PDA

View Full Version : Did anyone not like the...


Slap-Happy
05-31-2010, 11:25 AM
... 2k3 show?

I didn't really like it. :ohwell:
I didn't like the charcter designs that much, and it was too sci-fi and fantasy for me.

I don't really care for mystic ninja, fedual ninja, Shredder as an Utrom. Stuff like that.

What are your guys' thoughts?

Candy Kappa
05-31-2010, 11:31 AM
I enjoyed the 2k3 series a lot more then I have ever with the OT.

but the OT do have a lot of Uwe Boll greatness, like not having fun with the show, but making fun of it. It's the only reason I manage to have a see through all 10 seasons.

I did not like the design change in FF, and the BttS design was a 'meh' didn't like the return of the pupils in their eyes.

there was some things that I didn't like, but overall I think the 2k3 as the better show compared to the OT.

ToTheNines
05-31-2010, 11:32 AM
Why is this a thread? People voice their distain for this show all the time in other threads... totally pointless. And negative, to boot.

Candy Kappa
05-31-2010, 11:36 AM
come to think of it, don't we have one or several threads about 2k3 vs OT vs comics vs live action vs fan-fic....

Slap-Happy
05-31-2010, 11:42 AM
If that's in the new cartoon section, I wouldn't have known. Sorry.

Andrew NDB
05-31-2010, 12:57 PM
... 2k3 show?

Wasn't too impressed with it myself, really. But it is head and shoulders above the old cartoon.

Samhain
05-31-2010, 02:16 PM
Personally, I loved it. Way better than the 80s toon, IMO.

TheCanadiandrome
05-31-2010, 03:27 PM
i didn't like it at first, but after TMNT Forever and watching the first season on dvd i've grown to like it. so much so that i want it all on dvd.

it's not head and shoulders above the old cartoon imo and never will be

Powder
05-31-2010, 03:46 PM
When it first aired I liked it until shortly after the underground eps. It wasn't until the 25th anniversery shellabration that I decided to give it a shot again. I bought the first season on DVD, loved it. Bought all the rest, loved it. Even got Fast Forward & much to my surprise, loved it. Back to the sewer... meh. I haven't seen enough of it to REALLY judge it but the animation alone is such a turnoff. If ever it comes out on DVD in the states, you can bet your asses I'll buy it. But as far as the newer stuff goes, that was (seemingly) pretty awful.

I've been planning to watch 2k3 over again, chronologically, I may have to do so tonight.

DrSpengler
05-31-2010, 05:39 PM
I liked it pretty thoroughly up through season 4. After that, the series took a major nosedive in quality. I could still enjoy the Ninja Tribunal and Fast Forward seasons to an extent, but they were too overboard with the gimmicks and it really didn't seem like the same show anymore. I quit Back to the Sewers after about 4 episodes. The "search for Splinter's bits" was too inane, even for me.

The first four seasons, though, are some good television. It started out a little rough, and when the show wanted to be, it could be AWFUL.

But it also had some of the most daring stuff I'd seen on a Saturday morning cartoon, some really consistent and excellent animation from Dong Woo, and was more enjoyable than not. I thought, given the limitations of the Saturday morning medium, they did a good job adapting most of the Mirage plot lines, only dropping the ball on a few stories (couldn't stand "City at War" and they completely missed the point of "Sons of the Silent Age").

Season 4 seemed to be where it really shined, as they resorted more to original plots and villains, with Bishop being perhaps the best original concept to come out of the series.

A shame that once they reached their peak in storytelling the writing just plummeted. And I really, really hated the angular redesigns. I know it was done for cost-efficiency and all, but damn were they unattractive.

"Turtles Forever" won me back, though. I loved every ounce of that film.

CyberCubed
05-31-2010, 06:37 PM
It was a great series, and its pretty much up there with some of the best superhero/action cartoons ever made.

There were some crappy eps along the way, but every show in existance has its terrible episodes.

The Nick cartoon has some pretty big shoes to fill.

Cipher
05-31-2010, 06:48 PM
they completely missed the point of "Sons of the Silent Age."To be fair, that seemed to have been Murphy doing an eco-centric rewrite of his own story to use Saturday morning cartoons as a kind of soap box.

Overall, the show falls somewhere in the upper spectrum of American action cartoons, but doesn't quite mark the pinnacle. Still, it was daring, every season was entertaining save for maybe five and seven, and the animation ranged from tolerable to excellent. It doesn't compare to the subdued tone of the Mirage series, but it added some great material to the overall mythos, particularly Bishop and Ch'rell.

The Stryker
05-31-2010, 06:58 PM
... 2k3 show?

I didn't really like it. :ohwell:
I didn't like the charcter designs that much, and it was too sci-fi and fantasy for me.

I don't really care for mystic ninja, fedual ninja, Shredder as an Utrom. Stuff like that.

What are your guys' thoughts?

Right here.

I didn't like the show at all.

Gyt Kaliba
05-31-2010, 07:13 PM
I really need to see more of it, but I have a hunch that when I do get to see it all, I'll like it better than the old toon. As of now though, the old toon is my favorite purely due to nostalgia.

plastroncafe
05-31-2010, 07:31 PM
It's weird, the Sci-Fi/Fantasy direction that Slap Happy mentions disliking in the 2k3 cartoon is why I'm not really a fan of the Vol.4 Mirage books. Yet for some reason what I don't like in the comics doesn't bother me in the cartoon.

Koi
05-31-2010, 08:19 PM
I didn't like it... It came off corny to me, and really lame.

I have to agree with Slap Happy and Plastroncafe with everything else.

Dragon Turtle
05-31-2010, 09:21 PM
Wasn't interested at all when I first heard about it, the turtles were practically dead to me, but the 2k3 cartoon brought me back and was easily one of the best animated action cartoons in recent memory. I would even have to say that, in my opinion, it actually surpassed the original Mirage comics in some aspects.

shuriken
05-31-2010, 10:28 PM
I enjoyed it, especially season 1 and 4. 5-7 were ok, at least decent concepts just handled kind of half-assedly. I enjoyed it as much if not more than the OT. To be honest though the comic adaptations were either a hit or miss. Golden Puck sucked, but I monster was just as awesome as the comic, even moreso with the whole rat spliced Bishop angle.

Spacebabie
05-31-2010, 11:36 PM
I enjoyed it. I refused to watch it at first because my Nostalgia goggles were on too tight, but after I took them off and gave the show a chance I grew to enjoy it.

Anarchistguy
06-01-2010, 01:09 AM
I pretty much loved seasons 1 to 4 (Although, some episodes were downright AWFUL. The first nine episodes of the show aged TERRIBLY, in my opinion). But from Fast Forward on...no comment.

Krang
06-01-2010, 02:00 AM
but the OT do have a lot of Uwe Boll greatness, like not having fun with the show, but making fun of it. It's the only reason I manage to have a see through all 10 seasons.
I think you're missing the point of the OT. It's meant to be a lighthearted, fun show, not something that's supposed to be taken seriously.

come to think of it, don't we have one or several threads about 2k3 vs OT vs comics vs live action vs fan-fic....
We do, but that's not what this thread is supposed to be about. It's about the 2K3 cartoon only, so I'm not sure why people are bringing up other TMNT universes.

TMNachoT
06-01-2010, 08:35 AM
I love the 2k3 show, but not FF nor BttS.

Nelson
06-01-2010, 08:46 AM
It was pretty corny. I think a lot of ot comes from the background music. I'd love to see a rough version of any episode before the music was added.

Vivi
06-01-2010, 09:33 AM
I'm a shameless fan of 2k3. The only thing I didn't like is that it ended (well not the only thing, but my fandom glosses over the crappier parts).

Jelly Bean
06-01-2010, 12:43 PM
I liked the 2k3 series. It was the first introduction to the turtles I had that I really watched. My only complaints is that there was a few missed oppurtunites and I didn't care for the lsot season and FF that much.

Also (this is more of a nit pick) I didn't care for some on the musical cues. I think someone already mentioned this already, but I got a little annoyed by the that musical exclamiation mark the show would do when someone said something supposedly "funny" or someone would make a face? Anyone kniow what I'm taling about?

Kendamu
06-01-2010, 02:27 PM
I've always liked 2k3, but Seasons 3 and 4 are the only seasons I'm a big fan of. It's like how Seasons 1 and 7 are my favorite OT Seasons.

Koi
06-01-2010, 05:09 PM
It was pretty corny. I think a lot of ot comes from the background music. I'd love to see a rough version of any episode before the music was added.

I have to agree. I am not sure if it was the background music or not, but something made it pretty darn corny. I don't think 2k3 ever really did pull off dramatic and as epic as I think they wanted. But of course, it was for kids. So I can't really complain to a large extent about how corny it was.

Candy Kappa
06-01-2010, 05:59 PM
My kid brother thoguht it was shredder making the "wuu-ah" sound effect in the theme Shredder had every time he appeared.
he always made it while playing with his figures

Koi
06-01-2010, 06:05 PM
My kid brother thoguht it was shredder making the "wuu-ah" sound effect in the theme Shredder had every time he appeared.
he always made it while playing with his figures

That is the cutest thing ever!

RiseAbove873
06-01-2010, 06:35 PM
I like the show. Is it my favorite cartoon? Nope. A few things that come to mind that I disliked are:

1. The lack of detail in the animation and characters.

2. The bland shading.

3. Leo's and Don's voices. Not terrible but I feel that they should have been more masculine.

4. Some of the character designs. Not too big on the exaggerated, animated look. Compare the 2K3 April O' Neil and Shredder with their original cartoon designs and you'll know what I mean.

5. Shredder being an Utrom.

6. The sci-fi elements. I love fantasy and I love sci-fi but when it comes to the Turtles, I prefer them battling a human Shredder and the Foot rather than monsters and aliens.

7. The theme song. Total step backwards from the original.



I'm sure there are more but these are the things that come to mind as I write this.

Mutagen
06-01-2010, 10:45 PM
I cant say I dont like it, I just dont find it appealing, innovative, interesting and distinctive from any other modern cartoons.

As I said in a different thread:
The show seems very by the book. It heavily resembles Teen Titans, the new anime-styled Batman and SpiderMan, Ben 10 and many others, and not only with the animation style (which I really dislike too, all the squary feature and the bodies of bodybuilders - huge arms and torsos and normal legs), but with the feel too. Its in the same basket with all those other faceless, paint by numbers cartoons that come out these days. The characters are stock characters too. Swap personalities of the new Turtles with just about any teens from some other cartoon show, like maybe Teen Titans and there wont be much of a difference. Not to even mention Shredder who is absolutely empty and acts like every other big bad villain in modern cartoons. His lines and personality is out of the book. Courage The Cowardly Dog had villains acting the same way, with that stock villain personality

I dont mean to sound too harsh on it. Again, I dont dislike it but I see nothing appealing in it. The one major, major pro of the show is that it reinvented the franchise and did something new as oppose to trying to do a copy of the classic cartoon. That was a brave move

gobo
06-02-2010, 06:16 AM
I honestly love the 4Kids 'toon. To me, it's like Justice League is to Super Friends.

Spacebabie
06-02-2010, 10:54 PM
Gobo, that is one great analogy. Or it could be compared to some of then newer Transformers Cartoons in comparison to G1.

Mutagen
06-02-2010, 11:46 PM
Hmm, I sense the classic toon isnt very liked here. Too bad, I was hoping to reconnect with the fans of the classic toon

Powder
06-02-2010, 11:57 PM
Hmm, I sense the classic toon isnt very liked here. Too bad, I was hoping to reconnect with the fans of the classic toon


Wrong. The majority of people here are here because of the toon. Problem is, the most active/talkative/productive members for the most part are those who either are deeply submerged in all versions equally, or prefer the comics.

Mutagen
06-03-2010, 12:12 AM
But the comments dont seem very complimentary for the OT, as oppose to the new toon

gobo
06-03-2010, 01:16 AM
People who joined with their OT fandom way above other incarnations either decide to leave or end up doing 'general discussions'. Some folks here hate the new 'toon because "it's so serious it's boring". But, if you look hard enough, you can find OT-centric threads in the 'general TMNT' section.

Personally, I was never crazy about the OT. I was/am obsessed with it, but not crazy about it. Does that make sense? ... Anyhow, the pilot season was pretty neat and gave me the same feeling I used to get from watching ThunderCats (one of the few shows I ever watched religiously) and I still think they were the best the series had to offer. However, each additional season seemed like a step down in quality. By the time Season 3 ended, I was almost embarassed to call myself a TMNT fan. But, Archie kept my interest in the franchise alive until CBS started their run and it seemed like the show had won back some of its dignity (even if it was just that extra coat of polish CBS used). Still, my head's filled with trivia about the broadcasting aspects of the series and, to a somewhat lesser extent, the plot.

Long story short, I've been waiting for the 4kids show since 1988. But, I still talk about the OT despite being sickened by how lazy and derrogatory several of the eps were. Some were actually quite good. "USAGI YOJIMBO", for example.

Cipher
06-03-2010, 02:24 AM
Mutagen, I think it's just the fact that this thread is basically asking people to defend the 4Kids cartoon. I'm sure that if there were another topic about what made the Fred Wolf version good or bad, there'd be just as many comments praising it.

Personally, I have nothing bad to say about the old cartoon. (Well, mostly.)

Episode for episode, I probably even enjoy it more than the 4Kids cartoon, but no one can deny that there was some seriously quality work going on there. The animation, oh god, it's fantastic.

To be honest, I think all versions pan out about equally for me, beneath the Mirage comics.

Krang
06-03-2010, 02:55 AM
Hmm, I sense the classic toon isnt very liked here. Too bad, I was hoping to reconnect with the fans of the classic toon
That's not true at all. While people whose favorite TMNT universe is the OT may be in the minority, the vast majority of people on this forum do enjoy the OT along with whichever other universes are their favorites. As Cipher mentioned, opinions are a little skewed in this thread (and possibly this section) due to its subject, but check out the General TMNT section for plenty of OT-related discussion.

But the comments dont seem very complimentary for the OT, as oppose to the new toon
That's just because the people who make those comments tend to be rather loud and obnoxious about it, making it seem like there is more support for their opinions than there really is. But don't let that trick you into thinking this whole forum is like that, because thankfully, it's far from it.

Luzmagica
06-03-2010, 03:10 AM
I love the 2k3 show,specially first seasons, even I like FF and BttS!! :tcool::tgrin:

Mutagen
06-03-2010, 03:46 AM
That's not true at all. While people whose favorite TMNT universe is the OT may be in the minority, the vast majority of people on this forum do enjoy the OT along with whichever other universes are their favorites. As Cipher mentioned, opinions are a little skewed in this thread (and possibly this section) due to its subject, but check out the General TMNT section for plenty of OT-related discussion.


That's just because those who bash the OT (here or anywhere else on the internet for that matter) tend to be loud and obnoxious, making it seem like there is more support for their opinions than there really is. Don't let that trick you into thinking this whole forum is like that, though, because thankfully, it's far from it.

Well that sounds promising then. It was just an impression I've got that most fan here think that OT is a dumb cartoon for kids that they tolerate only because of nostalgia and the 03 show is some kind of deep and dark artpiece.

I think one of the reasons why OT became such a phenomenon for so many years was because of its originality and imagination with the characters and stories, not for being a plain kids cartoon (otherwise fans wouldnt stick with it for so many years and the characters wouldnt become iconic). While I can easily see how 03 may be appealing, I think its being way overrated and mistaken for something its not. Again, the supposed seriousness and darkness isnt exclusive for this show. If you watch Justice League or the new He Man or even other cartoons produced by the same studio it has the same feel, if not darker with some of those examples. I just dont think that a cartoon from the 80s with 80s mentality (which at the time was considered very violent and too serious) should be bashed solely for being slightly different than what would be done today after 2 (3) decades. Different mentality, different times. And at the time, you couldnt really go further than that and TMNT pushed the boundaries then. Still today the OT has some of the most imaginative characters ever done in cartoons (like Krang). The OT had a great contrast of cutesy likeable characters and serious and completely evil villains. Shredder is the most iconic cartoon villain of the 80s next to Skeletor. The OT Shredder that is. On other non-Turtles forums, many people say they watched the toon solely for Shredder because he was such a great villain. The idea of him having a deep, Darth Vader-like voice came from the show and was then adapted into the Motion Picture. So again, my point is thatsome praise seriousness or darkness while thats what the series was called at the time. You couldnt do more then. It had that PLUS all those amazing villains

Powder
06-03-2010, 04:35 AM
This isn't a "Bash the OT" thread nor is it an "ALL HAIL THE OT" thread so just chill out, man.

Anarchistguy
06-03-2010, 01:43 PM
Ehhh...to me, this thread is basically saying: "I got the truck load of gas. now someone bring a match."

Redeemer
06-03-2010, 03:01 PM
truthfully I think that the 2k3 show was really good, but I think I still like the OT better.

Spitfire
06-03-2010, 04:02 PM
2K3 was a blast when it was happening. I looked forward to new episodes weekly, until BTTS came on. Once the series ended I went back and re-watched it.

The first season was pretty solid, except a few episodes. It followed some comic stories, if not taking a few too many liberties with them. Overall I liked it.

Season 2 was some mutant freak season. I found the entire space thing to be tiring. It dragged out way longer then it needed to. So then they do "City At War" and cut it down to 3 episodes. It made no logical sense. They spent 8 episodes on the events in 4 issues. They spent 3 episodes on the events of 13 issues. The in between the story arc episodes didn't do much for me. Also no matter how hard you try to hide it "Reflections" is a clip show.

Season 3 was good. I liked most of the episodes. It had two big story arcs and a great finale. It also had two of my favorite episodes "The Darkness Within" and "Bishop's Gambit".

Season 4 was the peak of the series. The animation had a darker tone to it and the stories themselves did as well. This was probably the height of the animation for me. The stories told were all good as well for the most part. Some comic adaptations, again taking some liberties, but overall I enjoyed it. "I'Monster" being another favorite.

Season 5 is weird. I didn't really get into it. For one it looked to be of lower quality compared to the other seasons. The story was interesting but I was sick of Shredder at this point. They killed him in season 3, as far as I was concerned, he should be gone for good. I mean it wasn't horrid but it wasn't that good either. I did like how they wrapped it up. It was kinda like a send off to the 2K3 style.

Season 6 gets a lot of hate but I liked it. FF was a nice addition to the series. I got the lighter tone. It made sense to me that they'd have lightened up. The world had just been saved from the only threat in the foreseeable future. Karai was on their side, Bishop wasn't going to mess with them, and Shredder was gone. In their world they really had nothing to worry about. Them going to the future was a shock but I could see them taking it lightly. Nothing there was as dangerous or threatening as Shredder, except maybe Shoko. Sometimes they acted a bit out of character but for the most part it worked. Mikey was the only issue, his joker tard personality was played up way too much. This season also got a nice wrap up, them defeating the biggest threat in the future. Though I'm still mad Darius never got wrapped up.

Season 7 is the last gasps from a dying series. FF season 2 should have been allowed to continue but constant whining from the fan base caused them to yet again revamp the series. The proposed season 2 episodes all sounded awesome I'm sad we never got to see them. What we got was something even more kid friendly. The Serling episode being quite possibly the worst turtles episode ever second to "Fathers and Sons" from season 5. The good thing is BTTS wrapped the series up quite well. It ended with something we've been waiting to see since season 1.

The thing about this series for me is it lacks re-watch value. I don't ever feel like popping it in. Since it ended I've had no urge to go back and watch the series from the start to finish. The OT I can watch anytime, even if it's just in the background while I work. It has that timeless feeling to it, something this series lacked. It also has a charm this series never captured. While the animation in 2K3 is great and the fight scenes are all well done and engaging the series as a whole doesn't stack up to what the OT did. Most of the episodes in 2K3 can be enjoyed better by reading the comic books they came from.

CyberCubed
06-03-2010, 06:43 PM
The reason people may not have the urge to rewatch 2k3 yet is it JUST ended. We have to wait a couple years until the nostalgia sets in.

Personally after Turtles Forever aired, I did a marathon and rewatched all 155 episodes and Turtles Forever over the span of about a month.

As I rewatched it, I loved it just as much as I did originally. This show works great because continuity wise it was fantastic, and if you ever marathon through it its great seeing how almost everything leads to something else.

As I said, the Nick cartoon has some big shoes to fill. If it is a remake of the original cartoon it should be great, but the 2k3 series really is probably the pinnacle of TMNT animation thus far.

sdp
06-03-2010, 07:13 PM
Yeah the new show needs to be very different from 2k3 since it has big shoes to fill and will only be compared to it and not be allowed to shine.

Look at The Batman, it came out after the amazing BTAS, and it tried being serious but it was its own thing and because of it people bash the show for not being as good as BTAS. Then brave and the Bold came out and tried something totally different and people love it. It needs to set apart from 2k3 and also the 87 series and be its own entity, I think it will too.

Can another cartoon like 2k3 happen? sure but not at this moment and it could even surpass it.

FlawedCoil82
06-03-2010, 09:58 PM
This is really the only section concerning TMNT that I post in. The OT killed my interest in TMNT and X-Men filled that void. Then in 2003, this new toon filled (to the best of it's abilities) the immense void left by X-Men. And for the most part it succeeded. It was pretty much the cartoon of TMNT that I always wanted to see. It revived my long, dead interest in TMNT. I loved a lot of the music (I still adore that sinister "Oroku Saki" theme played in early seasons along with that solemn theme they play whenever a character dies or something sad happens, for example at the end of "Dragon's Brew" they play it when the tarantula monster is looking at the gazeebo). Love it!

The action in 2k3 can not even be compared to the goofy "fights" that occured in the OT. I wanted to see "ninja" turtles in the OT, and what I got was "Teenage Mutant Joker Turtles". That just didn't work for me in the least. That fact alone put the 2k3 series on a completely different level than the OT. Basically, OT chased me off and 2k3 won me back with its superb fight sequences (that only got better as the series progressed, until after the first episode of Ninja Tribunal at least).

Having said that, there certainly were bad episodes in the 2k3 series as well. I hated (with a passion) the entire "Justice Force". "Garbageman" was utterly ridiculous. FF angered me at first but once I gave it a real chance and ignored that hideously annoying robot police officer, I found there to be decent episodes hidden within the series. BTTS didn't work for me. The fights were not near as interesting. Nearly every battle required the turtles to be wearing some different kind of uniform or battle gear and that frustrated me quite a bit. Turtles Forever pretty much redeemed itself from the BTTS series, though I still desired to see one final martial arts fight between the turtles and Shredder where they all used their fighting skills to defeat him instead of him just being bigger than them to where they had to avoid being squished instead of hand to hand combat. But it was far better than even the best episode of BTTS. I truly wish the 3rd, 4th and 7th seasons would be released on dvd (in correct order) as well as Turtles Forever. Perhaps one day...
Jack

Spacebabie
06-04-2010, 10:46 PM
just because we actually like the newer series or if we rpefer it to the OT does not mean we hate the OT. I like the OT for its corny charm. They obviously were doing something right ofri t to last as long as it did, but I like the 4kids version even better.

Ninjafromanotherseries
06-08-2010, 10:16 AM
I liked this show very much, definitely one of my favorite animated shows, the best is still Futurama. i liked this show from episode 1 and didn't ever come big fan but show I took many of storylines casually, I like the mix of street-level, fantasy and sci-fi stories.

Seasons 1-4 were great, 5 and 6 were okay, 5 was bit stupid with anime powers and 6 needed some time but after a while I started to enjoy it. 7 was good too but had few episodes that were pointless.

First 5 episodes were great but after that things were downhill. I think Serling episode should have been made that Serling goes into Khans past and Khan was first good ninja but Serlings interference would have made Khan evil. Then made "Identity Crisis" should have been two-parter, first part would have ended with Turtles helping Shedder into real world and second episode Hun and purple dragons vs Shedder troops and Turtles also. Then maybe "Superquest" it wasn't good episode but still pretty funny. Then should have been again two parter and it should have gone that Turtles get into future and Darius Dunn takes over city in "City under siege" style and he would have capture turtles and Bishop. It would have needed Cody to use his ninjaskills without technology and Dark Turtles teaming up to defeat Dunn.

12th episode should have been dedicated to Turtles saving Splinter from Cyberspace, make Garbageman as bad guy as ultimate spambot. And then last episode almost same as it is already but only start right away from the farm.

Sorry for my fanfic and I haven't seen yet "TMNT Forever" but I plan to watch it after I have watched all the other episodes first.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
06-11-2010, 07:51 AM
No way, the 1987 cartoon is so much better, but even the Archie comics rock.

Shark_Blade
06-12-2010, 11:35 PM
I much prefer the classic 87 toons but the y2k turtles is watchable. :) I really don't like the heavy sci-fi influence on it though. Let's keep it in New York City, where the turtles belong. And keep it ninja-esque.

ToTheNines
06-13-2010, 11:26 AM
I much prefer the classic 87 toons but the y2k turtles is watchable. :) I really don't like the heavy sci-fi influence on it though. Let's keep it in New York City, where the turtles belong. And keep it ninja-esque.

Way to contradict the holy sh*t out of yourself.

Turo602
06-14-2010, 07:56 PM
I really enjoyed 2K3 a lot more then the 80s series but they are both really great shows. I love 2K3 because I love the action, the passable jokes, and the story telling. It also had some great animation, designs, and voice acting. Fast Forward was alright, it was something new, fun and lighthearted, but the animation went a little down. I would of liked season two of Fast Foward only so we could have more TMNT and also because it was really intresting. Then Back to the Sewers was still decent but the animation just kept getting more kiddish. It was alright and I would of liked to see the Shredder Wars!

I find it funny how the 80s series got darker and that the 2k3 series got kiddish as time went by.

ToTheNines
06-14-2010, 08:18 PM
I believe you're confusing "animation" with "character design", Turo.

Walkabout
06-28-2010, 04:47 AM
I hadnt really thought about the Turtles for years when by chance I saw the 2003 show on TV-I thought it was pretty darn good.

Im no real expert on either cartoon (stopped watching OT by about 92, seen the first 2 and a bit seasons of the 2003 show) but I like them both for different reasons.

Koi
06-28-2010, 11:20 AM
http://img3.imageshack.us/img3/3382/cheesyo.jpg
"Want to look like a purple dragon, try getting your butt kicked by a ninja turtle"
"I'm down with that HERP DERP"
*Activate stupid handshake*

Ugh, the lines, the writers make me want to cry. This show has some of the most dumb lines ever.

Let me just reference ONE episode.
"I guess you could say I am having a bad hair day."
"Oh YEAH! I got the juice"
"Have you ever seen a human in his skibbies? Trust me, it ain't a pretty sight."
"I think the biology lesson is the least of our problems now."
"Lard butt"
"Hate to break up this tearful reunion"
"Don't look now but tiny still wants to dance."
"ooooooh Taxi!"
"Mhhhm pie"
"The unsung heroes of the urban jungle"
"What kind of pie do you think it was?"

;_; just makes you want to die a little. The older show is a lot more clever in there random jokes then most of the stuff that is coming out of turtle's mouths in the newer series is crud.

I swear every episode was pretty bland, (in my opinion). The lines and dramatic scenes came off completely corny and lame, the animation wasn't that good, the character designs scared me at times (where is there bridge?), it just got worst the more the series went on. It was bearable for the first few eps then totally crashed and burned by season 5.

Yeah it did do a bunch homage to the original comic, referenced it, but that doesn't make it good. I mean if someone watched the newer series and someone said "This is more based off of the more gritty comics etc. whatev." The person new/watching the 2k3 series would think less of the comic if you ask me.

But I digress...

Shellsweet
06-28-2010, 01:07 PM
Well, For me, 2k3 TMNT is what got me started. I like the OT too, but I love the 2k3 series much more, I loved the Style, the characters, And how it was pretty much right out of the comics. (I love reading the comics.)

And I kinda like the Shredder as a utrom, and him as a human would have worked well too, but It wouldnt have been fun to see him come back in the series, like, 8 times or how many times he came back to haunt the turtles. Because a human probabtly wouldnt make it back after getting his head sliced off, or trampled by a water tower, or trapped in a exploded building and a boat, ect. But When the Cyber Shredder came back from the 'internet' THAT was pushing it a little to far for me. Though the Character Design was pretty sweet. :trazz:

But when Fast Forward/BTTS came out. That was pushing it a little bit too. I do have FF on DVD, only for the laughs cuz it did have some funny stuff in there.

But yea, 2k3 wins my heart pretty much. :trazz:

I'm yabbering here so forgive me. :P

ToTheNines
06-28-2010, 08:52 PM
"I guess you could say I am having a bad hair day."
"Oh YEAH! I got the juice"
"Have you ever seen a human in his skibbies? Trust me, it ain't a pretty sight."
"I think the biology lesson is the least of our problems now."
"Lard butt"
"Hate to break up this tearful reunion"
"Don't look now but tiny still wants to dance."
"ooooooh Taxi!"
"Mhhhm pie"
"The unsung heroes of the urban jungle"
"What kind of pie do you think it was?"

You're being a little hard on the show there, aren't ya? I agree, the 2k3 show had plenty of "narm" but half of your examples aren't that bad at all.

Shark_Blade
07-12-2010, 01:22 AM
Way to contradict the holy sh*t out of yourself.You don't make any sense so talk to the hand.

... 2k3 show?

I didn't really like it. :ohwell:
I didn't like the charcter designs that much, and it was too sci-fi and fantasy for me.

I don't really care for mystic ninja, fedual ninja, Shredder as an Utrom. Stuff like that.

What are your guys' thoughts?

I feel the same about the sci-fi stories. But I do like:
- the new turtle designs + their individual personalities and attitudes
- Splinter's trainings
- April and Casey
- Badass Shredder (I can make do without Karai, Hun, Baxter and the rest of the lame so called "villains")

The 2k3 got travelling to other planet and what not; way too much, and I really don't like the aliens, humanoid professor turned to robot thingamagic stories and the likes.

primatives
07-16-2010, 05:15 AM
I reckon its the best show!! Such good stories all the characters are soo good. Mikey is funny leo is always the humble one, raph is justa hot head and donny a geek :) I give it 2 thumbs up :) i thought the anmiation was awesome too. i initially didnt like it cos i grew up with the old turtles but i gave ita chance and i havent looked back! also i dont like it that they use "What the shell" alot oter than that i like it :)

Spitfire
07-16-2010, 02:54 PM
;_; just makes you want to die a little. The older show is a lot more clever in there random jokes then most of the stuff that is coming out of turtle's mouths in the newer series is crud.
You haven't see every episode of the old series if you think that. The OT had some embarrassingly bad moments.

the animation wasn't that good
Now you're just talking out your ass. The animation in this series is quite good. I've known several animators, my girlfriend included, who agree.

Yeah it did do a bunch homage to the original comic, referenced it, but that doesn't make it good. I mean if someone watched the newer series and someone said "This is more based off of the more gritty comics etc. whatev." The person new/watching the 2k3 series would think less of the comic if you ask me.
Or they'd realize it was toned down for kids, you know the target audience of the series. If people were that thick anyway they wouldn't have read the comic just off what they saw from the old cartoon.

I'm not a massive fan of the series myself but some of your arguments are completely invalid.

ToTheNines
07-17-2010, 10:47 AM
You don't make any sense so talk to the hand.

"Talk to the hand"? Good one...

Anyways, since I don't make sense to you allow me to explain: You said you didn't like the NT for it's heavy sci-fi influence, but even though the OT had a very different tone it still had a huge sci-fi element to it.

Herald7
08-07-2010, 08:32 PM
I tried watching the 2k3 a couple of times, it felt like your standard action cartoon. I don't think it's bad or anything, I'm sure it's fine, just didn't stand out for me.

I do think the OT is a bit misunderstood. It wasn't supposed to be a straight forward action cartoon. Rather it was a tongue in cheek parody of an action cartoon. And even when I watch the episodes now I'm amazed at the quality of the writing and acting performances. It's not easy to do comedy well; it many ways it's much more difficult than drama and angst. They could have just settled for "kiddie" humor, but they always managed to include references to pop culture and adult situations you wouldn't get until you got older. As opposed to many kids shows today that just like to pretend they're being grown up.

Redeemer
08-10-2010, 12:12 PM
Truthfully I think that the 2k3 series is better than the OT, but I love them both. I like the design of the turtles and setting in 2k3. But I like the villian characters more in the OT. Both show have excellent qualities to them. Hopefully Nick stick to its word and combines the best elements of all the universes.:tgrin:

Rise1184
08-10-2010, 01:32 PM
i didn't like it at first, but after TMNT Forever and watching the first season on dvd i've grown to like it. so much so that i want it all on dvd.

it's not head and shoulders above the old cartoon imo and never will be

Basically the same for me. Turtles Forever was a "open gate" to love the new TMNT. I was born and raised with the OT, so at first I was upset that they kept making fun of the version I grew up with lol That was at FIRST watching the movie, than by the end, I just laughed and loved all of it! :tgrin:

Redeemer
08-15-2010, 03:09 PM
truthfully I think the reason people dont like the 2k3 is bc of what a standered the OT set and their ignorence as well as the nastalga with the OT

But most people give legitamit reasons for not liking the 2k3 which I respect. But the truthfully the shows are on 2 different sprectrums of sorts

Herald7
08-15-2010, 11:19 PM
truthfully I think the reason people dont like the 2k3 is bc of what a standered the OT set and their ignorence as well as the nastalga with the OT

Well it's true that I have nostalgia for the OT. However I wouldn't still be watching it if I honestly didn't enjoy it. It's more than just nostalgia, the OT was a quality cartoon.

I definitely know TMNT's history as a more serious story and that's fine (no ignorance here, hehe). I appreciated the more serious aspects of the comics and the original film. I just wasn't that moved by the 2k3 series. ::shrugs::

Koi
08-16-2010, 12:19 AM
You haven't see every episode of the old series if you think that. The OT had some embarrassingly bad moments.

Now you're just talking out your ass. The animation in this series is quite good. I've known several animators, my girlfriend included, who agree.

Or they'd realize it was toned down for kids, you know the target audience of the series. If people were that thick anyway they wouldn't have read the comic just off what they saw from the old cartoon.

I'm not a massive fan of the series myself but some of your arguments are completely invalid.

Those are just my opinions. And perfectly valid as an opinion. :)

No, I haven't seen every episode of the old toons. But the embarrassing moments that I saw in the OT were funny. Cheesy, sometimes had bad puns. But funny even at those times. While when the 2k3 make a joke and it goes south, it still isn't funny because of it's dark atmosphere it was shoveling in at the same time.

The animation to me maybe not you, was mediocre, and was really sloppy at times, ignoring simple perspective laws, and stretched and skewed scenes at points way out of the norm, and the more the series went on the more they seem to forget to color everything in. In comparison to a lot of other mainstream cartoons that came out at the same time, it was bad.

The first season was the best animation in all the seasons, but the animation died as it continued.

I understand the 2k3 was toned down for kids, but I am really disappointed with how they made the 2k3 series. The genres they mixed, didn't fit well together for me. I am not sure if it was the way the lines were delivered, writing, or whatever. But for me nothing mixed well together. The dark and comedic genres clashed really bad for me. And really got bad over time.

I admit my scenario for the 2k3/comic thing was really broad, and would only apply to a few selective people. But I just wanted to get my opinion across, and at the time that was all I could think of.

I just really didn't get into the swing of the 2k3 at all, so for me I just don't care to much for it, and the OT beats the "shell" out of 2k3 by a long shot. IMHO.

Sorry if you got upset over what I said Spitfire.

Berserker
09-19-2010, 10:00 AM
After not watching the original series in about 20 years, I recently bought seasons 1 & 2 of both the OT and the 2k3 cartoon. Just a random TMNT obsession took hold, and for some reason I really wanted to watch the show again. The only TMNT comics I've read were Archie ones.

So far, having watched 13 episodes of the OT and 7 episodes of the 2k3, I already prefer the new series. The OT is just too geared towards young children, which is typical of cartoons for the 80s; not just the action and characterizations (I understand that it's meant to be lighthearted,) but the dialogue/vocabulary of the characters and the paint-by-numbers writing really makes it hard for me to pay attention to the show as an adult. The same holds true for G.I. Joe, The Real Ghostbusters, and other cartoons from that time period. My nostalgia for the series is just not powerful enough to overcome this, and although there are things that I love about the show, overall it doesn't hold up as well as I thought it would.

Batman: The Animated Series put an end to the 80s generation of American cartoons, and most superhero shows afterward (including the new TMNT) are Batman's direct progeny. Pop culture changes over time, and most of the cartoons from the 80s, including the original TMNT, sadly seem dated and out of place in comparison to the media of today's generation. True "kids shows" are becoming harder to find, as cartoons more often cross demographic boundaries to capture more viewers.

The 2k3 show is simply more modern and more mature as a result, which is why I enjoy it more. Watching the OT makes me feel like a 6-year-old whose hand is being held by condescending adults who created the cartoon under the assumption that I'm too dumb to understand anything but the most basic storytelling. By comparison the 2k3 series is tightly paced, takes more risks, and has more complex action; it was made for kids of the internet generation, who are older than their years would imply. Despite the occasional silly line, I can get into the show much more easily.
________
Macintosh games (http://macgame.org)

cartoonistaaron
09-19-2010, 12:47 PM
Never got into the new show. The 2k3 series had extremely bland character designs. They kind of go after the "Batman the Animated Series" Bruce Timm style but they don't quite get there. The animation was lousy but that's true of many cartoon series. Certainly the original show didn't have fantastic animation (outside of the original miniseries).

What I like about the old show are the charming character designs and the wacky sci-fi type stuff. Krang, Baxter the Fly, etc. That stuff is fantastic. Also, the old show never took itself too seriously (at least not until the last couple years). It was a fun cartoon with a little action and a ton of humor, which is when I think TMNT works best. The 2k3 series was way too heavy-handed.

For the record, I've followed the Mirage comics since 1989 and was (and remain) a hardcore fan of the B&W series. The 2k3 show just missed the mark with boring character designs and an overall bland style. I was interested in some of the adaptations of the Mirage comics but I just don't think they managed to pull it off very well.

CrazySquirrel
09-19-2010, 02:24 PM
I LOVED the 2k3 series...

The only things I didn't like were

1. The Superhero Squad Episodes

2. The entire Flash Forward idea.... I actually liked a few of the episodes but it felt like it was still the same 2k3 characters that I loved thrown onto an entirely different terrible plot that wouldn't end... I thought the characters were still great and I liked Mikey's enthusiasm for future video games. :)

3. The Back to the Sewers episodes that were based around being "stuck in the internet" for the same reasons as 2....



I was ok with no original series characters and the Utrom Shredder... but I would have liked 1 or 2 episodes with Bebop and Rocksteady...

Brodie
09-19-2010, 03:55 PM
Those are just my opinions. And perfectly valid as an opinion. :)
The animation to me maybe not you, was mediocre, and was really sloppy at times, ignoring simple perspective laws, and stretched and skewed scenes at points way out of the norm, and the more the series went on the more they seem to forget to color everything in. In comparison to a lot of other mainstream cartoons that came out at the same time, it was bad.

The first season was the best animation in all the seasons, but the animation died as it continued.

That's all very, very true.

Spitfire
09-19-2010, 04:32 PM
Sorry if you got upset over what I said Spitfire.

Not at all. I get slightly annoyed when people talk out their ass. Like when people make broad comments with no context or validation that they even know what it is that they're talking about. In my book if you can't explain your opinion then it is a rather weak one. You obviously can but you don't need to prove anything to me. I'm just a big turtles nerd on a message board searching for like minded people. :lol:

A lot of your problems with 2K3 are the same ones I have. The series tries to take itself seriously but fails a lot of the time. I also hated almost every comic adaptation episode and Mikey got annoying all too fast in several of the episodes. I would argue the animation in seasons 1-4*5 looked like **** for some reason* was quite good stylistically at very least. I loath the new animation style of making everything all angular so seeing 2K3 not following that trend made me quite happy. I don't watch cartoons often though. Every time I turn on a toon network I end up seeing something like "Marvel Super Hero Squad" that makes me miss the days of X-men and Spider-man on Fox.

You should seriously see all of the OT though. There's some episodes so horrid it's hard to watch them without cringing. Though I've never cringed more then I did when I watched the baby turtle episodes in 2K3 and BTTS. Those were hands down the worst episodes of both cartoons in my opinion.

Fugitoid Jones
09-21-2010, 10:11 PM
I love both shows alot. The OT show helped me to become obsessed with TMNT and it was always the highlight of my saturday mornings, but if I had to choose a show to watch today, I'd choose the NT. I just loved all aspects of it and found it completely entertaining. It appeals to me more now that I'm an adult for some reason I guess.

And am I the only one that didn't find the 4Kids show to be as dark as everyone else makes it sound? I mean it had it's dark moments, but everyone makes it sound so dark and gothic.

Berserker
09-22-2010, 07:05 AM
I mean it had it's dark moments, but everyone makes it sound so dark and gothic.

I think most people's complaint is that it tries to be dark and gothic but fails when it attempts to mix in comedy. So what we get is some kind of weird mixture of conflicting moods.

Which is why I love the series, actually, it reminds me of the first TMNT live action movie in terms of tone and character.
________
Suzuki tsx (http://www.suzuki-tech.com/wiki/Suzuki_TSX)

Koi
09-22-2010, 05:30 PM
I think most people's complaint is that it tries to be dark and gothic but fails when it attempts to mix in comedy. So what we get is some kind of weird mixture of conflicting moods.


YES! My feelings to this show exactly! I just couldn't put it into words as well.

Coola Yagami
09-22-2010, 06:13 PM
Dark and Gothic...? Naw. Sure they're ninjas in the night, the bad guys are dangerous and Shredder isn't running around in a purple cape trying to kill the turtles with poisoned pizzas. But dark? Other than a few episodes like Insane in the Membrane and Bad Day, the series as a whole isn't all that dark, its just that the turtles are actually allowed to act like ninjas.

Koi
09-22-2010, 06:43 PM
Dark and Gothic...? Naw. Sure they're ninjas in the night, the bad guys are dangerous and Shredder isn't running around in a purple cape trying to kill the turtles with poisoned pizzas. But dark? Other than a few episodes like Insane in the Membrane and Bad Day, the series as a whole isn't all that dark, its just that the turtles are actually allowed to act like ninjas.

I think I can't actually recall a scene with pizza in the newer stuff.

I would have to argue your point of view, I think it tried pretty hard to be edgy and dark, not really Gothic, but dark. If you listen to the music in some scenes along with the dark coloring, and violence. I have to say it was pretty dark, but not dark dark, only do to the enforced comedy placed everywhere.

shuriken
09-22-2010, 08:35 PM
I think I can't actually recall a scene with pizza in the newer stuff.

I would have to argue your point of view, I think it tried pretty hard to be edgy and dark, not really Gothic, but dark. If you listen to the music in some scenes along with the dark coloring, and violence. I have to say it was pretty dark, but not dark dark, only do to the enforced comedy placed everywhere.

^^ I totally understand where you are coming from. Even though I did thoroughly enjoy the show up until they went all mystic then to the future and into cyberspace. In terms of being "dark" well it was mostly set IN the dark, and they're freaking ninjas trying to be all sneaky and stuff. As opposed to the OT when a LOT of the action happened in the day and the TMNT just wore creepy looking masks and trench-coats to get around.

gobo
09-23-2010, 01:29 AM
If the show had been entirely grimdark, like Gargoyles, I wouldn't be a fan today. Why do people insist that things have to be all or nothing like that? That's just boring... as shell.

Rise1184
09-23-2010, 01:18 PM
I actually had not watched it until recently. I like it, to be honest.. I already own the whole series, but yet to go and watch the whole thing.

Fugitoid Jones
09-25-2010, 10:05 PM
As opposed to the OT when a LOT of the action happened in the day and the TMNT just wore creepy looking masks and trench-coats to get around.

And alot of times the TMNT wouldn't even wear the trench coats and masks! They'd be walking around during the day with no disguises. That's one of my only complaints of the OT.

megashredder
10-09-2010, 07:54 AM
I liked the show mostl seaosn 1-4. The rest is crap but its intersting to see the foot making robots.

Prowler
10-10-2010, 08:27 PM
Haven't watched seaons 5-7 yet but I can safely say it was a good show, it wasn't perfect, not even close but it was good.

It was well animated, it had exciting fight scenes specially the ones with Shredder(Man, was he a badass in this show) and The Foot.

It also had nice continuity which always kept you interested in watching the next episodes.

There are things I didn't really like:

- The voice acting wasn't that good at the beginning;
- The art looked kind of ugly and exagerated sometimes. I'm not much of a fan of the Battleshell and the Turtle's Lair design. Also, why did most females look masculine?;
- Sounded pretentious sometimes, it was hard to take this show seriously when Michelangelo cracked a joke that not even 10 year olds would find it funny;
- Raphael was a bit too angry and hard headed and Michelangelo got retarded by season 2;
- Casey was fine in season 1 but by season 2 he got as dumb as Michelangelo, maybe even dumber. Also, he got his a** handed to him in every fight since then;
- Most of the humor wasn't funny it was more like meh or facepalm like;
- The theme song. Definitely a step back compared with the OT.
- Baxter Stockman's mutilations, seriously;
- Notes From undergroudn arc and the Ylinthians(however that's spelled) story, by mid season 4 I was sick and tired of it;
- Leonardo hogging the spotlight, now I know he's the leader so that naturally makes him slightly more talented than his brothers but they almost made it seem that he was the main character of thje series in some episodes, mainly season 4 when he gets his ridiculous "wannabe badass" voice.
- Nanotech Robot, UGH!
- Karai. Did she really believe the Utroms were the ones who were "evil" and not Shredder?:roll:
- Some of the single episodes weren't that great, namely Garbage Men, Nanotech eps, The Golden Puck, Monster Hunter and a few others.
I won't compare it with the OT since they're different shows.

I think that the show was kinda overhyped. I remember reading comments on this show back when it aired in 2003 and people were praising it like it was the best thign ever and how the OT sucked compared to it, so I was a little bit disappointed.

Which one do I like the best? Wel, I grew up with the OT while I haven't fully watched the 2k3 yet and have been doing it in the past couple of months so it's kind of hard to answer this question.

I guess most people would rather pop in an OT episode instead of a 2k3 one bevcause the OT was episodic so it's easier to watch a single episode while the 2k3 series has continuity and if your memory of it is kinda foggy it's not a good idea to watch a random episode, meaning you would have to watch the whole series again.

Spitfire
10-10-2010, 09:13 PM
I think that the show was kinda overhyped. I remember reading comments on this show back when it aired in 2003 and people were praising it like it was the best thign ever and how the OT sucked compared to it, so I was a little bit disappointed.

I wouldn't consider it over hyped. You go to a Turtles message board and of course most the people on there will be praising the media in question.

2K3 was awesome for most fans in the beginning because a series was finally being made that more accurately represented the source material. Not only that but it was adapting stories from the comics as well, which worked out great for the animated comic series of the 90's that most of us also loved.

By the time 2K3 had come out most of the fans that grew up with the OT were teenagers or in their early 20's. The series was more mature then the OT so it was a logical stepping stone. Not having read the comics yet the stories were even better. It wasn't until I actually read the entire Mirage run that the series felt a bit watered down for me. The comic adaptations of the later seasons were less then satisfying to say the least.

I believe part of the problem was what was allowed. In most of the 90's comic series they got away with quite a bit and while the stories weren't always 100% accurate they let more slide. Turtles had to work within a lot harsher constraints. I imagine it's a bit hard to re-image a comic book with decapitations and body explosions for children.

This doesn't completely excuse the writing but the bad jokes are probably the only thing that kept kids from turning it off. You look at those 4Kids blogs where kids post comments and all of them love Mikey. They think he's hilarious. Without the humor or lighthearted moments the series would have been to down beat for kids. The Turtles isn't exactly known for it's inspirational storytelling.

CyberCubed
10-11-2010, 12:58 AM
The 2k3 series was hyped simply because it was a NEW TMNT CARTOON.

Back then none of us ever believed that the Turtles would come back to the the spotlight with new toys/cartoons,etc.

The mere fact that it was a new cartoon almost 7 years after the original run ended is why the show was so, "hyped."

That's common sense.

kenshin
11-25-2010, 11:32 AM
One the main reasons OT fans hate 2k3 because Utrom Shredder but no one see the real reason why they turned him utrom.The reason is simply:violence.The reason turns make old turtles like clown.You still have no idea I'm talking about first watch this;

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tCFEyd-44jA

Now think foot fight scenes,We never saw turtles cutting anybody on screen both shows but like this video things change fight between turtles and Shredder.I mean are you really think possible cutting somebody on screen in tv cartoon? No,it's not possbile.This the only way we saw awesome fight scenes like this.Honestly I'm also hate Utrom Shredder idea at the begining but after think and watch whole series,I like it.Come on original Shredder just a man wanted his brother's revenge.Other one people who like it because human or his voice actor played some uncle carachter in crap sitcom.Utrom Shredder is most succesfull villian in all tmnt history.He's smart,almost kill the turtles many times (old one not even close) and destroy f...king planets.His better voice actor also better.Biggest irony here is 2k3 show getting worse after s4 old one getting better last season.

Avatar Yuffie
12-08-2010, 06:50 PM
I felt they really wasted Karai's character. :/

It would have been so interesting how'd she'd run the Foot without the daddy issues hanging over her head (kind of like her Karai counterpart in the 2007 movie, and heck her Mirage original). The show could have a chance for a gray morality in which she and the Turtles would have issues with (they did this with City of War, I know they can replicate that). I really believed they could have make her a credible villain without resorting her as a Shredder Junior.

The Rat King is my favorite villain in the OT. It was a shame he was a one shot character.

Leo's character arc that lasted season 4 was just too much, I really wanted Raph to butt in and give him a punch when he was being insufferable.

Spitfire
12-08-2010, 07:02 PM
Rat King was a one shot villain in the Mirage verse too. He came back as a ghost a few times but other then that he never fought the Turtles again, just Splinter.

2K3 made the mistake of not killing him, probably because they weren't allowed to show a death, especially one that brutal. They left his story open and ended with him making threats to attack them again some day. Had the series not gone in a direction that didn't allow for darker storytelling we might have seen him again. His cameo at the wedding was not only weak but stupid. He wouldn't have been there.

Avatar Yuffie
12-08-2010, 07:09 PM
Precisely that: The Rat King should have at least fought Splinter in 2K3. It's tradition. :p

Eh, being a one shot in original comics shouldn't be an excuse of not using him. I mean look at the Shredder...

Candy Kappa
12-08-2010, 07:16 PM
it would have been interesting seeing a battle of wits between splinter and The Rat King in 2K3, they could have made the dialogue different and the end result not being cannibalism.

raphfan84
12-08-2010, 09:36 PM
I have not seen the 2K3 series so I can not really say I don't like it, but I have seen pics of the 2K3 turtles along with the figures and a few clips from the show. It looks like a cool series and all, and I have heard it's good as far as it's suppose to be a darker version cartoon. But I don't like the whole whited out eyes. I know that may sound dumb, but I really don't. I know that's how they started out and all in the comics and it looks fine in the comics cause there all blk and white but it just does not look right with the colored turtles.:ohwell:

k_lala
12-13-2010, 09:13 AM
... 2k3 show?

I didn't really like it. :ohwell:
I didn't like the charcter designs that much, and it was too sci-fi and fantasy for me.

I don't really care for mystic ninja, fedual ninja, Shredder as an Utrom. Stuff like that.

What are your guys' thoughts?

Wow, i never heard any "Turtle" fan say they did not like this series. I loved it!! From what I understand they did follow the comic book. Like many i loved the series other than FF and BTTS.

I like to hear more on why you didn't like it.

Wildgoose
02-01-2011, 06:40 AM
Hmmm, this is gonna take reaally long. Almost everywhere I see tmnt fans to fight over which show is better than the other. It's usually the NT fans that "win" but I find all this thing really pointless. We are all fans after all, cant we get together. And we shouldnt forget that if there wasnt the comic, none of the shows would have existed...
Right on topic now...

1.theme song
The old tunes' theme song was way much better that the 2k3. It was memorable, catchy. The 2k3 theme song wasnt something special.

2.The action
The classic series had some good fighting scenes...but as it was so old, they had more "silly" action due of being a kids show.
The 2k3 series had much much better action scenes. Fast moves, suspences, really awsome.

3.Comedy
The classic series had good jokes....especially the relationship of Shreeder and Krang and the sarcasm of Raphael
The 2k3 has some jokes...not that good. Of course Mickey is a comic relief but sometimes he is annoying.

4.The turtles
a)Leo
OT Leo: He has many similarities with the NT Leo. He was the hero to save the day and at the same time funny
NT Leo: Much more depper character development, more serious, and I think better than the OT

b)Mickey
OT Mickey: Really funny character, and his battle cry "cowabunga!!" was a phenomenon. The bad thing is that they took his weapons and gave him a grapling hook...lame
NT Mickey: A little annoying, cute, funny, but still OT rules

c) Donnie
OT Donnie: the braniac of the team, but most of the time his inventions exlpoded
NT Donnie: Many similarities with the old one but.....it was supposed that his inventions were from parts of junkyards....well, his toys were a lil' too much sci-fi...more like they were made from another planet

d) Raphael
OT Raph: The sarcastic member of the team, funny and cute
NT Raph: A total hothead, spycho, with a bad temper....still he was very awsome

5.April O' Neil
OT April: a reporter who always was getting in trouble for getting a good story...a nice appearance but not much of a character developpment
Nt April: Not so nice appearance (and whats with the purple hair? R we watching an anime or something?) Still she had a much better character development and she knew how to defend herself...you go girl!

6.Shredder
OT Shredder: He was the main villain of the turtles. Along with Krang, Bebop and Rocksteady, he was making the turtles' life miserable...at least that was he wanted to do. He always was defeated with a ridiculous and funny way. Plus his relationship with Krang was priceless....and lets not forget that in some episodes we could see something like sexual tension between him and April

NT Shredder: Im trying to forget the fact that the archienemy of the turtles is a tinny winny ugly alien....He was always appearing everytime that the turtles thought that they had been rid of him. Too clever, too stong, too much ego...what can I say...too much cliche... He was like almost every villain in any action show....boring. Oh, and another thing...just how many shredders were in that show???? THAT was annoying.

7.Music (backround)
OT had some memorable tracks, unique and it help the turtles stuck up from other shows

NT had some tracks with more japanese echo to give a more japanese touch, and also the two songs at "city at war" and "april's artifact"...

8. Animation

OT animation was well done consider WHEN these series were on air...of course sometimes we remember that the colour bandanas were mixed or the weapons. The red sky episodes had a much better animation but the back story wasnt my cup of tea.

NT animation was really really good. The bad thing was that from season 6 the whole style had changed and many fans didnt like it (count me in too)

Finally I have too say that as a fan of the turtles I like both series...old and new...I still dont see why many people are fighting over their opion..in the end...IT IS A CARTOON PEOPLE!!!

Fugitoid Jones
02-03-2011, 01:24 PM
5.April O' Neil
OT April: a reporter who always was getting in trouble for getting a good story...a nice appearance but not much of a character developpment
Nt April: Not so nice appearance (and whats with the purple hair? R we watching an anime or something?) Still she had a much better character development and she knew how to defend herself...you go girl!



Which episode of the 2K3 show did she have purple hair? I know she had a purple shirt most eps...

I wish people wouldn't say which show was 'better', because both shows are so vastly different, it's more a matter of opinion, as in which show do you prefer. It's like comparing Jack Nicholson's Joker and Heath Ledger's Joker. Both are different, and it really comes down to which one do you enjoy more.

Wildgoose
02-03-2011, 01:45 PM
Which episode of the 2K3 show did she have purple hair? I know she had a purple shirt most eps...

I wish people wouldn't say which show was 'better', because both shows are so vastly different, it's more a matter of opinion, as in which show do you prefer. It's like comparing Jack Nicholson's Joker and Heath Ledger's Joker. Both are different, and it really comes down to which one do you enjoy more.

Well, you cant describe her hair as red....she had a red-purple color

actually I agree with you +100
that's why I wrote aaaaall that above...to show that both shows were fun to watch and both have their ups and downs...but as a true turtle-fan you must love them all...even the next mutation series...

Leonardo87
02-03-2011, 03:40 PM
b)Mickey
OT Mickey: Really funny character, and his battle cry "cowabunga!!" was a phenomenon. The bad thing is that they took his weapons and gave him a grapling hook...lame
NT Mickey: A little annoying, cute, funny, but still OT rules



...How many times do people have to spell Michelangelo's nickname wrong? It's MIKEY, not Mickey..as in Mouse.


Anyways; I like both the OT and 2k3 series. When the FoxBox and the Ninja Turtles website announced that there was going to be a new Turtle cartoon, I was pretty hyped. I couldn't wait to see what new tale they are going to tell now. When I saw the first episode; I was amazed of how well it looked and I enjoyed the new surrounding. The 80's cartoon (what I grew up on which was no surprise there; along with everyone who was born in the 80's) and the 2k3 cartoon is totally different and it works both ways. It was for a new generation and it worked out greatly.

Slap-Happy
02-22-2011, 02:03 AM
The 2k3 show NEVER had a joke that worked.

Also, the designs in the show and the animation itself, felt like vanilla anime (something that I also don't generally like, apart from a few things)

gobo
02-22-2011, 02:42 AM
The 2k3 show NEVER had a joke that worked.
"Nice hats..."

Avatar Yuffie
02-22-2011, 03:10 AM
I weirdly laugh at the parts when they weren't trying to be funny.

Hun proudly showing off the robots that looks like the US President and the UK Prime Minister for example. I don't think that came up again, but when I first saw that I was laughing like a loon.

Redeemer
02-22-2011, 02:41 PM
Yeah that is probably thing almost everybody will agree on is the lack of good comedy. But I must say they had there moments in the show that made me laugh my ass off. But alot of the time When I heard Mikey try to crack a joke I cringe my teeth or hang my head in dissapointment or! or! or hide behind my.....couch! :tcouch:

PizzaPower
02-22-2011, 09:26 PM
**** i loved the new toon, not a huge huge fan of season 3, but some of them eps where damn good!

Redeemer
02-23-2011, 02:19 PM
**** i loved the new toon, not a huge huge fan of season 3, but some of them eps where damn good!

I thought Season 1 had some of the best episodes in the series, but season 3 was good as well

gobo
02-24-2011, 12:51 AM
It always bothered me, and I never voiced the concern, but I really disliked (most of) Season 3 and found "Exodus" to be an awfully weak finale. Am I actually alone here or do others find it grating that the Turtles could be found out like that just to be so easily dropped from the public consciousness?

Avatar Yuffie
02-24-2011, 03:44 AM
Actually, it's kinda weird Karai didn't get any backlash from New Yorkers... I mean, the rocketship launching from the main Foot HQ, demon Shredder causing havoc when he was invading, that should have raised eyebrows already. Or does Shredder have MIB agents with memory wiping technology?

Sage Ninja
02-25-2011, 12:41 PM
It always bothered me, and I never voiced the concern, but I really disliked (most of) Season 3 and found "Exodus" to be an awfully weak finale. Am I actually alone here or do others find it grating that the Turtles could be found out like that just to be so easily dropped from the public consciousness?
yeah I agree, major plot hole. Actually I thought Exodus was kinda weak too, and it irriated me how it led up to Karia being an even more stupid annoying bitch than she already was. Too bad Leo couldn't have squared off against her while he was still feral and killed her off. That would have been a more interesting twist in my book.

Ninjafromanotherseries
02-27-2011, 02:39 PM
It was shown that the mayor of New York was corrupt and he has influence over police and media so they could come up with some weird story about the rocket.

Also Bishop was there too so I guess government also came up with cover up story.

Avatar Yuffie
02-28-2011, 05:33 AM
It was shown that the mayor of New York was corrupt and he has influence over police and media so they could come up with some weird story about the rocket.

Also Bishop was there too so I guess government also came up with cover up story.

I dunno about the rocket... important party guests were seen falling to their deaths going on there...

voltron80
02-28-2011, 05:47 PM
... 2k3 show?

I didn't really like it. :ohwell:
I didn't like the charcter designs that much, and it was too sci-fi and fantasy for me.

I don't really care for mystic ninja, fedual ninja, Shredder as an Utrom. Stuff like that.

What are your guys' thoughts?

I liked it part of me wished they introduced more villains like they did in the Archie universe. I got love for the old school series but this series out shine it.

rav4ge
02-28-2011, 09:50 PM
I loved the 2003 show as a kid because it was the first time I had seen the Turtles on TV. Up until then, I had been living on remnants of the Mirage comics and the toys. I had no idea they were in production of a brand-new TMNT cartoon series.

Naturally, when I saw the giant Raphael 2003 toy in a store - new art style, box art, and all - I was ecstatic. It was so cool to know a new show was on the way, and that they were bringing the Turtles to my generation.

But about the show - I loved it. I remember I would wake up every Saturday, get my cereal, and sit down and watch before my parents came down. I made my brothers watch too, and they enjoyed it too. It was great.

Unfortunately - but also fortunately (watching the show now, it's obvious the whole thing spiraled downwards) - I didn't get to see many episodes past most of the ones in the first season. I can't remember exactly why... oh, that's right! We moved. I think the channels/times were different so I missed everything after that.

Watching 2k3 today, it still holds up pretty well. The jokes suck sometimes, but at least they're trying. The whole overlaying plot with Shredder's alternate past in season one (and maybe two?) was really well done. Absolutely loved it, and it was a good move on their part not dumbing it down for kids. The show is pretty dark.

TMNT2003 and Spongebob, prime-time stuff of my younger childhood.

PizzaPower
03-01-2011, 07:27 AM
It always bothered me, and I never voiced the concern, but I really disliked (most of) Season 3 and found "Exodus" to be an awfully weak finale. Am I actually alone here or do others find it grating that the Turtles could be found out like that just to be so easily dropped from the public consciousness?
I have to agree, season 3 was my least favorite. I really like the 1 and 2 seasons.

Bauer536
05-21-2011, 07:23 PM
I am glad I am not the only one who feels like this. Here’s a reason why I did not like the 2k3 series:

1.The voice actors. I’m going to have to agree with RiseAbove873. Leo and Don’s voices were not that masculine. That’s probably why I found Leonardo as an annoying whiner. I also hated Casey’s voice. It was too stereotypical, and it sounded like the actor was trying too hard.

2.Some of its characters. Garbageman stunk, Silver Sentry looked freaky and not super, Hun (I want Tatsu!), Bishop looked like Agent Smith, Angel was very annoying, Ancient One was (like I said previously) a nastier and crude version of Yoda, and even Serling, along with the rest of the Fast Forward characters.

3.The animation was not top notch. This did not feel like Batman: The Animated Series. This felt a lot more like Spiderman: The Animated Series. Remember that show? It was like that Spiderman show because of that animation. Same bright colors, not enough shadow. Plus I’ve seen what New York City looks like. It doesn’t remind me of New York. When I watched this series, I never saw the Statue of Liberty or the Empire State Building.

4.Shredder as an Ultrom. Ugh! That just ruins things! So wait, are you trying to tell me that the Shredder was a robot all along? To find out Shredder is an Ultrom is displeasing. Now, if Shredder was brought back to life by Ultroms by adding in one like Krang into his body, that would have been cool. To me, I just thought of Shredder like he was a highlander – human, but completely immortal. :tthumbsd:

5.It’s not Batman. Batman had better storylines. Storylines, I must say, that did not drag on. The 2k3 TMNT series went on and on with science fiction and time travel, I was like “And this is what ninjas do?” Why were there five episodes on the Futigoid and Triceratons? To me, 2 or 3 would have been enough. Same thing for Leo’s temper in the start of season 4. 13??!!! 13 episodes of my favorite character losing it. I don’t know. I would have liked 4 or 5 episodes of this. It went on too long. Even though it gave Leo some attention, it made him a lot more unlikeable. Watching him going off the deep end is like Tony Almeida becoming the villain in season 7 of “24” (Yet, I love “24.” I usually consider Leo to be like Jack Bauer). :tcry:

6.Fast Forward, the Lost Season, Back to the Sewers, and Turtles Forever. I didn't like Fast Forward because the turtles were in the future way too long, the characters like Cody Jones and Serling, and most of the plotlines did not scream ninja action. The Lost Season was too much. Plus, why wasn’t it really released after season 4? Back to the Sewers: hated it. The characters were given the look of the 2k7 CGI depictions, when the show was completely different from the film. Plus, a Cyber Shredder? Are you kidding me? Was Peter Laird really stuck in computer world? Then the worst: Turtles Forever. How embarrassing. Were the OT turtles really that brainless when they first aired on television? Why did they make this film? It makes it appear that the franchise was over, when in reality, it is alive with a new series on the way.

7.Turtle Titan. To me, that’s a silly name for a superhero. My heart was set on Superturtle, because Superman is not called Man Titan. Plus, the storyline with the Justice Force was stupid.

There are other reasons why I did not like this show, but I think we all get the picture. If some of you do like the series, that’s fine. I’m not going to change anyone’s opinions. Hopefully, like I say, the new one will be better. :tgrin:

Koi
05-21-2011, 10:26 PM
I also hated Casey’s voice. It was too stereotypical, and it sounded like the actor was trying too hard.

Every time I watched the 2k3 all I thought about when Casey talked was this.
ISO_8rtguzI

***First of Two Latin Kings***
05-22-2011, 11:50 AM
Same voice actor? Would make sense, I can hear a little Serling in there as well. :tlol:

Galactus
05-22-2011, 03:52 PM
1.The voice actors. I’m going to have to agree with RiseAbove873. Leo and Don’s voices were not that masculine. That’s probably why I found Leonardo as an annoying whiner. I also hated Casey’s voice. It was too stereotypical, and it sounded like the actor was trying too hard.

Arn't you a fan of the '87 show? Certainly none of the turtles in that show sounded overly masculine. Not that every character should have an overly masculine voice. I don't see how Casey's was stereotypical and trying too hard, he's a New Yorker. You may have a case with the ultra gruff Raph trying too hard but I fail to see with Casey.

2.Some of its characters. Garbageman stunk, Silver Sentry looked freaky and not super, Hun (I want Tatsu!), Bishop looked like Agent Smith, Angel was very annoying, Ancient One was (like I said previously) a nastier and crude version of Yoda, and even Serling, along with the rest of the Fast Forward characters.

Again arn't you a fan of the '87 show. How are these worse than Gadgetman, Bug Man, the Badd family, the Polarisoids, Mr Ogg or any of the myriad mad scientists and kooky characters that flooded the Fred Wolf show.

It's not like these characters were used to any great degree and I believe Bishop is supposed to look like Agent Smith, that's the set look for rogue government agents.

3.The animation was not top notch. This did not feel like Batman: The Animated Series. This felt a lot more like Spiderman: The Animated Series. Remember that show? It was like that Spiderman show because of that animation. Same bright colors, not enough shadow. Plus I’ve seen what New York City looks like. It doesn’t remind me of New York. When I watched this series, I never saw the Statue of Liberty or the Empire State Building.

Again arn't you a fan of the '87. Apart from season 1 and odd episodes here and there that was hardly top notch animation, proof you can generaly forgive a cartoon bad animation if everything else is "right".

I'm by no means an expert on todays animation but seasons 3 and 4 seemed like it was the best or close that could be done at the time.

Also we did see the Statue of Liberty a few times as well as the UN and even other New York landmarks like Belvedere Castle in the '03 show. Even the outline of Manhattan Island seemed right. So you're wrong there.

4.Shredder as an Ultrom. Ugh! That just ruins things! So wait, are you trying to tell me that the Shredder was a robot all along? To find out Shredder is an Ultrom is displeasing. Now, if Shredder was brought back to life by Ultroms by adding in one like Krang into his body, that would have been cool. To me, I just thought of Shredder like he was a highlander – human, but completely immortal.

That particular plot point was certainly divisive. I personaly thought it was a stroke of genius, it took some balls for a show that was at that point quite accurate to the comic to deviate in such a way and allowed things which we wouldn't have gotten otherwise. Although I certainly understand why some hate it and now it's been done I wouldn't want to see it again.

Your suggestion doesn't much sense. So Saki would have an evil Utrom in his stomach??? :roll:

5.It’s not Batman. Batman had better storylines. Storylines, I must say, that did not drag on. The 2k3 TMNT series went on and on with science fiction and time travel, I was like “And this is what ninjas do?” Why were there five episodes on the Futigoid and Triceratons? To me, 2 or 3 would have been enough. Same thing for Leo’s temper in the start of season 4. 13??!!! 13 episodes of my favorite character losing it. I don’t know. I would have liked 4 or 5 episodes of this. It went on too long. Even though it gave Leo some attention, it made him a lot more unlikeable. Watching him going off the deep end is like Tony Almeida becoming the villain in season 7 of “24” (Yet, I love “24.” I usually consider Leo to be like Jack Bauer).

Who said it was Batman? I believe the show is Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Space adventures and time travel are part of turtle canon almost all of the '03 shows episodes devoted to this adaptions of the comic.

Not all of the turtles adventures of based around the ninja aspect. To be honest I'm not sure if any version has ever portrayed them truly as ninjas but certainly the '03 was one of the better attempts.

Oh...and again arn't you a fan of the '87 show where space adventures, aliens, dimension hopping, time travel and the like were rife? When did those turtles do what ninjas do?

6.Fast Forward, the Lost Season, Back to the Sewers, and Turtles Forever. I didn't like Fast Forward because the turtles were in the future way too long, the characters like Cody Jones and Serling, and most of the plotlines did not scream ninja action. The Lost Season was too much. Plus, why wasn’t it really released after season 4? Back to the Sewers: hated it. The characters were given the look of the 2k7 CGI depictions, when the show was completely different from the film. Plus, a Cyber Shredder? Are you kidding me? Was Peter Laird really stuck in computer world? Then the worst: Turtles Forever. How embarrassing. Were the OT turtles really that brainless when they first aired on television? Why did they make this film? It makes it appear that the franchise was over, when in reality, it is alive with a new series on the way.

Do I really need to use...arn't you a fan of the '87 show? remember the Red Sky seasons with Carter, Dregg and co and the turtles mutations. To be honest I'd take Fast Forward story and characters over those.

Fast Foward was pushed into creation because Playmates wanted to sell their FF toys right then and there since the toy sales were starting to wane. Season 5 or the Lost Season might not have even been made if not by Laird's push and the good grace of 4kids. Same with BTTS was done partly to sell leftover toys from the movie. (Both cartoons are essentialy 30 minute toy commercials)

It's been hotly debated everywhere but the things that some fans found wrong about depiction of the '87 turtles in that movie can be stemmed back to things from the old show. Between how faithfully the characters and their world were recreated and the numerous easter eggs in there I'd say Turtles Forever was more than generous to the '87 show.

The Movie was made to celebrate the 25th anniversary of the turtles franchise. But for the record at the time it was made the franchise was being put to bed, they'd had their second wind and everything was ending bar a movie in a few years time. But since then Nickleodeon buy the franchise and now we got new cartoons and new toys for kids and overgrown kids alike to buy.

Thank you for playing.:tcool:

FearlessLeader
05-22-2011, 04:19 PM
3.The animation was not top notch. This did not feel like Batman: The Animated Series. This felt a lot more like Spiderman: The Animated Series. Remember that show? It was like that Spiderman show because of that animation. Same bright colors, not enough shadow. Plus I’ve seen what New York City looks like. It doesn’t remind me of New York. When I watched this series, I never saw the Statue of Liberty or the Empire State Building.

Go to New York City sometime before you say this. While not always 100% perfect they do a pretty damn good job of representing the City in this show. There have a been a few shots were I have even laughed because I remember standing on the street the characters are standing on.


4.Shredder as an Ultrom. Ugh! That just ruins things! So wait, are you trying to tell me that the Shredder was a robot all along? To find out Shredder is an Ultrom is displeasing. Now, if Shredder was brought back to life by Ultroms by adding in one like Krang into his body, that would have been cool. To me, I just thought of Shredder like he was a highlander – human, but completely immortal. :tthumbsd:


The character is called an UTROM


5.It’s not Batman. Batman had better storylines. Storylines, I must say, that did not drag on. The 2k3 TMNT series went on and on with science fiction and time travel, I was like “And this is what ninjas do?” Why were there five episodes on the Futigoid and Triceratons? To me, 2 or 3 would have been enough. Same thing for Leo’s temper in the start of season 4. 13??!!! 13 episodes of my favorite character losing it. I don’t know. I would have liked 4 or 5 episodes of this. It went on too long. Even though it gave Leo some attention, it made him a lot more unlikeable. Watching him going off the deep end is like Tony Almeida becoming the villain in season 7 of “24” (Yet, I love “24.” I usually consider Leo to be like Jack Bauer). :tcry:


I said everything I needed to say about Leonardo's season 4 character development in the Leonardo thread. There you said I had finally explained it in a way you understood, from your comments here that perhaps was not true.

As for all your complaints about what the show consisted of?? Have you ever even watched Turtles before or read the comic books. EVERY version of Turtles is packed full of sci-fi/ fantasy elements. Even if the 2007 film had the 13 monsters storyline.

6.Fast Forward, the Lost Season, Back to the Sewers, and Turtles Forever. I didn't like Fast Forward because the turtles were in the future way too long, the characters like Cody Jones and Serling, and most of the plotlines did not scream ninja action. The Lost Season was too much. Plus, why wasn’t it really released after season 4? Back to the Sewers: hated it. The characters were given the look of the 2k7 CGI depictions, when the show was completely different from the film. Plus, a Cyber Shredder? Are you kidding me? Was Peter Laird really stuck in computer world? Then the worst: Turtles Forever. How embarrassing. Were the OT turtles really that brainless when they first aired on television? Why did they make this film? It makes it appear that the franchise was over, when in reality, it is alive with a new series on the way.


Your Turtle's Forever statement was what actually made me want to reply to you. You do understand the reason the film was created right?? It was created in honor of the 25th anniversary of franchise. That's why ALL the Turtles were involved. It was made as something ALL fans of the Turtles could enjoy together and honored every aspect of the franchise.

How it is embarrassing makes absolutely no sense.

I mean god forbid 4Kids and Mirage make something nice for the fandom in honor of all of us sticking by the guys for 25 years :tgrumble:

As for everything else Galactus said pretty much everything I feel about all the other topics you covered.

Candy Kappa
05-22-2011, 05:44 PM
don't think ya need to waste time on Bauer, he be trollin'

just misspelling Utrom is proof enough :P

ABrown
05-22-2011, 07:39 PM
I am glad I am not the only one who feels like this. Here’s a reason why I did not like the 2k3 series:

1.The voice actors. I really liked the vocal cast for the 2003 series. It's as good as I possibly could've hoped for.
2.Some of its characters.I'll have to agree with you on the Garbageman. He was a pretty stupid character. Fortunately he only appeared in a couple of episodes. Asides for him, I really liked the other characters that you mentioned. I thought that Bishop was awesome. And the other characters weren't bad.
3.The animation was not top notch.I don't know, I really liked the animation. The Fast Forward and Back To The Sewers animation wasn't quite as good, but I still enjoyed it.
4.Shredder as an Ultrom. Ugh! That just ruins things! True, I have to agree that the Shredder turning out to be an utrom was a horrible idea. But I was ok with it since we didn't see him in his utrom form in every episode. I really sometimes think that the writers knew that it was a bad idea, and that's why we rarely ever saw him in his utrom form.
5.It’s not Batman. Batman had better storylines.
Now this is a matter of personal preference. Batman:The Animated Series had basically stand alone stories. The 2003 TMNT had ongoing stories. Neither version is right or wrong. I personally prefer the ongoing stories. But like I said, it's a matter of personal preference.
6.Fast Forward, the Lost Season, Back to the Sewers, and Turtles Forever. Give the Fast Forward episodes another chance, they're not that bad. I don't think they're as good as the first five seasons, but they're ok. I will agree that the Back To The Sewer season wasn't all that great. But the show was past its prime. I wouldn't have wanted the show to continue for an additional ten years in the BTTS style. Better to let it end with some dignity.
7.Turtle Titan.Turtle Titan was cool! Now if Michaelangelo had dressed up like Turtle Titan in every episode, that would've gotten old very fast. But the way that the creators handled it, I really like the concept.

Jo Dawn
05-22-2011, 11:21 PM
I really liked the 2K3 show... when it first started.

They kind of started to lose me when they began to overemphasize certain personality traits. Mikey screaming like a girl? Funny. I cried, I laughed so hard. Mikey screaming like a girl every. Other. Episode? It got old. But it still wasn't enough to put me off. What did that was (everyone say it with me together now):

Fast Forward. It was awful. It annoyed me. I couldn't stand Cody. Oh, I loathe a kid sidekick. Fifth turtle. Ugh. I actually don't think I watched the end of the show.

Other than that, I was very pleased, like I said. Most important to me is voice acting ( which I approved of), personality traits (which were also fine), and writing, all of which were fine to better-than-fine to really-good.

CyberCubed
05-22-2011, 11:51 PM
Why are people nitpicking extremely minor or short-lived characters as if we saw a lot of them?

Someone complained Angel is annoying. She appeared in what....2 episodes tops with a speaking role?

Garbageman? He was in 2 episodes.

The Ancient one? Sure I can see how he would bother people, but it was easy to ignore the bad parts.

Spitfire
05-23-2011, 04:09 AM
Why are people nitpicking extremely minor or short-lived characters as if we saw a lot of them?

Because nitpicking is the foundation of the TMNT fandom. It's especially necessary when we get something awesome, like a statue of a character whose never gotten one before. Nothing shows appreciation more than nitpicking.

k_lala
05-23-2011, 10:29 AM
This series was my ALL TIME FAVORITE CARTOON SHOW OF ALL TIME!!

k_lala
05-23-2011, 10:39 AM
I am glad I am not the only one who feels like this. Here’s a reason why I did not like the 2k3 series:

1.The voice actors. I’m going to have to agree with RiseAbove873. Leo and Don’s voices were not that masculine. That’s probably why I found Leonardo as an annoying whiner. I also hated Casey’s voice. It was too stereotypical, and it sounded like the actor was trying too hard.

2.Some of its characters. Garbageman stunk, Silver Sentry looked freaky and not super, Hun (I want Tatsu!), Bishop looked like Agent Smith, Angel was very annoying, Ancient One was (like I said previously) a nastier and crude version of Yoda, and even Serling, along with the rest of the Fast Forward characters.

3.The animation was not top notch. This did not feel like Batman: The Animated Series. This felt a lot more like Spiderman: The Animated Series. Remember that show? It was like that Spiderman show because of that animation. Same bright colors, not enough shadow. Plus I’ve seen what New York City looks like. It doesn’t remind me of New York. When I watched this series, I never saw the Statue of Liberty or the Empire State Building.

4.Shredder as an Ultrom. Ugh! That just ruins things! So wait, are you trying to tell me that the Shredder was a robot all along? To find out Shredder is an Ultrom is displeasing. Now, if Shredder was brought back to life by Ultroms by adding in one like Krang into his body, that would have been cool. To me, I just thought of Shredder like he was a highlander – human, but completely immortal. :tthumbsd:

5.It’s not Batman. Batman had better storylines. Storylines, I must say, that did not drag on. The 2k3 TMNT series went on and on with science fiction and time travel, I was like “And this is what ninjas do?” Why were there five episodes on the Futigoid and Triceratons? To me, 2 or 3 would have been enough. Same thing for Leo’s temper in the start of season 4. 13??!!! 13 episodes of my favorite character losing it. I don’t know. I would have liked 4 or 5 episodes of this. It went on too long. Even though it gave Leo some attention, it made him a lot more unlikeable. Watching him going off the deep end is like Tony Almeida becoming the villain in season 7 of “24” (Yet, I love “24.” I usually consider Leo to be like Jack Bauer). :tcry:

6.Fast Forward, the Lost Season, Back to the Sewers, and Turtles Forever. I didn't like Fast Forward because the turtles were in the future way too long, the characters like Cody Jones and Serling, and most of the plotlines did not scream ninja action. The Lost Season was too much. Plus, why wasn’t it really released after season 4? Back to the Sewers: hated it. The characters were given the look of the 2k7 CGI depictions, when the show was completely different from the film. Plus, a Cyber Shredder? Are you kidding me? Was Peter Laird really stuck in computer world? Then the worst: Turtles Forever. How embarrassing. Were the OT turtles really that brainless when they first aired on television? Why did they make this film? It makes it appear that the franchise was over, when in reality, it is alive with a new series on the way.

7.Turtle Titan. To me, that’s a silly name for a superhero. My heart was set on Superturtle, because Superman is not called Man Titan. Plus, the storyline with the Justice Force was stupid.

There are other reasons why I did not like this show, but I think we all get the picture. If some of you do like the series, that’s fine. I’m not going to change anyone’s opinions. Hopefully, like I say, the new one will be better. :tgrin:

I can respect your opinion, to each is own right? Is it ok if I disagree? I do because I really love this show and we both are turtle fans so our heart is there.

As far as the voice actors. I thought Leo and Don's voice were great! I wouldn't want a too masculine voice, kind of the like the Mirage voices in the Forever movie. It fit just right! Casey's voice was PERFECT!! Too stereotypical...it was CASEY! That's like saying Raph and Mikey's voice is too stereotypical...those guys sounded just like they should sound. They have an identity. I feel they hit it just right...also the Shredders voice was PERFECT!

I thought the animation and design was excellent from Seasons 1-5. FF and BTTS, yes I agree, it sucked. The only knock i have on Seasons 1-5 is that they had scenes where if you zoomed in you can see the blurry details of it. They did have enough shadows and detail in the first 5 seasons, the main part of the show.

Your point with Shredder as an Utrom, i can respect that pov..at first I too was upset with this, but as the series went on and how it all came together, i'm happy with how it all went down. I really enjoyed the shredder utrom and the history of the Shredders, at least there was a REAL Oroku Saki.

The story lines were GREAT! I really enjoyed the story arcs, that's what I really loved about the series, not a lot of silly one offs. The Shredder strikes arc, ALL there arcs were great. That's what made the show so intense and excellent.

Anything regarding FF or BTTS, i will not argue with you. I thought FF was ok, I HATE BTTS. I do though love the the main 2K3 series.

Coola Yagami
05-23-2011, 11:36 AM
I still feel some comedy was forced, especially when some of the plots had alot of serious stuff on the line. Sometimes it looks like the editor read the script and told the writers, 'good. now throw some jokes in there'. 'but sir... the Triceratons are taking over everything in this one, we're talking apacolypse here' "I SAID THROW SOME JOKES IN THERE, DAMMIT!!!"

FearlessLeader
05-23-2011, 12:15 PM
I still feel some comedy was forced, especially when some of the plots had alot of serious stuff on the line. Sometimes it looks like the editor read the script and told the writers, 'good. now throw some jokes in there'. 'but sir... the Triceratons are taking over everything in this one, we're talking apacolypse here' "I SAID THROW SOME JOKES IN THERE, DAMMIT!!!"

Well the show is far from perfect. This is one area I totally agree with you about. I just have a feeling someone higher up figured certain scenes were getting to intense for a little kid and told them to throw in a joke to lighten the mood. Sadly that just often made Mike look like a moron because he often said the jokes and it was really completely inappropriate at the time.

I still think the good points of the show far outweighed the bad and for a kids TMNT show I think they put a lot more passion and love into the work then I would have imaged they would.

I said this somewhere else but I'll repeat it again, I think I lot is owed to the majority of the production staff that genuinely loved the franchise and really pushed what boundaries they could to try to make it the best Saturday morning interpretation of the comics I think we could get.

ABrown
05-23-2011, 01:10 PM
I still feel some comedy was forced, especially when some of the plots had alot of serious stuff on the line. Sometimes it looks like the editor read the script and told the writers, 'good. now throw some jokes in there'. 'but sir... the Triceratons are taking over everything in this one, we're talking apacolypse here' "I SAID THROW SOME JOKES IN THERE, DAMMIT!!!"

Well the show is far from perfect. This is one area I totally agree with you about. I just have a feeling someone higher up figured certain scenes were getting to intense for a little kid and told them to throw in a joke to lighten the mood. Sadly that just often made Mike look like a moron because he often said the jokes and it was really completely inappropriate at the time.

Really??? I found the 2003 TMNT to be absolutely hilarious at times. I never really found the original TMNT cartoon to be funny. Silly? Sure, not really funny. I never really felt like they were forcing comedy in the 2003 show. I mean I remember exactly when they were using humor during the Triceraton invasion. But I thought that it worked really well. If I were gonna say that either of the turtles cartoons had humor forced into the show, I'd say it was the original cartoon, not the 2003 one.

FearlessLeader
05-23-2011, 01:17 PM
Really??? I found the 2003 TMNT to be absolutely hilarious at times. I never really found the original TMNT cartoon to be funny. Silly? Sure, not really funny. I never really felt like they were forcing comedy in the 2003 show. I mean I remember exactly when they were using humor during the Triceraton invasion. But I thought that it worked really well. If I were gonna say that either of the turtles cartoons had humor forced into the show, I'd say it was the original cartoon, not the 2003 one.


Oh it's not all the time during the show, I too believe that 2k3 has some genuinely very funny moments. Raphael and Casey especially usually crack me up.

But it at least in my mind did has some forced humor. The first one that springs to mind for me was during Return to New York part 2 or 3 I can't recall which. The guys are fighting the Shredder things are really serious and Mike makes a crack about how he'd rather stay and fight because the cable's out at the lair anyway, so he has nothing to do.

Early in this trilogy of episodes Mikey's banter was funny. I still laugh at the part where they escape the Shredder clones and Mikey does the "I know I'll make clones of me REALLY ugly ones!" in the Shredder like voice.

It was just right here, with the life and death battle of his family happening around him, it seemed like a really inappropriate time to be making a joke, at least to me.

SuperIronRobo
05-23-2011, 01:59 PM
the OT had much sci fi and fantasy the 2k3. so invalid argument. If dealing with a warlord from another dimension, a ninja master with a robot legion and different mutants isn't sci fi then what is? Plus the turtleoids thing is pretty science fiction. TMNT in general is science fiction. The more science fiction in TMNT, the better IMHO. but I have to say, the OT fanbase is the worse since all they want is everything to be a rehash of the OT. We got TMNT 2k3, Season 1 to 4 is as close to the comics we can get I suppose. But I would like them to combine the best of 2K3 and the OT. Seriously or they can do something entirely original. The only limit with TMNT is you're imagination IMO.

Slap-Happy
05-23-2011, 03:08 PM
the OT had much sci fi and fantasy the 2k3. so invalid argument. If dealing with a warlord from another dimension, a ninja master with a robot legion and different mutants isn't sci fi then what is? Plus the turtleoids thing is pretty science fiction. TMNT in general is science fiction. The more science fiction in TMNT, the better IMHO. but I have to say, the OT fanbase is the worse since all they want is everything to be a rehash of the OT. We got TMNT 2k3, Season 1 to 4 is as close to the comics we can get I suppose. But I would like them to combine the best of 2K3 and the OT. Seriously or they can do something entirely original. The only limit with TMNT is you're imagination IMO.
While it did have sci fi elements, it definitely didn't have as much as 2k3. I can deal with some sci fi and fantasy stuff here and there, but 2k3 had it for the majority of it's episodes, all the way into fast forward and back to the sewers.

k_lala
05-23-2011, 03:59 PM
Bleah, can people stop talking about FF and BTTS...its completely different than seasons 1-5...i know its technically canon but we aren't really comparing apples to apples here.

The direction, writing, art, design, action....EVERYTHING was different. To me i feel like FF and BTTS is a separate show altogether.

Galactus
05-23-2011, 05:07 PM
While it did have sci fi elements, it definitely didn't have as much as 2k3. I can deal with some sci fi and fantasy stuff here and there, but 2k3 had it for the majority of it's episodes, all the way into fast forward and back to the sewers.

Did you actualy watch either show?

Surely this isn't something that's subjective to each viewer, clearly the old show was way more sci fi.

The turtles and most of the characters and concepts are inherantly science fiction to begin with but when it comes to something overtly sci fi surely the '87 show takes the prize.

Right from the off the Fred Wolf show was sci fi orientated with Krang and the Tecnodrome as fixtures. Every season had regular team ups with the Neutrinos, alien incursions, more than a few full on alien invasions, escaped monsters from Dimension-X. An endless parade of mad scientists with way out inventions...even gangsters were generaly armed with shrink rays or clone machines or things to make people laugh as well as magnets for mens underwear.

None of that is a knock to the old show obviously that's what worked for it but I'm not sure how anyone can think it's less sci fi than the 2k3 show.

Cure
05-23-2011, 05:13 PM
To me i feel like FF and BTTS is a separate show altogether.

But...they're not, whether you like it or not.

Bauer536
05-23-2011, 06:06 PM
Ouch! You got me! I will admit; I am a TMNT fan, but I’m obviously not a TMNT expert. I have not read every single comic book or seen every episode of each series. I was having a gut reaction over some things I’ve seen, heard, or read. Also, Fearless Leader, I understood your point that day. Unfortunately, I was not thinking about that when I posted on this forum. I didn’t mean to offend anyone, I’ve learned so much from all of you. I’m still learning a whole lot more on a few other threads. Thank you for the information.
Just to add: I’m sorry that I called an Utrom an Ultrom (I must have read it fast all the time that I didn’t catch it). Plus, I will admit, I was wrong about the science fiction and wacky moments seen in the franchise. I do like it, so everything doesn’t have to be too “ninja” on TMNT.

k_lala
05-23-2011, 06:56 PM
But...they're not, whether you like it or not.

It is somewhat of a separate show though. That's why it was called

TMNT Fast Forward
TMNT Back to the Sewers

I mean I understand that its canon BUUUUUUTT the creative, artistic, writing was all different compared to the main series. Heck even BTTS is different than FF. Even though we are talking about Fruits....we still are comparing Apples to Oranges to Peaches.

Wait...is Apple a fruit?

Redeemer
05-23-2011, 08:19 PM
It is somewhat of a separate show though. That's why it was called

TMNT Fast Forward
TMNT Back to the Sewers

I mean I understand that its canon BUUUUUUTT the creative, artistic, writing was all different compared to the main series. Heck even BTTS is different than FF. Even though we are talking about Fruits....we still are comparing Apples to Oranges to Peaches.

Wait...is Apple a fruit?

Apple is a fruit

and I agree with u I dont think FF and BTTS should be grouped with Season 1-5

Cure
05-23-2011, 09:31 PM
It is somewhat of a separate show though.

But...they're not. You can argue all you want, won't change a thing. Shows change along the way all the time, doesn't make them separate.

ABrown
05-24-2011, 11:16 AM
But...they're not. You can argue all you want, won't change a thing. Shows change along the way all the time, doesn't make them separate.

Agreed, they're the same show. Batman:The Animated Series/The New Batman Adventures = same show. Beast Wars/Beast Machines = same show. Justice League/Justice League Unlimited = same show.

CyberCubed
05-24-2011, 11:22 AM
Almost every serialized TV show in existence changes quite a bit from season to season. Some of you act like you don't watch TV at all.

Sometimes shows are completely different in their last season than what they were in their first season.

k_lala
05-24-2011, 07:33 PM
Well I think I do have a valid argument here's why.

The thread is talking about the 2K3 series and how they didn't like it. etc....

So if someone talks about well i didn't like the artwork or design/animation it was too bright and not enough detail....

When I see that statement i think of FF or BTTS not so much the main series.

So whether it was the writing, art, or whatever they didn't like....I just feel like you have to talk about it separately. Was it the FF you didn't like...was it the BTTS...or was it the 1-5 seasons. I don't think you can group it all together to make it whole if that makes sense? Like my fruit analogy...If i bit the orange and said it was too sour.... I can't say I didn't like the fruits bcuz it was sour. When the apple and banana is there..... wait is banana a fruit?

Because the creative direction changed for all 3.

Cure
05-24-2011, 09:57 PM
Jesus, it's like talking to a wall.

Koi
05-24-2011, 10:33 PM
Well I think I do have a valid argument here's why.
Because the creative direction changed for all 3.

Hey, I want you to go watch the first episode of FF, because to me it looks like it is a continuation of the 2k3 episodes. Then you should go watch the BTTS first ep, because it looks like a continuation of FF. Also notice the reoccurring characters and returning plot points through FF and BTTS. You can't freakin argue that they aren't part of each other, because they are. No matter the change in artwork.

Go look at the OT, the art style in that changes over years. Just because something about the damn show changes or is off compared to the other parts doesn't mean it isn't a continuation of the older crap.

On topic, my favourite season of the 2k3 was all the FF episodes. BTTS wasn't as good as FF, but I'd rather watch it then some of the earlier 2k3 seasons.

k_lala
05-25-2011, 09:27 AM
Hey listen...i never said the SHOW WASN'T CANON!! That's not what i'm talking about. FF and BTTS is part of the 2K3 series I know that.

What i'm talking about is this. When we a talking about the 2K3 series as a whole and critiquing it... it should be critiqued in separate parts because those 3 shows were different even though they were canon.

I gave examples...like if someone said I did not like the show because of the stupid fight scenes. Seasons 1-5 had great fight scenes. FF was average....BTTS was a joke. That's why I feel 2K3 should be critiqued separately...even the shows are canon the creative direction was not.

My argument was NEVER that the shows aren't canon...my argument is that when critiquing 2K3 it should be critiqued as 2K3...(the main)...then Fast Forward....and then BTTS. The reason why? It's because all 3 shows were different! The feel, the writing, the art, the action...all the creative direction! That's why the critiques should be divided separately...That's all!! I never argued it wasn't canon...although i wish it was but I know it is. Maybe I mispoke and I apologize for that. Maybe i didn't explain this well enough. TO be clear...2K3 is the main series, FF, and BTTS. I'm not debating that...I am saying though since all three shows are different (I dont think anyone can deny that). That is why when critiquing the show, it should be critiqued SEPARATELY!!

Since this is what the thread is about! It's about critiquing the 2K3 series. I think my post clears this all up.

Koi
05-25-2011, 01:32 PM
I didn't say anything about anything about being canon or not. I was just saying they are all parts of the same show.

Redeemer
05-25-2011, 02:03 PM
Hey, I want you to go watch the first episode of FF, because to me it looks like it is a continuation of the 2k3 episodes. Then you should go watch the BTTS first ep, because it looks like a continuation of FF. Also notice the reoccurring characters and returning plot points through FF and BTTS. You can't freakin argue that they aren't part of each other, because they are. No matter the change in artwork.


^This does not mean anything imo bc the first three movies are clearly sequals, but then about a decade later TMNT comes out its not considered a sequal by any means, but has reoccuring characters and even a continuation of the storyline.

Also Beast Wars and Transformers were two completely different shows, but was a continaution of the storyline and reoccuring characters and they are two shows not one.

So this does not mean anything.

Anyways back on topic, I loved the 2k3 series overal and I thought FF and BTTS was ok. My main complaint for the 2k3 series is that the Shredder was an alien. Also I hate how they made Mikey into a complete retard at times...

CyberCubed
05-25-2011, 02:14 PM
To be fair Mike didn't become annoying till Fast Forward. Only in a few older eps he was bad,

gobo
05-25-2011, 02:32 PM
More concisely put, Fast Forward was when Mikey became consistently intolerable.

Redeemer
05-25-2011, 02:35 PM
To be fair Mike didn't become annoying till Fast Forward. Only in a few older eps he was bad,

Yeah I agree, I think it was more than a few episodes too me, it was pretty much hit and miss with Mikey and his joking. I will say I am glad hes not a complete idiot like characters in Family Guy and so on.

In FF he did get worse, in BTTS I really cant even remember him being that bad, I think thats bc I try to block that season from my mind lol

k_lala
05-25-2011, 02:40 PM
I didn't say anything about anything about being canon or not. I was just saying they are all parts of the same show.

You just specifically asked me to go watch FF and BTTS to see if they were part of the same show. That's basically saying that its canon. I know they are canon. I was never arguing that point. Canon basically means its part of the same show or universe.

Redeemer
05-25-2011, 02:50 PM
Jst came to my mind why didn't the Rat King show up more?? I saw the end of an episode that foreshadowed his character, but I dont remember seeing him again??

gobo
05-25-2011, 03:03 PM
I saw the end of an episode that foreshadowed his character, but I dont remember seeing him again??
Cuz that was the last ep ever. :P

Spitfire
05-25-2011, 03:21 PM
^This does not mean anything imo bc the first three movies are clearly sequals, but then about a decade later TMNT comes out its not considered a sequal by any means, but has reoccuring characters and even a continuation of the storyline.

You really can't compare a season break between series to a 10+ year gap between movies, where it's never made clear if they're connected or not. Fact is FF continued the 2K3 story. It's made very clear when 2K3 events are referenced in FF and of course again in BTTS, which clearly follows FF.

Just because you think a season of something sucks doesn't mean it isn't part of the same series. Season 2 of the 96 Hulk cartoon is horrid but it's still apart of the series no matter how I feel about it.

Examples
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles_%282003%29_ep isodes
http://www.tvshowsondvd.com/shows/Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles/6245
http://www.tvguide.com/tvshows/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles/episodes/195665
http://www.tv.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-2003/show/11995/episode.html?tag=page_nav;episode

Notice how they all count the episodes together? Yeah.

Redeemer
05-25-2011, 03:29 PM
You really can't compare a season break between series to a 10+ year gap between movies, where it's never made clear if they're connected or not. Fact is FF continued the 2K3 story. It's made very clear when 2K3 events are referenced in FF and of course again in BTTS, which clearly follows FF.

Just because you think a season of something sucks doesn't mean it isn't part of the same series. Season 2 of the 96 Hulk cartoon is horrid but it's still apart of the series no matter how I feel about it.

Examples
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles_%282003%29_ep isodes
http://www.tvshowsondvd.com/shows/Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles/6245
http://www.tvguide.com/tvshows/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles/episodes/195665
http://www.tv.com/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-2003/show/11995/episode.html?tag=page_nav;episode

Notice how they all count the episodes together? Yeah.

Well like I said Best Wars and Tranformers follow each other in terms of storyline but yet they are two separate shows. So yeah There is precedent for it.

And have u seen TMNT? A couple times? I didn't see it until the second time, but at the end on Splinter's shelf. It has the Shredder's mask, The canister of Ooze, The Timecepter and Japaneese Mask. It is definantly a continuation of the storyline

Koi
05-25-2011, 03:33 PM
You just specifically asked me to go watch FF and BTTS to see if they were part of the same show. That's basically saying that its canon. I know they are canon. I was never arguing that point. Canon basically means its part of the same show or universe.

I don't think you know what canon means.

Spitfire
05-25-2011, 03:38 PM
Well like I said Best Wars and Tranformers follow each other in terms of storyline but yet they are two separate shows. So yeah There is precedent for it.
Except it ended in 1988 and Beast Wars is from 1996. Also no one ever calls Beast Wars season 6 of Transformers as to where everywhere refers to FF and BTTS as seasons 6 and 7.

And have u seen TMNT? A couple times? I didn't see it until the second time, but at the end on Splinter's shelf. It has the Shredder's mask, The canister of Ooze, The Timecepter and Japaneese Mask. It is definantly a continuation of the storyline

Because none of those things were in the comic, oh wait...There's a Triceration mask there too, don't recall those from the other movies. Also I believe the Ooze canister says TCRI and not TGRI.

gobo
05-25-2011, 03:50 PM
'Canon' is one of those things you have to light in order to shoot in Lego Pirates Of The Carribbean.

Redeemer
05-25-2011, 06:11 PM
Except it ended in 1988 and Beast Wars is from 1996. Also no one ever calls Beast Wars season 6 of Transformers as to where everywhere refers to FF and BTTS as seasons 6 and 7.



Because none of those things were in the comic, oh wait...There's a Triceration mask there too, don't recall those from the other movies. Also I believe the Ooze canister says TCRI and not TGRI.

I was talking about the season/show after Beast Wars. I was really young so if someone could help me, but anyways Bottom Line its the BTTS+FF is apart of the 2k3 series weahter I like it or not, but I will no refer to FF or BTTS as apart of 2K3 bc they are both very different from 2k3 as well as each other

Cure
05-25-2011, 06:16 PM
I don't see how anyone can argue what's official and what's not. Fast Forward and Back to the Sewers are OFFICIALLY seasons 6 and 7, according to the OFFICIAL ninjaturtles.com website. It's retarded, really.

CyberCubed
05-25-2011, 06:17 PM
All the events in them are directly continued too.

This reminds me of some people who didn't like TNBA because they changed all the designs of the characters from B:TAS.

Redeemer
05-25-2011, 06:23 PM
I don't see how anyone can argue what's official and what's not. Fast Forward and Back to the Sewers are OFFICIALLY seasons 6 and 7, according to the OFFICIAL ninjaturtles.com website. It's retarded, really.

Ur retarded really

Lol only joking I am just giving my arguements of why I dont group FF and BTTS with S1-S5. Yeah its the same series, but not in my book and never will be.

k_lala
05-25-2011, 06:40 PM
Ur retarded really

Lol only joking I am just giving my arguements of why I dont group FF and BTTS with S1-S5. Yeah its the same series, but not in my book and never will be.

Don't bother, its like talking to a wall with that guy.

Jester
05-25-2011, 06:46 PM
I know I for one didn't like either of the first 2 animated series. You know the first series with Shredder and Krang as the main villains, then the second one with Dregg.

See what I did there?

Redeemer
05-25-2011, 06:49 PM
I know I for one didn't like either of the first 2 animated series. You know the first series with Shredder and Krang as the main villains, then the second one with Dregg.

See what I did there?

lol good one Jester I dont think u really feel that way, lol

Jo Dawn
05-25-2011, 06:50 PM
I know I for one didn't like either of the first 2 animated series. You know the first series with Shredder and Krang as the main villains, then the second one with Dregg.

See what I did there?

Nice try, friend.

Cure
05-25-2011, 07:05 PM
Don't bother, its like talking to a wall with that guy.

I get it, cuz it's what I said about you. Clever.

CyberCubed
05-25-2011, 07:15 PM
LOL @ people still trying to pass off different seasons as different series.

Once again, how many other TV shows in existence go through drastic changes from season to season, with main character leaving the show, new ones coming in, and the show being taken in a different direction?

Almost every serialized TV show in existence has drastic changes season from season. The last season of any particular show is usually very different than the first.

k_lala
05-25-2011, 08:19 PM
LOL @ people still trying to pass off different seasons as different series.

Once again, how many other TV shows in existence go through drastic changes from season to season, with main character leaving the show, new ones coming in, and the show being taken in a different direction?

Almost every serialized TV show in existence has drastic changes season from season. The last season of any particular show is usually very different than the first.
No at least I am not but I think you think I am saying that? I swear did you or the other guy even read what i said to clear all the confusion up? I know that seasons 1-5, FF and BTTS = 2K3 TMNT. I Know that...i'm just saying if we are critiquing the show...lets critique it in those 3 parts because those 3 shows are different. You just said and admitted its different...omg wow we agree!

Just like how some people said Mikey got annoying in FF or real annoying in BTTS. I just don't understand why people are not understanding what I am saying but continue to fight me on this.

Jo Dawn
05-25-2011, 09:09 PM
What we got here, is a failure to co-mmu-ni-cate. ;)

I think, what's going on here, is misunderstanding. 2K3/FF/BTTS, are all one series, yes. I think we can all agree on that. Are they different? Well, yes. But they are all one series.

So, just like every show out there, the show went through some changes. To fully critique the show, it has take every facet of the series into consideration. Unless, the discussion is only about a certain season of the show.

Would there be less confusion in the thread if, say, it was noted that the characterizations began to wane in Season 6? (Which would be FF, I believe.)

Jester
05-25-2011, 09:12 PM
I think it's an argument of semantics: >> and BttS have the subheads/titles...thus...NEW SERIES! But using that logic, JL and JLU are 2 different shows, too.

Jo Dawn
05-25-2011, 09:18 PM
I think it's an argument of semantics: >> and BttS have the subheads/titles...thus...NEW SERIES! But using that logic, JL and JLU are 2 different shows, too.

Don't belittle me in front of the kids, my dear. ;) :P

gobo
05-25-2011, 09:19 PM
I think, what's going on here, is misunderstanding.
I don't get it. Could you explain? Slower and in smaller words? I'm so confused.

Koi
05-25-2011, 09:28 PM
http://img855.imageshack.us/img855/8274/ryanerfda.png

Jester
05-25-2011, 09:29 PM
I don't get it. Could you explain? Slower and in smaller words? I'm so confused.
Ok....I gotta.

"I'm not sure I understood all that, Chief Sterns. Would you mind repeating it... in English perhaps."

FearlessLeader
05-25-2011, 09:34 PM
Ok....I gotta.

"I'm not sure I understood all that, Chief Sterns. Would you mind repeating it... in English perhaps."

http://i51.tinypic.com/zy663p.jpg

Slap-Happy
05-25-2011, 10:12 PM
I gave examples...like if someone said I did not like the show because of the stupid fight scenes. Seasons 1-5 had great fight scenes. FF was average....BTTS was a joke. That's why I feel 2K3 should be critiqued separately.

...Or, they hated all fight scenes. You're acting like your opinion defines that of an entire fandom.

You're basically saying: "When they say the fight scenes are dumb, they obviously don't mean 2k3 because everyone (me) thinks those are the best fight scenes."

gobo
05-25-2011, 10:30 PM
Oh my goodness... Is this 'bash on a random person because we're bored' day? He said repeatedly that he's fully aware that >> and BttS are continuations of 2K3, but he doesn't count them because it makes him feel dirty. You guys oughtta make this the reason for your next psychiatrist visit. :roll:

FearlessLeader
05-25-2011, 10:35 PM
How about we all just agree to disagree! :tgrin:

Spitfire
05-25-2011, 11:05 PM
There's opinions and then there's being wrong. The public school system has made a fatal error in telling everyone that what they have to say is special and if people don't agree it's just a matter of opinion.

So if I made a completely ignorant statement like "Thomas Jefferson didn't write the Declaration of Independence." and someone told me I was wrong I could say "Well that's my opinion." But see that isn't an opinion that's just wrong and several facts could prove that statement wrong, just like several sources could prove that 2K3, FF, and BTTS are apart of the same series. If you chose to ignore all the facts that makes you ignorant.

When Ashton Kutcher joins the cast of 2 and a Half Men are you gonna argue it's a different series too?

Jester
05-25-2011, 11:14 PM
When Ashton Kutcher joins the cast of 2 and a Half Men are you gonna argue it's a different series too?
I'm sure it will be. It might actually be good. :P

Spitfire
05-25-2011, 11:15 PM
I'm sure it will be. It might actually be good. :P

I don't think any amount of recasting could save that show. Now that is my opinion. :lol:

Jester
05-25-2011, 11:17 PM
I don't think any amount of recasting could save that show. Now that is my opinion. :lol:
Yeah, i don't watch much TV anyway. I watch L&O: SVU, SNL, Simpsons, and Looney Tunes.

FearlessLeader
05-26-2011, 07:41 AM
Yeah, i don't watch much TV anyway. I watch L&O: SVU, SNL, Simpsons, and Looney Tunes.

And Christopher Meloni just left Law and Order SVU so I won't even be watching that anymore :tsad::tsad:

ToTheNines
05-26-2011, 08:16 AM
And have u seen TMNT? A couple times? I didn't see it until the second time, but at the end on Splinter's shelf. It has the Shredder's mask, The canister of Ooze, The Timecepter and Japaneese Mask. It is definantly a continuation of the storyline

So sick of this crap.... 4 years and running. Spitfire already responded with enough to prove you wrong BUT there's also the fact that there were literally no verbal references to any previous TMNT movie, and they obviously take place in different time periods.

Plus, the tone is just waaaay off. Could you imagine Josh Pais' Raphael from the first movie ever putting on a stupid metal suit and running around as a superhero? Nah.

Then there's Splinter's ear, April's job, and the prequel comics.

k_lala
05-26-2011, 08:37 AM
...Or, they hated all fight scenes. You're acting like your opinion defines that of an entire fandom.

You're basically saying: "When they say the fight scenes are dumb, they obviously don't mean 2k3 because everyone (me) thinks those are the best fight scenes."

My gosh here we go again...I'm giving an example. And yes, those are my opinions...its obvious the shows are different in many aspects. In my opinion, the fight scenes are one of them.

And in my opinion. YES, the seasons 1-5 had the best fight scenes, story boards, action.

BTTS....not so much. Am I wrong for saying that? Those are my opinions. And since this series is talking about Critiquing 2K3 I can say that. I can say seasons 1-5 had ****** fight scenes and I can say FF had average Fight scenes, and I can say BTTS was a joke! Give me a break!

But your right maybe someone wrote that they hated ALL the fight scenes... but in my opinion i don't know many people who thought seasons 1-5 sucked because of the fight scenes. But that is my strong opinion. What if someone commented on the art and design saying they looked too blocky and simplified? When i think of that i think of FF and BTTS...i don't really think of seasons 1-5...the point is...you leave room for interpretation...obviously everyone has different opinions on the show or series and we can all talk about it respectfully agreed?

The point i'm making is, each show (FF) (BTTS) (1-5 2K3) is different, but yes they do make up 2K3 as a whole. Why is everyone still fighting me on this? I don't know how much clearer i can make this.... all i'm saying is in my opinion the shows should be critqued separately because of all the differences between the three. And obviously everyone has different opinions of the three shows. Because I did say that....

People are writing back all angry saying....WHAT differences happen all the time in cartoon shows of course!! Then list the examples like JLA etc...

First of all I never said they weren't included in the 2K3 series. Whether or not I like FF or BTTS is my own opinion, but that doesn't mean I don't recoganize it as part of 2K3. I cleared this up even more and then people write back saying...

OMG FF and BTTS is a continuation of the series have you not watched?

I slap myself in the head again and explain more... but still people just like to argue even more when there really isn't an argument.

Since we all agree that the shows are different but still part of the continuity 2K3 series. I give examples of why i think the show be critiqued separately because of this...but yet i crudded on for that. Am i not explaining myself well? If so please let me know politely or do we just have people on here who just like to argue.

and btw on a side note...JLA and JLA Unlimited didn't have such a HUUUGE difference as 2K3 did when it changed. I know the roster got bigger, and they had more one off episodes...those were the major ones. But the art/design/writers/action/intensity all stayed the same. The core and essence of the show was in my opinion the same. It was a great great show! But that's a separate discussion.

Redeemer
05-26-2011, 09:03 AM
So sick of this crap.... 4 years and running. Spitfire already responded with enough to prove you wrong BUT there's also the fact that there were literally no verbal references to any previous TMNT movie, and they obviously take place in different time periods.

Plus, the tone is just waaaay off. Could you imagine Josh Pais' Raphael from the first movie ever putting on a stupid metal suit and running around as a superhero? Nah.

Then there's Splinter's ear, April's job, and the prequel comics.

Dude learn to read and shut it. I dont want to hear insults its childish is getting really annoying. I said it was my opinion, is 4th TMNT a sequal to the first three really cant say. There is the ending and then Kari referring to there past. Dont care it my opinion dont insult me and I cant be wrong if its a matter of opinion. so please jst leave me alone and drop it

k_lala
05-26-2011, 09:46 AM
There's opinions and then there's being wrong. The public school system has made a fatal error in telling everyone that what they have to say is special and if people don't agree it's just a matter of opinion.

So if I made a completely ignorant statement like "Thomas Jefferson didn't write the Declaration of Independence." and someone told me I was wrong I could say "Well that's my opinion." But see that isn't an opinion that's just wrong and several facts could prove that statement wrong, just like several sources could prove that 2K3, FF, and BTTS are apart of the same series. If you chose to ignore all the facts that makes you ignorant.

When Ashton Kutcher joins the cast of 2 and a Half Men are you gonna argue it's a different series too?

Your right, there's a difference between making a factual statement or giving an opinion. But people aren't going out and saying FF and BTTS isn't part of 2K3. The fact is, those shows are part of 2K3. We get that, I get that.

But let me make up a fake example with EXTREMES here. If I made a movie series called The Ninja Frogs. The first movie i had a high profile director and A list celebrities with a $400 million dollar budget. This movie was successful and fans everywhere loved it.

Ok for now the extreme example....For the next 2 sequels lets say i only had a $1-5 million dollar budget and i let you do the movie. And this did poorly. Some hard core fans loved it, others hated it.

Yes those 3 movies are part of the Ninja Frogs. But if we created a thread critiquing what they didn't like about the Ninja Frogs...my "suggestion" would be why not critique it separately since the shows were different? It's a suggestion that makes sense in my eyes. I don't want to keep hearing from people...WHAT its part of the series or company makes changes all the time. This is not what i'm talking about here.

I think that's what's the BIGGEST miscommunication going on on this thread, no matter how many times I try to clear this up it still gets talked about.

FearlessLeader
05-26-2011, 10:17 AM
I think I get what people are trying to get across here.

We all agree original 2k3, Fast Forward and Back to the Sewers are all the same show!

If there was one aspect of something that you didn't, like say you hated the way they portrayed Mike's character but only in Fast Forward and Back to the Sewers but were alright with how he was portrayed in original 2k3, please specify that you mean Fast Forward and Back to the Sewers instead of just lumping it all together.

Because let's face it even though they are all the same show Mike's character takes a nose dive in Fast Forward and never really recovers.

If you hate everything you hate everything and that's cool too.

Is this what everyone means?? Can we stop fighting about it now :twink:

k_lala
05-26-2011, 12:15 PM
I think I get what people are trying to get across here.

We all agree original 2k3, Fast Forward and Back to the Sewers are all the same show!

If there was one aspect of something that you didn't, like say you hated the way they portrayed Mike's character but only in Fast Forward and Back to the Sewers but were alright with how he was portrayed in original 2k3, please specify that you mean Fast Forward and Back to the Sewers instead of just lumping it all together.

Because let's face it even though they are all the same show Mike's character takes a nose dive in Fast Forward and never really recovers.

If you hate everything you hate everything and that's cool too.

Is this what everyone means?? Can we stop fighting about it now :twink:

So...your saying Mikey ONLY took a nose dive in FF!! You're acting like your opinion defines that of an entire fandom.

You're basically saying: "When they say Mikey is dumb, they obviously don't mean 2k3 because everyone (me) thinks those are the best Mikey scenes.


^^^ Just kidding...I just copied and pasted someone elses response to me and edited it a bit. You don't have to worry about me being an arse. Some other people on this board will have a problem with what you said though, for whatever reason...or at least that's my personal experience with it.

But yes this is what i've been trying to say all along, but I got this huge whip lash effect because of it.

ToTheNines
05-26-2011, 02:11 PM
Dude learn to read and shut it. I dont want to hear insults its childish is getting really annoying. I said it was my opinion, is 4th TMNT a sequal to the first three really cant say. There is the ending and then Kari referring to there past. Dont care it my opinion dont insult me and I cant be wrong if its a matter of opinion. so please jst leave me alone and drop it

At what point did I insult you?

Anyways, I already negated your "ending" argument and Karai referring to their past had nothing to do with the other movies. All she said was something about faces from your past.

Jester
05-26-2011, 04:52 PM
And the movie itself says that the Turtles defeated Shredder...but not how.

gobo
05-26-2011, 05:08 PM
Homage vs. sequel... I'm sure there are just as many reasons to believe that Superman Returns isn't a direct sequel of the Richard Donner Superman films, but so I don't have to nit-pick these itty bitty details myself, I just prefer to call both these examples homages.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-27-2011, 06:51 AM
Well, personally, I find nothing wrong with thinking about FF and BttS as "spin-offs". That doesn't mean they aren't continuations, or that they're not connected to everything that came before them, however. Yes, it's generally accepted that they are seasons 6 and 7 of the 2k3 show, but at the same time, I think they can be perfectly described as spin-offs, as well, due to the name change (season 5 may often be called "Ninja Tribunal", but the actual season is still just "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles", with no subtitle).

Now, I could be speaking with bias, as I don't really care for those two seasons, but honestly, season 5 had a series ending wrap-up, and the beginning of FF felt very sequel-ish.

I won't say anymore on that, though, as I only really skimmed through this argument about that.

As for the question in this topic's opening post...

I like the 2k3 show quite a bit. Now, I know most people seem to prefer the 87 toon due to nostalgia, but as obsessed as I was with the TMNT as a kid due to that show, I honestly do find myself liking the 2k3 show a lot more. Most especially, I like how it started off being a lot more faithful to the source material than the 87 toon ever was. That being said, however, there's still a lot of things about the 2k3 show that I don't like, despite it being my favorite animated TV version of the TMNT.

Here are the things about the show that bug me:

1) Karai being subordinate to the Shredder. Okay, I guess it doesn't REALLY bug me, especially since this version of the Shredder is a megalomaniacal alien warlord intent on universal domination and complete genocide that cheats death left and right rather than a human being wanting revenge for the death his brother that actually gets offed rather quickly. Considering what this show is like, Karai fits in well... buuuuuut, I just don't like this version of Karai anywhere near as much as the one from the comics, where she's the head of the entire Foot clan, and just plain badass. In this show, however, she comes off as more like an updated version of Lotus Blossom from the 87 toon, than as an adaptation of the true Karai.

2) Michelangelo. He can be amusing, I'll admit, and maybe this isn't even so much a strike against this show so much as just TMNT in general, outside of the original comics... but I really do feel that Mike gets dumbed down and sort of flanderized way too often in other forms of media. Even though the 87 toon completely changed Raph's personality, it was still mostly in tact in other versions of the TMNT. This isn't the case for Mike, though, as EVERY universe that isn't the original tends to give Mike the same "party dude" type of personality, rather than the understanding, caring, and quite possibly most "human" of all the Turtles.

3) "What the shell?" It's okay in small doses, but as the series went on, this really started getting overused. And don't even get me started on "It's Ninja Time!" (that started in Fast Forward, I think, right?)

4) They're superheroes. Seriously, everybody was making fun of Mikey for how he wanted to be like a superhero, and all that stuff... but yet, well... this version of the Turtles ARE superheroes! They don't just use regular communication devices, they use "shell cells", which much like the "turtle coms" of the 87 show, are shaped like turtle shells. There's so many aesthetically turtle themed devices and gadgets that are completely unnecessary and even impractical if these were truly ninja like they were in the comics. Now, while the original red headbands were uniform due to them all belonging to the same ninja clan, I can understand that they're using the multi-colored headbands in this series for marketability... and now I may be shooting myself in the foot, because obviously things like the shell-cell, shell-cycle, and battle shell are all for the sake of selling toys... but I don't have to like it. So, to sum up what I'm trying to say, I don't really think of these guys as real ninja, but as super heroes with a ninja (and turtle) theme. Still, considering that even though this show was much closer to the source material than the other cartoon ever was, the fact still stands that it IS a kid's cartoon, so I guess that's why they have to be all about "saving the city" as opposed to "avenging Master Yoshi".

So, ya, as you can see, there are things about the 2k3 show that I'm not particularly fond of... but it's all things I've come to accept, given that it's a cartoon aimed at children. My favorite incarnation of the TMNT will always be the original comics (and even then, only strictly volume 1), but for what it's worth, the 2k3 show is still quite entertaining, and definitely one of the better action shows for kids.

midknigt
05-27-2011, 08:07 AM
Since I grew up more with the Old Toon TMNT, watching 2k3 was pretty much getting used to the semi-dark atmosphere, new characters, the turtle's major personality tweak, story and so on.

2k3 may not be my top favorite but I would be lying if I said I didn't enjoy it. Of course, some episodes were awesome, others fell on the so-so line and some were just... SNOOOOOOOORE!

Obviously my favorite is the SAINW episode because it was an emotional rollercoster... for me anyways.

The only thing that REALLY disappointed me when I first watched the series: where's was Michelangelo's cowabunga?! I know there was one episode where he said it once (forgot which) besides Turtles Forever.

Ah well, you gain some, you lose some.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
05-27-2011, 11:29 PM
The only thing that REALLY disappointed me when I first watched the series: where's was Michelangelo's cowabunga?! I know there was one episode where he said it once (forgot which) besides Turtles Forever.

Ah well, you gain some, you lose some.

I think early on they threw it in there while they were testing the waters, and then realized that they were going to bank with or without it. A lot of fans of the original cartoon watched it, but a lot of people who watched it were people who had read the Mirage books, while still many many others were young kids who'd never even HEARD of TMNT prior to it airing.