View Full Version : Why did Mirage make a TPB for Zulli's "Soul Winter" trilogy?
CyberCubed
01-18-2011, 07:57 PM
Why did they decided to release a TPB only two years or so ago about Soul's Winter?
The issues are not part of Mirage canon, as they feature alternate Turtles in an alternate universe. Zulli is also not a Mirage artist/writer.
Why was this story arc given special treatment?
DrSpengler
01-18-2011, 08:20 PM
Well Zulli isn't a member of the Mirage staff but he is friends with many of them. He collaborated with Stephen Murphy on The Puma Blues and worked with other staffers on different projects.
So it could've been done out of respect for him/at his request. "Soul's Winter" may not be Mirage canon but it is generally held in high regard for its alternate take on the Turtles. Maybe Laird just felt that it was a good story that people might want to buy?
Galactus
01-18-2011, 08:27 PM
The best answer is...why not?
Laird has said that he likes it, quite a lot of fans like it and Zulli's work has a following. It would seem a no brainer if they were going to put something out there.
Tristan Jones also said here that part of the reason they did the Zulli trade was to raise funds for him.
in the vol.4 lettercol Laird said that a collection of Veitch's turtles work was a possibility. It seems they pursued that idea but someone said on here Mirage wanted him to sign his rights to story to them (or something along those lines) which he declined. I don't know how true that is.
Candy Kappa
01-18-2011, 08:34 PM
cause it's freakin' Michael Zulli and the story is awesome
CyberCubed
01-18-2011, 08:47 PM
Well we got Soul's Winter reprinted over Return to New York or any other trilogy, which I find a bit odd.
Was Mirage planning any more Vol. 1 collections before the Nick buyout?
DrSpengler
01-18-2011, 08:56 PM
Well we got Soul's Winter reprinted over Return to New York or any other trilogy, which I find a bit odd.
Was Mirage planning any more Vol. 1 collections before the Nick buyout?
Probably, considering the trade paperback collection they released in 2009 was emblazened with "Volume One" on the cover and spine, indicating they intended to release future volumes.
Laird has confirmed that the Viacom buyout was very abrupt and came as a surprise to everyone. They solicited products that they inevitably had to cancel because of the sudden decision to sell the franchise.
Further chronological and themed collections were a certainty until the buyout.
Powder
01-18-2011, 08:59 PM
I read/heard (don't remember which) that it was done to help him through a rough financial period.
Roseangelo
01-18-2011, 09:46 PM
The best answer is...why not?
This.
cause it's freakin' Michael Zulli and the story is awesome
This.
I read/heard (don't remember which) that it was done to help him through a rough financial period.
And also this.
Abnormal Freak
01-18-2011, 11:15 PM
I consider it to be the long-delayed TMNT: The Collected Book, Volume Eight, and I love it. :]
Venom
01-18-2011, 11:27 PM
Why did they decided to release a TPB only two years or so ago about Soul's Winter?
The issues are not part of Mirage canon, as they feature alternate Turtles in an alternate universe. Zulli is also not a Mirage artist/writer.
Why was this story arc given special treatment?
Because Zulli's work is badass, that's why!! Also, it was printed while Murph was still editor over publishing, and as mentioned by other, he and the others at Mirage put Soul's Winter together to help out Zulli. It's all laid out in the editorial page of the book.
So what was Zulli's financial problem (if anyone knows)? I don't even know what he does now for recent comics works, if any.
discordiatookie
01-19-2011, 03:57 PM
So what was Zulli's financial problem (if anyone knows)? I don't even know what he does now for recent comics works, if any.
Looks like he's got a new book out called The Fracture of the Universal Boy:
http://michaelzulli.blogspot.com/
&
http://www.forbiddenplanet.co.uk/index.php?main_page=product_music_info&products_id=62155
Dinobot
01-28-2011, 11:16 PM
So, is there no way this can be fitted into the canon?
CyberCubed
01-28-2011, 11:20 PM
Its an alternate universe with alternate Turtles.
It could take place if the Turtles ever dimension-hopped into the Zulli Turtles universe....but that didn't happen.
TuЯco
01-28-2011, 11:21 PM
i only had the first and the last one of zullis trilogy maybe it was because some people didnt own the whole thing
Dinobot
01-28-2011, 11:44 PM
Its an alternate universe with alternate Turtles.
It could take place if the Turtles ever dimension-hopped into the Zulli Turtles universe....but that didn't happen.
Leaving aside the artwork and how different they look - story wise, can it be fitted in?
Roseangelo
01-29-2011, 01:17 AM
Leaving aside the artwork and how different they look - story wise, can it be fitted in?
Repeat: It's an alternate universe. This has nothing to do with having a different art style. It's just its own thing.
Abnormal Freak
01-29-2011, 01:35 AM
I'd actually love to have more Zulli Turtles stuff, because...it's actually a lot more interesting than Eastman and Laird's stuff. :p I like the introduction Bissette wrote for the first or second issue of the trilogy: something about bringing the Ninja Turtles back to their roots, which go deeper in the past than even the first Eastman and Laird issue.
Venom
01-29-2011, 02:04 AM
something about bringing the Ninja Turtles back to their roots, which go deeper in the past than even the first Eastman and Laird issue.
By going back to their roots, he meant by tapping into the Anima and showing the Turtles as they are in their most basic form: primal beasts trained with one purpose in mind. Foot Soldiers, if you will.
Soul's Winter is much more than just an alternate take on the Turtles' mythos, it's a mystical study into the primordial battle between man and animal.
This trilogy will always hold a special place in my heart, as 31 (and 28) were my first Mirage books ever. My young mind was blown a million miles to hell and back at how awesome this take was. Murph will always be tops in my book!
Abnormal Freak
01-29-2011, 02:08 AM
I seem to recall Bissette going deeper with the "roots" thing, because he started talking about what TMNT #1 was inspired by, which goes back to Frank Miller's Ronin, which goes back to the Lone Wolf and Cub comics and films, which goes back to ancient Japanese lore, that sort of thing. That's what I got from his introduction, anyway.
Dinobot
01-29-2011, 09:49 AM
Repeat: It's an alternate universe. This has nothing to do with having a different art style. It's just its own thing.
Repeat: If one wanted to fit it into the timeline, could it be done?
DrSpengler
01-29-2011, 10:15 AM
Repeat: If one wanted to fit it into the timeline, could it be done?
Not at all.
The histories and backgrounds of the characters are very different, and while some similar events happen, they go in very different directions.
From a narrative standpoint, there is no logical way to shoehorn it into the primary Mirage continuity as it is simply to incongruous.
Venom
01-29-2011, 10:55 AM
Repeat: If one wanted to fit it into the timeline, could it be done?
What Spengs said. Think of Soul's Winter as a TMNT Elseworlds Tale.
DrSpengler
01-29-2011, 11:21 AM
Exactly. It'd be like trying to fit "Red Son" or "Kingdom Come" into mainstream Superman continuity.
Not gonna fit no matter how you wriggle it. Great stories, but strictly alternate universes.
Candy Kappa
01-29-2011, 11:49 AM
Repeat: If one wanted to fit it into the timeline, could it be done?
NO
It is a alternative universe
Dinobot
01-29-2011, 01:45 PM
NO
It is a alternative universe
OKAY
Thanks Spengs, love your list by the way, appreciate all the hard work.
Spitfire
01-29-2011, 02:49 PM
For me the question isn't why did they release it. Instead I ask why didn't they release City At War, yet they released Souls Winter. As it's been said though there were supposed to be more trades but I find it silly Laird didn't work out in his contract that he could release more of those instead of just comics. He knew he wasn't interested in writing or publishing more issues.
The books however were not only in high demand but the series never got very good trade treatment. We have several re-releases of the first main story arc plus the micro series and then maybe one each of some other random arcs. Turtles needs one of those essential books like Marvel does.
Venom
01-29-2011, 07:54 PM
Dude, the seven Collected Books gather issues 1-29. That's quite a bit of Volume 1.
CyberCubed
01-29-2011, 09:47 PM
Dude, the seven Collected Books gather issues 1-29. That's quite a bit of Volume 1.
And those books are from the late 80's and most fans who collected the comics didn't start till much later, some even in the late 2000's.
It's like wondering why Shell Shock was never re-released. Its old stuff that SHOULD be made more available to fans, but of course isn't.
In all seriousness I think its disgusting that people can't even get into TMNT comics because some issues are just too old and rare now. There's no reason this stuff can't at least all be scanned legally and uploaded.
Yeah the 7 TMNT Collected trade books cover alot of Volume ones early portion, 8 books if u count the Shell Shock shorts book. The only one I wished didn't get printed was book 5, The Mark Martin stuff. They just didn't belong in what the surrounding Collected books read like. That one certainly could've been skipped and maybe we'd have a more legitimate run of the 7 trades, something that collected into the early 30's issues. Yeah Mirage dropped the ball on the trades in the their 2nd run of printing comics this past decade. They certainly coud've done some more books. If they were willing to make 5 trades of Tales V2, why couldn't they have done re-releases of the 7 Vol. 1 trades? City at War and Vol. 2's run should've been collected. The order numbers were probably low anyway for all these Mirage trades and yet they still printed them. If they were doing trades of Tales V2 why did they not even make any books collecting TMNT Vol.4's stuff? This certainly could've at least helped V4 get more readers possibly, even if slightly? This series would've been better for trades and put some new readers right into the V4 issues at the time. Yeah I agree that TMNT comics could easily be in Essential/Showcase like tomes (they'd probably be cheaper too which would be good). Even the newsprint like paper would've put them right back into the old days like what the comics were printed on. The recent trades were all printed by Brenner Printing and the Collected Book 1 '09 trade was so thick cause of the paper they used on the comics was just thick for a trade of that size! The sad thing is we have no idea if and when Paramount/Nicko will even go with the Mirage TMNT books as a viable future for a TMNT book program, if any. Paramount seems to like to licence their properties to others for comics. Only their Pocket Books and Simon & Shuster does Paramount stuff, if some. But the thing is they've never done comics in their history I don't think. So I'm pretty sure the TMNT will be coming from a comics publisher via licenced. For now it may be a 50% bet that it maybe IDW. They do GI Joe movie, Transformer movie related comics for them and their Star Trek stuff. Thats just a logical assumption.
DrSpengler
01-30-2011, 07:50 AM
One of the reasons Volume 1 material got put on the backburner for reprints during the time when Mirage was pumping out their Tales (Vol. 2) trades and what not is because Laird insisted that none of the issues be collected until he'd personally "remastered" them all.
Since he was doing the digital "remastering" in his spare time, and he wanted no one to do it but himself, years and years and years went by and only the first issue was ever finished. And his release of that versions via the PBBZ reprint was met with vitriol (and much deserved vitriol, if you ask me).
If Laird hadn't insisted on "remastering" Volume 1, we might have gotten trade collections earlier than 2009, and quite possibly have gotten more than one collection.
But that's really only the tip of the iceberg when it came to Mirage's handling of trades and distribution. I don't really want to sound like a broken record by getting into it all over again, since it comes up quite a bit on these forums and, well, is all in the past, now.
CyberCubed
01-30-2011, 09:30 AM
Those Tales V.2 Trades were pointless. Why did Mirage even bother to collect 5 recent Tales issues that were still readily available?
I'm not surprised nobody bought them. Most people don't have the need to re-buy what they already own, and recently at that.
Scandia
01-30-2011, 12:48 PM
I think it is a beautiful story, even though it is certainly not canon.
They could have adapted it (to a degree) into an episode of 2k3. It may have worked.
Venom
01-30-2011, 03:36 PM
Those Tales V.2 Trades were pointless. Why did Mirage even bother to collect 5 recent Tales issues that were still readily available?
I'm not surprised nobody bought them. Most people don't have the need to re-buy what they already own, and recently at that.
Probably the same reasoning other comic publishers collect recent books into trades: they typically perform better than singles. The major hindrance Mirage's trades faced was the issue of not having their books in major retailers where they would have gotten wider visibility.
Spitfire
01-30-2011, 06:29 PM
Except when major publishers do it it's consistent. The Tales V2 trades came out randomly and contained issues from all over the place. I liked they kept some of the story arcs together but most companies would have released 6 books a trade in order of release.
Hardcover collections of 12 issues usually follow with some special features like unused artwork and variant covers. Had Mirage started doing this when V4 came out they would have been caught up by the time the buy out happened.
Also the turtles trades were sold in most comic stores. Every store I went to either had them in stock or were sold out. Unless you're talking about book stores in which case I never saw any turtles trades there. I doubt that would hinder sales much though.
Yeah adding extras bits into trades and hardcovers seems common now for comics publishers. I thought Mirage sortta started doing this with TMNT Collected Book 1 '09 (covers between issues, text info (if slightly inaccurate)) and TMNT: Future Tense trade (a pin up and alternate covers). Never the less, I thought TMNT Collected Book 1 '09 set the precedence for what future TMNT trades should exactly be like. Now we'll probably not ever see that after the buy out unless whoever and whenever someone does TMNT comics reprints thinks to go with this layout.
Venom
01-30-2011, 09:32 PM
You're forgetting that Mirage was not a big company. It may not have been financially feasible for Mirage, as a small company specializing primarily in the licensing of one particular property, to allocate funds to the publishing arm (which was consistently losing money) for printing a small batch of books that may or may not sell.
The Tales Volume 2 trades seem to have sold decently, but the old Volume 1 trades are still easily available from Mirage.
If you'll search the archives you'll come across Gary Richardson's reasoning for not allowing the trades to find their way into places such as Books-A-Million, Borders, and Barnes & Noble (which would have helped sales simply by putting the Turtles out there in front of people who shop those stores rather than a comic shop). Next time you're in a book store, take a gander at all the trades; next time you're in your LCS, do the same. You'll see the difference having a presence in those retailers could have made.
I just acquired Soul's Winter tpb in a Winnipeg store and read the intro from Steve Bissette. He seemed to imply there were plans to make a trade of Rick Vietch's stuff of "The River" and issue #30 soon. Obviously this didn't happen. Wonder why? Can't believe it was actually planned.
Venom
02-04-2011, 11:34 PM
this didn't happen. Wonder why? Can't believe it was actually planned.
*sigh* Welcome to the quandaries or Mirage.
Abnormal Freak
02-05-2011, 03:19 AM
A TPB of Veitch's stuff would've been rad, since they're some of my favorite Turtles tales. I do own an oversized TPB of "The River" on glossy paper...but it's in French. http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/smilies/icon_biggrin.gif Can't read the language, but it sure is a beautiful collection; Veitch even signed and drew an awesome attack pose of Raphael on the inside cover.
Bjarni
02-16-2011, 08:49 PM
So, is there no way this can be fitted into the canon?
I actually always felt that this takes place before Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #1. Splinter has evolved, but the Turtles are in this stage of Turtle and Man, they don't know for sure what they are.
Of course it wasn't meant to be taken like that, but that's how I view it.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.