PDA

View Full Version : What's Wrong With 2k3?


Turo602
02-16-2010, 10:49 PM
Has anyone ever known or is someone who grew up with the 80s/90s TMNT toon and for some reason disliked the 2k3 toon. I don't get it. Why do people hate it, it's like they can't see a new generation of TMNT which I think is the most dominate TMNT show with out sh*t talking it.

Like my brother says the 2k3 TMNT sucks more compared to the 80s one just because he grew up with it. He still enjoys the 2k3 toon but still bad mouths it a lot. He also said nobody wants to be a turtle any more like in the 80s/90s. My answer to that is, kids aren't how they use to be.

I don't see the problem with the 2k3 TMNT and don't see why the older fans hate it so much.

Spitfire
02-16-2010, 10:54 PM
It falls into a weird place for fans. Fans of the old toon will find little of what they enjoyed about the OT present, which makes them dislike it. Fans of the comic books will find the source material present but in a very dumbed down and juvenile manner.

To sum it up plainly the series is too serious for OT fans and not serious enough for comic fans. I fall into the category of person who likes all the universe for the most part. I equally like the OT and 2K3 for different reasons. The mood I'm in really depends on which I watch though I admit I am in the mood to watch the OT more then 2K3.

Turo602
02-16-2010, 11:06 PM
It falls into a weird place for fans. Fans of the old toon will find little of what they enjoyed about the OT present, which makes them dislike it. Fans of the comic books will find the source material present but in a very dumbed down and juvenile manner.

To sum it up plainly the series is too serious for OT fans and not serious enough for comic fans. I fall into the category of person who likes all the universe for the most part. I equally like the OT and 2K3 for different reasons. The mood I'm in really depends on which I watch though I admit I am in the mood to watch the OT more then 2K3.

Yeah that's true, but I prefer the 2k3 because I just like action better and because it has it's funny moments. But I still hate when they bad mouth it with out any back up. It's like they think the 80s one came first and is the TMNT's true origin.

Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
02-16-2010, 11:07 PM
Some older fans hate it because they flat out refuse to believe that the Turtles were first a very serious, dark comic book that 2k3 takes some homage towards and is slightly based on. It's not as goofy as the old toon and they don't like that. It's just hard for them to believe.

Raph
02-16-2010, 11:07 PM
Well I grew up with the classic cartoon. I was 8 back in '88. Because of it, my overall love for the Turtles grew fast and after the Next Mutation series I found out about the original Mirage comics. This made my overall love grow even faster.
I though the comics rocked and found out how the actual origin of the Turtles went, and how the the first live action movie was accurate in that. (Back then at the schoolyard we all talk about the weird thing, that Splinter was human and then rat, why was that changed in the live action movie!)

After my love for the comics and the original backstory of the TMNT the 2K3 cartoon came out. And I was happy as a child again seeying how this cartoon was more comic based. I love 2k3 more then the 80's cartoon now.
Maybe if I never found out about the comics, it would have been differently.

Turo602
02-16-2010, 11:13 PM
Well I grew up with the classic cartoon. I was 8 back in '88. Because of it, my overall love for the Turtles grew fast and after the Next Mutation series I found out about the original Mirage comics. This made my overall love grow even faster.
I though the comics rocked and found out how the actual origin of the Turtles went, and how the the first live action movie was accurate in that. (Back then at the schoolyard we all talk about the weird thing, that Splinter was human and then rat, why was that changed in the live action movie!)

After my love for the comics and the original backstory of the TMNT the 2K3 cartoon came out. And I was happy as a child again seeying how this cartoon was more comic based. I love 2k3 more then the 80's cartoon now.
Maybe if I never found out about the comics, it would have been differently.

Same here about the first live action film, back in sixth grade I found out how accurate and how close to the comics the movie was. And yeah I remember when I first learned about the TMNT's real origins and learned about the comics a bit more and realized that the 2k3 cartoon was so close to the original TMNT comics.

Bry
02-16-2010, 11:13 PM
Never underestimate the power of nostalgia. The 2K3 show isn't perfect, but I think the main "flaw" it has for many people is that it's different than the Ninja Turtles they're used to - and unfortunately, many people with those nostalgic feelings toward something just aren't willing to give a fair shake to anything "new"/different.

(Granted, if the tone/style/whatever of the show just isn't to someone's liking, that's fair. But I'd bet that a lot of the old cartoon's fans tend to be overly caught up on what TMNT is "supposed to be" and automatically dismissing anything that doesn't fit that mould.)

ToTheNines
02-16-2010, 11:21 PM
Since previous posters pretty much got it all, I'm gonna go off topic yet still answer the title question: Use of the justice force past season 2.

Powder
02-16-2010, 11:21 PM
At first I had alot of qualms about it, some of which I still agree with. For the record I love it to death though...

1. The portrayel of mikey was contradictory to making the show more like the comic.
2. I felt they tried way too hard to be dark & it came off very pretentious to me.
3. Much like the old toon, the company had too much creative liberty in creating really lame villains.
4. Much like point number one, Casey jones' bad qualities were over-extentuated in a very unflattering manner.
5. Splinter was grey. It took me a long time to get used to it, let alone accept/like it.
6. Baxter Stockman. He was overused rediculously. The fact that he was getting practically butchered, at first, was great. They took it too far when making him a brain in a jar, numerous robots, holograms etc.
7. Too much super hero bullsh!t. Turtle titan was wack. Silver sentry was wack. ETC..
8. The gradual loss of its 'dark tone'.
9. As most mediums, I felt they focused too much on raph & leo, as well as the tension between them.
10. Touch & go. Ugh.
11. It took me a realllllyyyyy long time to like the voice acting. I guess now I'm used to it & therefore appreciate it, but at first I thought it was very amatuerish for the most part.
12. Too many wacky vehicles & the like. Donny can fix trucks, maybe supe up an VW, thats about all. They might as well have brought back the damn turtle blimp.
13. Many villains from the comics could've appeared (in place of the wack ones). Bloodsucker, Complete Carnage, (more of) The Rat King, I could go on about that for a while but I'm sure you're all familiar with them.
14. It was great that they made episodes that were comic adaptions, but they could've picked some better ones. For example, the issue Richard Corben did where the turtles have renets time traveling device & see the many old world scenarios.
15. No cerebus crossover.
16. The constant resurfacing of characters. It got old fast. Even with shredder. Maybe especially with shredder.

I could go on all night lol.

I love the hell out of it though & have all the dvds short of turtles against hate.

Turo602
02-16-2010, 11:24 PM
I like both incarnations a lot, and don't see why people can't like the show but have to jump to it sucking already without giving it a real chance. My brother did and he likes the 2k3 show but still really prefers the 80s/90s one overall.

Coola Yagami
02-16-2010, 11:28 PM
Course there's the whole Shredder being an Utrom thing.... many fans hated that.

Powder
02-16-2010, 11:30 PM
Course there's the whole Shredder being an Utrom thing.... many fans hated that.

That, IMO, may have been the best part. Shows based on comics & such, never usually make something up themselves that (most) fans could accept in the comics. Many people here have said they wouldn't have minded having seen it happen. I thought it was very creative & totally believable.

Turo602
02-16-2010, 11:34 PM
Course there's the whole Shredder being an Utrom thing.... many fans hated that.

That really didn't seem to bother me. But even before that was found out people attacked it already.

I even saw a stupid video on Youtube about someone's thoughts on the new TMNT and the retard started on season five and started to talk sh*t. It's called watching the beginning before watching a season that is out of the ordinary of the show.

Andrew NDB
02-16-2010, 11:56 PM
It falls into a weird place for fans. Fans of the old toon will find little of what they enjoyed about the OT present, which makes them dislike it. Fans of the comic books will find the source material present but in a very dumbed down and juvenile manner.

Which shouldn't strike anyone as too weird. It's not "for" either of these groups of fans.

CyberCubed
02-17-2010, 12:08 AM
Keep in mind that some of those are "casual" TMNT fans. These are people who probably never even bought the old toon DVDs, have no memory of what the show is like, and are going on faded nostalgia. Those people barely count as fans of the franchise.

The 2k3 series was very popular and very well-received amongst most of the fanbase. There are some aspects of it that could have been done better and it did have some crap episodes, but overall the show received a lot of praise during its run.

For a kids show, I get the feeling TMNT 2k3 is the best we're ever going to get. I don't think the Nick toon will top it, honestly.

Ninjinister
02-17-2010, 12:39 AM
Some of the self-titled "non-fans" here on the boards keep going on and on about how then villains who get character development in spades are "boring" in comparison to the original cartoon's villains.

I love me some B&R, but seriously, their entire story was "punks that were mutated". True, it worked for them, but you can't compare them to the likes of Hun and Bishop, or even 2K3 Baxter in the matter of "boring" or not. It's like apples and f***ing coconuts.

They're also way too defensive about it, citing how "boring" they are, like six times per post, but not even going into why.

Dragon Turtle
02-17-2010, 01:20 AM
Has anyone ever known or is someone who grew up with the 80s/90s TMNT toon and for some reason disliked the 2k3 toon. I don't get it. Why do people hate it, it's like they can't see a new generation of TMNT which I think is the most dominate TMNT show with out sh*t talking it.


Most likely because it's not the show they grew up with, both in terms of the actual show itself as well as content. A new show will never replace the one they grew up with, some people have a hard time keeping an open mind about new versions and interpretations of something they once held close to their hearts, especially given the long gap between the shows, for some people the OT was the only version they had ever known.

There is also the fact the new shows tone is quite different from the old one, some people prefer the light hearted comedy version of the turtles, and seeing them in more serious light goes against a big reason why they became fans of the turtles in the first place.

No doubt the Nick show will face a similar reaction from those who had grown up with the NT, and similar to the reaction the OT faced from Mirage fans long before.

Spitfire
02-17-2010, 04:08 AM
Some of the self-titled "non-fans" here on the boards keep going on and on about how then villains who get character development in spades are "boring" in comparison to the original cartoon's villains.

I love me some B&R, but seriously, their entire story was "punks that were mutated". True, it worked for them, but you can't compare them to the likes of Hun and Bishop, or even 2K3 Baxter in the matter of "boring" or not. It's like apples and f***ing coconuts.

They're also way too defensive about it, citing how "boring" they are, like six times per post, but not even going into why.
Character development is often boring to you when you have ADD and pure grade cocaine running through your veins.

ToTheNines
02-17-2010, 08:42 AM
They're also way too defensive about it, citing how "boring" they are, like six times per post, but not even going into why.

That's why I love the ignore list.

Luzmagica
02-17-2010, 08:48 AM
What´s wrong? ....:teek: ....uhh ..ahh.. Nothing is wrong!!! I love All the cartoons OT and 2k3 !!! Is it so rare/weird???....

Mona_Lisa
02-17-2010, 12:41 PM
Has anyone ever known or is someone who grew up with the 80s/90s TMNT toon and for some reason disliked the 2k3 toon. I don't get it. Why do people hate it, it's like they can't see a new generation of TMNT which I think is the most dominate TMNT show with out sh*t talking it.

I don’t hate the new TMNT cartoon, in-fact I like it very much, but I’ll always like the 80’s version better. It was my life as a kid LOL!
Honestly, I didn’t even no about the original comic until I was 15, and since I had (and still have) really slow internet I’ve only read the very 1st comic. So to me the 80’s turtles was “turtle prime”! The only comic to me was Archie…
But I love that there is a new generation of TMNT.
I don’t know what you mean about the NT being “dominate”, I guess now a day it is. I’d say the most successful version of TMNT on TV was the 80’s toon though.


(Back then at the schoolyard we all talk about the weird thing, that Splinter was human and then rat, why was that changed in the live action movie!)


Me and my friends could never figure that one out either. LOL!


5. Splinter was grey. It took me a long time to get used to it, let alone accept/like it.

I still can't get over Splinter being grey. I know thats dumb...

Course there's the whole Shredder being an Utrom thing.... many fans hated that.
I really hated that, until I got on this site and found out that was the way the comics went. Then I was OK with shreder being Krang (in my mind).:tgrin:

Revan
02-17-2010, 01:25 PM
At first I had alot of qualms about it, some of which I still agree with. For the record I love it to death though...

1. The portrayel of mikey was contradictory to making the show more like the comic.
2. I felt they tried way too hard to be dark & it came off very pretentious to me.
3. Much like the old toon, the company had too much creative liberty in creating really lame villains.
4. Much like point number one, Casey jones' bad qualities were over-extentuated in a very unflattering manner.
5. Splinter was grey. It took me a long time to get used to it, let alone accept/like it.
6. Baxter Stockman. He was overused rediculously. The fact that he was getting practically butchered, at first, was great. They took it too far when making him a brain in a jar, numerous robots, holograms etc.
7. Too much super hero bullsh!t. Turtle titan was wack. Silver sentry was wack. ETC..
8. The gradual loss of its 'dark tone'.
9. As most mediums, I felt they focused too much on raph & leo, as well as the tension between them.
10. Touch & go. Ugh.
11. It took me a realllllyyyyy long time to like the voice acting. I guess now I'm used to it & therefore appreciate it, but at first I thought it was very amatuerish for the most part.
12. Too many wacky vehicles & the like. Donny can fix trucks, maybe supe up an VW, thats about all. They might as well have brought back the damn turtle blimp.
13. Many villains from the comics could've appeared (in place of the wack ones). Bloodsucker, Complete Carnage, (more of) The Rat King, I could go on about that for a while but I'm sure you're all familiar with them.
14. It was great that they made episodes that were comic adaptions, but they could've picked some better ones. For example, the issue Richard Corben did where the turtles have renets time traveling device & see the many old world scenarios.
15. No cerebus crossover.
16. The constant resurfacing of characters. It got old fast. Even with shredder. Maybe especially with shredder.

I could go on all night lol.

I love the hell out of it though & have all the dvds short of turtles against hate.
All lot of what you say is understandable but you have to realize that it's difficult to write a show like this that airs on saturday mornings when kids will be watching while the turtles also have many older fans. Writers made those decisions in an attempt to keep kids interested and please the rest of us at the same time.
That being said, I can't argue with your points. Just something to keep in mind.

I have a few gripes of my own but if I would have had creative control, I would have made this show into something that I personally loved and I'll tell you one thing, kids would not have liked it. I can think of a handful of dromers that would have loved "my 2k3" series but OT fans and kinds would have been dissapointed to say the least. I'll leave it at that.

CyberCubed
02-17-2010, 01:54 PM
Yeah, they went as far as they could go for Saturday Mornings.

Hun and Baxter were brought back so many times because for the most part, they were "Bebop and Rocksteady" of the new show. Yes they were much more competent, but how many times did they fail at their missions?

Saturday Morning cartoons need villains and villain lackeys, that's the way it goes.

jestergoblin
02-17-2010, 02:52 PM
Maybe I just have a much harder time going back, but I can barely tolerate most of the original toon now. I've bought almost the entire series on DVD, and an episode or two is a blast to watch (especially after a few drinks) but nostalgia is a big draw. I don't watch it for character development or animation (after the first season), I watch it to remember that feeling I used to get waking up early on Saturdays with a big bowl of cereal and cartoons. But at the same time, TMNT Forever got me the same way.

With 2k3, I was in high school when it started and I loved almost the entire series. It wasn't until my second year of college that I missed an episode airing (hell, I woke up the morning after prom to watch the Justice Force episode).

As for problems with 2k3: Notes from the Underground. That would have been an interesting single episode or an okay 2-parter but as 3 parts it dragged and dragged.

But I'm willing to overlook that because of The Same as It Never Was. That single episode is the pinnacle of what the 2k3 series represented to me. After that episode, we were all freaking out and with good reason. It showed just how dark the series was willing to go.

gobo
02-17-2010, 03:44 PM
What's Wrong With 2k3?
User error. There's no other valid explanation other than some people just aren't watching it right. I've been waiting for this series since '89.

shinefra
02-17-2010, 04:06 PM
I still love the 80s one, but to be honest I think the 2k3 Is better, It had more action, It had better story telling and better animation.

Shure I still think the original April is hotter and the fact that shredder was an utrom kind of pissed me off a little, but all in all the 2003 version had more production value and more effort.

Turo602
02-17-2010, 04:07 PM
I don’t know what you mean about the NT being “dominate”, I guess now a day it is. I’d say the most successful version of TMNT on TV was the 80’s toon though.:tgrin:

I know the 80s was the most successful one, but what I mean by dominate is that the 2k3 is my favorite.

I still love the 80s one, but to be honest I think the 2k3 Is better, It had more action, It had better story telling and better animation.

Shure I still think the original April is hotter and the fact that shredder was an utrom kind of pissed me off a little, but all in all the 2003 version had more production value and more effort.

And dude, agree with you 100% except about the utrom thing. It just added originality to it.

Koi
02-17-2010, 05:49 PM
I grew up with the 2k3 but I prefer the 80's way more. The 2k3 seems very, corny. Just re-watching episodes now after buying them, they seem very corny. They didn't really master the dark atmosphere right so all their wines and sad moments just really came off corny to me making me laugh in response.

FlawedCoil82
02-17-2010, 07:00 PM
I can't even compare the two. I grew up with the 80's toon and I hated it just as much then as I do today. It is the sole reason why my interest in TMNT ever died in the first place. When I caught an episode of 2k3 one morning on tv, I was blown away and thought "now THIS is how the 80's toon should have been." After that I faithfully watched every episode until it changed to Fast Forward. It angered me so much when they didn't finish the Ninja Tribunal that I boycotted watching the rest of the series. I saw one or two episodes and was disgusted at how much it went back to the 80's style more. Only after I heard that Ninja Tribunal was going to finally air (and be put out on dvd) did I go back and order the FF dvds from WalMart.com (they were only like $6 each) and after watching the series without the anger, I was able to find a handful of episodes that I enjoyed. When I heard that Back To The Sewer was going to come out, I was excited to think it would go back to the glory days of 2k3. Not so.... :(

BTTS was (just barely) above the 80's toon for me. FF was a good step above it. 2K3 was in a completely different category. To this day, it is the only cartoon series that I (almost) loved as much as X-Men.
Jack

Turo602
02-17-2010, 07:16 PM
TMNT FF was not that bad, and Back to the Sewers wasn't bad either except for the designs which you could thank the TMNT 2007 film for. It's like that film doomed The TMNT figures and last season.

k_lala
02-17-2010, 08:01 PM
Has anyone ever known or is someone who grew up with the 80s/90s TMNT toon and for some reason disliked the 2k3 toon. I don't get it. Why do people hate it, it's like they can't see a new generation of TMNT which I think is the most dominate TMNT show with out sh*t talking it.

Like my brother says the 2k3 TMNT sucks more compared to the 80s one just because he grew up with it. He still enjoys the 2k3 toon but still bad mouths it a lot. He also said nobody wants to be a turtle any more like in the 80s/90s. My answer to that is, kids aren't how they use to be.

I don't see the problem with the 2k3 TMNT and don't see why the older fans hate it so much.

Nothings wrong with it, they probably saw Fast Forward or BTTS that's why. Ok those were horrible!!

Turo602
02-17-2010, 08:10 PM
Nothings wrong with it, they probably saw Fast Forward or BTTS that's why. Ok those were horrible!!

We all know that wasn't the highlight of 2k3 TMNT but that's already nearing the end of the series.

CyberCubed
02-17-2010, 08:35 PM
The old cartoon was good fun. It wasn't trying to be a serious show.

The Stryker
02-17-2010, 08:36 PM
Oooh man. This is my thread. Love you too Ninjinister.

I just did not like the show after the first season. It wasn't perfect in the beginning but it showed a lot of promise. I was really interested to see where they went but they just started losing me with the overuse of Baxter and the whole Shredder thing.

Sure, I prefer the OT but if 2k3 managed to do something that sparked my interest in the slightest I would give it all the props in the world. I'm not hating on it just because it wasn't "my" Ninja Turtles.

So for me atleast: Eh, I just don't like it.

Ninjinister
02-17-2010, 09:21 PM
What'd I do now?

Revan
02-17-2010, 11:55 PM
The old cartoon was good fun. It wasn't trying to be a serious show.
Amen. They are both good shows. It's apples and oranges. One doesn't have to be better than the other. Why can't they both be good and be appreciated as such.
Why can't we all just get along?:lol:

Leo656
02-18-2010, 02:09 AM
I'll always love 'em both for what they are. I liked the 2K3 series better for a lot of reasons, but I understand why people go the other way. Watching Season 7 of the OT recently, though, that show was really limping by then. The Red Sky Seasons weren't perfect, but they were a huge, much-needed shot of adrenaline by then. If they hadn't made the changes, I think Season 7 would have been the end. It was pretty weak.

I'm just very grateful that the newer show had a decent run, enough time to at least have had a chance to be established. Unlike some other 80s revivals that only lasted a season or two. ::COUGHmotuCOUGH::

oceam
02-18-2010, 05:47 AM
I find both shows easy to attack by both sides, I must admit that the NT personally has been losing it's appeal by each season and the OT has it's annoying quirks. In my opinion I'd prefer the classic show over the newer show anyway.

An NT fan will probably dislike the OT show because it didn't follow the comics, going it's own way. The NT has a lot more fanbase material, it has a lot of fanart and fanfics while the OT seems to be dwiddling for years in the fanbase but it's the most memorable as cartoon goes. It just goes by the individual viewer, seeing what appeals to them and what doesn't.

gobo
02-18-2010, 06:52 AM
Why can't we all just get along?:lol:
Where've you been? Opinionated critiques are essential for conversation 'round these parts, whether they be absurd questions being taken seriously or something even more ridiculous. Next up: what was wrong with Turtles Forever?

Revan
02-18-2010, 10:44 AM
I find both shows easy to attack by both sides, I must admit that the NT personally has been losing it's appeal by each season and the OT has it's annoying quirks. In my opinion I'd prefer the classic show over the newer show anyway.

An NT fan will probably dislike the OT show because it didn't follow the comics, going it's own way. The NT has a lot more fanbase material, it has a lot of fanart and fanfics while the OT seems to be dwiddling for years in the fanbase but it's the most memorable as cartoon goes. It just goes by the individual viewer, seeing what appeals to them and what doesn't.
That's all well and good except your generalizing viewers into 2 groups. There are lots of fans who like both the OT and the 2k3 series. Me being one such person.
I'll agree each show has its bright spots and weaknesses but what show doesn't?
There are definately three viewpoints
- OT fans
- NT fans
- fans of both

(- fans of neither?)

...perhaps four if you want to get technical

CyberCubed
02-18-2010, 11:07 AM
Season 7 of the OT recently, though, that show was really limping by then. The Red Sky Seasons weren't perfect, but they were a huge, much-needed shot of adrenaline by then. If they hadn't made the changes, I think Season 7 would have been the end. It was pretty weak.

The European Vacation eps weren't really part of Season 7, those eps were not good.

The regular Season 7 eps were excellent though, it was my favorite season. I wish the old toon was like that the whole way through. It was the closest back to Season 1 the show ever got.

For the original show:

Season 1
Season 7
Season 3
Season 6
Season 8
Season 10
Season 5
Season 4
Season 9
European Vacation

Turo602
02-18-2010, 11:19 AM
The European Vacation eps weren't really part of Season 7, those eps were not good.

The regular Season 7 eps were excellent though, it was my favorite season. I wish the old toon was like that the whole way through. It was the closest back to Season 1 the show ever got.

For the original show:

Season 1
Season 7
Season 3
Season 6
Season 8
Season 10
Season 5
Season 4
Season 9
European Vacation

Yeah I thought that too. It kinda of felt actiony to me

ToTheNines
02-18-2010, 03:05 PM
Next up: what was wrong with Turtles Forever?

Well a lot of people said NT April's voice sounded too young. Oh wait, that was only you :P

For the original show:

Season 1
Season 7
Season 3
Season 6
Season 8
Season 10
Season 5
Season 4
Season 9
European Vacation

Season 2 still exists.

gobo
02-18-2010, 03:44 PM
Next up: what was wrong with Turtles Forever?
Well a lot of people said NT April's voice sounded too young. Oh wait, that was only you :P
^_^ Inside jokes rule... But, about that, I can only assume the accoustics of the club were making her sound higher-pitched than normal. She was 100% recognizable every time I saw it since then.

Leo656
02-18-2010, 04:52 PM
The European Vacation eps weren't really part of Season 7, those eps were not good.

The regular Season 7 eps were excellent though


You know, now that I think of it, You're right. Watching that first block of eps on DVD after not seeing any for years, I was like "Hm. this is kind of... odd." I thought it was kinda neat how they were in a different country every episode, but it got old quick and of course the voice actor replacements throw you off a bit, and the animation wasn't as good... they just felt really cheap compared to some other eps, like the rest of that season which, as you said, was in fact much better.

I retract my earlier, sleep-deprived statement. It was on the whole better than I said it was.

SwordofTengu
02-18-2010, 06:49 PM
However;
1. Mikey could get really annoying
2. The turtles saying, "What the shell?" like every episode.
3. Some things were repeated too much. (like Shredder and Stockman always coming back)
4. Casey went from cool to a lug who can't fight.
5. Seasons 5-7 pretty much suck balls
6. Season 4 started to really decline in the show's quality.
7. Well as a matter of fact Season 1 was the only really outstanding season.
8. The superheros were shown way too much.
9. The cyber and tengu stuff was ridicoulous.

ToTheNines
02-18-2010, 06:54 PM
8. The superheros were shown way too much.

Yup. They were used so much I'm actually glad they didn't use Carnage and Radical (even if they were 100 times cooler than the Justice Force). While I didn't mind their first appearance, I fuc*ing cringe every time they're like "The President has called in the Justice Force!". Ugh.

And even with all the freaks and what not that showed up in the Christmas episode, Silver Sentry still looks ridiculous hanging out in the lair.

Koi
02-18-2010, 07:17 PM
However;
1. Mikey could get really annoying
2. The turtles saying, "What the shell?" like every episode.
3. Some things were repeated too much. (like Shredder and Stockman always coming back)
4. Casey went from cool to a lug who can't fight.
5. Seasons 5-7 pretty much suck balls
6. Season 4 started to really decline in the show's quality.
7. Well as a matter of fact Season 1 was the only really outstanding season.
8. The superheros were shown way too much.
9. The cyber and tengu stuff was ridicoulous.

I am amazed at how much I agree wish exactly what you said. Casey was pretty cool in his first episode, but soon enough his attitude died.

Turo602
02-18-2010, 07:21 PM
However;
1. Mikey could get really annoying
2. The turtles saying, "What the shell?" like every episode.
3. Some things were repeated too much. (like Shredder and Stockman always coming back)
4. Casey went from cool to a lug who can't fight.
5. Seasons 5-7 pretty much suck balls
6. Season 4 started to really decline in the show's quality.
7. Well as a matter of fact Season 1 was the only really outstanding season.
8. The superheros were shown way too much.
9. The cyber and tengu stuff was ridicoulous.

1. agree
2. agree
3. disagree
4. agree
5. disagree
6. disagree
7. disagree
8. disagree
9. disagree

k_lala
02-18-2010, 08:03 PM
We all know that wasn't the highlight of 2k3 TMNT but that's already nearing the end of the series.

It was the end of the series. And that's why some people who did watch it probably saw those episodes and wondered why people were so hyped about the new series.

Luzmagica
02-19-2010, 01:12 AM
What´s wrong? ....:teek: ....uhh ..ahh.. Nothing is wrong!!! I love All the cartoons OT and 2k3 !!! Is it so rare/weird???....

That's all well and good except your generalizing viewers into 2 groups. There are lots of fans who like both the OT and the 2k3 series. Me being one such person.
I'll agree each show has its bright spots and weaknesses but what show doesn't?
There are definately three viewpoints
- OT fans
- NT fans
- fans of both

(- fans of neither?)

...perhaps four if you want to get technical

Im agree! :twink::tgrin:

Krutch
02-19-2010, 05:45 AM
I never seen any of the BTTS episodes, but I loved all the 2k3 series. Even the FF episodes were light fun. Shredder being an Utrom made sense, and I loved the originality behind the idea, but I could never get over that a slug was kicking the turtles ass all the time by pulling levers(essentially). Its a dumb thing to complain about, I know, but it still kinda bugs me.

hudemx
02-19-2010, 09:54 AM
The European Vacation eps weren't really part of Season 7, those eps were not good.

The regular Season 7 eps were excellent though, it was my favorite season. I wish the old toon was like that the whole way through. It was the closest back to Season 1 the show ever got.

For the original show:

Season 1
Season 7
Season 3
Season 6
Season 8
Season 10
Season 5
Season 4
Season 9
European Vacation

Really? I kinda enjoyed the European Vacation episodes, even though they were animated really....really bad!

Mona_Lisa
02-19-2010, 12:05 PM
Shredder being an Utrom made sense, and I loved the originality behind the idea, but I could never get over that a slug was kicking the turtles a** all the time by pulling levers(essentially). Its a dumb thing to complain about, I know, but it still kinda bugs me.

Yeah, I feel the same way.... I guess we don't understand just how great Utrom technology is LOL!!!:tgrin:

gobo
02-19-2010, 02:47 PM
And even with all the freaks and what not that showed up in the Christmas episode, Silver Sentry still looks ridiculous hanging out in the lair.
I'm sure that was their intention. Holiday eps are more often than not more childish than usual. If I didn't know any better, I'd take that to mean holidays are just for kids.
Shredder being an Utrom made sense, and I loved the originality behind the idea, but I could never get over that a slug was kicking the turtles ass all the time by pulling levers(essentially).
Since reading this, I keep wondering how many tentacles an Utrom has...I kinda enjoyed the European Vacation episodes, even though they were animated really....really bad!
Glad to hear I'm not the only one. They certainly weren't my favorites, but I think all but two (Dublin & Norway) are decent once you get past the replacement voices. I just know there were plenty Season 3 eps that irritated me more than these.
However;
1. Mikey could get really annoying
2. The turtles saying, "What the shell?" like every episode.
3. Some things were repeated too much. (like Shredder and Stockman always coming back)
4. Casey went from cool to a lug who can't fight.
5. Seasons 5-7 pretty much suck balls
6. Season 4 started to really decline in the show's quality.
7. Well as a matter of fact Season 1 was the only really outstanding season.
8. The superheros were shown way too much.
9. The cyber and tengu stuff was ridicoulous.

disagree
disagree
disagree
disagree
disagree
disagree
don't be stoopit
disagree
are you insane? O_o

Come get you some.
http://www.sega-16.com/review_images/880/8.jpg

Cipher
02-19-2010, 03:03 PM
disagree
disagree
disagree
disagree
disagree
disagree
don't be stoopit
disagree
are you insane? O_o

Come get you some.
I think most of those, if blunt, are actually pretty fair and widely held complaints. The only points I'd disagree with him on are, Seasons Four and Six are both very enjoyable, and Season One is not the only good season.

Otherwise, that list was pretty accurate.

gobo
02-19-2010, 03:44 PM
*taking absurd posts eriously*
*facepalm* After a few people replied numbered agreements or disagreements to someone else's numbered list of complaints, the moderatist/pacifist known as gobo answers the the list of misworded questions all with "no" then tries to pick a fight.


Well, I thought it was amusing... :ohwell:

Cipher
02-19-2010, 03:56 PM
*facepalm* After a few people replied numbered agreements or disagreements to someone else's numbered list of complaints, the moderatist/pacifist known as gobo answers the the list of misworded questions all with "no" then tries to pick a fight.Oooooh. See, I hadn't read through any other posts in the thread.

Yup. They were used so much I'm actually glad they didn't use Carnage and Radical (even if they were 100 times cooler than the Justice Force).But I just saw this. At least Complete Carnage and radical were real characters. You know, rather than sub-standard homages.

Complete Carnage has always had the potential to be an awesome villain if used right. That guy in a city is like Viral in cyber space; an opponent so ridiculously powerful it's hard to write.

ToTheNines
02-19-2010, 04:32 PM
Complete Carnage has always had the potential to be an awesome villain if used right. That guy in a city is like Viral in cyber space; an opponent so ridiculously powerful it's hard to write.

Don't get me wrong, I would have much rather seen them over the Justice Force... but after seeing the JF more than enough in seasons 2/3, I was no longer hoping to see them.

SwordofTengu
02-20-2010, 09:36 PM
I'm sorry I said Season 1 was the only outstanding season. That was honestly a slip of my tongue. Season 2 and 3 were great (however I only really like the first 6 episodes and last 5 of season 3, the rest seem like filler).

I don't really hate the cyber or tengu stuff, it just got repetive to me.

I also really didn't mind Shredder and Baxter coming back. The Shredder kinda mind sense, he was an Utrom in that exosuit and all, but Baxter got pretty ridiculous.

shuriken
02-20-2010, 10:40 PM
The cyber and tengu stuff did get really, really repetetive.
I enjoyed seasons 1-4 quite a bit, as wel as like the first half of the lost season, you know before everybody "died".

Leonardo Mystic
02-20-2010, 11:34 PM
I loved this show up until Fast Forward came along. Then was it like "Are you kidding me?" Back to the Sewer was a little more tolerable, but not by much. At least no Cody except for the first episode of that season. There was a winning formula they had at the beginning of the series, but they changed it with starting with FF and it backfired on them. It was like they were trying too hard to make it more appealing to younger children. And really, Ninja Turtles isn't supposed to be made for five-year-olds.

I grew up with the old school 80's turtles, but now I couldn't go back to watch any of it without cringing. That one really was made for young children and it worked then, but that's not what I want now. One of the biggest factors that drew me to this series and ultimately back to the fandom was the edginess and seriousness of the Turtles.

Finally they could fight and mean business. They were kickass. It was around the same time I discovered they were actually a comic book first. I really enjoyed reading the first volume and I liked how adult it was.

This is what has me worried about what Nick will eventually do for its new series. I don't want to go backwards again. I want to keep the slightly young adult Turtles of the 2k3 series.

Scandia
02-21-2010, 05:38 PM
Honestly, when I first saw that there was a new TMNT show in 2006, I was afraid it would be all style and no substance. Must have been a bad episode that day.

Because 2k3 is now my favorite version of TMNT, followed by Archie.

Vivi
02-24-2010, 04:51 AM
It's far from perfect, but I love it nonetheless.

things that weren't so great:
-Some of the direction, timing and dialogue, music (in earlier episodes, the guitar riffs weren't doing it for me), random slew of one or two shot villains in filler eps, and most of BTTS which by that stage had been watered down to pond water. Also missing was a more binding story throughout the series other than the imminent threat of Shredder, whom by season 5 was a demon, season 6 a flashback, and season 7 a backup file.

TheCanadiandrome
02-24-2010, 09:43 AM
i used to not like the 2K3 series. watched a few episodes and was like, "meh". but after watching TMNT Forever, i don't know, suddenly there's a liking there. so much so, i've recently aquired the first season and the FF season, and am trying to complete this series on dvd

BubblyShell22
02-24-2010, 01:46 PM
I like both series equally. I grew up on the OT and was reintroduced to the Turtles via the new toon. I think both series are good, and that was shown through Turtles Forever. It was almost as though they were trying to say, "See? Both series are equally good."

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-24-2010, 05:53 PM
Well after I took off the nostalgia glasses and gave it a chance without thinking about the original toon it was great. On it's own it's great....

But for someone who grew up with the old toon it just didn't feel the same. It didn't have the same spirit, and I think that's what a lot of people who hated it cause of nostalgia felt.

and sometimes it just tried way too hard to be serious. Like it felt it HAD to be totally serious even when it came to the humor.

Also I agree with the Nostalgia Critic on the over use of What the Shell and stuff like that. Honestly it's like they were trying to be edgy by throwing in some pseudo curse words as if they thought it made them cool or something.

Turo602
02-24-2010, 06:01 PM
That show was serious and was also funny at times. But they did say what the shell to much.

Koi
02-24-2010, 06:26 PM
That show was serious and was also funny at times. But they did say what the shell to much.

They attempted at being serious and failed to a good extent, you can't be serious if a super immature Mikey and a bunch of very non funny jokes are plastered here and there.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-24-2010, 06:43 PM
Honestly I found the goofy OT world more amusing than the NT world that tries to be funny in a world where everyone is deadpan serious.

It's like listening to Ben Stein telling very funny jokes. You want to laugh but you just aren't able too.

Turo602
02-24-2010, 10:14 PM
They attempted at being serious and failed to a good extent, you can't be serious if a super immature Mikey and a bunch of very non funny jokes are plastered here and there.

The show was serious. They were serious when they needed to be, It's not like if Shredder was going to kill Splinter and you have Mikey over here making jokes. They made jokes at appropriate times, but not all of them were funny. And sometimes there was jokes that were funny to us but they weren't supposed to be funny to them.

The show still retained the darkness and seriousness. Just because they all had personality and weren't always dead serious doesn't mean that they weren't serious. They all had sense of humor.

Cipher
02-24-2010, 11:29 PM
I think the greater problem was that it tried to be ridiculously dark and yet still had to follow the conventions and formula of a kids' cartoon. It's a little tough to swallow all that "darkness" when everything has to be a cheesy, convenient melodrama.

And I say this with all respect for the show. It did a good job for the most part.

gobo
02-25-2010, 12:40 AM
It's a little tough to swallow all that "darkness" when everything has to be a cheesy, convenient melodrama.
That's exactly what I always thought about Batman: The Animated Series.

You're damn right. I went there.
What's Wrong With 2k3?
I want to change my answer. My new answer is: Your FACE!
Who needs alcohol when you've got sleep-deprivation? WOO!

Cipher
02-25-2010, 01:40 AM
That's exactly what I always thought about Batman: The Animated Series.

You're damn right. I went there.I actually completely agree with this. Half the time that show is way too pretentious for its own good.

Who needs alcohol when you've got sleep-deprivation? WOO!I actually left a drunk post in this thread last weekend and it was deleted. Which is a shame because as far as I can remember, it was totally coherent and legitimate. Just harsh.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-25-2010, 01:44 AM
That's exactly what I always thought about Batman: The Animated Series.

You're damn right. I went there.

I want to change my answer. My new answer is: Your FACE!
Who needs alcohol when you've got sleep-deprivation? WOO!

I never did like Batman the animated series... or Gargoyles for that matter. Never got why people thought such melodramatic series that tried to be super serious, dark, and edgy in every episode are the greatest cartoons ever made.

ToTheNines
02-25-2010, 09:35 AM
That's exactly what I always thought about Batman: The Animated Series.

You're damn right. I went there.

I actually completely agree with this. Half the time that show is way too pretentious for its own good.

"I Am The Night" anyone?

Turo602
02-25-2010, 11:06 AM
You are all really really wrong all of you, Batman The Animated Series is one of the darkest and the best cartoons of all time. It wasn't as dark when it got to the new adventures but never say it sucked or wasn't dark!!!!!!!!!!!!

And no, I am the Night, I am Vengeance, I'm Batman

ToTheNines
02-25-2010, 11:25 AM
Hmmm. You obviously don't know what you're talking about so i'll just explain it to you instead of fighting.

1. We never said it wasn't dark - we said it tried too hard to be dark at times.
2. We never said we didn't like it - I know for a fact that gobo and I like the show, and I'm sure Cipher enjoys it too.
3. "I Am The Night" was an episode of the show that tried really hard to be deep/emotional/dark, but it was full of corny dialouge and was not good - I was not refering to that quote from "Nothing to Fear", I love that episode.
4. The New Batman Adventures was great too - get over the designs.

Turo602
02-25-2010, 11:38 AM
Hmmm. You obviously don't know what you're talking about so i'll just explain it to you instead of fighting.

1. We never said it wasn't dark - we said it tried too hard to be dark at times.
2. We never said we didn't like it - I know for a fact that gobo and I like the show, and I'm sure Cipher enjoys it too.
3. "I Am The Night" was an episode of the show that tried really hard to be deep/emotional/dark, but it was full of corny dialouge and was not good - I was not refering to that quote from "Nothing to Fear", I love that episode.
4. The New Batman Adventures was great too - get over the designs.

No, I was just saying that I'm Batman. And somebody said they don't like it and it didn't try to hard it was hard. And anyway I was being dumb, you could tell by the big text.;)

ToTheNines
02-25-2010, 01:21 PM
My bad fella... I don't know you very well and I assumed you were some rabbid fan.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-25-2010, 04:18 PM
Personally I never really liked watching Batman until the new adventures when it was paired up with Superman on Kids WB.

Honestly though if 2k3 wanted to be dark then it should just be dark. It shouldn't try to be super serious and then throw in humor every five seconds. If they wanted to make TMNT humorous they should have stuck to the OT formula.

Turo602
02-25-2010, 06:57 PM
Yeah they did that. It's called Fast Foward. I wouldn't want that for the hole series.

gobo
02-25-2010, 06:58 PM
I was being dumb, you could tell by the big text.;)
I figured you were just making fun of 'rabbid Batfans'. It wasn't the most obvious joke in the world, but it was amusing. Good job, bud.
I actually left a drunk post in this thread last weekend and it was deleted.
I think I read that one thinking "he must be drunk", but I don't recall it being anything objectional.

Still, did it seem like I was drunk? I never can tell as I've never been a good judge of sobriety. I'm serious about that just being a sleepy-as-hell post... and hell is sleepy like you wouldn't believe (just for the sake of making my phrase accurate; bless hell's heart :evilgrin: ). But, you know, some people seem drunk 24/7, so I can rarely tell.
Honestly though if 2k3 wanted to be dark then it should just be dark. It shouldn't try to be super serious and then throw in humor every five seconds. If they wanted to make TMNT humorous they should have stuck to the OT formula.
Nay. There's too much of that one-sided mentality in tv. 2K3 was perfect the way it was as it was designed with us variety-lovers in mind.

This friendly argument reminds of the scene at the beginning of Ratatouille with Remy trying to explain to his cousin the difference between eating to be inspired and eating just because you can. :P

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-25-2010, 09:53 PM
.

Nay. There's too much of that one-sided mentality in tv. 2K3 was perfect the way it was as it was designed with us variety-lovers in mind.

This friendly argument reminds of the scene at the beginning of Ratatouille with Remy trying to explain to his cousin the difference between eating to be inspired and eating just because you can. :P

I suppose, but could you imagine how it would have been if 2k3 actually tried to be as dark and gritty as the comics but still kept in all the cheesy one liners and such that didn't fit the characters at all?

2k3 on it's own is great, but I wouldn't exactly say it's dark or anything. Unless you're just comparing it to the OT.

I suppose that's why people think Batman the animated series is dark. Because technically it was a lot more serious than any animated Batman that came before it. After all now you got Batman Beyond and The Batman that try to be just as serious. BTAS isn't as special anymore.

Yeah they did that. It's called Fast Foward. I wouldn't want that for the hole series.

I liked Fast Forward for the fact that it was more episodic and you really didn't need to watch the whole season in order to get what was happening.

Turo602
02-25-2010, 09:57 PM
I suppose that's why people think Batman the animated series is dark. Because technically it was a lot more serious than any animated Batman that came before it.

And after it.

But I would love to see a more mature TMNT cartoon with blood, heavy violence, and mild language. That's what killed 2k3 it was a kids show too.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-25-2010, 10:02 PM
And after it.

But I would love to see a more mature TMNT cartoon with blood, heavy violence, and mild language. That's what killed 2k3 it was a kids show too.

eh I wouldn't say that. Technically you could claim Batman Beyond was just as dark and gritty. Even though a lot of the character designs.... like Terry for instance look like they came straight out of hot topic.

Turo602
02-25-2010, 10:06 PM
eh I wouldn't say that. Technically you could claim Batman Beyond was just as dark and gritty. Even though a lot of the character designs.... like Terry for instance look like they came straight out of hot topic.

Batman Beyond was not as Dark as Batman TAS. They even allowed real guns and bullets instead of lasers.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-25-2010, 10:17 PM
Batman Beyond was not as Dark as Batman TAS. They even allowed real guns and bullets instead of lazers.

Batman Beyond was dark. It had the atmosphere. It was pretty darn violent and Terry was a pretty gritty Batman.

gobo
02-25-2010, 10:22 PM
They even allowed real guns and bullets instead of lazers.
When was it ever decided that bullets were more lethal than lasers? O_o You're acting like lasers are completely fictional or something. :P If you said Beyond wasn't as luminance-deficient for as long as TAS was, I could get behind that.

Turo602
02-25-2010, 10:34 PM
It's not about lethalness. The only reason shows use lasers is because it's not that violent and won't kill anyone.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-25-2010, 10:51 PM
It's not about lethalness. The only reason shows use lazers is because it's not that violent and won't kill anyone.

Since when did lasers not kill people? The only reason they use lasers is because guns are accessible in real life. That doesn't mean getting hit by a laser doesn't kill you.

Turo602
02-25-2010, 11:03 PM
Since when did lasers not kill people? The only reason they use lasers is because guns are accessible in real life. That doesn't mean getting hit by a laser doesn't kill you.

I've seen it in many shows were someone is shot by a laser gun and just gets knocked back.

Spitfire
02-26-2010, 12:20 AM
Batman Beyond was not as Dark as Batman TAS. They even allowed real guns and bullets instead of lasers.

There were guns in Batman Beyond I don't know what you're talking about. The very first episode has Bruce pointing a handgun at a thug and becoming disgusted at his action, hence why he gave up being Batman. There was also a fair amount of blood in the series. As time went on handguns were out. Is Mass Effect less violence because the guns fire lasers instead of bullets? No. Why do they do that? Because it takes place in the future.

"Return of The Joker" contains the most brutal death I've ever seen in any kids series. No BS just balls out. It also featured child torture.

I like both series but as far as "darkness" goes it was the same level. BB had the same atmospheric style as TAS it just seemed less because the future has a neon fetish, Blade Runner taught us that. The villains were just as tortured and some of them suffered worse fates then the ones in TAS did.

Cipher
02-26-2010, 12:48 AM
If you want to get into this completely asinine argument, Batman Beyond was darker than either New Adventures or B:TAS. There was some pretty sick sh*t in that show. But it still, I feel, hit a balance that neither of the other series did. It's mature, but not so in love with its own darkness that it's too ridiculous for a kid's cartoon.

But at the end of the day, they're still all children's cartoons, and it's really, really easy to mess up that balance in an embarrassing way. I feel that it plagues TMNT, B:TAS, and TNAB all equally.

Going by DCAU examples, JL/U and BB are some of the few shows to get it exactly right. I watch those as an adult without being distracted by that melodramatic cheese-factor that tends to hurt dark kids' shows.

Turo602
02-26-2010, 12:56 AM
There were guns in Batman Beyond I don't know what you're talking about. The very first episode has Bruce pointing a handgun at a thug and becoming disgusted at his action, hence why he gave up being Batman. There was also a fair amount of blood in the series. As time went on handguns were out. Is Mass Effect less violence because the guns fire lasers instead of bullets? No. Why do they do that? Because it takes place in the future.

"Return of The Joker" contains the most brutal death I've ever seen in any kids series. No BS just balls out. It also featured child torture.

I like both series but as far as "darkness" goes it was the same level. BB had the same atmospheric style as TAS it just seemed less because the future has a neon fetish, Blade Runner taught us that. The villains were just as tortured and some of them suffered worse fates then the ones in TAS did.

Bad comparison, a cartoon and video game. And your talking about a feature film that has less limitations. And I never said that Batman Beyond never had guns. I own the whole DCAU. I know what happened, Batman Beyond wasn't as Dark.

Spitfire
02-26-2010, 01:03 AM
Bad comparison, a cartoon and video game.
Forms of entertainment no? Works for me.

And your talking about a feature film that has less limitations.
It was made for television.

And I never said that Batman Beyond never had guns. I own the whole DCAU. I know what happened, Batman Beyond wasn't as Dark.
As do I. Maybe it's a matter of opinion but BB is on the same level as the other series. It's darker then most of Justice League and JLU and easily on par with Batman TAS. Just my opinion though.

shuriken
02-26-2010, 02:02 AM
As do I. Maybe it's a matter of opinion but BB is on the same level as the other series. It's darker then most of Justice League and JLU and easily on par with Batman TAS. Just my opinion though.

I think Batman beyond was darker than Batmna tas. People seem to forget that even though it was/is/ and forever shall be an amazing show, it still had quite a bit of cheezy episodes here and there. That isn't neccaessarily a bad thing bcuz if it's all serious and no fun than you get the unintentionally funny show that takes itself way too seriously. Kind of like Mortal Kombat Konquest. Although the fights were awesome, they all took themselves way too seriously with terrible dialogue that just made it humorous.
Iagree with Cipher saying that there has to be a happy medium.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-26-2010, 02:51 AM
Bad comparison, a cartoon and video game. And your talking about a feature film that has less limitations. And I never said that Batman Beyond never had guns. I own the whole DCAU. I know what happened, Batman Beyond wasn't as Dark.

GI Joe had lasers and stuff blew up all the damn time when they got shot. Heck knows they would have killed someone who was hit by them.

Cipher
02-26-2010, 03:20 AM
I own the whole DCAU. I know what happened, Batman Beyond wasn't as Dark.You and I weren't watching the same show then. Nerds becoming stuck in a cult and not being redeemed, Inque's daughter and her accomplice, the father who had been nearly killed and turned into a radio-active corpse? Shriek being permanently defeaned by Batman? That virtual-reality drug parallel, Ten never being redeemed, f*cking Ra's in Talia's body? The reporter who ceased to be solid and fell through the ground? The Mr. Freeze episode?

B:TAS and TNBA had their moments, but supervillain-du-jour and mobsters with guns didn't have anything on some of the twisted sci-fi plots BB came up with. Rarely if ever did that show end on a happy note. And it still managed to pull off those plots with a little more finesse and balance than B:TAS. It knew it wasn't working in the real world and it used that to its great advantage.

I'll say this. Several episodes of BB actually freaked me out as a kid. I can't say the same for either of the other DCAU Batman cartoons.

Leonardo_
02-26-2010, 09:38 AM
To get back to the topic I have to say, that in my opinion the 2003 toon was all but serious and dark. The fight scenes are always the same..the storylines are not that well...ok there were a few terrible looking monsters and such, but that was all.

I watched a few episodes with some of my friends and they had to shake their heads at what they saw.
I have read in some german forums about that toon and only a FEW of them really liked it.

I think the old one was way more varied..especially when thinking about their europa-tour.

Kendamu
02-26-2010, 09:59 AM
I liked 2k3, but it really didn't start feeling all that amazing to me until the 3rd Season. The first couple seasons were neat adaptions and all, but it wasn't until the 3rd and 4th seasons where there show started becoming it's own thing a little more that I really liked it. Then, after that, it kinda went downhill again for me. Too bad FUNi never did Season Sets for 3 & 4.

It's pretty much the exact opposite of my opinion of the OT. I thought the OT was great early on (Seasons 1-3) and kinda neat later on (Seasons 7 & 8, parts of 9 & 10), but the stuff in the middle isn't really something I'd watch again.

gobo
02-26-2010, 01:23 PM
I think the old one was way more varied..especially when thinking about their europa-tour.
Biased opinion... :P
Nice to see you still around, Deutschy.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-26-2010, 02:25 PM
Well I admit I did like the OT because you didn't really need to think about continuity or anything. It was just episodic and fun. It knew it wasn't serious and didn't mind pushing things.

I guess if you're looking for overlapping story arcs 2k3 wasn't bad, but it wasn't that same "throw your brain out the window" fun the OT was.

Plus a lot of the character designs put me off at first.... like why April was a scientist or why Baxter Stockman was a black man.... Though I got used to them after a while.

Spitfire
02-26-2010, 02:52 PM
I think the old one was way more varied..especially when thinking about their europa-tour.
The OT was way more formulaic then 2K3 sorry to say. They either fight Shredder and Krang every episode or some mad scientist. Rarely were there villains outside of that and it really didn't start happening until the last few seasons. Let's not count the number of times they had to save April. Also the European Vacation episodes are historically some of the worst episodes of the entire series.

Plus a lot of the character designs put me off at first.... like why April was a scientist or why Baxter Stockman was a black man.... Though I got used to them after a while.
That's how it should have been all along. No idea why they made Baxter white in the OT.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-26-2010, 02:59 PM
The OT was way more formulaic then 2K3 sorry to say. They either fight Shredder and Krang every episode or some mad scientist. Rarely were there villains outside of that and it really didn't start happening until the last few seasons. Let's not count the number of times they had to save April. Also the European Vacation episodes are historically some of the worst episodes of the entire series.

But that's what made it good. Being humorous and formulaic. It didn't need to have overlapping story arcs to be entertaining. As long as the turtles fought shredder and saved the day. That's all any of us kids cared about when growing up with the OT. Even looking back at it now. Sure I see all the cheesiness and things people say are wrong with it, but hey I can still pretty much watch any episode I want and I don't have to see all the others before it to understand what's happening.


That's how it should have been all along. No idea why they made Baxter white in the OT.

Well I never read the comics.... at all. The cartoons were always my main medium so of course Baxter Stockman going from a kooky white guy to a narcissistic, ego-centric black man would feel weird to me. Not to mention April being a scientist instead of a reporter. Heck I never had any problem with the actual turtles themselves since they reminded me of the first live action film, but everything else was so different that it's not something someone who grew up with only the OT could get used too right away.

Spitfire
02-26-2010, 03:11 PM
But that's what made it good. Being humorous and formulaic. It didn't need to have overlapping story arcs to be entertaining. As long as the turtles fought shredder and saved the day. That's all any of us kids cared about when growing up with the OT. Even looking back at it now. Sure I see all the cheesiness and things people say are wrong with it, but hey I can still pretty much watch any episode I want and I don't have to see all the others before it to understand what's happening.
See TV series with no story arcs seem like a waste for the most part. The point of a series is to watch to keep you coming back every week. You can't do that with single one off episodes. Also after the series has ended you'll be watching it in succession and those filler episodes will seem pointless.

X-men was one of the first cartoons to adapt a story arc format like 2K3 has and it worked really well. Spider-man joined in sometimes entire seasons were one long story. The cleaver thing to do is find ways to make all the episodes go together but also keep it open so people could jump in at any time. I think both series did that well and so did 2K3. There's plenty of episodes of 2K3 that have tiny plot points that pop up in other episodes or are related to others that you can watch solo and still understand.

Well I never read the comics.... at all. The cartoons were always my main medium so of course Baxter Stockman going from a kooky white guy to a narcissistic, ego-centric black man would feel weird to me. Not to mention April being a scientist instead of a reporter. Heck I never had any problem with the actual turtles themselves since they reminded me of the first live action film, but everything else was so different that it's not something someone who grew up with only the OT could get used too right away.

I started reading the comics after 2K3 aired and it didn't bother me at all. I'd been watching turtles since before I could remember. Reading the comics made me even more avid about the changes. It then later made me resent much of the series.

Kendamu
02-26-2010, 03:23 PM
See TV series with no story arcs seem like a waste for the most part. The point of a series is to watch to keep you coming back every week. You can't do that with single one off episodes. Also after the series has ended you'll be watching it in succession and those filler episodes will seem pointless.

X-men was one of the first cartoons to adapt a story arc format like 2K3 has and it worked really well. Spider-man joined in sometimes entire seasons were one long story. The cleaver thing to do is find ways to make all the episodes go together but also keep it open so people could jump in at any time. I think both series did that well and so did 2K3. There's plenty of episodes of 2K3 that have tiny plot points that pop up in other episodes or are related to others that you can watch solo and still understand.



I started reading the comics after 2K3 aired and it didn't bother me at all. I'd been watching turtles since before I could remember. Reading the comics made me even more avid about the changes. It then later made me resent much of the series.
Well, the early OT stuff sort of had a story to them. The Technodrome was the villains' ultimate weapon, but they needed fuel or a way to get it out of Dimension X. The Turtles would stop them from doing such. Sometimes the villains would get very close to winning but in the end the Turtles somehow snuck in a victory and the Technodrome would be stuck in some new place. Sure, it's not nearly as deep as the X-Men, but it was good for its time.

When it comes to stuff that's mostly episodic, however, I prefer something like the DCAU stuff like BTAS. If there needs to be an overall story, do it like you said and make it so people can jump in anytime like JL and JLU.

EDIT: I think that for something like the OT to work today what would be needed to keep kids coming back without making an overall story would be cool action scenes and fresh humor.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-26-2010, 03:46 PM
See TV series with no story arcs seem like a waste for the most part. The point of a series is to watch to keep you coming back every week. You can't do that with single one off episodes. Also after the series has ended you'll be watching it in succession and those filler episodes will seem pointless.

X-men was one of the first cartoons to adapt a story arc format like 2K3 has and it worked really well. Spider-man joined in sometimes entire seasons were one long story. The cleaver thing to do is find ways to make all the episodes go together but also keep it open so people could jump in at any time. I think both series did that well and so did 2K3. There's plenty of episodes of 2K3 that have tiny plot points that pop up in other episodes or are related to others that you can watch solo and still understand.



I started reading the comics after 2K3 aired and it didn't bother me at all. I'd been watching turtles since before I could remember. Reading the comics made me even more avid about the changes. It then later made me resent much of the series.

What do you mean? The OT always kept me coming back every week. Heck even stuff like the shows on the Disney Afternoon that WASN'T Gargoyles kept making me watch week after week and those were just as episodic and formulaic.

So I really don't understand why a series needs overlapping story arcs full of tons of depth to seem good or anything. It's not like any of us were looking for depth as kids or anything.

gobo
02-26-2010, 05:17 PM
It's not like any of us were looking for depth as kids or anything.
I was. The original TMNT 'toon infuriated me with how much of a joke it made its own continuity out to be. It's like the suits were always telling the writers, "Kids are too stupid to follow an epic storyline. Don't break their feeble brains with it." :roll:

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-26-2010, 05:21 PM
I was. The original TMNT 'toon infuriated me with how much of a joke it made its own continuity out to be. It's like the suits were always telling the writers, "Kids are too stupid to follow an epic storyline. Don't break their feeble brains with it." :roll:

Well I'm not sure how old you were but I was in elementary school during those years when I got up every saturday morning to watch Muppet Babies, Garfield, and TMNT. Heck I was 11 when TMNT 3 The Manhatten Project released on the NES.

and as I said I wasn't looking for depth. I just enjoyed watching the turtles. I suppose I could be accused of being simple minded, but honestly I didn't feel like I needed some deep, overlapping story full of continuity and plot twists to be interesting.

It's not like it is now where people expect every show to be like Avatar the last airbender.

Spitfire
02-26-2010, 05:49 PM
So I really don't understand why a series needs overlapping story arcs full of tons of depth to seem good or anything. It's not like any of us were looking for depth as kids or anything.

Take away the fact you watched it as a kid and imagine watching it for the first time now with zero nostalgic feeling towards it. Being an adult and not as easily entertained as a child attempting to watch the OT for the first time. You would think it's crap. In fact most people who attempt OT as adults have that reaction to it. It does not age well at all and while wildly popular was poorly produced. Voice actors changing all the time, tons of animation errors every episode, and what continuity it had flip flopped around. The only reason any of us now can watch the series as an adult is because we grew up with intense love for it. There are a few I'm sure who discovered it as adults and liked it but it's not often.

This is why I can't watch shows like "Batman Brave and the Bold" or "Marvel Super Hero Squad". Stuff like that just doesn't appeal to me as an adult. If I was a kid I'd be all over that. I freaking loved "Super Friends" when I was a kid. Series like Batman or Spider-man held up because they kept going and the stories were complex. It was a character study, either about a villain or the hero. The hero didn't always win or the way it ended wasn't the way they wanted it to. Was justice really served or would things have worked out better if they didn't get involved? Is being a hero destroying their personal life? What happens when you have power and you lose control?

Like Gobo I myself wanted more then just our heroes winning every battle and being perfect. I wanted complexity. At the time I didn't know that's what drew me to those series but I can see that now.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-26-2010, 06:09 PM
Take away the fact you watched it as a kid and imagine watching it for the first time now with zero nostalgic feeling towards it. Being an adult and not as easily entertained as a child attempting to watch the OT for the first time. You would think it's crap. In fact most people who attempt OT as adults have that reaction to it. It does not age well at all and while wildly popular was poorly produced. Voice actors changing all the time, tons of animation errors every episode, and what continuity it had flip flopped around. The only reason any of us now can watch the series as an adult is because we grew up with intense love for it. There are a few I'm sure who discovered it as adults and liked it but it's not often.

This is why I can't watch shows like "Batman Brave and the Bold" or "Marvel Super Hero Squad". Stuff like that just doesn't appeal to me as an adult. If I was a kid I'd be all over that. I freaking loved "Super Friends" when I was a kid. Series like Batman or Spider-man held up because they kept going and the stories were complex. It was a character study, either about a villain or the hero. The hero didn't always win or the way it ended wasn't the way they wanted it to. Was justice really served or would things have worked out better if they didn't get involved? Is being a hero destroying their personal life? What happens when you have power and you lose control?

Like Gobo I myself wanted more then just our heroes winning every battle and being perfect. I wanted complexity. At the time I didn't know that's what drew me to those series but I can see that now.

Well as I said. I've watched a few of the OT episodes a few months back. I understand that it was cheesy with bad dialogue and such, but even then I still enjoyed it. Besides many cartoons back then had horrible dialogue and one-liners. Not to mention questionable animation and ridiculous episodic plots set up to teach some sort of moral. That's just the way it was back then.

Nostalgia be damned it's still a fun show in my view even today. The only people I see hating the OT are the ones that were into the comics from the beginning or who started with 2k3 and then recently got into the comics without any prior knowledge of the OT.

and honestly even if I was a kid now. I don't think I'd even like any of the marvel and DC stuff as I was never much into the Marvel and DC stuff in the first place. Even when BTAS, Xmen, and Spiderman were on Fox Kids with a new episode out every week I just wasn't into it. I was more into stuff like Eek the Cat, and most of the stuff on ABC and CBS saturday morning at that time which was pretty much Garfield, TMNT, and stuff like Disney's Doug, Recess, and Pepper Ann.

and those were just fine.

The Stryker
02-26-2010, 06:22 PM
Kids don't really care much for character development. As long as they're entertained and the characters are fun enough they'll enjoy it.

Also, Brave and The Bold and Superhero Squad are fun little shows. Who gives a crap if there isn't a tacked on moral dilemma to every episode? Not everything is meant to be held under a microscope.

Spitfire
02-26-2010, 06:24 PM
Also, Brave and The Bold and Superhero Squad are fun little shows. Who gives a crap if there isn't a tacked on moral dilemma to every episode?

I do because that's what I find entertaining and did even when I was a kid. My point exactly why a show like that does nothing for me, and it shouldn't as it's made for kids.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-26-2010, 06:37 PM
I do because that's what I find entertaining and did even when I was a kid. My point exactly why a show like that does nothing for me, and it shouldn't as it's made for kids.

Weren't you the one though who just a post ago said that you shouldn't look at it as if you watched it as a kid?

If you only care about what adults find entertaining then of course everything that doesn't have some really deep storyline full of angst (or character development as you people call it these days) is going to come off really stupid.

Spitfire
02-26-2010, 06:58 PM
Weren't you the one though who just a post ago said that you shouldn't look at it as if you watched it as a kid?

If you only care about what adults find entertaining then of course everything that doesn't have some really deep storyline full of angst (or character development as you people call it these days) is going to come off really stupid.

What I said was at the time I didn't know it but I did like all the elements I listed even as a kid. I gravitated towards those shows.

My point is kid's series can entertain adults as well when they try to. I find Wolverine and the X-men entertaining. There are series that are just made for kids to laugh at and that's fine. The action toons are the ones that have story potential and just because it's for kids doesn't mean it has to be simple minded. Give the children a little credit.

Leonardo_
02-26-2010, 07:12 PM
Biased opinion... :P
Nice to see you still around, Deutschy.

Pssshht..man did you have to tell on me now? *whispers*

Naah...nice to see you, too, my friend ^^

Turo602
02-26-2010, 07:43 PM
I do because that's what I find entertaining and did even when I was a kid. My point exactly why a show like that does nothing for me, and it shouldn't as it's made for kids.

Same here. But it depends on what the show is. Like Wolverine and the X-Men is Badass hell, but not as good as the original. The only reason it's good is because it has really good story telling and decent animation. Because X-Men is that type of show that needs really good story telling.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-26-2010, 08:52 PM
What I said was at the time I didn't know it but I did like all the elements I listed even as a kid. I gravitated towards those shows.

My point is kid's series can entertain adults as well when they try to. I find Wolverine and the X-men entertaining. There are series that are just made for kids to laugh at and that's fine. The action toons are the ones that have story potential and just because it's for kids doesn't mean it has to be simple minded. Give the children a little credit.

Honestly I think the best modern cartoon that's come out in the last few years is Phineas and Ferb. That show while episodic and formulaic is genius when it comes to writing and execution without the need for character development. To me that's proof that you don't need depth to have a good show.

as for the action shows. Please shows like that were always made to sell merchandise. I mean look at He Man and GI Joe that had a story, but was more about the heavy action because it was marketed to children. Because children love action. I've only ever seen people truly care about story after anime became a fad in the US. before that I've never seen someone who looked for depth in cartoons that were designed to be for children or toy commercials.

Koi
02-26-2010, 09:51 PM
Honestly I think the best modern cartoon that's come out in the last few years is Phineas and Ferb. That show while episodic and formulaic is genius when it comes to writing and execution without the need for character development. To me that's proof that you don't need depth to have a good show.


That show is amazing, and I have to agree with you, I thought cartoons died till that came out. I haven't really noticed any character development in it, but it is also more of a comedy; and the characters are more or less there to make the audience laugh. Like Mikey in 2k3, he is not that well developed but children love him even though.

Turo602
02-26-2010, 09:54 PM
That show is amazing, and I have to agree with you, I thought cartoons died till that came out. I haven't really noticed any character development in it, but it is also more of a comedy; and the characters are more or less there to make the audience laugh. Like Mikey in 2k3, he is not that well developed but children love him even though.

Umm That because "Michelangelo is a party dude":P

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-26-2010, 10:05 PM
That show is amazing, and I have to agree with you, I thought cartoons died till that came out. I haven't really noticed any character development in it, but it is also more of a comedy; and the characters are more or less there to make the audience laugh. Like Mikey in 2k3, he is not that well developed but children love him even though.

Exactly. There have been a few times where Candace for instance could have been developed. Such as the episode where future candace changes the past and turns the tri state area into a dystopia by busting her brothers, and despite the present day Candice being involved in fixing things doesn't change at all personality wise. Yet all the characters are still likable in the end.

and as for Mikey I did like 2k3 Mikey even though he's considered a travesty. Compared to OT Mikey when I went back and watched the OT I still see 2k3 Mikey as an improvement despite how big of a douche people tag him as.

Sage Ninja
03-01-2010, 01:41 PM
meh, you are entitled to your own opinion. But I feel that 2k3 Mikey is a several steps down from his OT persona. Just my opinion. And is what turned me off somewhat to the 2k3 series. Yeah he doesn't bellow out DUDE and crave Pizza but the over all handling of his character in this series left alot to be desired.

Spacebabie
03-01-2010, 07:43 PM
I was a little meh on the newer toon since I was a fan of the 80's/90's cartoon, also being a bit of an anime fan I figured 4Kids would have watered it down.

Boy was I wrong. When I saw Leo lop of the Shredder's head I was dropping my jaw and asking "This is 4Kids?" I didn''t expect it to be like that.


of course I loved Gargoyles and about ten years earlier I loved the Dungeon's and Dragon's cartoon and that had an episode that CBS was worried about showing at the time.

Not too impressed with Fast Forward, although I do like the Dark Turtles

and BTTS was okay. I really loved the Superquest episode.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
03-02-2010, 06:41 PM
meh, you are entitled to your own opinion. But I feel that 2k3 Mikey is a several steps down from his OT persona. Just my opinion. And is what turned me off somewhat to the 2k3 series. Yeah he doesn't bellow out DUDE and crave Pizza but the over all handling of his character in this series left alot to be desired.

Well you have your opinions and I respect that, but since no version of Mikey ever seems to please the hard core comic fans I just don't see any reason to always hold expectations that high.

Sure maybe Mikey isn't handled right, but it shouldn't be taken as some personal insult against the franchise.