PDA

View Full Version : How would you feel if Nick licenses a new comic that reboots the series?


CyberCubed
01-10-2011, 03:59 PM
I am NOT talking about a possible comic based on the cartoon, like the Archie or Dreamwave series. I'm sure most of us expect a comic based on the cartoon to come out anyway.

I'm talking about serious take on the Turtles that is similar in tone to the Mirage or Image series, but is a reboot in vain of Ultimate Spiderman or so forth that re-does the history.

Would you be happy about an all-new take on the turtles or would you be angry if they retcon and ignore Mirage continuity?

Candy Kappa
01-10-2011, 04:46 PM
I'd rather see a reboot then see Viacom comtinue the current story without Laird.


But like Ultimate? Hell no, Ultimates and Ultimate X-Men is the worst crap I have ever read. The writers should be ashamed.

Andrew NDB
01-10-2011, 05:02 PM
Expect a soft reboot, if it happens.

Roseangelo
01-10-2011, 05:22 PM
It really doesn't matter to me what they do. I hope they do whatever they need to do to make it a successful series.

Venom
01-10-2011, 05:58 PM
I wouldn't mind if it was handled with respect by a competent writer/s and introduced the more memorable characters from Mirage at some point. One thing I would like, personally, if they start from the beginning, is to keep Saki around and delve into his character, his motivations, his twisted sense of honor, etc. and for the Turtles to hang around New York fighting the Foot a little longer than they did in the Mirage books.

All the main baddies the Turtles faced could easily carry a several issue arc to give more development to the villains, the situation at hand, and how the Turtle's react to it.

Oh, and color it. Hell, even the headbands. They could be a dark, muted version (Navy, Carmine, Burnt Sienna, Black) to aid in hiding in the shadows more so than the typical blue, red, orange, purple.

Andrew NDB
01-10-2011, 06:24 PM
It really doesn't matter to me what they do. I hope they do whatever they need to do to make it a successful series.

Well, depends on how you look at it. If the topic at hand is, "How would you feel if Nick rebooted the TMNT comic doing everything to it to maximize the possibility for revenue?" then the answer from me is "Pretty sh*ttily, because that would just mean churning out a focus committee-based product catering to the lowest common demoninator with only secondary thought to creative integrity or the source material."

If the topic at hand was, "How would you feel if Nick rebooted the TMNT comic in a manner that would think outside of the box in potentially reaching previously unseen sales while still keeping its creative integrity intact and reasonable attention/FYI-in-the-back-of-one's-mind to the source material?" then my answer would be, "Pretty good, I guess."

twopinacoladas
01-10-2011, 06:52 PM
I wouldn't mind a reboot I suppose, its really the only way to bring new readers to the turtles comic and older books are pretty hard to find for the average person for back issues. It would have to be done well hopefully keep the spirit of the original Eastman and Laird books. I'd also like to see similar art style to either issue 1, the Leonardo micro series, RTNY or even image (which I have yet to finish reading still need 2 more issues).

I guess I'd be fine with it, there is already a lot of Mirage stuff a reboot would probably be their best option. Hopefully it wouldn't be directly aimed at kids tho and it will hopefully be done well and respectful if it were to happen.

Powder
01-10-2011, 06:59 PM
Well, depends on how you look at it. If the topic at hand is, "How would you feel if Nick rebooted the TMNT comic doing everything to it to maximize the possibility for revenue?" then the answer from me is "Pretty sh*ttily, because that would just mean churning out a focus committee-based product catering to the lowest common demoninator with only secondary thought to creative integrity or the source material."

If the topic at hand was, "How would you feel if Nick rebooted the TMNT comic in a manner that would think outside of the box in potentially reaching previously unseen sales while still keeping its creative integrity intact and reasonable attention/FYI-in-the-back-of-one's-mind to the source material?" then my answer would be, "Pretty good, I guess."

I'm with this right here.

CyberCubed
01-10-2011, 07:08 PM
Although I guess since Nick turned down Image getting to officially published those two issues, I imagine they really don't want to do a serious themed TMNT comic anytime soon.

They'll probably just feel the comics are up to Mirage/PL to do if he ever continues them, while they'll just focus on the movies/TV show, and a possible comic based on the cartoon.

Eiko
01-10-2011, 08:19 PM
I'd rather see a reboot then see Viacom comtinue the current story without Laird.





Yea same here.

sdp
01-10-2011, 09:25 PM
Maybe Nick isn't even allowed to mess with the Mirage Universe, I mean Laird did put that clause about him being able to publish a certain amount of Mirage Universe books so its not out of the question he said Nick couldn't continue it especially since Nick wouldn't care. I mean what is the use of being able to publish mirage universe books if Nick can publish contradicting books at the same time.

Anyways I definitely don't see a new comic for the new series, theres a reason the Dreamwave comic didn't last. Adults are the (small) audience that buys comic books, very few kids buy them, its a very niche market. Now I can definitely see a new universe aimed at older people being done though that would essentially be a reboot but it wouldn't be Mirage universe.

Andrew NDB
01-10-2011, 09:42 PM
Although I guess since Nick turned down Image getting to officially published those two issues

They didn't turn down Image. They just didn't say "yes" either. I don't think anybody is super enthusiastic about the chances anymore, but it's still "wait and see."

I imagine they really don't want to do a serious themed TMNT comic anytime soon.

They do want to do serious-themed TMNT comics. "Soon," though? Doesn't seem like it.

They'll probably just feel the comics are up to Mirage/PL to do if he ever continues them

I don't think they have any invested interest in what they/he does with the comics, but moreover I don't think what they/he does with the comics -- if anything at all -- has any bearing on what Nick does as far as licensing in publishing.

TheCanadiandrome
01-10-2011, 10:36 PM
Well, depends on how you look at it. If the topic at hand is, "How would you feel if Nick rebooted the TMNT comic doing everything to it to maximize the possibility for revenue?" then the answer from me is "Pretty sh*ttily, because that would just mean churning out a focus committee-based product catering to the lowest common demoninator with only secondary thought to creative integrity or the source material."

If the topic at hand was, "How would you feel if Nick rebooted the TMNT comic in a manner that would think outside of the box in potentially reaching previously unseen sales while still keeping its creative integrity intact and reasonable attention/FYI-in-the-back-of-one's-mind to the source material?" then my answer would be, "Pretty good, I guess."

i agree with this

DrSpengler
01-11-2011, 10:48 AM
Well, depends on how you look at it. If the topic at hand is, "How would you feel if Nick rebooted the TMNT comic doing everything to it to maximize the possibility for revenue?" then the answer from me is "Pretty sh*ttily, because that would just mean churning out a focus committee-based product catering to the lowest common demoninator with only secondary thought to creative integrity or the source material."

If the topic at hand was, "How would you feel if Nick rebooted the TMNT comic in a manner that would think outside of the box in potentially reaching previously unseen sales while still keeping its creative integrity intact and reasonable attention/FYI-in-the-back-of-one's-mind to the source material?" then my answer would be, "Pretty good, I guess."

That's about the size of it, yeah.

In all likelihood, I see Nick focusing primarily on cartoons and movies and toys; the more profitable media.

Comic books are a dying medium and cater to a very niche market. If Viacom does license the property out to a publisher like IDW, I don't really see them going over their scripts with excessive scrutiny for approval.

The comics, should we get them, will likely be their one boon for older fans. Sort of how Hasbro licenses out Transformers to IDW for comics featuring the cast of G1 characters. Those comics certainly don't promote the toys, as the characters in them haven't had toys (or those particular molds) for 20+ years. It's simply for the older fans to enjoy.

Sure, Viacom may insist on other comics more geared towards a younger audience or based on whatever Turtle media they're putting out at the time, but that doesn't negate the chances of comics for the older fans.

And as for a reboot, yeah, I'm fine with that. Let some new talent come in and craft a new universe based on the elements left to them from ALL the previous incarnations of the brand, as well as a generous portion of their own ideas.

Could be very exciting.

Andrew NDB
01-11-2011, 01:40 PM
Let some new talent come in and craft a new universe based on the elements left to them from ALL the previous incarnations of the brand

Some kind of TMNT universe jambalaya in the comics? No thanks.

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_JrcZDFaBBfQ/TNIRG_-ymaI/AAAAAAAAC_s/e_c868L-vww/s1600/aunt-jemima-racist-ad.jpg

No, ma'am, not with my TMNT comics. Don't want any.

http://www.otrcat.com/z/auntjem.jpg

I mean, if it ends up they do a blank slate, new universe, they can do whatever New they want... but I don't see any benefit to populating it with Bebops or Shell Cycles or any other nonsense from the spinoff material.

DrSpengler
01-11-2011, 02:17 PM
Well, I guess that's a point where we'll never quite see eye to eye, then.

I like all the different versions of the Turtles for various reasons and I don't like the idea of restricting writers on the ideas and elements they can draw from with arbitrary boundaries; "that character wasn't in Mirage so you can't use him", etc etc.

The Mirage universe will remain untainted, but I think a rebooted continuity should be free to do whatever it wants.

A rebooted continuity where all non-Mirage ideas and characters are off-limits would just be the 4Kids cartoon all over again. I've, personally, had enough of that and I'd welcome seeing all characters and concepts from the backlog of Turtle media to get equal opportunity at reinvention and revitalization.


I'll concede, however, that if the forthcoming Nick cartoon goes in the direction of an amalgamated conceptual universe for the TMNT, then I can see the desire for a licensed comic to take a more Mirage-esque, grassroots approach as an alternative for the fans.

CyberCubed
01-11-2011, 04:06 PM
Agreed. I'm sure the Nick show is going to use elements from the various Turtle universes.

They'll probably use 2k3 characters like Hun and Bishop too.

Kendamu
01-11-2011, 04:46 PM
I'd be surprised if Nick does a comic at all.

CyberCubed
01-11-2011, 04:48 PM
I'd be surprised if Nick does a comic at all.

A comic based on the cartoon is at least a given.

Roseangelo
01-11-2011, 05:14 PM
A comic based on the cartoon is at least a given.

Uh, not really. You can assume that, and it might even be a reasonable conclusion, but it's not a given.

Andrew NDB
01-11-2011, 06:16 PM
I'd be surprised if Nick does a comic at all.

Well, they wouldn't be doing it themselves. Nick isn't in the comic book making business.

Now, I'd be surprised if Nick keeps saying "No" to publishers interested in doing something with the TMNT in comics. Especially after their game plan for TMNT in larger media becomes set in stone. Then it's just them leaving money on the table.

A comic based on the cartoon is at least a given.

That's true. They do have interest in that, in some form. But interest in that doesn't preclude interest in doing something for older readers/the real comic book market (which, as it is now, a collector's market).

CyberCubed
01-11-2011, 06:18 PM
Most Nick cartoons get comic books at some point. I know there have been Spongebob and Rugrats comic books.

Kendamu
01-11-2011, 08:41 PM
Well, they wouldn't be doing it themselves. Nick isn't in the comic book making business.

Now, I'd be surprised if Nick keeps saying "No" to publishers interested in doing something with the TMNT in comics. Especially after their game plan for TMNT in larger media becomes set in stone. Then it's just them leaving money on the table.



That's true. They do have interest in that, in some form. But interest in that doesn't preclude interest in doing something for older readers/the real comic book market (which, as it is now, a collector's market).
I was using "Nick" in a pretty general sense. I figured we all understood that I meant something like "if Nick has someone publish a" when I made that post.

You do raise a good point, though, about publishers approaching Nick.

sdp
01-11-2011, 08:59 PM
Spongebob and the like have only gotten small one or two page comics in Nickelodeon magazine and whatnot, I don't believe any of their properties have had a real run comic book wise.

There is no reason to believe there will be any comics based on the new show unlike the 80s or 90s the amount of kids who actually read comics is extremely small. Hell even sales to adults the main people who buy comics are pretty low. I was seeing an interview of an Image comics guy how in the 90s Image would cancel any comic that would be selling 200,000 IIRC and now that same number is what Marvel/DC consider successful book. No one buys comics especially not kids no reason for Nick to get one for TMNT unless someone wants to license it in which case they'd likely go for the older audience not kids. Counting the new show is CG probably doesn't help the chances of the comic since the art style is not as easy to translate back to 2D (yes I'm aware 3D shows start with 2D concept art). DC/Marvel mostly stay in the business to keep interest on their characters and the hardcore fans but all the money those companies make is from licensing the tv shows/cartoons/movies/merchandise. Of course I'd love to be wrong and I'd also love comics to make a comeback which they could if they are smart and embrace technology, tablets are made to read comics but they'll never catch on with the current pricing they have going on..

Ninjinister
01-11-2011, 10:01 PM
Spongebob and the like have only gotten small one or two page comics in Nickelodeon magazine and whatnot, I don't believe any of their properties have had a real run comic book wise.


http://www.digitalspy.com/comics/news/a287379/spongebob-comics-on-the-way.html

CyberCubed
01-11-2011, 10:18 PM
If the comic market is in such dire straights, how do these companies keep releasing new comics every month for multiple series? There are still an average of 20-30 comics per month released with all the companies combined.

Venom
01-12-2011, 02:15 AM
Heh, there's a WHOLE lot more than just 20-30 released each month. There are probably about 20-30 X-titles released a month. :P

jaymq
01-13-2011, 08:13 AM
Ugh, one of the reasons I don't dig the X-Men as much as I probably could otherwise.




And honestly, I'd probably be happy as long as it's not littered with shell jokes and excess silliness (and by excess, it'd probably have to be pretty bad for me to care enough). Comics tended to be my favorite medium for TMNT.

Avatar Yuffie
01-13-2011, 06:16 PM
Nickelodeon cancelled Nick magazine... denying fans some official side stories such as Avatar the Last Airbender and Danny Phantom.

I wouldn't hold my breath, really.

blockhead
01-14-2011, 12:37 AM
I would be fine with it as long as it was set in a different universe as the mirage universe. I would be pleased with it if they manage to write and draw it well. It would really be awesome to see a new turtles comic that is high quality back in the comic shops. I really doubt that Nick is going to make a serious comic though. Why would they? Think about it: their demographic is kids ages 4-13 or so. Kids aren't looking for a dark book, they are going to want one based on the new cartoon. It's just simple marketing.

Abnormal Freak
01-14-2011, 01:46 AM
Heh, there's a WHOLE lot more than just 20-30 released each month. There are probably about 20-30 X-titles released a month. :P

That's what's leaving me scratching my head about this "the comic book is a dying medium" talk. Tons of comics come out each week—somebody's gotta be buying 'em.

shuriken
01-14-2011, 03:06 AM
^^ true but those comic books are all established staples for the most part with independent comic books being snuffed out by the larger companies that publish hundreds of titles. It's been going on for years.

Luckyday
01-14-2011, 07:36 AM
Call me crazy but I think a mirage adaption could be possible I mean other than issue 1 or maybe issue 2 the rest series could be turn into a tv series under a PG-13 rating and shown during a 8 O'clock time slot.

Powder
01-14-2011, 01:20 PM
Call me crazy but I think a mirage adaption could be possible I mean other than issue 1 or maybe issue 2 the rest series could be turn into a tv series under a PG-13 rating and shown during a 8 O'clock time slot.

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

:tlol:

Venom
01-14-2011, 02:08 PM
Call me crazy but I think a mirage adaption could be possible I mean other than issue 1 or maybe issue 2 the rest series could be turn into a tv series under a PG-13 rating and shown during a 8 O'clock time slot.

Two questions:
1. What does yourp ost have to do with a new comic?
2. Where have you been for the past decade? The 4Kids! series was largely based on Mirage's Volume 1 books.

Toon
01-14-2011, 02:21 PM
Nickelodeon cancelled Nick magazine... denying fans some official side stories such as Avatar the Last Airbender and Danny Phantom.

I wouldn't hold my breath, really.

http://www.bleedingcool.com/2010/12/02/dark-horse-to-publish-avatar-the-last-airbender-comics/

Luckyday
01-14-2011, 04:30 PM
Two questions:
1. What does yourp ost have to do with a new comic?
2. Where have you been for the past decade? The 4Kids! series was largely based on Mirage's Volume 1 books.

sorry wrong thread.:teek:

But to give a proper response I say "Why borther?" if they not do anything different than Mirage plus I rather see it done in more capable hands or namely one that into the comic book industry.

blockhead
01-14-2011, 05:46 PM
Call me crazy but I think a mirage adaption could be possible I mean other than issue 1 or maybe issue 2 the rest series could be turn into a tv series under a PG-13 rating and shown during a 8 O'clock time slot.

implying nick has ever done any thing even remotely like this in the past

Andrew NDB
01-14-2011, 06:52 PM
Call me crazy but I think a mirage adaption could be possible I mean other than issue 1 or maybe issue 2 the rest series could be turn into a tv series under a PG-13 rating

No such thing as PG-13 on TV.

Luckyday
01-14-2011, 07:00 PM
No such thing as PG-13 on TV.

I mean TV-14.:oops:

Venom
01-14-2011, 11:51 PM
sorry wrong thread.:teek:

But to give a proper response I say "Why borther?" if they not do anything different than Mirage plus I rather see it done in more capable hands or namely one that into the comic book industry.

This is probably the biggest backhanded comment about Mirage I've ever seen in my life. :x

Luckyday
01-16-2011, 05:39 PM
This is probably the biggest backhanded comment about Mirage I've ever seen in my life. :x

I not insulting the series! I saying that the 2003 series is the closest thing we will get to a mirage adaption. If nick were to make a comic it would probably be more of a cine-manga.
I dont want to start a war.:(

And when I mean doing something different I mean adding more to the franchise.

Venom
01-16-2011, 10:05 PM
Oh okay, it sounded like you meant the guys at Mirage weren't really in the comic industry, lol.

Mr._Mutant_Man
01-23-2011, 10:06 AM
I'd like to see the comics get licensed out to IDW. IDW seems to be really good about having the classic comics based on various properties (Star Trek, Transformers) reprinted in TPBs. As long as that happened, they could do whatever they want to the Turtles in new comics for all I care.

DrSpengler
01-23-2011, 11:11 AM
I've had some differences with IDW in the past. In regards to their original material, particularly their Transformers titles, they have a habit of screwing over creative teams and there is a SERIOUS lack of professional editing going on at their business (the amount of type-o, cropping, coloring and speech bubble errors are absurd, to say nothing of their consistent discontinuity in storytelling).

And I won't even get started on how they treated Ghostbusters.

Honestly, if IDW's business plan didn't center entirely around monopolizing 80s cartoon licenses to corner the nostalgia market, I really don't think they'd last as a publisher.

As for their reprints, they've been doing decent work with GI Joe, I suppose (if you consider next to no art restoration and skipping over minis and specials when they're important to the narrative to be "decent"), but their Transformers reprints were done very much on the cheap and with very little consideration of story chronology. They wouldn't pay royalties for any Marvel characters that cameoed in the book, so many issues are missing entirely nomatter hwo important they are. Even worse, certain miniseries that are vital to story coherency were shuffled off to the last volume rather than being inserted into their proper place in the narrative. The previous publisher of old Marvel Transformer material, Titan, actually paid Marvel the proper royalties so they could reprint every issue and took care to keep the storyline in order for the betterment of the reader. Not IDW, though.

Nearly everything IDW does is half-hearted and I have little faith they'd do much better with TMNT, especially considering how they treat Transformers, their flagship property.

Sadly, considering the aforementioned business plan of IDW, buying every 80s cartoon license they can get their mits on, Viacom licensing the next comic out to them seems like a foregone conclusion.

Andrew NDB
01-23-2011, 02:55 PM
Sadly, considering the aforementioned business plan of IDW, buying every 80s cartoon license they can get their mits on, Viacom licensing the next comic out to them seems like a foregone conclusion.

I dunno. IDW has tried a couple of times already and no-go.

DrSpengler
01-23-2011, 04:02 PM
That restores my hopeful, optimistic demeanor!

Ah, who am I kidding? This is the internet. I'm gonna go blog some doom n gloom with extra angry emoticons for effect.

CyberCubed
01-24-2011, 12:15 AM
I guess the worse case scenario would be a new series that would get canceled quickly, like the Dreamwave series.

When DW got TMNT, it seemed like it was going to last for at least 1-2 years....instead we only get 7 measly issues out of it and it gets canceled quickly, with 4 of them just being episode adaptions.

I realize DW in general went out of business afterward, but it was so ridiculous to see the series canceled so quickly. Why did Mirage make a deal with them?