PDA

View Full Version : Do you ever wonder if early TMNT fans from the 80's kept with the comics?


CyberCubed
02-08-2011, 12:01 PM
Most of us were in diapers or were little kids (and some not even born yet) when the Mirage comics came out in 1984. I am reading through the letters section of all those early comics, and it got me to realize:

What happened to all those early TMNT fans? These were all fans of the comic before there was any cartoon/movies/toys, etc. as to what TMNT would be known for.

Were those hardcore comic fans that just purchased the early issues of TMNT, and just dropped it afterward? Do you ever wonder what happened to those very first TMNT fans from 1984-1987?

DrSpengler
02-08-2011, 12:07 PM
That is a good question.

The best answer I can imagine is that, well, they grew up. They probably got married, had kids and moved on.

That isn't to say *everyone* who likes a property discards it after marrying and having kids, but that major life changes such as that tend to be a factor in what hobbys people continue to pursue.

I also imagine the Fred Wolf cartoon and the sudden change the TMNT took into being a children's property, combined with the Mirage comic's shift toward zany guest issues, likely killed a large chunk of their audience who viewed Eastman and Laird as "sell outs" or what have you.

I'm sure some of them are still around, but even back in 84-87, the TMNT comic had only a modest audience, and once you factor in the various causes that would shed members of the audience, I imagine scarcely a handful would remain 25 years later.

Sword Slicin' Leo
02-08-2011, 12:20 PM
No, and the reason why is simple..I like TMNT for me, i don't care if anybody else likes it, if i am the last TMNT fan in the world then so be it.. while my freinds got outta TMNT and got more into WWF,XMen Transformers,Power Rangers, the Turtles were still it for me, while saying that, the more people that like TMNT is infact better for us on a marketing scale,it really does'nt matter its all about TURTLE POWER!!!

Powder
02-08-2011, 12:42 PM
You've thoroughly confused me.

Sword Slicin' Leo
02-08-2011, 01:01 PM
What i am saying is i don;t care if they're are more TMNT fans,because it does not matter to me,i like thme no matter what, but at the same time, themore fans there are,the more products will be produced...So to a point i am conflicted.

cartoonistaaron
02-08-2011, 06:12 PM
My dad and a friend of his bought the first couple issues. I was 5 so it was a little over my head. Dad didn't follow it for long but his friend did, at least up until the first movie came out... then I think he sold everything.

I remember because my Dad and I thought you'd have to be insane to pay a hundred bucks for the first issue!!!

Jephael
02-09-2011, 06:45 PM
What i am saying is i don;t care if they're are more TMNT fans,because it does not matter to me,i like thme no matter what, but at the same time, themore fans there are,the more products will be produced...So to a point i am conflicted.

I'm guessing you were drunk when you posted this.

Sword Slicin' Leo
02-10-2011, 10:38 AM
I'm guessing you were drunk when you posted this.

I like how some people get behind the computer with their little smart comments like that think they are all big and bad, but in real would say **** face to face..

Sword Slicin' Leo
02-10-2011, 10:38 AM
I'm guessing you were drunk when you posted this.

I like how some people get behind the computer with their little smart comments like that think they are all big and bad, but in real would'nt say anything face to face..

Venom
02-10-2011, 11:46 AM
I like how some people get livid about things and double post. :P Anyway, I think it was his general assessment based on your bad punctuation, careless typing, and somewhat incoherent statement. It reads as if you were very tired or otherwise influenced when you posted.

Coola Yagami
02-10-2011, 12:29 PM
How long were the comics around before the cartoon started? I don't think there was too big a gap for them to have 'grown out of it'. I think the original poster was asking how the comic fans felt when they first found out a cartoon was in the works and it turned out to be very different with all new characters and such.

Sword Slicin' Leo
02-10-2011, 12:33 PM
I like how some people get livid about things and double post. :P Anyway, I think it was his general assessment based on your bad punctuation, careless typing, and somewhat incoherent statement. It reads as if you were very tired or otherwise influenced when you posted.

to be honest i am at work,so i was typing fast...and as i read what i wrote it's sloppy as hell, but i dont like how people act on here sometimes..

Powder
02-10-2011, 01:40 PM
to be honest i am at work,so i was typing fast...and as i read what i wrote it's sloppy as hell, but i dont like how people act on here sometimes..

You yourself come off as tense sometimes man. We all have our moments. Tis a board of drama.

Sword Slicin' Leo
02-10-2011, 01:52 PM
Yeah, i know..and i am really not sure why..In life and one of the most nicest,relaxed laid back people u would ever meet...I guess sometimes things just come out wrong, and as you can tell i usually do not proofread what i write..

wilddiverse
02-10-2011, 02:06 PM
Have you considered proofreading what you write? I find it helps immensely in getting one's point across as intended.

Sword Slicin' Leo
02-10-2011, 02:18 PM
Sometimes i do..sometimes i just get in a hurry...if it makes u guys happy i will LOL!

Jephael
02-10-2011, 03:43 PM
The reason I made that comment was you seemed to not even care about what the thread's original subject was and saw it as an opportunity to boast about yourself and in a really absurd way.

DrVenkman
02-11-2011, 10:30 AM
Most of us were in diapers or were little kids (and some not even born yet) when the Mirage comics came out in 1984. I am reading through the letters section of all those early comics, and it got me to realize:

What happened to all those early TMNT fans? These were all fans of the comic before there was any cartoon/movies/toys, etc. as to what TMNT would be known for.

Were those hardcore comic fans that just purchased the early issues of TMNT, and just dropped it afterward? Do you ever wonder what happened to those very first TMNT fans from 1984-1987?

I've had this conversation with Comic dealers and fans alike.

Here are some factors to it all,

Before "Return To New York" you will see a lot of fan letters in the books that showed their dislike for the story line TMNT took on.

Fans were also lost when the cartoon came out. Deemed as "kiddy" and "selling out" to what TMNT was.

Fans also came to the comic due to the cartoon. At the same time, the Archie series took away some of that thunder.

The hype of the first movie caused a lot of people to sell their collection at the time.

I'd say the original fans are far a few. At least when it comes to holding onto their collection.

A friend of mine's older brother was one of those old enough at the time to be into the comics. He still thinks he has a bunch of them somewhere, but no idea. But he too felt they sold out and stopped collecting when the cartoon came out. His younger brother and I were big fans of the cartoon being 5 years younger than him, and if not for him we wouldn't even know it was a comic at such a young age.

sdp
02-11-2011, 02:27 PM
The reasons posted here make sense, funny how while none/extremely few of real original fans exist they were the ones who made TMNT popular enough for the rest of us who are here still today. I think another reason is a lot of them may also have just been comic fans in general and they're still reading comics but they weren't exclusive fans to the TMNT though, that was just a good book for that time so they read it and liked when it came out but didn't become say "turtle-maniacs" or whatever you want to call it, only kids at the time who grew up with the cartoon did which is why the fandom mostly consists of those people..

gobo
02-11-2011, 03:09 PM
Do you ever wonder if early TMNT fans from the 80's kept with the comics?
I'm sure some were put off by the international phenomenon of kiddy proportions the brand became, to the point that they were embarassed to even look in the direction of a TMNT comic. Others might have been put off by how Vol. 1 started having so many out-of-continuity stories. After all the other possible reasons, I imagine a small percentage of fans from the early '80s stayed with it for the long haul. Others may have rediscovered it after losing interest for a while, but I'd be surprised if most of the readers of TMNT comics today were with it from the beginning.

Coola Yagami
02-11-2011, 07:11 PM
yeah... exactly why did Pete and Kev suddenly decide 'the hell with it' and just any body draw whatever wacky story they wanted with the TMNT? What made them suddenly go back to City at War and going back to continuity?

DrSpengler
02-11-2011, 08:03 PM
yeah... exactly why did Pete and Kev suddenly decide 'the hell with it' and just any body draw whatever wacky story they wanted with the TMNT? What made them suddenly go back to City at War and going back to continuity?

I think the likeliest explanation is that they were just too busy running the Turtle franchise, which had just about reached its cross-media peak at the time and was probably a total handful between movies, toys, cartoons and other global merchandising.

So by turning the Mirage comic into a guest-creator "anthology" with no direction or, well, editorial processing, it was just one less thing for them to pay attention to.

The tone of the editorial letter published at the beginning of TMNT #45 seemed to convey tat they regreted the whole thing, or at least understood that readers were very displeased with it, and conceded to return focus to the comic.

CyberCubed
02-11-2011, 11:26 PM
Keep in mind only one new issue came out every month or two, so waiting that long just see another one-shot filler story felt like the TMNT comics were just going nowhere at the time.

Venom
02-12-2011, 12:52 PM
Every month or two? Holy jeez dude, the release was all over the place back then! They tried to put out 6 issues a year, but sometimes it would be 3 months, then 5 months, then 3 again, or a couple of times a book was printed before the preceding number was released.

Compound all of that together, along with the revolving door or guests, and it becomes easy to see why people fell away from the comics.

wilddiverse
02-12-2011, 01:38 PM
I pity the fool who bought the waste of paper that was Hedden/McWeeney's #38-40 new off the racks.

I self-pity the fool.

gobo
02-12-2011, 03:42 PM
I self-pity the fool.
Me too. :ohwell: Being my first Mirage books, this gave the whole run a bad name for me.

CyberCubed
02-13-2011, 12:44 AM
Every month or two? Holy jeez dude, the release was all over the place back then! They tried to put out 6 issues a year, but sometimes it would be 3 months, then 5 months, then 3 again, or a couple of times a book was printed before the preceding number was released.

Compound all of that together, along with the revolving door or guests, and it becomes easy to see why people fell away from the comics.

You mean like how Volume 4 was for us now, only with more filler and wacky stories. :p

Jester
02-13-2011, 01:13 AM
Part of me wonders how many of them realized past TMNT 1 there was gonna be an ongoing series. TMNT 1 is pretty cut and dried, 3 acts and over. But I agree with the idea of people falling off over the "selling out" or even growing out of TMNT. I remember just giving my Mighty Morphin' Power Ranger role playing toys to neighbor kids when I got old enough, because it wasn't cool for a kid my age to like them.

DK2
02-22-2011, 07:06 PM
Yeah I got involved with the Mirage TMNT right just before they became the huge mass media/merchandise success in like spring '87. Got exposed to it when I was in Grade 6. I think they were if not, my first exposure to an indie comic beyond DC and Marvel. It was TMNT #4 2nd print, TMNT #10 and Tales of TMNT #1. Its funny that Tales was suppose to be the filler gap for TMNT comics and it was to fill the void when the core series was in its off months. Yet it too became a delay hazard and ended so fast after 7 issues. I stopped buying TMNT comics after issue #28 (#27 was the best single issue story for me). It just became not as fun somewhat. I expected Eastman & Laird to be back on it and yet all they could do was #19-21 RTNY arc. Cause they said the readers demanded they come back together. Although at that point they'd done solo issues practically up to #18 (bar #13 and #16). Yet I remember we talk about the delays/2 month schedule of the TMNT comic right after RTNY we got 2 issues the same week #22-23 (Martins stuff)! It was like what the hell is this?! My brothers friend and myself were both aghast as these covers alone told us this is TMNT after the kick ass RTNY?! Then the series became that revolving door of guest creators. I didn't come back til #48 when i'd seen the semi hype for issue #50 that Kevin and Peter were gonna be back. An interview from them said that they wanted to get the title back on track, #48 would be the starting point. I bought the rest of the series years later at dollar boxes.
Mirages Vol. 2 could've been better, Images run I had to decide if I really wanted it as Mirage wasn't doing it. But I'm glad I did buy them as they were the best stories compared to the surrounding Mirage runs. Vol. 4 ain't so bad but like Vol. 2 certainly could've used Vol. 3 's action and pacing. I just find it ironic that the TMNT comics were so low key in story for action. This is NINJA TURTLES!. Why was it always like that from then on on the Mirage efforts? Tales Vol. 2 wasn't so bad most times, it tried to fit untold stories moreso than the rotating guests on Vol. 1's run at least. So in answer to the thread topic I'm one of the few who've stuck out with the TMNT comics among the '80's Mirage TMNT comic readers.