PDA

View Full Version : How would you like the comics to be collected by IDW?


CyberCubed
04-13-2011, 07:45 PM
Here's my view:

Volume 1

1st edition: #1-11 including Turtle/Fugitoid one-shots

2nd edition: #12-21. Includes Northampton through RTNY.

3rd edition: #22-33. Volume 1 one-shots.

4th edition: #34-46. The rest of the Volume 1 stories pre-City at War.

5th edition: #48-49 and City at War #50-62. #48/49 were setup for City at War.

Volume 2

Only edition: Collects all 13 issues.

Tales of the TMNT

Only edition: Collects all 7 issues plus Jim Lawson's, "Spinal Tapped" story, includes both old and new frontipieces.

Image:

1st edition: #1-12

2nd edition: #13-23

Special edition: Collects Image #24 and 25 of Andrew's finisher.

Tales of the TMNT V. 2

I'd have one volume collect about 11 issues each till we get through all 70 issues. The Turtle 4-parters would all be collected together separately.

Volume 4:

Collects every issue up to wherever PL is up to at about 12 issues each.

TMNT specials:

- Collects Turtle Soup, Challenges, all one-shots, back-up strips, Shell Shock stories, and Kevin Eastman Body Count issues.


And I'd also have separate TPB's collect the Archie stuff, if we ever get that far.


Looking through all of this, IDW is really going to have to put out a lot of trades if they're really going to get through it all. I hope sales are good enough to get everything collected.

Abnormal Freak
04-13-2011, 08:02 PM
That's probably how I'd do it, except collect the Image stuff in one collection (and I don't see Modeen and co.'s finisher being published "officially," but who knows). Alls I know is I don't want anything skipped for sake of continuity or canon. Just collect the $#!7 in the order it was originally released.

I'd also like full-color cover galleries for each collection, preferably showing the wraparound art when applicable.

John Pannozzi
04-13-2011, 08:49 PM
I've got a whole bunch of ideas for TMNT collected books, and here's a few to start with:


*”Mark Martin’s Complete TMNT”
TMNT vol. 1 #18, 22-23
“Lasagna Loves” (mini-comic)
Green-Grey Sponge-Suit Sushi Turtles (one-shot parody)
“Toyoduh in the Naked City” (from the color Turtle Soup #1)
“Velveeduh in The One That Got Away” (from Turtle Soup #2)"
“Viceroy in The One That Got Away” (from Turtle Soup #3)
“Pierrier in The Old Switcheroo!” (from Turtle Soup #4)

*”Rich Hedden and Tom McWeeney’s Complete TMNT”
TMNT vol. 1 #34, & 28-40
“Turtle Power!” (from the color Turtle Soup #1)
“The Maltese Turtle” (one-shot special)
“Yo-Ho-Ho! And a Bottle of Mutagen” (from TMNT Adventures Special #5)

*”Mark Bodé’s Complete TMNT”
TMNT vol. 1 #18 & 32 (both B&W and color versions)
“Times Pipeline” (one-shot special)
“Ninjara VS Mondo Dog Cathcer” (from TMNT Adventures Special #8)


That's how I would collect most of the crazier guest-creator issues, at least.

What I want to know is how the back-up stories from Tales of the TMNT vol. 2 should be collected? Should they be a part of proper Tales vol. 2 collections, or should they be shuffled off to a Shell Shock-type book with all the other back-ups and short stories? And for that matter, how should the main stories of Tales vol. 2 be collected? I'v come up with this crazy idea for all the Tales vol. 2 stories to be collected in the order of Splengs' timeline, but I don't know if the majority of Mirage TMNT comics fans here would think that would be particularly practical way to do it.

In any case, there are some short stories I feel deserve special placements in the collected books. For instance, maybe the first Vol. 1 book should have the story "Fifteen Years Later..." from Turtle Soup #4, because it serves as a nice complement to the very first issue, and even adds an extra layer and emotional impact to #1's story. Putting "Complete Carnage an' Radical" in the first Vol. 1 book would make the appearance of those characters later on in #28 less confusing to newcomers. I would like "Zog" from Tales vol. 2 inserted between TMNT vol. 1 #19 and 20, and "Temps" from Tales vol. 2 #46 inserted between TMNT vol. 1 #53 and 54, for hopefully obvious reasons:twink:. Inserting the Donatello: the Brain Thief miniseries between TMNT vol. 2 #9 and 10 might also be an interesting idea, same with putting the Michelangelo: The Third Kind mini between TMNT vol. 4 #5 and 6. And including the Super Turtles origin story from Tales vol. 2 #47 as a supplement in whatever book collects TMNT vol. 4 #7 would probably be best, considering that Tales vol. 2 #47 might seen a bit out of place with the other Tales story, what with being set in a different universe than the Mirage TMNT one and all.

Thorneyeagle
04-13-2011, 09:55 PM
I like the sounds of these collections these versions sound awesome...i am crossing my fingers on some good ones.

willtupper
04-14-2011, 12:31 PM
I'd like the comics to be collected in BOOKS. Book form, really, is the way that I would like to see them collected.

I figure that anything on top of that is just gravy :).

Candy Kappa
04-14-2011, 02:23 PM
I'd like the comics to be collected in BOOKS. Book form, really, is the way that I would like to see them collected.

I figure that anything on top of that is just gravy :).

no no no no, Scrolls all the way dude

Andrew NDB
04-14-2011, 02:38 PM
If it was me,

Book 1: #1-11, plus micros.

Book 2: #12-17, 19-26.

Book 3: #27-30, 33, 37 (preceded by Turtle Soup precursor story), 42 - 47.

Book 4: #48-62.

Book 5: Vol. 2 #1-13.

Book 6: Vol. 3, #1-23 (keep in mind these are significantly shorter than your average Mirage issue)

Various backups and other Turtle Soup/Plastron Cafe/etc. material sprinkled throughout where appropriate. Tales of the TMNT Vol. 1 sprinkled into the books where possible, with Tales of the TMNT Vol. 2 published as its own thing in massive omnibuses later.

TheCanadiandrome
04-14-2011, 02:42 PM
as long as it's good i'll take them any ways i can gets them

CyberCubed
04-15-2011, 11:13 AM
I kinda hope they go in order, but then that would mean if sales aren't good enough they'll just stop halfway.

Either way I think most of Volume 1-2 and the original Tales deserves to be collected first. If we get further than that, then Image, Tales V.2 should be next.

I'd say Volume 4 should be collected last, simply because it isn't finished yet. Plus its better to get the old stuff out first then something that's more recent.

Thorneyeagle
04-15-2011, 11:57 AM
Just curious...haven't been on IDW forums in a bit...but this thread probably do good over there...thats pressuming they follow it closely.

TristanHuwJones
04-15-2011, 04:21 PM
Just curious...haven't been on IDW forums in a bit...but this thread probably do good over there...thats pressuming they follow it closely.

Quoted for the truth.

CyberCubed
04-15-2011, 11:52 PM
I don't have an account on their forums. Someone else can post this thread there though if they'd like.

Venom
04-16-2011, 12:31 AM
Or you could take a minute to register there anc contribute to the cause. :P

jaymq
04-16-2011, 03:33 PM
In the order that they were released much like the OP said.

Cowabunga Carl
04-17-2011, 01:23 PM
I rather see the books pubished in order of story. I woudn't mind Tales stories mixed with main issues. To be able to pick up the trades and read the story in order would be awesom. Don't think it would happen, but it still would be great.