PDA

View Full Version : If the new movie was the OT in live action?


sdp
03-02-2010, 07:51 PM
Ok before everyone hates on this...

Lets say Paramount changes the new movie to be based more on the OT. Now before you think it as a lame kids movie...It would be live action and based on the OT but it'd be a serious take on it. You'd have Krang/Rocksteady/Beebop/technodrome all in the movie so it wouldn't be based on the Mirage comics however like I mentioned it wouldn't be kiddified it'd still be PG/PG-13 trying to get that older target audience as well, similar to Transformers was marketed.

Now this would be a sure hit since this is what everyone who grew up with the turtles want, a new movie based on the show/version they watched as kids but made "also" for adults not just kids. We all know we're in a minority and most don't know or care that the turtles did not start as a cartoon and thats not the version they want to see.

Personally I don't think it'd be that bad, it'd be nice to see a more serious interpretation of the OT, in fact when the OT was serious it still worked and was awesome.

The Stryker
03-02-2010, 08:15 PM
I don't want to see a serious version of Bebop and Rocksteady. Their whole appeal is being stupid.

Also, this idea sounds a lot like that fan project that nobody cares about.

sdp
03-02-2010, 08:22 PM
I'm saying a serious take on the OT, Rocksteady and Beebop would obviously still be stupid. Just because the Transformers movie is more serious doesn't mean its humorless.

I don't see how it sounds like a fan project, its definitely something that could happen and nobody cares about? besides comic geeks and the hardcore TMNT fandom, to people the TMNT ARE the OT, and thats what they want to see in a movie.

gobo
03-02-2010, 10:56 PM
If the new movie was the OT in live action?
>_< I read that wrong. I came in here thinking you were asking what if first movie had been just the original 'toon in live-action. If that had been the case (like I'm sure the suits wanted), I probably wouldn't be a fan today. It was the occasional shots of dignity in the franchise (Archie, Usagi eps, etc) that kept me coming back.

P.S. - The 'Party Van' back at SDCC '09 had little trivia facts flash on a monitor inside. It said original plans were to use Bebop & Rocksteady as the mutants in SotO. So glad they didn't...
Just because the Transformers movie is more serious doesn't mean its humorless.
O_o Bad example... The Transformers movies were the only part of that franchise that weren't humorless. As hard as I tried to wedge myself into that fandom, I could never sit through an entire ep of any related series for that reason.

CyberCubed
03-02-2010, 11:08 PM
Isn't this "Dawn of the Ninja" thing that someone is already working on?

Cipher
03-03-2010, 01:00 AM
Well, as far as Fred Wolf elements, you know what I've always liked? Baxter as a fly. That's something I've always felt could work in a more "serious" version of the Turtles. For example, they could keep his initial character role from the comics, but have him experiment in mutagenics after encountering the Turtles. Or, whatever, something.

It's right in line with all the sci-fi pastiche of TMNT, gives them an iconic villain, and was pretty sick sh*t even in the kids' cartoon. It's not that much higher than cyborg Baxter on the ridiculousness scale either.

Kendamu
03-03-2010, 03:11 AM
Hey, if Paramount makes an OT-style movie and it's at least as good as the first season of the OT, I've got no problems. I just hope it doesn't take a few sudden dives at various points like the actual OT did. So, yeah, not quite a "serious" take... more like a "high quality take."

Walkabout
03-04-2010, 08:40 PM
If they did-it would be awesome.

A blending of the different versions (Splinter as a rat, Shredder as a human, Krang as an Utrom) would be a real hit-well I mean Id go and see/buy it

:tgrin:

Gyt Kaliba
03-05-2010, 12:20 PM
I could totally get behind this idea. That's what's keeping me interested in the new toon that Nick's working on (other than interest just cuz it's the Turtles too), is what I keep hearing about it taking elements and/or characters from the old toon and re-imagning them. I'd love to see another take at Rocksteady, Bebop, and Krang. Heck, I'll even take April as a reporter again. I can do without the Neutrinoes though...but maybe that's just me.

On SotO though, I'm glad they went Tokka and Rahzar instead of Rocksteady and Bebop as well, simply cuz I've always liked Tokka and Rahzar. It was nice to get another batch of mutants.

Andrew NDB
03-05-2010, 03:54 PM
Ok before everyone hates on this...

Oops. Too late.

Turo602
03-05-2010, 04:01 PM
I don't want to see a serious version of Bebop and Rocksteady. Their whole appeal is being stupid.

Also, this idea sounds a lot like that fan project that nobody cares about.

It would still be awesome to see a meaner badder take on Bebop and Rocksteady. This way they would be more of a threat.

The Stryker
03-05-2010, 04:10 PM
It would still be awesome to see a meaner badder take on Bebop and Rocksteady. This way they would be more of a threat.

But I don't give a sh*t about them being more of a threat.

ToTheNines
03-05-2010, 05:20 PM
It would still be awesome to see a meaner badder take on Bebop and Rocksteady. This way they would be more of a threat.

But what's the point? If you wanna see mean mother fuc*in gang members, wouldn't it be better to have brand new gang members... that aren't bogged down by stupid nick-names names or cosplay outfits?

Turo602
03-05-2010, 05:45 PM
But what's the point? If you wanna see mean mother fuc*in gang members, wouldn't it be better to have brand new gang members... that aren't bogged down by stupid nick-names names or cosplay outfits?

I don't know, I always saw Bebop and Rocksteady as mutated Purple Dragons. It would be a cool idea to have an OT type of movie but also have a violent and more dark take but also humorous.

Lord Nightwalker
03-05-2010, 05:58 PM
If the new film were the OT TMNT, I wouldn't watch it.

Venom
03-05-2010, 09:36 PM
As a kid I was disappointed it wasn't Bebop and Rocksteady in the cages.

The concept of them being meaner and badder could work. The characters themselves come from violent backgrounds so it's not impossible to see them as being more competent, threatening individuals. Tristan even had a story to use them, albeit as giant aliens but still! :D

Andrew NDB
03-05-2010, 09:49 PM
I'll say the same thing I said in a comics thread about potentially importing "badass" Mirage-versions of Bebop and Rocksteady into the existing Mirage comic universe:

To me, it's just a pretty creatively bankrupt idea.

I mean, I get that nostalgiacs want that "OS Fix" of seeing their favorite children's cartoon TMNT characters like Bebop and Rocksteady again... but if they have to be "serioused up" and converted into real, credible threats, things that they were never created or intended to be... then why use them at all? Why not make new characters and villains that fit the mold of the serious, credible threats, or look to the actual source material for closer-fit matches that don't require any massive retooling?

The concept of them being meaner and badder could work. The characters themselves come from violent backgrounds so it's not impossible to see them as being more competent, threatening individuals. Tristan even had a story to use them, albeit as giant aliens but still!

If I remember, they weren't going to be aliens. They were to be the actual, OS Bebop and Rocksteady, visiting the Mirage "dimension" from presumably the OS "Dimension" in the TMNT multiverse. Wasn't a bad idea at all, really... and why not? Multiversal crossovers can be a lot of fun, as DC has taught us to varying results (some great stories out of the 70s, and Grant Morrison's "Earth-2" is awesome). It's only the idea and prospect of, "Let's make an actual Mirage universe Bebop and Rocksteady" that makes me think about investing in some ipicac.

sdp
03-05-2010, 10:00 PM
Well that is not what I mean though...

They HAVE to be Beebop and Rocksteady because that is what the 80s show had, if you replace them then its no longer based on the 80s show.

Also when I meant a serious take on the character I meant that they'd make the movie appeal to both kids and the kids who grew up with it. Think of all the recent movies like that and even superhero movies. The Spiderman movies are not grimdark yet they appeal to both kids as well as the older demographic. This wouldn't be a grimdark version of the 80s show but a more serious take to be able to appeal to both demographics.

Turo602
03-05-2010, 10:14 PM
Yeah but that doesn't mean that Bebop and Rocksteady have to be mentally challenged:D

Andrew NDB
03-05-2010, 10:15 PM
Yeah but that doesn't mean that Bebop and Rocksteady have to be mentally challenged:D

Yes. Yes, it does.

Turo602
03-05-2010, 10:20 PM
Yes. Yes, it does.

How It would still have the same characters like Shredder, Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady, heck even Robotic Foot Soldiers. That should keep OT fans happy.

Bebop and Rocksteady could be more of of a threat and it would still keep me pleased. That just like saying that the Turtles need to constantly keep throwing surrounding objects in the movie just because it's based off of the OT TMNT. Them being more of a threat just adds better action.

Venom
03-05-2010, 10:31 PM
If I remember, they weren't going to be aliens. They were to be the actual, OS Bebop and Rocksteady, visiting the Mirage "dimension" from presumably the OS "Dimension" in the TMNT multiverse. Wasn't a bad idea at all, really... and why not?

I was using the term "aliens" very loosely as they were from another dimension, not the OS dimension, but one that was things were much larger than the Mirage universe. The two were gigantic and wreaked havoc pretty much due to their sheer size.

Andrew NDB
03-05-2010, 10:32 PM
I was using the term "aliens" very loosely as they were from another dimension,

True... I suppose they would technically be "aliens" if they came from another dimension.

sdp
03-05-2010, 10:47 PM
Rocksteady and Beebop can be pretty credible threats, after all they are large and intimidating, they just aren't very smart. Not much different than how Tokka and Rahzar were portrayed.

Turo602
03-05-2010, 10:50 PM
Tokka and Rahzar were "Babies, their Babies uhh":lol:

gobo
03-05-2010, 11:29 PM
Well that is not what I mean though...
Whether or not that's what you meant, it's what you said. So, I'm guessing you mean just keep them consistently in their post-mutation, Season 1 character. Right? I'd be down with that.
Tokka and Rahzar were "Babies, their Babies uhh":lol:
Don't forget that Dr. Jordan has added something to the ooze to stunt their cognitive development. In other words, he kept 'em stupid.

Andrew NDB
03-06-2010, 01:13 AM
Rocksteady and Beebop can be pretty credible threats, after all they are large and intimidating, they just aren't very smart. Not much different than how Tokka and Rahzar were portrayed.

I'm not sure Tokka and Rahzar are good examples of how Bebop and Rocksteady could "work" on screen.

Krutch
03-06-2010, 03:52 AM
I'm not sure Tokka and Rahzar are good examples of how Bebop and Rocksteady could "work" on screen.

I can see it work. They can still be idiots and pose a physical threat, with weapons and whatnot. A couple morons shooting guns are still threats.

Andrew NDB
03-06-2010, 03:55 AM
I can see it work. They can still be idiots and pose a physical threat, with weapons and whatnot. A couple morons shooting guns are still threats.

True. It's just not a compelling TMNT film at that point, IMHO.

Krutch
03-06-2010, 04:06 AM
It's not what I'd prefer either, but hey, if we're talking an OT adaptation, my expectations would be pretty low already so what the hell?

Coola Yagami
03-07-2010, 01:04 AM
True. It's just not a compelling TMNT film at that point, IMHO.

You'd rather have baby-minded mutants that called Shredder 'Momma'?

Dragon Turtle
03-07-2010, 02:06 AM
Ok before everyone hates on this...

Lets say Paramount changes the new movie to be based more on the OT. Now before you think it as a lame kids movie...It would be live action and based on the OT but it'd be a serious take on it. You'd have Krang/Rocksteady/Beebop/technodrome all in the movie so it wouldn't be based on the Mirage comics however like I mentioned it wouldn't be kiddified it'd still be PG/PG-13 trying to get that older target audience as well, similar to Transformers was marketed.


It wouldn't be out of the question to see Viacom/Nick/Paramount go this route, since it's worked well for them in the past, they could easily PG-13 up the old cartoon just like Transformers and G.I. Joe.



Now this would be a sure hit since this is what everyone who grew up with the turtles want, a new movie based on the show/version they watched as kids but made "also" for adults not just kids. We all know we're in a minority and most don't know or care that the turtles did not start as a cartoon and thats not the version they want to see.


There are no guarantees to whether a TMNT movie based on the OT will be a sure fire hit, to truly reach out to a larger audience they need to go beyond OT fans. I believe the concept of the turtles is strong enough without the OT elements.

Andrew NDB
03-07-2010, 02:27 AM
You'd rather have baby-minded mutants that called Shredder 'Momma'?

That would be as equally non-compelling as it was in 1991. Of course, like most I was more forgiving as a 10 year old... though if we're all throwing in the towel that that's the audience they ought to be targeting, then the battle is already lost.

There are no guarantees to whether a TMNT movie based on the OT will be a sure fire hit, to truly reach out to a larger audience they need to go beyond OT fans. I believe the concept of the turtles is strong enough without the OT elements.

Completely agreed. To say nothing of the fact that the OS hardcore fans have already long aged themselved out of the target demographic of these types of films.

The question keeps coming up: "What fans should the movie be for? OS fans? Mirage TMNT fans? Most people know about the OS! That's what they should go towards! How many Mirage comics fans are there? Like 1,000?"

The answer is... no fans. Existing ones, anyway. As I said, even the OS fans have aged themselves out of the Holywood demographic for movies like these. The only sound solution left, I believe, is the one they've never, ever tried before... a relatively faithful take on the comic book source material with a visionary director in nothing less than PG-13.

Will that happen, or will history and the vicious circle of the snake eating its own tail (TPTB making TMNT product that is too easy to outgrow again and again, then wondering why it fails)... the jury is out. But rooting back to the OS children's cartoon for mining material is ass-backwards.

Now, for the new CGI cartoon in 2012? Why not? They can do whatever they want for the latest children's cartoon. It is, after all, for children.

sdp
03-07-2010, 10:43 AM
Of course an OS movie doesn't guarantee a hit, but nothing guarantees a hit. Focusing on the 80s show does give them a large audience since its what people who grew up with it know and like and new kids would be interested just as we were as kids.

Completely agreed. To say nothing of the fact that the OS hardcore fans have already long aged themselved out of the target demographic of these types of films.

The question keeps coming up: "What fans should the movie be for? OS fans? Mirage TMNT fans? Most people know about the OS! That's what they should go towards! How many Mirage comics fans are there? Like 1,000?"

The answer is... no fans. Existing ones, anyway. As I said, even the OS fans have aged themselves out of the Holywood demographic for movies like these. The only sound solution left, I believe, is the one they've never, ever tried before... a relatively faithful take on the comic book source material with a visionary director in nothing less than PG-13.

How did the OS fans aged themselves out of the target demographic long ago for these films? Just like other 80s revivals they are the right age.

And they've already tried a Mirage adaptation with the original movie, albeit with changes but thats to be expected for any hollywood adaptation. Batman Begins is not a straight forward comic book adaptation either. Also the turtles are NOT Batman, you can't expect the regular demographic to treat the turtles like Batman, the whole concept by itself is still silly heck the comic started as a parody.

I'd prefer the version we were promised before the buyout but I don't think I'd be against it being adapted from the OT. And besides very few Mirage fanboys, thats the version all the general public would want.

Now, for the new CGI cartoon in 2012? Why not? They can do whatever they want for the latest children's cartoon. It is, after all, for children.


Thats ignorant like saying comic books are after all for children.

The Stryker
03-07-2010, 02:10 PM
Thats ignorant like saying comic books are after all for children.

Weren't they both originally created for Children?

Andrew NDB
03-07-2010, 04:31 PM
How did the OS fans aged themselves out of the target demographic long ago for these films?

Old Father Time, I suppose. Are there a lot of OS fans out there that are 15-21?

Just like other 80s revivals they are the right age.

What, like G.I. Joe and Transformers? If you were to break down the ticket sales of those, how many do you suppose were the actual GI Joe/Transformers fans from the 80s and how many were tweens and teens -- ones that had never seen any Transformers or GI Joe cartoons from the 80s -- that wanted to see robots fight each other and a big summer actioner? Or to see Megan Fox bend over? The aged, existing fandoms are the icing on the cake, not the cake itself, man.

And they've already tried a Mirage adaptation with the original movie, albeit with changes but thats to be expected for any hollywood adaptation.

C'mon, let's take off the nostalgia glasses. It was a good movie and remains one... but while it had heart and a world more "grit" than the other movies (which let's keep in mind is not saying much), they essentially made it a slapstick comedy in more places than not... and the crux of it to be, "Oh no! Will little Danny turn to the Dark Side and join the evil Foot Clan halfway house for children?" I don't remember that rubbish in the comic books.

Batman Begins is not a straight forward comic book adaptation either.

It's an amalgam of very successful, very critically praised Batman comic book stories and elements. I don't think it's unrealistic to think a similar approach to TMNT would bear similar fruit.

Of course, nowhere near that scale. No one's suggesting that.

Also the turtles are NOT Batman, you can't expect the regular demographic to treat the turtles like Batman, the whole concept by itself is still silly heck the comic started as a parody.

If you believe that the scant number of parodic elements in its inception were the crux of the TMNT then you probably shouldn't be a fan.

Eastman and Laird have both said it wasn't a parody. I'm going with them.

I'd prefer the version we were promised before the buyout but I don't think I'd be against it being adapted from the OT. And besides very few Mirage fanboys, thats the version all the general public would want.

Again, the people that would actually be versed in the time of yore of Bebops and Krangs are not the target demographic of films like these. And again, if they show up, great, it's icing on the cake... not the cake itself.

And "the general public" isn't what a movie studio and financiers are going to concern themselves with. They're doing an actioner, possibly a summer actioner, then there's a very specific target demographic they're going to be going for... it's not a difficult concept. And I'm sorry, but the OS fans haven't been a part of it for some time now.

Thats ignorant like saying comic books are after all for children.

You know what I mean. Little kids. 6-8 year olds who beg mommy and daddy to buy them action figures at Toys 'R' Us or have to save up money from the tooth fairy to do so.

Krutch
03-07-2010, 05:37 PM
I think your underestimating the 80s revival audience. I'm in that demographic, and I know a ton of friends who were giddy to see their childhood shows on the big screen. These are the same friends who stick to downloading cam quality bootlegs of most movies, but were first in line for G.I. Joe and Transformers.

Dont get me wrong, I'd much rather see a true representation of Mirage Turtles as well. But unless a big name director comes on board feeling the same as we do, expect a movie geared towards the 80s revival crowd.

sdp
03-07-2010, 09:00 PM
Old Father Time, I suppose. Are there a lot of OS fans out there that are 15-21?

I know plenty of 18-21 TMNT fans, I'm only 23 myself.

I think you're underestimating the power of these old franchises, online there was huge hype and talk on them from people who grew up with them, I also knew plenty of older people than me who were very excited for these movies based on the shows they age. Are they the main demographic for the movie? Kind of, they make the movies to be able to appeal to kids and an older audience. Kids will buy all the toys and merchandise but if they were the only audience then they'd be G rated movies. The movies are obviously marketed to both audiences, and no, if the movie wasn't called Transformers and it was just about transforming robots fighting each other and Megan Fox the movie would not have been in people must watch list. You don't give enough credit to people who grew up with it not necessarily fandoms.




C'mon, let's take off the nostalgia glasses. It was a good movie and remains one... but while it had heart and a world more "grit" than the other movies (which let's keep in mind is not saying much), they essentially made it a slapstick comedy in more places than not... and the crux of it to be, "Oh no! Will little Danny turn to the Dark Side and join the evil Foot Clan halfway house for children?" I don't remember that rubbish in the comic books.

It's an amalgam of very successful, very critically praised Batman comic book stories and elements. I don't think it's unrealistic to think a similar approach to TMNT would bear similar fruit.

No nostalgia glasses, I'm just saying that it was a fairly decent adaptation from the comic. Not 100% accurate of course but no movie or cartoon adaptation of comic/books ever are, they always change stuff for one reason or another.

And I disagree, the turtles is a silly concept and it can not be sold to a mass audience as easily. No one wants a grimdark adaptation besides us the fandom. Yeah they'll take a more serious take on it whether based on the 80s show or Mirage comic adaptation but never a more direct gritty Mirage adaptation, that will never happen. So no a similar approach to what Begins/Dark Knight wouldn't work it would definitely have to be lighter and have more humor a la Transformers/GI Joe.


Anyways in conclusion since I think my post is kinda messy...what I mean to say is you are not giving the OT enough credibility to work as a movie. I perfectly understand that is now that you want to see and I don't necessarily want it to be that I'd also prefer the version that we were told before the buy out, this is just a "what if" and I think I'd be alright with it. And if it happened I think it would be a hit since its what people want and kids would love it, would the version we were promised before the buyout also be a hit? I also definitely think if done right it can be a hit and do great. Only thing I disagree is that an OT influenced movie would be what people want and that the only way the movie can get an older audience is being a more direct adaptation.

Andrew NDB
03-07-2010, 10:00 PM
I know plenty of 18-21 TMNT fans, I'm only 23 myself.

I think you're underestimating the power of these old franchises, online there was huge hype and talk on them from people who grew up with them, I also knew plenty of older people than me who were very excited for these movies based on the shows they age. Are they the main demographic for the movie? Kind of, they make the movies to be able to appeal to kids and an older audience. Kids will buy all the toys and merchandise but if they were the only audience then they'd be G rated movies. The movies are obviously marketed to both audiences, and no, if the movie wasn't called Transformers and it was just about transforming robots fighting each other and Megan Fox the movie would not have been in people must watch list. You don't give enough credit to people who grew up with it not necessarily fandoms.

I don't belittle it. I'm sure there was many thousands, maybe even tens of thousands of the actual kids -- now grown -- that used to watch the original Transformers and GI Joe cartoons that went to the theatre to see the movie. These do, however, account for only a small percentage of the box office returns.

No nostalgia glasses, I'm just saying that it was a fairly decent adaptation from the comic.

Some scenes. Thematically it was quite another beast.

Not 100% accurate of course but no movie or cartoon adaptation of comic/books ever are, they always change stuff for one reason or another.

Of course. But then there's... adding stuff in that wouldn't be and isn't organic to the universe of the source material. Excess of slapstick and Foot Halfway House for Troubled Youths and Darth Shredder, I'm talking to you.

And I disagree, the turtles is a silly concept and it can not be sold to a mass audience as easily. No one wants a grimdark adaptation besides us the fandom. Yeah they'll take a more serious take on it whether based on the 80s show or Mirage comic adaptation but never a more direct gritty Mirage adaptation, that will never happen. So no a similar approach to what Begins/Dark Knight wouldn't work it would definitely have to be lighter and have more humor a la Transformers/GI Joe.

Which is fine... as long as the humor isn't an excess of slapstick and there's the right, comic-equivalent (or close) amount of "ninja action" to balance things out.

Anyways in conclusion since I think my post is kinda messy...what I mean to say is you are not giving the OT enough credibility to work as a movie.

It can work as a movie, I'm not doubting that. But is going that route the best shot a new movie has at maximizing success? Is it the best, most logical option on the table? Absolutely not.

I perfectly understand that is now that you want to see

While I am a unapologetic hardcore fan of the comics and little else, it isn't about what I want to see... I'm talking about what we haven't seen -- the last bastion that's never been tried before while every other route has been explored:

A kick-ass TMNT movie that brings the comic universe to life.

and I don't necessarily want it to be that I'd also prefer the version that we were told before the buy out, this is just a "what if" and I think I'd be alright with it. And if it happened I think it would be a hit since its what people want and kids would love it, would the version we were promised before the buyout also be a hit? I also definitely think if done right it can be a hit and do great. Only thing I disagree is that an OT influenced movie would be what people want

What people? We're back to talking about the existing TMNT fans, which the studio can't and shouldn't concern itself with (I hate to say it).

and that the only way the movie can get an older audience is being a more direct adaptation.

You say that like it must be be an OS influenced movie or it must be a "more direct adaptation." What precludes a "more direct adaptation" that's PG-13 (I'm not advocating an R-rated movie here, as much as I'd love it) from drawing in the kiddies? If you think I'm underestimating the draw of the OS on screen, you are woefully underestimating the drawing power of films with kid-friendly enough premises (hey, Turtles that are Ninjas is pretty much a cool draw in itself, as a concept) that don't cater to the lowest common denominator.

Dragon Turtle
03-07-2010, 10:25 PM
The question keeps coming up: "What fans should the movie be for? OS fans? Mirage TMNT fans? Most people know about the OS! That's what they should go towards! How many Mirage comics fans are there? Like 1,000?"

The answer is... no fans. Existing ones, anyway. As I said, even the OS fans have aged themselves out of the Holywood demographic for movies like these. The only sound solution left, I believe, is the one they've never, ever tried before... a relatively faithful take on the comic book source material with a visionary director in nothing less than PG-13.


It's a sound solution, but not the only one, as much as I feel that a TMNT movie doesn't need to cater to OT fans to be successful, building a movie around the OT and making it PG-13 could potentially be just as successful as one based on the comics, since the general public, at this point, probably doesn't care about either to any great extent.



Of course an OS movie doesn't guarantee a hit, but nothing guarantees a hit. Focusing on the 80s show does give them a large audience since its what people who grew up with it know and like and new kids would be interested just as we were as kids.


Unless you can guarantee every kid who grew up a fan of the OT will automatically go out and see a movie that's focused on the OT, the size of the audience this type of movie would attract is pure speculation.


I think your underestimating the 80s revival audience. I'm in that demographic, and I know a ton of friends who were giddy to see their childhood shows on the big screen. These are the same friends who stick to downloading cam quality bootlegs of most movies, but were first in line for G.I. Joe and Transformers.


I'm in the demographic of the 80s revival audience, but even I don't believe that it was this demographic that powered movies such as Transformers and G.I. Joe to nearly 2 billion in total box office.

If there is anything that movies such as Transformers and G.I. Joe have taught us is that, the the general public could care less about the source of the content of the movie, just as long as something blows up.

Koi
03-08-2010, 08:22 AM
If there is anything that movies such as Transformers and G.I. Joe have taught us is that, the the general public could care less about the source of the content of the movie, just as long as something blows up.

The old toon had explosions... So did the comics, and as well the more recent ones.

My guess is that it will have a good focus on the newer toon and comic to tell you the truth. It is usually focused on the newest viewers. Which makes me sad, for I adored the 90's toon ten times more then the more recent shows.

Kendamu
03-08-2010, 03:03 PM
If you believe that the scant number of parodic elements in its inception were the crux of the TMNT then you probably shouldn't be a fan.

Eastman and Laird have both said it wasn't a parody. I'm going with them.

I respect you a lot. You're one of my favorite people to read posts from around here and you're doing a lot for TMNT comic fans like myself right now. However, I think that's a bit harsh.

One of the big draws for me when it comes to TMNT is how ridiculous it is and how it homages and parodies other popular elements of comics. Whether it's the Daredevil knockoff stuff, the idea of Turtles being Ninja in the first place, the cheesy epic Ninja battles, or even those alternate universe Superhero Turtles that look like they should be hanging out with the Superfriends, part of what makes the TMNT comics so cool is that it has a nice mix of homage/parody humor or it has a bit of a "so serious that it's funny" sort of gritty atmosphere that's way too realistic for the premise itself.

As much as Eastman and Laird say, "It's not a parody. It's not a joke. This is serious business," I can't quite completely believe that. Sure, I can definitely see that it's gotten more serious over time as fans started to take the characters more seriously, but even in the worst-case scenario (like recovering from the nice Christmas Eve ambush that revealed that the Shredder was still alive) you end up getting a story like "The Unmentionables" right in the middle of it all. Noir detective hockey mask Casey in a small town where nothing ever happens chasing after some cow statue with a bunch of turtles in a story named after a word that references underwear.

Hell, the very concept of Casey Jones (a masked vigilante popping out of the shadows to beat up crooks like he's Batman or something) is funny as can be and I love it! It's part of why he's my favorite character and I haven't seen anything so cool and funny since then until Mark Millar started publishing Kick-Ass.

Or maybe one of my all-time favorites: Shell of the Dragon. An obvious Bruce Lee homage with parody elements to it and a kooky enough villain back-story involving the huge beast of a warrior having irrational and brutal fits of rage whenever he sees a turtle... and all of the trouble that brought such a guy into the story was over a small-time independent Chinese restaurant that could never compete with corporate Chinese food found almost everywhere was being attacked because everything's made from scratch.

Another all-time favorite of mine is TMNT Vol. 1 #41. The one about the Turtles' dreams. Sure, it's probably not canon, but it could fit anywhere. They're just napping or something. That was part of the Vol. 1 hardcore B&W old days of Turtles and it was a very kooky and funny story. Probably the only one mentioned so far not involving Eastman or Laird, either.

Finally, there's Bodycount. When seen from my "I like the humor" perspective, this is probably one of the funniest stories I've ever read and I'm pretty sure you understand why I would think so.

Those kinds of stories, those kinds of elements being put into the serious stuff, or the serious stuff being so epic that it's cheesy (in that cool martial arts movie sort of way) are why I'm a fan. Another reason I'm a fan, though, is because you and I can see the same stories in a completely different light and still enjoy them equally. You focus more on the serious business and I focus more on the humor, but they're both there and I love it! I just hate that even Eastman and Laird seem to be downplaying the less serious elements when asked about it. I know that it's not a straight-up parody. Even if it were at one point, it grew out of that early on. I just like that the stories blended "laughing at yourself" humor with serious business so well in the Frank Millar/Alan Moore era that parented the "X-TREME 90s COMIX GGRRAAHHH" stuff.

It really kinda hurts me as a fan when people try and downplay the humor in the comics. I know you're a hardass about it and all, and I appreciate that because it gets the ball rolling in potentially great ways (like the Vol. 3 conclusion), but I'm the guy who likes the funny stuff or sees the funny side to the serious moments and I'm just as much a legit fan of the comics as you are.

Andrew NDB
03-08-2010, 03:18 PM
Where did the idea come from that I'm against humor in the TMNT? I love humor in the TMNT. It's an instrumental part of their "draw." I just prefer there to be a sense of balance about it and not an oversaturation of it such as there is in the films and children's cartoons... that's all.

I dunno, I just feel like I should be able to watch more than 2 minutes of a TMNT movie without being beaten over the head by a Three Stooges impression, or someone clowning around with a funny coo-coo sound effect dubbed in. Maybe it's just me.

"It's not a parody. It's not a joke. This is serious business,"

They've never said that. They acknowledge the parodic elements... but the parodic elements do not define it.

Kendamu
03-08-2010, 03:32 PM
That's the difference between me and you. I feel like, since there's a balance, that the parodic elements can define it as much as the serious elements can. I'm not a, "Oh yeah, the humor is there, but that's not what it's about," kind of guy. Looking at the examples I brought up, I'm also not the type who thinks the Three Stooges elements are what the humor in TMNT should be.

Even if I take the OT as an example, just look at the first little bit of the first episode where April is reporting on the crime in the city. It's not a series of intentional wisecracks on the characters' parts. They're all acting dead serious about what they're saying, but what's being said is just goofy and off-the-wall in that Naked Gun kind of way. That's the OT humor that I like.

Or maybe the TMNT manga. I love that stuff! It sets up a plot where the Turtles get way in over their heads and it looks like the Shredder is about to win, but the entire short story's just actually been a set-up for the punchline of when things go horribly wrong in an otherwise flawless plan. Kind of a "Murphy's Law" thing taken to very funny lengths.

I didn't mean to imply that you don't like the humor. Sorry I came off that way. Part of what I said ended up being responses to what I've read from a lot of TMNT comic fans (or at least a few very loud ones) over a long period of time and I got into a long-winded rant involving things that weren't necessarily about you personally.

I just had a lot to get off my chest as a guy who loves, amongst other things, subtle comedy and parodic elements sprinkled throughout otherwise serious stories that can be taken seriously.

EDIT: One big example that I know you're into the humor as well is your very apparent feelings toward "Dawn of the Ninja."

Andrew NDB
03-08-2010, 04:33 PM
That's the difference between me and you. I feel like, since there's a balance, that the parodic elements can define it as much as the serious elements can.

I guess you can do whatever you want. I just think defining it by something both creators are saying shouldn't define it seems dodgy to me at best.

I'm not a, "Oh yeah, the humor is there, but that's not what it's about," kind of guy.

So in your book... it's about the humor? We're just going to have to agree to disagree.

Looking at the examples I brought up, I'm also not the type who thinks the Three Stooges elements are what the humor in TMNT should be.

Yeah.

Even if I take the OT as an example, just look at the first little bit of the first episode where April is reporting on the crime in the city. It's not a series of intentional wisecracks on the characters' parts. They're all acting dead serious about what they're saying, but what's being said is just goofy and off-the-wall in that Naked Gun kind of way. That's the OT humor that I like.

I respect self-aware/almost fourth wall-breaking humor like that. I just don't like it in the Turtleverse.

But children's cartoons? They can make it as goofy and silly as they want. Go all out, I'll completely support it (from afar... way afar).

Or maybe the TMNT manga. I love that stuff! It sets up a plot where the Turtles get way in over their heads and it looks like the Shredder is about to win, but the entire short story's just actually been a set-up for the punchline of when things go horribly wrong in an otherwise flawless plan. Kind of a "Murphy's Law" thing taken to very funny lengths.

What can I say. Gotta love Japan.

I didn't mean to imply that you don't like the humor. Sorry I came off that way. Part of what I said ended up being responses to what I've read from a lot of TMNT comic fans (or at least a few very loud ones) over a long period of time and I got into a long-winded rant involving things that weren't necessarily about you personally.

I can respect that.

I just had a lot to get off my chest as a guy who loves, amongst other things, subtle comedy and parodic elements sprinkled throughout otherwise serious stories that can be taken seriously.

Oh, I love subtle comedy... though the kinds of nonsense I'm talking about/arguing against, there ain't nothing subtle about it.

EDIT: One big example that I know you're into the humor as well is your very apparent feelings toward "Dawn of the Ninja."

Toward what?

Kendamu
03-08-2010, 04:49 PM
I guess you can do whatever you want. I just think defining it by something both creators are saying shouldn't define it seems dodgy to me at best.

Like I said, I feel like it's being downplayed even though it's obviously there and it's not just a tiny little thing that's hard to notice. Maybe I'm just seeing it differently than it was intended to be seen. I just see humor as a much larger point throughout the comics than other people do.

Yes, there are some very serious elements. They're some of the big classic TMNT moments that I love as much as anyone else. I just don't define the Turtles by those moments as much as other people do.

jalexbrown
03-08-2010, 07:38 PM
Where did the idea come from that I'm against humor in the TMNT? I love humor in the TMNT. It's an instrumental part of their "draw." I just prefer there to be a sense of balance about it and not an oversaturation of it such as there is in the films and children's cartoons... that's all.

I dunno, I just feel like I should be able to watch more than 2 minutes of a TMNT movie without being beaten over the head by a Three Stooges impression, or someone clowning around with a funny coo-coo sound effect dubbed in. Maybe it's just me.



They've never said that. They acknowledge the parodic elements... but the parodic elements do not define it.

As someone who has been a fan of pretty much everything that has been offered in the way of the Turtles, I agree with Andrew that it is probably best to take a comic book route with the new movie. I'm certainly not going to be fanatic and obsessive about it dripping with realism - these are four walking, talking, fighting turtles, after all - but I would appreciate them trying to give the franchise a new tone and showing the mainstream what it's really all about. The 90s movies had their chance in the spotlight, and it worked well for the movie companies, and the movies - well, the first one mostly - were good, maybe nearly perfect at what they were trying to accomplish. But I would love to see them try to take the movies in a new, unexplored direction; the last bastion of unexplored territory for the movies, really, is the comics.

TristanHuwJones
06-09-2010, 05:49 AM
Sorry if I'm digging up an old thread, but just to clarify, what I wanted to do with B & R isn't quite what people are getting at here. Here's what I pitched. Pete dug it, but still, I don't think the idea of the two appearing in the Mirage comics appealed. Which is fair enough... read on. The idea was that it would be a con exclusive or a special one-shot specifically for the anniversary... an optional-canonical comic.

We open in another dimension (Caption: NOT Dimension X…), where the two massive brutes are being pursued by authorities in an intense car/other-dimensional-vehicle chase! Suddenly, a vortex starts opening in midair just ahead of them…

Cut to our world, where a Foot Mystic and a band of renegade Foot ninjas are trying to open up a portal to the Netherworld (to summon a demon to help them against the Turtles). Unfortunately, the mystic has misinterpreted one of the symbols in the spell used to open the portal correctly. A portal opens, but when the vehicle Bebop and Rocksteady had hi-jacked comes thundering out and pastes the mystic, it becomes very clear that it’s not the right one!

The rest of the Foot renegades scatter and Bebop and Rocksteady check out this strange new world they’ve stumbled into. They are massive too, at least twice the size of Leatherhead. A registered, costumed superhero flies down to try and stop the duo, but they pulverize him (in a comically brutal way, not to death, but there’s no way a normal human would be able to take it).

Cut to the Turtles’ lair, where Raph, Don and Mike are watching late night television (Leo is reading something). A sudden live news broadcast interrupts and reveals that Bebop and Rocksteady are tearing up midtown as police try and take them down.

After getting a call from April (who’s been caught in the midst of the carnage), they spring into action (they would be disguised somehow, either in gear similar to #36, or civilian clothing – long coats, etc.).

They pluck April out of the danger zone and get her to safety without being noticed, everyone seems too freaked out by the massive duo to care.
Mike notices that Karai and a band of her best warriors are on a nearby rooftop. They join her to try and find out what’s going on, and Karai reveals that a rogue mystic had recently stolen a tome from their archives containing spells/rituals that could supposedly open pathways to parallel dimensions. However, without the book they have no idea what spell/ritual was used, or how to send the two creatures back to where they came from. Don and Karai discuss their options and agree to try and come up with something together, but it means that Mike, Leo and Raph, along with the Foot warriors, will have to try and keep the dimension-hopping duo occupied.

As Mike, Leo and Raph fight Rocksteady and Bebop (taking a number of jabs at the old cartoon along the way), Karai and Don manage to put together a trans-dimensional portal using Leatherhead’s makeshift transmat device and various other bits and pieces Don has accumulated over the years. By channelling the mystic energies of a similar spell through the device, they are able to open a wormhole to another dimension (though not necessarily the one they came from).

The group lures Rocksteady and Bebop to the area above Leatherhead’s old lair (where the portal will open), but the two brutes realise they’re being herded towards a trap and start playing dirty. Don and Karai can only keep the portal open for a small amount of time, and with the brutes wise to the trap, the portal overloads the device that opened it.

At a loss for what to do, Mike suggests they call Renet, but none have any idea how to do that – considering she’s just appeared every time they’ve needed her. However, true to form, she does appear, having sensed a disturbingly large tremor in the space-time continuum. The guys fill her in, and Renet floats up towards Bebop and Rocksteady. She begins channelling her energies, chanting (similar to good ol’ Doctor Strange), but suddenly – WHAM! One of the monsters punches her into a building, sending the sceptre scattering off into an alley.

Don rushes to her aide while Raph, Leo, Mike and the Foot launch another assault on the pair. When it looks as though all is lost, Splinter suddenly arrives on the scene, standing quietly between the battle-weary warriors and the battle-ready monsters. The Turtles freak out, thinking Splinter has finally gone insane, and Bebop and Rocksteady find the situation hilarious. But Splinter has Renet’s sceptre!

Splinter mumbles something and suddenly the two are sucked into the sceptre itself!

With the city saved, Don returns with Renet. Karai tells them that she will help provide the funds to repair the damages caused in the chaos. (If you like the alternate ending, Mike could ask where Splinter sent them).

The turtles return home with their master, exhausted.

ALTERNATE ENDING (one final jab at the old cartoon):
We cut to find that Rocksteady and Bebop have been transported to a dusty, arid dimension, somewhat similar to the surface of Mars. They have been secured by hi-tech restraints and are being marched towards a gigantic construct by hulking soldiers who look similar to The Thing. They stop at the base of the construct, just in front of what appears to be large boarding ramp. “New prisoners for you my lord! We found them inside the forbidden zone.”
Bebop and Rocksteady look up, and we see a grotesquely obese Utrom, sitting in the torso cavity of a massive exosuit (think Obediah Stane’s “Iron Monger” suit compared to Tony Stark’s Iron Man suit). The Utrom grins: “Excellent!”

We zoom out for the final panel, revealing that the construct is disturbingly similar to a certain subterranean construct made famous by the old TMNT cartoons..


The End.


END NOTES: I thought it might be funny if the Mirage U Superheroes tried to fight the two, but would just get flicked away like annoying bugs, the only reason the Turtles manage to get their full attention is because Raph or Mike manages to throw either a sai, or a makeshift explosive up Rocksteady’s nose, pissing him off to no end.

The other thing I thought would be to not have any of Rocksteady and Bebop’s language be English, or even remotely recognisable. It would be alien gibberish, but we would be able to ascertain what they’re saying through visuals.

Finally, Rocksteady and Bebop’s names would never be uttered either, except in their native tongues (which we wouldn’t be able to read anyway).

Kendamu
06-09-2010, 08:47 AM
Too bad that never got made. I would have loved to have shown that to friends who grwew up on the OT.

TristanHuwJones
06-09-2010, 08:19 PM
Too bad that never got made. I would have loved to have shown that to friends who grwew up on the OT.

That was the idea. Long-timers would show people who remember the old show the comic version of Bebop and Rocksteady as something of a lure, but there'd also be a healthy dose of Mirage stuff in there as well for those people who may jump in at the FCBD or Con issue (we talked about doing it as either) and want to learn more about these extra characters they'd never heard of (Karai, Renet, etc.)

Ninjinister
06-09-2010, 09:56 PM
Aaaand yet they sort of appeared in #58 anyway.

I know, it was a cameo. But still...

mikey22
06-11-2010, 03:57 PM
the OT movie would be ok.. but why not have better fresher ideas


no one from the 90s batman animated series could have thought the joker would have been that sadistic


we need a turtle movie to start out right so it can have more than one movie

we need the story to start out with hamato yoshi and orku sakia for a good 20-30 minutes... we need the turtles at pets.. we need them growin up and eventually turning into ninja turtles

for all i can it can be a 2 hour movie of before they became teenage mutant ninja turtles....
it can be how leo was the only one following directions where raphael questions why things need to be done a certain way
mikey n don would sneak out from ninja practice to do their own thing

mikey would be more a sports guy/ skateboards video games/ like he always was while don was more interested in gadgets and reading books

their first battle i think would be a great cameo apperance!

we should have the rat king in the sewers and have a stale mate battle with the very young turtles

or even leatherhead!!! ( i ejnoyed the mirage leatherhead a lot!)

there are many other ideas but this is good for now


I REALLY DONT WANT UTROMS THOUGH!!!! LOL I THINK THOSE ARE STUPID

Sidian
06-20-2010, 12:26 AM
i feel like im always the minority but i would love to see a serious take on the OT....my son and i watch it all the time and i love it as much as i did when i was a kid....

to me the turtles ARE the OT, archie comics and the original films...and i feel like we need to get back to that place. anything less will be a failure in my eyes.

the 03 series sucked. yeah it was more serious but it didnt make it more entertaining. 50 friggin shredders and a bunch of bland characters..no thanx.

Andrew NDB
06-20-2010, 03:02 AM
to me the turtles ARE the OT, archie comics and the original films

http://www.hockeydrunk.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/obama_hell_naw.jpg

Powder
06-20-2010, 04:32 PM
LOL my thoughts exactly...

Sidian
06-20-2010, 09:57 PM
yeah i knew id get that response...dont care though...

my first exposure to them was from the cartoon...i can still remember watching the very first episodes when it came out. and a short time later it was the comics and the movies..

as a little kid i didnt even know that when they were talking about comics that they werent talking about the Archie ones.

and honestly when you talk about the turtles its these things that everyone remembers...you dont see t-shirts in mall stores showing the turtles all in red bandanas...

the turtles are iconic..but not because of the original comic or the newer cartoon or movie.


so yeah i know there are you guys here that are some sort of "purist" and somehow im describing mcdonalds compared to your filet mignon....but were talking about MUTANT TURTLES. if the film is done seriously having bebop and rocksteady makes it no more ridiculous.

ToTheNines
06-20-2010, 10:01 PM
the turtles are iconic..but not because of the original comic

http://www.zacharyquinto.com/assets_c/2009/04/17%20Spock%20Logic-thumb-autox450-210.jpg

Weapon X
06-21-2010, 10:30 AM
I personally would love to see a live action Bebop and Rocksteady, always have since Secret Of The Ooze. Unfortunately we all have a interpretation that we want to see on film. I really cant see a overly serious movie being made, I just feel the concept of "Dark Knight Of Turtle Films" a bit silly, but I guess we'll just have to see.

Shark_Blade
06-21-2010, 07:21 PM
I'm all for it. :D Or if they want to go with the comic origin, I will like that as well.

As long there's a badass Shredder in it, I'm sold.