PDA

View Full Version : Talkback: Laird's 2k3 development notes!


Pages : 1 [2]

CyberCubed
04-03-2012, 02:49 PM
After reading the latest FF scripts, its nice to see some cringeworthy dialogue and useless belching scenes removed.

At the same time, how did some of it still make it into episodes? In the wrestling episode, Raph says "Cowabunga" after knocking down Triple Threat. How the hell did that get past Peter Laird? He even removes that line from a different episode.

I also can't believe he didn't have them re-write Mike's dialogue during the Turtle Titan episode.

MikeandRaph87
04-03-2012, 03:59 PM
After reading the latest FF scripts, its nice to see some cringeworthy dialogue and useless belching scenes removed.

At the same time, how did some of it still make it into episodes? In the wrestling episode, Raph says "Cowabunga" after knocking down Triple Threat. How the hell did that get past Peter Laird? He even removes that line from a different episode.

I also can't believe he didn't have them re-write Mike's dialogue during the Turtle Titan episode.

Come on,dude,Cowabunga says it all!:D

If he did not focus all the humor on Michelangelo it would have been better.

TheSkeletonMan939
04-03-2012, 05:05 PM
After reading the latest FF scripts, its nice to see some cringeworthy dialogue and useless belching scenes removed.

At the same time, how did some of it still make it into episodes? In the wrestling episode, Raph says "Cowabunga" after knocking down Triple Threat. How the hell did that get past Peter Laird? He even removes that line from a different episode.

I also can't believe he didn't have them re-write Mike's dialogue during the Turtle Titan episode.

Because the morons at 4Kids think their jokes are funny.

THEY ARE NOT. FF and BttS are considered the weakest seasons because of their terrible jokes and plotless storylines.

There's a reason that they aired FF and BttS more often and I think that's because PL had little influence on them and therefore 4Kids thought it was better because it was, in essence, 95% 4Kids written.

stormbringer
04-03-2012, 05:22 PM
Because the morons at 4Kids think their jokes are funny.

THEY ARE NOT. FF and BttS are considered the weakest seasons because of their terrible jokes and plotless storylines.

There's a reason that they aired FF and BttS more often and I think that's because PL had little influence on them and therefore 4Kids thought it was better because it was, in essence, 95% 4Kids written.

Well clearly 4Kids was correct, since FF and BttS lasted so many seasons. Oh wait a minute....:P

CyberCubed
04-03-2012, 10:01 PM
There's a reason that they aired FF and BttS more often and I think that's because PL had little influence on them and therefore 4Kids thought it was better because it was, in essence, 95% 4Kids written.

Plotless storylines? The hell? Fast Forward had a very clear narrative and cohesive story arc. They didn't get to finish the Darius/Dark Turtle arc but everything else was properly done.

I always found it laughable the way some people act like FF had no continuity or no plot, when in reality it was just as narrative driven as the past 5 seasons.

The Big Bad
04-07-2012, 12:27 PM
Hooray! Finally, we get to see Darius Dun's complete character model--I was starting to believe we wouldn't see it. It's interesting to compare it with the model Boardman had shown some years back; coloring aside, it's nearly identical, except you can see how it's been streamlined to fit the Fast Forward aesthetic by removing the various clothing folds.

http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y1/Perez85/DariusDunbyJoseAndresVelasco.gif
http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y1/Perez85/DariusDun02.jpg

Xav
04-07-2012, 04:25 PM
Plotless storylines? The hell? Fast Forward had a very clear narrative and cohesive story arc. They didn't get to finish the Darius/Dark Turtle arc but everything else was properly done.

I always found it laughable the way some people act like FF had no continuity or no plot, when in reality it was just as narrative driven as the past 5 seasons.
No it wasn't as narrative driven. It didn't even have one multi-part episode.

MikeandRaph87
04-07-2012, 04:28 PM
No it wasn't. It didn't even have one multi-part episode.

True ,however both had not just episode length plots but season long ones as well. Fastforward especially had multiple ongoing plots. I do not love it but it has some good points to it as well.

CyberCubed
04-07-2012, 04:31 PM
No it wasn't. It didn't even have one multi-part episode.

What does not having multipart episodes have anything to do with a season long story arc?

Xav
04-07-2012, 04:38 PM
But it didn't just have one story arc, it was all over place.

CyberCubed
04-07-2012, 05:16 PM
But it didn't just have one story arc, it was all over place.

I doubt you remember FF at all because it had at least 3-4 continuing plotlines that went throughout the season. It of course had standalone episodes but to say there was no continuity is false.

Xav
04-07-2012, 05:38 PM
Yes I do remember Fast Forward. That's my whole point it had multiple continuing plotlines, not one single story arc, and I never said it had "no" continuity just not as much as some of the other seasons.

CyberCubed
04-07-2012, 10:37 PM
Yes I do remember Fast Forward. That's my whole point it had multiple continuing plotlines, not one single story arc, and I never said it had "no" continuity just not as much as some of the other seasons.

Seasons 3-4 also had multiple story arcs. I really don't get what you're trying to say here, Fast Forward wasn't just a bunch of random episodes with no continuity and no plots.

The only eps I'd say are like that were the 3 Triple Threat episodes, but everything else was neatly tied together.

Xav
04-07-2012, 11:41 PM
I never said it had no continuity and no plots. Stop putting words in my mouth. It definitely wasn't as narrative driven as season 5, which was pretty much one big story arc.

CyberCubed
04-08-2012, 01:19 AM
THEY ARE NOT. FF and BttS are considered the weakest seasons because of their terrible jokes and plotless storylines

^ This was your comment. They definitely do not have plotless storylines.

Xav
04-08-2012, 03:08 AM
My name is not "TheSkeletonMan939"

TheSkeletonMan939
04-08-2012, 09:39 AM
^ This was your comment. They definitely do not have plotless storylines.

When I say "plotless" I mean it's just a mix of bad jokes and predictable outcomes. The only reason I forced myself to watch FF was because I wanted to see every episode of the series. There definitely was a story in each ep, but it felt bland and tedious.

CyberCubed
04-08-2012, 11:07 AM
When I say "plotless" I mean it's just a mix of bad jokes and predictable outcomes. The only reason I forced myself to watch FF was because I wanted to see every episode of the series. There definitely was a story in each ep, but it felt bland and tedious.

The entire series has bad jokes. And some of FF's episodes rank up there with some of the best of the entire series.

The only eps of FF that were truly a chore were the 3 Triple Threat episodes, all the others ranged from either average to very good.

Xav
04-08-2012, 11:24 AM
And some of FF's episodes rank up there with some of the best of the entire series.
That's your opinion. I think it may be my least favorite season of the show.

CyberCubed
04-08-2012, 11:37 AM
That's your opinion. I think it may be my least favorite season of the show.

I won't disagree that it was one of the weaker seasons, but it had many enjoyable episodes and a great rogues gallery.

Xav
04-08-2012, 06:19 PM
None of the villains seemed as good the modern ones.

CyberCubed
04-08-2012, 07:54 PM
None of the villains seemed as good the modern ones.

They were better than the secondary villains of the show. While Shredder, Hun, Karai, Baxter and Bishop were all the most fleshed out and best handled villains of the show, I can't say the same for the third tier villains.

Jester
04-08-2012, 08:06 PM
Yes, but how many "third tier villains" recur more than twice? The villains you mentioned are the only ones the I can even remember. Who are the 2nd....or even 3rd tier villains? Garbage Man? Malignius? Touch and Go? The Mob?

CyberCubed
04-08-2012, 08:11 PM
Yes, but how many "third tier villains" recur more than twice? The villains you mentioned are the only ones the I can even remember. Who are the 2nd....or even 3rd tier villains? Garbage Man? Malignius? Touch and Go? The Mob?

And Savanti, etc. They were just average at best characters to give the Turtles someone up fight outside of the Foot.

I think Shokonobo, Viral, Torbin Zixx, Boss Zukko, and the Inuwashi Gunjin were all well done characters.

Jammerhead and the Dark Turtles were average, nothing horrible but not too great.

I'd say the only bad FF villains were Triple Threat and that Adam Zeto guy from the collector episode.

MikeandRaph87
04-08-2012, 08:14 PM
And Savanti, etc. They were just average at best characters to give the Turtles someone up fight outside of the Foot.

I think Shokonobo, Viral, Torbin Zixx, Boss Zukko, and the Inuwashi Gunjin were all well done characters.

Jammerhead and the Dark Turtles were average, nothing horrible but not too great.

I'd say the only bad FF villains were Triple Threat and that Adam Zeto guy from the collector episode.

The Inuwasi Gunjin were not villains they were just misunderstood and Torbin Zixx was an Anti-hero opposed to a villain.


There were weak villains spread out throughout the series not just from one stretch of it. Any show is like that.

CyberCubed
04-08-2012, 08:18 PM
Well most villains were connected to the Foot. And then you had the rankings of the Foot, Foot Tech Ninja, Elite Guard, Mystic Foot, Foot Gunners, Hun and Khan.

I will also forever believe Khan was one of the Elite Guards unless something in these development scripts reveals otherwise.

MikeandRaph87
04-08-2012, 08:29 PM
Well most villains were connected to the Foot. And then you had the rankings of the Foot, Foot Tech Ninja, Elite Guard, Mystic Foot, Foot Gunners, Hun and Khan.

I will also forever believe Khan was one of the Elite Guards unless something in these development scripts reveals otherwise.

The main villains were. Its going to always be like that. There will be a few that are not but a bulk will always be. In this show Bishop, and the rivials Prime Leader Zandramon and General Blanque I would argue were. Rat King and Dregg in the other show not connected to Shredder in some way.

Jester
04-08-2012, 08:55 PM
Can't believe I forgot the Ultimate Ninja and Draco.

I liked Zixx, the IG, Darius,Viral and the Dark Turtles, especially DNA is Thicker Than Water, which I feel is the best >> episode and one of the better episodes of the series. Not a huge fan of Shokonobo and the other one or 2 off villains though.

CyberCubed
04-10-2012, 02:38 PM
The cartoons have always had a problem finding a Shredder replacement. The old show tried with Lord Dregg, Season 4 tried with Karai and Bishop, Season 6 with Shokonobo...and then they just went back to Cyber Shredder.

Overall Shoko'nobo was a pretty good main villain for FF. I loved how he was like an alien version of Clayface.

Killer Moth
04-30-2012, 03:39 PM
Speaking of "DNA Is Thicker...," the recently released first draft has this exchange between Mike and Dark Mike:

"ON MIKEY/DARK MIKEY – charging. Mikey jumps over Dark Mikey. Dark Mikey stops - confused! Dark Mikey turns around.
ON MIKEY – he smirks, waves, and extends his left arm OFF-CAM.
MICHELANGELO (O/C)
Over here!
Mikey speaks out of the corner of his mouth (ala ventriloquism) as CAM PANS the length of Mikey’s left arm REVEALING he has EYES painted on his hand and is doing a Senor Wences-style DUMMY.
MICHELANGELO
(in a high-pitched voice)
No…over here!
D. MIKEY looks BACK/FORTH between Mikey and his hand - CONFUSED.
DARK MICHELANGELO
Aargh! What manner of SORCERY IS this?"

Laird's response is what anyone would expect:

Oh. My. God.

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/04/blast-from-past-526-re-140-dna-is.html

I know it's bad and shouldn't have been done, at all, yet I can't stop grinning.

BubblyShell22
04-30-2012, 04:56 PM
Yeah, I couldn't stop grinning at that little bit either. That was funny.

Xav
04-30-2012, 07:06 PM
The cartoons have always had a problem finding a Shredder replacement. The old show tried with Lord Dregg, Season 4 tried with Karai and Bishop, Season 6 with Shokonobo...and then they just went back to Cyber Shredder. Though Karai in season 4 did become the Shredder.

TurtleTitan97
04-30-2012, 07:16 PM
Speaking of "DNA Is Thicker...," the recently released first draft has this exchange between Mike and Dark Mike:

"ON MIKEY/DARK MIKEY – charging. Mikey jumps over Dark Mikey. Dark Mikey stops - confused! Dark Mikey turns around.
ON MIKEY – he smirks, waves, and extends his left arm OFF-CAM.
MICHELANGELO (O/C)
Over here!
Mikey speaks out of the corner of his mouth (ala ventriloquism) as CAM PANS the length of Mikey’s left arm REVEALING he has EYES painted on his hand and is doing a Senor Wences-style DUMMY.
MICHELANGELO
(in a high-pitched voice)
No…over here!
D. MIKEY looks BACK/FORTH between Mikey and his hand - CONFUSED.
DARK MICHELANGELO
Aargh! What manner of SORCERY IS this?"

Laird's response is what anyone would expect:

Oh. My. God.

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/04/blast-from-past-526-re-140-dna-is.html

I know it's bad and shouldn't have been done, at all, yet I can't stop grinning.

:tlol: That was funny. Dark Mikey's line there reminded me of Hudson's line from Disney's Gargolyes.

Killer Moth
04-30-2012, 07:17 PM
Yeah, I couldn't stop grinning at that little bit either. That was funny.

It was Dark Mike's reaction that really sealed the deal for me. Heh.

Anyway, I forgot to include this in my previous post, as our young, hip generation may not have heard of Senor Wences:

uEio4rQDU5A

S'alright? S'alright.

Killer Moth
05-10-2012, 04:08 PM
(Apologies for the double post, but I had to share this.)

The recently released "Day of Awakening" first draft contains a rather interesting insult Serling would have had for Viral:

"TURTLE X/SERLING LANDS between Cody and Viral.
SERLING
Have at thee, harlot!"

Laird's reaction:

"Have at thee, harlot"? WTF??!!! Why is Serling suddenly spouting pseudo-Shakespearianisms and calling Viral a whore? VERY weird.

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/05/blast-from-past-532-re-huge-mouser.html

Have fun with this one. Here is to hoping no writer would do the same thing with trollop or hussy in the new Nicktoon. :trolleye:

Xav
05-13-2012, 04:30 PM
Hey we get a look at the lost Forward episodes.
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/05/february-1-2007-re-here-we-go-again.html

CyberCubed
05-15-2012, 01:19 AM
Seems like we didn't miss much. Ch'rell returned in Turtles Forever anyway, the Serling ep was saved in BTTS, and "Master Fighter" has the completed animatic we saw. Lastly the final ep is very similar to what we get in BTTS' first episode.

Some of those story ideas are really stupid. Constable Biggles reprogrammed to arrest the Turtles? Darius Dunn building evil Turtle robots to attack the Dark Turtles with?

The only story I like is the one where Baxter gets a new human body, for obvious reasons.

TheSkeletonMan939
05-15-2012, 05:08 AM
Reading these FF scripts shows that the people at 4Kids are complete idiots when it comes to writing a basic story.

Jester
05-15-2012, 05:20 AM
Wait...Leatherhead transfering his essence into a Utrom...What. The. Heck.

BubblyShell22
05-15-2012, 08:35 AM
I laughed at Serling's line. That just made me laugh. They probably thought that since he's British, they'd have him quote Shakespeare.

oldmanwinters
05-15-2012, 10:38 AM
Oooo, Triceraton Shredder has a pretty awesome profile:
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/05/blast-from-past-537-february-13-2007-re.html

Xav
05-15-2012, 11:02 AM
Seems like we didn't miss much. Ch'rell returned in Turtles Forever anyway, the Serling ep was saved in BTTS, and "Master Fighter" has the completed animatic we saw. Lastly the final ep is very similar to what we get in BTTS' first episode. I don't see how the final ep is similar to the first BTTS episode, other than the fact that the turtles return home.

MikeandRaph87
05-15-2012, 11:11 AM
Chr'ell was the Shredder again here in a facehugger situation of a Triceraton correct?

CyberCubed
05-15-2012, 12:45 PM
Yes originally Ch'rell was to return in FF. I am glad it didn't happen, saving his return for the finale of the show was much more epic.

As I said, the only story I wish we got was seeing Baxter get a new human body.

Killer Moth
05-16-2012, 04:56 PM
Oooo, Triceraton Shredder has a pretty awesome profile:
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/05/blast-from-past-537-february-13-2007-re.html

Indeed, except his rather distracting Triceraton-designed shoulder pads. Might be a tad problematic in animating fight scenes with them, but maybe not. They still look cool, nevertheless. And between the actual helmet and the chest armor, it's FTW, right there.

Not sure what to make of Leatherhead as an Utrom. I could see it, as Mirage canon has him tied with them, but it's hard to see a brusier gator mutant become that. If they really wanted to, and before Baxter's body was about to be restored, the "Character X becomes an Utrom" would have been perfect for him. If not as a callback to Laird's second movie plotbunny, then to Baxter's temporary use of an Utrom exo-suit in "City At War." That really would have made for some fun and distant foreshadowing.

Then again, 2003 Baxter deserved a happier ending and to be whole again, so it's just as well if they didn't. Just thinking out loud.

Killer Moth
05-23-2012, 06:26 PM
Laird released the second draft with the Triceraton Shredder intro episode, today (apparently, he didn't get the first draft, at the time, so he posted what he had, instead):

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/05/blast-from-past-539-february-24-2007-re.html

Also includes the Ch'rell facehugger art that mikeandraph mentioned. Enjoy.

oldmanwinters
05-23-2012, 08:00 PM
Laird released the second draft with the Triceraton Shredder intro episode, today (apparently, he didn't get the first draft, at the time, so he posted what he had, instead):

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/05/blast-from-past-539-february-24-2007-re.html

Also includes the Ch'rell facehugger art that mikeandraph mentioned. Enjoy.

Wow!

Yeah... Triceraton Shredder = cool, Ch'rell facehugger Triceraton Shredder = not so much.

Xav
05-23-2012, 08:05 PM
I guess this means TMNT4Kids wasn't joking after all.

CyberCubed
05-23-2012, 08:13 PM
Its interesting to see they already had almost completed scripts for new FF episodes before they abandoned them.

At least we know none of them had completed animation, as "Master Fighter 2105" was the first episode and it still only had only a completed animatric but it wasn't animated.

MikeandRaph87
05-23-2012, 08:17 PM
How many Fastforward "Season 2" episodes were there before it was scrapped?

Xav
05-23-2012, 08:52 PM
There were 10.

CyberCubed
05-23-2012, 09:57 PM
How many Fastforward "Season 2" episodes were there before it was scrapped?

One of them wound up being the Serling episode from BTTS, they salvaged that one for some reason.

"Master Fighter 2105" has a completed animatic with VA but no completed animation.

Keep in mind the other episodes were only in script form, they never even recorded voice work for them before they were abandoned.

Xav
05-25-2012, 04:54 AM
Now I know why Ch'rell jumped on Raph's head in Secret Origins. He was trying to take control of his body!

Killer Moth
05-26-2012, 04:31 PM
Today, Laird released more of the Triceraton Shredder intro script, however, this bit from another episode draft has my attention:

"EXT. ALIEN ALLEY. MAO-TRON'S DUMPLING HOUSE - CONTINUOUS
Mikey pulls up to this modest store, indicated by HOLO-SIGNAGE of a TENTACLED ALIEN stir-frying happy-looking dumplings.
MIKEY - rubs his hands together as he takes a deep whiff.
*MIKEY
<SNIFFFFF>Breathe in the deep fried goodness, bros! Mao-Tron's Teriaki Tentacle Tempura two-fer Tuesdays! "

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/05/blast-from-past-540-march-1-2007-re.html

Laird's response:

I don't know if this was intentional or not, but naming this restaurant "Mao-Tron's" makes me think of a robotic Mao Tse-Tung. Maybe we could get in a few sly references to the old Chairman, like maybe the menus could look like little red books, or Mikey could say at the end of his lines above "It's like a cultural revolution... in your mouth!"

Make of it what you will, because I don't know what to think of the above. Enjoy.

Jester
06-09-2012, 09:18 AM
Some stuff about Back to the Sewer was posted:
*Peter wanted Cyber Shredder to hack Nano to enter the "real" world. Kinda like that idea, since I actually really grew to like Nano.
*Peter wanted Serling (or a new bot built from Serling plans) in BTTS. I think a built from scratch new Serling would have been better, he could have been less pompous and there wouldn't be the "Cody's alone in the future filled with evil uncles and Turtle clones." hole.
*Hun as Shredder...as part of the Shredder Wars...which they had planned. Crap, why did BttS have to only last 13 really filler filled episodes?

oldmanwinters
06-09-2012, 10:31 AM
Too bad Peter Laird's ideas weren't given a little more weight for the later seasons. But at least we know that he didn't just ignore the drafts he received.

Crap, why did BttS have to only last 13 really filler filled episodes?

Now that you mention it, that whole season pretty much consisted of filler episodes. Odd. Wasted opportunity.

It's been a while since I watched them all. About how many plot essential episodes do you think that season consisted of between Tempus Fugit and Wedding Bells and Bytes?

Jester
06-09-2012, 05:41 PM
It's been a while since I watched them all. About how many plot essential episodes do you think that season consisted of between Tempus Fugit and Wedding Bells and Bytes?
Let's see:
S7, Ep1: Tempus Fugit. Essential, sets up the season as a whole.

S7, Ep2: Karate Schooled. Essential, introduces Khan.

S7, Ep3: Something Wicked. Essential, first episode where the Turtles face Cyber Shredder.

S7, Ep4: The Engagement Ring. Essential, furthers Casey and April's plot, leads to the wedding.

S7, Ep5: Hacking Stockman. Essential, features Shredder invading Stockman. Just awesome.

S7, Ep6: Incredible Shrinking Serling. Filler.

S7, Ep7: Identity Crisis. Essential, Khan hacks the Turtles to do the Foot's bidding.

S7, Ep8: Web Wranglers. Essential, Shredder's attempts to become corporal seen.

S7, Ep9: SuperQuest. 1/2 and 1/2, it has the Turtles looking for data bits, in Mikey's favorite MMORPG.

S7, Ep10: Virtual Reality Check. Not sure, but it's just virtual Bad Day rip-off.

S7, Ep11: City Under Siege. Not sure, Shredder pulls a page out of FW Shredder's play book and control of the cities electronic stuff...FOR EVIL!!!

S7, Ep12: Super Power Struggle. SOOOO MUCH FILLER! Sorry, I hate this useless episode.

S7, Ep13: Wedding Bells and Bytes. Essential, series finale. April and Casey's wedding, Splinter back, and Shredder defeated.


So....surprisingly, a lot more is essential than I thought. Only 2 episodes are pure filler, and a couple are kinda sorta filler.

Cipher
06-09-2012, 05:57 PM
I don't think that's quite fair, Jester. Sure, most episodes seemed to introduce ... some kinda something, but how often was the plot of Shredder almost becoming corporeal recycled, with little buildup to the actual moment?

I remember as it was airing, everyone was predicting, "Man, this'll be the episode where Shredder gets out so we can get the real plot going."

And that was a totally fair prediction, because every episode felt like it was treading water and we kept being teased with the Shredder becoming real and a big threat gearing up for the rest of the season. Man, remember what a watershed episode Web Wranglers was going to be? Halfway through the season and time for a big change-up? A description that implied major catastrophe and the return of the Shredder? And then everything reset and it continued to tease you with the idea that the Shredder might kinda sorta do something in the near future.

It ... didn't really happen. And then it did, and he promptly seemed to die. And then he came back for about ten minutes in the season finale to attack a bunch of cameos and be quickly wiped from the Earth again.

The majority of the series is a painful cycle of the Turtles gathering data bits and the same, looming threat almost happening.

Back to the Sewer is all about treading water for 13 episodes to sell toys that never hit shelves.

EDIT --

Weird how Lloyd Goldfine was apparently tuned into the fact most of the fanbase disliked Nano. Did kids dislike him too?

EDIT EDIT --

"<<LG: Let us mull this one over. There might be some fun in the following: someone is rebuilding the foot organization. Meanwhile the Turtles learn of the CyberShredder. They ASSUME that it’s CyberShredder that’s putting the Foot organization back together, but --SURPRISE SHOCKER!-- it’s Hun, who’s dubbed himself the new Shredder!>>"

Man, that alone is a more interesting and fully realized dynamic than anything explored in the actual series. And both Laird and Goldfine were on board for this? What the hell, man.

The Big Bad
06-10-2012, 06:13 AM
I'm actually really glad "Hun becomes the Shredder" never came to pass. It seems out of place, given his character trajectory until that point. Plus, it'd been established he doesn't really give a damn about the Foot Clan itself, so why would he take on their master's identity?

Some stuff about Back to the Sewer was posted:
*Peter wanted Cyber Shredder to hack Nano to enter the "real" world. Kinda like that idea, since I actually really grew to like Nano.
*Peter wanted Serling (or a new bot built from Serling plans) in BTTS. I think a built from scratch new Serling would have been better, he could have been less pompous and there wouldn't be the "Cody's alone in the future filled with evil uncles and Turtle clones." hole.

It's time travel. There's nothing preventing Serling from returning to the future a second after he left it, even if he spends years in the past, especially since the time window has apparently been perfected and can be rebuilt. While Cody very well could have been left alone for X period of time, there's no evidence supporting that particular scenario over any other potential one.

Powder
06-10-2012, 05:01 PM
I'm actually really glad "Hun becomes the Shredder" never came to pass. It seems out of place, given his character trajectory until that point. Plus, it'd been established he doesn't really give a damn about the Foot Clan itself, so why would he take on their master's identity?

Probably because he's a brute with an ego who loves having authority over a mass of thugs. Makes sense to an extent.

BAXTER STOCKMAN 19
06-11-2012, 08:14 AM
Probably because he's a brute with an ego who loves having authority over a mass of thugs. Makes sense to an extent.

If Nick wants then Hun can become Shredder in Nick show . Some of the ideas that they have for another season of 2003 series, can be used in the Nick show if nicks wants it.

Powder
06-11-2012, 02:14 PM
How very kind of you to give them your permission.

TobTurn
06-25-2012, 05:24 PM
Ha, this part made me laugh:

13.) Re: the following:

"LEO
It' s Ninja Time!"

No.

MikeandRaph87
06-25-2012, 05:42 PM
Ha, this part made me laugh:

13.) Re: the following:

"LEO
It' s Ninja Time!"

No.

I am currently rewatching the entire series and am up to The Journal. It seems as if Cody says it to make him think he is cool and then after some time the turtles say it. If it was just Cody it would be fine but not the turtles.

oldmanwinters
07-21-2012, 11:24 AM
Laird is starting post his early notes on the Turtles Forever project!
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/07/blast-from-past-561-february-5-2008.html

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/07/blast-from-past-568-may-5-2008re-tmnt.html

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/07/blast-from-past-569-june-4-2008-p-laird.html

MrPliggins
07-22-2012, 09:54 AM
I like how Peter suggested using the COOTS Turtles in the montage sequence. Did they end up being used?

Killer Moth
07-22-2012, 08:59 PM
Nice to know he actually did have Slash and Tokka in mind for Hun's mutation. Awesome.

But the real reason for the post:

And while I'm on the subject... when I think back to the old '88 show, I keep hearing in my mind Krang's whiny/burpy voice calling for "Saki" (typically spoken in a drawn-out fashion like this -- "Saaaakiii") when he addressed the '88 Shredder. I think we should have him do that at least once in this project.

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/07/blast-from-past-568-may-5-2008re-tmnt.html

I haven't seen the uncut version in a while, yet I don't recall Forever Krang ever saying "Saki." (Or did he and I missed it?) If so, it is a shame it got dropped, but good for Laird for remembering it. I never did understood why that trait of Krang's was dropped after the original mini-series or first season ended. Oh, well.

ChromeDome
07-23-2012, 09:32 AM
From what I can remember Krang only refers to Shredder as Saki in the first season of the 1987 series, afterwards he calls him Shredder. Although I maybe mistaken.

I know that in Turtle Tracks, Krang asks for Shredder to come and see him and calls him Saki, but Shredder insists that Krang call him Shredder.

Xav
07-24-2012, 06:33 PM
Why do they keep calling the Fred Wolf show and the characters from it 88, when the show premiered in 87?

Galactus
07-24-2012, 06:36 PM
Why do they keep calling the Fred Wolf show and the characters from it 88, when the show premiered in 87?

TMNT4Kids that used to post here did give a reason though for the life of me I can't remember what it was.

Xav
07-24-2012, 06:44 PM
88' just rolls off the tongue easier I guess.
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showpost.php?p=700518&postcount=1972

Genesis
07-24-2012, 10:21 PM
It premiered in like, December, so it might as well have been 1988, I guess. Plus, the point of the cartoon was to market the toys, which didn't appear until '88, so it makes sense, either way.

Xav
08-01-2012, 11:23 PM
Laird's now posting emails from early on in the deployment. I guess this pretty much proves that Utrom Shredder was planed early on.
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/blast-from-past-573-may-2-2002-re-new.html

CyberCubed
08-04-2012, 09:32 AM
So PL called Krang a, "bastardization of the old Utrom concept."

Its amazing how the guy didn't like how much Fred Wolf changed the characters from the comics, yet he goes ahead and gives the approval to turn Shredder into an Utrom right away.

It really doesn't make any sense. Its like if he doesn't have a direct hand in the changes, he seems to dislike them.

The Big Bad
08-04-2012, 01:55 PM
I don't see why that'd be so inconceivable: given his output, I think it's rather clear that Laird cares more for the Utrom concept than he does for the Shredder. Plus, Krang is a much more fundamental deviation from its original concept than the Utrom Shredder was--note that the toon got adaptations of all the major Shredder stories (including keeping the "Return to New York" money shot, which almost certainly couldn't have been adapted any other way), while Krang as he existed doesn't allow for any adaptations of the original Utrom stories, and his similarity to that one is almost entirely superficial.

oldmanwinters
08-04-2012, 04:02 PM
Reading through the last Laird-Lloyd email (http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/07/blast-from-past-572-june-23-2009-re-hey.html) regarding the TMNT show, I couldn't help but notice this and get all misty eyed.

In a message dated 7/22/09 4:20:02 AM, Lloyd writes:

Hey Pete –

...

Finally, as I suspected, I was laid-off earlier today (my last actual day is Friday – the ComicCon screening will be my last official Turtles’ duty). You and I already talked about all this, and I don’t wanna get all mushy in an e-mail, so just know that I hope we get to work together again sometime.

...

Thanks mucho amigo,

Lloyd

PS – I love(d) bein’ a Turtle!

I am convinced that without the involvement of Lloyd Goldfine, the 4Kids show would have been an absolute disaster from start to finish. I think he really possessed good communication skills and a creative mind; probably one of the best at the 4Kids operation. It's sad to think someone of his caliber was given the pink slip as soon as the cartoon was over. I know the whole company ended up folding not long after that, but it's still some tough lumps to stomach.

And even Laird noted:
the experience of working with you over the last seven (eight?) years has been great -- I'd definitely put it in my top five TMNT-related work experiences. You know, it's possible that you and I worked together on the show longer than Kevin and I worked together on the comics.



To change the subject a little...
given his output, I think it's rather clear that Laird cares more for the Utrom concept than he does for the Shredder.

I can only imagine how upset Peter Laird might have been if the Fred Wolf series had ever tried to use the Fugitoid character and alter him beyond recognition.

Speaking of which... that might be a good question for the next "Ask PL" segment (hoping there is one). :tgrin:

cartoonistaaron
08-04-2012, 04:17 PM
Reading this stuff, I get the sense that Laird was a much bigger fan of the sci-fi elements of the TMNT than Kevin Eastman, who seems to be more into the street-fight / martial arts / more earthbound stuff.

I'm re-watching the 4Kids TMNT show from the first episode on, and while I liked most of the Utrom stuff, I still think the Shredder as a character was weakened incredibly by having him be nothing more than an evil Utrom. I think it would have been a much more interesting development (and a way to fix a plot point in the Mirage comics that I never liked) if the Shredder had been much the same character as in the Mirage comics, and met the same fate as that Shredder, but was then found and pieced back together by the Utroms (similar to how they found and nursed Splinter back to life).

The whole "Bishop" character just isn't clicking for me. Is he a pissed-off evil guy? Or does he just want to capture the Turtles and dissect them?

Genesis
08-04-2012, 04:37 PM
I still think the Shredder as a character was weakened incredibly by having him be nothing more than an evil human.See how easy it is to turn on its head? Being just an evil anything makes for some lacking dynamism. I like the Shredder either way - evil for no good reason or given a legit backstory for it; Utrom or human - but your alternative idea is very interesting.

The whole "Bishop" character just isn't clicking for me. Is he a pissed-off evil guy? Or does he just want to capture the Turtles and dissect them?He's a badass; that is all you need to know. Seriously, though, I didn't much like him, at first. Maybe he'll grow on you, too.

Killer Moth
08-04-2012, 06:01 PM
The whole "Bishop" character just isn't clicking for me. Is he a pissed-off evil guy? Or does he just want to capture the Turtles and dissect them?

If you read the old emails, Laird and Goldfine did converse at length on what motivations Bishop had or should have. Unlike most of the villains, when the motivation were clear enough, "is Bishop, a true villain or an anti-hero or anti-villain?" The show could be inconsistent like that, but at least the writers did acknowledge it, as they were trying to figure which direction to go with the character.

As for the "Krang bastardization" part, I personally view Krang as a compromise, as to be, at most, a visual nod to the Utrom design, yet allowed to forge his own evil identity, as until the 2000's, Utroms weren't meant to be antagonists, anyway. However, the Big Bad is right in how protective Laird is of the Utrom concept -- which I never realized until now -- whereas, he was fine with revising the Shredder for the get-go. Is it considered a double standard with his characters vs. others, or some characters, while liking them, are allowed to be changed, and legitimately believing he or she would be better off for the change? (Some characters work better as being revamped, and some work better at their relative status quo.) Who inspired the Shredder, as who had more influence on the character? I forget the story, so feel free to remind me.

As for CyberCubed, "Laird disliking X or Y for not having more active creative control," a possible counterpoint could be implied with this interview in 2009:

http://thedailycrosshatch.com/2009/02/09/interview-peter-laird/

TV Tropes offers this as said counterpoint with the link (in the Lighter and Fluffer heading):

"Peter Laird said in an interview that, faced with the reality of needing to water down his creation for a younger audience, he largely let the show's staff do it for him. This may have been a wise choice on his part, as had he tried to do a more comic-accurate version in the face of the rigid censorship of The Eighties, it quite possibly would have come off as a total bastardization of the comics. As it was, it came off as an extremely loose adaptation but very entertaining when taken as its own entity."

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/WesternAnimation/TeenageMutantNinjaTurtles1987

Win some, lose some, right? Of course, had Laird waited until the 90's, maybe things would have changed. (Then again, look at Erik Larsen and his USA toon of Savage Dragon in 96.) Not that it mattered, as he finally had his chance in 2002, and here we are. Both are valid in their respective ways, so take what you can get.

cartoonistaaron
08-04-2012, 06:36 PM
I think so as far as letting the Fred Wolf show go its own way, I don't think Laird had the power to pull rank and demand creative control. Plus - Turtlemania was in full swing in the late '80s and early '90s, and I don't think Eastman and Laird would have had time to pore over scripts, along with all the other Turtle stuff they were dealing with.

For the 2k3 show, Laird had 20 years of Turtle success to support his demand for creative control (if it was a demand - it seems like 4kids hired the writer, and he was good enough to get Laird involved). And by then, Mirage had a CEO running things, so Laird had more time to work on something like reviewing cartoon scripts.

Regarding the Shredder - I thought the Mirage comics Shredder had a ton of potential and a very compelling back story, almost like a reverse Batman. He was a villain but he wasn't a straight-up "bad guy." I know why they changed him for the kiddie-fied 80s show. But changing him into a straight-up "bad guy" for the more sophisticated 2k3 show just seemed to make him less interesting. He's a robot body with a little alien in his stomach, and he's pissed off, and he's the baddest dude in town... Okay? But what motivates him? He's evil? That works for a straight-up lunatic, but the Shredder was very calculating in the first season. Afterwards, he turned into kind of a brainless bad guy. I felt like all that potential character development was wasted.

I dunno, turning him into an Utrom seemed to have been done just so all the characters could freak out over him being an Utrom.

Killer Moth
08-04-2012, 06:58 PM
I think so as far as letting the Fred Wolf show go its own way, I don't think Laird had the power to pull rank and demand creative control. Plus - Turtlemania was in full swing in the late '80s and early '90s, and I don't think Eastman and Laird would have had time to pore over scripts, along with all the other Turtle stuff they were dealing with.

For the 2k3 show, Laird had 20 years of Turtle success to support his demand for creative control (if it was a demand - it seems like 4kids hired the writer, and he was good enough to get Laird involved). And by then, Mirage had a CEO running things, so Laird had more time to work on something like reviewing cartoon scripts.

Regarding the Shredder - I thought the Mirage comics Shredder had a ton of potential and a very compelling back story, almost like a reverse Batman. He was a villain but he wasn't a straight-up "bad guy." I know why they changed him for the kiddie-fied 80s show. But changing him into a straight-up "bad guy" for the more sophisticated 2k3 show just seemed to make him less interesting. He's a robot body with a little alien in his stomach, and he's pissed off, and he's the baddest dude in town... Okay? But what motivates him? He's evil? That works for a straight-up lunatic, but the Shredder was very calculating in the first season. Afterwards, he turned into kind of a brainless bad guy. I felt like all that potential character development was wasted.

I dunno, turning him into an Utrom seemed to have been done just so all the characters could freak out over him being an Utrom.

I agree with all of that, to start with.

But wasn't the whole thing with Mona Lisa, because of the "no female Turtles" edict, and that forced Eastman and Laird's involvement (re-design her and then abandon her), even when they long since left the series? Unique circumstances aside, you're right, as both men had their attentions focused on their empire, but as per Mona Lisa, they could force themselves to step in, if need be. And the irony to the Mona Lisa incident is that the fandom or enough of it rather digs her (including myself), to this day. You never know.

You're right, as Laird gained more experience about the licensing business, and with Gary Richardson eventually appearing as Mirage CEO, he would have had more time to be more involved.

And you sum up nicely my present issues with 2003 Shredder. I long got over the Utrom revision, but "why should I care if you win?" Unlike the other villains (Karai, Bishop, Chaplin, Baxter, Hun), one can identity with them. After the Utrom reveal after the excellent Season 1 build-up, Utrom Shredder essentially became a living prop (in my opinion, so feel free to correct me or inform me otherwise). Now, he's very competent at what he does, but is that enough? 87 Shredder had his problems, but as noted in other threads, he proved to be an actual character while doing his villainy. Don't have to agree or like with what was done to him, but he was a character, alright.

Then again, one could say that about Mirage Shredder, but between his backstory, motivations (avenging his brother), his overall legacy and paucity of appearances, it balances out. Harder to do over many seasons and Ch'rell's character is more or less constant. Which is interesting, as Mirage in the 2000's was all about changing or progressing their iconic characters, both in form and personality.

MikeandRaph87
08-04-2012, 07:26 PM
To further your point Moth, there is also the incident with Man Ray/Ray. Laird and Eastman stepped in again in 1991 when Man Ray was going to be the gnetic experiment stooge of a mad scientist in Rebel Without A Fin. They did not want the character depicted as evil but did not care when the less memorable Zack And The Alien Invaders made Wingnut was Screwloose's lacky hypnoizing boys as thier personal army. Leatherhead was the most diversely portrayed character and still is within the franchise best remembered for the cajun bully from the Florida swamp portrayal.

The problem with making Shredder a renagade utrom is it makes fans even if knowing better think Shredder and Krang melded into one character. Its far from intended but what it ultimatly comes across and makes me feel that we did not have an actual Shredder but variants of the character.

Jester
08-04-2012, 07:37 PM
To further your point Moth, there is also the incident with Man Ray/Ray. Laird and Eastman stepped in again in 1991 when Man Ray was going to be the gnetic experiment stooge of a mad scientist in Rebel Without A Fin.
I think it was more Ryan Brown's fighting to keep his creation from being bastardized than Eastman and Laird putting their foot down.

Killer Moth
08-04-2012, 07:47 PM
To further your point Moth, there is also the incident with Man Ray/Ray. Laird and Eastman stepped in again in 1991 when Man Ray was going to be the gnetic experiment stooge of a mad scientist in Rebel Without A Fin. They did not want the character depicted as evil but did not care when the less memorable Zack And The Alien Invaders made Wingnut was Screwloose's lacky hypnoizing boys as thier personal army. Leatherhead was the most diversely portrayed character and still is within the franchise best remembered for the cajun bully from the Florida swamp portrayal.

The problem with making Shredder a renagade utrom is it makes fans even if knowing better think Shredder and Krang melded into one character. Its far from intended but what it ultimatly comes across and makes me feel that we did not have an actual Shredder but variants of the character.

I recall Ryan Brown stepping in with Man Ray, but I didn't know if Eastman/Laird were involved, as well. (I remembered it, but I didn't post on it originally, because I didn't think it was germane, as I thought that didn't involve Eastman/Laird.) Although, Ray, as a character, had a nice nonchalant attitude and proved that having all the abilities of sea life at your physical command isn't so lame, either.

Ironically, 87 version is my least favorite of Leatherhead, mainly for lack of nuance, I suppose. Though, his Southern-ism was a nice touch. Win some, lose some, and Archie did a good job with him in the end.

Someone on the TMNT Entity blog, had a nice snarky comment that 2003 Shredder was made to be like Krang, and Mirage Shredder was made to be like Wyrm. But was the change worth it for the character's sake or for the sake of change itself?

It's all easy to muse such things, as hindsight is 20/20 or whatever. Laird and Eastman both made their share of calls, good or bad, going with what they knew at the time. Had to do something right, even if they did make their share of mistakes along the way. Wonder how the Turtlemania would have been like or what the media products would have been, had Eastman and Laird knew then what they know now.

Edit: Read Jester's post after my posting, so until I get direct evidence otherwise, I'd just presume it was all on Brown's part. Or, after seeing Eastman and Laird doing it with the Mona Lisa episode, he better follow suit or, in all likelihood, would have stepped in, anyway?

oldmanwinters
08-04-2012, 07:56 PM
I'd just presume it was all on Brown's part. Or, after seeing Eastman and Laird doing it with the Mona Lisa episode, he better follow suit or, in all likelihood, would have stepped in, anyway?

What do you mean about E&L and the Mona Lisa episode?

Jester
08-04-2012, 08:00 PM
What do you mean about E&L and the Mona Lisa episode?
It's been rumored that originally Mona Lisa was to be a female Turtle, but Eastman and laird had that changed to a lizard.

oldmanwinters
08-04-2012, 08:02 PM
It's been rumored that originally Mona Lisa was to be a female Turtle, but Eastman and laird had that changed to a lizard.

Ah, I'd be interested to see a source on that. It really does make a lot of sense though (Renaissance painters = male turtles, Renaissance artwork = female turtles). However, if that was indeed the original plan, then you'd think they would have written her into more episodes.

Killer Moth
08-04-2012, 08:05 PM
What do you mean about E&L and the Mona Lisa episode?

Mind you, this is internet rumor meme from memory (I think it was TV Tropes or Wikipedia, so take it with a grain of salt), and officially, I don't know if there is actual proof or if anyone asked Laird or Eastman, or what not. First, her design had to be changed to be less of a Turtle (which kinda explained how the character's action figure had a Turtle-like shell on her back) and then when the episode's climax set her to be a recurring character, she was eventually dropped completely.

Of course, you guys are the experts, so if I misread or just let a rumor gain traction by mistake, feel free to call me out on it. Because I would love to know, seriously.

Edit: Read the last two posts after posting this one. Whoops.

oldmanwinters
08-04-2012, 08:27 PM
Mind you, this is internet rumor meme from memory (I think it was TV Tropes or Wikipedia, so take it with a grain of salt), and officially, I don't know if there is actual proof or if anyone asked Laird or Eastman, or what not. First, her design had to be changed to be less of a Turtle (which kinda explained how the character's action figure had a Turtle-like shell on her back) and then when the episode's climax set her to be a recurring character, she was eventually dropped completely.

Of course, you guys are the experts, so if I misread or just let a rumor gain traction by mistake, feel free to call me out on it. Because I would love to know, seriously.

Edit: Read the last two posts after posting this one. Whoops.

Eh, I guess we'd just have to ask on the Mirage guys. Too bad Murphy's old blog has been forever wiped out of existence.

I never had a Mona Lisa action figure, so this is the first I've heard about a "turtle-like shell on her back." But I always thought the figure's mold looked a little "phoned in" or whatever. Maybe Playmates Toys just jerry-rigged that lizard tail on at the last minute?

Xav
08-04-2012, 08:58 PM
According to TMNTPedia it was revealed in the letters pages in volume 4, issue 18 that she was originally supposed to be a female mutant turtle.

oldmanwinters
08-04-2012, 09:25 PM
According to TMNTPedia it was revealed in the letters pages in volume 4, issue 18 that she was originally supposed to be a female mutant turtle.

Time for me to go check that out!

EDIT:
Ugh, I don't actually own a hard copy of that issue!

MikeandRaph87
08-04-2012, 09:26 PM
Ah, I'd be interested to see a source on that. It really does make a lot of sense though (Renaissance painters = male turtles, Renaissance artwork = female turtles). However, if that was indeed the original plan, then you'd think they would have written her into more episodes.

Um,I can confirm on that. I have no source because I cannot exstract it form my brain. I met Peter Laird, Ryan Brown ,and Dan Berger back at the Heroes Con in 2008 and that was one of the things I asked about. He said that "was supposed to be a female turtle and you know I fell about that" so I changed the subject to why not bring Shredder back every so often and making it look like he might be dead or might not situations like with The Joker.


As for Ryan Brown on Man Ray, I just assumed that one after I read it on the net four to five years ago...heck,it was probably here in my lurker days. Why would Ryan put his foot down though after Leatherhead was heavily tweaked? Was it because he heavily tweaked his own character around that same time into a human named Jess Harley by curse of an alien woman?

CyberCubed
08-04-2012, 09:46 PM
Yep, its indeed confirmed by Peter Laird that he had Mona Lisa changed from a mutant turtle to, "some type of lizard."

Good thing its in print in one of the Volume 4 issues, but I think someone asked him it on his blog and he replied with the same answer.

Newton Gimmick
08-05-2012, 12:49 AM
So PL called Krang a, "bastardization of the old Utrom concept."

Its amazing how the guy didn't like how much Fred Wolf changed the characters from the comics, yet he goes ahead and gives the approval to turn Shredder into an Utrom right away.

It really doesn't make any sense. Its like if he doesn't have a direct hand in the changes, he seems to dislike them.

Big Bad hit several of the points, but it's not really a slant on the Fred Wolf series from Laird. It's a pretty accurate statement, to be honest. Krang more or less was a bastardization of the Utrom concept. I really didn't see that as him bashing Krang, it's just mostly true.

Likewise Laird was trying to do something new and not a straight up redo, whereas the Fred Wolf stuff was so early on that it would have seemed more like unnecessary changes, but the 2K3 stuff was more like tweaks to old concepts.

As to Fred Wolf control versus 4Kids control, it was a lot more work for E&L to get anything changed on the OT and they rarely if ever cared. But when something like "let's make a 5th Turtle and it be a girl" they still had enough that they could step in and shut it down. Which according to Laird happened... A LOT!

:o

oldmanwinters
08-05-2012, 10:56 PM
Lloyd amuses me with his comments on the "Utrom Shredder":
While I really do love the creepy Shredder cranium transfer ritual stuff, I think one of the great things about making Shredder an Utrom is that he now becomes 80% exoskeleton, and that means we can chop his limbs off, toss him off a roof, blow him up, and most importantly.. we can have Leo slice his @#$%^&* head off his shoulders! If he becomes a series of "meatbags" that contain his brain, a lot of our fun gets spoiled, methinks!>>
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/blast-from-past-574-may-3-2002-re-new.html

BubblyShell22
08-06-2012, 07:49 AM
Yeah, that is funny and very true. As an Utrom, Shredder gets to receive more punishment than he would if he were just straight up human.

oldmanwinters
08-06-2012, 06:30 PM
Leonardo's bold line of dialogue in the opening of the first episode was going to be:
""We're not the ones about to get our butts beaten..."

Fortunately, Peter Laird sent that email to champion the classic "He's wrong. We're not wearing costumes!" bit.

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/blast-from-past-575may-9-2002-re.html

Killer Moth
08-13-2012, 04:26 PM
Laird did one of his "Ask PL" feature, a few days ago, and I see he answered your questions about Mona Lisa, Adam (just to wrap up the tangent):

Yes, Mona Lisa was originally planned to be a fifth Turtle, and it was one of the few times, sadly, that Kevin and I were in total accord and managed to put our foot (feet?) down and get her changed into some other type of creature.

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/ask-pl-9.html?showComment=1344566375563#c7076745230356963 062

For a modern flavor, he also addressed why Klunk wasn't around for the middle 2003 seasons:

Well, I think Klunk just sort of disappeared during the fourth season and didn't show up again until "Back to the Sewers". In all seriousness, I can't remember exactly why Klunk wasn't in the series during the time in question. I suspect he was just not considered that important a plot element.

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/ask-pl-9.html?showComment=1344549115490#c7408594617692725 759

Questions asked, questions answered, right?

oldmanwinters
08-13-2012, 04:51 PM
Laird did one of his "Ask PL" feature, a few days ago, and I see he answered your questions about Mona Lisa, Adam (just to wrap up the tangent):

Yes, Mona Lisa was originally planned to be a fifth Turtle, and it was one of the few times, sadly, that Kevin and I were in total accord and managed to put our foot (feet?) down and get her changed into some other type of creature.

Yeah, man, I was so glad to finally get that confirmed. It is amazing that E&L banded together in solidarity to put their foot down against Playmates & FWF. I wonder if (Playmates and Fred Wolf Films) had big plans for the Mona Lisa character as originally envisioned. You would think a recurring female turtle would have been highly desired so as to theoretically increase the franchise's appeal among female viewers. It's interesting to wonder what could have been.

Killer Moth
08-16-2012, 05:22 PM
Yeah, man, I was so glad to finally get that confirmed. It is amazing that E&L banded together in solidarity to put their foot down against Playmates & FWF. I wonder if (Playmates and Fred Wolf Films) had big plans for the Mona Lisa character as originally envisioned. You would think a recurring female turtle would have been highly desired so as to theoretically increase the franchise's appeal among female viewers. It's interesting to wonder what could have been.

Same here. Glad you asked him. I viewed her episode, last week, and was quite impressed. Sure, she was technically a Mary Sue Love Interest character, yet she was surprisingly good (and her voice actor giving an excellent performance). While it is a shame nothing else could be done with her in 1990, the irony with the fandom liking her, 20 years later, is a pleasant side effect or blowback or what have you.

You do raise an interesting point about ML playing into the female demographic (and the same could be said of Venus). That should be a thread, as the issue is worthy of discussion.

Anyhoo, Laird had an interesting reply to someone asking on whether the Turtles count as superheroes or not:

It's not a dumb question at all. And, at first, I thought it would be an easy one to answer, at least the way I think of superheroes: If a character has no superhuman powers, that character is not a superhero.

But… I decided to check the definition online, at both dictionary.com and wikipedia.com. Here's what I found at the former:

"World English Dictionary
superhero (ˈsuːpəˌhɪərəʊ)

— n , pl -roes

any of various comic-strip characters with superhuman abilities or magical powers, wearing a distinctive costume, and fighting against evil

su·per·he·ro   [soo-per-heer-oh]
noun, plural su·per·he·roes.
a hero, especially in children's comic books and television cartoons, possessing extraordinary, often magical powers.

… and here's a relevant quote from the Wikipedia entry:

"By most definitions, characters do not strictly require actual superhuman powers to be deemed superheroes,[3] although terms such as costumed crime fighters are sometimes used to refer to those such as Batman and Green Arrow without such powers who share other common superhero traits. Such characters were generally referred to as "mystery men" in the so-called Golden Age of Comic Books to distinguish them from characters with super-powers."

So by my definition, the TMNT are not superheroes… but by other people's definition, they are.

Does that help? -- PL

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/ask-pl-9.html?showComment=1345063174150#c7777538234324609 006

Good question, in light of Nobody, Radical and the rest of them. Hmm.

oldmanwinters
08-16-2012, 06:05 PM
er the Turtles count as superheroes or not:

It's not a dumb question at all. And, at first, I thought it would be an easy one to answer, at least the way I think of superheroes: If a character has no superhuman powers, that character is not a superhero.

But… I decided to check the definition online, at both dictionary.com and wikipedia.com. Here's what I found at the former:

"World English Dictionary
superhero (ˈsuːpəˌhɪərəʊ)

— n , pl -roes

any of various comic-strip characters with superhuman abilities or magical powers, wearing a distinctive costume, and fighting against evil

su·per·he·ro   [soo-per-heer-oh]
noun, plural su·per·he·roes.
a hero, especially in children's comic books and television cartoons, possessing extraordinary, often magical powers.

… and here's a relevant quote from the Wikipedia entry:

"By most definitions, characters do not strictly require actual superhuman powers to be deemed superheroes,[3] although terms such as costumed crime fighters are sometimes used to refer to those such as Batman and Green Arrow without such powers who share other common superhero traits. Such characters were generally referred to as "mystery men" in the so-called Golden Age of Comic Books to distinguish them from characters with super-powers."

So by my definition, the TMNT are not superheroes… but by other people's definition, they are.

Does that help? -- PL

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/ask-pl-9.html?showComment=1345063174150#c7777538234324609 006

Good question, in light of Nobody, Radical and the rest of them. Hmm.


Those Turtles might be mutants, but they sure ain't no "Meta-Humans," that's fo' sure! :tlol:

Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
08-23-2012, 12:12 PM
Peter Laird goes over an email from Lloyd Goldfine about the infamous, never completed Season 5 episode, "Nightmares Recycled". Check it out!!

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/01/blast-from-past-359-february-26-2005.html?showComment=1345740856306#c5136115476730 070188

oldmanwinters
08-23-2012, 04:06 PM
Peter Laird goes over an email from Lloyd Goldfine about the infamous, never completed Season 5 episode, "Nightmares Recycled". Check it out!!

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/01/blast-from-past-359-february-26-2005.html?showComment=1345740856306#c5136115476730 070188

Heh... an oldie but a goodie.

For future reference, I've included an index of every episode discussed on the first few posts of this thread (though I have been lazy for the past few weeks). You might find some real archived info in that list.

Killer Moth
08-23-2012, 05:06 PM
Heh... an oldie but a goodie.

For future reference, I've included an index of every episode discussed on the first few posts of this thread (though I have been lazy for the past few weeks). You might find some real archived info in that list.

I can't wait for that list, whenever you have it completed. And Laird has been really active about the 2002 emails, lately, as his latest is the first Baxter episode script.

Plus, this caught my attention, as this apparently inspired "Notes from the Underground":

Goldfine said this:

"I’ve been thinking about the lair/underground story I asked you about in my previous e-mail and I think I’ve changed my view of it a bit. I still think it’s cool to have the genetically altered “monster-thingies” attack the turtles’ lair, but I don’t think the lair has to be a former Foot genetics facility. I think the creatures can attack the turtles’ lair because they fear it is the Foot starting up another facility, but the turtles will prove to the genetic freakies that that’s not the case. In the turtles’ investigation of “what the hell was that that attacked our lair,” they can explore the underground and come across the original abandoned Foot genetics lab (as you and I discussed)."

And Laird's response (and after which he proposes about his plans for the Turtles' lair, which are worth a good reading):

"My gut feeling is that the turtles (and our viewers) need to have a sense of security and "home" when the turtles are in their lair, and any story we hit them with right off the bat that has them getting attacked in their lair by monsters on the first day they move in is not going to give us/them that feeling. It sets up a "bad vibe." I also don't think that EVERYTHING in this show which threatens the turtles has to or should have a connection to the Foot or the Shredder (which one of the [many] failings of the Fred Wolf cartoon series)."

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/blast-from-past-576-may-14-2002-re.html

In the syndicated seasons, he is quite correct. And yet, once the show went to CBS, the ratio was far more split of Shredder being involved vs. his not being involved (not counting the Red Sky seasons). It doesn't matter, but I wanted to point that out, anyway. Whateveh.

Check out the 8/19 email, as the 2003 logo is discussed at length. It's rather neat.

oldmanwinters
08-23-2012, 09:24 PM
Heh, apparently Gary Richardson was really nervous about Mikey's "Can we keep her?" line at the end of A Better Mousetrap:

Finally, the very last line of dialog "So? Can I keep her?" is very close to a line from the first movie. Therefore, I think we may want to stay away from plagiarism whenever possible. Plus the line makes Mike seem like kind of a sex starved pervert to me. In the movie they at least knew who April was from watching her on TV.

And Peter Laird's response:
I didn't at all get the "sex starved pervert" implication, and the plagiarism thing is questionable (who actually came up with that line?), but when you stop and think about it, it made a lot more sense in the movie in the context of the scene as opposed to here in the context of this scene. I could live with losing it and coming up with a new funny line ("Is it my breath?" or something).
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/blast-from-past-579-may-28-2002-re.html

Ninjinister
08-24-2012, 01:31 PM
What the heck was going through Gary's mind? o.O It's obviously a joke about what kids say about pets that follow them home, and has been used with humans as the subject a lot for humor.

Xav
08-25-2012, 08:18 PM
Interesting, they were at one point considering Hun turning into an ally of the Turtles.
17.) And of the "ideas that haven't found a place yet", I don't like the first one (Shredder tries to get the Turtles to work for him), and wasn't too hot about the last one (Hun gets turned into an ally of the Turtles). However, one of the things you mention is the Guardians", the good ninjas we discussed before. I really think there should be some kind of encounter -- even if it's mysterious -- with these good guys in the first season.
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/blast-from-past-580-june-2-2002-re.html

oldmanwinters
08-30-2012, 08:05 PM
Check it out, this early Splinter design kinda resembles the Nick design:
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a56/slimer2erasmus/TMNT%20model%20sheets/Splinter4KidsdesignwwithPLtweaks.jpg
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/blast-from-past-584.html

He looks so tall and dignified!


Also, apparently "Demon Shredder" was thought up quite early in the process... or maybe it was just really ironic!
Now on to the figure/character drawings. Why is it that all new artists feel the need to change established and iconic details unnecessarily in our characters? I just don't get it. If they were drawing Superman, would they change the style of his chest "S", give him a crewcut, and make him wear sneakers?

I think a directive should go out to any and all artists employed on this project that they should NOT do stuff like change the shape of the kneepads, give the Turtles gloves or leg wrappings, etc., and instead concentrate on getting a cool STYLE for the new show. I like these drawings, but only as drawings. I don't like a lot of the details. Leo's face in the full-body shot has a ridiculously tiny jaw and a tiny, bizarre, birdlike beak. If I am reading the art properly (and given that these are faxes and not the best way to present pencil sketches, I may not be), the use of the mask to "denote a 'nose'" as shown (i.e. a nose shape underneath the mask) seems really silly. I also don't get the "sumo knot" approach to Mike's mask... but that may be because the drawing is unfinished to the point that no difference from the regular style mask is readily apparent.

As for the Shredder... that's not the Shredder. It might make a neat design variant for a "Future Shredder" or a "Demon Shredder" or an "Other-Dimensional Shredder", but it's not THE Shredder. I would suggest again that the artist concentrate on STYLE as opposed to detail.

One thing I DO like in the two Turtle drawings is the overall posture and attitude of the Turtles.

Talk to you soon!
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/blast-from-past-582-june-10-2002-re.html

Also of note, either Peter or Gary (I can't really make sense of whom the quote is attributed) wanted to at least keep the possibility open that the TMNT may have met other humans prior to April O'Neil:
2.) Pg. 6: Mike says on this page (re: April) that "This is the first human we've ever talked to." Do we want to establish this as stated... or do we want to leave it open for any future flashback-type story which might tell the tale of how the turtles encountered humans before this episode with April? If we want to leave it open, we could easily change Mike's line to something like "We don't have much practice talking to humans".
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/08/blast-from-past-583-june-14-2002.html

CyberCubed
08-31-2012, 11:32 AM
The series never changed much, most episode outlines were kept with some tweaks.

pannoni1
09-02-2012, 04:25 PM
I wish Fred Wolf still had the development notes to the OT, though it seemed like much of that series was created on the fly except for perhaps the first season. Anyways, this is a great thread that really shows how well-planned this series was compared to FW's, and when the executive meddling started in 2005, it really shows how the series gradually led to its decline.

Jester
09-02-2012, 05:03 PM
I just wish there were tapes of the bloopers from the FW series. I've heard that those would be gold!

Xav
10-29-2012, 11:35 AM
Inserting both Lloyd and Laird thought the Guardians shouldn't think the Shredder was dead. Yet that made it into the episode anyway.
4.) Pg. 9: Lloyd, as you pointed out in one of our phone conversations, the Guardians wouldn't have thought the Shredder was dead because his head got cut off, as they know his true nature (Utrom in robot body). I think the same applies for the Utrom Council, so this exchange referring to the Shredder...

Council Member #2: "Could he still be alive?"

Guardian Dorn (Radio VO): "Possible. He has deceived us before."

... would seem to need reworking.
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/10/blast-from-past-601-december-3-2002.html

oldmanwinters
10-29-2012, 03:56 PM
Inserting both Lloyd and Laird thought the Guardians shouldn't think the Shredder was dead. Yet that made it into the episode anyway.

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/10/blast-from-past-601-december-3-2002.html

I'm glad they had the foresight to recognize that point. It was weird when the flashback episodes revealed that they should have known all along.

CyberCubed
10-29-2012, 04:12 PM
Laird has almost finished posting his notes for the entire series. He started halfway into Season 2 and to the end of Turtles Forever...and now he went back and has finished almost all of Season 1.

All he has to do now is post his notes for the first half of Season 2 and he should be done.

Then...maybe he can finish Volume 4? :D

oldmanwinters
12-15-2012, 08:15 PM
In his most recent update, Laird expressed his bewilderment of April's "lab attire":

The major thing which has got me a little worried, and maybe you can say something that will easily allay my fears, is the issue of April's outfit. When you were up here for our meeting last week, I remember you saying some stuff about how slavishly the animators in Korea follow the model sheets and storyboards, which occasionally results in weird/undesirable things happening. Well, as I watched April in her lab coat and belly shirt (a combination which was okay but looked a BIT odd), I began to wonder if we were seeing the beginning of another situation where -- even though I know we talked about this, and agreed that she should wear different clothes sometimes -- April would be seen wearing the exact same thing in episode after episode. I don't recall seeing any model sheets showing April in different outfits... were there any done?

I know we all don't want to repeat the horrible Fred Wolf-era mistake of keeping April in one set of clothes forever (boring!), so I was wondering what ideas you have for solving that problem. Obviously some of the episodes are far enough along in the animation production line that if April is wearing the same pants/sneakers/belly shirt getup in them, it's too late to change . On the other hand, might we attempt to change this situation in some of the shows which are NOT that far along? (Assuming the problem that I am talking about actually does exist, of course.) What would it take -- supplying a specific new model sheet of April in a different outfit (or outfits) for each episode in which we decide she should have changed her clothes?

I think that some careful attention to this might result in benefits such as making the show more appealing to girls (who pick up on that kind of thing right away) as well as opening up a greater possibility of doing April fashion doll-style toys (Barbie scale). I talked with my daughter about this, and she has some interest in possibly sketching out what she thinks might be some different cool outfits for April, if you think that would be helpful.

Come to think of it, although it's clearly most important where April is concerned, it might not be a bad idea if we kept this idea in mind for all of our major human characters, especially Casey.
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2012/11/blast-from-past-603-january-10-2003-re.html

I guess his feedback must have paid off in some sense, since April ended up having more outfit changes (and official model sheets) than any other character in the show; definitely a rarity in children's animation.

MikeandRaph87
12-15-2012, 08:40 PM
I don't know about you all,but the belly shirt did not seem to fit April. I am glad it was changed after a short while because it didn't seem to fit.

MikeandRaph87
01-02-2013, 09:20 PM
Peter posted an odd item with the TMNT brand from the 2003 cartoon branding days. A tan lotion applicationor of Donatello! Wierd. I never have seen this one. Peter posted it to ask and I am curious myself,have any of you seen this or own this specifcTMNT merchandise?

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/

Jester,you have an affinity for the oscure. Winters,your all knowing and a a fellow blog poster? Azrael or Dr. Spengler?

oldmanwinters
01-09-2013, 10:19 PM
Peter posted an odd item with the TMNT brand from the 2003 cartoon branding days. A tan lotion applicationor of Donatello! Wierd. I never have seen this one. Peter posted it to ask and I am curious myself,have any of you seen this or own this specifcTMNT merchandise?

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/

Jester,you have an affinity for the oscure. Winters,your all knowing and a a fellow blog poster? Azrael or Dr. Spengler?

Nope, I don't ever remember seeing that one.

Here's the full link, BTW:
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2013/01/a-curious-tmnt-product-from-2k3-era.html

Also, I hope Mr. Laird finds his notes soon!
Followers of this blog have probably noticed that I have not posted any "behind the scenes of the 2K3 TMNT show" emails lately. That's because I had been having a problem getting the emails off my old desktop computer in a consistently good form. Almost half of the ones I transferred had weird text corruptions and/or were incomplete. And with the holidays coming on, I had other things to deal with. I hope to get back to those emails shortly.

rufus
01-19-2013, 06:15 PM
New Blast from the past 4KIDS notes.http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/