View Full Version : Michael Bay's Platinum Dunes to produce new Turtles movie
ToTheNines
05-30-2010, 06:11 PM
Because of the negativity? Well, to be fair, there's not much to get excited about. Michael Bay's name is attached to it. Platinum Dunes, a production company that has only done horror remakes, is in charge. The dude who wrote Forbidden Kingdom was rumored at one point. So, what's the good news, aside from a new TMNT movie being made? If Paramount said, "JJ Abrams is producing, Alex Kurtzman & Robert Orci are writing, and D.J. Caruso was directing" then we could start celebrating. But for now we have to be skeptical. The movie could be good/great. I'm not saying it won't. But at the moment there's no evidence to support that it will.
Bay is just the executive producer, I wish you fu*k-tards would realise that. PD has only done horror remakes, but if you want to branch out you gotta start somewhere. Do you honestly think everyone at PD went to film school and learned about nothing except horror movies? Do you think horror movies is all they ever think about? No. They can do other things, even a chevy mechanic could fix a dodge.
"The dude who wrote Forbidden Kingdom" has also wrote other pretty good movies, Young Guns and Thunderheart. And he's not attached anyways.
1. A more detailed backstory between Oroku Saki and Hamato Yoshi.
2. A film that's dark and violent (like the comics) but light-hearted and fun (like the `87 cartoon). The 1990 movie had the right idea.
3. Yes, I want Krang, the Technodrome, and Dimension X...but only as set-ups for the sequel. The first movie should be Batman Begins-esque with the origins of the Turtles, Shredder, and Splinter.
4. No CGI. The Jim Henson suits worked perfectly fine. If they want to CGI the faces, like in Where the Wild Things Are, then that's okay - but no full CGI.
5. April O' Neil as a reporter. Sorry, but I prefer it that way.
6. Casey Jones in a smaller supporting role. He should be there, but save the best for the sequel.
7. New York City in full display.
1. Pointless, Yoshi dies too early in the story for anyone to care too much about him. And besides, his feud is with Nagi not Saki.
2. wtf?
3. wtf?
4. If they spend enough money on it, CGI would be good. Otherwise, no.
5. Bleh.
6. Bleh, CJ rocks.
7. Agreed.
Gyt Kaliba
05-30-2010, 07:11 PM
I haven't seen it yet, but from the trailers, it looks like they just copied the original. So, what's the point when you can just watch the original?
Not to drag it back up, but as others have said, you can't judge it just from the trailer. Of course it's going to mostly show the stuff like the original, that's to draw you in. The film itself when you watch it though is VERY different from the original, in a good way though.
And I'm gonna get thwacked for this, but am I seriously the only one who likes Shia as an actor? Mind you I don't want him in TMNT (can't think of a single person he could be), but I think he's one of the only really good actors in his age group right now.
Warhorse
05-30-2010, 07:53 PM
If Shia laBOOF plays any part in a TMNT movie, I will eat my own ****. *
*Does not guarantee I will eat my own ****.
Why would you think Shia LaBeouf would have any part at all? Last I looked, he's joined to Steven Spielberg at the hip, not Michael Bay. You'd have more of a chance of Michael having a cameo in the movie instead of Shia.
Candy Kappa
05-30-2010, 08:20 PM
1. Pointless, Yoshi dies too early in the story for anyone to care too much about him. And besides, his feud is with Nagi not Saki.
yeah, the only interaction Yoshi and Saki had is:
"I've come to avenge my brother!"
*Sploit!*
"Augh!"
but am I seriously the only one who likes Shia as an actor?
I think he's a horrible actor, he's flat and dull.
You'd have more of a chance of Michael having a cameo in the movie instead of Shia.
I could totally see Michael get a nunchuck in his head
You'd have more of a chance of Michael having a cameo in the movie instead of Shia.
As long as he plays a guy who gets his a$$ kicked, I think everyone would be okay with that. :lol:
Gyt Kaliba
05-30-2010, 08:24 PM
I think he's a horrible actor, he's flat and dull.
That's fine, it's your opinion. Out of curiousity, who are some of your favorite actors for his age group though?
And color me stupid again - Michael?:ohwell:
Samhain
05-30-2010, 08:37 PM
What do I want to see?
1. A more detailed backstory between Oroku Saki and Hamato Yoshi.
2. A film that's dark and violent (like the comics) but light-hearted and fun (like the `87 cartoon). The 1990 movie had the right idea.
3. Yes, I want Krang, the Technodrome, and Dimension X...but only as set-ups for the sequel. The first movie should be Batman Begins-esque with the origins of the Turtles, Shredder, and Splinter.
4. No CGI. The Jim Henson suits worked perfectly fine. If they want to CGI the faces, like in Where the Wild Things Are, then that's okay - but no full CGI.
5. April O' Neil as a reporter. Sorry, but I prefer it that way.
6. Casey Jones in a smaller supporting role. He should be there, but save the best for the sequel.
7. New York City in full display.
My thoughts:
1.I dont really think this is needed. I think the 1990 film did a great job with what they explained.
2.While I do understand what you mean, its kinda hard to have both. The humor I think could be dialed down a tad bit with way more fights and I think we would have a winner.
3.Hell no. I dont want any 80s toon characters. No thanks.
4.I dont mind CG just as long as its believeable, which not alot is. I DO want turtle suits so if they wanna CG a face on them, that is fine with me.
5.I really dont mind if April just flat out drops dead in the first 5 minutes of the movie. She wont. Of course. So I dont care what she is.
6.Casey is awesome. I like how much time he got in the 1990 film. If they give him more screentime,great. But they gotta get the right actor to pull it off. Elias Koteas did an awesome job.
7.Agreed.
And I'm gonna get thwacked for this, but am I seriously the only one who likes Shia as an actor?
Nope. I actually like the guy. I think that he is a great actor and No, I would not mind seeing him in a TMNT movie. He wont be, but if he was, I wouldnt care in the slightest.
Gyt Kaliba
05-30-2010, 08:46 PM
Michael Bay. :P
...MAN do I feel stupid. I think I'm the one that received a nunchaku to the head, sheesh. ~_~
And just so I actually have something else to respond about...
1. A more detailed backstory between Oroku Saki and Hamato Yoshi.
2. A film that's dark and violent (like the comics) but light-hearted and fun (like the `87 cartoon). The 1990 movie had the right idea.
3. Yes, I want Krang, the Technodrome, and Dimension X...but only as set-ups for the sequel. The first movie should be Batman Begins-esque with the origins of the Turtles, Shredder, and Splinter.
4. No CGI. The Jim Henson suits worked perfectly fine. If they want to CGI the faces, like in Where the Wild Things Are, then that's okay - but no full CGI.
5. April O' Neil as a reporter. Sorry, but I prefer it that way.
6. Casey Jones in a smaller supporting role. He should be there, but save the best for the sequel.
7. New York City in full display.
1. That would be interesting to see, but maybe in another set of comics or something.
2. I love the old film series, but the real appeal here is something 'different' from that, so I'd like it to not be too much like the old one.
3. Eh...as much as I like the old toon, and an old-toon inspired but darker film would make me squeal like a fanboy piglet, I'm also more tempted to see a closer to the comics story, since I've never read more than a handful of those.
4. Agreed whole-heartedly. One of the many reasons I enjoy the Hellboy films so much is because they are awesome prosthetics and not over-done CG work.
5. I'd like to see her as a scientist for this series, or maybe even just the runner of the antique shop, but I won't mind if she's a reporter at all.
6. It's funny, I was actually just discussing this with my mom the other day (she likes the Turtles too, to an extent), and even though she's a huge Casey fan, she thinks this is a great idea too.
7. Agreed, whole-heartedly again.
turkishproverb
05-31-2010, 01:13 AM
Yep and who knows. Maybe Platinum Dunes having experience with the horror genre can make for a really disgusting, realistic looking mutated ninja turtle. And with the right writers and director,it could be amazing. Or, it could suck. And we and the franchise would be in the same exact place as we are now.
Their horror films DO SUCK. It's not an or issue.
Nightmare was vapid and frankly almost boring, Friday the 13th and TCM were both boring as well, with the added bonus of sterile atmosphere and unenjoyable characters...
Amityville, in addition to the others, was cliche ridden and had plot points and images bordering on insane troll logic.
The hitcher was a jump movie that got me out of my seat and into my dvd collection to find something else to watch.
Their "original" films aren't better.
PizzaFan87
05-31-2010, 01:20 AM
As for the reboot, I am sure that their won't be any Bebop, Rocksteady, or Krang because there is a new generation of kids and they wouldn't understand it like we did.
It's possible, I suppose, but you also have to think about it from a marketing point-of-view. Krang, Bebop, and Rocksteady is a major appeal to the original fanbase. And it's the original fanbase that matters most since kids these days aren't exactly big TMNT fans. That could change once Nickelodeon starts airing the 2003 cartoon series. So, like I said, anything is possible at this point.
its kinda hard to have both.
No, not really. I was just watching the Empire Strikes Back on Spike TV and they did a great job of balancing a serious tone with humor. So, with the right screenwriter and director a TMNT movie with darkness and humor can work.
Kendamu
05-31-2010, 01:24 AM
Their horror films (at least the remakes) DO SUCK. It's not an or issue.
Nightmare was vapid and frankly almost boring, Friday the 13th and TCM were both boring as well, with the added bonus of sterile atmosphere and unenjoyable characters...
You sound like a friend of mine that, back when he studied music, seriously believed that good music and bad music (i.e. music he likes and music he doesn't like) were facts of life as opposed to a matter of opinion.
CJStyles
05-31-2010, 01:38 AM
Micheal Bay producing? Cool. That means more attention will be placed on this movie.
Honestly, the first Transformers movie wasn't bad. I didn't care for the second too much, but it wasn't G.I. Joe: Rise of Cobra bad.
It's too early to make a decision on whether or not this is going to be a ****** movie or not. I'm gonna hold my opinion until I actually see the finished product on the screen and the credits traverse signifying the end.. but I missed the best part could we please go back to start.. forgive my indecision. I am only a man.... sorry, I just felt like throwing in Incubus.. dunno why.. lack of sleep maybe
Anyways, just wait and see the movie before you place judgment.
P.S. I wouldn't mind seeing Megan Fox straddling a bike in this movie either
turkishproverb
05-31-2010, 01:41 AM
You sound like a friend of mine that, back when he studied music, seriously believed that good music and bad music (i.e. music he likes and music he doesn't like) were facts of life as opposed to a matter of opinion.
Let me put it this way.
I know writing. I know film. I know art (to a lesser degree).
True, t's not always as simple as good/bad, but when something is poorly done I'm going to point it out. I can take reinterpretation. I can take unusual decisions. I can take work I don't enjoy. I'm not going to make a big issue of that.
I can't take work that seems to lack MERIT.
There are plenty of classic films I don't enjoy. Plenty of classic books I hated reading. Plenty of classic songs I can't listen to.
In reverse, I know many pieces I enjoy have no substance, or no style, or lack most determiners of a quality work. Schlock films and the like.
I can respectfully analyze them and find the "merit" even if I don't enjoy them, or the lack of "merit" even if I do. Critical analysis is often about those things.
I'm generally a lenient critic, but when something fails as a horror film, or as a film, or as a book, I'll say it fails. Criticism isn't strictly about liking or disliking a work. It's about analysis. Like a professor grading a work.
These films fail.
Luzmagica
05-31-2010, 02:42 AM
I want to know who/what company is going to make the visual effects!!!! :D:D:D
Any clue ? Use PD work with any company of visual effects ??
PizzaFan87
05-31-2010, 02:45 AM
I want to know who/what company is going to make the visual effects!!!!
ILM, most likely.
Kendamu
05-31-2010, 04:08 AM
Let me put it this way.
I know writing. I know film. I know art (to a lesser degree).
True, t's not always as simple as good/bad, but when something is poorly done I'm going to point it out. I can take reinterpretation. I can take unusual decisions. I can take work I don't enjoy. I'm not going to make a big issue of that.
I can't take work that seems to lack MERIT.
There are plenty of classic films I don't enjoy. Plenty of classic books I hated reading. Plenty of classic songs I can't listen to.
In reverse, I know many pieces I enjoy have no substance, or no style, or lack most determiners of a quality work. Schlock films and the like.
I can respectfully analyze them and find the "merit" even if I don't enjoy them, or the lack of "merit" even if I do. Critical analysis is often about those things.
I'm generally a lenient critic, but when something fails as a horror film, or as a film, or as a book, I'll say it fails. Criticism isn't strictly about liking or disliking a work. It's about analysis. Like a professor grading a work.
These films fail.
Analysis isn't why most people go to the movie theater. The reasons most people go are for entertainment and having fun. If you look at some general-audience Summer blockbuster or Fall horror film as if you are a professor grading a work, you're often looking at it from a completely different point-of-view than the target audience. I don't want to say that you're "missing the point" by looking at it that way, but you're certainly not getting into heads or the mindset of the people the film was actually intended for.
When you look at it with a different set of goggles than that of the intended audience, you can have a lot of fun. However, you also run into the risk of making a mountain out of a molehill and seeing problems that aren't "really" there. It's like when the book Seduction of the Innocent examined comics. The biggest problem with the book was that the author was looking at comic books that were clearly aimed exclusively at children with an adult sensibility. By taking himself out of the mindset of the children who read these books, he found strong homosexual overtones that an adult would see instead of the "No Girls Allowed :P" sign that little boys saw.
Feel free to base your ideas of success and failure on prescriptive notions that come from studying film and art. Just remember that the professor handing out grades isn't in the majority and the guy who thinks Megan Fox is hot, explosions rock, and robo-testicles are funny is.
PAAATE
05-31-2010, 04:48 AM
Analysis isn't why most people go to the movie theater. The reasons most people go are for entertainment and having fun. If you look at some general-audience Summer blockbuster or Fall horror film as if you are a professor grading a work, you're often looking at it from a completely different point-of-view than the target audience. I don't want to say that you're "missing the point" by looking at it that way, but you're certainly not getting into heads or the mindset of the people the film was actually intended for.
When you look at it with a different set of goggles than that of the intended audience, you can have a lot of fun. However, you also run into the risk of making a mountain out of a molehill and seeing problems that aren't "really" there. It's like when the book Seduction of the Innocent examined comics. The biggest problem with the book was that the author was looking at comic books that were clearly aimed exclusively at children with an adult sensibility. By taking himself out of the mindset of the children who read these books, he found strong homosexual overtones that an adult would see instead of the "No Girls Allowed :P" sign that little boys saw.
Feel free to base your ideas of success and failure on prescriptive notions that come from studying film and art. Just remember that the professor handing out grades isn't in the majority and the guy who thinks Megan Fox is hot, explosions rock, and robo-testicles are funny is.
Yeah, but c'mon... If you have an automatically analyzing mind like I do, you can't just shut it off.
Anyway, regarding the news this thread is all about... I don't care... Don't wanna comment on anything until I at least know who the writer is.
Weapon X
05-31-2010, 09:18 AM
I just breezed through this thread and I have to say that I'm alright with this, it puts a "name" behind the movie which is good. What I cant believe is how many people don't know the difference between a Director and a Producer, but even If he was directing all these comments of "Oh it's going to be full of explosions OMG!!" are retarded, Bay's films are primarily action films right?, I've only seen The Rock and Transformers. I mean it's giant robots fighting each other what do you expect. I doubt he would inject the same level of action, but I'm not him so it's up to debate. Also all these complaints about the Platinum Dunes remakes/sequels/prequels and how they suck, especially NOES, have you watched the original lately? I like it, but it hasn't aged particularly good, it's the truth, deal with it.
Warhorse
05-31-2010, 11:45 AM
As long as he plays a guy who gets his a$$ kicked, I think everyone would be okay with that. :lol:
Doesn't he always plays a complete loser in his cameos? Come on, him getting flicked by Megatron's finger was priceless.
I just breezed through this thread and I have to say that I'm alright with this, it puts a "name" behind the movie which is good. What I cant believe is how many people don't know the difference between a Director and a Producer, but even If he was directing all these comments of "Oh it's going to be full of explosions OMG!!" are retarded, Bay's films are primarily action films right?, I've only seen The Rock and Transformers. I mean it's giant robots fighting each other what do you expect. I doubt he would inject the same level of action, but I'm not him so it's up to debate. Also all these complaints about the Platinum Dunes remakes/sequels/prequels and how they suck, especially NOES, have you watched the original lately? I like it, but it hasn't aged particularly good, it's the truth, deal with it.
Also, people who think Bay is nothing but explosion after explosion after explosion haven't watched The Island (which I thought was very good) and Pearl Harbor (OK, but I'd probably never watch it again)
So sue me, I like Bay's movies. I have no problem paying to see Transformers 2 in the theater multiple times, while waiting for The Hurt Locker to come on bootleg (I did eventually buy THL, but that's just because I thought Jermey Renner was hot in it. But I still think Star Trek and District 9 were the best films of 2009. Just my humble opinion.
turkishproverb
05-31-2010, 12:47 PM
Analysis isn't why most people go to the movie theater. The reasons most people go are for entertainment and having fun. If you look at some general-audience Summer blockbuster or Fall horror film as if you are a professor grading a work, you're often looking at it from a completely different point-of-view than the target audience. I don't want to say that you're "missing the point" by looking at it that way, but you're certainly not getting into heads or the mindset of the people the film was actually intended for.
When you look at it with a different set of goggles than that of the intended audience, you can have a lot of fun. However, you also run into the risk of making a mountain out of a molehill and seeing problems that aren't "really" there. It's like when the book Seduction of the Innocent examined comics. The biggest problem with the book was that the author was looking at comic books that were clearly aimed exclusively at children with an adult sensibility. By taking himself out of the mindset of the children who read these books, he found strong homosexual overtones that an adult would see instead of the "No Girls Allowed :P" sign that little boys saw.
Feel free to base your ideas of success and failure on prescriptive notions that come from studying film and art. Just remember that the professor handing out grades isn't in the majority and the guy who thinks Megan Fox is hot, explosions rock, and robo-testicles are funny is.
...
That's the stupidest comeback I've ever gotten about analysis. That's like arguing American idol or ******* survivor are great art because of ratings. The fact people are morons doesn't make **** into filet.
And really, you're bringing up Wertham? On a comic book centric message board? That's practically Godwining.
Samhain
05-31-2010, 01:42 PM
Their horror films DO SUCK. It's not an or issue.
Nightmare was vapid and frankly almost boring, Friday the 13th and TCM were both boring as well, with the added bonus of sterile atmosphere and unenjoyable characters...
Amityville, in addition to the others, was cliche ridden and had plot points and images bordering on insane troll logic.
The hitcher was a jump movie that got me out of my seat and into my dvd collection to find something else to watch.
Their "original" films aren't better.
That is all your opinion. Nothing but. While you may have not liked those movies there are plenty that do. Including me. What I meant was when watching PD films, they are visually appealing to me. Dark and artfull. Which can really work for a TMNT film. But, thats my opinion. I enjoyed those films. Did they get the best rating or reviews? Hell no. But I believe alot of people consider the horror genre a joke and they dont take it seriously anyways. PD specializes in horror films. So far that is all they have done. So how can we judge them for a film they have not made yet? One that will branch out from what they normally do. There's no telling how cool they can make the TMNT.
Katie
05-31-2010, 02:47 PM
I've been avoiding this thread because I knew what was in it....but today, I read through it. I'm already in a sh!tty mood so I figured why not.
I'm disappointed.
I had no idea that there were so many whiny people in here who can predict the future just because one producer gets picked over another. Seriously. So many self described industry experts in here who have already judged this to be horrible just because of one name. It's disgusting!
No one in here should judge this or ANY movie until you've seen it. Then, if you feel its necessay, rip it up. have at it. But all this whining and bitching and complaining....and all the stupid pissing contests about who knows more about movies and the industry (which I'd be willing to bet my next paycheck is ZERO for most of you)
Why can't we just take this piece of information and recognize that it may be good or may be bad and reserve judgement and (if needed) bitching until AFTER we see the movie?
Movie people don't care what a bunch of whiny people on a message board have to say. Newsflash, the general population, no matter how stupid you think they are, is going to determine the future success of this franchise.
Make a movie that appeals to them and we got a new generation involved. Make one that caters to the 1% of us that want to see a specific type of movie....and the movie will fail (because the population won't know what the hell is going on) and the TMNT will fade to obscurity.
Having a biger name producer (no matter the name. It really doesn't matter) can achive success. Please reverve judgement for later.
AquaParade
05-31-2010, 03:46 PM
I'm starting to see more "Why so much Negativity?!?!", then actual negativity itself.
If the producers over at Platinum Dunes do have a heavy hand in this flick, I'm excited to know that they have a good eye for visuals. A visually stylized turtles film has a lot of potential.
Platinum Dunes aside, we still have Scott Mednik on board, and he was the guy voicing his love for the original 13 issue run way back when he first joined the project.
I feel we are in good hands so far.
Kendamu
05-31-2010, 04:54 PM
...
That's the stupidest comeback I've ever gotten about analysis. That's like arguing American idol or ******* survivor are great art because of ratings. The fact people are morons doesn't make **** into filet.
And really, you're bringing up Wertham? On a comic book centric message board? That's practically Godwining.
Really? The amount of people it entertains is a stupid thing to take into account? Sure, I don't like Survivor or American Idol, but there must be something about it that keeps people watching. Just because I have different tastes than them in that context doesn't mean that my tastes are more important just because I want something with just a splash more depth to it.
And, yes, I brought up Wertham. I brought him up as an outside example in relation to movies. I could've just as easily used Jack Thompson and video games to make the same point. Not arguing my point and simply saying the equivalent to, "You're cheating!!!" isn't going to make it less valid.
Yeah, but c'mon... If you have an automatically analyzing mind like I do, you can't just shut it off.
That's why I also mentioned in my post that you can have a lot of fun analyzing stuff more deeply than need be. For example, there was some Geocities site once upon a time where someone took a serious psychological look at the characters and motivations in the OT and everyone basically turned out to be extremely screwed up. It was all tongue-in-cheek, though, and it was a lot of fun to read. Even if you do try to take it a bit more seriously, it's still fun to read.
It's when analyzing stops being fun and it starts being a reason to not enjoy certain things that would otherwise be fun that it starts to get out-of-hand for me.
I would prefer a Turtles movie never be made again than have Michael Bay produce it and have it make millions. Transformers made millions and that stuff it a travesty of motion picture. How somebody is happy that a movie will make millions and keep in mind none of that money is going into your pocket and their just happy it makes money as it becomes one of the biggest travesty's next to Bayformers as for as quality goes is beyond me. I think any TRUE fan would respect quality over quantity
Michael Bay+ TMNT= Bigger fan base. Even if it will drag in different folks then the norm it is all good in my book. At least there is going to be another movie, sheesh. What type of fan are you?
Powder
05-31-2010, 09:23 PM
This has been my point the whole time. You clearly weren't enough of a fan to join this board for productive conversation... You joined to bash Michael Bay. Can't you do that somewhere else?
We're the type of fans who don't judge on first glance.
We're the type of fans to just be glad that the turtles are to be kept alive.
What type of fan are you?
plastroncafe
05-31-2010, 09:45 PM
.We're the type of fans to just be glad that the turtles are to be kept alive.
Maybe I'm speaking for only myself here, but I for one won't be "glad the turtles will be kept alive" if their new movie comes out looking like Bay'formers II. I prefer my canon on the side of quality, not quantity.
I'll be excited about a new direction when I hear more about said direction, until that point I'll hedge my bet with caution based upon Bay's recent filmography. And yeah, I know he's only the producer, but as his is really the only name I recognize, his is the reputation I'll be using to make my judgement.
I guess just having a new movie is enough to make me happy. I am more into the creativity in movies than anything else when it comes to TMNT. A good story line would be nice. I am just in it for the suits and cgi.
But Bay is not the director so there shouldn't be that much harshness over this situation.
BoggleKng
05-31-2010, 09:58 PM
I am split on this. He has had good movies and bad ones. But he has done pretty well with the Transformers.. nothing mind blowin or special in my mind but decent..
Samhain
05-31-2010, 10:07 PM
I know he's only the producer, but as his is really the only name I recognize, his is the reputation I'll be using to make my judgement.
Wow.:roll:
voltron80
05-31-2010, 10:12 PM
Michael Bay+ TMNT= Bigger fan base. Even if it will drag in different folks then the norm it is all good in my book. At least there is going to be another movie, sheesh. What type of fan are you?
If there's one thing Michael Bay knows it's action, and TMNT have the potential to be a great action franchise so that should be something most TMNT fans could look forward to. As for PD and horror remakes I believe it's harder to remake a horror movie because those movies spawn so many sequels that there's little ground to break when you redo a Friday the 13th or a Nightmare on Elm Street so you got to take chances with them.
With The Turtles there are so many possible routes to go with like Archie comics Turtles universe, Mirage Turtles universe, 2k3 Turtles, '87 Turtles(to appease everyone maybe Archie comic turtles the best route to go larger rouge gallery including villains the old school fans love and nice mixture of light and mature stories)
plastroncafe
05-31-2010, 10:15 PM
Wow.:roll:
So clearly you approve then.
Look, I don't have an anti-Bay axe to grind. Loved his earlier stuff. Not so much his recent stuff. My only real experience with the production house is the new Nightmare movie, which...I've heard isn't great, save for the casting of Jackie Earl Haley.
Am I going out of my way to organize a boycott of a movie that doesn't have a script or director? No.
Am I gung ho yippie skippy for the direction Viacom wants to take the turtles based on their production house? Not yet.
Bay's reputation lost some shine when he dipped into bathroom humor punchlines and pointless objectification.
Samhain
05-31-2010, 10:19 PM
So clearly you approve then.
Look, I don't have an anti-Bay axe to grind. Loved his earlier stuff. Not so much his recent stuff. My only real experience with the production house is the new Nightmare movie, which...I've heard isn't great, save for the casting of Jackie Earl Haley.
Am I going out of my way to organize a boycott of a movie that doesn't have a script or director? No.
Am I gung ho yippie skippy for the direction Viacom wants to take the turtles based on their production house? Not yet.
Bay's reputation lost some shine when he dipped into bathroom humor punchlines and pointless objectification.
My ''wow'' was me responding to the fact that you said just because Bay is the only name you recognize,his reputation is what you will be using to make your judgement.
Which is kinda dumb. No offense.
plastroncafe
05-31-2010, 10:25 PM
My ''wow'' was me responding to the fact that you said just because Bay is the only name you recognize,his reputation is what you will be using to make your judgement.
Which is kinda dumb. No offense.
Well of course it sounds dumb, you took it out of context by completely ignoring the sentence that came before your cherry-picked quote.
"I'll be excited about a new direction when I hear more about said direction, until that point I'll hedge my bet with caution based upon Bay's recent filmography."
dontplaydead27
05-31-2010, 11:08 PM
Why would you think Shia LaBeouf would have any part at all? Last I looked, he's joined to Steven Spielberg at the hip, not Michael Bay. You'd have more of a chance of Michael having a cameo in the movie instead of Shia.
I...I don't think he would have any part in it, at all....that was the joke...hence me saying i'd eat my own ****.
Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
06-01-2010, 12:19 AM
Good. Get this movie written. Get it greenlit and get it cast. I have posted this before but my choice for Oroku Saki/The Shredder....Ken Wantabe.
http://cdn.buzznet.com/assets/imgx/1/6/6/3/6/6/1/orig-1663661.jpg
Andrew NDB
06-01-2010, 01:30 AM
Good. Get this movie written. Get it greenlit and get it cast. I have posted this before but my choice for Oroku Saki/The Shredder....Ken Wantabe.
http://cdn.buzznet.com/assets/imgx/1/6/6/3/6/6/1/orig-1663661.jpg
Hey, that'd be a pretty cool Saki.
Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
06-01-2010, 01:50 AM
Updated picture. And yes, he would be totally badass.
http://img132.imageshack.us/img132/6802/sakid.jpg
Candy Kappa
06-01-2010, 03:00 AM
Maybe I'm speaking for only myself here, but I for one won't be "glad the turtles will be kept alive" if their new movie comes out looking like Bay'formers II. I prefer my canon on the side of quality, not quantity.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BhTsYQzjamI
I'm so glad he's only producer
Kendamu
06-01-2010, 04:44 AM
Unrelated to most of the postings I've made so far, but very related to the subject of this thread, I felt like sharing something that happened tonight.
Tonight, I was out with some friends at a restaurant and various bars with some friends that are full of mid-20s types who grew up watching the OT on TV. While I was out, I was wearing my Turtley Awesome (http://www.80stees.com/products/Turtley-Awesome-TMNT-T-shirt.asp) shirt that someone got me for Christmas this past year.
Random people from the age group mentioned previously would see my shirt and get a big grin on their face and remembered the days when they were kids and they watched TMNT on TV or when their younger siblings watched TMNT on TV. Following that would be them trying to name all the Turtles on my shirt and then they'd ask my friends and I which Turtle was our favorites.
After the general conversation about TMNT it'd go something like this:
"Hey, you know Michael Bay is making a new Turtles movie that'll be coming out in 2012 right?"
"Who?"
"That guy who made the Transformers movies. He's making a Turtles movie."
"Oh, really? I haven't seen anything about that."
"The news was announced just the other day."
"Cool! Those movies were good! I'll definitely have to go see that when it comes out!"
So, it seems that the normal people who grew up watching the OT are on board for this like it's a blast from the past or something. I guess Michael Bay's reputation doesn't stretch far beyond the Internet let alone hardcore Turtles and Transformers fandom.
Luzmagica
06-01-2010, 05:01 AM
^ Lovely t-shirt and intersting comment!!! Thanks for share! :tcool:
Candy Kappa
06-01-2010, 05:06 AM
expect for one guy I know, I have yet to meet someone that liked transformers 2, some in class enjoyed the CGI, but that was it.
but without a director, there aren't any movies to look at how the movie might or can turn out to be, Bay's movies don't count when he's a producer, and Platinum Dunes stepping into new waters.
I'm still skeptical, but then I might get a pleasant surprise in the near future.
expect for one guy I know, I have yet to meet someone that liked transformers 2, some in class enjoyed the CGI, but that was it.
I am in a high school, just about everyone love both movies in my area. Just thought I should say something to add.
Jelly Bean
06-01-2010, 12:25 PM
I'm just happy a producer has been picked, so that this show can get on the road already. And the fact that his name might bring in other viewers than I say that's cool and smart.
And if Megan Fox and Bay hate each other, than I'm psyched as well. Because I loathe Megan Fox and was afraid they where going to dye her hair red and stick her in as April O'Neil. The girl can't act for sh** and is just eye candy for trouser happy losers.
P.S. that Ken Wantabe pic is hardcore! I would welcome a Ken Wantabe Shredder.
PizzaFan87
06-01-2010, 01:02 PM
http://cdn.buzznet.com/assets/imgx/1/6/6/3/6/6/1/orig-1663661.jpg
He has become the go-to Asian.
PizzaFan87
06-01-2010, 01:11 PM
So, what about April? This is who I have in mind:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/db/Yvonne_strahovski_%28cropped%29.jpg
Yvonne Strahovski
Warhorse
06-01-2010, 04:41 PM
I am in a high school, just about everyone love both movies in my area. Just thought I should say something to add.
Well, I've been out of school for sometime, but pretty much the same thing here, I actually haven't met one person who didn't love the movies. Majority love TF2 while they thought Avatar was boring and too long. Go figure.
ToTheNines
06-01-2010, 06:22 PM
Watanabe would be a good voice for Splinter too.
Random people from the age group mentioned previously would see my shirt and get a big grin on their face and remembered the days when they were kids and they watched TMNT on TV or when their younger siblings watched TMNT on TV. Following that would be them trying to name all the Turtles on my shirt and then they'd ask my friends and I which Turtle was our favorites.
:lol: I wear a TMNT shirt most fridays that I go out.
but without a director, there aren't any movies to look at how the movie might or can turn out to be, Bay's movies don't count when he's a producer, and Platinum Dunes stepping into new waters.
I'm more worried about writer and cast.
I am in a high school, just about everyone love both movies in my area. Just thought I should say something to add.
Yep, I'm 19 and all my friends were apesh*t over the first TF movie and liked the second one. Even my dad loved the first one.
Yvonne Strahovski
She's pretty, but I'd prefer Rachel McAdams.
oldmanwinters
06-01-2010, 08:58 PM
I can't believe no one has posted this yet, so...
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a56/slimer2erasmus/Magazine%20Scans/TMNT61_MichaelBayHR.jpg
Poor Raph...
I don't get the joke. I think I am missing something here.
Samhain
06-01-2010, 09:21 PM
I don't get the joke. I think I am missing something here.
Apparently not all the turtles are keen on Bay.
Powder
06-01-2010, 09:32 PM
Lol I was gonna post it but since I couldn't find whoevers sig it was, I wasn't hip to the idea of scanning it.
Leonardo87
06-01-2010, 10:32 PM
Lol I was gonna post it but since I couldn't find whoevers sig it was, I wasn't hip to the idea of scanning it.
I think it was Jester's.
BoggleKng
06-01-2010, 10:32 PM
I was watching the first movie tonight with my kids for the millionth time and I found that I really enjoyed the POV shots from the Turtles perspectives, like when Raph rescues April from the Foot in the train station. Be great to see more creative stuff like that..
Lol I was gonna post it but since I couldn't find whoevers sig it was, I wasn't hip to the idea of scanning it.
They actually say those lines? Which comic? :O
Powder
06-01-2010, 10:38 PM
They actually say those lines? Which comic? :O
Tales of the TMNT 61 I think it is.
Kendamu
06-01-2010, 11:15 PM
Mikey seems to do his job of representing Joe Average by saying that Michael Bay rocks. Haha!
I'm pretty sure I have that issue.
Andrew NDB
06-01-2010, 11:26 PM
Pretty sure that tells us which way Tristan Jones swings on the Michael Bay discussion. :)
PizzaFan87
06-01-2010, 11:38 PM
Watanabe would be a good voice for Splinter too.
I think I prefer that over Shredder to be honest. With Shredder they should hire a professional martial artist and just have him dubbed by a real actor.
Doc_ock_4mugen
06-02-2010, 07:33 AM
I still believe that it was a typo and should've said Licks... not kicks.
Kendamu
06-02-2010, 01:10 PM
I think I prefer that over Shredder to be honest. With Shredder they should hire a professional martial artist and just have him dubbed by a real actor.
Speaking of, it's going to be hard to top the 1990 movie in my eyes when it comes to portraying Shredder. If they do end up doing a better job (or at least as different take that's just as respectable) I'll be very pleasantly surprised.
Dragon Turtle
06-02-2010, 03:09 PM
I can't believe no one has posted this yet, so...
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a56/slimer2erasmus/Magazine%20Scans/TMNT61_MichaelBayHR.jpg
Poor Raph...
I got a feeling Raph will be replaced by a Victoria's Secret Model right before production of the movie starts.
Pretty sure that tells us which way Tristan Jones swings on the Michael Bay discussion. :)
One of many reasons why Tristan was one of my favorite Mirage writers.:)
Speaking of, it's going to be hard to top the 1990 movie in my eyes when it comes to portraying Shredder. If they do end up doing a better job (or at least as different take that's just as respectable) I'll be very pleasantly surprised.
In terms of character development and on screen martial arts ability, I believe you can do much better then the 90's Shredder, who never really rose higher then generic bad guy in my eyes.
Candy Kappa
06-02-2010, 03:12 PM
James saito was a awesome Shredder, and McCharen had a perfect voice.
I hope they'll use the comic origin, and have a more menacing Shredder in combat as well. The first movie, he was bad-ass just standing there looking at the turtles
Brodie
06-02-2010, 05:44 PM
I got a feeling Raph will be replaced by a Victoria's Secret Model right before production of the movie starts.
You are stupid.
I thought it was amusing... :ohwell: To each their own, I suppose.
jaymq
06-02-2010, 06:07 PM
I can't believe no one has posted this yet, so...
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a56/slimer2erasmus/Magazine%20Scans/TMNT61_MichaelBayHR.jpg
I posted it in the form of a quote on the first page actually...
*shrug*
Dragon Turtle
06-02-2010, 06:34 PM
You are stupid.
Somebody missed their nap time? Lighten up junior, sheesh.
A nap wouldn't change you from being stupid.
Dragon Turtle
06-02-2010, 06:44 PM
A nap wouldn't change you from being stupid.
Clever retort, I see you trolls rove in packs, Micheal Bay seems to bring out the best.:)
Brodie
06-02-2010, 07:18 PM
Somebody missed their nap time? Lighten up junior, sheesh.
Clever retort, I see you trolls rove in packs, Micheal Bay seems to bring out the best.:)
"Junior"? Please.
I'm just still very surprised that people can't differentiate Micheal Bay directing and Micheal Bay's Production COMPANY.
What I'm not surprised about is the fact that people on this forum will always, always find something to bitch about in regards to the Turtles.
People should just be glad something is happening. Complain when it comes out.
It was already apparently earth-shattering when Nick/Viacom bought the Turtles, now this?! HEAVEN HELP US!
Seriously, if this is the **** that keeps you guys up at night, it's gonna be a pretty harsh wake up call when reality strikes.
agliarept
06-02-2010, 07:30 PM
goddamn it Micheal Bay has turned us against each other already!!!!! is their no mercy!!!!!!!!!! lolooolo
Dragon Turtle
06-02-2010, 07:54 PM
I'm just still very surprised that people can't differentiate Micheal Bay directing and Micheal Bay's Production COMPANY.
I'm surprise people would overreact to a little off-the-cuff joke, so much so they need to throw out a personal insult(OK, maybe not too surprised). Perhaps a laughing emoticon would have lightened the mood of the joke a bit. Lets all be a bit more civil and respectful to each other.
People should just be glad something is happening. Complain when it comes out.
If it is bad, I will definitely complain when it comes out.
goddamn it Micheal Bay has turned us against each other already!!!!! is their no mercy!!!!!!!!!! lolooolo
This is what typically happens in forums when you invoke the name of the Destroyer, Forty years of darkness! Earthquakes, volcanoes...The dead rising from the grave! Human sacrifice. Dogs and cats living together. Mass hysteria!:lol:
Mr. Stay Puft
06-02-2010, 08:35 PM
This is what typically happens in forums when you invoke the name of the Destroyer, Forty years of darkness! Earthquakes, volcanoes...The dead rising from the grave! Human sacrifice. Dogs and cats living together. Mass hysteria!:lol:
Best thing I've seen in this thread.:thumbsup::thumbsup:
oldmanwinters
06-02-2010, 09:30 PM
I posted it in the form of a quote on the first page actually...
*shrug*
Must have missed it! Props to ya!
turkishproverb
06-02-2010, 09:52 PM
I'm surprise people would overreact to a little off-the-cuff joke, so much so they need to throw out a personal insult(OK, maybe not too surprised). Perhaps a laughing emoticon would have lightened the mood of the joke a bit. Lets all be a bit more civil and respectful to each other.
If it is bad, I will definitely complain when it comes out.
This is what typically happens in forums when you invoke the name of the Destroyer, Forty years of darkness! Earthquakes, volcanoes...The dead rising from the grave! Human sacrifice. Dogs and cats living together. Mass hysteria!:lol:
Well, his work is a criminal violation of the Environmental Protection Act.
jaymq
06-02-2010, 11:29 PM
Must have missed it! Props to ya!
And back at you for taking the extra step for the image. ;)
PizzaFan87
06-03-2010, 12:18 AM
In terms of character development and on screen martial arts ability, I believe you can do much better then the 90's Shredder, who never really rose higher then generic bad guy in my eyes.
I agree, but he did have great screen presence.
Luzmagica
06-03-2010, 03:25 AM
goddamn it Micheal Bay has turned us against each other already!!!!! is their no mercy!!!!!!!!!! lolooolo
LOL !!! Wait to see when we know the Diretor´s name!! :tlol::tlol::tlol:
This is what typically happens in forums when you invoke the name of the Destroyer, Forty years of darkness! Earthquakes, volcanoes...The dead rising from the grave! Human sacrifice. Dogs and cats living together. Mass hysteria!:lol:
LOL!!!! :tlol::tlol::tlol::tlol: At least the Drome is boiling with news and comments!!!! I like a bit mass hysteria!!! :lol::lol:
PizzaFan87
06-03-2010, 03:43 AM
LOL !!! Wait to see when we know the Diretor´s name!! :tlol::tlol::tlol:
May wanna start buying that life insurance.
BlueLightning
06-03-2010, 12:34 PM
I don't know. I never liked the recent Michael Bay films. Transformers 2 gave me headaches. Now, I know that only Platinum Dunes is in charge of producing the film, and if Bay is producing, he can say "I want this, take that out", after all is his money, and that worries me.
Brodie
06-03-2010, 01:14 PM
He hasn't done that with the Platinum Dunes films. Its actually quite the opposite, as evidenced by him walking out of Friday the 13th.
Spitfire
06-03-2010, 04:06 PM
I completely gave up on this topic when I saw people just weren't getting it. It doesn't appear to have changed in the least bit since I last looked at it.
shuriken
06-03-2010, 05:55 PM
Eh, I'm just happy that AT THE VERY LEAST he knows how to help promote the movie and with him producing he CAN (and most likely will) reach a larger audience.
Spitfire
06-03-2010, 06:15 PM
Eh, I'm just happy that AT THE VERY LEAST he knows how to help promote the movie and with him producing he CAN (and most likely will) reach a larger audience.
That was my point then people started arguing that Transformers 2 made almost 1 billion dollars because there was nothing else out at the time. You know because histrionically movies make that much based on that and that alone not because people liked it or anything.
BlueLightning
06-03-2010, 09:57 PM
He hasn't done that with the Platinum Dunes films. Its actually quite the opposite, as evidenced by him walking out of Friday the 13th.
I hope you are right, I really do. But for now I will remain skeptikal.
Someone needs to stinking change the title of this thread... Producers don't do that!
Venom
06-03-2010, 10:16 PM
histrionically
Hmm, "histrionically"...I like that word. It has more flair than "historically". :P
Spitfire
06-03-2010, 10:22 PM
Haha oh man way to go auto spell correct. That word is still relevant to movies at least.
Quit playin.. You misspelled that on porpoise, ya weirdo. :P
shuriken
06-04-2010, 02:24 AM
Haha oh man way to go auto spell correct. That word is still relevant to movies at least.
I thought you meant ironically and historically. Hence the "histrionically".
I like the word.
Spitfire
06-04-2010, 04:19 AM
I wish my typo was that clever. It means "acting" essentially or being excessively dramatic/emotional.
But we can totally go with your theory :lol:
Mutated Turtle
06-04-2010, 04:34 AM
Typos are epic. Sometimes they're funny. SOMETIMES.
Luzmagica
06-04-2010, 05:11 AM
Do you think it could be a posibility that the new apparence of the turtles at the movie can had any relation with the new Sideshow statues....??? ...
...No flames...just an innocent question..! :trazz:
Time Mistress
06-06-2010, 09:50 AM
As a Transformers fan I'm of two minds about Bay doing TMNT too. I expect some good and some bad overall.
Who wants to bet April's aparment will get blown up instead of catching on fire.:twink:
Cowabunga Carl
06-07-2010, 01:08 AM
http://i939.photobucket.com/albums/ad234/winterwarrior83/mb.jpg
So here is what Raph thinks of Micheal Bay, lol, from issue 61 of Tales
Powder
06-07-2010, 01:23 AM
Haha, too bad thats been posted in this thread twice already. Nice try though.
Cowabunga Carl
06-07-2010, 10:09 AM
I'm sorry. I knew I had seen it in a book and couldn't remember which one. I've been rereading the comics and just came across it again. I should really catch up on this thread. Now that it has settled I think I'm actually okay with Bay producing, heck I think I would be okay with him directing.
TheShowstoppa
06-11-2010, 02:49 AM
Just for everyone to know so that it's cleared up - Andrew Form and Brad Fuller are the main producers behind Platinum Dunes. When you see interviews for the Amityville, Friday the 13th, or Nightmare on Elm St. remakes, it's usually Form and Fuller who are the ones who know most of the info. Bay may make some comments here and there, but because it's mainly his company, he gets a producing credit - Much like Sean S. Cunningham got for Freddy Vs. Jason and the Friday remake. He had no major game changing say in the preliminary cuts or the way the story was done, but because it's his baby, he gets a credit.
So, to clarify - Michael Bay is not directing the new TMNT movie at this date in time and currently will only have a producing credit in the film!
Now - With that said, I am quite happy with quite a few of the remakes the Dunes team has done, namely Amityville and Texas Chainsaw Massacre. Since they're finally branching out to other territories, I think TMNT is a great product for them to get their feet wet outside of horror. I can't wait to see what they can do with the franchise since they pushed the envalope with Amityville being PG13. If they, in fact, keep it PG - It's going to be fun to see how far this thing can go so long as they keep Krang and the other (in my opinion) dumb mutants out of the picture for now.
Luzmagica
06-11-2010, 03:26 AM
Is there available any other new about next movie?? I believe much more dates pop up fast after the first announce about Michael Bay as producer!? :trazz:
Shark_Blade
06-12-2010, 08:08 AM
Just found out about this. :o
I hope the story is good and not lame like Transformers. Either way I'm glad we are getting a new movie very very soon!
JoY!:tmad:
shuriken
06-12-2010, 09:17 PM
Just found out about this. :o
I hope the story is good and not lame like Transformers. Either way I'm glad we are getting a new movie very very soon!
JoY!:tmad:
The story in Transformers wasn't bad, IMO I just think that the setup and execution could have and should have been handled a lot better.
TheShowstoppa
06-13-2010, 03:31 AM
Just found out about this. :o
I hope the story is good and not lame like Transformers. Either way I'm glad we are getting a new movie very very soon!
JoY!:tmad:
See - Plainly, everyone blames Bay for that **** too. The rundown - The director turns his vision based on what was written on the script. Yeah - Bay goes a little overboard on certain movies with the explosions, but really - if you want to blame stuff on anyone in a big budget film as far as story - blame the writers. The first one wasn't bad. The second... Whoa.
Alex Kurtzman and Roberto Orci were the writers for the first two Transformers. Bay had directing (Boom goes the dynamite) privileges.
Also - People can actually complain about Kevin Munroe doing a piss poor job on TMNT because he wrote and directed it. Laird signed off on it, so he had major say in what happened there too. (Before people get off on their soap boxes, I didn't have a problem with TMNT - I'm just stating it for example purposes.)
I don't know why everyone is putting so much emphasis on Bay. Or Transformers. Transformers was a Paramount & Hasbro bi-product. Platinum Dunes isn't like Bad Robot (J.J. Abrams). They didn't have a hand in Transformers, nor did Michael Bay have a lot to do with the other reboots/remakes that PD did.
plastroncafe
06-13-2010, 09:49 AM
The writers have no control over how the actors deliver their lines, or if they deliver the lines they're given in the first place. The actors don't control the placement of cameras, or the cinematography, or the editing, or...any of the million things that go into making a movie fantastic or not.
The director does.
Whether or not the director had a hand in writing the script, he still agreed to make a movie based on that script, worked with the actors performing that script, and then released the finished product under his/her name.
So no, I don't think it's unreasonable to hold a director responsible when a movie isn't good.
Cowabunga Carl
06-13-2010, 10:30 AM
The writers have no control over how the actors deliver their lines, or if they deliver the lines they're given in the first place. The actors don't control the placement of cameras, or the cinematography, or the editing, or...any of the million things that go into making a movie fantastic or not.
The director does.
Whether or not the director had a hand in writing the script, he still agreed to make a movie based on that script, worked with the actors performing that script, and then released the finished product under his/her name.
So no, I don't think it's unreasonable to hold a director responsible when a movie isn't good.
That is exactly it. It is the directors job to get the best performance out of his actors, make sure the lighting is right, fix things he doesn't feel are working. At the end of the day he is the one who has to be accountable. If he doesn't try to get the best out of the people who he has working for him its his fault. As in any job. It is the managers responsibility to make sure things are done right.
TheShowstoppa
06-13-2010, 04:11 PM
Regardless, it's the fact that you're bashing the hell out of a man who will likely not have any hand in making this movie.
You want to watch a blasphemy of Directing and Writing? Go watch Troll 2 and tell me that it's all Director. That movie couldn't have been saved even if some God like Steven Spielburg had been behind the camera.
Candy Kappa
06-13-2010, 04:43 PM
Troll 2
off-topic:
The troll series have more entertaining value then Bay ever could accomplish
turkishproverb
06-13-2010, 08:39 PM
off-topic:
The troll series have more entertaining value then Bay ever could accomplish
*hugs Kiwamu*
I agree with everything this Kappa just said.
ooglafina
06-13-2010, 09:46 PM
Regardless, it's the fact that you're bashing the hell out of a man who will likely not have any hand in making this movie.
I think that's a good thing to keep in mind, whatever your view of Bay. Until, in the very unlikely event, we find out that he is directing, then there is no telling what will happen until there is further information.
And I can't decide who is to blame: writers or directors. I was a creative writing major and so I do secretly hate on bad screenwriters. But the director has the right and duty to edit bad writing in any screenplay that they take on. But I've found that it's the scripts with more than two writers that are the worst. It usually means that somebody wrote a really putrid script and then they went through seventeen revisions with eight writers. It will never have the cohesion of a script that is written well the first time.
I was satisfied when I heard that John Fusco was writing the script because at least we know he's written movies that were successful, whatever anyone's opinion is of him. And he's a real life ninja. My biggest fear is that they will hire people who only write crap and need to have their crap repolished over and over again.
Maybe I'm just nervous at not-knowing.:tgrin:
TheShowstoppa
06-14-2010, 05:52 AM
What really sucks is the process that uncredited screenwriters do. Some of the most putrid lines from the movie Freddy Vs. Jason were written by David "I made Blade and Batman look like badasses" Goyer. I mean horrible. No matter what way those lines would have been directed, they would have been horrible. It happens with every movie. There are on set writing changes, back room writing changes, even pre-shooting that day script changes.
I also have little faith in Nickelodeon. This is a network obviously aimed at young children and preteens. Some of their shows have hit the mark - because I've grown up with them. Others are so horrible they make me want to gag. If you're telling me you want to deviate, again, from the source material and bring back Krang, the blasphemy mutants, and whatever else you're wanting for this movie/new cartoon, it makes me sick. I could live with the deviations from season 1 of the OT. I love that season. It went downhill after that. When we got something good, something reliable and something that wasn't 36 episodes a season of nothing but filler eps, it was amazing! I love substance. I love my season finales to have cliffhangers and overlapping storylines! That's what keeps me into it! 2K3 did it well, TMNT carried on the movie series by making subtle, but amazing nods to their previous movies. We need something like that again for both the new movie AND cartoon. But plainly - just some badassery for the new movie. Insert Platinum Dunes and we'll see how well that goes.
And for the above quotes about Troll 2 being more entertaining and watchable than The Rock and Bad Boys 2, and even Transformers - Please don't EVER suggest movies to me. You're both probably the same people who thought American History X was a biography about Malcom X or that MASH is an excellent representation to the Vietnam war compared to Apocalypse Now.
Volvagia
06-14-2010, 06:17 AM
I love both Transformers movies and I don't mind Bay producing if he can bring in the big money to the movie.
The worst thing that can happen is that they do like the old cartooned Transformers movie and kill off everyones favorites to make room for a new toy line.
Gyt Kaliba
06-14-2010, 07:36 AM
The worst thing that can happen is that they do like the old cartooned Transformers movie and kill off everyones favorites to make room for a new toy line.
They don't have to do that with TMNT though. They just shove the Turtles into different outfits - WHAM! New action figure.:D
Volvagia
06-14-2010, 08:44 AM
They don't have to do that with TMNT though. They just shove the Turtles into different outfits - WHAM! New action figure.:D
Yup and thank god for that :)
ooglafina
06-14-2010, 09:27 AM
If they are truly doing a reboot then they should have more than enough source material from the comics without bringing in lots of unnecessary filler stuff, but that would be in a perfect world I suppose.
And I've never seen Troll 2 and have had absolutely no desire to do so. Bay's movies are meant to be watchable fun, not profound works of meaningful philosophy and I think they achieve their purpose. I've never really understood why people are so derisive about him.
I don't know too much about Nickelodeon, but I wonder if they'll realize that the web is crying out for a grown up movie finally. Maybe if we all complain loudly enough, they'll get a clue. hehe
As to the importance of directors and writers, I remember hearing Neil Jordan say that he wrote the entire last scene of Interview With the Vampire because he thought that Lestat needed to go out with a more memorable bang. So I think directors do have that power, but most of them are too lazy to exercise it. Or else they are too incompetent of writers/ storytellers in their own right. In which case they shouldn't be directing. This line of thought is making me depressed. :cry:
redsai4lex
06-14-2010, 09:31 AM
When I heard the news that Michael Bay was going to be doing the new Turtles movie, the first thing that comes to mind is what he did with Transformers (of course) The aspect of filming a live action movie with the main characters being mostly CGI... This is the best thing they could've done for a new Turtles movie, and Nickelodeon will run wild with TMNT characters after the new show comes out too...
ooglafina
06-14-2010, 10:50 AM
I can see plusses with both live men-in-suits turtles and full on CGI turtles. So far the only rumor I've seen is the men-in-suits with face replacement strategy. They used it in Where the Wild Things Are. I haven't seen it, but probably should. I know the suits in the three live action movies had a phony factor before, but animitronics have come a long long way since then. Del Toro's stuff and Jurassic Park III are the first things that come to mind. I think the suits this time around could be made to be quite elegant and accomadate a performace from an actor much better this time around. And face replacement would definitely help with the acting. That's something that always dispappointed me before.
Also, I'm getting sort of tired of seeing people in movies, looking at the wrong thing when they are supposed to be looking at an alien. Acting to a tennis ball doesn't enhance performance and there's sort of a new green screen acting style that's cropping up.
I can't decide if full CGI turtles would be more expensive than the live turtle method or not because animitronics can be so expensive.
As for full CGI turtles. It would be helpful at controlling their full physiological makeup. Humans in suits are restricted by human anatomy. A CGI turtle could do pretty much anything. Also they would not be restricted by gravity and wires for their stuntwork. Also, I could see how they could just look a lot prettier if they were CGI because they would control all of the texturing and lighting in the computer.
plastroncafe
06-14-2010, 11:44 AM
Oh you really should, "Where the Wild Things Are" was just beautiful in terms of effects. Story-wise it's a big budget "indie" film, which I know people either love or hate, but check it out for the Wild Things.
I wasn't exactly jumping out of my chair when I heard the next turtle flick was going to be of the men-in-suits variety. Like you said, there's just a limited range of motion available to a guy in a suit. TMNT may had it's issues, but how the turtles moved was not one of them.
But after having seen "Where the Wild Things Are" I'm far more excited for the upcoming movie. A blend of CG and 3D Men-in-Suits could really get things right.
turkishproverb
06-14-2010, 12:21 PM
And for the above quotes about Troll 2 being more entertaining and watchable than The Rock and Bad Boys 2, and even Transformers - Please don't EVER suggest movies to me. You're both probably the same people who thought American History X was a biography about Malcom X or that MASH is an excellent representation to the Vietnam war compared to Apocalypse Now.
It is more entertaining. Just not in the way the creator intended. :D
ooglafina
06-14-2010, 02:51 PM
Like you said, there's just a limited range of motion available to a guy in a suit. TMNT may had it's issues, but how the turtles moved was not one of them.
I was thinking about that after I posted. I think the problem I had was that the actors seemed to be compensating for the poor acting ability of their animitronic heads with this exaggerated mime acting that sort of bugged me. It didn't bother me when I was younger, but it's really noticeable to me now.
TheShowstoppa
06-14-2010, 10:47 PM
I thought that there was a filter somewhere where the stage actors could see out of the heads. Maybe I was wrong.
I think that PD coming in helps credibility since they've had a string of successful reboots, but the only problem is that they have a huge reputation of sinking off in the second weekend by 50% or more. Friday the 13th fell off 57% + in the first week following its release. Nightmare dropped off even more because the week following was Iron Man 2. What's more is that they also have a huge succession rate of adding additional features or doing a Director's Cut of their films when transferred to DVD. That's always a plus because there could be a whole separate film out there!
Marcus Nespeil (sp) is credited with at least 2 of PD's reboots and he has a damn good eye for action and suspense. I thought F13th had some excellent shots and I think if it's done live action with a CG based turtle - He could add some amazing views as to how the action is done, especially a final battle with Shredder.
Unfortunately, I don't think he'll come on for a "kiddie" franchise. If PD brings in someone to helm this, it's going to likely be a not-so well known person. Who would I like to see? Neill Blomkamp. District 9 was not only an amazingly well written story (by him as co-writer) but the Prongs looked so damn real it was unbelievable! Not to mention that him and Producer Peter Jackson wanted to do the Halo movie and did a quick rendition that can be found on YouTube. If you haven't seen it, go watch it and you'll understand where I'm coming from. I also highly reccommend District 9. AMAZING movie all around.
I also think the thread title needs to be changed. It's driving me more than insane that people are continuing to say it's Michael Bay coming in to do anything with this project. As of right now - It's just Platinum Dunes.
ooglafina
06-14-2010, 11:28 PM
I was just reading something about Blomkamp the other day, but I can't remember what. District 9 is another movie that I've been sitting around thinking about and not watching. I was wondering the other day if Peter Jackson's having any luck with his projects because The Hobbit was just dropped indefinitely and I've heard zero about Halo. If Jackson has faith in this guy, then I would definitely have faith if he was chosen. But we shall see.
You're right about the heads. They could see out of them. I think I mean that they knew that the acting capability of the electronics in the head was limited so they compensated in their performance ahead of time to balance that with exaggerated body movements. Like they knew that the heads couldn't emote very well. Maybe that's a better way to put it. And so they did the emoting through exaggerated body language.
Venom
06-15-2010, 10:52 PM
Halo is dead indefinitely and Jackson is no longer attached.
Walkabout
06-16-2010, 02:25 AM
Im a bit slow here I know...
but I think this is positive news here (Bay as producer)
I love the Transformers (G1) and as it happens the Friday The 13th and Nightnmare On Elm Street franchises (and the Tobe Hooper Texas Chainsaw Massacre) and despised what the remakes did to them but I have faith that TMNT could break that trend.
How can you go wrong with the TMNT?
Ok, dont answer-we all saw TMNT 2 and 3 (last movie wasnt so bad IMO) but I think they could really do the Turtles justice...heres hoping anyway.
I thought the first Transformers movie was pretty sort of okay besides the what I considered changes for the sake of change (like Frank Welker not being Megatron...I mean CMON!!!) the special effects were awesome and the hand to hand fights were very good.
Im super pumped for a new TMNT movie-good or bad!!!
redsai4lex
06-16-2010, 02:27 AM
As for full CGI turtles. It would be helpful at controlling their full physiological makeup. Humans in suits are restricted by human anatomy. A CGI turtle could do pretty much anything. Also they would not be restricted by gravity and wires for their stuntwork. Also, I could see how they could just look a lot prettier if they were CGI because they would control all of the texturing and lighting in the computer.
Very well said... :tgrin:
I love the idea of seeing them in a real city though instead of a CG one.
ToTheNines
06-16-2010, 11:12 AM
Im super pumped for a new TMNT movie-good or bad!!!
You make me quite sad.
Sage Ninja
06-16-2010, 12:48 PM
I guess i don't know what to think of this because I never saw any of the transformers movies so I have no idea how raped the second movie was compared to the first to form an opinion. All I know is that everyone hated the second one because of bay. I'm just hoping it does well this new movie.
ooglafina
06-16-2010, 02:08 PM
Well, he laid the blame on the writers. Because he always blames somebody else. I like to listen to his commentaries because he will inevitably blame somebody for failing him somehow.
But I don't think we have that much to worry about from Bay because I think his involvement will be limited. Also there are four other people on the project so far, including Galen Walker, who produced TMNT and Scott Mednick who produced 300 and bunch of other junk. I wasn't a big fan of 300 because I'm bored easily by guys who just run around talking about how great they are, but they may exert a positive influence on the other three.
Walkabout
06-17-2010, 01:18 AM
You make me quite sad.
Because you are a fat beardy who has lost his passion for TMNT? :twink:
Nah Im being super pumped for a new TMNT film now before it actually comes out and I see it and find it the biggest pile of Bay laced garbage since Revenge Of The Fallen...
Because you are a fat beardy who has lost his passion for TMNT? :twink:
You make ME quite sad.
ToTheNines
06-19-2010, 11:50 AM
Because you are a fat beardy who has lost his passion for TMNT? :twink:
Nah Im being super pumped for a new TMNT film now before it actually comes out and I see it and find it the biggest pile of Bay laced garbage since Revenge Of The Fallen...
Even without the unprovoked and baseless insults, you're still pretty far off. I still love TMNT, but saying you're pumped for a piece of sh*t is just jack-assery.
c_pokey
06-19-2010, 12:17 PM
Well, I'm not gonna comment on Michael Bay because there are probably enough negative comments in this thread about him. Having said that, I would rather have a full CGI movie than a live-action movie where the actors 'interact' with CGI characters. I know a lot of people don't like full on CGI, but I personally don't mind. The men-in-suits with CGI faces sounds like the plan for me.
Candy Kappa
06-19-2010, 12:25 PM
fixing the whole "looking at a golf ball" issue is easy.
just have the actor in a green suit and stamp the 3d model over him and his movements.
ooglafina
06-19-2010, 05:39 PM
fixing the whole "looking at a golf ball" issue is easy.
just have the actor in a green suit and stamp the 3d model over him and his movements.
Just superimpose the mockette over him. That would be an interesting method. Definitely cheap.
Granitor
06-21-2010, 05:10 PM
When I heard about this movie I was pretty stoked. Another tmnt movie live action movie, just what the doctor ordered! Some people dont like Michael Bay, I however am a fan of some of the things he can accomplish. Its hard to think of a better raw action packed movie maker than him right now
Walkabout
06-22-2010, 04:26 AM
Even without the unprovoked and baseless insults, you're still pretty far off. I still love TMNT, but saying you're pumped for a piece of sh*t is just jack-assery.
Jack assery is my forte' :tcool:
No offence meant dude, I dont really think that Ive read a lot of your posts here
Powder
06-22-2010, 05:02 AM
Jack assery is my forte' :tcool:
No offence meant dude, I dont really think that Ive read a lot of your posts here
Well for one, hes not a fat beardy. Thats Zach Galifianakis. ...But I am a fat beardy & I take offense!
:trazz:
ToTheNines
06-22-2010, 07:33 AM
No offence meant dude, I dont really think that Ive read a lot of your posts here
It's cool, dude.
Well for one, hes not a fat beardy. Thats Zach Galifianakis. ...But I am a fat beardy & I take offense!
:trazz:
Oh lmao.... I didn't realize he thought my profile pic was me :lol: I'm honored to be confused with such a hilarious guy.
Andrew NDB
06-22-2010, 01:11 PM
I know a lot of people don't like full on CGI
Clearly. TMNT Part 4 was a critical flop and a (deservedly) financial letdown.
You'll never see another full-on TMNT CGI movie. Ever.
ooglafina
06-22-2010, 01:30 PM
It did feel like sort of cop out from doing a live action. So I think you're right, Andrew.
ToTheNines
06-22-2010, 01:38 PM
It did feel like sort of cop out from doing a live action. So I think you're right, Andrew.
I wouldn't call it a cop out. TMNT07 wasn't held back from greatness by being CGI, credit that to the script, childish/corny tone and most characterizations.
I'm glad they at least tried out the medium of computer animation.
Walkabout
06-24-2010, 10:17 PM
The CGI was very well done I thought, the movie suffered due to the halfbaked plot more than any visuals.
Dragon Turtle
06-24-2010, 11:43 PM
Clearly. TMNT Part 4 was a critical flop and a (deservedly) financial letdown.
You'll never see another full-on TMNT CGI movie. Ever.
Judging from the box office of recent Dreamworks and Pixar movies, clearly a lot of people enjoy CGI.
TMNT 4 marketing held it back more then anything else, and WB didn't consider it so much of a financial letdown as to not to go ahead and greenlight a CGI sequel.
plastroncafe
06-25-2010, 11:08 AM
Clearly. TMNT Part 4 was a critical flop and a (deservedly) financial letdown.
You'll never see another full-on TMNT CGI movie. Ever.
Them's bold words right there.
I'd be willing to say that it's not probable that we'll see an entirely CGI turtle movie again, but make the claim that it's beyond the realm of the possible? That's bold, is what that is.
(Especially seeing as we're to be expecting a CGI cartoon in the next few years.)
Michael Bay is not really in charge of the Turtles movie.... He is not the director. The thread title is irritating me.
Sage Ninja
06-25-2010, 10:20 PM
F*ck CGI I hate it!
F*ck CGI I hate it!
I agree to an extent, there is always room for CGI, but... Not everything!
Candy Kappa
06-26-2010, 07:59 AM
F*ck CGI I hate it!
you hate many movies then?
Sage Ninja
06-26-2010, 03:47 PM
most modern animated movies yes. Even when I enjoy the storyline somehow I can't get by how some CGI looks. TMNT was a hage concession on my part when it came out and I still disliked how some the turtles came out in certain times. And I couldn't stand the human characters at all. If CGI looked more like this: (warning some violence and nudity)
GxlaMdvlnRo&feature=player_embedded
I'd have more respect for, at least as far as human characters go. And yes I realize this is a game segment sequence, however I have scene CGI movies look like this.
Dragon Turtle
06-26-2010, 04:38 PM
most modern animated movies yes. Even when I enjoy the storyline somehow I can't get by how some CGI looks. TMNT was a hage concession on my part when it came out and I still disliked how some the turtles came out in certain times. And I couldn't stand the human characters at all. If CGI looked more like this: (warning some violence and nudity)
GxlaMdvlnRo&feature=player_embedded
I'd have more respect for, at least as far as human characters go. And yes I realize this is a game segment sequence, however I have scene CGI movies look like this.
It sounds like you have more of a problem with the designs themselves then the medium. Much of the designs for today's CGI animated movies are still rooted in 2D caricatures.
Candy Kappa
06-26-2010, 04:45 PM
saying you hate CGI covers a lot of stuff, more then just animated films. Most Hollywood movies got CGI in them one way or the other, everything from crowds to extra landscape.
many movies got CGI you wouldn't at first glance notice.
like the entire scene from matrix reloaded, where trinity falls from the window, 100% CGI even the actor is replaced with a 3d model.
Sage Ninja
06-26-2010, 06:44 PM
I understand that. But i also eleborated on how I mostly dislike fully animated CGI movies with a few execptions.
Candy Kappa
06-26-2010, 08:21 PM
I see many CGI movies copying a mix of Pixar and Dreamworks human design, which they often don't get quite right, seen it in some indie films as well.
but that particular style is easy to animate, and might also be based off a animator rigg called Lowmax and MAX.
A link whit some lip sync made by a guy I know, he's a amazing 3D artist, and are top in class. he even excel the teachers, and make 3D characters so real it's awesome.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S_o1YKxK6zM
Dragon Turtle
06-27-2010, 12:07 AM
I see many CGI movies copying a mix of Pixar and Dreamworks human design, which they often don't get quite right, seen it in some indie films as well.
I believe it has more to do with many animators being influenced by the designs of older animators and cartoonists such as Chuck Jones, Tex Avery, ect.
Those who are impressed by the Dante game trailer should check Blur Studios other works especially their Star Wars cinematic trailers.
t_5wJ3yrVy4
Redeemer
06-27-2010, 12:28 AM
Hey Has Bay even said what direction they are going with the reboot?
Krutch
06-27-2010, 01:59 AM
Clearly. TMNT Part 4 was a critical flop and a (deservedly) financial letdown.
You'll never see another full-on TMNT CGI movie. Ever.
I wouldn't say never. CGI wasnt TMNTs problem, it was pretty much everything else. And the future is a very very long time. If the turtles survive long enough, I'm pretty sure someone out there will give it another go. Plus, there's a chance that the CGI turtle series comin out might do some direct to DVD movie.
Brodie
06-27-2010, 02:19 AM
Hey Has Bay even said what direction they are going with the reboot?
No. This is because Bay ISNT in charge of the movie, but rather his production company.
Someone change the title of the ****ing thread.
Candy Kappa
06-27-2010, 05:07 AM
I believe it has more to do with many animators being influenced by the designs of older animators and cartoonists such as Chuck Jones, Tex Avery, ect.
with many newer 3d movies it doesn't feel like that
TheShowstoppa
06-27-2010, 05:53 AM
No. This is because Bay ISNT in charge of the movie, but rather his production company.
Someone change the title of the ****ing thread.
I'm so glad someone else agrees with me finally. :tgrin:
Dragon Turtle
06-27-2010, 04:59 PM
with many newer 3d movies it doesn't feel like that
I believe most seem to be influenced by the need to display some exaggerated caricature, which seems popular with many animators, as well as being clean and simplified for animation purposes.
Sage Ninja
06-27-2010, 09:51 PM
I believe most seem to be influenced by the need to display some exaggerated caricature, which seems popular with many animators, as well as being clean and simplified for animation purposes.
except that they look like ass even more so in CGI form than in hand drawn form.
The Stryker
06-27-2010, 10:45 PM
except that they look like ass even more so in CGI form than in hand drawn form.
Opinion. I liked the designs in the CG movie over some of the stuff in the live action movies and especially anything in the 2k3 show.
Shellsweet
06-29-2010, 01:32 PM
ok, Well, Live Action Turtles, There's something about it that works with that incredibly well.
But CGI is especially hard on the Turtles, I think so anyways, Only because I can only imagine in any style, it will still make the turtles look awkard, It's especially the faces, and especially since they were trying to keep the "Mirage comic" Style to it.
Which is why from what I herd that Nick is going to do a Computer animated TMNT series, and that I'm not look too forward to because of that reason.
(And their Computer Animated series arent that...good. But their 2d shows are great! like Wolverine and the X-men and Avatar: The Last Airbender, which I hope they will change their minds to switch to 2d cuz it works well with the turtles better)
So, 2d you can DEFENITLY get away with. But computer animation makes it a little harder.
But to defend 07, I did like the character designs a lot, it was an interesting style.
But live action still owns. But 2d would be nice too, in my opinion, even though if they're going to make a movie like that I'm sure it'd just go straight to DVD. :/
I mean, Even Disney is straying away from 2d and doing computer animated movies.
The Stryker
06-29-2010, 01:39 PM
But CGI is especially hard on the Turtles, I think so anyways, Only because I can only imagine in any style, it will still make the turtles look awkard, It's especially the faces,
Serious? The faces and expressions on the Turtle's faces in the live action movies were almost always off.
"Good! Go! WE DON'T NEEEEEED YA." All with a blank face and a barely moving mouth.
Shellsweet
06-29-2010, 03:29 PM
Serious? The faces and expressions on the Turtle's faces in the live action movies were almost always off.
"Good! Go! WE DON'T NEEEEEED YA." All with a blank face and a barely moving mouth.
LOL! dude, now that you mention it, your totally right :P
I completely forgotten that! But that's the 90tys for you. but considering what they could do today would be amazing.
The Stryker
06-29-2010, 03:52 PM
And CG effects today are where it's at.
Look at District 9. They had a somewhat limited budget and the effects looked great.
ToTheNines
06-29-2010, 11:16 PM
But CGI is especially hard on the Turtles, I think so anyways, Only because I can only imagine in any style, it will still make the turtles look awkard, It's especially the faces, and especially since they were trying to keep the "Mirage comic" Style to it.
Ok, you have a banner of the TMNT07 CGI turtles in your sig... but I'll move on...
It's your opinion that they didn't look good for the 2007 movie, but you can't just say the entire medium of CGI doesn't work for Ninja Turtles.
Spitfire
06-29-2010, 11:34 PM
Look at District 9. They had a somewhat limited budget and the effects looked great.
D9 got freebies from Peter Jackson's production company. That's the only reason it looks that good for so cheap.
Slap-Happy
06-30-2010, 12:16 AM
It sounds like you have more of a problem with the designs themselves then the medium. Much of the designs for today's CGI animated movies are still rooted in 2D caricatures.
That's so they don't have to worry about the uncanny valley (which is actually something studios care about.)
Sage Ninja
06-30-2010, 12:58 AM
Opinion. I liked the designs in the CG movie over some of the stuff in the live action movies and especially anything in the 2k3 show.
I'm talking about hand drawn animation vs. CGI animation when they use typical cartoon styling for characters.
Shellsweet
06-30-2010, 01:15 AM
Ok, you have a banner of the TMNT07 CGI turtles in your sig... but I'll move on...
It's your opinion that they didn't look good for the 2007 movie, but you can't just say the entire medium of CGI doesn't work for Ninja Turtles.
I like the movie, I do! I'm just trying to explain with 2d Vs. computer animated. I had a feeling I didnt explain it right. Sorry. I'm gonna give up on that part.
The Stryker
06-30-2010, 02:52 AM
D9 got freebies from Peter Jackson's production company. That's the only reason it looks that good for so cheap.
Oh sure and this Turtle movie has Michael Bay's production company. Comparable I would say.
Spitfire
06-30-2010, 04:16 AM
Maybe but the filmmaker was a friend of Jackson and Jackson helped get the movie bankrolled because he had a lot of faith in the screenplay. I think that's a different relationship then Bay being attached to a company. Bay to my knowledge doesn't have his own Lucas Arts style company he can get free special effects labor out of if he wants to. Maybe he does but to my knowledge D9 was a very rare case.
Dragon Turtle
06-30-2010, 07:57 AM
That's so they don't have to worry about the uncanny valley (which is actually something studios care about.)
Not really, some animators are just dead set against realistic looking human characters, believing there must always be some caricature in animated characters.
TheShowstoppa
07-02-2010, 06:32 PM
Maybe but the filmmaker was a friend of Jackson and Jackson helped get the movie bankrolled because he had a lot of faith in the screenplay. I think that's a different relationship then Bay being attached to a company. Bay to my knowledge doesn't have his own Lucas Arts style company he can get free special effects labor out of if he wants to. Maybe he does but to my knowledge D9 was a very rare case.
That's actually really close. Blomkamp is a friend of Jackson's and was Jackson's pick to be the director for Halo while he was attached to it. As far as Peter Jackson's company goes - The hardware they used in the movie The Frighteners was the platform hardware they used when they started making Lord of the Rings. It's been pretty much bought and paid for with that wonderful Billion + the series made in theaters.
With District 9 - The movie was made for a modest $30 Million, but it was also actually shot in South Africa, which made production really cheap to begin with. Aside from the interior of the spaceship, etc - the majority of those sets were actual buildings and not a CG backdrop. Wonderfully - It was also done with the aid of Jackson, so Blomkamp had no complaints about his input.
Basically - The whole entire reason D9 was even made was because Jackson was trying to sell Blomkamp as a great director to the studios so he could land the Halo series. Had the movie not have forever been in production hell, then yeah - It would have worked. The movie was Number 1 at the box office and an Academy Award Nominee for Best Picture. I'm sure we'll see more awesome from those two in the future (D9 2... PLEASE!!!)
The big thing that's different about Platinum Dunes and Michael Bay compared to Jackson's company is that PD doesn't have the wonderful tech that Jackson has. Truth be told, they - like many others, still lease out hardware for CG effects with the biggest winner being ILM. The only reason PD is huge is because of their string of hit remakes.
And once again - It's Andrew Form and Brad Fuller that are the head producers for Platinum Dunes... Not Michael Bay.
Brodie
07-02-2010, 07:18 PM
And once again - It's Andrew Form and Brad Fuller that are the head producers for Platinum Dunes... Not Michael Bay.
Again, in case people missed it that time.
Krutch
08-10-2017, 01:42 PM
This thread makes me smile :D
neatoman
08-10-2017, 02:52 PM
Huh, so judging from the OP post date, the decision to go with Bay as the producer happened less than nine months after the buyout and it took them four years to make the damn movie...
I know the plan was for the movie to hit 2012 rather than 2014 but still, memories get fuzzier over time and you forget how quickly they chose producer and how long it took for the movie to come out.
Andrew NDB
08-10-2017, 02:57 PM
Huh, so judging from the OP post date, the decision to go with Bay as the producer happened less than nine months after the buyout and it took them four years to make the damn movie...
Crazy, when you think that even after those 4 years, they didn't know what kind of movie they wanted and shot 3 different movies from it.
DisKosh
08-10-2017, 04:31 PM
If it's like Out of the Shadows, I'll enjoy it. :)
CyberCubed
08-10-2017, 04:56 PM
Look at this Andrew post on the third page, everything he said here was the exact opposite of what happened, it's like his worst fears come true:
1. People whining about Bay inserting explosions and nonsense are just knee-jerking, and otherwise aren't really well versed in the politics or track record of Platinum Dunes.
2. There's nothing stopping anybody from including any characters from the OS cartoon in the movies and there never has been -- except Kevin and Peter, and thank god for them doing so (in fairness though, it's not like their exclusion helped the last few movies suck any less than they did, though).
3. A studio like Platinum Dunes -- having put out the very grown-up films they have and quite successfully -- is nothing but a huge, huge boon for this reboot movie. For the first time we may be looking at a situation where the people heading up the movie can look TPTB (Paramount/Viacom/Nick) in the eye and tell them, "We want to make this movie our way" (be it -- gasp -- PG-13) and they might not get a great deal of argument back.
4. Sorry, Krang in a new TMNT movie reboot would be b*******. No offense, Krang.
This is from 2010. So Andrew was uh...29 when he made this post? Look at how hopeful he was in his 20's compared to now.
DevilSpooky
08-10-2017, 04:56 PM
If it's like Out of the Shadows, I'll enjoy it. :)
Dude, this thread was created 7 years ago for the original movie, it's not a OOTS sequel... :trolleye:
Andrew NDB
08-10-2017, 05:05 PM
Look at this Andrew post on the third page, everything he said here was the exact opposite of what happened, it's like his worst fears come true:
This is from 2010. So Andrew was uh...29 when he made this post? Look at how hopeful he was in his 20's compared to now.
At that time I was on the phone with Kevin Eastman quite a bit, and what he was telling me as it was happening WAS pretty hopeful. He was hopeful, it was contagious. "Fights like The Raid! Action like District 13!" blah blah.
And at that point PD hadn't really done anything yet I didn't like.
neatoman
08-10-2017, 05:05 PM
Crazy, when you think that even after those 4 years, they didn't know what kind of movie they wanted and shot 3 different movies from it.
Well, there was that whole "alien" controversy that might have contributed to the delay but I still find the idea that writing a new script would delay it for as long as it was.
AquaParade
08-10-2017, 05:21 PM
Going off the fact that they filmed "three very different versions", I'd be super curious to see a different cut of the first Platinum Dunes TMNT.
I think it could potentially be a salvagable film by adding/deleting a few things:
1. Finish the cg for the fight scene that was cut for budgetary reasons - all the actors were gushing about it. Potentially what inspired Kevin's "raid" comments. Some of the fight choreography was pretty good in this film. More would help.
2. Cut out things like the turtles absorbing bullets, fart jokes, etc. Lot's of easy nip/tucks. Maybe cut out some excess Megan Fox scenes.
Honestly, as much as I dislike the film, I could actually enjoy it if they added/deleted some of these bits. It's not very likely they'd ever do this, but it's fun to dream of potentially possible things.
CyberCubed
08-10-2017, 05:21 PM
LOL, at the time this thread was made I was only 24. Goddamn, where does the time go? We're all a lot more hopeful and bright-eyed in our early 20's then as cynical adults.
Andrew NDB
08-10-2017, 05:23 PM
LOL, at the time this thread was made I was only 24. Goddamn, where does the time go? We're all a lot more hopeful and bright-eyed in our early 20's then as cynical adults.
What exactly has Nickelodeon given us to be hopeful about, with TMNT? To look forward to? At every turn it's just varying balances of exactly the same pasteurized Fred Wolf rubbish.
FredWolfLeonardo
08-10-2017, 05:23 PM
the same pasteurized Fred Wolf rubbish.
That cuts pretty deep.
neatoman
08-10-2017, 05:24 PM
4. Sorry, Krang in a new TMNT movie reboot would be b*******. No offense, Krang.
Well, you were right about that at least...
Andrew NDB
08-10-2017, 05:27 PM
That cuts pretty deep.
Nothing personal.
FredWolfLeonardo
08-10-2017, 05:33 PM
Nothing personal.
No offense taken.
I wonder whether the next film will be darker or lighter in tone.
Since the 2018 show will be lighter than the Nick show, which was darker than the PD movies, I wonder if that will have any bearing on what the next movie will be like.
Will they try to gain a wider audience by making a tmnt film for adults while kids enjoy the Rise show?
neatoman
08-10-2017, 05:48 PM
No offense taken.
I wonder whether the next film will be darker or lighter in tone.
Since the 2018 show will be lighter than the Nick show, which was darker than the PD movies, I wonder if that will have any bearing on what the next movie will be like.
Will they try to gain a wider audience by making a tmnt film for adults while kids enjoy the Rise show?
Well, the PD series is dead so I guess making it darker is the best way to distance future movies from it?
I really have no idea what to think of what Rise will be like, it will take inspiration from the PD movies yet be lighter and goofier than the Nick show, I honestly can't imagine how that'll work out.
Seems logical, too bad we're not dealing with logical producers...
Andrew NDB
08-10-2017, 05:48 PM
I wonder whether the next film will be darker or lighter in tone.
It all depends. On the one hand, I would think they would look at the failure of the Bay movies and look at them as stern warnings of what NOT to do... on the other, they may look at the Bay movies in retrospect and go, "Huh... maybe they were 'too adult.' Let's aim even younger!" That's exactly what they're doing with "Rise," in response to the original Nick show's diminished ratings. The very first press release about Rise touted it as being "more lighthearted" and "comedic" than the existing Nick show. The Nick show has always been pretty lighthearted and comedic.
I don't have a lot of faith at this point.
Will they try to gain a wider audience by making a tmnt film for adults while kids enjoy the Rise show?
So far I haven't really seen anything from them to indicate they even acknowledge an older (and when I say "older," I mean over the age of 12) audience, let alone any desire on their part to encourage or cater to one.
FredWolfLeonardo
08-10-2017, 06:20 PM
If kids back in 1990 loved the first tmnt film,I see no reason why they wouldn't like a darker tmnt film in todays age of gritty reboots.
I have a feeling that if Rise suddenly becomes a big hit and brings on the second turtlemania, that will give the creators of the film more liberty over the next film since the tmnt brand would generate good profit anyway.
On the other hand, if the show only performs average, then Nick will play it safe and make the next movie as light as the show by listening to what the charts say about the latest trends and their profit potential.
pferreira
08-17-2017, 03:53 PM
Look at this Andrew post on the third page, everything he said here was the exact opposite of what happened, it's like his worst fears come true:That post is hilarious! It's okay Andrew, honestly we could have all got those things wrong. :lol:
That cuts pretty deep.Andrew needs to daily bash the FW series like he takes vitamins. It's the law alright! :D
myconius
09-22-2017, 07:45 AM
If it's like Out of the Shadows, I'll enjoy it. :)
um, yeah! it's going to be EXACTLY like Out of the shadows.
https://media.giphy.com/media/jUwpNzg9IcyrK/giphy.gif
btw...i hope you were only joking.
It all depends. On the one hand, I would think they would look at the failure of the Bay movies and look at them as stern warnings of what NOT to do... on the other, they may look at the Bay movies in retrospect and go, "Huh... maybe they were 'too adult.' Let's aim even younger!" That's exactly what they're doing with "Rise," in response to the original Nick show's diminished ratings. The very first press release about Rise touted it as being "more lighthearted" and "comedic" than the existing Nick show. The Nick show has always been pretty lighthearted and comedic.
I don't have a lot of faith at this point.
http://scratchbomb.com/images/tmnt_xmas.jpg
^ THIS is what the next movie is gonna be like! i'm TELLIN' ya!!!
Prowler
09-23-2017, 07:27 AM
LOL, at the time this thread was made I was only 24. Goddamn, where does the time go? We're all a lot more hopeful and bright-eyed in our early 20's then as cynical adults.
I was 19.
At first, the Viacom purchase of the property and the announcement of a new movie looked very promising, so no point in chastising Andrew for being hopeful these movies would turn out good. I also initially believed that :lol:
Galactus
09-23-2017, 10:48 PM
If kids back in 1990 loved the first tmnt film,I see no reason why they wouldn't like a darker tmnt film in todays age of gritty reboots.
Very true.
I have a feeling that if Rise suddenly becomes a big hit and brings on the second turtlemania, that will give the creators of the film more liberty over the next film since the tmnt brand would generate good profit anyway.
On the other hand, if the show only performs average, then Nick will play it safe and make the next movie as light as the show by listening to what the charts say about the latest trends and their profit potential.
I doubt Rise will lead to Turtlemania part 2. Partly because it seems so thrown together but mostly because the wave of popularity enjoyed by the franchise in the 80s and early 90s is something I don't will ever be properly replicated.
I tend to think there's been a diminishing returns with the shows. The success of the Fred Wolf show era speaks for itself, the 4kids show can seem like the awkward, overlooked middle child but for two years in a row it's toys where the best selling and it had a slew of mediocre but commercially successful video games, the Nicktoon can seem a big deal with being broadcast in the nerd media era and having prime time specials and all but frankly it seems less of a hit with it's intended audience of kids the '03 show which in turn was clearly much less of a hit than the '87 show.
Of course if Rise does become a success then it's 50/50 whether they would try and replicate the show's formula in a theatrical movie or treat TV and movies as separate entities for very different audiences. This all assume that even with a hit show a movie would be on the cards, frankly after Out of the Shadows I still think pitching a new TMNT movie to a studio would be an uphill battle.
Metalwolf
09-24-2017, 11:14 AM
I think they are mainly focusing on kids, at the near exclusion of the adults. I'd be surprised if they came out with a more 'grownup' movie, since the (unfortunate) mentality is that these movies are merely a vehicle to sell toys. Having a more mature and darker TMNT might go against that idea.
The only way I could see someone challenging this, is if some smaller indie director decides to make some darker TMNT movies and these prove to be good (showing there is a potential audience for this stuff) or that the child market (or toy market) is no longer profitable. Otherwise they will continue to cater to children since studios tend to be risk adverse now, and they want to make certain bank.
pferreira
09-28-2017, 11:12 AM
At first, the Viacom purchase of the property and the announcement of a new movie looked very promising, so no point in chastising Andrew for being hopeful these movies would turn out good. I also initially believed that :lol:I'm always sceptical of modern movies and I kind of hate to be right when the stuff I like turns out the way it does.
Chabrendeki
12-30-2017, 09:33 AM
How is it with the rights? If a new movie would happen', could it be made by an other studio as Platinum Dunes? Or can Viacom lend it to other studios too?
What are the possibilities?
Powder
12-30-2017, 02:05 PM
Another studio could do it, but it would still be a Paramount production, as far as I know.
RaphaelinSTL
12-30-2017, 08:15 PM
Another studio could do it, but it would still be a Paramount production, as far as I know.
Yeah, I assume it’s like with Batman films being a WB property.
I like the PD movies well enough for what they are, not great cinema but there's enough there for me to like.
I'm still incredibly bitter by the sale to Viacom, remember the movie Laird was promising us? Sure it could've been all a lie but it did seem like it was going to happen, and all of that got scrapped and we got these movies instead, now that is the salt on the wound more than the movie themselves.
CyberCubed
12-30-2017, 08:40 PM
I'm still incredibly bitter by the sale to Viacom, remember the movie Laird was promising us? Sure it could've been all a lie but it did seem like it was going to happen, and all of that got scrapped and we got these movies instead, now that is the salt on the wound more than the movie themselves.
Laird workd on the 2007 movie and thought that was "great and dark," meanwhile it was just ok.
You can't tell me you weren't excited when we were being promised a dark mirage like movie with Baxter as the villian and using real suits with CG like where the wild things are.
Sure it might've not been all it was promised but at least the potential was there. All of that was scrapped for alien turtles and white shredder as the new plan for the movie after the sale.
Redeemer
12-30-2017, 10:57 PM
Laird workd on the 2007 movie and thought that was "great and dark," meanwhile it was just ok.
I need a quote other wise I don't believe that the same man who violently killed off his main antagonist in the first issue would consider 2k7 dark :lol:
You can't tell me you weren't excited when we were being promised a dark mirage like movie with Baxter as the villian and using real suits with CG like where the wild things are.
Sure it might've not been all it was promised but at least the potential was there. All of that was scrapped for alien turtles and white shredder as the new plan for the movie after the sale.
Yeah I was pretty bummed to. Especially sense it seemed so likely to happen.
Chabrendeki
12-31-2017, 12:28 AM
Another studio could do it, but it would still be a Paramount production, as far as I know.
Thanks! That's good news. We still got hope! :D
Andrew NDB
12-31-2017, 12:43 AM
Maybe Tarantino can do this after Star Trek XIV. ;)
Chabrendeki
12-31-2017, 12:52 AM
Maybe Tarantino can do this after Star Trek XIV. ;)
:D And break his 10-movies-rule? I'm not sure of that... ;)
I still wish a Malick-directed adaptation of Soul Winter :roll:
PS.: or Fincher doing City at War?
Andrew NDB
12-31-2017, 01:46 AM
:D And break his 10-movies-rule? I'm not sure of that... ;)
Tarantino has officially said that Trek 14 would not apply to his 10 movie rule. So no, Turtles: The Movie Part 7 wouldn't apply either.
PS.: or Fincher doing City at War?
Oh man... I really wish Fincher was a TMNT fan.
Chabrendeki
12-31-2017, 02:01 AM
Tarantino has officially said that Trek 14 would not apply to his 10 movie rule.
:o When was that? I googled it, and didn't find it.
Andrew NDB
12-31-2017, 02:58 AM
:o When was that? I googled it, and didn't find it.
http://www.aintitcool.com/node/79071
"Will this affect Quentin's set 10 number of films he had in mind to make? It won't! QT said that if he made a James Bond or a Star Trek, that would be outside of his 10! So we may get 11"
Chabrendeki
12-31-2017, 03:06 AM
Thanks! The TMNT-flick could be then his 12th! :D
Andrew NDB
12-31-2017, 03:12 AM
Thanks! The TMNT-flick could be then his 12th! :D
It might be of one of those, "Be careful what you wish for!" scenarios, though. Maybe Tarantino is, like, a closet Fred Wolf cartoon fan who's been exposed to that and nothing else, and wants nothing more than to make that version on an adult platform and subvert it as an allegory to apartheid or something.
But I dunno. If he could bring some Bride vs. Crazy 88s-style stuff to TMNT... that'd be worth the price of admission alone.
Chabrendeki
12-31-2017, 04:21 AM
It might be of one of those, "Be careful what you wish for!" scenarios, though. Maybe Tarantino is, like, a closet Fred Wolf cartoon fan who's been exposed to that and nothing else, and wants nothing more than to make that version on an adult platform and subvert it as an allegory to apartheid or something.
Oh, yes! I see that happen! :D But who knows: perhaps he succeds with it so well, that it will be your gate to the FW cartoon, and you convert to a FW-fan! ;):D
But I dunno. If he could bring some Bride vs. Crazy 88s-style stuff to TMNT... that'd be worth the price of admission alone.
Yes, the way he coreographed tha fight scenes in Kill Bill was great. I wish to see something like that in a TMNT-movie somedays. If everything turns out well, I have 40-some years left, so I have time to wait...:lol:
neatoman
12-31-2017, 06:44 AM
http://www.aintitcool.com/node/79071
"Will this affect Quentin's set 10 number of films he had in mind to make? It won't! QT said that if he made a James Bond or a Star Trek, that would be outside of his 10! So we may get 11"
"Aw man, I phased Red in the face!"
RaphaelinSTL
12-31-2017, 07:52 AM
You can't tell me you weren't excited when we were being promised a dark mirage like movie with Baxter as the villian and using real suits with CG like where the wild things are.
Sure it might've not been all it was promised but at least the potential was there. All of that was scrapped for alien turtles and white shredder as the new plan for the movie after the sale.
Completely agree ... I remember being incredibly hyped for it and I honestly still think Baxter and real suits with CGI is still the way to go. John Fusco apparently wrote the script for it and I've been wishing that thing would leak already.
It makes me nervous though with Paramount helming TMNT as a whole since they didn't seem to be on board with this version. According to a 2012 interview with Kevin Eastman (https://www.nbcchicago.com/entertainment/movies/NATL-TMNT-Co-Creator-Says-Michael-Bay-Wont-Ruin-Franchise-179664711.html#ixzz2CPhfKvzH) ...
"Three years ago, I started working on the John Fusco version, which was this awesome, awesome, awesome ‘Batman Begins’ kind of take on the first movie. It was really interesting, but it was maybe a little too edgy for what Paramount wanted. It went through a couple of different versions before Michael Bay took it over and brought in Jonathan Liebesman (‘Wrath of the Titans,’ ‘Battle Los Angeles’) to direct.”
There's always a chance too that the disappointment of those Platinum Dunes movies could lead Paramount into trying something a little different with their TMNT films. Perhaps in 2009 after the acquisition, they only had a particular vision for how the movies SHOULD be ... and now they'll be willing to experiment a bit.
Though a good number of people apparently went to see the first PD film, the sequel made less than half of what movie one did ... so that shows the hunger for TMNT movies is there, but the public ultimately wants to see GOOD TMNT movies.
Laird workd on the 2007 movie and thought that was "great and dark," meanwhile it was just ok.
I need a quote other wise I don't believe that the same man who violently killed off his main antagonist in the first issue would consider 2k7 dark :lol:
Yeah, I'm not a huge fan of 2007's "TMNT" either ... but I think that movie's only true "dark" moment is just the battle tension between Leonardo and Raphael. However, that proved to me ultimately more emotional than ANYTHING that those PD movies produced ... and Kevin Eastman was talking ad nauseam about how incredible those movies were.
pferreira
01-11-2018, 03:35 PM
Yeah, I'm not a huge fan of 2007's "TMNT" either ... but I think that movie's only true "dark" moment is just the battle tension between Leonardo and Raphael. However, that proved to me ultimately more emotional than ANYTHING that those PD movies produced ... and Kevin Eastman was talking ad nauseam about how incredible those movies were.I personally found the fight scene between them to be just fan indulgence. There was absolutely no reason at that point in the film why they needed to fight so it felt hollow, at least to me.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.