PDA

View Full Version : What would you say to..


Shred87
07-06-2010, 05:23 PM
no Shredder in the upcoming movie???

This of course would mean that we would have to get a solid story and box office successful movie right off the bat. Then you can bring in Shredder in a sequel that people will anticipate... Pretty much just ripping off what Nolan did with Batman by bringing in their ace villian in the second film.

I personally think if done correctly this could be a huge hit. You can introduce villians that have never gotten any screen time which let me think a second...is all of them. Then use a cliffhanger ending giving a glimpse of the Shredder. What's everyone think?

gobo
07-06-2010, 05:27 PM
What would you say to no Shredder in the upcoming movie???
Attempted twice to abysmal results, so I doubt it'd happen regardless of what we fans think.

Andrew NDB
07-06-2010, 05:32 PM
no Shredder in the upcoming movie???

At this point there kind of has to be Shredder in it, whether it's a complete reboot or it's another kind of quasi-continuation (and we already know it's a complete reboot).

Shred87
07-06-2010, 05:40 PM
Attempted twice to abysmal results, so I doubt it'd happen regardless of what we fans think.

I know one was obviously TMNT...I may smack myself for asking when I get the answer but...what is the second??

-edit- slgiht brain fart...I answer my own question in the next post lol

Turo602
07-06-2010, 05:40 PM
no Shredder in the upcoming movie???

I see where you're going with this. But no Shredder? come on! At least give us Oroku Saki building up to his true destiny.

Shred87
07-06-2010, 05:43 PM
At this point there kind of has to be Shredder in it, whether it's a complete reboot or it's another kind of quasi-continuation (and we already know it's a complete reboot).

I know what your saying...I wish it wasn't the case though..Apart of me really is hoping that this new team will try a different approach with this franchise. I know everyone is going to start screaming about how much they hated TMNT and the third film (slaps myself in the face because I just answered my question above) But those films were garbage in general. If they had used a established villian from the comics those films could have at the very least added something to the franchises canon.

gobo
07-06-2010, 05:45 PM
I know one was obviously TMNT...I may smack myself for asking when I get the answer but...what is the second??
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III: The Turtles Are Back... In Time (1993)
No Shredder referenced for the entire movie...

Shred87
07-06-2010, 05:51 PM
I see where you're going with this. But no Shredder? come on! At least give us Oroku Saki building up to his true destiny.

I'd be fine with that... I'd like it if maybe there was a character appearing throughout and we find out at the end his name is Oroku Saki...

I don't know about anyone else I just can't get that pumped up about a film featuring the turtles origin and the Shredder.... It's been done and done well for that matter. I'd personally love it if the first films main villian was Baxter Stockman/mousers.. Shredder takes over in the second in a City at War type storyline.

Of course this would only work if a sequel is indeed planned. If your one and done..then yea give me Shredder. Gun to my head I honestly don't know if there will be a large enough audience to support a trilogy for this franchise. I don't think the animated film is a good test of the type of numbers a movie can put up. If you go to a Live action film and add a serious tone I think you'd get a lot more ppl who loved the turtles going back to see it including new fans from the 2k3 series. If thats the case I think holding Shredder off could work.

Andrew NDB
07-06-2010, 05:56 PM
I know what your saying...I wish it wasn't the case though..Apart of me really is hoping that this new team will try a different approach with this franchise. I know everyone is going to start screaming about how much they hated TMNT and the third film (slaps myself in the face because I just answered my question above) But those films were garbage in general. If they had used a established villian from the comics those films could have at the very least added something to the franchises canon.

I dunno... I think we should be glad TMNTs Part 3 and 4 didn't feature any established villains from the comics. The kiddy garbage vibe they were shooting for in those would have only served to end up tarnishing them on the big screen and spreading the wrong idea.

I don't know about anyone else I just can't get that pumped up about a film featuring the turtles origin and the Shredder.... It's been done and done well for that matter.

You getting pumped up for the new movie is optional -- it's not for you. The last time the Turtles origin was on the big screen will have been 22 years beforehand... and that was in a mostly dodgy movie affair.

Shred87
07-06-2010, 06:06 PM
You getting pumped up for the new movie is optional -- it's not for you. The last time the Turtles origin was on the big screen will have been 22 years beforehand... and that was in a mostly dodgy movie affair.

LOL... I guess your right. I can't believe it's been 22 yrs. I was only one at the time.

When you say the movie isn't for me what do you mean exactly?? I could be dead wrong (and it wouldn't be the first time) but I don't think the 2k3 series produced enough new fans to make a new film franchise a success. Like most other comic movie franchises the box office numbers will come from (at first) people going back to see characters they loved in past years. So I have to say I disagree with you. I don't think there are enough little kids out there that are crazy enough about the turtles to test any box office records.

ooglafina
07-06-2010, 06:08 PM
The amount of sequels all depends on how they present this to the audience. If they aim this at kids again, then probably not. If they aim for entertaining people young and old then maybe.

And if they do aim at kids then the resulting sequels will be really crappy. It's sort of like, it you start out aiming at too small of an audience then the franchise with wear itself out quickly. If you aim big, then the franchise could just go up and up.

I guess what I mean to say is that studios just shoot themselves in the foot most of time.

Shred87
07-06-2010, 06:14 PM
The amount of sequels all depends on how they present this to the audience. If they aim this at kids again, then probably not. If they aim for entertaining people young and old then maybe.

And if they do aim at kids then the resulting sequels will be really crappy. It's sort of like, it you start out aiming at too small of an audience then the franchise with wear itself out quickly. If you aim big, then the franchise could just go up and up.

I guess what I mean to say is that studios just shoot themselves in the foot most of time.

I pretty much agree with everthing you said. I do have some hope with the recent amount of great comic movies coming out that Nick has intentions of replicating that process. The comic genre is no longer a taboo genre and I think its been proven when you aim at teens and up there's the possibility to cash in (Dark Knight/Spiderman). When you aim at children your destined to fail (Batman and Robin).

Spitfire
07-06-2010, 06:16 PM
Not bringing out the big gun, I'd like to say guns but turtles really only has one movie usable main villain in the public eye, is suicide. There wouldn't be a sequel.

Know why it worked in Batman? Because Batman is 10X more popular then turtles. There's tons of villains I'd rather see before Shredder but it makes no sense not to use him. People want to see Shredder. You want to be obscure do it in the sequel.

I like your idea but from a marketing stand point it just isn't plausible.

ooglafina
07-06-2010, 06:24 PM
I was thinking as I walked across the parking lot just now that huge franchises can be made out of anything. Look at Transformers (regardless of personal views, it made money hand over fist ad infinitum).

I see what you mean about Batman having such potent villains. I can't help but feel that if the first movie sucks people in and moves people enough that they will come back for more. The way to really push this past a movie for turtles fans is to bring in people who know nothing about the villains in the first place. Maybe that's just my vision through these rose tinted glasses though.

Andrew NDB
07-06-2010, 06:27 PM
When you say the movie isn't for me what do you mean exactly??

It wouldn't, couldn't, and shouldn't be targeted to any existing, active fandom of the TMNT. There's just not enough of any, even cumulatively.

Not to suggest a TMNT movie of this tone wouldn't make me punch the nearest wall, but it's the same as the G.I. Joe movie didn't overly concern itself with existing G.I. Joe fans, or the Transformers movie similarly didn't overly concern itself with any existing Transformers fans.

Like most other comic movie franchises the box office numbers will come from (at first) people going back to see characters they loved in past years.

Not really. Not really at all.

Do you really think 80%... or hell, even 40% of the people that went to see "Fantastic Four" were already existing Fantastic Four fans?

Of course not. People saw a slick trailer, some savvy marketing, bought tickets and waited in line.

I don't think there are enough little kids out there that are crazy enough about the turtles to test any box office records.

Good. F them.

The amount of sequels all depends on how they present this to the audience. If they aim this at kids again, then probably not. If they aim for entertaining people young and old then maybe.

Right. The repeating cycles in TMNT history (in the larger media) is kind of like this:

http://votingfemale.files.wordpress.com/2009/11/snake-eating-its-own-tail.jpg

They do the same thing over and over again, aiming at the lowest common denominator time and time again and every time they throw their arms up and go, "Huh! We keep aiming for toddlers and they keep outgrowing this! -- why? Ah well, let's just try it again in a few years."

Shred87
07-06-2010, 06:43 PM
Not bringing out the big gun, I'd like to say guns but turtles really only has one movie usable main villain in the public eye, is suicide. There wouldn't be a sequel.

Know why it worked in Batman? Because Batman is 10X more popular then turtles. There's tons of villains I'd rather see before Shredder but it makes no sense not to use him. People want to see Shredder. You want to be obscure do it in the sequel.

I like your idea but from a marketing stand point it just isn't plausible.

Just to play devils advocate.. For the first movie do you think that people won't go see it because Shredder isn't in it? I tend to think that people will go see the first Live Action turtle movie regardless out of nostalgia. If it's any good people will def go back to see a sequel if Shredders a factor. I feel it can be more succesful this way then the other way around. What if Shredder is used in the first film and the movie is average. What is going to keep those fringe fans coming back for a second??

Now it's funny you said this other thing...is Batman really 10x more popular than the turtles?? I was born when the first movie came out for the turtles so I may have a warped sense of what was popular growing up but I don't remember anything being as popular as the turtles. Batman has gotten better treatment over the 70 yrs he's been around. He's been around longer and there's many more versions of him that people relate too. But IMO that goes on the shoulders of Eastman and Laird for not continuing to develop the turtles story.

Shred87
07-06-2010, 06:55 PM
It wouldn't, couldn't, and shouldn't be targeted to any existing, active fandom of the TMNT. There's just not enough of any, even cumulatively.

Not to suggest a TMNT movie of this tone wouldn't make me punch the nearest wall, but it's the same as the G.I. Joe movie didn't overly concern itself with existing G.I. Joe fans, or the Transformers movie similarly didn't overly concern itself with any existing Transformers fans.

Not really. Not really at all.

Do you really think 80%... or hell, even 40% of the people that went to see "Fantastic Four" were already existing Fantastic Four fans?

Of course not. People saw a slick trailer, some savvy marketing, bought tickets and waited in line.


Right. The repeating cycles in TMNT history (in the larger media) is kind of like this:

They do the same thing over and over again, aiming at the lowest common denominator time and time again and every time they throw their arms up and go, "Huh! We keep aiming for toddlers and they keep outgrowing this! -- why? Ah well, let's just try it again in a few years."

Well the Fantastic Four thing is kind of irrelevant here because that was never a franchise that was as big as some of the other heavyweights. And I guarentee that the Spider-man and Batman film franchises had a lot to do with the numbers B-Level superhero movies like the Fantastic Four put up.

Are you telling me though that people didn't go see Batman out of nostalgia at first? Same thing with Spider-man. Especially Batman though after the horrendous Batman and Robin film. People came back for nostalgic purposes. A few good reviews and a solid story and bam...you have Dark Knight a few yrs later. Correct me if I'm wrong but when growing up nothing was bigger than the turtles at school...Everyone loved them. Even if they don't have the same legnthy publishing history I feel like the turtles can be on that level. I think there is a following of people who still enjoy them and old fans that would come back .. I think it just has to do with getting a good story. GI Joe and Transformer were big but I don't believe they were as big as the turtles.

And I have to respectfully disagree with your last statement. Maybe a few yrs ago that would be true but in 2010 after the box office beaking numbers the Dark Knights and the Iron Mans put up I'd be shocked if this movie was aimied at little kids. At worse I think the tone will be very close to the 2k3 series. I'd be shocked if it was any lighter.

joe-eyeball
07-06-2010, 07:05 PM
Does anybody really think this movie will do great box office. Most people who know of the turtles but were never really fans will more than likely be turned off by another ninja turtle movie and there is not enough die hards out there that would create large box office numbers. And if it is marketed towards kids then you really only grab boys as most girls would not be interested in this. The bottom line is that the TMNT is kind of a B list band of superheroes that had their day at #1 back in the late 80's and early 90's but will never achieve the level of some of the Marvel and DC characters do today. I wish this were not true but it is probably fact.

ooglafina
07-06-2010, 07:08 PM
And if it is marketed towards kids then you really only grab boys as most girls would not be interested in this.

Who's to say girls wouldn't be interested? My sister and I are girls and we were and are interested. Girls like "boy" stuff too. If it's cool we like it.

Shred87
07-06-2010, 07:11 PM
Does anybody really think this movie will do great box office. Most people who know of the turtles but were never really fans will more than likely be turned off by another ninja turtle movie and there is not enough die hards out there that would create large box office numbers. And if it is marketed towards kids then you really only grab boys as most girls would not be interested in this. The bottom line is that the TMNT is kind of a B list band of superheroes that had their day at #1 back in the late 80's and early 90's but will never achieve the level of some of the Marvel and DC characters do today. I wish this were not true but it is probably fact.

Part of me agrees with you . The other part asks how many quality variations of the turtles have been created since the early 90's. With the comic movie explosion and a fresh creative team taking a crack at the characters there is certainly some reason for hope. Especially if it's live action... the CGI movie had no shot.

And to a point your right about the DC/Marvel characters. And thats because they have kept there character's alive and fresh over the years. If there was one independent franchise that had a shot at that level I'd say it'd be the turtles though just because they were on top at a time. I really wish Eastman and Laird would have flipped this franchise to one of those two companies in the heyday. I bet this would be a much different conversation.

joe-eyeball
07-06-2010, 07:12 PM
Who's to say girls wouldn't be interested? My sister and I are girls and we were and are interested. Girls like "boy" stuff too. If it's cool we like it.

Because this is a fact. I think you know that the TMNT fanbase is mostly made of people of the male sex. I know there are always exceptions, but the fact is that the turtles have always been marketed heavily and almost exclusively towards the boy demographic and not girls.

Spitfire
07-06-2010, 09:18 PM
Just to play devils advocate.. For the first movie do you think that people won't go see it because Shredder isn't in it?
One of the major complaints about TMNT was no Shredder. That alone tells me that's what people want to see. Plus you can't do the origin without Shredder unless you completely change everything. They may decide to do that but again that wouldn't be very smart.

I tend to think that people will go see the first Live Action turtle movie regardless out of nostalgia.
People already did that once a few years ago, I don't see them jumping to do it again. Most people hated TMNT or thought it was just "okay", fans included.

If it's any good people will def go back to see a sequel if Shredders a factor. I feel it can be more succesful this way then the other way around. What if Shredder is used in the first film and the movie is average. What is going to keep those fringe fans coming back for a second??
Your logic only works assuming most people like good movies. However most people don't like good movies they like ****, complete ****. Crap like Twilight makes tons of money while the good movies for the most part sit on the back burner and make barely enough to cover production costs.

Now it's funny you said this other thing...is Batman really 10x more popular than the turtles?? I was born when the first movie came out for the turtles so I may have a warped sense of what was popular growing up but I don't remember anything being as popular as the turtles. Batman has gotten better treatment over the 70 yrs he's been around. He's been around longer and there's many more versions of him that people relate too. But IMO that goes on the shoulders of Eastman and Laird for not continuing to develop the turtles story.
Dark Knight is #3 on the highest all time domestic gross list. Batman is more popular then turtles. You ask someone from another country who can't speak English who Batman is and I bet you they're more likely to know then if you asked them about the Ninja Turtles. Batman's fanbase is larger as well if that's any indication. Batman has a huge base of hardcore and casual fans. Turtles has a lot of casual fans who have "rose tinted" memories of the old toon but not so many hardcore fans. The hardcore fans it does have are usually jaded anyway because we've been treated like crap for so long.

Again I like your idea but I just don't see it working. I can see from an optimistic stand point why you'd not only want it to work but think it would, I'm sadly just a cynic.

Shred87
07-06-2010, 09:42 PM
One of the major complaints about TMNT was no Shredder. That alone tells me that's what people want to see. Plus you can't do the origin without Shredder unless you completely change everything. They may decide to do that but again that wouldn't be very smart.


People already did that once a few years ago, I don't see them jumping to do it again. Most people hated TMNT or thought it was just "okay", fans included.


Your logic only works assuming most people like good movies. However most people don't like good movies they like ****, complete ****. Crap like Twilight makes tons of money while the good movies for the most part sit on the back burner and make barely enough to cover production costs.


Dark Knight is #3 on the highest all time domestic gross list. Batman is more popular then turtles. You ask someone from another country who can't speak English who Batman is and I bet you they're more likely to know then if you asked them about the Ninja Turtles. Batman's fanbase is larger as well if that's any indication. Batman has a huge base of hardcore and casual fans. Turtles has a lot of casual fans who have "rose tinted" memories of the old toon but not so many hardcore fans. The hardcore fans it does have are usually jaded anyway because we've been treated like crap for so long.

Again I like your idea but I just don't see it working. I can see from an optimistic stand point why you'd not only want it to work but think it would, I'm sadly just a cynic.

LOL We'll agree to disagree on some points.. I don't think TMNT is a good benchmark though because it's CGI..I mean it's a cartoon. If a Batman cartoon was to be made I'd imagine it would have similar results. I don't see teens/adults paying $12 to watch a cartoon. I think Live Action would have better results. Yo

The Twilight series is lightening in a bottle. It has a strong niche now but it goes without saying no one will be asking for a Twilight comeback 10 yrs from now.

I'm not at all saying the Turtles can put up Dark Knight numbers. But I def think they could be a success at the box office. It's all about the story and getting a few positive reviews. Can that happen? We'll see.

As far as changing the orgin with no Shredder.. I guess I had something like the 2k3 series in mind. If my memory serves me correct I believe it was quite a few eps before we actually saw Shredder in Shredder gear. I think it could work if somethin glike that was done.

I can't argue that Batman is more popular than the turtles now. Highest grossing comic movie, one of the best cartoon series, a new animated film out every other month, one of the longest running comics..it goes on and on. I hate to keep repeating myself but it's simply because more has been done with the character since the early 90's. Batman was the other childhood love of mine so I know just about everything about the character's history. I honestly see a lot of similarities with the two franchises. I'm just hoping that with a new creative team we might get the turtles version of Frank Millers Dark Knight Returns and give this franchise the makeover and facelift it needs.

Dragon Turtle
07-06-2010, 11:57 PM
I'm not at all saying the Turtles can put up Dark Knight numbers. But I def think they could be a success at the box office. It's all about the story and getting a few positive reviews.


And Marketing/Hype.

ooglafina
07-07-2010, 07:45 AM
I guess I just keep coming back to the idea that if you make an appealing movie, they will come. Not necessarily a good movie, but an appealing movie. Sometimes these paths cross.

Koi
12-17-2010, 12:07 AM
no Shredder in the upcoming movie???

I don't really mind, as long as the plot line stays away from magic, and outer space.

The Stryker
12-17-2010, 02:21 PM
It would be awful. The series only has one good villain and that's Shredder.

Sorry mirage fans but nobody wants to see Savanti Romero in a starring role.

azrael
12-17-2010, 03:14 PM
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III: The Turtles Are Back... In Time (1993)
No Shredder referenced for the entire movie...

Thats not true you just have to know where to look.

http://sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash2/hs300.ash2/58075_146404665409645_100001203382887_287194_83162 66_n.jpg

;) I didnt notice it until recently
________
house wives Webcams (http://www.girlcamfriend.com/webcam/housewives/)

Candy Kappa
12-17-2010, 03:24 PM
I don't see any shredder reference there just a Samurai

Powder
12-17-2010, 03:35 PM
Yeah, dude. That's not a reference to Shredder, its a samurai. Shredders armor is a reference to Samurai...

Spitfire
12-17-2010, 03:47 PM
It would be awful. The series only has one good villain and that's Shredder.

Sorry mirage fans but nobody wants to see Savanti Romero in a starring role.
If we're just talking Mirage Shredder would be the worst villain to pick.

Stockman? He could easily carry a movie. Throw in the robot body transformation in the same film and you make a good story about consequences. The turtles destroy Stockman's Mouser factory, assume he's dead, and he comes back as the robot.

Complete Carnage. Flesh him out a little more and he'd make a good one.

Rat King, extend his story.

The gang story they were working on before Mirage ended was neat. They could use that character, forgot his name.

The turtles has plenty of villains that would be memorable on screen. The problem is Shredder is the most well known so they're pretty much required to use him because it's what everyone expects.

They could also pull a Hellboy. The first movie used the most well known story from the comics. The sequel used all new villains made just for the film. Since TMNT's villains are all basically unknown except by hardcore fans that formula could work.

Koi
12-18-2010, 12:30 AM
Look at the CGI TMNT villians.

Fugitoid Jones
12-20-2010, 05:02 AM
I'm indifferent if they actually use the Shredder in the movie, but I have a feeling they will use him. I don't think Nick is gonna wanna take chances by not having the A list characters in a movie that is not a guarantee hit.

And I'm sorry, but you can't compare the Batman franchise to the Turtles franchise. Batman has been around for like 70 years and is part of Americana and is instantly recognized around the world and the character has been in the public eye nearly the entire time. The Turtles were a pop culture phenomenon in the late 80's, early 90's, that had a moderate comeback in 2K3. Batman has mass appeal and has always stayed relevant, while most people, that aren't hardcore fans like us, still associate the Turtles with dated 80's/90's references like "Cowabunga", "Radical" and "Pizza time". There really is no comparison.