View Full Version : Motion to retroactively retitle TMNT 4
Andrew NDB
03-21-2011, 06:23 PM
Who's with me? Let's hit the polls.
discordiatookie
03-21-2011, 06:29 PM
First to vote! I went with no, I rather like they designs. :P
Spitfire
03-21-2011, 06:29 PM
Can we also destroy every copy of the 3rd movie while we're at it?
Jephael
03-21-2011, 06:49 PM
Good lord, do we really need another thread where we bash the movies?!
I realize this topic is for fun but I really like the designs so I can't vote for yes. Also it is not TMNT 4 ;)
Jephael
03-21-2011, 06:51 PM
I'll admit I went off on Kevin Munroe's writing, but atleast he made a reasonable attempt at a Ninja Turtle movie.
the problem with the movie for me is there was way too much stuff happening, what was the point of having 13 monsters if they were just kinda there and never really used to their full extent. The foot cool but they really served no purpose and the generals would have been cool but since they had to share time with the other things that weren't given important roles anyways they barely had anything to do, not to mention Raph/Leo taking most of the screen time, which is fine since that was the best part of the movie but why make the plot so complicated if the main thing was going to be that?
Also for the "return of the turtles" we wanted something big, and most of us wanted to see Shredder again and that wasn't delivered and we get some mystical villain instead, I realize magic and mystical stuff has always existed in TMNT lore but it wasn't appropriate for their first return to the big screen, especially with the convoluted plots mentioned above. Heck I think the 13 monsters and the Generals could have been a much more interesting story if it was say a 13 episode arc and we get to slowly flesh out everything and see each monster etc. The fact that Munroe hyped the hell out of the movie in the forums and the forums were filled with hype as well it made it especially tough to live up to that with an average movie. I still liked it and would have wanted to see more stories from that universe.
Master Splinter
03-21-2011, 07:29 PM
the problem with the movie for me is there was way too much stuff happening, what was the point of having 13 monsters if they were just kinda there and never really used to their full extent. The foot cool but they really served no purpose and the generals would have been cool but since they had to share time with the other things that weren't given important roles anyways they barely had anything to do, not to mention Raph/Leo taking most of the screen time, which is fine since that was the best part of the movie but why make the plot so complicated if the main thing was going to be that?
Also for the "return of the turtles" we wanted something big, and most of us wanted to see Shredder again and that wasn't delivered and we get some mystical villain instead, I realize magic and mystical stuff has always existed in TMNT lore but it wasn't appropriate for their first return to the big screen, especially with the convoluted plots mentioned above. Heck I think the 13 monsters and the Generals could have been a much more interesting story if it was say a 13 episode arc and we get to slowly flesh out everything and see each monster etc. The fact that Munroe hyped the hell out of the movie in the forums and the forums were filled with hype as well it made it especially tough to live up to that with an average movie. I still liked it and would have wanted to see more stories from that universe.
I agree with this but to put it simply, the movie should have been longer.
-ms
CyberCubed
03-21-2011, 07:48 PM
How exactly did the frog comparison start? Is it because they leap from buildings?
I think it's cuz Mikey wets his shell as a defense mechanism.
FearlessLeader
03-21-2011, 08:31 PM
I voted no.
I liked the film and I actually liked the character designs.
I do think the entire film comes off more as a plot line to a random throw away issue of the Tales series and I do think something with a known villain would have been better.
But I still like this loads better then the 3rd film. At least it has re-watch value if you ignore the fairly annoying soundtrack!
plastroncafe
03-21-2011, 08:34 PM
I won't deny that the movie had problems, but animation wasn't one of them.
I loved the designs to death, and I could watch this movie just for how beautifully made it was.
Newton Gimmick
03-21-2011, 09:21 PM
I actually quite liked this movie, despite it's flaws. Never really got a lot of the designs hate.
DrSpengler
03-21-2011, 09:50 PM
I thought it was an okay episode of the 4Kids series.
Wait... it was a full length feature film!?
Oh my.
oldmanwinters
03-21-2011, 10:00 PM
I thought it was an okay episode of the 4Kids series.
Wait... it was a full length feature film!?
Oh my.
lol, that is more true than one might think. Nevertheless, at least one scene did have the honor of making your "25 Greatest Moments in TMNT history."
Anyway, I like the film.
The AVGN nerd liked it too, and he pretty much hates everything, right?:lol:
DrSpengler
03-21-2011, 10:24 PM
All joking aside, I liked the production values and animation quality of the film and I DID love that fight between Leo and Raph...
But that isn't enough to make it a good movie, in my eyes. Not as bad as TMNT II or III, but still bad its own unique way.
Again, it would've made a fine episode of the 4Kids series, but not a feature film.
deadpoolRKO
03-22-2011, 07:20 AM
I loved the designs to death, and I could watch this movie just for how beautifully made it was.
i second this.
Me too I liked the designs as well
Candy Kappa
03-22-2011, 08:27 AM
The designs are very good, great for agile action scenes. But, for me it's the story that fall short. Besides for the Raph vs. Leo fight, the fight scenes wasn't well filmed sadly.
Donnie
03-22-2011, 09:08 AM
I really like TMNT, it's my second favorite movie after the first film. It's edgy and I personally really like the plot. I agree with some that it should have been longer, and I was disappointed that we saw absolutely no pivotal fighting from Donatello or Mikey. Besides that though, I thought it was great. I also liked the character development...well, besides Mikey.
Andrew NDB
03-22-2011, 12:01 PM
It's edgy
Only if you compare it to the second two. Sort of. But that's just comparing dog sh** to cat sh**.
I was disappointed that we saw absolutely no pivotal fighting from Donatello or Mikey
We actually didn't see any fighting from Mikey from all, period. He didn't use his weapons once in the whole film.
Andrew NDB
03-22-2011, 12:04 PM
Me too I liked the designs as well
To blanketly say, "The designs were great" would mean one would need to be OK with the design of Michelangelo and all the humans that either look like relatives of Inspector Gadget or Elmer Fudd... and that would be very, very stupid, IMHO.
FearlessLeader
03-22-2011, 12:15 PM
To blanketly say, "The designs were great" would mean one would need to be OK with the design of Michelangelo and all the humans that either look like relatives of Inspector Gadget or Elmer Fudd... and that would be very, very stupid, IMHO.
Well you have to admit from the title of your poll, it seems like the topic was solely the way the Turtles looked and not any of other characters and that seems to be all anyone else is focusing on.
Other then that, I think we will all have to agree to just disagree with you. Obviously you hate the film, that is your choice. I hate Next Mutation but don't really feel the need to start threads to justify that hatred to myself.
We will enjoy movie 4 for our reasons and you can hate it for yours and everything will continue to be as right as the world can be :tgrin:
I mean't I liked the designs of the turtles except Michelangelo. So I was focusing on the designs of the turtles
plastroncafe
03-22-2011, 03:30 PM
To blanketly say, "The designs were great" would mean one would need to be OK with the design of Michelangelo and all the humans that either look like relatives of Inspector Gadget or Elmer Fudd... and that would be very, very stupid, IMHO.
Consider me on the stupid side of the equation, because I'm okay with Michaelangelo's design, and prefer my cgi humans to look highly stylized rather than attempt to jump the uncanny valley. I'd rather them look like cartoon characters and not distract me with Final Fantasy/Cut Scene realism.
Andrew NDB
03-22-2011, 03:39 PM
Consider me on the stupid side of the equation, because I'm okay with Michaelangelo's design, and prefer my cgi humans to look highly stylized rather than attempt to jump the uncanny valley. I'd rather them look like cartoon characters and not distract me with Final Fantasy/Cut Scene realism.
One man's meat is another man's garbage and all that. :)
twopinacoladas
03-22-2011, 03:52 PM
I honestly didn't really enjoy the 4th movie and left feeling underwhelmed by it. The character models (turtles anyway) were good imo. They could have done them to look like the first or second movie which could be cool to see but I don't think they looked like frogs.
Had the story not been about stone warriors and what not I probably would have liked it more. It didn't really feel like a Ninja Turtles movie that much I couldn't help get a bit of a Ghostbusters vibe with the portal and what not. I agree it could have been longer.
The movie wasn't terrible tho, I did like what they did with the turtles just not the overall story, it also didn't help that I think there was video or images from almost every scene so there were no surprises during the film.
The Shelf
03-25-2011, 08:54 PM
Who's with me? Let's hit the polls.
LOL, Andrew, you're awesome! :tgrin:
Yes, it should! 1 4.00%
No, it shouldn't. 24 96.00%
EDIT: Just noticed it was actually Spitfire who voted 'yes', but still funny nonetheless.
ToTheNines
05-30-2011, 10:41 PM
We actually didn't see any fighting from Mikey from all, period. He didn't use his weapons once in the whole film.
Even though I loved it when it came out, I dislike this movie about as much as you now. However, you're wrong on this one.
He uses them on two different occasions during the Foot brawl, and I believe in one other fight.
Djwz9ieByw0
First whack is clear as day, the second usage is at the end (on the far right and you have to watch closely).
I quite liked the movie, although with the plot the way it was I think it should've been longer, it felt too short and like it was lacking something. The animation was good also, but I'll admit they did kinda remind me frogs....but i think it was just the shape of their legs and the way they jumped from building to building *shrugs*.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.