PDA

View Full Version : Identical Bodies??


Shred87
06-30-2010, 05:12 PM
I don't know if anyone has ever noticed but I feel in every variation of the NT all 4 have identical bodies. I'm hope in the next movie they change that and make their body fit their personality more... Don for instance I see having a much thinner build than Raph who I think of as being much larger and the most muscular. Leo would have an ideal athletes build and I see Mikey being a little heavier set. I was looking at the fan project in another thread and it looks like they are taking this approach to their look. What do you all think?

Turo602
06-30-2010, 05:30 PM
I've always seen Leo to be a little smaller then Raph, sorta like an athletes build, and Raph being the most muscular and and tallest Turtle by like an inch. Donny could fit being like the thinnest turtle but with some muscle, and Mikey being the shortest and heaviest but not to of a fat turtle but with some muscles on the arms. That's what I liked about Fast Forward-BttS TMNT, that they had there own body types. It should always stay like that.

Shred87
06-30-2010, 05:42 PM
I with you 100%...Leo would def be smaller than Raph but the best athlete... Raph would be more jacked but not the same athlete as Leo... I always see Raph as kind of the juiced up head case..

shuriken
06-30-2010, 06:06 PM
In my mind I have my own image of the TMNT and how tall they are and how much they weigh and such. I always thought that the shell and plastron would make up about 25-30 pounds that would leave the TMNT to weigh about the same as Welterweights, which would be 145-160.
Anyway Raph is the most muscular, being 5'5" about 186 lbs.
Leo is more compact and is more cut than Raph, he would be 5'5 180 lbs.
Donnie would be a bit lankier but with less muscle, with longer arms and legs kind of like a swimmer's body, 5'7" about 178 lbs.
Mikey would be the shortest and since he is the most naturally athletic he'd be more muscular than Donnie but not as ripped as Leo, 5'4" 176 lbs.

Shred87
06-30-2010, 06:21 PM
i always thought of mikey as not really fat but def softer looking... I always kind of pictured him as having the most potential to be even greater than leo but his personality /laziness hold him back...naturally the most talented and shows it at times but can't give the consistent effot..

donnie is def the smallest... he's the brains of the group and brains and brawn just don't usually go together..

Talking about it really makes me wish this was taken into consideration for the next movie...I hope we don't just get a rehash of what we've already gotten

Koi
06-30-2010, 06:40 PM
Mikey slightly fat, the munchies really got to him.
Don, stick skinny nerday
Raph steroided, because he wants to chemically enlarge his muscles.
Leo fat, from just sitting and meditating all the time and not getting off his rump.

Shredder would have an Edward Cullen body type. Maybe it will get the fangirls to like him better then the turtles...

ToTheNines
06-30-2010, 07:28 PM
I don't know if anyone has ever noticed but I feel in every variation of the NT all 4 have identical bodies.

That's kinda bullsh*t. In the OT yeah, but pretty much every other version there's height and muscle differences.

Shred87
06-30-2010, 10:23 PM
WHoa Whoa must have hit a nerve... but sry maybe there's a slight height difference but I havn't ever noticed any real difference in body type..

sagelwwa
07-01-2010, 04:05 AM
I would like to see a stocky brownish colored Don would look like in live action, but I bet it would look retarded. Every once in awhile we got that color variation in the toons and I loved that, but probably not a concept that translates to cool live action very well.

Luzmagica
07-01-2010, 07:21 AM
Is this the draw you where looking? :D:twink:
http://img6.imageshack.us/img6/813/turtlessketch.jpg (http://img6.imageshack.us/i/turtlessketch.jpg/)

Shred87
07-01-2010, 10:24 AM
Yes actually...I think these guys are on the right track...i like raph and don... I see Leo being a little bigger and mike a little smaller but its not too bad.. also glad you have a photo of these guys from the movie.. I don't know about anyone else but I'm not seeing any muscle differences

Nelson
07-01-2010, 12:26 PM
The 2007 movie did give each turtle a different body type, although the only one that was easily noticeable (by me) was Raph's, being more muscular than the rest.

Andrew NDB
07-01-2010, 12:39 PM
I don't know if anyone has ever noticed but I feel in every variation of the NT all 4 have identical bodies. I'm hope in the next movie they change that and make their body fit their personality more...

Their bodies look very different from one another in every movie, including the latest. Heads and faces, especially.

And why does someone's body need to fit their personality? What a bizarre concept. Should I go up to someone that's funny and say, "You seem jolly... your body type is all wrong. You need to get big and fat."

Shred87
07-01-2010, 03:15 PM
And why does someone's body need to fit their personality? What a bizarre concept. Should I go up to someone that's funny and say, "You seem jolly... your body type is all wrong. You need to get big and fat."

Yes you should def do that, thats exactly what I'm saying..your an ivy league grad aren't you?

http://www.planetvideo.com.au/blog/2009/08/29/tmnt_poster.jpg

Your telling me that these bodies are different from each other? You must be counting pixels because they look pretty similar to me...I don't know why there's so much resistence to this..I'm only saying that it would be a way to reinvent or add something new to the franchise to make if different from past variations.

Shred87
07-01-2010, 03:22 PM
http://1416andcounting.files.wordpress.com/2009/03/tmntiii.jpg

Look pretty similar to me here...


http://farm1.static.flickr.com/97/219782461_2f60aebad2_o.jpg

Slight height difference I'll give..probably more to the people in the costume than a creative decision but what am I missing?

http://nerdcityonline.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/12/tmnt.jpg

pretty identical to me..


So what am I missing when people are saying in every variation their bodies have already been different??

Koi
07-01-2010, 03:34 PM
In each of those I still see a lot of variation, so I don't see your point.

First picture, facial differences, size differences.
2nd picture Size, face, muscle differences.
3rd pictures has differences, not sure if they are attentional though.

Shred87
07-01-2010, 04:31 PM
you see "alot" of variation in each of those?? please point one out to me... if you siad in their face i'd say ok but in there bodies?? This is like arguing what color grass is?

Koi
07-01-2010, 04:39 PM
In each of those I still see a lot of variation, so I don't see your point.

First picture, facial differences, size differences.
2nd picture Size, face, muscle differences.
3rd pictures has differences, not sure if they are attentional though.

:l Where is the word body?

Edit:
http://www.dublinzoo.ie/img/pics/grass-01.jpghttp://i.ehow.com/images/a05/p4/na/grass-seed-lawns-1.1-120X120.jpg

shuriken
07-01-2010, 06:51 PM
Mikey slightly fat, the munchies really got to him.
Don, stick skinny nerday
Raph steroided, because he wants to chemically enlarge his muscles.
Leo fat, from just sitting and meditating all the time and not getting off his rump.

Shredder would have an Edward Cullen body type. Maybe it will get the fangirls to like him better then the turtles...

That would just be too much. We'd get team TMNT of Team Shredder posters at the theater which would kill the whole movie going experience. That being said can I get I get a hit of whatever it is you've been smoking? jk

Koi
07-01-2010, 07:48 PM
That would just be too much. We'd get team TMNT of Team Shredder posters at the theater which would kill the whole movie going experience. That being said can I get I get a hit of whatever it is you've been smoking? jk

lol, I was making fun. I kid.

shuriken
07-02-2010, 12:48 AM
tis fine as was I. But now I can't take out the image of Robert Pattinson dressed as Shredder

ToTheNines
07-02-2010, 06:25 AM
pretty identical to me..

So what am I missing when people are saying in every variation their bodies have already been different??

Not to be a dick, but you obviously just don't have a very good eye for that kinda stuff.

Shred87
07-02-2010, 11:00 AM
Maybe your right... because those bodies look just about the same to me in each pic... and if it was a creative decison to make them look different why would you need a trained eye to notice the differences...maybe I'm 100% wrong here but to me they look close to identical when you compare it to the photo from the fan project...if anyone would like to enlighten me on what I'm missing here I always up to learn something new and if I'm wrong I will gladly admit it

Koi
07-02-2010, 12:28 PM
It's ok Splint87, I mean. You also have to remember they are brothers, they share 50% and more genetics with each other. The sketch is really unrealistic and unproportional to ever be an actual design (in my opinion).

They need enough similarities to be brothers, but enough differences to define them enough.

If you have ever noticed, there is a scar on Raph's face in the old movies, eye color differences in the newer one, and Mikey has freckles. The third one had a lot of facial differences still. The freckles are in different areas, beaks are different from each other, they are small differences that help define them.

You don't need to have large differences that set them a part. They pretty much exercise at the same time on a daily basis. Some just go a little further not enough to create brand new character designs for them

Besides what we get will most likely have the same generic body suits with slight differences, and cgi will do the rest. Frankly, I am ok with that. I don't need Raph to to be bulkier, or Mikey to be more fat, or whatever. There personality defines them, not there body.

I would also like to apologize to you Splint for being rude and stubborn and set upon my own view. Sorry.

/Rant.

Shred87
07-02-2010, 01:19 PM
Besides what we get will most likely have the same generic body suits with slight differences, and cgi will do the rest.

I would also like to apologize to you Splint for being rude and stubborn and set upon my own view. Sorry.

/Rant.

Lol I think we may have just been miscommunicating... There is def a difference in the face sculpts and the face of the characters. I was really scratching my head because I would describe their body suits exactly the way you did above..generic I kept looking at these things and I thought i was crazy. For the record I was never trying to say that you can't tell each character apart..Each face is def unique and there are differences .. Basically I was just trying to see how everyone felt about the Dawn of a Ninja project where the body differences seem to be much more exaggerated and if ppl would want that concept used in the future.

No need for an apology my friend.. I brought an idea/topic to the table to try and start a convo/debate. Everyone has an opinion and the back and forth banter is all in good fun..at least from my end. My main goal is to try and make the time go by as fast as possible until the franchise gets moving again. I appreciate it though..

Koi
07-02-2010, 02:15 PM
I thought you were upset, but I am happy all is alright. The bodies are pretty identical but there are enough smaller things upon inspection that even the bodies are different, not on as large of a scale though in comparison to the sketched image earlier.

TuЯco
07-02-2010, 05:14 PM
i agree with you. but the ff and btts made mikey really tall and i didnt like that. it doesnt seem right like that.

discordiatookie
07-02-2010, 05:30 PM
There's a fair difference between Raph and Mikey in this here picture.
http://i201.photobucket.com/albums/aa15/discordiatookie/tmnt-2.jpg

Koi
07-07-2010, 11:12 PM
Not that many prob notice, but all there jaws are different in the CGI film. Each with something different, low jaw, high jaw, rounded jaw, square jaw. Then Mikey had freckles, blue eyes, larger expressive eyes, there beaks are different, Raph had more veins then the others (they talked about there different anatomy in the special features).

Candy Kappa
07-08-2010, 02:13 PM
identical bodies?

http://ninjaturtles.com/gallery/tmnt/group_02.jpg
http://ninjaturtles.com/cartoon/btts/lineup.jpg

personally, I like similar body types on them, and have subtle differences.

Shred87
07-08-2010, 02:36 PM
i cant get your links to pop up

Candy Kappa
07-08-2010, 05:49 PM
then go into ninajturtles.com -> Art Gallery

Shred87
07-09-2010, 02:20 PM
then go into ninajturtles.com -> Art Gallery

Forget it Im not that interested in your point..your the one using the photos to make a point if you have no interest in showing them im not goin out of my way to find them..

once again though.. when i said identical bodies basically i was saying if you were to remove each turtles head they have close to an identical body to each other. I saw the fan projects Dawn of the NInja concept art (photo posted in this forum) and it showed each turtles body being dramtically different in size to each other. I liked the idea and wanted to see what everyone else thought.

ooglafina
07-09-2010, 02:27 PM
I think in their next incarnation, they should design them all without the masks and only add them after they can tell them all apart with out them. That would be interesting.

Andrew NDB
07-09-2010, 02:36 PM
I saw the fan projects Dawn of the NInja concept art (photo posted in this forum) and it showed each turtles body being dramtically different in size to each other. I liked the idea and wanted to see what everyone else thought.

I don't like the idea at all. They're all brothers, they all eat the same stuff, they all have the same training regime... I just don't buy that "The Angry One" should be beefier, or that one Turtle is going to be lankier than the other. And it doesn't even make sense... if one Turtle lifts more weights and does more pushups, it's not like the plastron of his shell is going to expand and grow, is it?

I'm not saying their bodies should be identical but there shouldn't be a wide gulf of difference between each one.

Shred87
07-09-2010, 03:44 PM
I don't like the idea at all. They're all brothers, they all eat the same stuff, they all have the same training regime... I just don't buy that "The Angry One" should be beefier, or that one Turtle is going to be lankier than the other. And it doesn't even make sense... if one Turtle lifts more weights and does more pushups, it's not like the plastron of his shell is going to expand and grow, is it?

I'm not saying their bodies should be identical but there shouldn't be a wide gulf of difference between each one.


Hey I respect your opinion and thats why I posted this to start a discussion about it... I'll come back to you and say that I think that Ralph is much more likely to lift weights in his spare time then Donnie so therfore would be a little thicker...see what I'm saying? And I'm sure you hate this but Mikey has the whole crazy pizza thing built in his character so maybe he'd be a little less defined? I'm not saying their shell size should be drastically different but I think I kind a like the idea of different body types just to give the franchise a different look/fresh perspective.... Well at the very least it would make me feel good to see something like this so I know this new creative team has plans to build upon the franchise or add to it instead of giving us a rehash to see how much more $$$ can be pumped out of it.

Now you bring up another points that I've always wondered.. and I'm sry if its been discussed already but are the turtles actually blood brothers? Now that I think about it I dont know if I've ever seen something saying one way or the other.

Andrew NDB
07-09-2010, 04:04 PM
Hey I respect your opinion and thats why I posted this to start a discussion about it... I'll come back to you and say that I think that Ralph is much more likely to lift weights in his spare time then Donnie so therfore would be a little thicker...see what I'm saying?

Yeah, but again, the plastron and carapace of a Turtle isn't going to expand and grow just because they're putting on a little extra muscle. That's about as silly and nonsense as a female Turtle with shell-breasts.

And I'm sure you hate this but Mikey has the whole crazy pizza thing built in his character

Like hell he does. Find me where he has the whole "Crazy pizza thing" anywhere in the source material.

Now you bring up another points that I've always wondered.. and I'm sry if its been discussed already but are the turtles actually blood brothers?

In every universe that I'm aware of aside from the NT:TNM one. But they only made them not brothers there so they create bullsh** tension with the Turtles wanting to bang Venus or something (which would have been weird if they were all siblings).

ooglafina
07-09-2010, 04:18 PM
Forget it Im not that interested in your point..your the one using the photos to make a point if you have no interest in showing them im not goin out of my way to find them.

I don't know why it's such a big deal. It took me about 20 seconds to find them.

Like hell he does. Find me where he has the whole "Crazy pizza thing" anywhere in the source material.

I really hate the idea of making Mike sort of fatty for any reason, particularly because he supposedly eats a lot of character-centric pizza. Ugh.

Shred87
07-09-2010, 04:19 PM
Yeah, but again, the plastron and carapace of a Turtle isn't going to expand and grow just because they're putting on a little extra muscle. That's about as silly and nonsense as a female Turtle with shell-breasts.

Maybe so but there arms and legs would look differently if someone lifts more vs reading a science magazine...or if one turtles diet is better than another.. Yeaa the Venus thing is a little outrageous I'm with you on that... I don't think this is on that level, come on now lol


Like hell he does. Find me where he has the whole "Crazy pizza thing" anywhere in the source material.

In the source material your 100% correct its not...but whether anyone likes it or not I believe we will probably never see another version where Mikey isn't the goofy/comic relief turtle...and believe me I'm not a fan of that but thats the way it is.. in TMNT he was even looks a little goofy with those giant eyes. In general the stereotypes will probably always follows each turtle in any movie going foward.

In every universe that I'm aware of aside from the NT:TNM one. But they only made them not brothers there so they create bullsh** tension with the Turtles wanting to bang Venus or something (which would have been weird if they were all siblings).

I learn something new every day..thanks

Koi
07-09-2010, 08:48 PM
In every universe that I'm aware of aside from the NT:TNM one. But they only made them not brothers there so they create bullsh** tension with the Turtles wanting to bang Venus or something (which would have been weird if they were all siblings).

...lmfao. XD

Redeemer
07-09-2010, 10:43 PM
Why does everyone think Mikey should the shortest and fatest? He is suppose to be the fastest of the four. This makes no sense I think Mikey should be the smallest of the four, to complement his speed.

Turo602
07-09-2010, 11:10 PM
Why does everyone think Mikey should the shortest and fatest? He is suppose to be the fastest of the four. This makes no sense I think Mikey should be the smallest of the four, to complement his speed.

Yeah, I always thought he should be the fastest but he's too lazy and eats too much so it fits.

Shred87
07-09-2010, 11:12 PM
Why does everyone think Mikey should the shortest and fatest? He is suppose to be the fastest of the four. This makes no sense I think Mikey should be the smallest of the four, to complement his speed.

I guess it's the OT character... Ever since then I've always thought of Mike as kinda a surfer/stoner whos always eating pizza.. I dont particularly care for that type of persona but thats what i think of

Coola Yagami
07-10-2010, 08:51 PM
Under Splinter's training, Mikey shouldn't be fat to begin with. Slacker or not, he still has to do the same daily excersises the others do when the sensei commands them. Plus, he doesn't train as hard cause he doesn't have to as much, he's naturally gifted at the most complex weopon to master of the four and has the most speed and agility.

Shark_Blade
07-11-2010, 09:03 AM
Mikey, fat? What are you smoking at?

I agree that he should be the most agile and fastest among his brothers. I always have that kinda of impression when playing as him in the games (NES and until now).

shuriken
07-11-2010, 10:32 PM
Under Splinter's training, Mikey shouldn't be fat to begin with. Slacker or not, he still has to do the same daily excersises the others do when the sensei commands them. Plus, he doesn't train as hard cause he doesn't have to as much, he's naturally gifted at the most complex weopon to master of the four and has the most speed and agility.

Exactly none of the TMNT should be fat. the OT it made sense cuz they always had a sh*tload of pizza. Have any of you ever been on a sports team where there is just one guy that trains with everyone else but never really pushes himself above and beyond? But when there is a big game or a race he always does fantastic due to just natural ability? I always thought that Mikey was like that, he knows that he is the most gifted so he doesn't feel the need to go above and beyond.

Koi
07-11-2010, 10:59 PM
Imagine seeing a bunch of fat ninjas everyone.

Redeemer
07-12-2010, 12:18 AM
Fmnt fat mutant ninja turtles!

Volvagia
07-12-2010, 06:08 AM
Wasn't there an old episode where the turtles came to the future and found out that they had become fat from watching TV and eating pizza?

Am I right or is my memory playing tricks with me.

Shred87
07-12-2010, 10:16 AM
I may be completely wrong but was this the ep from there easter special where that bunny comes in from another dimension?

Volvagia
07-12-2010, 04:48 PM
I have no idea and I'm too lazy to look it up right now.

Koi
07-12-2010, 05:14 PM
I may be completely wrong but was this the ep from there easter special where that bunny comes in from another dimension?

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0897442/
duh duh duuuuhh!

shuriken
07-12-2010, 07:14 PM
Imagine seeing a bunch of fat ninjas everyone.

I just remembered Chris Farley in Beverly Hills Ninja... Rest in Peace Chris.:cry:
I dunno about the toon episode but there is this one Mirage comic called turtle dreams in which Donnie has a nightmare that they get discovered by scientists and a cartoon show is made about them. Once the scientists lt them go they are confined to live in the sewer for fear of their adoring fans. They then become fat and stop training.