View Full Version : Idw have tmnt!
Kendamu
04-05-2011, 12:21 AM
No, I'm acting like Pete wanted to wash his hands of the Turtles (for the most part) and move on with his life. That seems to be exactly what he's doing. Whether it's 10 minutes or 10 years doesn't matter.
I don't even see what the argument is. If he does more, cool. I don't expect it, though.
AquaParade
04-05-2011, 12:30 AM
Writer Gail Simone (Birds of Prey, Secret Six, The Simpsons, Wonder Woman) posted on her message board the other day:
Re: The Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Have Come To IDW!!!!
I was asked to write this, actually, or some of it. Kinda sad it didn't work out, love the Turtles and love IDW!
(source: http://www.606studios.com/bendisboard/showthread.php?205980-The-Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-Have-Come-To-IDW!!!!)
I'm kind of bummed that this didn't happen. I love her writing like that proverbial overweight kid who has romantic feelings for baked goods.
Still pretty freaking geeked about everything else that's happening, though! :D
This is very interesting. Has anyone read her work? May give us an idea of the type of tone IDW is headed for.
Jester
04-05-2011, 12:32 AM
She's a well like writer...but I've never read any of her stuff. I've heard she's quite good and very competent.
Abnormal Freak
04-05-2011, 01:14 AM
I'm happy IDW has the TMNT and we'll see TMNT stuff in bookstores. I don't mind a new comic start and hope their reprint plans are aggressive. Just avoid the sad cartoony Mirage fill ins stuff.
What stuff would that be? I adored nearly all the Mirage Vol. 1 stuff and would like all that to be collected in trades; only stuff I hate are the Hedden and McWeeney issues. Bad beyond bad. Everything else is pretty dang cool, and a lot of those issues I like far more than some of the Eastman and Laird collaborations.
I don't really see Peter and Kevin working together again. Hasn't Peter said on a number of occasions that he likes the freedom of working alone? Reading his thoughts on writing solo, going at his own pace, and not having to compromise like with the Eastman collaborations, it came across to me like the guy just didn't wanna do anything unless it were his own way. So, even if he were to ever do any more TMNT stories, I don't see him collaborating with anybody.
Andrew NDB
04-05-2011, 01:54 AM
Gail Simone? Are you kidding? She is amazing. Secret Six is the best mainstream comic being published today, and it's gritty and bloody as all hell.
AquaParade
04-05-2011, 02:01 AM
Gail Simone? Are you kidding? She is amazing. Secret Six is the best mainstream comic being published today, and it's gritty and bloody as all hell.
Damn. Well a shame she wont be taking part at this point, but good that IDW is taking this seriously. I wasn't aware of Secret Six. I may check that out.
DrSpengler
04-05-2011, 08:37 AM
Writer Gail Simone (Birds of Prey, Secret Six, The Simpsons, Wonder Woman) posted on her message board the other day:
Re: The Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Have Come To IDW!!!!
I was asked to write this, actually, or some of it. Kinda sad it didn't work out, love the Turtles and love IDW!
(source: http://www.606studios.com/bendisboard/showthread.php?205980-The-Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-Have-Come-To-IDW!!!!)
I'm kind of bummed that this didn't happen. I love her writing like that proverbial overweight kid who has romantic feelings for baked goods.
Still pretty freaking geeked about everything else that's happening, though! :D
Though it's a bummer they couldn't get her onboard (I've enjoyed quite a bit of her stuff and she's EXCELLENT at fusing action and comedy), it is reassuring to know IDW is taking the brand seriously enough to approach some high profile and highly respected talent.
Just... keep Grant Morrisson out of it, please. ;)
AquaParade
04-05-2011, 09:44 AM
Just... keep Grant Morrisson out of it, please. ;)
Not a Grant Morrisson fan? I thought some of his work on "Batman and Robin" was pretty good. I kinda like his style.
CyberCubed
04-05-2011, 09:59 AM
How much do IDW comics generally cost? About $3.25 per issue?
xZAOx
04-05-2011, 01:25 PM
Not a Grant Morrisson fan? I thought some of his work on "Batman and Robin" was pretty good. I kinda like his style.
I agree - he's done some great stuff on Batman. I love how much attention he pays to continuity, the way he builds stuff up, the way it all ties together, and how he likes to continue long-forgotten storylines.
DrSpengler
04-05-2011, 02:09 PM
My comment was more tongue in cheek (hence the wink), but not to derail the thread...
I have a love/hate opinion of Morisson. He's a "high concept" writer, but often let's those concepts get away from him, resulting a lot of incoherency masked as "sophistication", which I find a rather disingenuous and insulting tactic. I think his run on JLA was especially guilty of this, whereas his lengthier arcs tended to get out of hand.
I've enjoyed his work on Batman and his "everything counts" approach, even though I don't quite consider it the end-all be-all ultimate run of Batman ever penned; and many of the more celebrated arcs from his run I found a tad overrated (RIP) or just plain bad (Batman & Robin Vol. 1).
He's a good writer, but not when he let's his own stereotypes get out of hand (Frank Miller is similar in that regard).
But yeah, sorry, this isn't a thread for this topic. My bad.
azrael
04-05-2011, 02:24 PM
I loved morrison's run up until the last 2 pages of batman and robin 16.
Well what I want from idw I would like red bandanas, but i think thats going to be a "mirage" thing. I would like to see them have a shade of green that represents the turtle's attitude.
All I expect to get from IDW will be some bad ass stories everything else I really dont care about. I mean look at all the different versions there are? Winter's arc on the tmnt is one of my favorites, even though its completely different than what we have had in vol 1. Imagine reading tmnt vol 1 and then the release of the cartoon talk about 2 different worlds.
Kendamu
04-05-2011, 02:25 PM
Man, I suck at being a fan. I like Batman & Robin Vol. 1!
Bjarni
04-05-2011, 02:57 PM
Talking about writers, I would love to see someone like Scott Lobdell or Chris Claremont. I just remember loving their X-books and how sad I was when they were just shoved aside, ironically for Grant Morrison to become the main X-guy.
I've heard that their recent stories haven't been good, but I think it has more to do with editorial aspects. Last time I checked they know how to write some very good character development and good pacing on the stories they do.
If I would have to pick someone from the vast universe of comic book writers, it would be them, I would love to see their take on the Turtles.
I would also have loved to see Gail Simone or Grant Morrison (even though I doubt he would ever do TMNT, though his "everything is cannon" approach would be really welcomed after Peter's "these events never happened").
Talking about writers, I would love to see someone like Scott Lobdell or Chris Claremont. I just remember loving their X-books and how sad I was when they were just shoved aside, ironically for Grant Morrison to become the main X-guy.
I've heard that their recent stories haven't been good, but I think it has more to do with editorial aspects. Last time I checked they know how to write some very good character development and good pacing on the stories they do.
If I would have to pick someone from the vast universe of comic book writers, it would be them, I would love to see their take on the Turtles.
I would also have loved to see Gail Simone or Grant Morrison (even though I doubt he would ever do TMNT, though his "everything is cannon" approach would be really welcomed after Peter's "these events never happened").
Agreed with everything you said
Jester
04-05-2011, 11:33 PM
He's a good writer, but not when he let's his own stereotypes get out of hand (Frank Miller is similar in that regard).
Is it sad when I read that I thought, "Yeah, Frank Miller. HE should write TMNT. Talk about irony."?
What stuff would that be? I adored nearly all the Mirage Vol. 1 stuff and would like all that to be collected in trades; only stuff I hate are the Hedden and McWeeney issues. Bad beyond bad. Everything else is pretty dang cool, and a lot of those issues I like far more than some of the Eastman and Laird collaborations.
I don't really see Peter and Kevin working together again. Hasn't Peter said on a number of occasions that he likes the freedom of working alone? Reading his thoughts on writing solo, going at his own pace, and not having to compromise like with the Eastman collaborations, it came across to me like the guy just didn't wanna do anything unless it were his own way. So, even if he were to ever do any more TMNT stories, I don't see him collaborating with anybody.
Thats pretty much the stuff there I was referring to and the Mark Martin stuff. I don't know but to me if ur gonna reprint Mirage TMNT comics keep only the ones that fit into continuity or are of a consistant flow in the main narrative. Altho some of the stuff ain't so bad either like Vol. 1 #27 and #45. The Rick Veitch stuff and Mike Zulli stuff should again just get their own books as a creator visonary. I've said it before but just keep Vol.1 #1-11 + TMNT solo's, Fugitoid, RTNY (maybe add Tales V2 #70), CAW, Vol. 2-4, Tales Vol. 1 stuff, short stories. IDW can do whatever they want and Images Vol. 3 run can easily be reprinted as well. Vol. 4 too but to have no conclusion maybe off for them unless they ask Peter to do it or let them finish it off. Maybe if they offer him "we'll print it you just make it with Jim", he may have less worries on the releasing and printing end he may be more willing. Because this means he doesn't have to worry about those other things and Mirage doesn't need to be revived for a moment just to finish Vol. 4, if ever.
I don't think IDW should reprint the whole Vol.1 like they have with GI Joe and Transformers in those 12+ issues trades/HC's. U just don't want to sour the book stores with stuff that changes the identity of the TMNT's old history. Putting out the crappy stuff wouldn't help the image if a potential new reader ever saw the bad stuff. Perception is just ruined, just my opinion. Remember IDW wants to sell these not find out the odd book had hideous sales. I think their in it for the long run and can every few years rerelease these books to new readers/generations down the line. TMNT is just generational as the two runs of multi media/merchandise success has shown.
CyberCubed
04-05-2011, 11:44 PM
They should re-print all of Vol. 1, including all the wacky guest writer issues. Sure, they may not be canon, but who cares? Otherwise we'd miss out on stuff like, "The River" if they only print core issues.
Let them reprint everything. No harm done.
Roseangelo
04-05-2011, 11:54 PM
IDW's initial interest is most definitely just in reprinting "Eastman & Laird" stories.
TurtleGuy
04-06-2011, 12:04 AM
Since IDW has been working with Archie comics to release Archie Collections, maybe there's a chance that IDW could reprint TMNT Adventures sometime in the future.
Even if they don't, I'm pretty stoked about the turtles returning in comic book form anyway, and this summer to boot.
Roseangelo
04-06-2011, 12:05 AM
Since IDW has been working with Archie comics to release Archie Collections, maybe there's a chance that IDW could reprint TMNT Adventures sometime in the future.
Even if they don't, I'm pretty stoked about the turtles returning in comic book form anyway, and this summer to boot.
The possibility is on the table.
http://ninja-pizza.blogspot.com/2011/04/more-details-on-idws-comic-book-plans.html
CyberCubed
04-06-2011, 12:06 AM
IDW's initial interest is most definitely just in reprinting "Eastman & Laird" stories.
So then any Jim Lawson or Dan Berger story is out? This is why they should just re-print in consecutive order.
I can see it now, IDW is already going to screw up these trades by omitting issues.
Roseangelo
04-06-2011, 12:08 AM
So then any Jim Lawson or Dan Berger story is out? This is why they should just re-print in consecutive order.
I can see it now, IDW is already going to screw up these trades by omitting issues.
They're not necessarily out, they just won't be first.
Again... weighing my options of ignoring you and punching you in the face.
CyberCubed
04-06-2011, 12:10 AM
After #1-11, we can imagine #12-20 next skipping #16 as that was Mark Martin, then RTNY...and from there what on?
I don't mind them jumping around, like say skipping ahead to do a City at War collection immediately after #1-11 is fine, so long as they go back and collect what they skipped.
Abnormal Freak
04-06-2011, 12:30 AM
I love the Mark Martin issues. ;) But I can certainly understand keeping a continuity thing going with just the issues Eastman and Laird had a hand in. Maybe after that's done and the trades sell well, they could release the other issues in unnumbered trades. I'd love to have a book containing all of Rick Veitch's stuff, and have all the other issues collected as well since I love practically all of 'em—again, only excluding the Hedden/McWeeney issues, which...good Lord, why did Mirage ever give those the go-ahead??? Kevin seemed to praise the two authors in one or the more of the intros, so after I read 'em, all I could think was, "WHAAAAAAA'?"
TheShowstoppa
04-06-2011, 12:40 AM
I've been needing to finish my Tales Vol. 2 collection. Guess I have 2 comics to surge through a month now until I finish getting them all. Love this news and I'm greatly looking forward to sharing these with my daughter when she's finally old enough to understand where Daddy's obsession came from. :-)
So then any Jim Lawson or Dan Berger story is out? This is why they should just re-print in consecutive order.
I can see it now, IDW is already going to screw up these trades by omitting issues.
I don't mind them jumping around, like say skipping ahead to do a City at War collection immediately after #1-11 is fine, so long as they go back and collect what they skipped.
It's a little early to be getting so worked up over what may or may not happen based on the little information that IDW has made available.
Powder
04-06-2011, 01:02 AM
It's a little early to be getting so worked up over what may or may not happen based on the little information that IDW has made available.
& these words are proof of how little you're here.
Hahaha, that is how Cybercubed has always been, and will always continue to be. It's... something.
& these words are proof of how little you're here.
Hahaha, that is how Cybercubed has always been, and will always continue to be. It's... something.
What can I say? I had to take a shot at it.
Andrew NDB
04-06-2011, 01:54 AM
After #1-11, we can imagine #12-20 next skipping #16 as that was Mark Martin, then RTNY...and from there what on?
I don't mind them jumping around, like say skipping ahead to do a City at War collection immediately after #1-11 is fine, so long as they go back and collect what they skipped.
If it was me,
Book 1: #1-11, plus micros.
Book 2: #12-17, 19-26.
Book 3: #27-30, 33, 37 (preceded by Turtle Soup precursor story), 42 - 47.
Book 4: #48-62.
Book 5: Vol. 2 #1-13.
Book 6: Vol. 3, #1-23 (keep in mind these are significantly shorter than your average Mirage issue)
Various backups and other Turtle Soup/Plastron Cafe/etc. material sprinkled throughout where appropriate. Tales of the TMNT Vol. 1 and Vol. 2 worked in there too, if possible, or kind of made into its own thing.
Bjarni
04-06-2011, 05:16 AM
I wouldn't mind seeing something like what Andrew mentioned. I would love to see recolletions of such mini series like the Turtle Soup one as well.
While I understand concerns of publishing "wacky" stories in the order they were released so that more 'canon' stories can all be together, I remember that the Mark Martin stuff was re-released in a seperate book when originally released by Mirage in a trade. See no reason why they can't do that again.
Also, with Laird no longer in charge, I'm hoping IDW will not stick to reprinting stories only he thought canon. Like, I always considered 'The River' canon and it's one of the few stories I still don't own. I would love to have guest issues (especially those more well written and which feature the Turtles in character, like Turtle Drams and the guest issues between Return and City At War) to still be included in newer collections.
azrael
04-06-2011, 07:11 AM
I wouldnt mind if they reprinted all the specials in one book including shell shock, then raph don leo mike mini in a nother book
Bjarni
04-06-2011, 09:19 AM
I also think that Tales of the TMNT (first book) should be released with the "Year in Northampton" stories, if I'm not mistaken they all take place before Return to New York? They should at least be where they belong story-wise.
I would also love to see Tales of the TMNT Volume 2 released in the right chronology, by time rather than issue or artist.
Kendamu
04-06-2011, 09:26 AM
I also think that Tales of the TMNT (first book) should be released with the "Year in Northampton" stories, if I'm not mistaken they all take place before Return to New York? They should at least be where they belong story-wise.
I would also love to see Tales of the TMNT Volume 2 released in the right chronology, by time rather than issue or artist.
That's why I think the canon and possibly-canon stuff In Vol. 1 between #11 and #18 should be released as part of the RtNY trade. Otherwise, the trade's gonna be pretty thin compared to 1-11 or CaW.
Then, because your idea rocks, maybe the first Tales trade could come out between the first Vol. 1 trade and the RtNY trade.
CyberCubed
04-06-2011, 12:11 PM
Does IDW have a link to the Mirage Continuity timeline?
Just curious, but how likely does everyone think it is that IDW has the option to reprint the daily strips? That website just dropped 'em mid-run when the sale was announced. :ohwell:
John Pannozzi
04-06-2011, 01:14 PM
If it was me,
Book 1: #1-11, plus micros.
Book 2: #12-17, 19-26.
Book 3: #27-30, 33, 37 (preceded by Turtle Soup precursor story), 42 - 47.
Book 4: #48-62.
Book 5: Vol. 2 #1-13.
Book 6: Vol. 3, #1-23 (keep in mind these are significantly shorter than your average Mirage issue)
Various backups and other Turtle Soup/Plastron Cafe/etc. material sprinkled throughout where appropriate. Tales of the TMNT Vol. 1 and Vol. 2 worked in there too, if possible, or kind of made into its own thing.
That's pretty much what I would do, except I'd prefer to have Mark Martin's stuff collected in its own book, seperate from the main Mirage canon.
Abnormal Freak
04-06-2011, 03:05 PM
I can't understand skipping #18. :p How is it any more goofy or less canon than Martin's stories? That and it's just one of my favorites—first Mirage comic I ever read, in fact.
BentonGrey
04-06-2011, 04:05 PM
I'm more than a little excited about this. I do hope we see something of a happy medium between the Archie series/original 'toon and the original books. While I love those original stories, I like the wider, more mutant-filled, and more fantastic setting of the later Archie stories. Plus, being the faithful child of the 80's that I am, I'll always own the original cartoon as my favorite version of the Green Machine. Either way, I am really hopeful about this new book. A great many of the series IDW is putting out are of a pretty solid quality. I would love to have a monthly dose of Turtle action.:tgrin:
Also, it would be fantastic if their access to the Archie books might end up with those unpublished stories finally seeing the light of day.
PizzaPower
04-06-2011, 04:13 PM
If it was me,
Book 1: #1-11, plus micros.
Book 2: #12-17, 19-26.
Book 3: #27-30, 33, 37 (preceded by Turtle Soup precursor story), 42 - 47.
Book 4: #48-62.
Book 5: Vol. 2 #1-13.
Book 6: Vol. 3, #1-23 (keep in mind these are significantly shorter than your average Mirage issue)
Various backups and other Turtle Soup/Plastron Cafe/etc. material sprinkled throughout where appropriate. Tales of the TMNT Vol. 1 and Vol. 2 worked in there too, if possible, or kind of made into its own thing.
yea i really love this idea, shoot maybe we will get it done like this :)
Spitfire
04-06-2011, 07:32 PM
I really don't need to buy the first group of books again. I own them all singular and several times over in book form. HC releases would sell me though, I've been wanting a nice all HC TMNT set since I started collecting.
New book sounds okay. If they can keep the art consistent, and good, I'm game. Though restarting the timeline after going through the trouble to re-release the old material seems oddly silly. Not that I mind if it's well done but from a marketing stand point it seems strange. I also thought Mirage still owned the rights to the comics but I guess those got sold off too.
A book based off the toon sounds interesting too. Might end up being throw away though we'll have to see.
Venom
04-06-2011, 10:03 PM
Just curious, but how likely does everyone think it is that IDW has the option to reprint the daily strips? That website just dropped 'em mid-run when the sale was announced. :ohwell:
I don't know, I asked the same thing over on their forums.
Andrew NDB
04-07-2011, 03:34 AM
No offense to the contributions of Mark Martin and Hedden/McWeeney, but that stuff should be held and released much, much later down the line (if at all). I don't think it helps what IDW is trying to do by confusing readers by intermixing the noncanonical wacky stuff.
That's pretty much what I would do, except I'd prefer to have Mark Martin's stuff collected in its own book, seperate from the main Mirage canon.
Wait, did you see any Mark Martin stuff in my listing?
turkishproverb
04-07-2011, 04:24 AM
Book 2: #12-17, 19-26.
I gotta ask. Why leave out 18?
Bjarni
04-07-2011, 08:51 AM
I can see leaving out #18 because it has the Turtles just walking around in Asia... how and when does that fit into the story? If it should collected it should be somewhere between Return to New York and City At War or after City At War....
Or Shell of the Dragon, Mark Martin, Hedden/McWeeney (including Maltese Turtle) and some of the random one-shot TMNT Adventure Specials could all be collected in a hardcover of their own down the line...
CyberCubed
04-07-2011, 10:45 AM
#18 was a Kevin Eastman story and should be included.
Venom
04-07-2011, 11:09 AM
It doesn't flow well with the main narrative; in fact it feels more like a Tale rather than the normal E&L continuity issues.
CyberCubed
04-07-2011, 12:23 PM
Its a filler story, but there's no reason it can't fit in right before RTNY.
wilddiverse
04-07-2011, 12:40 PM
Its a filler story, but there's no reason it can't fit in right before RTNY.
Right, but it's a filler story.
CyberCubed
04-07-2011, 12:43 PM
IDW never said they were just collecting the big story arcs. If that was the case, a lot of canon Mirage stories even ones written by Dan Berger or Jim Lawson would be skipped.
#45 was an all Dan Berger story, but its canon with Leatherhead and the transmat. Seeing that skipped just because it wasn't an, "Eastman/Laird story," would be ridiculous.
discordiatookie
04-07-2011, 01:22 PM
Does IDW have a link to the Mirage Continuity timeline?
I sent em a link along with my email about Tristan Jones to them; i'm sure that i'm not the only one!
wilddiverse
04-07-2011, 01:23 PM
IDW haven't said much of anything to draw conclusions from yet.
I would just like it recognized that there's a difference between issues being entirely omitted from these hypothetical collections and an intentional publishing strategy that would see the release of major story arcs first, with later volumes then collecting remaining issues by creator, theme, or tea leaves.
Abnormal Freak
04-07-2011, 01:58 PM
Wait, did you see any Mark Martin stuff in my listing?
Yes, which is what left myself confused, ha ha. And made it all the more strange you excluded #18.
I totally understand a canonical (whatever that means in the world of TMNT) approach to releasing first the stories which fall into place in a bigger overarching story, then releasing some of the wackier stuff later. I'm not sure what makes #18 any more filler than, say, #13 and #17, though; and if it weren't for what Peter did with the characters later in Vol. 4, #15 seems just as goofy and "out of place"—even more so than the others mentioned, I'd say. But, those characters play a big role in Vol. 4, so of course now it only makes sense to include the issue if IDW intend on going as far as Vol. 4.
'Course, it could just be they give us a hardcover of the first eleven issues sans micro-series and be done with previously-published Turtles comics. ;)
I wonder how they might handle an issue like #27? Would they release the "Complete Carnage an' Radical" short and Tales #5 beforehand? You'd definitely have to go cross-title for a proper chronology.
CyberCubed
04-07-2011, 02:03 PM
I prefer the original 7 Tales issues and the "Spinal Tapped" story to be released in a separate TPB, just like Mirage did back in 2007.
They could re-release the book just like that, AND with the frontipieces of the old Turtles.
Bjarni
04-07-2011, 02:15 PM
I wonder how they might handle an issue like #27? Would they release the "Complete Carnage an' Radical" short and Tales #5 beforehand? You'd definitely have to go cross-title for a proper chronology.
I just realized how much I would love to see a hardcover entitled TMNT: THE COMPLETE COMPLETE CARNAGE SAGA. Have all the stories together. For some reason I doubt we will ever see the Complete Carnage and Radical short released just because I doubt they'll know about all that stuff and in what order they are set to be released...
They could re-release the book just like that, AND with the frontipieces of the old Turtles.
I'd rather that IDW release the titles their own way instead of just re-releasing what Mirage was doing two years ago.
Spitfire
04-08-2011, 02:41 AM
I'd rather they release them all, in the order they were printed, 12 to 13 issues a book until the whole series is out. Trying to put them into order is stupid. The timeline for TMNT is convoluted and stuff is canon and non-canon, just release it all. That's what any normal comic would do.
TristanHuwJones
04-08-2011, 07:37 AM
That becomes a real mess once you hit Tales vol.2 though. A book like that is fine on a monthly basis (arguably) but unless you start grouping similar stories together in specific sets it gets REALLY messy. You look at the month by month feedback on each tales book, it speaks for itself: "I want more of this one" "The art was great in this one" "I hate the way we have to wait for the next part to story X" etc. You collect them in release order and you get some really messy storytelling and a very disjointed read.
You ask me, TMNT has to be collected in chronological order or themed sets.
ToTheNines
04-08-2011, 08:29 AM
Just occurred to me that while all this Tristan love we're sending IDW is great, we should probably drop some other names as well...
Particularly Dan Berger.
PizzaPower
04-08-2011, 08:48 AM
yea i really hope re-release all 62 issue's, i really want the city at war in graphic novel form.
Danny Burger for president! ^_^
Bjarni
04-08-2011, 12:05 PM
Particularly Dan Berger.
I can't think of anyone who could handle the Universe better.
PizzaPower
04-08-2011, 12:13 PM
i agree as well Dan should be party of it, i love his artwork as well.
Venom
04-08-2011, 12:44 PM
It's Murph or muffin!!
It'd really be great if the guys at IDW were to pull the Mirage gang together.
It's Murph or muffin!!
:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:
Chris
04-08-2011, 12:56 PM
Personally I'd like something like this;
TMNT Vol. 1 Collection 1 - Vol. 1 #1-11, 4 TMNT Specials, Fugitoid Special, any short stories from those issues/reprints
TMNT Vol. 1 Collection 2 - Vol. 1 #12-15,17,19-21,27-29,43,45-49, any short stories from those issues/reprints
TMNT Vol. 1 Collection 3 - Vol. 1 #50-62, any short stories from those issues/reprints
These would be 3 hardback collections of the Mirage "canon" issues. The rest of Volume 1 would be collected as smaller writer/artist/story arc paperback collections (TMNT - Souls Winter, TMNT - The River, etc.)
Tales of the TMNT Vol.1 Collection - Tales Vol. 1 #1-7, new material created for the old and new collected editions
Turtle Soup/Shell Shock - Collects all the short stories from Turtle Soup, Shell Shock, Plastron Cafe, Casey Jones, etc
Tales would be a hardback collection, not sure about Turtle Soup/Shell Shock.
If they ever get this far;
TMNT Vol. 2 Collection - Vol. 2 #1-13
TMNT Vol. 3 Collection - Vol. 3 #1-25 (or an official ending if they can't/won't use the fan ending), TMNT/Savage Dragon Crossovers
Would love both to be hardback, but I'd take paperback.
Tales Volume 2 I'd collect in paperbacks in chronological order as much as possible (maybe making some exceptions and keeping story arcs together). I'd love to see Tristan get chance to fully complete his gang wars story as an original graphic novel in the Tales Volume 2 collections.
TMNT Vol. 4 would be hardbacks, maybe 12 issues per collection which would leave room for a 5 issue conclusion done either by Peter and Jim or IDW (preferably from Peter's notes if it comes to this)
Spitfire
04-08-2011, 01:26 PM
That becomes a real mess once you hit Tales vol.2 though. A book like that is fine on a monthly basis (arguably) but unless you start grouping similar stories together in specific sets it gets REALLY messy. You look at the month by month feedback on each tales book, it speaks for itself: "I want more of this one" "The art was great in this one" "I hate the way we have to wait for the next part to story X" etc. You collect them in release order and you get some really messy storytelling and a very disjointed read.
You ask me, TMNT has to be collected in chronological order or themed sets.
True but the book was formatted that way. The only reason fans complained was because the release dates tended to be inconsistent and waiting forever for the next issue only to find it doesn't wrap up a plot point you had been hanging on was a bit of a let down.
I could see them collecting the Tales issues that dealt with the mini series for each turtle into books together but a better option would be to just collect all the mini series into one book. The current Tales trades suck because they jump all over the place and would have been nicer if they started from the beginning and went through all the issues up to a point.
The idea behind doing the books in some sort of order is nice in theory. In practice good one off stories will get completely left out and not all the arcs are big enough to warrant their own book. In fact none of them really are except maybe City At War. We'd have either small releases or stories that don't go together would get tossed in anyways.
Plus I don't really trust IDW will do the proper research to make sure they collect the timeline properly. That worry comes from years of watching the turtles get the short end of the stick. Look how bad companies have screwed the DVD releases up. Maybe IDW and Nick will really surprise me but till I see some proof I'll remain pessimistic about it. :lol:
CyberCubed
04-08-2011, 01:28 PM
If they don't do it right I expect a lot of angry complaints.
Their first TPB better be as good as Mirage's from 2009. I bet they'll forget the Turtle one shots due to their incompetence.
Spitfire
04-08-2011, 01:31 PM
If they don't do it right I expect a lot of angry complaints.
Their first TPB better be as good as Mirage's from 2009. I bet they'll forget the Turtle one shots due to their incompetence.
My hope lies in the fact they seem to like giant HC collections. They seem nicely done so I'm holding out for some new HC releases.
You know what would be best? A giant collection like the Usagi book that came out recently. Cover as much as they can. That would be keen.
Andrew NDB
04-08-2011, 02:37 PM
I can see leaving out #18 because it has the Turtles just walking around in Asia...
Or Shell of the Dragon
Are these not one and the same?
Kevin's involvement or not, I don't think it was intended as canonical even when it was written.
xZAOx
04-08-2011, 03:30 PM
i agree as well Dan should be party of it, i love his artwork as well.
While I really dig his art (and love Leatherhead), he does have a bad habit of neutering the turtles' tails. It's a pet peeve :P
Bjarni
04-08-2011, 03:30 PM
It's the same, I just remembered the name in mid-post. :tsmile:
discordiatookie
04-08-2011, 05:05 PM
If they don't do it right I expect a lot of angry complaints.
Their first TPB better be as good as Mirage's from 2009. I bet they'll forget the Turtle one shots due to their incompetence.
How about, instead of pissing and moaning about it now, drop them an email, get on their message boards and let them know about how integral the one shots are to the story (particularly Raph's and Leo's ones.) And then, if they somehow miss them out, then start to piss and moan about it. And i'll be right here, behind you. But to stand there calling them incompetent before they've even done anything is a bit much.
Hell, they can't print issue 10 without Leo's one first, so doubt that they are going to miss that, at least.
CyberCubed
04-08-2011, 05:39 PM
I wish someone here could oversee the trades just to make sure they're done right.
PizzaPower
04-08-2011, 05:41 PM
How about, instead of pissing and moaning about it now, drop them an email, get on their message boards and let them know about how integral the one shots are to the story (particularly Raph's and Leo's ones.) And then, if they somehow miss them out, then start to piss and moan about it. And i'll be right here, behind you. But to stand there calling them incompetent before they've even done anything is a bit much.
Hell, they can't print issue 10 without Leo's one first, so doubt that they are going to miss that, at least.
i totally agree with this, we dont need to complain or put then down in anyway, shoot they are trying to help the fans (and make some money) but yea lets wait and see if they release it right.
CyberCubed
04-08-2011, 07:06 PM
Does anyone know what story they have planned for their first issue? What I hope is that it's based on the Mirage storyline but with their own twists.
Roseangelo
04-08-2011, 07:31 PM
Does anyone know what story they have planned for their first issue?
Do you honestly expect someone to answer yes to this? Really?
PizzaPower
04-08-2011, 07:44 PM
beee nice rosee, lol, nobody knows cyber, i know its going to be TMNT though, lol.
xZAOx
04-08-2011, 08:08 PM
Does anyone know what story they have planned for their first issue? What I hope is that it's based on the Mirage storyline but with their own twists.
Why the hell would anyone want that? If you want Mirage stories again in comic form, GO READ YOUR MIRAGE COMICS. After you read them, they don't just like...disintegrate and immediately wipe from your mind.
"Hey Stephen King, could you please write The Stand again, except this time make The Walkin' Dude have a cane!"
azrael
04-08-2011, 08:59 PM
Why the hell would anyone want that? If you want Mirage stories again in comic form, GO READ YOUR MIRAGE COMICS. After you read them, they don't just like...disintegrate and immediately wipe from your mind.
"Hey Stephen King, could you please write The Stand again, except this time make The Walkin' Dude have a cane!"
That is essential what they are doing, They will take the pre-existing story line, 4 turtles and 1 rat get oozed and then tweak their whole story. You really think they will change that? Its all going to be with the creative teams objectives, do they want splinter as a guy who gets bit by a dying oozed rat? Will it be 4 friends stumble upon a dying turtle thats been slimed and they gain turtle appearance. Who knows you dont take character that have been written for 20+ years and completely do something new. You have the foundation, then walls and finally the paint are the tweaks (twist) that let it breathe new life.
I mean there are constances even in all the universes of tmnt
Raph vs Leo
April n Casey
Leo Leads
Raph is cool but rude
Don does machines
Mike being the party dude
Splinter is their mentor/father
Shredder is the Turtles "Joker."
Only thing that happens with the characters are the tweaks of different universes. If i want the original I will read the original but if I want the original with tweaks I will read Image and IDW
ToTheNines
04-08-2011, 09:07 PM
April n Casey
Shredder is the Turtles "Joker."
Those two aren't always true.
azrael
04-08-2011, 09:38 PM
Those two aren't always true.
how are those not true?
Because of shadow?
Because Shredder dies?
That becomes a real mess once you hit Tales vol.2 though. A book like that is fine on a monthly basis (arguably) but unless you start grouping similar stories together in specific sets it gets REALLY messy. You look at the month by month feedback on each tales book, it speaks for itself: "I want more of this one" "The art was great in this one" "I hate the way we have to wait for the next part to story X" etc. You collect them in release order and you get some really messy storytelling and a very disjointed read.
You ask me, TMNT has to be collected in chronological order or themed sets. Well why don't you try talking to IDW about this? You worked with them before.
PizzaPower
04-08-2011, 10:11 PM
Well why don't you try talking to IDW about this? You worked with them before.
totally agree :) i want every issue from mirage in graphic form, but also easy to obtain unlike the mirage comics.
TristanHuwJones
04-09-2011, 02:22 AM
Well why don't you try talking to IDW about this? You worked with them before.
I haven't actually. I was asked to pitch for Ghostbusters years ago (while I was still working with Mirage), but it never ended up happening. I'm sure IDW know what they're doing.
TristanHuwJones
04-09-2011, 02:54 AM
how are those not true?
Because of shadow?
Because Shredder dies?
The relationship between the Shredder and the Turtles is no where near as complex as the one between the Joker and Batman. The Shredder is simply the only villain to have appeared long enough in the Turtles' continuity to come across as a villain in a similar sense to the Joker, and even then, Shredder's tenure as a villain wasn't that great...
I also don't think the April/Casey thing has to be a constant either. There are a lot of ways you can play that out.
Spitfire
04-09-2011, 05:44 AM
The Foot are more of the turtles main villain. Shredder was the leader but he spends 2/3rds of the comics dead so you can hardly count him as the main baddie. Like Tristan said the relationship isn't as complex. If we're talking cartoon series I could agree but in the comics he's hardly anything.
TristanHuwJones
04-09-2011, 06:24 AM
I got really, REALLY friggin' tired of the Shredder in the new toon. The relationship was closer to the Joker Batman thing, but still, none of the subtext of that relationship existed. I liked the idea of the Shredder Utrom, but I hated the fact that he was the MAIN Shredder -- I was holding out for a human Shredder to take that bastard down :P
Keldor1578
04-09-2011, 07:44 AM
I got really, REALLY friggin' tired of the Shredder in the new toon. The relationship was closer to the Joker Batman thing, but still, none of the subtext of that relationship existed. I liked the idea of the Shredder Utrom, but I hated the fact that he was the MAIN Shredder -- I was holding out for a human Shredder to take that bastard down :P
I never understood what was so great about about a human Shredder, he was more one dimensional than Ch'rell and he was not the turtles's arch enemy in Mirage comic, The foot clan were the turtles's arch enemy. I don't any human Shredder could have taken Ch'rell down in the 4kids cartoon.
TristanHuwJones
04-09-2011, 08:16 AM
This is an argument that comes down to personal preferences. I didn't like Ch'rell at all. I dug it when we first find out he's an Utrom, but I got really tired of him. Really tired of him.
azrael
04-09-2011, 08:21 AM
As far as the Batman/Joker relationship yeah its on a different level. TMNT/Shredder I was meaning thats their arch nemesis I mean why try to bring him back time and time again. If he wasnt anything. In each comic series has to have a Shredder. It may have not been the same as the one in issue 1 but they premised it like that for a cliffhanger, of course it would be someone else. I would like him (shredder) to be used as like the Joker, once in a while (even though the joker has been used a lot lately).
As for April/Casey thing they are same star lovers. No mater what happens its only a matter of time before they are back in love and together.
PizzaPower
04-09-2011, 08:53 AM
I haven't actually. I was asked to pitch for Ghostbusters years ago (while I was still working with Mirage), but it never ended up happening. I'm sure IDW know what they're doing.
or maybe they are just crazy, but lets hope they do for everybodys sake :)
oldmanwinters
04-09-2011, 09:33 AM
I got really, REALLY friggin' tired of the Shredder in the new toon. The relationship was closer to the Joker Batman thing, but still, none of the subtext of that relationship existed. I liked the idea of the Shredder Utrom, but I hated the fact that he was the MAIN Shredder -- I was holding out for a human Shredder to take that bastard down :P
I guess that was the idea of the "Ninja Tribunal" arc, in which we got to see the Tengu Shredder, who was formerly a human. But yeah, it's just not the same. It's too bad we never got to see the "Shredder Wars" plot realized.
TheCanadiandrome
04-09-2011, 10:49 AM
i liked the Shredder(s) in the 2K3 series, but i much preferred the OT Shredder
PizzaPower
04-09-2011, 11:41 AM
i agree i like the old toon shredder, and i love the mirage shredder as well, even if it was the one comic he was in.
The relationship between the Shredder and the Turtles is no where near as complex as the one between the Joker and Batman. Did the Joker ever kill Batman's masters master forcing a chain of events that would cause him to be created? Was Batman trained to kill the Joker? Batman would have existed without the Joker. The Turtles wouldn't without the Shredder.
TristanHuwJones
04-09-2011, 03:39 PM
Did the Joker ever kill Batman's masters master forcing a chain of events that would cause him to be created? Was Batman trained to kill the Joker? Batman would have existed without the Joker. The Turtles wouldn't without the Shredder.
That's just a complex history, though, and even then it's not that complex. Look at why Batman HASN'T killed the Joker after all these years and you'll see what I'm getting at.
Joe Chill is a closer approximation to the Shredder history wise, but we don't even know the full details of Batman's history OR the Joker's, so it's not the best example to run with. Fact is, the Mirage Shredder is barely a fleshed out character.
Ch'rell Shredder was fleshed out, but he became a one-note villain ("Try to kill the Turtles/take over the world, get beaten, come back in a bigger machine"). Villains with a world domination scheme tend to wear thin on me when you beat their drum too often, which is what happened in the 2k3 toon (for me at least).
Anyway, this is starting to get off topic, for the Shredder to be the Joker of the new comic/comics, he needs to be handled much differently, and even then I think the character might suffer because of it. There are ways around it, of course, but in the TMNT world, there are so many great villains that were never really given a true chance to shine, and I think the new comic is a great outlet for that.
Baxter, Rat King, Hun, Karai, Leatherhead, the Triceratons, Bishop, Savanti Romero, the plethora of smaller crims and gangs -- so many that became one-offs or never really got to live up to their true potential as characters because of the nature of the Mirage comics are worth are all going to be given an opportunity to shine. Heck, if it were up to me, you'd be seeing Bebop & Rocksteady, Sho'kanabo, Touch & Go and a few more from each of the other established continuities as well (yes, even the Next Mutation).
Even allies and support cast can be greatly expanded on. All these things help further enrich the TMNT universe, and when you get given a chance to fully flesh them out the same way Mirage did with April and Casey, the reading experience becomes much more fulfilling, the universe feels more realistic (within its own boundaries), and you can really raise the stakes for the Turtles themselves. It's fine focusing on the Turtles, but you need to give them a thoroughly fleshed out world to inhabit, and this is something I think IDW has the opportunity to really do justice with.
oldmanwinters
04-09-2011, 03:51 PM
Ch'rell Shredder was fleshed out, but he became a one-note villain ("Try to kill the Turtles/take over the world, get beaten, come back in a bigger machine"). Villains with a world domination scheme tend to wear thin on me when you beat their drum too often, which is what happened in the 2k3 toon (for me at least).
Ditto. I was really hoping for a complex Shredder after viewing the incredible "The Shredder Strikes pt.1" the first time. I would have preferred a villain with a twisted sense of honor who lived by his own code.
PAAATE
04-09-2011, 03:57 PM
The important thing to me is characters. I've come to realize lately that as long as the characters are well-written and has some development (and doesn't return to status quo after the development) I can enjoy whatever story they throw at me. That's why I'm currently in love with two so different TV-shows as Six Feet Under and Battlestar Galactica (yeah, I'm a little behind).
So as long as the writer understands characters and character-development, I'll probably like it.
Venom
04-09-2011, 03:58 PM
(yeah, I'm a little behind).
That's okay, at least you're not a giant d***. :P
PAAATE
04-09-2011, 05:07 PM
That's okay, at least you're not a giant d***. :P
Aww, you sweet talker, you.
Baxter, Rat King, Hun, Karai, Leatherhead, the Triceratons, Bishop, Savanti Romero, the plethora of smaller crims and gangs -- so many that became one-offs or never really got to live up to their true potential as characters because of the nature of the Mirage comics are worth are all going to be given an opportunity to shine. Heck, if it were up to me, you'd be seeing Bebop & Rocksteady, Sho'kanabo, Touch & Go and a few more from each of the other established continuities as well (yes, even the Next Mutation). Karai and Leatherhead weren't really villains in the Mirage comics.
TristanHuwJones
04-09-2011, 05:41 PM
Well, yeah, but that's kinda the point. Both were ambiguous and could've swung either way, it's just that the run of continuous storytelling utilizing those characters is limited. And this isn't Mirage anymore. You make them allies and you run the same ground both characters have been on for the past 20 or so years. Both make much more interesting villains in my mind.
Venom
04-09-2011, 06:05 PM
I'd prefer them two, and Rat King even, remain in the murky grey waters. Morally ambiguous characters are always far more interesting that cookie-cutter good/bad ones.
That's one thing I really enjoyed about the Mirage Turtles - yeah, they're genuinely good guys for the most part, but their upbringing gives them a certain shade of grey that creates such an interesting dichotomy to their cartoon counterparts.
PizzaPower
04-09-2011, 07:02 PM
i would really like to seee alot moe different villians in the new tmnt comic.
TristanHuwJones
04-09-2011, 07:37 PM
As in "brand new" or just a variety of villains used more evenly?
AquaParade
04-09-2011, 07:56 PM
The Shredder, Rat King, and Stockman have the most potential of all the pre-existing tmnt villains, in my mind. I'd like to see those three used to their full potential. Other then them, I think TMNT is one comic franchise desperately in need of a new rogues gallery.
TristanHuwJones
04-09-2011, 08:09 PM
I don't necessarily think it needs a "new" rogues gallery, it just needs more added to the ones there already. That was one of the primary motives for me with the Gang Wars -- find a way to tell stories that'd introduce new villains or rework familiar ones (ala Hun).
I agree with you on those three though, but I think there are interesting avenues you can take Baxter in if you make him less of a villain and push him into those murky waters Karai is often in... I think Rat King is also more of a threat to Splinter than the Turtles themselves, it's just that to get to Splinter he's gotta deal wit them.
PizzaPower
04-09-2011, 08:21 PM
triastan, you should deff start doing "fan" comics and release them on the internet for us to read :)
AquaParade
04-09-2011, 10:56 PM
I agree with you on those three though, but I think there are interesting avenues you can take Baxter in if you make him less of a villain and push him into those murky waters Karai is often in... I think Rat King is also more of a threat to Splinter than the Turtles themselves, it's just that to get to Splinter he's gotta deal wit them.
Agreed. "Villain" is a broad term. I would the same goes for the Rat King as well. Most villains work better when their morals lean more towards a grey area, and less black and white, if you know what I mean. Although, Shredder definitely works as a straight up enemy of the turtles, in my opinion.
Although, some of the TMNT villains in the past have just been...boring. Savanti Romero, Carnage, Garbageman, Lord Dregg, etc. Any interpretation of the tmnt you look at has a number of pretty useless rogues gallery type characters, in my humble opinion. I don't mean to offend anyone who see's these characters differently. I am obviously biased, but I just feel like the tmnt deserve better. I guess they don't need "new" enemies, but to make them interesting, I feel that you'd have to reinvent them anyways, which basically makes them new.
Jester
04-09-2011, 11:24 PM
Yeah, grey villains are the best villains. That's why people really like the villains of say, Gargoyles. They weren't bad for bad sake, they had motivation. Maybe that's why I'm starting to reject previous "I like the FW series for ____ and the 4Kids series for ___" feelings. I finished the FW series and am working on the 4kids, and I had more fun with the FW. Maybe it's because there they were evil, but not not so annoyingly "MUHAHA!" as Ch'rell.
I think the "specter" of the Shredder was the big bad of the TMNT. Splinter's revenge plot started a ball rolling that wasn't easily stopped. I think any of the "lesser" villains if given a shot might do well in the IDW TMNT universe. It's all about the writing.
CyberCubed
04-09-2011, 11:47 PM
Although, some of the TMNT villains in the past have just been...boring. Savanti Romero, Carnage, Garbageman, Lord Dregg, etc.
For the OT universe, Lord Dregg was an excellent villain. He would only work in that particular universe though, because in any of the others he would just seem like a cartoony supervillain, which is what he was.
Anyway what I hope is the IDW are based in the Volume 1 timeline, so they don't have to deal with the events of Volume 2 onward, but we can still see the Turtles after RTNY.
Remember, the beginning of Volume 2 and 4 were considered, "fresh starts" yet they kept continuity.
TristanHuwJones
04-10-2011, 12:48 AM
Although, some of the TMNT villains in the past have just been...boring. Savanti Romero, Carnage, Garbageman, Lord Dregg, etc. Any interpretation of the tmnt you look at has a number of pretty useless rogues gallery type characters, in my humble opinion. I don't mean to offend anyone who see's these characters differently. I am obviously biased, but I just feel like the tmnt deserve better. I guess they don't need "new" enemies, but to make them interesting, I feel that you'd have to reinvent them anyways, which basically makes them new.
Agreed. Some of those origins don't hold up these days either. They were fun because they were riffing on an older generation of superheros and villains, but these days, the core audience for TMNT has little care or knowledge (unfortunately) of "The King". Lord Dregg was also unfortunate in that he came so abruptly and tried to take the spotlight from villains who had been mainstays for far too long. I think Dregg is a good idea on paper, but I don't think he was handled as well as he deserved to have been in the show. It's like the NM villains -- a lot of them sound rad on paper, and when you see some of them in Kevin's book, seem really cool, but the execution (while suitable for that particular show) wasn't up to the idea. One of the last stories I sold to Mirage (and hinted at in Tales #64) was to expand on Savanti Romero.
Jester
04-10-2011, 09:08 AM
When I finally watched Season 9 and 10, I didn't mind Dregg so much, especially since it didn't even mean the end of Shredder and Krang. We see them again. I mean, according to IMDB he was only in 11 episodes, at most 16. And a lot of the time he was actually rather competent, then again in season 10 Shredder and Krang are fairly competent...why? WRITING!
PizzaPower
04-10-2011, 09:13 AM
I really love the last episode as well Jester, where they go back to the technodrome, yea it was great.
Jester
04-10-2011, 09:20 AM
I was more thinking the 3 part episode in the middle of the season where Dregg brings Shredder and Krang to him to gain their power, and Shredder and Krang work together to out smart him.
PizzaPower
04-10-2011, 09:34 AM
what episodes where these?
CyberCubed
04-10-2011, 09:37 AM
Shredder/Krang return for a 3-parter in Season 10 of the original series, and that's the last we see of them.
By the end of the original series, Shredder/Krang are lost somewhere in Dimension X, the Technodrome is destroyed and abandoned on an asteroid, and Lord Dregg is blown up by Krang's Android Body off-screen.
When you stop to think about it, the original series did have a pretty decent ending for a cartoon in the 90's.
Villains are interesting or boring because of the way they are written. Look at Mr. Freeze, before BTAS no one cared about that character and boom, its written very well in the episode and now he's a well known rogue. Lord Dregg could be written for the comic or a new show, what makes it harder for him is how is he different from say the Triceratons who are already fairly interesting evil space aliens.. I always like to mention that TNM has good villains with a ton of potential to be written well, but this is a topic about Mirage which I'm not familiar with so I don't know how well they could fit there.
PizzaPower
04-10-2011, 10:23 AM
Villains are interesting or boring because of the way they are written. Look at Mr. Freeze, before BTAS no one cared about that character and boom, its written very well in the episode and now he's a well known rogue. Lord Dregg could be written for the comic or a new show, what makes it harder for him is how is he different from say the Triceratons who are already fairly interesting evil space aliens.. I always like to mention that TNM has good villains with a ton of potential to be written well, but this is a topic about Mirage which I'm not familiar with so I don't know how well they could fit there.
wait?!?! you never read the comics?
Chris
04-10-2011, 02:21 PM
I always like to mention that TNM has good villains with a ton of potential to be written well, but this is a topic about Mirage which I'm not familiar with so I don't know how well they could fit there.
Have to agree with you here. TNM actually has a very good premise and potentially fantastic villains, but it was wasted. Bringing those concepts/characters back and doing the right could lead to some incredible stories.
PizzaPower
04-10-2011, 03:03 PM
Have to agree with you here. TNM actually has a very good premise and potentially fantastic villains, but it was wasted. Bringing those concepts/characters back and doing the right could lead to some incredible stories.
you have to admit it was written by the guys who did power rangers (i think) or at leaat the power rangers had some good written episodes.
Bjarni
04-10-2011, 05:06 PM
What sold Lord Dregg for me was that he was voiced by the late great Tony Jay.
I wouldn't mind seeing him in the comics (rather than the show, he seems to fit a lot better as a comic villain), especially if they made him into an actual threat.
I hope to see Tristan's Romero story when IDW realize he's the best man for the job. :tgrin:
PizzaPower
04-10-2011, 05:09 PM
What sold Lord Dregg for me was that he was voiced by the late great Tony Jay.
I wouldn't mind seeing him in the comics (rather than the show, he seems to fit a lot better as a comic villain), especially if they made him into an actual threat.
I hope to see Tristan's Romero story when IDW realize he's the best man for the job. :tgrin:
lets hope, did has tristan like applied for a job with them?
wilddiverse
04-10-2011, 05:15 PM
Heck, if it were up to me, you'd be seeing Bebop & Rocksteady, Sho'kanabo, Touch & Go and a few more from each of the other established continuities as well (yes, even the Next Mutation).
You had me at Bebop & Rocksteady.
PizzaPower
04-10-2011, 05:17 PM
oh man oh man oh man he has me at next mutation, come on get the job already!
Bjarni
04-10-2011, 05:37 PM
I would love for Tristan to re-write the TMNT Rogue's gallery and really make them memorable with his updates.
If you ever do The Shredder, I would love to see some more honor in him.
Have him evil, a warrior, a ninja, maniacal and honor-bound.
My favorite Shredder so far is probably the one that appeared in Murphy's and Zuli's 'Souls Winter'.
Another good story was when Murphy (again) was writing TMNT Adventures and was saved by the Turtles, even though they couldn't trust that he would be true to his words, Saki promised that he was honor-bound to the Turtles for saving him. Then, when he had Splinter cornered (maybe 10 issues later or something), the Turtles reminded him of saving his life and he let Splinter go.
That's the Shredder I would like to see.
That and a brutal fighter, like in the first movie and during some of his cartoon fights. He should be able to handle all four Turtles.
Kendamu
04-10-2011, 05:38 PM
I think I'm gonna bug IDW about maybe localizing the TMNT manga, too. I'd certainly like to see that in print.
Utromshredderhater
04-10-2011, 05:45 PM
Has anyone seen any promo pictures yet?
TristanHuwJones
04-10-2011, 05:50 PM
I would love for Tristan to re-write the TMNT Rogue's gallery and really make them memorable with his updates.
If you ever do The Shredder, I would love to see some more honor in him.
Have him evil, a warrior, a ninja, maniacal and honor-bound.
My favorite Shredder so far is probably the one that appeared in Murphy's and Zuli's 'Souls Winter'.
Another good story was when Murphy (again) was writing TMNT Adventures and was saved by the Turtles, even though they couldn't trust that he would be true to his words, Saki promised that he was honor-bound to the Turtles for saving him. Then, when he had Splinter cornered (maybe 10 issues later or something), the Turtles reminded him of saving his life and he let Splinter go.
That's the Shredder I would like to see.
That and a brutal fighter, like in the first movie and during some of his cartoon fights. He should be able to handle all four Turtles.
Paul and I were going to do a "Year 1" style Shredder story (I think I'd called it Nemesis Rising, or something to that effect) which basically retold Shredder's origins, expanding on it to suit the Mirage continuity that came from Leonardo #1 onwards. Had that big fight with Hun we alluded to in Tales #56. I was putting the doc's for it together just before the sale.
Has anyone seen any promo pictures yet?
I don't think anything's been released from IDW yet. They haven't announced the creative team.
CyberCubed
04-10-2011, 06:00 PM
Tristan, is there any way you could pitch all these unused story ideas you had to IDW? From what I can tell this series could wind up being a loose continuation of the Mirage universe, and thus most of your stories can fit.
I'd love to see the story with Hun concluded in IDW. It just proves we don't need a reboot of the comics just yet. Maybe when we get bogged down with 50 years worth of comics.
TristanHuwJones
04-10-2011, 06:10 PM
Tristan, is there any way you could pitch all these unused story ideas you had to IDW? From what I can tell this series could wind up being a loose continuation of the Mirage universe, and thus most of your stories can fit.
I'd love to see the story with Hun concluded in IDW. It just proves we don't need a reboot of the comics just yet. Maybe when we get bogged down with 50 years worth of comics.
I'm sure there is, but it's up to IDW. I'm sure they have plans already, but I'd certainly love to get back to the Turtles comics at some point.
Mirage (and subsequently NICK) bought a few stories off me back before the sale in case Tales was able to continue, so I've already got about 6 or so unpublished stories that they already own that would've continued on the whole Hun thing specifically.
Revan
04-10-2011, 06:15 PM
Tristan's hun story was one of my favs. Anyone have IDW's email address if I was interested in emailing a fan letter of recommendation? :)
Venom
04-10-2011, 06:27 PM
Heck, if it were up to me, you'd be seeing Bebop & Rocksteady, Sho'kanabo, Touch & Go and a few more from each of the other established continuities as well (yes, even the Next Mutation).
As much as I enjoy your writing/stories Tristan, the Bebop and Rocksteady idea was my least favorite; I just didn't like it. The potential for those two is certainly there, but the other-dimensional giants aspect was altogether "meh" for me, man.
To get back to something positive, Touch & Go was a cool idea! :D
@ Neutrino:
[email protected]
TristanHuwJones
04-10-2011, 06:30 PM
As much as I enjoy your writing/stories Tristan, the Bebop and Rocksteady idea was my least favorite; I just didn't like it. The potential for those two is certainly there, but the other-dimensional giants aspect was altogether "meh" for me, man.
To get back to something positive, Touch & Go was a cool idea! :D
To be fair, that was a Free Comic Book Day idea, and the idea behind those books is to attract people to the book and give them a feel for what it's like. I was aiming that book outside the fanbase more so than regular readers of Tales, but wanted it to feel along the lines of #50 or #61.
Touch & Go is something I definitely want to revisit though. That was my favorite of the unpublished stories :P
PizzaPower
04-10-2011, 07:28 PM
so are there any unpublished stories besides volume 4?
TristanHuwJones
04-10-2011, 09:58 PM
Muscle and Faith, the Murphy/Lawson retelling of #8, and there are probably a handful of stories Mirage bought in case Tales continued beyond #70, but I can't say how many others beyond my own without speaking to Dan. Either way, only thefirst two I mentioned made it to production (as far as I know), so I don't think there's much likelihood of IDW publishing the others to "complete" the Mirage run. The first two possibly could, but again, that's up to IDW. I'd love to see the Titan publishing Fast Forward shorts collected. Jake and I both wrote for those, as did Simon Furman and a couple of others but they only came out in the UK
Cowabunga Carl
04-10-2011, 11:58 PM
I just can't wait to see what IDW has in store. I mean really I've been cool with all the different takes on the Turtles so far. Each to me has been its own thing. I mean really I can't judge it by what came before or after. It isn't fair to the creative team that will produce it or the stuff that came befor or will come after.
Saying that though I would really like it to stay in black and white.
CyberCubed
04-11-2011, 12:15 AM
Saying that though I would really like it to stay in black and white.
They already confirmed the new series will be in color. I just hope they remember the Turtles all have red bandanas.
The trades should be in black and white though, although I wouldn't object to seeing most of the old Volume 1 stuff in color. I guess some purists would hate that though.
Cowabunga Carl
04-11-2011, 12:22 AM
I wouldn't hate it. But then again I don't consider my self a purists. I am trying to get all the old issues though.
I am looking forward to seeing some characters make their apperance in comic form though. Silver from TNM for one. I think that had a lot of potentail.
CyberCubed
04-11-2011, 12:25 AM
Silver the talking ape? He just reminded me of Sergeant Bananas from the old toyline, just in a business suit.
Cowabunga Carl
04-11-2011, 12:34 AM
See to me he could have been such a threat, granted I've only seen him in like 2 eps. Haven't watched much TNM. But the idea that there is a mutant Godfather and he has the humans scared could be such an amazing story arch. Could be a way to expose the humans to mutants the first time. Just so many different ways to go with it.
Silver could be the 'KINGPIN' (daredevil) of the TMNT universe.
TristanHuwJones
04-11-2011, 05:13 AM
Silver was the first NM villain that came to my mind, Vam Mi was another and Dragon Lord was someone I was actually subtly working towards with "Burning Man". Take that as you will ;)
John Pannozzi
04-11-2011, 09:31 AM
so are there any unpublished stories besides volume 4?
This story (http://www.miltonknight.net/cid.html) Milton Knight did for TMNT Adventures, at least (in addition to the ones Tristan mentioned)
Venom
04-11-2011, 08:34 PM
This story (http://www.miltonknight.net/cid.html) Milton Knight did for TMNT Adventures, at least (in addition to the ones Tristan mentioned)
I like his homage to Klunk:
http://www.miltonknight.net/cid4.jpg
RossMay
04-11-2011, 09:56 PM
A shout out to Tristan right now who'll be one of the writers for the ongoing Ghostbusters monthly at IDW. Congrats, Trist! This is good news both for GB, and could mean good things for the turtles down the line...
Venom
04-11-2011, 10:08 PM
I don't necessarily think it needs a "new" rogues gallery, it just needs more added to the ones there already. That was one of the primary motives for me with the Gang Wars -- find a way to tell stories that'd introduce new villains or rework familiar ones (ala Hun).
I agree with you on those three though, but I think there are interesting avenues you can take Baxter in if you make him less of a villain and push him into those murky waters Karai is often in... I think Rat King is also more of a threat to Splinter than the Turtles themselves, it's just that to get to Splinter he's gotta deal wit them.
I don't know how I missed this reply Trist, but I agree on Rat King. I didn't much care for the "transcended guardian" in the animal pantheon thing, but it is what it is. Personally, I've always had this idea in my mind about the Rat King being a psychological nemesis to Splinter that would pull mindf***s on him and cause him all sorts of disarray and "WTF-ness" when they interact.
The big question surrounding Rat King would be "Does he want to kill Splinter or is he trying to help him?" because it would seem to go either/or; "help" is a loose interpretation too, because it would have a mean streak to it.
Do you see where I'm going here? Who's a good comic analogy to this, Scarecrow?
TristanHuwJones
04-11-2011, 10:47 PM
I don't know how I missed this reply Trist, but I agree on Rat King. I didn't much care for the "transcended guardian" in the animal pantheon thing, but it is what it is. Personally, I've always had this idea in my mind about the Rat King being a psychological nemesis to Splinter that would pull mindf***s on him and cause him all sorts of disarray and "WTF-ness" when they interact.
The big question surrounding Rat King would be "Does he want to kill Splinter or is he trying to help him?" because it would seem to go either/or; "help" is a loose interpretation too, because it would have a mean streak to it.
Do you see where I'm going here? Who's a good comic analogy to this, Scarecrow?
I have my own spin on it, but I might sit on it... just in case :P I do see where you're going with it though.
A shout out to Tristan right now who'll be one of the writers for the ongoing Ghostbusters monthly at IDW. Congrats, Trist! This is good news both for GB, and could mean good things for the turtles down the line...
Hey, thanks Ross! There's a little more to it than that, but you'll have to wait and see! And again, maybe someday, but that's not my call to make :)
I've always thought TNM had very interesting villains with a ton of potential, even with the slapstick writing you could like the characters and I would want them to see them in another incarnation were they are actually written well. Most of them were made way too crazy similar to how Batman Forever made Two-Face and Riddler overly crazy and laugh happy than they should.
Dragonlord - Plenty of potential. Especially his Rank members were definitely cool foot soldiers, especially the Rank Leader who was never given a name, not to mention the good dragon rank member.. In the actual show he was only written as a big threat in very few episodes.
Dr. Quease - He was kind of the Baxter Stockman of the show, but what separates him is that he doesn't care if he's working for someone who is bad or good, he did all of it for science without regards if someone suffers in the process. Donatello admiring him was an interesting point. Sadly they made him a bit too 'crazy' in most episodes.
Bonesteel - Great character but used terribly in TNM, he was made way too goofy/crazy. There is one episode where they actually portray him as a badass, still crazy but not in a spapstick way and an actual threat who will hunt his bounties at all costs.
Silver - I really liked him, he was a mob boss and didn't care about the turtles at all unless they actually interfered with his jobs. He wasn't a brooding villain but he wasn't wacky either, it was his henchmen who acted like the three stooges that ruined him in the actual show.
and not a villain but I always liked the way Splinter interacted and played chess in the surface with "Andre" who was blind. I think its neat that Splinter was able to befriend a human who obviously couldn't see him, though its hinted that he realizes Splinter is not human.
Vammi- I didn't care much for her, she had a pretty graphic death scene though, heh. the benefits of being a vampire on a kids tv show I guess. Not really crazy about vampires in TMNT.
discordiatookie
04-12-2011, 03:46 PM
I like his homage to Klunk:
That's got me scratching my head. Why Klunk? :P
That's got me scratching my head. Why Klunk? :P
That's what the bomb said.
discordiatookie
04-12-2011, 04:02 PM
That's what the bomb said.
:toops: I didn't even see that!
Kendamu
04-12-2011, 04:17 PM
Nevermind.
discordiatookie
04-12-2011, 04:19 PM
Yep, I know who Klunk is. I just never saw the word KLUNK on that page. :lol:
Pretty sure that was Venom's sadistic intention: just see how many WTFs he can trick Da 'Drome out of. ^_^
azrael
04-12-2011, 04:49 PM
Tristan: Would I have to read all the other ghostbuster comics to "get" the newest one? I may pick this up.
DrSpengler
04-12-2011, 04:53 PM
Tristan: Would I have to read all the other ghostbuster comics to "get" the newest one? I may pick this up.
If Tristan so much as references "The Other Side" or "Displaced Aggression" I swear I'll kill his pets.
TristanHuwJones
04-12-2011, 05:04 PM
Tristan: Would I have to read all the other ghostbuster comics to "get" the newest one? I may pick this up.
You can definitely get started right here at this first issue! It might help a LITTLE bit if you pick up the two Infestation Ghostbusters comics from last month, as I think they might come into play somewhere down the track (and they're just good comics).
The other TPB's are worth checking out. The Haunted Holidays book is good and in spite of what others say I didn't mind Displaced Aggression. It was a little too far out, but if you can deal with the stories in Real and Extreme Ghostbusters, then you shouldn't have a problem with this.
If Tristan so much as references "The Other Side" or "Displaced Aggression" I swear I'll kill his pets.
Other Side was awful, but again, I didn't mind Displaced Aggression. It wasn't great, but it was in no way terrible. That was the time I was originally asked to pitch actually. My story was drastically different to that one, but communication problems at Sony's end meant it didn't go through.
Anyway, I'm happy to be back on board, hopefully you all dig it!
DrSpengler
04-12-2011, 05:14 PM
Other Side was awful, but again, I didn't mind Displaced Aggression. It wasn't great, but it was in no way terrible. That was the time I was originally asked to pitch actually. My story was drastically different to that one, but communication problems at Sony's end meant it didn't go through.
Anyway, I'm happy to be back on board, hopefully you all dig it!
Well, at least we agree on "Other Side".
"Displaced Aggression" I didn't appreciate for the immature overuse of gore which has *never* been a watermark of any Ghostbusters media (the first issue was particularly bad about it), the very stale and predictable writing tropes (the resolution to Morgan Lafay issue was such a play-by-numbers ending it hurt) and the awful Mary Sue "punk rock haircut girl Ghostbuster from the future who also knows magic" character, I don't even want to get started on her.
It wasn't as offensively terrible as "The Other Side" but very much rubbed off as Scott Lobdell phoning in four scripts for a quick buck and calling it a day, which is terrible in a totally different sort of way.
The Holiday oneshots were all aces, though, and the Infestation mini was surprisingly good, so I'm content that IDW has "figured Ghostbusters out", so to speak.
azrael
04-12-2011, 06:49 PM
then I will pick up ghostbusters whats the release date?
Venom
04-12-2011, 06:59 PM
Welp, I can't remember where we were posting replies from IDW but I just got mine. It was rather cookie-cutter, but stil hopeful:
Hey Rob,
Thanks for writing, the enthusiasm of you and other is very heartening.
We're definitely aware of Tristan and his great talent... there's a lot of people clamoring for him! It's too early to say what creative team we'll be going with, but your voice is heard!
Best,
IDW Publishing
Venom
04-12-2011, 07:20 PM
Pretty sure that was Venom's sadistic intention: just see how many WTFs he can trick Da 'Drome out of. ^_^
:shifty:
Well, the bomb was thrown by a cat.
Raph's Girl
04-12-2011, 10:04 PM
then I will pick up ghostbusters whats the release date?
Release date for the first issue is September.
http://i1.cdnds.net/11/13/550w_comics_ghostbusters_teaser.jpg
http://www.digitalspy.com/comics/news/a312164/ghostbusters-ongoing-announced-by-idw.html
CyberCubed
04-12-2011, 11:52 PM
Is anyone else e-mailing them reminding them to include the Turtle one-shots in the first TPB? Better to be safe than sorry.
They even have Mirage's TPB for reference of how to do it right.
Roseangelo
04-12-2011, 11:56 PM
Someone who went to WonderCon might be keeping in touch with IDW to help them get things right (hopefully). :tcool:
CyberCubed
04-12-2011, 11:59 PM
I got an e-mail back from IDW:
Thanks for writing, and we're glad you're excited! As for continuity, we'll be starting with our own new take and continuity- but there will be a healthy amount of honoring what has come before.
Best,
IDW Publishing
Well this seems interesting.
oldmanwinters
04-13-2011, 12:18 AM
Someone who went to WonderCon might be keeping in touch with IDW to help them get things right (hopefully). :tcool:
Hey, I read on this girl's blog (http://ninja-pizza.blogspot.com/2011/04/more-details-on-idws-comic-book-plans.html)that she actually interviewed IDW COO Greg Goldstein! I wonder if there is a connection?:tidea:
Jester
04-13-2011, 12:20 AM
Hey, I read on this girl's blog (http://ninja-pizza.blogspot.com/2011/04/more-details-on-idws-comic-book-plans.html)that she actually interviewed IDW COO Greg Goldstein! I wonder if there is a connection?:tidea:
Even so, that girl also said she saw the pilot of the new show and figures too, but she didn't show any pictures. It's probably bogus! :P
Release date for the first issue is September.
http://i1.cdnds.net/11/13/550w_comics_ghostbusters_teaser.jpg
http://www.digitalspy.com/comics/news/a312164/ghostbusters-ongoing-announced-by-idw.html Why does the black guy have to be in a small bubble in the corner?
DrSpengler
04-13-2011, 02:20 PM
Why does the black guy have to be in a small bubble in the corner?
I'm guessing because the main image is a parody of the commercial seen in the movie, which didn't include Winston. They probably could have put Winston in the commercial for the parody, though they chose faithfulness over that, so they included Winston in the corner so that he'd be in the picture.
Candy Kappa
04-13-2011, 02:25 PM
What DrSpengler said, seriously Xav. You haven't seen the movie?
TristanHuwJones
04-13-2011, 03:21 PM
Why does the black guy have to be in a small bubble in the corner?
:teek:....
Bjarni
04-13-2011, 04:15 PM
Even so, that girl also said she saw the pilot of the new show and figures too, but she didn't show any pictures. It's probably bogus! :P
>Ninja Pizza
>bogus
wtf am i reading?!? :tconfuse:
What DrSpengler said, seriously Xav. You haven't seen the movie? Yeah I have seen the movie. It does seem like Winston is the forgotten Ghostbuster alot of the time though.
DrSpengler
04-13-2011, 05:09 PM
Yeah I have seen the movie. It does seem like Winston is the forgotten Ghostbuster alot of the time though.
Heading dangerously off-topic here, but since Ghostbusters is a subject I'm just as empassioned about as TMNT...
Winston's strength as a character is that he's the "everyman" of the group; he's essentially the personification of the audience. While Peter, Egon and Ray all have multiple PHDs and backgrounds in hi-tech sciences and whatnot, Winston is the guy who applied for the Ghostbusting job by answering a want ad.
Because he's the "everyman", a lot of writers don't know what to do with him, which is a shame, since he has the potential to be the most interesting and amusing member of the group, or at least on par with the other three Ghostbusters.
Peter sees Ghostbusting as a means to being a rockstar or a celebrity, Ray sees it as a means to being a superhero and saving the world, and Egon sees it as an observational science like he's staring into a petri dish. But Winston is the only member of the group who sees it for what it really is: absolutely insane. He's the guy who'll raise his hand while they're on their way to fight a poltergeist made of sausages and say "This is completely nuts, you know that right?"
Winston really shouldn't be "the forgotten Ghostbuster", as he can be just as great a character as Peter, Ray or Egon. The hard part is finding a writer who "gets" him, though.
Hey, wait, weren't we talking about alien kung-fu frogs or something stupid like that? I'm confused...
Why does the black guy have to be in a small bubble in the corner?
That "black guy" has a name. :evil: According to the movie, he was hired on after that commercial was filmed.Yeah I have seen the movie. It does seem like Winston is the forgotten Ghostbuster alot of the time though.
Oh. Well, in that case, I agree with you. Poor Winston... :(
Winston really shouldn't be "the forgotten Ghostbuster", as he can be just as great a character as Peter, Ray or Egon. The hard part is finding a writer who "gets" him, though.
Too true... But, to my dismay, he was the most annoying character in The Videogame. Wasn't that supposed to be Peck's job? O_o
oldmanwinters
04-13-2011, 06:11 PM
Winston really shouldn't be "the forgotten Ghostbuster", as he can be just as great a character as Peter, Ray or Egon. The hard part is finding a writer who "gets" him, though.
Yeah, I hated it that Ernie Hudson didn't even make it onto the top billing in the movies, but I guess that's because he was just the replacement for Eddie Murphy (now that would have been interesting; probably not as good but interesting).
Also, in "The Devil to Pay" episode of RGB, it is revealed that Winston's hobby was Biblical Studies, which is sort of ironic with him being a "ghost"-buster but also a nice little nod to one of the scenes from the first movie. It was also my major in college.:)
Some great Winston lines in that episode too:
"I have sold my soul to a minor demon." lol:lol:
TristanHuwJones
04-13-2011, 06:12 PM
He comes off (as does everyone) far better in the Wii version of the game. The script is integrated into the game much, much better. Regardless, we're getting off topic -- thanks for the kind words regarding Ghostbusters, I'm excited, but I'm also really excited about IDW having the TMNT.
I can't be the only person thinking IDW = Transformers, IDW = TMNT, Transformers + TMNT = Awesome? You could have some kinda crazy awesome retro book -- Turtlevan Autobot anyone? Decepticon Technodrome?! There are a ******** of crazy fun stories in there! :)
oldmanwinters
04-13-2011, 06:16 PM
I can't be the only person thinking IDW = Transformers, IDW = TMNT, Transformers + TMNT = Awesome? You could have some kinda crazy awesome retro book -- Turtlevan Autobot anyone? Decepticon Technodrome?! There are a ******** of crazy fun stories in there! :)
Oh yeah, the crossover of the 21st century! Because we demanded it!:tlol:
DrSpengler
04-13-2011, 06:26 PM
Infestation seemed like IDW getting their feet wet when it comes to crossing over their licensed properties; seeing if there's a market for such a thing and seeing if they can pull it off.
In the end, none of those properties actually met through Infestation, but it's possible that they may in the future.
Hopefully it'll be done well. Crossovers often have the problem of being written via "checklist" and having no depth to them outside of "Yay! These two characters are on the same page together! LEMME GET MAH CAMERA!"
It all comes down to the writer, of course.
In regards to TMNT/Transformers, specifically, well, the Transformers are an inherently difficult property to crossover with, do mainly to their size and power levels making them hard to pull off Ye Olde "heroes trade their villains" plot.
I mean, out of the dozen Transformers/GI Joe crossovers we've gotten in the past 20 years, I'd only qualify 2, maybe 3 as being any good.
Now, Ninjta Turtles/GI Joe? That I could see working.
I mean. Dude. Ninjas. There ya go.
TristanHuwJones
04-13-2011, 06:50 PM
Infestation seemed like IDW getting their feet wet when it comes to crossing over their licensed properties; seeing if there's a market for such a thing and seeing if they can pull it off.
In the end, none of those properties actually met through Infestation, but it's possible that they may in the future.
Hopefully it'll be done well. Crossovers often have the problem of being written via "checklist" and having no depth to them outside of "Yay! These two characters are on the same page together! LEMME GET MAH CAMERA!"
It all comes down to the writer, of course.
In regards to TMNT/Transformers, specifically, well, the Transformers are an inherently difficult property to crossover with, do mainly to their size and power levels making them hard to pull off Ye Olde "heroes trade their villains" plot.
I mean, out of the dozen Transformers/GI Joe crossovers we've gotten in the past 20 years, I'd only qualify 2, maybe 3 as being any good.
Now, Ninjta Turtles/GI Joe? That I could see working.
I mean. Dude. Ninjas. There ya go.
It depends on which angle you take. If you were to take it as the the two cartoon shows crossing over (which I guess you could do now that IDW has access to both licenses), you could rock some pretty mad balls.
I can't be the only person thinking IDW = Transformers, IDW = TMNT, Transformers + TMNT = Awesome? You could have some kinda crazy awesome retro book -- Turtlevan Autobot anyone? Decepticon Technodrome?! There are a ******** of crazy fun stories in there! :)
O_O I vote YES! Never saw a Transformers show I liked, but that sounds awesome. If nothing else, they should make those into toys. :D
Jester
04-13-2011, 09:04 PM
I'm not sure which I'd rather see...a TMNT/Transformers crossover or a TMNT/Ghostbusters crossover. :D
oldmanwinters
04-13-2011, 09:09 PM
I'm not sure which I'd rather see...a TMNT/Transformers crossover or a TMNT/Ghostbusters crossover. :D
Who ya' gonna call?
The Monster Trapper Turtles!
http://www.tmnttoys.com/05figures/monstertrappers/review.html
Jester
04-13-2011, 09:15 PM
Or....
http://home.comcast.net/~cartoonistaaron/ghostbustin-raphael.jpg
Powder
04-13-2011, 09:35 PM
I'd MUCH rather see the TMNT crossover with Ghostbusters. I never got into Transformers or GI Joe (Unless for TF you count Beast Wars).
John Pannozzi
04-13-2011, 09:40 PM
Ya know, IDW is also the current publisher (last time I checked, at least) of Grimjack. I'm thinking that this could lead to the possibility of a certain TMNT-related backup story be reprinted down the line in its original form (including being in color, I hope)....
ToTheNines
04-13-2011, 09:52 PM
(Unless for TF you count Beast Wars).
Lmao, same here man.
Or....
http://home.comcast.net/~cartoonistaaron/ghostbustin-raphael.jpg
Where in the world did THAT come from? O_o
Jester
04-13-2011, 10:05 PM
It's a drawing by CartoonistAaron for Powder's "Toys that Never Were" thread in the Fan Art section.
Cowabunga Carl
04-13-2011, 10:34 PM
Well I just sent off my email to IDW. I'll post the responce I get if I get one.
That "black guy" has a name. :evil: Yeah but I couldn't remember it.
RskimB
04-14-2011, 05:06 AM
i'm cautiously optimistic
azrael
04-14-2011, 08:41 AM
his name is winston and he has seen **** that will turn you white.
his name is winston and he has seen **** that will turn you white.
O_o But... I'm already white.
Candy Kappa
04-14-2011, 02:21 PM
O_o But... I'm already white.
then you'll turn transparent:o
TheCanadiandrome
04-14-2011, 02:42 PM
Or....
http://home.comcast.net/~cartoonistaaron/ghostbustin-raphael.jpg
ahaha! that's awesome :tcool:
discordiatookie
04-14-2011, 03:42 PM
What the hell is this, some Ghostbusters forum that i've just clicked on? Take it elsewhere people, I got TMNT comics to discuss! Sheesh! :P
And I would much prefer a TMNT/Ghostbusters crossover than a TMNT/Transformers one. Don't know much about GI Joe to comment on that'un!
Slap-Happy
04-14-2011, 03:56 PM
They should make a arc where all of their 80s properties crossover.
Similar the current "Infestation", featuring The Transformers, Ghostbusters, G.I.Joe, and Star Trek characters eventually crossing over to defeat a zombie threat. Just add TMNT to that.
discordiatookie
04-14-2011, 03:59 PM
They should make a arc where all of their 80s properties crossover.
Similar the current "Infestation", featuring The Transformers, Ghostbusters, G.I.Joe, and Star Trek characters eventually crossing over to defeat a zombie threat. Just add TMNT to that.
Only if HeMan can join in! :P
Jester
04-14-2011, 04:54 PM
And Bucky O'Hare....wait?
BentonGrey
04-14-2011, 05:04 PM
And the Thundercats!
TristanHuwJones
04-14-2011, 05:09 PM
And Silverhawks! And Galaxy Rangers... and-and and Strawberry Shortcake... and-- wait, what?
Kendamu
04-14-2011, 05:19 PM
And the guys from Quantum Leap!!!!
No? You sure? Alright...
Jester
04-14-2011, 06:37 PM
Michael Knight or nothing!
azrael
04-14-2011, 06:56 PM
O_o But... I'm already white.
:trolleye:
So was the mayor, in the movie.
Venom
04-14-2011, 07:43 PM
Hey, what about My Little Pony? They even have wings!
Bjarni
04-14-2011, 08:49 PM
Biker Mice & Street Sharks VS. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
CyberCubed
04-15-2011, 12:02 AM
This is what happens when there's nothing new to discuss.
Jester
04-15-2011, 12:12 AM
This is what happens when there's nothing new to discuss.
We could just start a pointless new thread...but we figured, why bother.
ToTheNines
04-16-2011, 12:26 PM
For some reason, I hear Dwight Schrute's voice when I read Cybercubed's posts.
Jester
04-16-2011, 12:33 PM
For some reason, I hear Dwight Schrute's voice when I read Cybercubed's posts.
PYkWWnZm6-w
Redeemer
04-17-2011, 02:03 PM
Well I found this, it talks about what they r aiming for and even talks about a collected book with issues 1-11 of the original series, hard cover!!
http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=31647
azrael
04-17-2011, 02:17 PM
I was noticing something weird, well all of a sudden Gail is picking up a bunch of indy comics. Didnt say which ones or what for but just that she got a lot. Is she completely out of the question?
Jester
04-17-2011, 02:22 PM
Who, Gail Simone? I heard she was approached but had to turn it down.
azrael
04-17-2011, 02:31 PM
Thats what I heard.... I have just known her to read indy books I guess I wonder if it was a put off thing. Where was she approached?
Jester
04-17-2011, 02:34 PM
It was posted in this thread. Here. (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showpost.php?p=835630&postcount=247)
Venom
04-17-2011, 06:39 PM
Thats what I heard.... I have just known her to read indy books I guess I wonder if it was a put off thing. Where was she approached?
In the lady's bathroom stall at DC.
TristanHuwJones
04-17-2011, 07:30 PM
Doesn't she have an exclusivity contract with DC? Did I remember reading that somewhere around two years ago?
azrael
04-17-2011, 10:35 PM
I dont know I just found it odd.
LOL about the bathroom stall thing, was it at a con is what I ment.
azrael
04-19-2011, 01:14 PM
So we got roughly 3 months, before we see something in shops and 1-2 months in the previews book.
What does everyone expect to see first the HC or the new series, and as far as the new series what is something you can see happening in issue 1.
I expect the HC and New Series only a week apart, which I am equally excited for. As for Vol5 issue 1 I have a sneeky suspicion that its going to be more about splinter and shredder than the turtles.
If it were me I would have everything lead up to a one page splash of the TMNT at the end. On the cover keep it very simple a turtle shell with the new tmnt logo. I also wouldnt release the TMNT pics until after its dropped.
PizzaPower
04-19-2011, 06:59 PM
so when is the release date?
so when is the release date?
For any TMNT books? 2nd Quarter, 2011...
PizzaPower
04-19-2011, 07:55 PM
so probably in aug or sept.
Redeemer
04-19-2011, 09:18 PM
I jst cant wait for them to release issues 1-11 hardbook cover of the original series :D
azrael
04-19-2011, 09:24 PM
I jst cant wait for them to release issues 1-11 hardbook cover of the original series :D
Quoted for truth.... Anyone else expect a 2nd priniting of this?
Jester
04-19-2011, 09:25 PM
Quoted for truth.... Anyone else expect a 2nd priniting of this?
Depends on how large the initial print run is.
Redeemer
04-19-2011, 09:25 PM
Quoted for truth.... Anyone else expect a 2nd priniting of this?
Its not expected I posted a link of it in my first post
Here's to hoping they don't. Of all the TMNT trades in the world, those stories are beyond the most plentiful. Give some other stories a chance to shine already.
Roseangelo
04-19-2011, 09:31 PM
Quoted for truth.... Anyone else expect a 2nd priniting of this?
I'm expecting it to stay in print so long as sales support it.
azrael
04-19-2011, 10:07 PM
I want vol 1 and CAW arc in hardcover
John Pannozzi
04-21-2011, 11:27 AM
Here's a podcast in which Chris Ryuall (editor-in-chief and chief creative officier at IDW) discusses some of the company's plans ofr TMNT. (http://www.fictionalfrontiers.podcastpeople.com/posts/42512)
Roseangelo
04-21-2011, 01:46 PM
Here's a podcast in which Chris Ryuall (editor-in-chief and chief creative officier at IDW) discusses some of the company's plans ofr TMNT. (http://www.fictionalfrontiers.podcastpeople.com/posts/42512)
So I listened to all of that, and it was incredibly non-informative. Meh.
John Pannozzi
04-21-2011, 03:57 PM
So I listened to all of that, and it was incredibly non-informative. Meh.
Yeah, I only posted it because I found it through the IDW message board, and thought it would more interesting.
Venom
04-21-2011, 06:07 PM
Anyone care to give a rundown? Was it basically a rehash of what's already been said about their plans?
TristanHuwJones
04-21-2011, 06:21 PM
Pretty much, the only real light shone on the whole thing is that IDW were sussing it all out way longer than anyone seems to have realised.
CyberCubed
04-21-2011, 06:28 PM
Well its already almost May, don't they have to start showing previews if the first issue is supposed to be out around September or something?
Powder
04-21-2011, 06:30 PM
They don't have to do anything.
If we're lucky, maybe something will be seen at SDCC but I dunno how those things usually go so I'm not expecting much.
CyberCubed
04-21-2011, 06:36 PM
Don't they have to drum up interest for the new book with advertisements and solicitations? They said the series would be out by the end of summer, even if that means September, its only 3 months from now.
Powder
04-21-2011, 06:39 PM
Who knows? Maybe they're looking to have the TMNT return abrubtly/surprisingly...
Or we may be a few weeks away from advertisements!
With the TMNT, some companies seem to think they sell themselves (though we know that isn't always true).
Roseangelo
04-21-2011, 06:40 PM
Don't they have to drum up interest for the new book with advertisements and solicitations? They said the series would be out by the end of summer, even if that means September, its only 3 months from now.
How is September 3 months from now?
Solicitations could start as early as next month's Previews, but all it needs to be is something that says TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES ARE BACK! It doesn't mean they have to give the entire plot outline and/or even show any art.
Jester
04-21-2011, 06:45 PM
January, February March, and April.
May, June, July, and August.
September, October, November, December.
12 Months in a year!
CyberCubed
04-21-2011, 06:50 PM
How is September 3 months from now?
Solicitations could start as early as next month's Previews, but all it needs to be is something that says TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES ARE BACK! It doesn't mean they have to give the entire plot outline and/or even show any art.
Well I was also assuming it could come out during August. And since we're only 9 days away from being in May...
I'm just wondering why it sounds like they don't even have a creative team yet. Every single time they've been asked via e-mail it was something along the lines of, "we're still deciding on the creative team for the book and will announce something soon," or at least that's what they told me.
John Pannozzi
04-21-2011, 07:55 PM
It turns out that the CreeD Omnichronus (which will include the CreeD/TMNT crossover) will be released by IDW in August. (http://www.facebook.com/idwpublishing/posts/10150163855753279) Interesting.
PAAATE
04-22-2011, 01:51 AM
Every single time they've been asked via e-mail ... or at least that's what they told me.
How many times have you bugged them about this? Be honest! :P
That they tell people a creative team hasn't been decided yet, doesn't mean it's true.
And even if they haven't decided on one yet, a skilled writer could probably map out the first story arc in a few days or a week, and then have in the back of his/hers head where they want to take it from there... And then there's plenty of time to do the rest.
azrael
04-22-2011, 04:16 PM
IDW has said AUGUST for tmnt Stuff. I just asked on their Facebook page and they said August ... So about 3 months away since we are close enough to may..... I cant wait
CyberCubed
04-22-2011, 07:56 PM
I strongly believe the Turtles will all have different color bandanas, especially since this is not part of Mirage continuity. And also because its actually in color.
Sorry, Andrew.
azrael
04-23-2011, 07:22 AM
what does it matter about the color bandanas? I mean look how mature the first movie was with those different bandanas.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.