PDA

View Full Version : Now that Tales of the TMNT is nearly over, how would you rate it as a whole?


CyberCubed
02-22-2010, 08:52 PM
With only 4 issues yet to be released, Tales of the TMNT has come to an end.

We got 70 issues out of it, plus the Leo/Raph/Mike/Don 4-issue miniseries (adds another 16 issues), which brings us to a total of 86 issues to add to the Mirage universe.

I'd have to say I enjoyed it. While not every issue was spectacular or ground-breaking, it helped fill in a lot of plotholes that were going on in the Mirage universe over the years, (as well as added some unfinished plotlines), and provided some nice further adventures of the Turtles that we would have otherwise never gotten.

Think of it this way, if the new Tales never happened, the Mirage universe would seem a lot more "barren," with only Vol. 1-4 making it up. I feel like Tales of the TMNT really helped flesh out the comic series in general and tied up a lot of loose ends.

Powder
02-22-2010, 08:55 PM
It was great. I will deffinately say it was hit or miss, but sometimes, one hit would make up for three misses. There were alot of new artists showcased which was great (not always though....) & we got to see alot of our favorite old school TMNT folks too. Overall they filled alot of cracks, entertained, & even surprised me here & there so I totally have a great love for it. I much prefer tales vol.2 to vol.4 & vol.2 (regular) as far as interesting reads go...

DrSpengler
02-22-2010, 09:35 PM
I'm going to save my complete thoughts for an article I plan on writing once the entire series is finished. But for the sake of conversation...

As already mentioned, "hit and miss" sums it up pretty concisely.

The series wasn't everything it could have been. Though an anthology title, it could have boasted more multi-issue plot threads. I find that the ones we got were some of the best stories the series produced, such as the Worms of Madness/Loops arc and the Gang Wars arc. Several ongoing threads were begun but never completed, often being dropped because of "editorial changes", whatever *that* meant. As a reader, there's nothing more frustrating than seeing a storyline begun and then unceremoniously ignored as if it never happened. 70 issues and they couldn't find the time to complete those threads? Unacceptable.

When the series was good, though, it produced many of the best TMNT stories ever written; instant classics. The rotating cast of Mirage staffers was a treat, even digging up some great non-Mirage TMNT talent like Chris Allan. Sure, not all the Mirage staffers got to do full issues, but those that did were a nostalgic treat and those that could only provide covers and frontispieces, their contributions were appreciated. Jim Lawso was utilized FAR too much, though, and I think his rather unappealing style (at least so far as mainstream readers are concerned) partially resulted in the poor sales number (likewise goes for Volume 4). But he seems to be joined to Peter Laird at the hip, so there was nothing that could be done about that.

Mirage staffers aside, I think the MOST ADMIRABLE thing about Tales Volume 2, and something I eternally respect Mirage and Laird for, is that it gave opportunities for lots of budding writers and artists to contribute to the series and get their feet wet in the professional comics medium. Lots of talented, unknown folks got to have their big break on Tales of the TMNT and the Mirage crew encouraged their participation. Having "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" on your resume has got to be pretty impressive and a great way to get your foot in the industry's door. The fact that Mirage facilitated something like that is really, truly a beautiful thing and I will always respect them for it.

Almost all the spin-off minis were let-downs in my opinion, for varying reasons on each title (to say nothing of Lawson's art). Most of them carried on the most inane plot threads from the least important one-shots, where-as more important and mre interesting threads were left to wallow in incompletion. The only one that really seemed necessary to me was "The Third Kind", which is probably the only story we needed to take place in the Volume 4 six month gap.


I could go on and on, and I WILL when #70 has come and gone and I write my full article, but these are just the bullet points. The series was a rollercoaster ride of excruciating lows and phenominal highs. Somehow, it both lived up to its potential and fell short of it miserably at the same time.

More so than any other TMNT title (well, with the exception of Volume 1), it's a series best left cherry-picked for content, but when it was good, it was REALLY good.

ToTheNines
02-22-2010, 10:16 PM
I agree with the hit or miss thing, but I just went through the list real quick and I'd only call about 12 (or so) of them total wastes. It was a good run, I'm glad they did it, and now I'll patiently wait for Tales Volume 3 :)

Almost all the spin-off minis were let-downs in my opinion, for varying reasons on each title (to say nothing of Lawson's art). Most of them carried on the most inane plot threads from the least important one-shots, where-as more important and mre interesting threads were left to wallow in incompletion. The only one that really seemed necessary to me was "The Third Kind", which is probably the only story we needed to take place in the Volume 4 six month gap.

Exactly! I can't imagine Lawson even having the desire to tell those stories, let alone for Mirage to think they'd be successful. Third Kind wasn't bad, Blindsight and Brain Thief had potential... but did anyone on earth want to see Tales #7 continued?

CyberCubed
02-22-2010, 10:24 PM
Raphael: Bad Moon Rising was definitely the worst of the bunch, although the Don one comes in second for wasted potential.

I thought the Mike one was good and fit into Vol. 4 nicely with the Xihad extremists, and I rathered like the Leo one even though it wasn't really needed. The story set in Japan almost felt like an Usagi story, but with Leo in place.

Kendamu
02-23-2010, 01:22 AM
I really liked having a Turtle book out there that didn't stick to one part of their lives or drag on a storyline forever. Sure, muti-issue arcs are great, but I'm a fan of one-shot stories. It allows me to pick up a book at anytime. Tales accomplished that for me.

Leo656
02-23-2010, 04:24 AM
It's hit or miss, as many said, but still one of the best TMNT books ever.

I have most TMNT books, and have read everything I own at least once, but I'm missing a few key issues and despite reading most of them I never felt "at home" in the Mirage universe. I got into it way late, and between not knowing what was and wasn't canon and missing those few key issues, I felt the least engaged in that universe. I agree with CyberCubed, I felt the Mirage universe was kind of "barren", with the "real" stories fighting for space with the non-canon ones and huge time gaps between the stories.

Tales definitely changed that for the better. It fleshed out a ton of stories and characters that waited years (or even decades) to get more attention, and even hinted at a multiversal thread between TMNT universes (We missed you Cudley! Well... maybe just me...).

Not perfect, but I'd recommend it over Vol. 4.

discordiatookie
02-24-2010, 04:31 PM
I really dug it. Alot of fantastic stuff, and only a handful that I didn't really like. Bit disapointing that some stories were started and then just left, with no ending, but for the most part - it was a great ride. Heh, and it aint even finished yet!

Coola Yagami
02-24-2010, 06:33 PM
I agree with the hit or miss thing, but I just went through the list real quick and I'd only call about 12 (or so) of them total wastes. It was a good run, I'm glad they did it, and now I'll patiently wait for Tales Volume 3 :)



Exactly! I can't imagine Lawson even having the desire to tell those stories, let alone for Mirage to think they'd be successful. Third Kind wasn't bad, Blindsight and Brain Thief had potential... but did anyone on earth want to see Tales #7 continued?

What was Tales # 7 about?

Oculus Orbus
02-24-2010, 07:57 PM
I quite liked Tales, most of the time. But, there are a few things about it that really bother me, mainly the Gang Wars arc. In my opinion, that's one of the best stories ever told with the Turtles, and Tristan Jones was doing simply great, and it's really sad that it's not gonna have an ending.

As for the series as a whole, I thought some issues were very bad. A bit too much. I felt sometimes like a lot of potential wasn't being used. I don't believe it was necessary to fill in so many gaps in the continuity, and instead it would have been a lot more interesting to go deeper into the few arcs that were created for the series, or just write new stories. Don't get me wrong, I did love many of the fill ins, but you know, most of the "out of continuity" stories were just Don in some kind of sci-fi action.

Now, I have to say that many of my favourite TMNT comics ever are in Tales Vol.2. It had bad times, but it did amazingly good some times. Also, I love Jim Lawson, so I enjoyed him a lot more than what I would have if we hadn't had Tales, and that made me happy. And then there's the frontpieces. Most of them are incredibly nice (spectacular Dooney), and it gave us a great gallery of artists, and I truly enjoy this kind of stuff.

I liked as well the spin-off minis, including the Don's one. Bad Mon Rising, aside from the great covers, doesn't exist for me (really, I couldn't believe it when I was reading it).

So, I'm really glad it happened. In my opinion, it made a lot of good to the TMNT comics.

DrSpengler
02-24-2010, 09:16 PM
I think the need for more ongoing arcs became necessary when Laird decided to shelve Volume 4 for several years.

Before that, Tales' approach of "one-shot continuity gap fillers and random meaningless adventures" was fun because we had Volume 4 going simultaneously to give us a monthly, ongoing TMNT storyline to follow.

But when that went away with nothing to fill the void, Tales' one-shot nature became a little tedious. It seemed like they eventually realized that down the line, when they decided to dust off Tristan's Gang Wars arc (twenty issues after it started, no less), but by then the series was already in its death throws and it was too little, too late.

Tales was a great complimentary series when Volume 4 was on the racks beside it. But when Laird turned his back on that title, Tales sort of needed to adjust its purpose to accomodate that absence of an ongoing storyline. It simply took too long to do so, I felt.

Not that I didn't enjoy MANY of the one-shot stories we got during that span of time after Volume 4 went kaput, but I still think they should have shifted their focus from a random anthology title more toward arc-driven stories.

CyberCubed
02-24-2010, 10:36 PM
One thing that I found odd is that the writers often times forgot (or at least didn't care) that this was the Mirage universe. Is it just me, or did the Turtles sometimes act like their cartoon counterparts in some Tales issues? We've had more "Cowabunga's" and silly dialogue in Tales than in any other Mirage book.

Sometimes I felt like I was reading a story that would better fit in with the cartoons than the Mirage universe. I'm sure all of you noticed that.

Cipher
02-24-2010, 11:26 PM
One thing that I found odd is that the writers often times forgot (or at least didn't care) that this was the Mirage universe. Is it just me, or did the Turtles sometimes act like their cartoon counterparts in some Tales issues? We've had more "Cowabunga's" and silly dialogue in Tales than in any other Mirage book.Are you sure you weren't reading the guest artist issues in Vol. 1 instead?

CyberCubed
02-27-2010, 06:41 PM
There were a few issues where I felt the Turtles were acting out of character from their Mirage counterparts, and they seemed more like the cartoon turtles in some issues.

I can't remember exactly which issues it was off the top of my head, but it seemed sometimes they acted more "cartoonish" in personality. I also recall "Cowabunga" being in at least three or so issues of Tales.

I'm going to have to re-read the entire Tales issues in the summer after the last issue comes out, I want to re-read all 70 issues (and the mini-series), so I can refresh them in my mind.

DrSpengler
02-27-2010, 07:15 PM
While I don't think they ever got as bad as acting like their Fred Wolf incarnations, there were some "lighter" stories that felt a little off.

The only issue containing achingly bad characterization that I can recall was "Soul Survivor", where Don spends the whole thing acting like Raph. Odd, too, since Steve Murphy co-wrote that thing.

I think it was the COWboys of Moo Mess crossover arc that felt the "silliest" of all the Tales stories, but that seemed to have been done intentionally, so eh.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-28-2010, 11:04 PM
The only issue containing achingly bad characterization that I can recall was "Soul Survivor", where Don spends the whole thing acting like Raph. Odd, too, since Steve Murphy co-wrote that thing.

What issue was this?

ToTheNines
03-01-2010, 10:22 AM
I'm pretty sure he meant "Sins of the Past".

DrSpengler
03-01-2010, 10:32 AM
Yeah, that's what I meant. Whoop.

CyberCubed
03-01-2010, 10:33 AM
I did love many of the fill ins, but you know, most of the "out of continuity" stories were just Don in some kind of sci-fi action.

Strangely enough, I liked almost all of those Don sci-fi adventures when he went with the Utroms into outerspace.

Usually I don't like excessive sci-fi in TMNT, but for some reason I really enjoyed all those Don solo adventures. I also loved the evil Utroms or whatever they were, the ones that made clones of Leatherhead.

It was nice to see not all Utroms are good.

sdp
03-01-2010, 10:48 AM
I think most are not too fond of excessive sci-fi on TMNT but looking back almost every incarnation including the 80s show theres plenty of sci-fi in fact its a large part of the franchise so Don being in space is perfectly alright with the franchise.

Kendamu
03-01-2010, 11:19 AM
It's not that I'm not a fan of the Sci-Fi stuff. I loved when the TMNT were stranded on another planet fighting Triceratons and stuff in the early Vol. 1 issues. I just don't really relate to Donatello that well, so I can't really "be there" when I'm reading it like I could with a gritty Raph or Casey tale or a fun Mikey adventure.

CyberCubed
03-01-2010, 12:13 PM
It's too bad Kevin Eastman never did any new Turtle stories, I recently read through his "25th anniversary collected book," and even though I read those issues before, I loved most of them again.

A lot of Kevin's stories revolve around urban crime, mobs, gangsters, and stuff like that, and I really enjoy it. Of course something like Bodycount is too extreme, but his other stuff was quite good.

Cipher
03-01-2010, 02:22 PM
A lot of Kevin's stories revolve around urban crime, mobs, gangsters, and stuff like that, and I really enjoy it. Of course something like Bodycount is too extreme, but his other stuff was quite good."Bodycount" is a gag book. I'm not sure why everyone brings it up when they talk about Kevin's vision of the Turtles.

The reality, though, is that he's just as hit-or-miss as Pete. Maybe more so. What all did he write without Laird? "The Unmentionables," "Distractions," "The Shell of the Dragon?" "North by Downeast" with all its glorious lobster-people?

I think it's pretty clear that Eastman always treated the series as more of an experiment/joke than Laird. Which is totally fine. But while it's possible he may have approved more "gritty" stories than Laird (we'll never know), I don't think he would have ever given us a serialized plot like Volume 4. And I think it's expecting a lot that he would have written any one-shot serious gangster/ninja stories either, because he really never did that to begin with. This is the guy who was biding his time until he could take over the ero-sci-fi rag Heavy Metal, after all.

Honestly? As far as Turtles stories go, Gary Carlson and Tristan Jones are closer to what fans expect Kevin Eastman to be than Kevin Eastman is.

AquaParade
03-01-2010, 04:07 PM
"

I think it's pretty clear that Eastman always treated the series as more of an experiment/joke than Laird. Which is totally fine. But while it's possible he may have approved more "gritty" stories than Laird (we'll never know), I don't think he would have ever given us a serialized plot like Volume 4. And I think it's expecting a lot that he would have written any one-shot serious gangster/ninja stories either, because he really never did that to begin with. This is the guy who was biding his time until he could take over the ero-sci-fi rag Heavy Metal, after all.

Honestly? As far as Turtles stories go, Gary Carlson and Tristan Jones are closer to what fans expect Kevin Eastman to be than Kevin Eastman is.

Very well said...an interesting point that sort of crossed my mind while I was reading Kevin's 25th Anniversary release.

TristanHuwJones
03-02-2010, 12:05 AM
I always tried to get back to that "Eastman AND Laird" vibe. Both dudes were a big influence, but the issues they both worked on together always worked out the best.

Cipher
03-02-2010, 12:12 AM
I always tried to get back to that "Eastman AND Laird" vibe. Both dudes were a big influence, but the issues they both worked on together always worked out the best.I didn't mean to pigeonhole you or anything. And I agree.

It's just that the fanbase seems to have it in their mind that Kevin was the uber-gritty ninjaness to Pete's relaxed sci-fi, and that the series would have been "sooper dark and surius" if he'd been in charge. And there's just no evidence for that at all (plenty against it even). His art is gritter though.

(shrugs)

CyberCubed
03-02-2010, 12:18 AM
Eastman probably wouldn't have done on-going story arcs, but I do think we would have seen more urban crime stories. And his stories definitely had an ounce of humor in them, it was not like they were all serious.

Sometimes I wonder how different the franchise would be if Kevin and Peter were reversed, and it was Kevin who was in charge from 2000 onward and Peter sold the rights.

Volume 4 would have been totally different and I wonder what he would have done.

Cipher
03-02-2010, 12:24 AM
Volume 4 would have been totally different and I wonder what he would have done.See, I don't think there would have been a Volume 4. If he was for some reason still interested in running the comic, I think we would've seen a second take of the "guest artist era," i.e. Kevin using the book for whatever silly genre experiment he and his artist friends were up for.

Which, personally, I could dig. But I seriously doubt the man left the franchise with any sprawling crime operas up his sleeve. That was really never his schtick, much as people like to imagine otherwise.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
03-02-2010, 12:34 AM
This has been discussed before. Every story would've been Casey and Raph getting into fights at bars :tlol: