PDA

View Full Version : Did Shredder win Battle Nexus?


Shred87
08-02-2010, 12:11 AM
I know we saw his helmet but I remember reading a letter to PL and his response was... "Someone wearing the Shredder helmet won the nexus".....did we ever get a direct answer to this?

gobo
08-02-2010, 12:18 AM
I think that suggests the original, human Oroku Saki did. Not sure though.

Vivi
08-02-2010, 12:18 AM
Well, the Damiyo's son came to Earth pre-Nexus to fight Leonardo in lieu of Shredder as Leo had already defeated the best warrior (aka Shredder). I guess it's possible that the Shredder has at some point reigned supreme at the Battle Nexus but to what ends, who knows?

Spitfire
08-02-2010, 12:33 AM
I was under the impression the BN statues were lined up by winner. So Splinter won, Yoshi won, Mikey won, Shredder won. I could be remembering this wrong but Mikey's statue was next to Splinter's and wasn't Shredder's next to Yoshi's or Splinter's? This would to me suggest that if they competed every time it came around that Splinter would have crossed paths with Shredder in the BN or Yoshi at least.

I could be wrong about that though. Anyways to answer your question I think PL was referring to Utrom Shredder. As he wasn't the real Shredder and he was "wearing" Shredder's helmet. It could have also been one of the members of the Ninja Tribunal.

Shred87
08-03-2010, 07:10 PM
hmm ok... here's the thing ppl keep saying that the "real" Shredder may have won it...to this point I have only seen seasons 1-3 completly. I just purchased the region 4 version of season 4. I've been waiting to watch that before the Ninja Tribunal season. In what season is this real Shredder utrom Shredder sorted out? I kind of feel out of the loop.

ToTheNines
08-03-2010, 07:25 PM
Coulda been Oroku Yoshi from Mirage Volume 4.

gobo
08-03-2010, 08:59 PM
This would to me suggest that if they competed every time it came around that Splinter would have crossed paths with Shredder in the BN or Yoshi at least.
Yoshi was killed before Splinter was even mutated. :ohwell:
In what season is this real Shredder utrom Shredder sorted out?
Season 5 (aka Ninja Tribunal), ep "Legend of the 5 Dragons"...

Shred87
08-04-2010, 07:09 PM
Coulda been Oroku Yoshi from Mirage Volume 4.

nice call my friend... i forgot about that one

Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
08-05-2010, 12:09 AM
I'm sorry but I'm not buying the Ch'rell fought in the Battle Nexus, unless he was there just to try and take the Daimyo's warstaff. It might of been human Oroku Saki before he was possessed by the Shredder Tengu but even that is pushing it. Most likely just a look alike or maybe one of the Ninja Tribunal. Remember that all 5 of them wore that exact helmet. And the statue itself did not have any spikes on the gauntlet and gloves.

BubblyShell22
08-05-2010, 08:00 AM
Yes, I'm guessing it was probably one of the Tribunal members and not Shredder himself. It seems more logical to me since Yoshi also fought in the Battle Nexus and probably learned about it from the Ancient One via the Tribunal.

Redeemer
08-05-2010, 11:26 PM
Yes, I'm guessing it was probably one of the Tribunal members and not Shredder himself. It seems more logical to me since Yoshi also fought in the Battle Nexus and probably learned about it from the Ancient One via the Tribunal.

If this was so wouldn't have all of them one and would they have not been anual champions due to there powers and skill?

Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
08-06-2010, 12:27 AM
If this was so wouldn't have all of them one and would they have not been anual champions due to there powers and skill?

Remember the Tribunal were just ninjas before they got all their magical powers. They didn't look to achieve that until after Saki made the deal with the Shredder Tengu. So it makes sense that any of them could of gone to the Battle Nexus and would of fought traditionally with no aid of magic.

Shred87
08-16-2010, 09:36 PM
well i just got caught on on seasons 4 and 5 and sure enough all my questions were answered...but i must say.. what the heck happened in season 5? i felt like i was watching animated power rangers...i wasnt digging the whole ninja tribunal...no wonder they decided to skip that season

shuriken
08-17-2010, 11:43 AM
^Yeah it felt out of place like a sore thumb didn't it? But I'd say it was probably the 13th or 14th century Oroku Saki, the original one that competed.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
08-18-2010, 06:20 PM
The Ultimate Ninja came to earth to challenge Leonardo because Leonardo "killed" the Shredder before the Ultimate Ninja got to him...but I don't remember whether or not he wanted to challenge Shredder because he'd lost to him at some point in the Battle-Nexus, or simply because he had never had the chance to face Ch'rell and simply couldn't resist the idea of facing him (both are egomaniacs, Ultimate Ninja and Ch'rell are essentially the same character, except in the sense that there is no chance of redemption for Ch'rell, whereas Ultimate Ninja is given a second chance).

Considering Ch'rell's ego and amazing fighting abilities, it wouldn't surprise me if he won the Battle-Nexus championship at some point, and I'm almost certain that Oroku Yoshi did as well... I have a theory that Laird stated "someone wearing the Shredder helmet won the Battle-Nexus championship at some point" not to imply that the person wearing the Shredder helmet wasn't Shredder, but to create suspense/keep it open-ended. Vol. 4 is confusing, but I almost wonder if the Warriors of Virtue were a separate branch of the Foot Clan whatsoever who existed to serve Oroku Saki in another dimension much like our own (hence the Al Gore medallion), and I almost wonder if they think that Oroku Yoshi and Leonardo were both responsible for Saki's death--hence their beef with the both of them. It would explain their beef with the Foot Clan in this dimension and with Karai. It would make sense if their purpose is to exterminate anyone who isn't an outspoken Leonardo enemy.

ABrown
09-24-2010, 03:05 PM
My opinion on this matter is a little complex. See originally I think that the creators of the show intended for the Shredder to be a human. And after season one was more or less completed, someone decided that Shredder needed to return after season one. However, Leonardo had already cut his head off. What was the easiest way to fix this problem? Turn Shredder into an utrom.

How does this fit in with the whole Battle Nexus story? I think that it was going to be been revealed that Shredder did in fact win a Battle Nexus tournament. So the Ultimate Ninja came to Earth to compete against the Shredder. However, Leonardo had already killed Shredder. So the Ultimate Ninja turned his sights to Leonardo. Since the creators decided to screw this all up by making the Shredder an utrom, none of this makes any sense. Shredder most likely knew nothing of the Battle Nexus, given that he didn't learn of alternate dimensions until "Turtles Forever."

Coola Yagami
09-24-2010, 11:22 PM
My opinion on this matter is a little complex. See originally I think that the creators of the show intended for the Shredder to be a human. And after season one was more or less completed, someone decided that Shredder needed to return after season one. However, Leonardo had already cut his head off. What was the easiest way to fix this problem? Turn Shredder into an utrom.

How does this fit in with the whole Battle Nexus story? I think that it was going to be been revealed that Shredder did in fact win a Battle Nexus tournament. So the Ultimate Ninja came to Earth to compete against the Shredder. However, Leonardo had already killed Shredder. So the Ultimate Ninja turned his sights to Leonardo. Since the creators decided to screw this all up by making the Shredder an utrom, none of this makes any sense. Shredder most likely knew nothing of the Battle Nexus, given that he didn't learn of alternate dimensions until "Turtles Forever."

Naw, season 1 already had some clues, like Saki being conviniently taped up around the waist and such.

shuriken
09-27-2010, 11:53 PM
Go back and watch season one again ABrown, there are some pretty heavy cues that ol' Shredhead was an Utrom. No "Living "organism could touch the sword of Tengu without getting burned or shocked. The reason Shredder could hold it was due to the fact that he wasn't human, but rather an exosuit with an Utrom inside of it.

Powder
09-28-2010, 12:33 AM
Heh, well anyone can tell from the first time the sword of tengu shows up that it has an utrom head as the bottom cap whos tentacles wrap around the handle.

Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
09-28-2010, 12:49 AM
Well we all thought that the Foot Symbol was actually a representative of what an Utorm looks like but Season 5 changed that because we then learned that the Foot Symbol is the 5 Dragon's emblem turned upside by the Tengu Shredder as a perversion to his former friends.

megashredder
10-09-2010, 02:52 AM
Yes it was the human shredder, he's much stronger than the Utrom Shredder.

phillytmnt
10-09-2010, 05:05 PM
I think it was the utrom shredder. Ultimate ninja came to earth wanting to fight him and one of the reasons he could know of the shredder is because he was a former battle nexus fighter. I also thinks it fits the utrom shredders personality to wanna compete in a tourtament like that. He always seemed to have a large ego and claim nobody can defeat him. I can see him wanting to fight to prove to others he is the best.
I cant see it being the human shredder. First of all, he didn't become the shredder until he became one with the tengu. I couldn't see an all powerful tengu wanting to compete against mortals in a fighting tourtment. He was too worried about conquering the world. He would also have far to much of an advantage with all the magic he posscesses

ABrown
11-24-2010, 11:52 AM
Remember, the utrom Shredder stated in Turtles Forever that he was just learning about parallel dimensions. So if he had competed in the battle nexus, he would've known that parallel dimensions do exist. And furthermore, if he had ever fought in the battle nexus, he would've sought allies to aid in his fight against the utroms. It makes much more sense that it would be the demon Shredder that fought in the battle nexus at some point. And the Ultimate Ninja came looking for him, unaware that the utrom Shredder had stolen his identity.

kenshin
11-25-2010, 10:48 AM
I think Battle Nexus isn't between dimensions just different worlds like mortal kombat.We see Triceratons and turtles same galaxy.Dimensions in turtles forever always had some smiliarites.We don't see any similar things beetween nexus fighters.If Utrom Shredder try the make allies there no one wants the join him.His fake identity just a undergorund crime lord in Earth. He's not has any weapon or tecnology better than space crimals.Saki not big as Ch'rell and if He tells true identity Utroms find Him before make an attack.

k_lala
12-28-2010, 07:41 PM
I always took it as the Chrell Shredder that won it. That guy was around for a long time.

ABrown
12-31-2010, 02:19 PM
I always took it as the Chrell Shredder that won it. That guy was around for a long time.

But so was the demon Shredder.

k_lala
01-01-2011, 02:16 PM
But so was the demon Shredder.

Yup could be both, the battle nexus is held every 3 years. Ultrom was around for centuries so its not like he couldn't have been in it.

Although i do remember the Domino did say when he came to earth to seek out the most skilled warriors the humans found them to be Tengu.

Keldor1578
01-12-2011, 07:08 PM
I just can't see Ch'rell in competing the battle nexus, I think it was any of the ninja tribunal won the battle nexus.

k_lala
01-13-2011, 01:38 PM
I just can't see Ch'rell in competing the battle nexus, I think it was any of the ninja tribunal won the battle nexus.

Why not? I find it weirder that Ch'rell adopted Karai and became a father figure to her.

Desslok
01-17-2011, 07:48 PM
Competing for sport in the Battle Nexus seems like something that would be "beneath" the Utrom Shredder. If he had some sort of access to the Nexus, I'm most definately sure he would have attempted to plunder its resources to further his evil intentions elsewhere, then destroy it once it served him no further purpose as he's done with so many other worlds.

Defeating the Daimyo and his forces would be no small task, but if there's anyone who could figure a way to do it it would be that crafty little Utrom.

AT-Man
01-18-2011, 05:02 AM
I can't remember if the original Oroku Saki had a shredder-type armour before he became a demon, but if he did, my guess is it was the HUMAN Oroku Saki who competed.

Hard to think that either Utrom or Tengu Shredder had stood there with the prize and everybody cheering...

shuriken
01-18-2011, 10:49 PM
I can't remember if the original Oroku Saki had a shredder-type armour before he became a demon, but if he did, my guess is it was the HUMAN Oroku Saki who competed.

Hard to think that either Utrom or Tengu Shredder had stood there with the prize and everybody cheering...

Tengu Shredder probably not. But the Utrom Shredder could have won it Centuries ago. Before he was captured by the Utroms even. Matbe he destroyed a civilization and went incognito and decided to compete to hone his skills. Of the 5 Shredder's introduced (CH'rel, Tengu, Karai, Saki, and Cyber) in the 2K3 Series, Feudal Oroku Saki and Utrom Shredder seem the best candidates.