View Full Version : Integrity vs. Completion: Mirage and creator-owned rights
DrSpengler
01-18-2011, 09:18 PM
Eastman and Laird have always been fierce supporters of creator-owned character rights in the comics industry. In the editorials of the old Volume 1 series, they never seemed to miss a chance to condemn Stan Lee and support Jack Kirby (dedicating an issue to him while the man was still alive, even), who were both on different ends of the creator ownership issue.
The support of this notion went so far as to allow guest creators on TMNT Volume 1 the priviledge of keeping the rights to any characters they created.
This, of course, has led to some troubles with reprinting and "canonicity" in recent years, as these rights issues (particularly with Rick Veitch and "The River") have kept certain material from being reprinted or included in "canon" (obviously we're all capable of making our own "canon", but I'm talking in terms of official/legal status).
Though I also have to wonder how much of that is the creators being unwilling to "play ball" or how much is Laird simply being uncooperative/non-communicative?
We all recall the hullabaloo with TMNT (Vol. 1) #8, where Laird swore up and down that it could never be reprinted due to the presence of Cerebus, going so far as to commission Jim Lawson to write and draw a Cerebus-free alternate version (which, to date, has only seen print in Spanish language TMNT trades).
This was brought to the attention of Dave Sim who basically came out and said, "Dude, why didn't you just ASK!?" Sim vocally gave Laird permission to reprint the issue, free of freakin' charge, so long as he made sure to include a proper ownership credit. Laird, in all his panic, simply never bothered to ask.
And so it was reprinted without incident in 2009.
On the flipside of the coin, we have the work-for-hire heavy Tales of the TMNT (Vol. 2). Lots of creators who were not Mirage staffers, mostly newcomers to the industry, contributed to that book, but unlike during the "guest era" of TMNT Volume 1, none of these non-staff creators got to keep any of their creations.
While this creates a greater ease for reprints, as Laird wouldn't have to worry about picking up a phone and asking someone for permission, it has the opposite effect of turning Mirage into exactly the thing it railed against back in the 80s: Marvel/DC.
While no doubt all the freelancers who contributed to Tales Vol. 2 were aware of what they were signing away when they worked on the book and were cool with it, it still comes across as a breach of Mirage's company standard and integrity; by taking the work contributed by others because they want them for their own convenience.
So the question I want to ask you is, what matters more to you: "integrity" or "completion"?
We may never get to see much of Volume 1 reprinted (if Viacom ever sees it fit to do reprints) and much of it had to be "de-canonized" (not that it really matters) because of the creator-ownership issues.
However, the attitude maintained Mirage's integrity as a publisher that supported creator ownership and didn't "swindle" creators out of their creatons.
Then there's Tales Vol. 2, which had the creators from outside Mirage sign away their creations if they wanted to contribute and get paid, but at the same time, we will never have to worry about any of those stories being unavailable for reprint or stricken from continuity due to legal matters.
Which is more important to you? Are you willing to forgo creator-ownership rights if it means having complete collections in the future (at the same time, everyone who signs a contract should know what they're signing away, so they aren't "victims")? Or are you willing to forgo ever seeing a story reprinted again or willing to see it overwritten in continuity due to ownership rights, so long as the person who created it gets to keep their creation?
Roseangelo
01-18-2011, 09:43 PM
Mirage's support for creator-owned work died in the early/mid-90s (yes, very hypocritical). The material in question that hasn't been reprinted isn't due to Mirage simply not asking, it's due to Mirage requiring all creators to sign over 100% of the rights to their work to Mirage. If a creator, such as Rick Veitch, didn't do so, Mirage basically wasn't going to bother doing anything with that work again.
This, of course, was all pre-Nick. So I suppose it's possible for things to change in the future.
John Pannozzi
01-18-2011, 11:33 PM
This was brought to the attention of Dave Sim who basically came out and said, "Dude, why didn't you just ASK!?" Sim vocally gave Laird permission to reprint the issue, free of freakin' charge, so long as he made sure to include a proper ownership credit. Laird, in all his panic, simply never bothered to ask.
More specifically Sim came up with the "Reciprocal Licensing Agreement" (meaning "I'll let you reprint it if you let me reprint it"), which he explained in a bit more detail in the Spawn Origins Book One Hardcover.
And it's worth noting that Sim's attitude and actions towards intellectual property laws are much looser than most, which means Laird probably didn't know as much about Sim's views over ownership rights as he should (I mean, the two of them were among the co-signers of the Creator's Bill of Rights, for Will Eisner's sake), but also that the other freelancers on TMNT might not necessarily be as easy to work out reprint legalities with as Sim.
Mirage's support for creator-owned work died in the early/mid-90s (yes, very hypocritical). The material in question that hasn't been reprinted isn't due to Mirage simply not asking, it's due to Mirage requiring all creators to sign over 100% of the rights to their work to Mirage. If a creator, such as Rick Veitch, didn't do so, Mirage basically wasn't going to bother doing anything with that work again.
The last TMNT-related thing published by Mirage and done by outsiders (Pre-Tales v.2, at least) was the Casey Jones 2-part mini-series by Rick Veitch (published in May and July of 1994), right? Though IIRC, Mirage was kind enough to let Gary Carlson keep the rights to some of the characters he created for TMNT vol. 3 (not sure which ones, though, I'd have to check the legal info).
Oh, and I while sympathize with creators, how many characters were actually created by freelancers for Tales v.2? I can't think of too many characters who debuted in that series at the moment, and at least a fair amount of Tales has done by Mirage staffers like Berger, Murphy ( A.K.A. Clarrain ) and Lawson. Though I wonder if Jake Black, Will Tupper, Ross May and Tristan Jones count as Mirage staff members?
Oh, and to answer the question, from an ethical perspective, yes the creators should ideally retain ownership of the characters they create. But from a logical standpoint, when someone creates a character that's very much a part of an established franchise/series that they do not own, it makes more sense for the IP holders to own incidental characters. Like say, in the Change of Power issue of Tales v.2, I think Ross May created (or co-created, along with Peter Laird and the artists of that issue) a character who was a relative of someone integral to the backstory of the TMNT (not saying who). That would prove tricky if fictional characters were related yet owned by separate legal entities (though for all I know there very may well already be a handful of examples out there). But, to give credence to creator rights, other comics like the Savage Dragon and Powers have cameos by numerous characters owned by other people, and they seldom, if ever, have had to omit or alter any stories in reprinted forms, making Spengler's assessment of Laird seem all the more accurate.
willtupper
01-19-2011, 01:28 AM
I can't speak for the other guys, but I'm pretty sure we were all mercenaries.
Hired by the generosity of the great Saint Murphy :).
Though I wonder if Jake Black, Will Tupper, Ross May and Tristan Jones count as Mirage staff members?
Abnormal Freak
01-19-2011, 02:33 AM
We all recall the hullabaloo with TMNT (Vol. 1) #8, where Laird swore up and down that it could never be reprinted due to the presence of Cerebus, going so far as to commission Jim Lawson to write and draw a Cerebus-free alternate version (which, to date, has only seen print in Spanish language TMNT trades).
Wha'? This actually got made? (I read about it in a Vol. 4 letters column, I believe.) What are the names/ISBNs of these trades? :p I would love to see the redone comic, though not knowing Spanish, it'd be great if someone would supply translations.
wilddiverse
01-22-2011, 10:19 PM
Until I hear otherwise, I'm going to believe the redone TMNT v1 #8 is in Las Tortugas Ninja volume 2 (2007). The wheels are in motion.
azrael
01-23-2011, 07:54 AM
yeah thats it I thought about getting it but I just dont really care thats not the story...imo
________
Burningchick (http://www.girlcamfriend.com/cam/Burningchick/)
RossMay
01-24-2011, 09:10 PM
I appreciate your thinking about this, DrSpengler. As Will says, we were freelancers, not staff. Personally I was more pragmatic about our situation. Sure, I've noticed the exact same things you have regarding Mirage and copyright, but I think Dave Sim and the other signatories of the Creators' Bill of Rights were being somewhat unrealistic back in 1988, so I don't begrudge Mirage for its policy changes.
I can go out and make my own original works, but when I sign up to freelance I know exactly who owns the work and am willing to live with that. Jerry Siegel, Joe Shuster, Bill Finger, Jack Kirby and others didn't have this luxury, only the avenue where their work was not theirs.
John Pannozzi
04-17-2011, 06:23 PM
Here's an interesting statement from A.C. Farley regarding why Mirage made everyone sign over over rights regarding TMNT (http://www.facebook.com/notes/ac-farley/john-pannozzi-posted-on-your-wall/203612562995480):
Initially we all owned copyright to our work. Then Mirage got spooked regarding ownership later in the game because the complete and total dumbass that was doing the TV cartoons decided he owned the TV version of the TMNT and sent the TMNT business world into a spin. This occurred at EXACTLY the point when I turned in my Leo sculpture. Mirage became afraid that they didn't have a strong enough grip on their rights. They said if I didn't agree to remove my copyright, the sculpture would not be produced. I'd been placing my copyright on all of my work for years up to then, and nobody ever objected. I'd even had an upset and complained early on in my dealings with Mirage when I saw one of my collected TMNT cover paintings being sold as a poster at my local grocery. I hadn't agreed to that and I wasn't paid for that use. I set the Mirage business folks straight, telling them that they had to ask, and pay, for reuse. I forgave that use and even allowed the use with no pay. And the next time they wanted to reuse a painting they did make certain to ask me beforehand, so they did indeed recognize my ownership. It was for a t-shirt for some charity, so I allowed the use for free. I endeavor to be a nice guy, after all.
Anyway, their new opinion, years later, was that I didn't own the TMNT so I couldn't have copyright to the sculpt or anything else with a TMNT involved. Well no, I don't own the TMNT, but I did own that sculpt, all rights to my art, and the rights to reproduce it. I got very pissed off. We had agreements from the start. I'd made it perfectly clear from the very start I was only selling first time, North American rights to any art I did for them. Now they wanted all rights and we were all told we couldn't do any TMNT work if we wouldn't sign 'work for hire' agreements for any new work, and retroactively, for past work. (Pardon my redundancy) Then they bought all rights to our previous work, for a small price, in my opinion, and made it all work for hire retroactively.
There were convenient memory lapses during all of this, for their own good, at Mirage regarding verbal agreements they'd made. I'd always insisted everything be in writing up until my dealings with Mirage. I didn't think that would ever be a problem there. There I go, thinking again.
This is all in the past, and just a sore spot in an otherwise wonderful bunch of very happy memories. It is sore, all the same.
Anyway, get everything in writing, even if it's your own mother you're making business agreements with. Do that or suffer the consequences later on. I can't even really blame Mirage for any of this, since I should have gotten the agreements in writing in the first place. I let my personal feelings guide me instead of my good sense. I do that a lot. Usually it's okay. Sometimes I get 'bit in the ass' because of that. Live and learn.
All that being said, we all got as okay with it as we could and moved forward from there. I just stopped doing TMNT art after that, except for a few things here and there. I understand business. I really do. Only, I'd have done things differently if it was my company. I wouldn't have 'forgotten' my verbal agreements, mostly. Mirage will always be one of the highlights of my life. We were a tight knit group of friends. We were all like the Beatles. I mean, there was that kind of excitement in what we were doing and the level of acceptance we were enjoying. Heck, people are still excited by it all.
There are a lot of things I'd do differently in my life, looking back from this point. I'm a 13 year old in my head, operating as an adult, as is required in an adult world. However, I'm an older guy. There certainly are things that I wish I could go back and change. You don't get to be 56 years old without having at least a few regrets. That's not at all productive, dwelling on it all, so I move forward and do things differently, leaving the parts of the past I don't like to remember behind, as much as I can, doing my best not to make any more errors.
Interesting. So, it apparently was Fred Wolf (or someone else involved with the first TMNT cartoon) who was the cause of Mirage forcing everyone to sign away their rights regarding TMNT.
oldmanwinters
04-17-2011, 06:30 PM
Ah yes, verbal agreements. Nuff' said.
Well, I will say that Farley is awesome. It's too bad he got the shaft by the company he helped rise to prominence.
EDIT:
Interesting. So, it apparently was Fred Wolf (or someone else involved with the first TMNT cartoon) who was the cause of Mirage forcing everyone to sign away their rights regarding TMNT.
I can't say that I have a big problem with an animation company claiming rights to its own programs. Studios claim ownership rights over movies based on licensed properties (i.e., Universal= Hulk, The Incredible Hulk, Sony= Spider-man 1-3, Fox= X-Men films, etc.)
It doesn't strike me that Fred Wolf did anything crooked, unless he violated a prior "verbal agreement."
Jester
04-17-2011, 06:38 PM
So it's all Fred Wolf's fault...Go figure. :P
I think if they get the creators' permission, give them credit and maybe even royalties it shouldn't be a huge problem to reprint.
DrSpengler
04-17-2011, 06:49 PM
Wow, so that's why we've seen very little TMNT work from Farley in the past, um, decade and a half or more? A real shame, as I've confessed before, he's one of my all-time Mirage faves.
Guess it's also why Laird considered "Men of Shadow" to be one of those "guest issues" unlike "Sons of the Silent Age" or "Dreams of Stone". Farley wouldn't "play ball".
It's definately an interesting look at the behind the scenes of Mirage. Eastman and Laird always ragged on guys like Stan Lee and railed against the corporate comics machine stealing the work from creators and such...
Then they turn around and pull something like that. Real classy.
Spitfire
04-17-2011, 06:53 PM
If you create a character for use with TMNT there's no need to take it out of TMNT and do something else with it. Every real company operates under the rule that anything you make while at work, or using equipment from work be it your day off or not, belongs to them. If you want to create something and make sure they don't retain ownership of it then you have to go through the proper channels.
In the turtles case characters were created for use with the turtles. If the artist thought the character had tons of potential and wanted to use it for something else they shouldn't have wasted it on turtles. All this free rights stuff does is over complicate creating collections for hardcore fans, as you all mentioned. I think it's silly. If anyone didn't bother to read their contract and felt like their characters got stolen that's their problem.
It might seem noble at first for Mirage to have taken this approach but I see it more as being too nice. They didn't want to ask someone for rights to their characters because they didn't want to put another artist out. Stan Lee stole from Kirby but everyone knows it so what does it matter? The man is still a legend.
DrSpengler
04-17-2011, 07:12 PM
I think the difference here, though is that the "work for hire" Farley speaks of was retroactive. When he went to work for Mirage, it was under the impression that it would be freelance labor allowing him to retain the rights to his creations (a deal which was apparently done entirely through verbal contracts which, as Farley admits, was a bad business decision).
I fully agree that people who sign work for hire contracts need to accept the consequences of their business decision, but Farley's (and, subsequently, most of the Mirage staff's) case is more complicated, as a BS legal move forced them to sign away the work they'd done as freelancers retroactively.
The Mirage staffers probably could have gone to court over the matter at the time, and perhaps the blame still lies with them that they didn't fight back when they had the chance; or maybe they felt burning that bridge and expending massive legal costs wasnt worth it at the time?
Again, it was their decision, so I guess that's all it boils down to.
John Pannozzi
04-17-2011, 07:36 PM
I think I may have an explanation as to why Laird was reluctant to ask Dave Sim for the permission to reprint TMNT vol. 1 #8.
Remember that for the longest time, Spawn #10 (the one guest-starring Cerebus and written by Dave Sim) was never reprinted?
In the Spawn Origins Collection Book One Hardcover (as well as the Spawn Origins Collection Deluxe Edition vol. 1), there's a forward to #10 by Sim, which explains everything. Basically, around 1995, a somewhat drunken Sim told Larry Marder (creator of Tales from the Beanworld, and at the time one of the bigshots at Image Comics), "Listen, you tell Todd if he ever tries to reprint Spawn 10 without asking me, I'll take him down. I'll go to the mat over it." Though Sim goes on to say that he didn't intend to never let McFarlane reprint if they worked out an agreement.
Maybe that's what scared Laird off.
DrSpengler
04-17-2011, 07:43 PM
That's certainly a telling insight. I've read that Sim is notoriously... "difficult" and has lived a rather checkered lifestyle, though the way Sim tells it, Laird never even made an attempt to contact him to negotiate terms.
So its certainly understandable why Laird would have been intimidated by Sim's reputation, though to not even make an effort is a tad less excusable.
That is interesting, which makes me wonder why exactly Mirage owns the OT characters and not Fred Wolf, there are similar examples like My Little Pony/He-Man/The Tick and other shows that they can't use original characters from the cartoon because they do not own them I guess because Laird/Eastman designed most of them? So does that mean that FW does own some of the characters they did without Mirage's assistance?
Personally I think creator owned rights are ********, if you are working on a franchise why shouldn't what you create be owned by said franchise. All it does is cause trouble later on, just look at Image and its the fans who suffer the consequences. Same thing when a company creates a character for a franchise and then says they own said character. Anything created for a franchise whether its from a creator or big company should be owned by the franchise.
I wonder if Mirage owns Ninjara since she did get a spin-off comic.
DrSpengler
04-17-2011, 08:19 PM
I wonder if Mirage owns Ninjara since she did get a spin-off comic.
Stephen Murphy and Chris Allan share the rights for Ninjara. Precisely what that entails when it comes to reprinting TMNT Adventures issues with her in it, I do not know (if Viacom/IDW has to pay a licensing fee to Murphy and Allan for her, or if Murphy's and Allan's original contracts forked over licensing rights for the issues she appeared in).
It's all very confusing.
But again, it all comes down to whether the contract says "freelance" or "work for hire". "Freelance" means that yu retain ownership of whatever it is you create, where as "work for hire" means the company you are working for retains rights to any of your ideas created under their employment.
Of course, it's never that cut and dry. Lots of "work for hire" contracts from the 30s and 40s are coming under scrutiny these days (take a look at the Siegal and Shuster vs. DC/Time Warner hullabaloo that's raging as we speak over owenership of Superman). And, as Farley pointed out in his statement, lawyers can "bully" freelancers into signing away their creations retroactively as work for hire.
Litigation. There's nothing easy about it.
Galactus
04-17-2011, 08:37 PM
This has been alluded to before in Lavigne/Brownes blog which stated that the Archie book was on the brink of breach of contract with it's cartoon adaptions.
I can't say that I have a big problem with an animation company claiming rights to its own programs. Studios claim ownership rights over movies based on licensed properties (i.e., Universal= Hulk, The Incredible Hulk, Sony= Spider-man 1-3, Fox= X-Men films, etc.)
It doesn't strike me that Fred Wolf did anything crooked, unless he violated a prior "verbal agreement."
Or a written one. If I'm interpreting Farley's words correctly and assuming they're an accurate description of the situation back then it seems that Fred Wolf decided he owned the TV version of the turtles.
Owning the show which is their work is one thing but Mirage owns the TMNT in all it's likenesses. Obviously that's what we eventualy ended up with since we got the '87 toon characters and world recreated accurately in Turtles Forever. We didn't get the old shows soundtrack or any animation for the the old show since that does and should belong to Fred Wolf.
Of course intellectual property is a huge grey area anyway. If for example Mirage or rather Nickleodeon now decide that they don't want anyone using the character of Leatherhead does that mean they can't release anymore DVDs of eps of either cartoon that feature him.
I think the difference here, though is that the "work for hire" Farley speaks of was retroactive.
Well it's as good as definitely but since he got some money for it then they essentialy wanted to buy the work from him...even if it wasn't what he would consider a fair price. I don't believe they had no choice in this matter since Rick Veitch told 'em to take a hike.
I've read that Sim is notoriously... "difficult" and has lived a rather checkered lifestyle, though the way Sim tells it, Laird never even made an attempt to contact him to negotiate terms.
So its certainly understandable why Laird would have been intimidated by Sim's reputation, though to not even make an effort is a tad less excusable.
Dave Sim isn't that easy to get a hold of since he doesn't use email and he doesn't use contracts and to quote Farley here "get everything in writing, even if it's your own mother". Sim did eventualy agree to a very basic contract.
The lack of communication goes both ways. Sim stated that he doubted that Laird would allow TMNT #8 to be reprinted in Cerebus miscellany and made no attempt to find out. I believe the right for Sim to reprint #8 was part of the contact that allowed it to be reprinted in Mirage's own trade.
John Pannozzi
04-17-2011, 08:41 PM
Chris Allan told me that he never owned Ninjara, and that Murphy eventually sold her to Mirage. Same with all the TMNT Adventures characters that were originally copyrighted by their respective creators (who were all Mirage staffers).
This has been alluded to before in Lavigne/Brownes blog which stated that the Archie book was on the brink of breach of contract with it's cartoon adaptions.
Really? Where?
I believe the right for Sim to reprint #8 was part of the contact that allowed it to be reprinted in Mirage's own trade.
Yeah, the Reciprocal Licensing Agreement, which I mentioned earlier in this thread.
Powder
04-17-2011, 08:46 PM
*Waits for Cybercubed to storm in and blame Fred Wolf directly for the lack of Seasons 9 & 10...*
:fshifty:
Galactus
04-17-2011, 08:57 PM
So does that mean that FW does own some of the characters they did without Mirage's assistance?
I don't know but it would make sense seeing as Goldenharvest own Tatsu and Keno and Konami own Aska.
Personally I think creator owned rights are ********, if you are working on a franchise why shouldn't what you create be owned by said franchise.
Creator owned rights were very important. When you think that the likes of Jack Kirby got so little compensation for creating and co-creating some of industrys biggest characters. Some merchendise like action figures not only use his designs but his actual art for the box to this day.
Of course these days most creators know what they're getting into. In some ways it's kinda sad that Mirage had to operate in this way but I think it was a very necessary step to protect the franchise.
Venom
04-17-2011, 09:01 PM
Farley is awesome. It's too bad he got the shaft by the company he helped rise to prominence.
It's bit of a stretch to say Farley helped Mirage "rise to prominence." The Turtles were already a well-established property and Mirage was at its heights.
Eastman and Laird always ragged on guys like Stan Lee and railed against the corporate comics machine stealing the work from creators and such...
Then they turn around and pull something like that. Real classy.
I doubt it was so much Kevin and Peter as it was the brass at Mirage. Remember, Kevin and Peter may have owned the business itself but they had others who proclaimed to have the appropriate acumen to run the show for them. Whoever was the "Gary Richardson" back then was probably the one who created the new contract terms.
oldmanwinters
04-17-2011, 09:06 PM
It's bit of a stretch to say Farley helped Mirage "rise to prominence." The Turtles were already a well-established property and Mirage was at its heights.
That's a fair statement. Although in my own experience with the Mirage comics, the City at War issues were the part of the series that really got me interested in the series, and that Farley covers were a bit reason for that. So I guess my statement is more personal that general. The comics certainly rose to prominence in my own mind thanks to Farley's contributions.
How about this:
"Farley helped Mirage rise to prominence artistically." ;-)
John Pannozzi
05-05-2011, 05:27 PM
Here's a couple letters from Dave Sim, the first (http://albert.nickerson.tripod.com/creatorsbillofrightssim21.html)about his agree with Laird regarding the reprinting of TMNT vol. 1 #8, and the second (http://albert.nickerson.tripod.com/creatorsbillofrightssim22.html) regarding the sale of TMNT to Viacom.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.