View Full Version : Least favorite TMNT movie.
Redeemer
08-07-2010, 10:21 PM
Hey have a Q. Why does everybody hate the 3rd movie so much?
Truth be told I like it better than the second. I think I dont like bc only don uses his weapon and he uses it 1.
Anythoughts ?
Herald7
08-07-2010, 10:31 PM
The 3rd movie had a couple of nice moments, but overall the story just felt confused and rushed. It was obvious that less effort had been put into the writing, the characters' looks, etc.
However, I did like hearing Corey Feldman voice Donatello again. I don't know how other fans felt about that, but I always thought he did a good job, hehe.
TMNachoT
08-07-2010, 11:07 PM
first film... great!
second film... too many silly jokes. they made tokka and razhar too stupid. vanilla ice?
regarding the third film, casey is not a crazy vigilante but some kind of babysitter, Splinter looks less real compared w/ secret of the ooze. how come they started the film with a dance???? ok, they were practising... but with a dance???
what i liked from the 3th film is that they used the weapons more than they did in the second film. in that aspect the 3th film is better than secret of the ooze... just that.
4th film... munroe, when talking about the film in pre-production, gave me the impression that his film will be the ultimate tmnt film... no way! monsters? that thing of the planets...? no, way.
Powder
08-07-2010, 11:14 PM
My vote went to "TMNT 4" as you put it, otherwise simply known as "TMNT". For one, I'm not a fan of CGI. That alone took points off. The fact that it was one big Leo/Raph catfight was wack, there were too many villains & not enough character development, Casey & April were pretty much romantic relief, Mikey was even more played out then he was in 2k3 (not to mention the fact that he & Don both were pratically ignored for the duration of the film), & the up in the air vibe of the canon has us fans arguing all the time regardless of what is fact or fiction. I mean, I do like the film, really, but its my least favorite without a doubt.
how come they started the film with a dance???? ok, they were practising... but with a dance???
Haha, need I remind you that it was a kids movie? Its that simple.
TMNachoT
08-07-2010, 11:19 PM
Haha, need I remind you that it was a kids movie? Its that simple.
don´t need to.
:lol: :lol:
Herald7
08-07-2010, 11:20 PM
second film... too many silly jokes. they made tokka and razhar too stupid. vanilla ice?
Yeah the Vanilla Ice scene with the turtles dancing in the middle of a fight was just the worst kind of commercialism and pop culture hype, which inevitably seems dated and embarrassing years later. (Especially with the scientist joining in. I mean that guy's a great actor and that was kind of painful to watch, heh.)
how come they started the film with a dance???? ok, they were practising... but with a dance???
Yes that's one reason you can't take the movie seriously right off the bat. Again, they were being treated like a trendy brand name, rather than actual characters.
I haven't actually seen the 4th film, only the Nostalgia Critics's review, which was awesome, hehe. It does sound like its big problem was a storyline that nobody really cared about overshadowing the turtles.
My least favorite TMNT movie is the 4th. Why because no Donatello or Michelangelo Raph and Leo fighting gets a bit boring after awhile and the darn monsters.
Herald7
08-07-2010, 11:22 PM
Raph and Leo fighting gets a bit boring after awhile
Yeah plus that was already done in the 1st movie (and much better ;) ).
TMNachoT
08-07-2010, 11:23 PM
i do not like cgi, but this technique was the best way to bring characters/plots that were hard to recreate with a live action film... the saga with the triceratons could have been better than the characters seen in the tmnt film.
Voidoid
08-08-2010, 12:36 AM
My vote went to "TMNT 4". I think everyone already pretty much summed it up on here. I can't even look at those turtles without cringing and dying a little bit inside. They need a pizza or two.
Herald7
08-08-2010, 12:44 AM
Well I do also want to add that the depiction of Asians in the 3rd film was pretty insensitive to say the least, especially in this day and age.
hudemx
08-08-2010, 05:49 AM
I didn't like the fourth one.
It had so many Plotholes that I simply just can't stand to watch it anymore...
ooglafina
08-08-2010, 10:01 AM
I picked the third because at least it's pretty and I like the voice actors. hehe. I need pretty pictures. The suits in the third movie are so irritatingly bad that I can't watch it all the way through. Plus the voice acting, particularly on Splinter, is not very good. I could list endless reasons, but it's already been done somewhere else in another thread.
Redeemer
08-08-2010, 01:10 PM
Wow I didn't think there would be so much hate for the 4th movie.
I thought at least a few people agree with me about the 2nd one. This is very confusing.
1.They dont use weapons
2. Too many corny jokes
3. The super shredder fight sucks
4. Fight scenes overal sucks.
only good thing- Super Shredder= Kevin Nash = awesome
Shred87
08-08-2010, 01:11 PM
I voted for 3 even though its close between 3 and 4... I think the look of the suits from 3 kind of turn me off to it... and not to start a war the thing that I hate about the 4th film that although it's considered to be in film canon it certainly feels like its the 2k3 cartoon CGI movie... April a ninja? Not in the movies I saw..
discordiatookie
08-08-2010, 02:01 PM
I don't really like polls like this, as I try to see the best in everything. Sure, the suits are a bit crap in the third one, but there's still parts of that film I really dig. And I think I must be the only one on here that still likes the CGI movie. Sure, there ain't enough Don/Mikey scenes, but I had a blast watching it and still find it to be pretty enjoyable.
TheCanadiandrome
08-08-2010, 03:19 PM
my vote is also the 4th one. just not a fan of CGI
Spitfire
08-08-2010, 04:13 PM
How many times a month does this topic of discussion have to come up?
Venom
08-08-2010, 04:20 PM
Fourteen:D
Redeemer
08-08-2010, 08:24 PM
How many times a month does this topic of discussion have to come up?
my bad I never saw this topic pop up... lol I am suprised. lol sorry:D
Guitar_Raph
08-09-2010, 04:48 AM
Didn't much care or see 2 that much. But it was cool to see the musical moment...
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/PCenter/Ninja%20Turtles%20The%20Next%20Mutation/DancingTMNT.jpg
Dancing TMNT.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/PCenter/Ninja%20Turtles%20The%20Next%20Mutation/MikeyandVanillaIce.jpg
Mikey & Vanilla Ice
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/PCenter/Ninja%20Turtles%20The%20Next%20Mutation/Mikeyonkeytar.jpg
Mikey playing keytar.
Also, 3 was OK. But the coolest part was when Mikey sported the super sized trunks.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/PCenter/Ninja%20Turtles%20The%20Next%20Mutation/Mikeyswimwear.jpg
Fugitoid Jones
08-09-2010, 05:36 AM
I HATE the third movie.
The first one is one of my all time fav movies, the second one is entertaining but I thought lacked the action and story of the first, and the new movie was again entertaining but imo had a very weak story and was only fun to watch when the Turtles were onscreen.
That third movie though, I can't even watch it anymore. I hate the way the costumes look, Splinter looks like a dime store puppet, the jokes are old and cliche, the action scenes are unimpressive, the villains are uninspired, and Casey Jones is horribly misused. It's garbage.
Shark_Blade
08-09-2010, 09:21 AM
Hey have a Q. Why does everybody hate the 3rd movie so much?
Truth be told I like it better than the second. I think I dont like bc only don uses his weapon and he uses it 1.
Anythoughts ?I feel the same. This is how I see it:
1. TMNT I
2. TMNT III
3. TMNT II
4. TMNT IV
1. Tmnt 2
2. Tmnt 3
3. Tmnt
4. Tmnt 4
:d ...
Bmaga123
08-09-2010, 12:34 PM
1. TMNT 1
2. TMNT 2
3. TMNT 4
4. TMNT 3
Sorry but the costumes in part 3 killed that movie along with the horrible splinter puppet and voice. Didnt like the story or villians to much either and agree that Casey Jones was misused big time. First movie is one of my all time favorite movies, I consider it to be a masterpiece :-)
ooglafina
08-09-2010, 04:41 PM
1. TMNT 1
2. TMNT 2
3. TMNT 4
4. TMNT 3
Sorry but the costumes in part 3 killed that movie along with the horrible splinter puppet and voice. Didnt like the story or villians to much either and agree that Casey Jones was misused big time. First movie is one of my all time favorite movies, I consider it to be a masterpiece :-)
I agree with your order of favorites.
Charlotte_Sometimes
08-09-2010, 07:55 PM
For me, the first and second movie come up tie.
The grittiness of the first movie was great, and the fights were really cool. The first film felt like a watered-down adaption of the Mirage comics. Decent, but still lacking.
With the second movie, the costumes looked the best, and the humor and action made it alot of fun to watch. It was more like a live-action version of the classic cartoon.
I wasn't at all impressed with the third movie. The story and plot was poor, and the costumes were just as bad. It was nice seeing more scenes and camera time on April though. And it was especially fun watching her get into the action instead of being a helpless dame.
The fourth movie was a step up from the third one, but still not as great and fun as the first two movies.
And I was rather peeved that Don and Mikey didn't get as much attention as Leo and Raph. Would have been nice to see the story more centered around Don and Mikey rather than Leo and Raph (especially Raph).
And I was also peeved that Mikey was so annoying and not at all funny really. It's like he's lost his touch somehow since the classic cartoon.
ooglafina
08-09-2010, 08:13 PM
And I was rather peeved that Don and Mikey didn't get as much attention as Leo and Raph. Would have been nice to see the story more centered around Don and Mikey rather than Leo and Raph (especially Raph).
And I was also peeved that Mikey was so annoying and not at all funny really. It's like he's lost his touch somehow since the classic cartoon.
I think that's the big problem that most people had with that one. I like Raph. He's my favorite. I just get tired of him being presented as a guy who has no idea of how to not hate everyone and everything. I'd like to see him enjoying himself for a parsec for once.
And Mikey was way too brain dead. I thought Don was pretty annoying. He was like the bitchy wife of the family.
I didn't mind Leo so much. I thought he had a good entrance as the heroic figure literally catching the falling damsel. But I'd also like to see him crack a joke or smile or something. Kid around with Raph maybe. I don't know.
Charlotte_Sometimes
08-09-2010, 08:31 PM
I agree with all of that.
Raph just annoys me with his ridiculous attitude. I very much prefer Raph from the classic cartoon over the rest.
Mikey just tries too hard to be funny to the point that's it's just annoying. Like I said, he's lost his touch in the 2000s.
Don was fine but needs more attention. He's got soooo much untapped depth. Probably more so than the rest of his bros.
Leo was actually portraid as cool and cocky for once, which I think is an accurate depiction.
Like really, living his whole life as the superior ninja and leader of his bros, and isolated from any real oposition and challenge from the outside world should logicly make Leo cocky, arrogant and proud. Especially as a teenager.
I never understood the whole modesty approuch in other mainstream versions of him.
Herald7
08-10-2010, 09:09 PM
Raph just annoys me with his ridiculous attitude. I very much prefer Raph from the classic cartoon over the rest.
I agree; I think that whole "Grrr I'm the angry" gets tiresome after awhile. During "Turtles Forever" I kept thinking, "Why would the others even keep him around?"
I did like Raphael in the 1st movie because you could see how some of the hostility was just him feeling insecure and conflicted. He really does remind you of a teenage boy. That's why I love the 1st film, they really took it seriously without becoming ridiculous.
Of course OT Raphael is a watered down version of the character, but he still provides a much needed contrast in the group. The other three are for the most part pretty cheerful and dedicated to the cause, and Raphael adds some spice by being sarcastic and sort of snarky. And let's face it, he always had some of the best lines, hehe. :twink:
Samhain
08-10-2010, 09:56 PM
I voted for 3. I can watch all the Turtle movies easily but its hard not to turn off 3 and go do something else. lol. If Im thinking like that during a movie, there is something wrong.
I LOVE the first movie. One of my top ten favorite movies of all time.
Two, not so much. It is kinda annoying with all the dumb jokes. A little over the top.
Four I like. Im a sucker for CGI.
ooglafina
08-10-2010, 09:56 PM
I agree; I think that whole "Grrr I'm the angry" gets tiresome after awhile. During "Turtles Forever" I kept thinking, "Why would the others even keep him around?"
I did like Raphael in the 1st movie because you could see how some of the hostility was just him feeling insecure and conflicted. He really does remind you of a teenage boy. That's why I love the 1st film, they really took it seriously without becoming ridiculous.
I've had those, "Why don't they just hog-tie him and dump him someplace," thoughts too.
I like Raph best when he's presented as being conflicted because that's all I see his bravado and aggression as being. Just covering up alot of fear. And that's a much more interesting angle than a guy who just seems to have PMS all the time.
raphfan84
11-05-2010, 05:44 PM
Sorry Movie III fans, but I thought 3 was the worst. I just didn like the fact the suits looked horrible, I did not like the fact it did not take place in New York and sorry I know some may disagree but Shredder was never mentioned. Yes I know they killed him in the 2nd but still when I think of the tmnt I also think of Shredder and the Foot. I would of liked to have seen maybe Tatsu be the main villain in 3 along with the foot...but idk just a thought. Another thing is Splinter had to of been the worst looking Splinter out of the 3 not to mention Kevin Clash not doing his voice that didn help either. But that's just my OP. :toops:
drewizzle88
11-05-2010, 05:55 PM
I had to vote for #4 I actually fell asleep during it at the theater the first time I watched it.
DonatelloDomeHead31
11-09-2010, 11:41 PM
I chose the 2nd one. it's my least favorite because the turtles don't use their weapons as much, and in my opinion, humor isn't wasn't that good. Michaelangelo made more jokes than Donatello in the 1st and 3rd movies.
Donatello was funny in the 1st & 3rd movies, which is why I enjoyed them more.
"East Meets West" was the worst movie, no contest.
tone-master21
11-10-2010, 12:25 AM
I thought that TMNT 3 was the worst.
Powder
11-10-2010, 12:45 AM
"East Meets West" was the worst movie, no contest.
I guess I'm not the only one who somewhat considers that to be a movie. I may however be the only one who likes it more then TMNT, though.
Spitfire
11-10-2010, 01:42 AM
With the second movie, the costumes looked the best, and the humor and action made it alot of fun to watch. It was more like a live-action version of the classic cartoon.
This is exactly why 2 is my favorite. I have more fun watching it because it's not trying to take itself seriously. However the production value is very good, as you mentioned the best costumes of the series. Also the voice acting is my favorite. Adam Carl is my all time favorite Donatello.
The jokes, no matter how corny, make me laugh. It's probably a nostalgia thing. The pre-fight doughnut line always gets me. You can mock the Vanilla Ice part all you want but you know as a kid you were all into that. I think most would agree that Ninja Rap is the best and most iconic turtles related movie song. Turtle Power is a close second but the song lacks the energy and isn't as memorable.
Another thing 2 did well was give all 4 turtles equal screen time. Not only where there lots of fights but most of them had all 4 in it. Also as far as story went each turtle had their part to play and it was more balanced then 1 in that respect. My problem with 1 was Mikey and Don were reduced to nothing but comic relief.
shuriken
11-10-2010, 02:02 AM
This is exactly why 2 is my favorite. I have more fun watching it because it's not trying to take itself seriously. However the production value is very good, as you mentioned the best costumes of the series. Also the voice acting is my favorite. Adam Carl is my all time favorite Donatello.
The jokes, no matter how corny, make me laugh. It's probably a nostalgia thing. The pre-fight doughnut line always gets me. You can mock the Vanilla Ice part all you want but you know as a kid you were all into that. I think most would agree that Ninja Rap is the best and most iconic turtles related movie song. Turtle Power is a close second but the song lacks the energy and isn't as memorable.
Another thing 2 did well was give all 4 turtles equal screen time. Not only where there lots of fights but most of them had all 4 in it. Also as far as story went each turtle had their part to play and it was more balanced then 1 in that respect. My problem with 1 was Mikey and Don were reduced to nothing but comic relief.
I agree on a lot of things, epecially production value. The lip synching is amazing in that movie, miles ahead of 1 and 3.The first is still my favorite one. My least favorite though has to be TMNT (07). Just didn't feel like a movie. It was more like an elseworlds comic that was supposed to be 10 comics but crammed into 3. At least TMNT 3 had a semi interesting villain and lines so bad they were good. TMNT (07) just isn't very memorable.
Abnormal Freak
11-10-2010, 03:19 AM
I hate the third movie. Haaaaaaaate it.
Bad acting, horrendous animatronics/suit designs/puppeteering, a real lousy story, terribly unfunny jokes, etc., etc. There are very few things I care for about the movie. What do I like? The soundtrack CD, though you barely hear any of the songs in the movie save for ZZ Top's song. The scene at the bar/restaurant where the guards dance to "Tarzan Boy"—amuses me every time. A few of the jokes/one-liners ("She's a man!" for instance). And, really, watch the Angry Video Game Nerd's review and I pretty much echo all that, ha ha. Except I don't exactly think it's the most horrible movie in the world.
I do still watch it every now and then. Perhaps I'm a glutton for punishment. I'm not sure why I watch it, but I think it's mostly just for the sake of nostalgia. I saw that flick in the theater when I was six years old, and I came home talking and thinking about it for days. I'm pretty sure it was the first TMNT film I got to see in the theater, and I loved it, and would watch it about a million times on VHS when I was young. So I guess I kind of cherish the movie for this reason alone. Which is weird, because I rarely hang on to anything for nostalgia value if I think the product is really terrible. Usually, if a movie or cartoon or whatever I loved as a kid I think totally stinks now, I hate it. But for this film, there's an exception. Weird.
Uh... I tend to talk more about things I dislike, ha. Must be a negative/pessimistic person. I love the first movie to death, and refuse to believe that anybody seriously voted it as the worst. Like...I just can't take that seriously. I can't! It's got all the best music, the best effects, best acting, best story, best editing, best everything. It's a perfect movie, and one I deeply love and admire. Some of you are talking about the second one having better animatronics: When I compare the two, sure, they have more lip movements in the sequel, but the suits and those lip actions just look far more cartoony to me, and takes away from the believability. In the first flick, they look practically REAL. I've always loved that about the first movie over all the rest.
Second movie, eh, it's fun. I don't hate it. I'm not wild over it, but it is pretty funny and amusing to watch (and I really love the outrageous Ninja Rap segment). Also hold a special place for it in my heart like the other two, but it's several rungs on the ladder below the first movie for me. I don't like the drastic change in subject matter, how cartoony it got. Even before I'd read the original comics, I always loved the story and feel of the first film better than the second. (And when I read the comics, I appreciated the first movie even more.)
I like the fourth movie, TMNT. I just...do. :p A lot of people don't, but I had a blast with it, both times I saw it: in the theater (where there were tons of rambunctious, talkative, laugh-out-LOUD little tykes, and I loved it) and at home. I'm not typically big on CGI, but I liked the CGI work in this film. It just flows real nicely. I thought the story was pretty intriguing. I dunno, I just dig a lot. :p Hard to say why having only seen it twice. To me it feels like an extension of the '03 series, which I really like as well. I just don't get why they didn't use the voice actors from the series for the film. They do for the video games that use the same character designs, don't they? I distinctly remember hearing them in Smash-Up, which clearly followed the '03 series, but...had the CGI movie designs for the Turtles, heh. I guess that was just the style of the day thanks to Ubisoft.
Uh... So yeah. TMNT would probably be my second favorite TMNT flick, followed by...
Turtles Forever. :p Hey, why NOT include it? I really like that flick. Wish I could've seen the director's cut; didn't even know it was available to watch online.
So, to sum up, I'd rank 'em:
1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
TMNT
.
.
2
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
3
;)
2 WAS a lot of fun and obviously had the best suits, but it seriously unraveled at the end. Shredder being ejected from the club by blown-out speakers? Super Shredder having a measly 5 seconds of screen time?? WTF!!! :x
Just my two cents...
Abnormal Freak
11-10-2010, 11:46 AM
I really don't get why people are saying 2 has the best suits, ;) The suits and heads are all super cartoony. Donnie's face the most so. The first movie's suits look about a million times better and more realistic.
Spitfire
11-10-2010, 02:56 PM
Because 2 did have the best suits. You may not like the look of them but the animatronics in them were leagues beyond the 1st movie. In the first film there's scenes where they just had a head that didn't move with an angry look on it's face or something. They were much more lively in 2. There were also less errors.
Abnormal Freak
11-10-2010, 04:08 PM
What sort of errors? I hope you're not talking about the kinds of "errors" I saw on YouTube that mostly had to do with the old VHS transfer being open matte, where stuff that was never meant to be seen is visible. ;) Aside from those, there are a number of errors, but not much that really takes the believability away.
But if you're strictly talking facial features, that has more to do with animatronics, not so much the suits. I'll agree that the animatronics give the faces in the second movie more expression, but the craftsmanship of the suits and heads in the first film is so much better. The second movie's suits are all rubbery; the first movie's suits look like real skin.
Aren't the animatronics part of the suit though?? O_o
Spitfire
11-10-2010, 04:34 PM
Aren't the animatronics part of the suit though?? O_o
Yes they are.
While most of the errors are only visible on a FS copy of the film there's still some that are visible in the WS version. The arm shot when Don is skating in the sewer even made it into the trailer. They just had lower production value/standards for the first film. That's the main reason Judith left and didn't do a sequel.
That's the main reason Judith left and didn't do a sequel.
Wha??? I thought it was cuz she didn't test well with teenage boys.
Abnormal Freak
11-10-2010, 04:48 PM
Aren't the animatronics part of the suit though?? O_o
Part of the suits in that they're the underlying robotics structure of the heads that make the facial movements, true. But I'm talking more about the construction and cosmetics. The first movie's suits just look a whole lot better and realistic to me. You can actually believe, to a point, that there are mutated humanoid turtles interacting with the "live" actors.
I wouldn't say the first film has low production standards. Sometimes with low-budget moviemaking you just have to make certain compromises. Standards (and practices) don't really equate to production value and monetary input. Of course, one's limited in ways to what they can do with a low budget, but that doesn't hurt the integrity of filmmakers, and the art and craft of the overall production. The first TMNT movie and Bubba Ho-tep are perfect examples of very skillfully-made low-budget films that use their low funds efficiently and to the fullest, while putting out great pieces of cinematic art.
shuriken
11-10-2010, 05:56 PM
Whoever edited the 1st movie made A LOT of mistakes. The Donnie arm thing is unforgivable. In a lot of the fight scenes, when the turtles are speaking and you know they are speaking, their lips don't move and you're like what? The scene where Shredder lunges for Splinter you can see the background is just a curtain backdrop. The second one has very little errors like that, their lips always matched what the TMNT or Tokka and Rahzar said. The Story and the fighting in the 1st is the best IMO, but based solely on how the TMNT looked and their facial expressions, SOTO takes the cake.
Spitfire
11-10-2010, 06:18 PM
I wouldn't say the first film has low production standards. Sometimes with low-budget moviemaking you just have to make certain compromises. Standards (and practices) don't really equate to production value and monetary input. Of course, one's limited in ways to what they can do with a low budget, but that doesn't hurt the integrity of filmmakers, and the art and craft of the overall production. The first TMNT movie and Bubba Ho-tep are perfect examples of very skillfully-made low-budget films that use their low funds efficiently and to the fullest, while putting out great pieces of cinematic art.
I would. The film was not low budget. Bubba Hotep cost 1 mil to make in 2002. Turtles cost 13.5 mil to make in 1989. For the time that was pretty substantial for a kids movie, only a few mil less then Home Alone cost which was the top picture of that year by the way. Also Bubba Hotep was an independent film while Turtles had studio backing.
I also wouldn't call turtles 1 cinematic art. Aside from the costumes that's a tough sell. There's nothing at all amazing about the actual filmmaking be that the acting, cinematography, editing, music, and overall production value. I like the movie but it's not amazing by any standards except guys managing to pull off karate moves wearing pounds of rubber.
The Evil Dead films are a better example of what you're talking about. 2 only cost 3.5 mil and had some great costume effects. It was also a well crafted film even if it was obviously a b movie.
Wha??? I thought it was cuz she didn't test well with teenage boys.
I'm just going by what she said in the interview she did with a member here awhile back.
Bjarni
11-14-2010, 08:10 AM
I like all 4 films. But 1 is the only one I would consider flawless.
2, 3 and 4 were all a little too cartoony (it's a kid's film, I know, I just liked the tone of the first one).
3 also seemed a little cheaper and the special effects weren't as good, story-wise I thought it was good. Not as good as the first or second one, which I feel is more of a sequel. Kinda wish Renet was in this one.
4 is also good. Though it lacked Donnie and Mike which sucked. But I have no problem with the villains. I see no problem for them doing a story that is original, instead of doing something they have done in the comics or cartoons.
Scandia
11-14-2010, 07:47 PM
Back when I was 12/13, it was the first one. Too long and grim.
Nowadays, well, I do not know.
I still do not regret going to watch the third one at the theatre.
Fugitoid Jones
11-15-2010, 01:32 AM
I was watching SOTO the other day with a buddy of mine, and I couldn't help but realize how incompetent of a ninja master Shredder is towards the end. Shredder is holding some chick hostage with ooze, and then Keno busts throught the doors of the club (groan) and starts yelling and making a commotion and runs to the stage and kicks the ooze out of Shredder's hand. What, the 15 seconds of Keno announcing that he was coming didn't give Shredder enough time to react and prepare for him? Then Keno is shoved into him and he does nothing to avoid it. Those are some reflexes.
And how disappointing was it seeing that movie for the first time, and seeing the Super Shredder, and thinking "Oh man, this is going to be some epic confrontation!" and then SS brings the pier down on himself after nearly zero contact with the Turtles (save for Leo's failed drop-kick and SS tossing him). After the club scene, watching Super Shredder kill himself really helps make the ending of this movie anti-climatic.
I consider SOTO to be the movie of missed opportunities. They dropped the ball with Super Shredder, not having Prof. Perry reveal himself to be an Utrom, and not having Bebop and Rocksteady instead of Tokka and Rahzar.
voltron80
11-24-2010, 01:53 PM
first film... great!
second film... too many silly jokes. they made tokka and razhar too stupid. vanilla ice?
regarding the third film, casey is not a crazy vigilante but some kind of babysitter, Splinter looks less real compared w/ secret of the ooze. how come they started the film with a dance???? ok, they were practising... but with a dance???
what i liked from the 3th film is that they used the weapons more than they did in the second film. in that aspect the 3th film is better than secret of the ooze... just that.
4th film... munroe, when talking about the film in pre-production, gave me the impression that his film will be the ultimate tmnt film... no way! monsters? that thing of the planets...? no, way.
TMNT 1: The most underrated comic book movie of all time.
TMNT2: Was decent, still little tick the turtles didn't use their weapons, cheesy at times Vanilla Ice Ninja Rap scene prime example.
TMNT 3: Really like the idea of the turtles going back in time, like them using their weapons and the fight scenes were pretty cool But it's like they quit ideas in mid thought which hurt some scenes Raph bonding with Yoshi and Mike falling in love with that chick(sorry I forgot her name).
TMNT: Was good but was it a sequel to the first 3 movies or was it something totally different? The Turtles look like they're were from the 2k3 universe. It also had Karai yet she was never seen or even mention in the first two Turtles movies. But it still made references to the first three movies the shrine scene at the end when you see Shredder's helmet from the first two movies, the time scepter and outfits from TMNT 3 and the ooze canister from TMNT 2.
Overall I can't hate on any of the four movies, but if I had to pick the weakest of the four I would say it's "TMNT". The story didn't do anything for me, 13 monsters, a bad guy who wasn't really a bad guy, the drama between Leo and Raph just overshadow Don and Mike's role in the movie and again was this a sequel or was it something totally different?
Bjarni
11-24-2010, 02:04 PM
TMNT: Was good but was it a sequel to the first 3 movies or was it something totally different?
It's a sequel to the first 3 movies. They didn't call it the fourth one and looked upon it as a reboot because Laird didn't like 2 and 3.
So it was only a 100% sequel to the first film.
* They don't mention how or when Shredder died (so people can look at the first film or second for the answer)
But 2 and 3 def happened, it says TGRI instead of TCRI on the ooze canister in Splinter's closet.
Gyt Kaliba
11-24-2010, 02:50 PM
But 2 and 3 def happened, it says TGRI instead of TCRI on the ooze canister in Splinter's closet.
Actually, it's cracked in just the right place to where you can't tell if it says TCRI or TGRI. They talk about that in the commentary.
Abnormal Freak
11-24-2010, 03:19 PM
[...] not having Prof. Perry reveal himself to be an Utrom [...]
Don't you think that would've been a little, um...weird? Especially with no backstory to why this weird creature is in this dude's stomach? Also, every kid would've thought it was Krang anyway, so why add to the confusion? They would have thought, "Oh man, Turtles III is DEFINITELY gonna have Krang, 'cos he appeared in the second one!" only to be faced with the biggest letdown of their entire lives. (Well, the third movie kind of was that anyway, but, y'know—things could've been worse.)
TMNT: Was good but was it a sequel to the first 3 movies or was it something totally different?
It was an homage, like Superman Returns was to Richard Donner's Superman movies.
Funfact: TMNT director, Kevin Munroe, got his first production credit from cowriting a TV short named Donner (the reindeer).
Laird didn't like 2 and 3.
O_o Where did you get that idea? I know he wasn't fond of the second, but I never heard any such thing about the third.
Bjarni
11-24-2010, 04:24 PM
O_o Where did you get that idea? I know he wasn't fond of the second, but I never heard any such thing about the third.
The second one was goofy and tried to be a little too much like the cartoon show.
The third one was a commercial failure and a flop that ruined the TMNT movie franchise.
It's one of the reasons why TMNT is not called TMNT 4.
That's at least what I heard when the fourth one was in production.
raphfan84
11-28-2010, 11:30 PM
2 WAS a lot of fun and obviously had the best suits, but it seriously unraveled at the end. Shredder being ejected from the club by blown-out speakers? Super Shredder having a measly 5 seconds of screen time?? WTF!!! :x
Just my two cents...
I agree 100% with you about the end of the movie! When I saw the movie for the first time as a kid I was like ALRIGHT a Super Shredder this is going to be a good ending! Then within 10 seconds it was over just like that, I was PO! I would have loved to have seen a good battle between Shredder and the Turtles again but never happened, but maybe in the 2012 movie we can see another if not better than the first battle between them.:D
Avatar Yuffie
12-09-2010, 07:46 AM
Third.
I am so sorry, but I could never watch that movie again for the sake of nostalgia. The plot is ridiculous, the antagonist is not memorable, and Mikey having a thing with that Japanese girl is kinda creepy.
I really like the third one, for obvious cheesy reasons. Also, I kind of liked the plot line, and what they did. The only thing I didn't like about it was Splinter's voice.
Ninja Turtles 25 Years
02-27-2011, 11:46 PM
I didn't care much for TMNT 2007. In fact, I didn't like it enough to where I don't even remember it, because I didn't want to see it nearly as much as the live-action movies, which I know very well still. I didn't care for Turtles being in CGI. I don't have any issues with CGI, because I like Shrek and Ice Age. I think they should of used a real villian for TMNT 2007. I mean I'm used to the Turtles fighting crime and ninja warriors, but not monsters from thousands of years ago. I found the Turtles in this movie to be a little too thin, less muscular. I hated April, because she seems way too young looking. She's suppose to be like 27 or 28 years old, and she looks like she's about to graduate high school. Casey Jones remindes me too much of the 2003 TV series, but badly designed. The Turtles' eyes are too big. I keep on thinking that the 2007 movie was because of the 2003 TV series being on air. I personally think Raphael should chill out in this movie instead of acting like Leonardo is his enemy. Michelangelo was more annoying in this movie than his regular annoying self. As long as the Turtles needed to have jobs, I see Donatello as a scientist, not a phone operator. Like I said, I hated TMNT 2007 so much that I didn't want to watch it anymore and now I don't remember hardly much about it; it's going to be real pleasure when I get to that point in my Ninja Turtles 25 Years web project when I get finished with Image gallery #5, and Audio quotes from TMNT III soon.
As far as my favorite, I would say that Secret Of The Ooze was my top favorite, and 3 was a very close tie. I did like and disliked all 3 live-action movies for different reasons. They all got my soundtrack approval. I did like April from 2, 3 (3's version better), I did like the Japanese thing in the third, and I did like Casey Jones better in the first. However, I didn't care much for the farm and appartment setting in the first; it looks old and run down looking. I found the Super Shredder fight kind of action-less, and I wish they hadn't of killed Shredder in the second because I found it would of been something if he went into time to Japan, team up with Norinaga and fight against the Turtles. I didn't care much for the costuming for the third movie; the spots, Splinter looking like he's aged 20 more years, and the Turtles looking kind of scrawny didn't quite do it for me.
As for the user who mentioned "East Meets West," I guess you could argue the fact that it being a 5-part episode it was also a movie pilot for The Next Mutation short-term series. I personally hated The Next Mutation all around! I'm glad it only lasted 1 season.
As for those who didn't know the name of that Japanese girl Michelangelo fell in love with in the third movie is Mitsu.
And fact indicates that Judith ended her role as April because of her reduced role in the sequals, not because of popularity.
The budget of the first movie came up in an earlier reply. Here's a trivia fact I don't know if anyone knows, but did you know at that time TMNT I was the lowest budgeted independent movie in history, and yet made the most profit. That is for independent movies, not over all.
Donnie
02-27-2011, 11:59 PM
I'm surprised a lot of people do not like TMNT 4. As far as I'm concerned, I rank it second after the first movie, which is by far my favorite. TMNT 4, besides Casey & Michelangelo, was pretty dark in my opinion, a lot closer to the first movie than the other 2 live action films were. I mean, Raph and Leo come to blows for god's sake. Pretty dark material.
I voted TMNT 2 as the worst. I used to love it as a kid, but these days I almost find it hard to watch. Don's mask was ultra-light purple - not cool. Dark purple all the way. I liked the Turtle suits (Don in specific) from movie 1, and even movie 3, better than 2. I also really just can't get into the Ninja Rap at the end. The fighting is just...bad. Movies 2 & 3 lacked the darkness and suspense that 1 had. I mean, c'mon, Shredder is defeated in 2 by Mikey hitting a keytar on full volume. It's just not right. I like 3 more than 2 maybe just because I'm biased and it's the only movie I remember seeing in the theatres and being more excited for than a kid on Christmas morning.
But hey, that's just me. :D
I'm surprised a lot of people do not like TMNT 4. As far as I'm concerned, I rank it second after the first movie, which is by far my favorite.
Me too! It kinda alternates with SotO for the #2 spot, but it just depends what kind of a mood I'm in. SotO was more fun, but TMNT07 had more integrity.
Jester
02-28-2011, 01:55 AM
Me too! It kinda alternates with SotO for the #2 spot, but it just depends what kind of a mood I'm in. SotO was more fun, but TMNT07 had more integrity.
I never really liked the "13 Monsters of Max Winters" and I always liked time travel stories...so I'm one of those who puts TMNT behind Turtles III.
Part of me, and honestly this just came to mind, if Monroe was trying to do what evryone says is "good TMNT", a mix of ninja action and sci-fi elements, and in my mind kinda failed at both. The final "battle" seemed to short, mainly between the Turtles and the Foot, but I guess it had to make way for the final showdown with the generals.
And another thing dawns on me as I type, people gripe about Norinaga and Walker who show up nowhere else but that movie, and yet have no problem with Winters, the Stone generals, and the 13 critters. Sure TMNT had the Foot, but they were totally on the back burner, maybe due to sequal that Munroe had in mind that was hinted at but never materalized.
Bjarni
02-28-2011, 04:35 AM
However, I didn't care much for the farm and appartment setting in the first; it looks old and run down looking.
That was like, the point. I hope you don't dislike the first movie just because of this.
Also, the budget was 12 million (funded by New Line Cinema before they were bought by Time Warner) and it was the most successful independent film of all time (it made something around 200 million in the box office). It def wasn't the most cheapest low budget film or anything like that, Nightmare on Elm Street cost around five mill or less... and they pretty much made the studio what it is.
Golden Harvest also produced the film, Hong Kong studios make films on a lesser budget, but it's not really independent....
people gripe about Norinaga and Walker who show up nowhere else but that movie, and yet have no problem with Winters, the Stone generals, and the 13 critters.
Really? Sure, I remember some people hating on Walker just because he wasn't The Shredder when the movie first came out, but I recall a lot more hate coming from Winters, Stone Generals and 13 monsters then Walker or Norinaga.
But why shouldn't the movies have new characters? They introduced Danny in the first one and Keno in the second. As well as Tatsu. I don't mind new characters, as long as they are well established and developed. The characters in 4 got the backstory, but the characters in 3 interacted a lot more with the Turtles and therefor were a bigger part of the overall Turtle story, which is why I understand why some people were frustrated at the fact that a Turtle movie was focusing on random monsters that were only briefly explained in the opening of the film.
deadpoolRKO
02-28-2011, 09:28 AM
I picked TMNT 4 , only because i enjoy live action ones over the animated one. i love all 4 movies.
I don't watch them and see errors and animatronics though, i just love to watch the turtles.
Ninja Turtles 25 Years
02-28-2011, 11:28 AM
That was like, the point. I hope you don't dislike the first movie just because of this.
Uh, Like no. I don't hate movies for stupid reasons. I was explaining my likes and dislikes of each movie. I don't hate or like anything 100%.
Bjarni
02-28-2011, 01:01 PM
I would go as far as to say that I like the first film 100% In fact, my only beef with it is that it wasn't long enough. I want to see all the deleted scenes in tact. I want to see Michelangelo destroy that punching bag, April publish a Ninja Turtle comic and have Tatsu kill that kid.
Redeemer
02-28-2011, 02:57 PM
I would go as far as to say that I like the first film 100% In fact, my only beef with it is that it wasn't long enough. I want to see all the deleted scenes in tact. I want to see Michelangelo destroy that punching bag, April publish a Ninja Turtle comic and have Tatsu kill that kid.
Amen! Amen! I say Amen Speak the truth! lol I agree
ssjup81
03-01-2011, 05:27 AM
Hm, let's see. I voted for the third movie. I know, I know, but I was just so upset with that one when I first saw it as a kid and I guess the bias has stuck with me over the years. I didn't care for the story (even if I did like the time traveling element, like Turtles in Time), as it just seemed off to me. I didn't feel like I was watching Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. I felt like I was watching something where they tossed the Turtles in so they could call it that...sorta like that Dragon Ball Evolution movie that was beyond horrible (and I was stupid enough to see it because my curiosity got the better of me). You'd forget it was Dragon Ball if the title hadn't have said so.
I also hated the fact that Shredder wasn't in movie 3. As a kid, after seeing movie 2, I just knew that meant that Shredder wasn't defeated, and they just wanted us to believe that he was because being done in by a DOCK is about as lame as it gets, and I also believed that he'd be in the third film because the Turtles never actually fought against Super Shredder.
After movie 3, even though I didn't mind it, and liked it, I'd have go with maybe movie 4. I do agree that the Raph and Leo stuff was a bit overbearing, and in a way, it felt as if I were watching original movie 1 again (their rivalry), so I'm a bit half and half with it since I liked it. I did like that aspect in TMNT. IMO, I think the main thing that hurt TMNT for me was the fact that Donny and Mikey were shafted big time for Leo and Raph's rivalry. The pacing could've also been a bit better, but overall, this movie is probably as close to movie 1 as you can get.
After movie 4, I'd have to say movie 2. Movie 2 is a bit of a guilty pleasure. It's so cheesy and corny, but as a kid (and being a fan of the OT series), I really liked it. I loved the Vanilla Ice scene, even now and not embarrassed to say so. The main thing wrong with this film was that it was dumbed down and kiddified because of the soccer moms. I didn't notice it as much as a kid, but did when watching the movie when a little older (teens) that the Turtles didn't fight with their weapons once. That was just as mind-baffling as Mikey's nunchucks being fazed out for the OT series and how they showed him with his nunchucks, but only used the grappler until they got rid of them altogether (which I did notice as a kid). So yeah, comedy and humor wise, movie 2 was okay, but incredibly corny by today's standards.
Movie 1 was just awesome and is my favorite of the four. I loved how they were portrayed a bit darker and the fight scenes were cool, and I liked the bonding this movie seemed to portray (Leo and Raph; Donny and Mikey). I wouldn't say it was perfect, but it seemed to be the most balanced of the four films. I wouldn't mind seeing this one now. I have for a while, since I haven't seen it in so long. Have the VHS of the movie stateside. Wish I had it on DVD now. I don't have a VCR here.
So, bottom line, I still feel that movie 3 is the worst because of the expectations I had for it, which let me down, and even though I'm usually very objective when it comes to stuff like this, seems my bias just forced its way through. Movie 3 is also a film I outright dislike. I like the other three.
PizzaPower
03-01-2011, 06:42 AM
lol i knew everybody would pick the 3rd movie to be there least favorite.
lol i knew everybody would pick the 3rd movie to be there least favorite.
Dude, are you a ghost? It seems you're only seeing the posts you wanna see.
Candy Kappa
03-01-2011, 12:09 PM
Dude, are you a ghost? It seems you're only seeing the posts you wanna see.
think he means the poll
rav4ge
03-01-2011, 03:29 PM
I voted for 3 because I was young when I watched it, and even back then I knew it sucked. Such a laughable plot (time travel? really?), and overall just a bad movie, full of cliche. Definitely in my list of worse movies ever made.
I liked TMNT07, but the more I watch it, the less I like it. I feel like they shouldn't have strayed so far from the source material that made TMNT so great in the first place. It's still a pretty good movie though. They did a good job.
Redeemer
03-04-2011, 11:12 PM
The hate is stronger than I thought!:o
Someone mentioned previosly that it felt like the 3rd's story was jst thrown together and I would have to agree. I could come up with a better story in 5 mins.
I think they could have kept the time travel, but go back to when the foot clan was first founded or at its peak in power, in futal Japan and have the turtles try to take down the foot clan in order to try to prevent the death of Hamato Yoshi, but they would have to chose between preventing Yoshi's death or saving their lives. I would have the turtles try to save Yoshi, but have them fail in order to set up maybe a fourth?
shuriken
03-05-2011, 12:38 AM
The hate is stronger than I thought!:o
Someone mentioned previosly that it felt like the 3rd's story was jst thrown together and I would have to agree. I could come up with a better story in 5 mins.
I think they could have kept the time travel, but go back to when the foot clan was first founded or at its peak in power, in futal Japan and have the turtles try to take down the foot clan in order to try to prevent the death of Hamato Yoshi, but they would have to chose between preventing Yoshi's death or saving their lives. I would have the turtles try to save Yoshi, but have them fail in order to set up maybe a fourth?
Terminator TMNT style? I doubt they would want to mess with the fabric of existence like that but what the hell, worked out well in the Terminator series right?
I did not have a problem with TMNT3's story. It was fairly interesting and ya know I liked Walker and Noringa way more than those stone Generals and Winters. The story in TMNT3 made way more sense than that ridiculous catch all the monsters story BS that they had going on in TMNT(07). The best thing about 07 was the voice acting and the Leo vs Raph fight scene, which I still think looks very beautiful. A crappy story is one thing, but bad lines and uninteresting characters that have little to no plot development are the nails on the coffin. 3 makes me laugh cuz it's so bad. (07) Just annoys me because it tries to hard to be badass and just ends up being convoluted and pretentious.
Mr._Mutant_Man
03-05-2011, 11:37 AM
I think the latest movie might actually be my least favorite. The third movie might be really cheesy, but at least it had some neat looking sets. The fourth movie doesn't really hold my interest on repeat viewings, and in the beginning it felt like it took too long to get to the turtles.
Redeemer
03-05-2011, 02:49 PM
Terminator TMNT style? I doubt they would want to mess with the fabric of existence like that but what the hell, worked out well in the Terminator series right?
I did not have a problem with TMNT3's story. It was fairly interesting and ya know I liked Walker and Noringa way more than those stone Generals and Winters. The story in TMNT3 made way more sense than that ridiculous catch all the monsters story BS that they had going on in TMNT(07). The best thing about 07 was the voice acting and the Leo vs Raph fight scene, which I still think looks very beautiful. A crappy story is one thing, but bad lines and uninteresting characters that have little to no plot development are the nails on the coffin. 3 makes me laugh cuz it's so bad. (07) Just annoys me because it tries to hard to be badass and just ends up being convoluted and pretentious.
My biggest problem with the 3rd storyline was the whole Demon turtle back story which I htought was complete BA when I was little, but that is a huge plot whole, did they travel back in time again? it has a huge plot hole is all. I still think it would have been cool if they went back in time to fight the foot. It could still fit into the storyline and would make for some awesome fight scenes.
Definitely the Thrid Movie for me.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.