot, and if it's going to work as an ending to the entire series, at least reference the future Turtles we've seen.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-05-2010, 11:58 PM
Umm... we see future Mike for one panel in "Swan Song", he's ok.

We do? I guess I need to reread that issue as well...

Powder
02-06-2010, 12:26 AM
I've noticed a pattern here. The number 3 is bad news.

vol.2 ends at 13
vol.3 at 23
vol.4 potentially at 30
two thousand & THREE series cut short (reaching for that)
3rd movie, garbage. Presumably causing the franchise downfall for a few years.
Is it 3 episodes total missing from the OT series dvd's?

How many times did the forever war get cancelled?
3 times?

Hmm..

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-06-2010, 12:32 AM
I think you meant to say that Vol. 3 ended at #23.

Andrew NDB
02-06-2010, 12:37 AM
What? How is that nobody has replied to this specific post yet?

I have a feeling you've already saved me a LOT of work, Andrew... :tlol:

Probably because most of us know Buffy is working on this and in contact with Murph.

Buffy is neither the first person that's been in contact with him or the only one, and no one is working on anything right now. But there's a very good reason for that... but it will pay off.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-06-2010, 01:13 AM
More vague teaser replies from Andrew... :trolleye:

Venom
02-06-2010, 07:06 AM
I've noticed a pattern here. The number 3 is bad news.

vol.2 ends at 13
vol.3 at 23
vol.4 potentially at 30
two thousand & THREE series cut short (reaching for that)
3rd movie, garbage. Presumably causing the franchise downfall for a few years.
Is it 3 episodes total missing from the OT series dvd's?

How many times did the forever war get cancelled?
3 times?

Hmm..

How many future Turtles do we know are alive? 3

How many fingers does the Turtles have on each hand? 3!

How many prongs on a sai? 3!!

"Cowabunga" has 9 letters, which is divisible by 3!!! ZOMG!!!!!1!! :twink:

ToTheNines
02-08-2010, 04:08 PM
I hate to discourage... but anyone remember Peter saying this in the letter column of #24?

"I suppose I could run out of money and not able to continue doing the book. Or I could get tired of doing it and stop. (I must say, the idea of a short --i.e. 6 months or so -- hiatus or vacation from the book has some appeal to me these days.) But neither currently seems to be very likely. I wish I could tell you definitely what's going to happen, but that's just not the way I'm doing this Vol. 4, I can pretty much gaurantee you that there wil be no "rush job to conclude the story" -- it's acutally more likely that it will NEVER be concluded and people will have to use theri imaginations....."

There was some more stuff after that, mostly talk about going annual or bi-annual.

Oh, I know. No worries, man... I just get a little touchy when it's implied that Vol. 3 (Image) was kind of perpetually always not in Mirage canon... it's simply not true. It was part of the Mirage universe until the middle of Volume 4 when Laird said it wasn't any longer.

Which in itself is even odd because Peter himself was approving every Vol. 3 story and issue and even contributed a great many ideas himself to the mix.

To quote Pete some more:
"As I've said before, I greatly appreciate the fact that Eric Larsen stepped up and published the TMNT book at Image, and Gary Carlson did a lot of interesting work on that series. But I've also said, it's not the direction in which I would have gone had I been writing the book. Now that I am back and writing this new series, it makes the most sense as far as I am concerned to ignore what happened in those Image issues and move forward using what I think of as "Mirage continuity".

CyberCubed
02-08-2010, 08:58 PM
That stuff doesn't really matter anymore now that PL doesn't own the Turtles. From the looks of things, PL's "official timeline" will never be published anyway, so it doesn't make a difference.

I also believe the main plots of Volume 4 will be wrapped up, I think PL was talking about minor plot stuff like Don clipping off a piece of Splinter's fur, something like that will probably be left to our imaginations even after Vol. 4 ends.

If Image officially publishes the new issues, it'll be interesting to see what he thinks of them.

sdp
02-08-2010, 10:32 PM
No TMNT universe has ever received a proper ending. Comics or TV or, hell, even movies. I have been making note of this and it has been collectively bothering me for at least 15 years.

If you want to get that picky then most franchises don't get "proper" endings.

CyberCubed
02-10-2010, 09:53 PM
At least TMNT comic continuity isn't as messed up as some DC or Marvel comic continuity.

Thank god we don't have 50 years worth of TMNT comics to retcon, we only have 25 years and less than 200 canon comics. The Mirage universe is so simple compared to most comic series

Spitfire
02-10-2010, 10:08 PM
I feel Mirage had an ending. Just read any of the stories that take place way in the future. The little inserts in the new Tales volume 1 reprint detail to me that all the turtles are dead but Donatello and he pretty much lives a lonely and hallow life. Depressing ending maybe but it's an ending still. I guess if you have to know how or why they died then that doesn't fulfill you but it works for me. As for the in between that's yet to be finished but if you wanted to skip to the end of the book and read the last page with Mirage you could.

Archie got a proper ending. Granted Forever War never happened the fact remains even without it the time line is complete. Another depressing last note but it's like anything. We can assume there's more adventures but the main villains are all taken care of.

2K3's ending wrapped up everything nicely. I saw some posts saying that didn't get a proper ending. The OT did as well. The turtles defeated their enemy for what appeared to be the last time. Sure more could happen to them but for all we know it's done with.

Stuff could go on forever sure but if you want an ending sometimes you have to look for one or accept what we got.

ToTheNines
02-10-2010, 10:17 PM
I feel Mirage had an ending. Just read any of the stories that take place way in the future. The little inserts in the new Tales volume 1 reprint detail to me that all the turtles are dead but Donatello and he pretty much lives a lonely and hallow life. Depressing ending maybe but it's an ending still. I guess if you have to know how or why they died then that doesn't fulfill you but it works for me. As for the in between that's yet to be finished but if you wanted to skip to the end of the book and read the last page with Mirage you could.

Does that ever pop up on ebay? I have the original collection, but I really want to check out the new frontpieces and read the conclusion.

Spitfire
02-10-2010, 10:53 PM
Does that ever pop up on ebay? I have the original collection, but I really want to check out the new frontpieces and read the conclusion.

I see it sometimes on Ebay. I got mine at a local comic shop that had extras. That was awhile ago though. I scout Ebay for turtles books quite often so if I happen to see one I'll let ya know.

Andrew NDB
02-10-2010, 11:30 PM
I get the impression that Plastron Cafe #1 has been somewhat retconned by Laird himself. Or at least pushed much further in time than the "Early 21st Century" as it was said to be in it.

ToTheNines
02-11-2010, 10:14 AM
I see it sometimes on Ebay. I got mine at a local comic shop that had extras. That was awhile ago though. I scout Ebay for turtles books quite often so if I happen to see one I'll let ya know.

Ok, thanks man.

I get the impression that Plastron Cafe #1 has been somewhat retconned by Laird himself. Or at least pushed much further in time than the "Early 21st Century" as it was said to be in it.

Why's that?

Andrew NDB
02-11-2010, 11:50 AM
Why's that?

Because Don's apparently crying that he's the last Turtle, and yet we know from Tales V2 stuff that most/all the TMNT are alive and well in the "Early 21st Century" that Plastron Cafe #1 is set in. And since Volume 4 pretty much sits smack in the middle of the "Early 21st Century" and we haven't seen Don become a hermit with a computer in Japan yet.

Don seems similarly melancholy in the new epilogue seen in the Tales TPB reprint, and it's basically telling us the same story but just much further in the future.

ToTheNines
02-11-2010, 12:20 PM
Hmmm, I think the date is just a screw up in Plastron Cafe. I mean, he shows definite signs of old age with his wrinkles in that piece.

He was also in "Triptyche", I'll check that one in a bit and compare dates.