View Full Version : Peter Laird and George Lucas
Abnormal Freak
01-24-2011, 10:47 PM
Sooooo... :p I'm reading through Vol. 4 for the first time, just finished issue 28, and it's interesting how in a letters column from a few issues back, Laird talked about Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith for a bit, noting his distaste for the prequel trilogy and how unfortunate that Lucas didn't have somebody to kind of scale him back a bit and say, "That's really dumb!" What's funny is the issue that was printed in is the one where April's origin is explained. (I assume there are people here who haven't read Vol. 4 and don't know about these plot points, so I don't wanna spoil 'em for anyone, and expect others to do the same in this thread.) That whole story is...well, quite outrageously dumb, in my opinion. Laird, who has some interesting ideas but a lot of bad ones as well, is definitely someone whom I think needs to have someone near him to say, "That's really dumb!" Not like he would have listened. :p
Anyway, the Lucas–Laird connection gets stronger. In the letters column to issue 28, Laird was asked about Vol. 1 and 4 trade paperbacks, and Laird replies that he has plans to print such collections, but that they're coming along rather slowly because he's planning to rework the issues—redoing lettering and sound effects, rewriting some of it, adding new tones, doing all-new pages, eliminating other pages, etc. Thank goodness he never realized these ideas (aside from maybe the Lawson-drawn issue 8 recreation, which I'd love to read), because that would have been really dumb and frustrating, and totally reminds me of Lucas, who can't seem to quit bastardizing his films, adding new content and the like, making them into something other than what they originally were.
I guess there's not much to this post beyond, "Holy $#!7, Laird's ufckin' loony!" not being able to see that his ideas and attitude are/were similar to Lucas' lamebrained ideas. If the 2009 trade had been such a reworking, I'd have been pissed. :p Laird's relettering/retoning of issue 1, while interesting just because you get to see the ink work so cleanly, isn't very good or befitting of the original art and story. Kind of makes me wish Eastman had been the one to maintain control of the TMNT and continued to make comics... I always enjoy Eastman's urban/earth-grounded Turtles stories more. Though at the same time, without Laird, TMNT probably would have been a pretty filthy comic, ha ha, with tons of nudity and intense violence. Just a guess (based on a lot of Eastman's non-TMNT work).
Cowabunga Carl
01-24-2011, 10:58 PM
Yeah I had thought along the same lines as you when I read that issue. It is a very sad thing that sometimes those who create such a large peice of pop culture can't leave it alone.
However I can see their side of the coin to and it is something I don't think a lot of people think about. Both Laird and Lucas have said that they make the stories they want to see. That more or less they do them for themselves. I can respect that, more so in Laird, because the TMNT books really didn't make money towards the end.
Yet however you want to look at it, it really boils down have you enjoyed the good parts more then the bad parts have spoiled it for you? I know that for me there are parts of Vol 4 I am not a fan of but others that I have enjoyed. So yeah he is a crazy old man but my hat is off to him for doing this for 25 years.
CyberCubed
01-24-2011, 11:05 PM
Considering PL's plans to re-master all of Volume 1 never happened, I don't see why this is worth complaining about.
And obviously at this point it will never happen, so any fears are unfounded.
Cowabunga Carl
01-24-2011, 11:13 PM
I don't think anyone is complaining more just saying how it was funny that he was doing what Lucas did to his creation. Just talking about things we notice and things that have happened.
Abnormal Freak
01-24-2011, 11:17 PM
Oh, yeah, I enjoy Vol. 4—I probably wouldn't keep reading it and looking forward to each next issue if there weren't things I enjoy. He's totally free to create his own work and do things he wants to do—and he made it very clear in the letters columns plenty of times that he's doing it for himself more than anyone, and even mentioned that Mirage is losing money on each issue. I just don't like it when an artist feels a need to totally redo a previous work in a fashion that they would do now, simply because they feel the technical limitations or where they were in their life at the time are so different from how they are and would do things now.
I think a lot of people, myself included, wouldn't be so pissed at Lucas if he would simply offer the theatrical cuts of all his films in the highest quality possible (Blu-ray, finest restorations keeping the filmlike look of the films, keeping all mistakes and stuff intact, etc.), which he continues to deny his fans over BS claims that the original elements are damaged beyond repair (which is a total lie).
Sometimes artists get this crazy idea that because they wanna redo or tweak their works, solely for themselves, that the fans should be A-OK with it. I don't mind at all an artist revisiting a piece and redoing some things so long as they offer up at the same time the originals untouched, y'know? Like Ridley Scott with Blade Runner: the Blu-ray set contains all the cuts of the film looking brilliant, in addition to his Final Cut—and what I really appreciate about his Final Cut is that all of the tweaks and changes are actually befitting to the original work, and I actually prefer it to the other cuts.
Fans of an established work have just as much right to a film or comic or other art piece as the creator does, and I hate how egotistical artists can be at times with their "My way, or GTFO" attitude toward older works. That's why I would have been pissed if Laird's reworked TPBs would have come to fruition. Though if he had published the original works alongside that, that'd be just groovy—I'd even buy the reworked stuff just to see how it is. I may not necessarily like it, but I'd find it interesting, and would be happy to have the choice to choose what I, as a fan, please.
Now if only Lucas would put the theatrical versions of THX 1138 and the first three Star Wars films on Blu-ray... ;p And release American Graffiti with the original, non-CGI-background title screen.
And yeah, I'm not so much complaining (because obviously things didn't happen that way) as I am just amusing myself and wanting to voice my thoughts about these things, not just about Laird but artists in general. If I hadn't been able to get an original copy of The Killing Joke cheaply and easily, I might be pissed at the reworking of it. I like the reworked colors, though, even though I wish the scanning and decoloring of the original elements weren't so pixelated and crummy. :S Or maybe it's just due to how comics are printed these days. (I notice a digital/pixel appearance to a lot of the Mirage books from the last several years—it's worst in the Future Tense TPB.)
CyberCubed
01-24-2011, 11:17 PM
Its just his opinion. PL also hated the new Star Trek movie, and people gave him hell for it on his blog, which was stupid, because its his opinion.
PL doesn't have to like the Star Wars prequels ( a lot of people don't), but he didn't see what he was doing to TMNT was similar.
Abnormal Freak
01-24-2011, 11:27 PM
That's what's amusing. ;p And part of why I made this thread, ha ha.
Fugitoid Jones
01-25-2011, 02:54 AM
The thing that really grinds my gears is the reworking of someone elses' hard work. Take the special effects guys from the original Star Wars movies for example. Those poor guys put so much hard work and time and effort into making George's creatures and making the spaceships fly, and now George covers it up with CGI that will look dated in a year or two, if it doesn't look dated already, just because he has the technology now to add things in that he just thought of.
With Peter going back and redoing elements of vol. 1, he's not just messing around with his work, he's messing around with Kevin's, and that pisses me off. Kevin put alot of hard work and effort into those books too, and Peter wanting to redo them just because he can with today's technology or whatever, drives me nuts.
Abnormal Freak
01-25-2011, 03:02 AM
God looked down on us poor nerds and smiled, guaranteeing such a thing would never happen to us, ha ha.
Unless somehow Laird fully realizes the dream by sweetening up Viacom somehow and being able (and having the drive) to go ahead with the idea. D:
DrSpengler
01-25-2011, 06:22 AM
Keep reading the letters pages because I swear there was one where someone called Laird out on his hypocrisy for condemning Lucas's reworking of the original trilogy while simultaneously "special editioning" TMNT #1. Laird's response, as I recall, was a very unconvincing "No I'm not! AND STOP READING MY COMIC BOOK!"
Or maybe I'm just nuts. But I swear he actually addressed that in the letters page...
Abnormal Freak
01-25-2011, 06:51 AM
For the last seven or so issues, I skimmed the letters. :p Mostly just checking Laird's responses. Didn't see anything like that, but it could be in there.
In #28, I think it was, Laird basically mentioned mainly wanting to reletter and retone Vol. 1, not really overhauling some of the art and stories as he'd made it sound before, but doing tweaks here and there. His reasoning is he found the DuoShades tiresome and so he sought to "improve" the looks of the books by doing the toning he did in Vol. 4 and Vol. 1 #1 PBBZ edition. Eh... No, thanks. :p Again, awesome to see more clarity in the ink/line work, but the computer dot tones just didn't work for issue 1, and I love those old duo tones. They're just as vital to the art as the inks, I'd say.
Anyway... Having finished #31, I'm a little bummed that'll be the last Vol. 4 issue in a long while, perhaps the last issue ever. I can't imagine how frustrating it must have been for you guys reading it since the beginning. :p Waiting two months per issue, plus with three or four issues each being released a year apart from each other. Now, this: an end, because Laird doesn't want to do it anymore. That's a bit of a slap to the face... Hope he finishes writing it, and releases them all physically along with #31. And for cryin' out loud, since he takes so long on the tones and they don't look so hot anyway, just let Jim and Eric draw the comics on DuoShade boards and get the issues out quicker (well, as quick as Peter writes them).
CyberCubed
01-25-2011, 11:37 AM
Its actually been almost an entire decade since Vol. 4 starred.
The first issue came out in December 2001, when we hit Dec. 2011, it'll be a full 10 years.
I can't believe this comic started 10 years ago and still doesn't have a conclusion. I was only in Junior High School when Vol. 4 started!
John Pannozzi
01-25-2011, 02:18 PM
(I'm half-joking) So if Laird is the George Lucas of TMNT, then are Dan Berger and Lloyd Goldfine (and possibly Steve Murphy) the Paul Dini and Genndy Tartokovsky of TMNT? (see what I did there?)
twopinacoladas
01-25-2011, 03:46 PM
I didn't really like Aprils origin and thought it was a little hypocritical or ironic perhaps would be better phrasing that rant about Lucas in that issue. I enjoyed vol 4 while I read it I thought they could do without changing Aprils origin or creating one I guess.
Venom
01-25-2011, 04:42 PM
I've always thought of Lucas's decision to change some things with the original trilogy was - for better or worse - to be able to bring his original vision to the light of day. I remember back in the late '90's people who liked Star Wars were going ape over how awesome the CG effects looked and how much better the set peices were now that technology allowed for them to be filled with life rather than emptiness.
I've seen all 6 movies, still don't care for them, but I guess as someone who hasn't really invested himself in that particular franchise it's easier for me to accept the changes.
Peter, on the other hand, I felt just wanted to make the old books feel more professional rather than amateurish but forgetting that the amateur feel of the old books was part of their charm.
Venom
01-25-2011, 04:58 PM
I can't imagine how frustrating it must have been for you guys reading it since the beginning. :p Waiting two months per issue, plus with three or four issues each being released a year apart from each other. Now, this: an end, because Laird doesn't want to do it anymore. That's a bit of a slap to the face...
As someone who began with Volume 4 at number 1, I can honestly say that it wasn't frustrating for me. I always had Tales to read inbetween Vol. 4 issues, then when Peter put the series on hiatus, Tales went monthly. I was eager to find out what happened next, but understood the man had bigger things on his plate to take care of.
You know what, I almost hope Volume 4 doesn't see a conclusion. Know why? Because seeing another Splinter peering out across the landscape remarking about Leonardo will always make us devoted fans wonder where it would have went; and ultimately the series didn't truly end on a note of "life at best is bittersweet" because we know that all four Turtles are alive and well, have adjusted to each of their unique situations, and have many, many more adventures ahead of them in the future when the one we left them on finishes.
CyberCubed
01-25-2011, 05:09 PM
You know what, I almost hope Volume 4 doesn't see a conclusion. Know why? Because seeing another Splinter peering out across the landscape remarking about Leonardo will always make us devoted fans wonder where it would have went; and ultimately the series didn't truly end on a note of "life at best is bittersweet" because we know that all four Turtles are alive and well, have adjusted to each of their unique situations, and have many, many more adventures ahead of them in the future when the one we left them on finishes.
On the other hand we could get proper closure to Vol. 4's stories AND still know the Turtles live to old age and then die. ;)
Abnormal Freak
01-26-2011, 02:44 AM
If it weren't for Viacom's "no books/trades larger than 60-some pages" condition (which means there'll never be any trades from Mirage, 'cos a lot of issues are 40-plus pages apiece), it'd be neat if Laird and co. just worked on it at a pretty steady pace (again, letting Lawson and/or Talbot take care of the tones, preferably on DuoShade board) and release the remainder of Vol. 4 in a graphic novel format, including issue 31. Would be cool, I think.
But that's only if, of course, Laird gives enough of a crap to ever write any more. I'd like to see the series concluded.
(I'm half-joking) So if Laird is the George Lucas of TMNT, then are Dan Berger and Lloyd Goldfine (and possibly Steve Murphy) the Paul Dini and Genndy Tartokovsky of TMNT? (see what I did there?) So what is Kevin Eastman the Gary Kurtz of TMNT?
John Pannozzi
01-26-2011, 10:55 PM
So what is Kevin Eastman the Gary Kurtz of TMNT?
With all his attempts to remake The Melting Pot, I'd say Eastman is the Korean entertainment industry of TMNT! ('cause someone once told that the Koreans are perfectionists when it comes to remaking their intellectual properties, like with the remake of Yonggary.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.