View Full Version : Hey guys, want to know something.
azrael
04-14-2011, 10:52 PM
Not really sure where to put this but I got in touch with some I am guessing high touch people at IDW. Well I am very pushy and only have about 6 months left of art school. I have already recieved Honor awards and my BAC. Well back to subject I got in touch with the current "tmnt editorial" and well I submitted some art. Nothing too much has happened but they wanted to see more, like a fight scene with Raph and Leo with the shredder popping up at the end so I did that. So Now they are saying they want a few more. Will you guys show some love or hate at IDW. Guys this would be a dream come true. Help me out please. I am sending more art in a day or so.
Thanks oh btw please feel free to move this around where it needs to be.
Also the page is in my fan art here: (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=33233)
Powder
04-14-2011, 10:56 PM
How'd you get in touch with these guys?
Venom
04-15-2011, 12:06 AM
Scott Dunbier is the editor so I guess he emailed him.
azrael
04-15-2011, 12:09 AM
Scott and Tom, So here is hoping guys. I need some feedback on my pics what I should/shouldnt do.
Oh, I thought you were asking us to start a campaign for ya over at IDW's boards. I'll check out your art in the morning. I'm too out-of-it to critique right now... and that's always the last process to go before consciousness. :tsleep:
azrael
04-15-2011, 03:10 AM
Hey thanks I would honestly love for more critiques I want to be a better artist and if I get this gig even if its for a 1-shot or a issue 0. Then you can bet your bottom dollar that it will be nothng but heart inside each panel/page.
Powder
04-15-2011, 03:23 AM
Proportions are poor, the "fighting" isn't well implied at all, needs to be more dynamic, the silhouette doesn't accurately depict the weapons (they're not well defined, just jagged & misshapen), no background to show the reader where they're fighting, there are some visual continuity errors (Leo has shoulder straps in one panel while not in another/Raph has pupils in one panel), sense of lighting is really off & there is no given source of light, & I have no idea what's going on in the second to last panel. Is Leo choking himself, stretching his knee, or catching a fist?
All due respect, though I would further encourage you to work on your art seeing how you obviously enjoy doing it, I wouldn't put my vote in for you at IDW. It's too crude for a published comic. I assume most of us have very high standards for how the turtles should look, especially considering how so many fans hated on Jim Lawson's simplified angular work of later years (though I myself don't share the same negative feelings).
I really like your art stye Azrael. Just keep on drawing and you will get much better.
azrael
04-15-2011, 10:10 AM
Thanks to both of you. Plus the add Eiko.
Samhain
04-16-2011, 06:01 PM
Hey thanks I would honestly love for more critiques I want to be a better artist and if I get this gig even if its for a 1-shot or a issue 0. Then you can bet your bottom dollar that it will be nothng but heart inside each panel/page.
Dude, I hate to break it to you but, if you need critique, you are not going to get a gig drawing a publicated comic book. Just saying. You are not horrible but I wouldn't buy a book if you were drawing it.
azrael
04-16-2011, 07:44 PM
Dude, I hate to break it to you but, if you need critique, you are not going to get a gig drawing a publicated comic book. Just saying. You are not horrible but I wouldn't buy a book if you were drawing it.
Your loss, I dont need critiques I want them. If you think people dont give critiques on major comic artist/titles because they are professional you sir/mam (not trying to offend I just dont know.) are foolish. If it wasnt for critiques no artist would ever get better. I asked for help even though powder's critique was the "harshest" I respect that cuz for 1 its useful for 2 it shows his love for the material and 3. I can tell he gets art.
I know I am not the best in the industry or the world, but I know where I stand. Your statement shows lack of knowledge in art, comic editorial, or how critiques work. When they say "David Finch was born to draw Batman." thats a critique of praise, where as yours is in a very negative response that does nothing but borderline troll. I know its your opinion and all but a worthless statement is a worthless statement.
Samhain
04-16-2011, 07:58 PM
Your loss, I dont need critiques I want them. If you think people dont give critiques on major comic artist/titles because they are professional you sir/mam (not trying to offend I just dont know.) are foolish. If it wasnt for critiques no artist would ever get better. I asked for help even though powder's critique was the "harshest" I respect that cuz for 1 its useful for 2 it shows his love for the material and 3. I can tell he gets art.
I know I am not the best in the industry or the world, but I know where I stand. Your statement shows lack of knowledge in art, comic editorial, or how critiques work. When they say "David Finch was born to draw Batman." thats a critique of praise, where as yours is in a very negative response that does nothing but borderline troll. I know its your opinion and all but a worthless statement is a worthless statement.
Dude, this is a message board. I was just giving my opinion. I may have not crituqed your work but I didn't say you sucked. I was simply stating that if people are saying
''Proportions are poor, the "fighting" isn't well implied at all, needs to be more dynamic, the silhouette doesn't accurately depict the weapons (they're not well defined, just jagged & misshapen), no background to show the reader where they're fighting, there are some visual continuity errors (Leo has shoulder straps in one panel while not in another/Raph has pupils in one panel), sense of lighting is really off & there is no given source of light, & I have no idea what's going on in the second to last panel. Is Leo choking himself, stretching his knee, or catching a fist? ''
You prob shouldn't be hoping for a ''gig'' at IDW. Dont be cocky.You gotta be high to think that. And to say I know nothing about art, comic editorial, or how critiques work doesn't make sense. You are either cut out to do a publicated comic or you are not. Granted, it's not always about the art, still, you gotta have eye candy.
But, if Liefeld can make a career in comics maybe you can too.8)
azrael
04-16-2011, 08:41 PM
i agree i was just excited when i did that i mean come on to be "in talks" working in somethinf i feel i love too much. my 2nd one is way better. i sent them the 1sr batch and got a reply they want more so im going to give them more.
one of my problems is when i "write" and draw its a flood if ideas. im like a a dog chasing a car tire, i have no idea what i would do if i actually got it.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.