PDA

View Full Version : What should the movie take most of it's influence from?


Slap-Happy
06-19-2010, 12:43 AM
On the "Execs watching forums" thread, Jephael brought up the fact that all of the fans want something different from the movie. I thought I'd see what you guys want from this movie.

Do you want it to take influence from the comics, cartoons, etc.

I think it should be like the first movie, with a mix between the comics and OT. I think it worked perfectly already.

Andrew NDB
06-19-2010, 12:59 AM
I know what OS is... but what is OT? The original Star Wars trilogy?

Slap-Happy
06-19-2010, 01:29 AM
I know what OS is... but what is OT? The original Star Wars trilogy?
Ummm... "Original Toon".

hudemx
06-19-2010, 04:31 AM
I'm going with the original Toon, not only is it my favourite Part of the TMNT Franchise, but it was also the most successful to date and I'm pretty sure with the right promotion the Movie, based on that incarnation, could also be more successful than the last Movie (I mean TMNT not Turtles Forever).

Powder
06-19-2010, 05:05 AM
How clones of the same threads are we gonna have?



A dream come true would be vol. 3 (image comics) so thats where my vote went.
Realistically though, Mirage makes the most sense to me.

Candy Kappa
06-19-2010, 06:51 AM
Mirage comics no doubt

I feel a sense of déjà vu

voltron80
07-05-2010, 03:13 PM
What's the toy line mythology? Didn't the toys match the cartoon universe other than bringing up new heroes and villains?

shuriken
07-05-2010, 03:41 PM
Mirage comics. If they do a second movie than Mirage comics. A third then Mirage comics. If they actually get to a fourth then they can do whatever the hell they want.

Redeemer
07-05-2010, 04:54 PM
Mirage comics for sure. This would be the best path for the franchise I think, but also my favorite.

And the mithology toyline is the mutant animal B.S. i think correct me if I am wrong.

Andrew NDB
07-05-2010, 05:31 PM
And the mithology toyline is the mutant animal B.S.

Correction, the mythology toyline stuff is just B.S.... period.

John Pannozzi
07-08-2010, 03:34 PM
Mirage comics. If they do a second movie than Mirage comics. A third then Mirage comics. If they actually get to a fourth then they can do whatever the hell they want.

Actually, I think it would be interesting if they did a trilogy based on the key events of the Laird/Eastman/Lawson-helmed issues of Mirage Vol. 1 (plus Tales Vol. 1, and the Fugitoid and 4 turtles microseries and the "Radical an' Complete Carnage" short story), then after that, maybe a different series based on the Archie Comics (which would naturally include the storyline of the first and best season from the Fred Wolf cartoon), perhaps mixing in some of the more intriguing/potentially interesting elements from the Fred Wolf cartoon's second season onward (i.e. Baxter becoming a fly, the Punk Frogs, etc.).

shuriken
07-08-2010, 04:18 PM
Other than the last two lines you pretty much agreed with me. Although it would be trippy as hell to see BaxterFly, but not sure if it beats out RoboBaxter from Volume 2.

Candy Kappa
07-08-2010, 05:50 PM
Baxter's robot form shaped like a anthro Fly?

discordiatookie
07-08-2010, 06:01 PM
The original Mirage comics are where its at for me, so that's where I voted, however unlikely it may be.

Andrew NDB
07-08-2010, 06:04 PM
Baxter's robot form shaped like a anthro Fly?

In that case, I say make him suppository-shaped to be stuck right back into the ass of whoever would write such a script.

Redeemer
07-21-2010, 08:27 AM
Didn't Nick already say they were taking and combing all the unversed? So wouldn't they do the same for the movie?

BoggleKng
07-21-2010, 09:56 AM
The Multiverse in Turtles Forever was a neat concept but not for a movie. Stick to Mirage or Image comic line.. unfortunately, Image story would have a tough time appealing to a larger audience..

shuriken
07-21-2010, 10:14 AM
The Multiverse in Turtles Forever was a neat concept but not for a movie. Stick to Mirage or Image comic line.. unfortunately, Image story would have a tough time appealing to a larger audience..

I kind of disagree on the Image part. The fast pace and attime action movie dialogue would be perfect for, ya know an action flick... you have a point.

Sage Ninja
07-23-2010, 01:12 AM
this is a no brainer. Mirage. But when it come to how Michelangelo should be handled. Take it from Image.

Doc_ock_4mugen
07-23-2010, 08:38 AM
Mirage comics all the way. The Turtles deserve it.

NameGoesHere1066
07-26-2010, 02:18 PM
NEXT MUTATION!!!!

I'm kidding. Mirage.

John Pannozzi
08-01-2010, 01:22 PM
I've got a clear idea of what I want the new movie to be.

It should show the feud with Foot Clan as shown in v.1 #1, the Leonardo microseries, V.1 #10,#11, and the Return to the New York arc from V.1 #19-21 (minus Zog, I guess), as well as meeting April and rescuing her from Baxter Stockman as seen in v.1 #2, and Raph meeting Casey Jones from the Raphael microseries. It would show Spilinter raising the Turtles to kill Saki and avenge Yoshi as a mirror to Saki being manipulated by the Foot to kill Yoshi and avenge Nagi. But it would show that the Turtles and Splinter are the ones we root for, because despite the turtles and Splinter being vengeful, selfish, and far from role models, deep down inside they still care for each other (and they come to care about April and Casey, too, and vice versa), whereas Saki has not truly cared about anyone other than himself since Nagi's death (and no, the whole "Foot Clan halfway home" angle that Andrew Modeen loathes would not be explored). Plus, ya know, the Turtles and Splinter almost only ever fight and kill others in self defense, and aren't partaking in organized crime and manipulating politics like Saki and the Foot Clan are.

The sequel would show the more outlandish side of the Turtles' lives. The epic "Search for Splinter"/"Turtles in Space" that stretched from V.1 #3-4 to the Fugitoid oneshot to V.1 #5-7 and involved the Fugitoid, Utroms, Triceratons and the Federation. The time traveling adventures they had with Renet fighting Savanti Romero (and possibly Chote and Savanti Juliet if they could squeeze them in). The encounters with Nobody, Leatherhead, the Rat King, Complete Carnage and Radical. The Sons of the Silent Age storyline. Admittedly, all of this would probably be far too much for one movie, but I still want to see as many of these characters and storylines on the big screen as possible.

The third movie would be City at War. Maybe with the Shades of Grey arc also included if there's enough time.

Keldor1578
01-26-2011, 09:59 AM
I going for the 4Kids cartoon, Because i want Oroku Saki to be the head of the foot clan, Instead just the american branch of the foot. Plus i want to see Hun as Saki's righthand man.

Andrew NDB
01-26-2011, 11:56 AM
(and no, the whole "Foot Clan halfway home" angle that Andrew Modeen loathes would not be explored).

That's very charitable of you. :)

I going for the 4Kids cartoon, Because i want Oroku Saki to be the head of the foot clan, Instead just the american branch of the foot.

Why? And wouldn't that mean he'd be headquartered in Japan instead of New York?

Keldor1578
01-27-2011, 04:05 AM
Why? And wouldn't that mean he'd be headquartered in Japan instead of New York?[/QUOTE]

I just like the idea that Saki is the head of foot clan, which i feel make him a true crime lord. I hate to see Karai be Saki's superior.

Andrew NDB
01-27-2011, 11:28 AM
I just like the idea that Saki is the head of foot clan, which i feel make him a true crime lord. I hate to see Karai be Saki's superior.

But why is that?

sdp
01-27-2011, 01:09 PM
Because the Shredder is the TMNT's big bad and no one likes the idea that their most fearsome enemy is really just under Karai's leadership. Star Wars is an example where it worked with Vader being under the Emperor's command but besides that it doesn't work if say, "Oh look Megatron is really just a general of the decepticons and there is someone with a higher rank" Now that may be a bad example since I don't know much about transformers but you get the idea. Of course that doesn't mean that there can't be a bigger bad in those universes but just not above the rank of say shredders/megatrons own faction.

I mean I know in the Mirage Universe Shredder was killed in the first issue and wasn't that important in it however that can be debated, as Laird and Eastman did not know TMNT would become as huge as it did or that the Shredder would become the big bad that he is, I mean even if he died in the first issue Shredder kept appearing one way or another because of his popularity even recently with Oroku Yoshi (ugh). I understand you're a Mirage purist, we've been through this before but you also have to understand why people like Shredder being the big bad leader of the foot and not just "oh he's the NY division".

Andrew NDB
01-27-2011, 01:45 PM
Because the Shredder is the TMNT's big bad and no one likes the idea that their most fearsome enemy is really just under Karai's leadership. Star Wars is an example where it worked with Vader being under the Emperor's command but besides that it doesn't work if say, "Oh look Megatron is really just a general of the decepticons and there is someone with a higher rank" Now that may be a bad example since I don't know much about transformers but you get the idea. Of course that doesn't mean that there can't be a bigger bad in those universes but just not above the rank of say shredders/megatrons own faction.

I mean I know in the Mirage Universe Shredder was killed in the first issue and wasn't that important in it however that can be debated, as Laird and Eastman did not know TMNT would become as huge as it did or that the Shredder would become the big bad that he is, I mean even if he died in the first issue Shredder kept appearing one way or another because of his popularity even recently with Oroku Yoshi (ugh). I understand you're a Mirage purist, we've been through this before but you also have to understand why people like Shredder being the big bad leader of the foot and not just "oh he's the NY division".

My question has nothing to do with the Mirage comics -- there's nothing even in the Mirage comics to imply that Karai was in charge of the Japanese Foot at the same time Saki was in charge of the NY Foot for her to have been his superior... that she was is a toon thing.

Keldor's statement just seemed odd to me for several reasons:

1) The Foot has branches everywhere and it started in Japan, where its HQ is and has always been. This is kind of fundamental to who and what the Foot is, whether we're talking about the source material or the toon with slightly more coherence. And if its leader is hanging in New York screwing with the Turtles all the time... that's weird and makes the Foot a farce.

2) How does Shredder having someone to report to take away from the character? Is it because she's a woman, I wonder? I feel like it might be different to Keldor or the Keldors out there if it was a man or male figure. I mean, was there a huge problem with Shredder taking orders from Krang? I mean, the character -- like all of them -- was written as a joke, but in principle I don't remember anyone crying foul about him playing second fiddle to Krang. But Karai, this is a problem?

3) If there's someone of a higher rank than Megatron (and wasn't there at one point?), how would that be a bad thing? If anything, wouldn't it be a sensible direction to go for a reveal down the line after Megatron has run his course a bit? "Now we meet... someone even badder-ass than Megatron!" Wasn't this donein G.I. Joe as well with Serpentor?

Candy Kappa
01-27-2011, 01:57 PM
Megatron had to answer to Unicron in the Original movie, thoguht he became Galvatron at that time.

sdp
01-27-2011, 02:16 PM
Well I can't speak for Keldor I guess, I just tried posting a general idea of why someone might not like the Shredder not being the head of the foot with a little bit of my own opinion mixed in. Personally the Big Bad not being the actual Big Bad has to be done right for me to like it, and theres a few times its done great and others not but thats just me. Oh and I don't think in the OT Shredder was under Krang, it was more of an alliance/partnership deal.

chad
02-22-2011, 02:57 PM
I think the movie should be based on the mirage comics I always prefered the dark tone and seeing that on screen would be Awesome

NameGoesHere1066
02-24-2011, 05:23 PM
My question has nothing to do with the Mirage comics -- there's nothing even in the Mirage comics to imply that Karai was in charge of the Japanese Foot at the same time Saki was in charge of the NY Foot for her to have been his superior... that she was is a toon thing.

Keldor's statement just seemed odd to me for several reasons:

1) The Foot has branches everywhere and it started in Japan, where its HQ is and has always been. This is kind of fundamental to who and what the Foot is, whether we're talking about the source material or the toon with slightly more coherence. And if its leader is hanging in New York screwing with the Turtles all the time... that's weird and makes the Foot a farce.

2) How does Shredder having someone to report to take away from the character? Is it because she's a woman, I wonder? I feel like it might be different to Keldor or the Keldors out there if it was a man or male figure. I mean, was there a huge problem with Shredder taking orders from Krang? I mean, the character -- like all of them -- was written as a joke, but in principle I don't remember anyone crying foul about him playing second fiddle to Krang. But Karai, this is a problem?

3) If there's someone of a higher rank than Megatron (and wasn't there at one point?), how would that be a bad thing? If anything, wouldn't it be a sensible direction to go for a reveal down the line after Megatron has run his course a bit? "Now we meet... someone even badder-ass than Megatron!" Wasn't this donein G.I. Joe as well with Serpentor?

I agree with everything you just said here.