PDA

View Full Version : Was Cody Jones a good character, or was he a Marty Stu?


CyberCubed
08-10-2010, 11:21 PM
When FF was first announced, I originally feared Cody Jones would be another one of those annoying kid sidekicks who would have some sort of obsession/idolization for the heroes, and would miraculously save the day in every episode while the main heroes could not.

Much to my surprise, he really didn't turn out that way. Yes, there are episodes where he saved the Turtles, but that was expected so he didn't seem totally useless.

As a character, he did come off as April and Donatello combined together. He really didn't have as much as that annoying kid vibe as one would expect.

Overall looking back I didn't mind him, he even stayed out of most of the fights in general too which was a plus.

Jo Dawn
08-11-2010, 12:10 AM
You should have an option up there beyond 'dislike'.

I hated the character. Haaateeed. That's when I stopped watching the 2K3 series. He was unbelieveably annoying.

CyberCubed
08-11-2010, 12:14 AM
He was unbelieveably annoying.

Really? I can't think of much he did that I downright hated.

Redeemer
08-11-2010, 12:20 AM
I thought he was a great character and still had potential. I think they developed him well. I really enjoyed him as a character.

gobo
08-11-2010, 12:57 AM
...

Who's Marty Stu? :tconfuse:

Guitar_Raph
08-11-2010, 07:26 AM
Thought Cody's quite cool, though his robotic guardian Serling was a pain. Cody did make a virtual motorcycle for Rpah to drive.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/PCenter/Ninja%20Turtles%20The%20Next%20Mutation/BikerdudeRaph.jpg

But he got along great with Mikey!

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/PCenter/Ninja%20Turtles%20The%20Next%20Mutation/MikeyCody.jpg

TheCanadiandrome
08-11-2010, 10:25 AM
You should have an option up there beyond 'dislike'.

I hated the character. Haaateeed. That's when I stopped watching the 2K3 series. He was unbelieveably annoying.

cool sig

...

Who's Marty Stu? :tconfuse:

my question exactly :tconfuse:

Powder
08-11-2010, 11:12 AM
...

Who's Marty Stu? :tconfuse:

I think thats his male version of a Nancy Sue.



Anyways, I voted for option one. When starting the series I expected to hate his guts (as I did with Zach in the OT) but he grew on me after the second or third episode. I actually kinda liked what he brought to the show. He wasn't used in an excessively active way, he didn't seem all that pretentious (though the ninja training thing was kinda played out), & I liked that the turtles had a tour guide who was not only able to show them the ropes, but also what they did to contribute to the way the world was then.

Sage Ninja
08-11-2010, 11:23 AM
he was alright. As far as child side kicks go he wasn't nearly as annoying as Jade from Jackie Chan adventures, or Scrappy Doo. But meh, I just prefered April and Casey over him as the turtles buddies and confidants.

plastroncafe
08-11-2010, 11:23 AM
Marty Stu is a male Mary Sue. (http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Mary-Sue)

I could have taken or left Cody Jones, but instead I just dislike him for not being Shadow.

Jo Dawn
08-11-2010, 05:10 PM
Really? I can't think of much he did that I downright hated.

For me? He existed. I'm not big on 'kids' as sidekicks or being involved whatsoever. He was unneeded for pretty much ANYthing. I'm sure if I'd seen the show since it aired I could give more detailed explanation (since we had this discussion years ago) but I won't watch them.

cool sig

Thanks. That was made when Fast Forward started as a sarcastic homage to all annoying kiddie sidekicks.

Ninja Tiptup
08-11-2010, 08:07 PM
Oh wow they totally dropped the ball by not having Shadow in Fast Forward. She could have been the Turtles friend in the future instead. Cody was alright though. He didn't feel too terribly tacked on even, at least any more so than Fast Forward in general.

But I have a true question for the masses.

Will CyberCubed ever stop making threads that are frail attempts to over-analyze a cartoon to deal with some abandonment issues?

I'm guessing no.

Powder
08-11-2010, 09:02 PM
Oh wow they totally dropped the ball by not having Shadow in Fast Forward. She could have been the Turtles friend in the future instead. Cody was alright though. He didn't feel too terribly tacked on even, at least any more so than Fast Forward in general.

But I have a true question for the masses.

Will CyberCubed ever stop making threads that are frail attempts to over-analyze a cartoon to deal with some abandonment issues?

I'm guessing no.

You're one big ball of negativity. You sh!t-stormed all over Tothenines incessantly in that other thread & then you come here & use a poor excuse for an opinion as a means to insult Cybercubed, who is one of the few members here who is productive in making threads that are thought provoking. Take that somewhere else.

jaymq
08-11-2010, 09:10 PM
Maybe his mother was Shadow. :D

I'm indifferent on Cody, I do prefer Casey and April though. Even if April wasn't as big in this series.. or as useful as she could have been.

Turo602
08-11-2010, 10:40 PM
He was a great character and he proved himself to be the 5th Turtle. He wasn't annoying at all and he didn't steal the show. He also got along with all the TMNT.

plastroncafe
08-11-2010, 10:46 PM
Maybe his mother was Shadow. :D.

I kept waiting for that kind of revelation, but alas....no dice.
Maybe she'll be in the new one?


...

Yeah, not freakin' likely.

jaymq
08-11-2010, 11:13 PM
I kept waiting for that kind of revelation, but alas....no dice.
Maybe she'll be in the new one?


...

Yeah, not freakin' likely.

yea sadly. Could be an interesting fanfic or something tho, never saw it done before.

Jo Dawn
08-11-2010, 11:33 PM
He wouldn't have had April's red hair, though. Assuming, that is, that it IS her genes' hair coloring.

jaymq
08-12-2010, 12:03 AM
He wouldn't have had April's red hair, though. Assuming, that is, that it IS her genes' hair coloring.

Aye, but 2k3 wasn't Mirage-verse. Which could have left the whole thing open to interpretation. Shadow could've been Casey and April's own daughter (edit: or granddaughter, whatever the case may be) by DNA. .. which would leave out the not-really-4kids-drama-that-is-Gabrielle... y'know... since it doesn't follow a moral ideal of how she came into being.

That's the awesome thing about different universes. :D

Edit: Was he grandchild or great-grand. Could never remember. Oh well.

Jo Dawn
08-12-2010, 12:08 AM
True. And I'm really ok with that. Never was a fan of Shadow.

But I didn't give the 'aternate universe' idea much thought.

Eiko
08-12-2010, 07:36 AM
Cody Jones was kinda cool at least he wasn't annoying like Zack was.

Vivi
08-12-2010, 08:04 AM
I liked him more the less of him I saw. But very much a Marty Sue character, but at least he had the dough for a huge penthouse.

BubblyShell22
08-12-2010, 09:44 AM
I wasn't a fan of Cody at all. He did nothing for me and was a total Gary Stu (that's the guy version of a Mary Sue, not a Marty Stu). That's how I viewed him anyway. I just wasn't a fan of him.

TheCanadiandrome
08-12-2010, 03:01 PM
Thanks. That was made when Fast Forward started as a sarcastic homage to all annoying kiddie sidekicks.

lol, nice :tlol:

Candy Kappa
08-12-2010, 07:50 PM
didn't care much of him, he was the turtles link to the new society in the future, and pretty much was just there

shuriken
08-14-2010, 07:05 PM
I had nothing against the little bastard. He was just kinda there, not really helping or hurting the TMNT for the most part. The WORST thing he did was bring them to the future, the BEST thing he did was bring them to the past. Sure he saved them a few times, but in all honesty Venus and Zach were at least 10 times worse in terms of being Mary Sues.

Teddy
08-14-2010, 07:26 PM
I didn't care for Cody...or FF in general, really. Not much substance to the series. BUT, it was slightly better than BTTS. ;)

Shred Head
08-14-2010, 09:44 PM
I dont think he was a male Marty Stu or whatever the term for guy Mary Sue. Venus now that was a Mary Sue hell shes damn near the definetion of it. Now was he a good character I would say no I found him to be annoying he was pretty much a Scappy a character they force on people cause they think kids cant relate to any character unless there kids. Just like them. This is whats wrong with shows like Sonic X and a bulk of those post Beast Wars Transformer cartoons. I dont give a **** about little brat I want to see Sonic just blow up Robotnik's ****ing Death Egg or Metal Sonic or whatever.

Ninja Tiptup
08-15-2010, 10:53 AM
You're one big ball of negativity. You sh!t-stormed all over Tothenines incessantly in that other thread & then you come here & use a poor excuse for an opinion as a means to insult Cybercubed, who is one of the few members here who is productive in making threads that are thought provoking. Take that somewhere else.

Me negative? Not hardly.

I'm trying to fight negativity more times than not. Typically looking at the positive side of things. Such as the roster may be tiny but TMNT Smash-Up is a lot of fun and the character it has (aside from Rabbids) are great and the Turtles Forever DVD should be the uncut version but I'm pretty happy we're getting a DVD at all.Tothenines attitude on the whole thing is understandable but I felt he was making a big deal out of it and he also cursed me out and I kinda didn't like that. Don't get me wrong. I am also sick of getting the short end of the stick like most TMNT fans but I'm also sick of complaining and hearing complaints. I'm a bit fed up with Cybercubed from here but more so Toon Zone (where I currently do not post but not because of him). And I don't hate the guy but I do dislike his attitude lately. He used to be such a reasonable guy.

Perhaps you haven't seen quite the pissing a moaning I have from 'ol Cyber but that's just as well. I've gone a little far with my retaliations to him lately so I'll cool my jets. I'm not trying to provoke Tothenines either and haven't since the first time.

I gave my general thoughts on Cody as a character regardless but if you'd like me to into more detail I guess I could.

Cody was a decent character. I'm not sure if I'd define him as great but I guess I'd call him good. He was the turtles guide of sorts who helped them adjust and they grew bonds with him and even Serling. He was a much better executed character than Carter and Zack. And he even had "some moves" so to speak. He wasn't perfect nor was he useless. He wasn't just there for the sake of being there because they did a fair job of giving him purpose. If anything he was a bit bland but I can't really say what could make him a better character than he was. He was one of the better parts of Fast Forward as a whole in my opinion.

It might have been better to have Shadow instead and I may have liked Fast Forward more if she was there instead of Cody or perhaps as well as Cody. Though maybe if we had Shadow then we wouldn't have gotten Starlee and her riduclous parents. Or maybe we would have still but it always seemed like she was just there to have a girl in supporting cast.

Scandia
08-16-2010, 04:32 PM
Perfectly fine with him here. May not be my favorite character in the whole wide TMNT franchise, but I do not dislike him in any way.

NameGoesHere1066
08-16-2010, 04:54 PM
I disliked him. Just never got into him that much.

Shellsweet
08-19-2010, 10:30 PM
I hated him at first, He just annoyed me a lot for some reason, Probabtly because I was so quick to jugde that he was going to be one of those annoying Kid side kicks that keept getting into trouble, But he didnt and I got over it and realized he isnt AS bad as I thought he was.

I would really have liked seeing Shadow in the Series instead...
FF in general was just ok, Though it was hysterically funny at times. Didnt hate it though.

Cipher
08-19-2010, 11:28 PM
I first saw Fast Forward well after it aired on DVD. I'd heard the bad takes on it and was fully expecting Cody to be the unlikable standard kid hero, a la Zack in the Fred Wolf series.

He's much better than that. Yes, he's clearly only included because the show needed a child protagonist and the Turtles needed a guide to the future, so to speak. But he's about as fully realized as any character in that show is. His intelligence was a genuine attribute, and he was actually flawed in his shelteredness and naivety. That's really as much as you can ask for. And even when his ninja training did start, it wasn't played up to a ridiculous degree (as has been the case with, say, certain incarnations of April). He was still very much at a large disadvantage.

And to the series' great credit, it made no attempt to shoehorn him into every story. Every appearance he made felt genuinely necessary or enhanced the story. If there was no reason to include him in an episode, the writers didn't. There's a decent chunk of Cody-free plots if he really grinds your gears.

Cody is, all in all, a pleasant surprise. Much like the Fast Forward series itself. Even if he is a corporate-mandated kid side-kick, he's certainly the best executed one I've ever seen.

gobo
08-20-2010, 09:00 AM
I first saw Fast Forward well after it aired on DVD. I'd heard the bad takes on it and was fully expecting Cody to be the unlikable standard kid hero, a la Zack in the Fred Wolf series.

He's much better than that. Yes, he's clearly only included because the show needed a child protagonist and the Turtles needed a guide to the future, so to speak. But he's about as fully realized as any character in that show is. His intelligence was a genuine attribute, and he was actually flawed in his shelteredness and naivety. That's really as much as you can ask for. And even when his ninja training did start, it wasn't played up to a ridiculous degree (as has been the case with, say, certain incarnations of April). He was still very much at a large disadvantage.

And to the series' great credit, it made no attempt to shoehorn him into every story. Every appearance he made felt genuinely necessary or enhanced the story. If there was no reason to include him in an episode, the writers didn't. There's a decent chunk of Cody-free plots if he really grinds your gears.

Cody is, all in all, a pleasant surprise. Much like the Fast Forward series itself. Even if he is a corporate-mandated kid side-kick, he's certainly the best executed one I've ever seen.
You've explained my feelings on the matter better than I even cared to. Thanks. :)

METALHEAD
08-21-2010, 12:05 AM
i was alright with him, wasn't great, but not really hating the character.

Vivi
08-23-2010, 02:54 AM
Thinking about it, if Cody was a girl I'd be a bit more disturbed about the amount of fawning the turtles did. I think that the biggest crime of the season was that even the turtles treated him with cotton gloves.

Luzmagica
08-23-2010, 09:03 AM
I was fine with him, IMO a good character to introduce TMNT in the "new" world , and also he was a good link for them with the past... :tgrin:

In my wiki for male-character appears: "Gary Stu"

Cipher
08-23-2010, 05:37 PM
Thinking about it, if Cody was a girl I'd be a bit more disturbed about the amount of fawning the turtles did. I think that the biggest crime of the season was that even the turtles treated him with cotton gloves.As far as I ever noticed, they knew his knowledge and weaponry could come in a clutch. They just didn't treat him like an untouchable ninja master because, you know, he wasn't.

The Big Bad
08-23-2010, 09:20 PM
He took some getting used to, and even at his best he wasn't as good a character as Casey or April, but I liked him well enough--heck, I wouldn't have minded seeing a catch-up episode showing how he and Starlee were doing after the turtles had left.

twopinacoladas
08-23-2010, 10:31 PM
I also found him annoying he wasn't as bad as they could have made him as for an additional new character he wasn't bad but I did find him annoying.