View Full Version : Do you consider the Shredder to be the turtles's archenemy in Mirage comic
Keldor1578
04-21-2011, 04:16 AM
I don't feel that the Shredder was the turtles's archenemy since he only appears in one issue or four if count the worn clone Shredder and was not the main villain in Mirage comic.
Powder
04-21-2011, 04:23 AM
Yes I do. He was their entire motivation, he was the reason they were trained to be who they became. He haunted their dreams, "came back to life" various times (he was in more than 4 issues buddy) not to mention the Shredder mantle ultimately appeared 2-3 other times... C'mon. He was certainly a main villain to some extent, if not the main villain...
Jester
04-21-2011, 04:27 AM
Maybe the specter of the Shredder if not the man himself. Like Powder said, revenge is the crux of the story. Yoshi avenges Shen, Saki avenges Nagi, The Turtles avenge Yoshi, Shredder's forces (and the "clone" himself) avenge him. If any thing is the "main villain" in TMNT, it's revenge.
Kendamu
04-21-2011, 04:28 AM
He's not really an arch-enemy in the sense of being Lex Luthor or the Joker or Magneto, but he definitely is the "big one" that, if he was in an issue (or thought to be), you were supposed to be like "Uh-oh" when he appeared.
So, since the Turtles don't have much of a traditional returning rogues gallery, I'll just say "Yes" for the sake of simplicity.
discordiatookie
04-21-2011, 06:00 AM
Althoough not exactly related, I had this to say in a previous post:
Hmm, dunno if I would call him a 'minor' character. Although he is killed off in the first issue, he 'returns' to pretty much tear the turtles' and April's world apart in the Leo one shot/issue 10. Return To New York has a fair bit of Shredder action in it. City At War is about filling the void that the Shredder left (to simplify things). Several Tales issues have either the Shredder or the legacy of the Shredder featured (Shredder/Shark thingie, female Shredder, etc). Also, vol 4 (Leo making a Shredder snowman, the Battle Nexus Shredder,etc). In volume 2, I believe that Leo has an inner monologue about what his point is, when not battling Shredder/Foot. So although he does not appear in many comics, I don't think he could be classed as a 'minor character'.
Baxter is quite a huge bad guy in the comics also, but probably more so for April than the turtles...
ToTheNines
04-21-2011, 06:19 AM
No. TMNT isn't really a "superhero" book, so they don't have an archenemy.
FearlessLeader
04-21-2011, 07:18 AM
Peter says somewhere in the letter column for volume #4 that he would consider the Foot to be more close to the main adversaries of the Turtles, and that the Shredder is part of that; but not all encompassing.
I don't recall what issue nor the precis quote, but if people really want me to, I may sit down and look at all of them. :tgrin:
I agree with ToTheNines in saying I don't believe the Turtles really have an "archenemy" in the comics as I don't really consider them a "superhero" book.
Keldor1578
04-21-2011, 11:30 AM
For me the real the turtles's archenemy is the foot clan and the main villain in Mirage.
Spitfire
04-21-2011, 01:11 PM
Like I said in the IDW thread
The Foot are more of the turtles main villain. Shredder was the leader but he spends 2/3rds of the comics dead so you can hardly count him as the main baddie. If we're talking cartoon series I could agree but in the comics he's hardly anything.
I guess Peter agrees. I imagine if the OT never came out and implanted the idea in everyone's head that Shredder was the turtles #1 villain less people would think he is.
Candy Kappa
04-21-2011, 01:16 PM
Maybe the specter of the Shredder if not the man himself. Like Powder said, revenge is the crux of the story. Yoshi avenges Shen, Saki avenges Nagi, The Turtles avenge Yoshi, Shredder's forces (and the "clone" himself) avenge him. If any thing is the "main villain" in TMNT, it's revenge.
This...
No. TMNT isn't really a "superhero" book, so they don't have an archenemy.
... And this
Crobot91
04-22-2011, 06:46 PM
Arch enemies help define the heroes' cause and action; IMO Shredder did this too.
Candy Kappa
04-22-2011, 07:44 PM
Arch enemies help define the heroes' cause and action; IMO Shredder did this too.
depending on the canon I wouldn't call the turtles heroes, but the protagonists
Abnormal Freak
04-22-2011, 09:28 PM
He was their entire motivation, he was the reason they were trained to be who they became. He haunted their dreams [...]
So did the guy who shot Bruce Wayne's parents. Is he a leading antagonist? :p
Although I do view Shredder as "the big bad guy." Could be due to the cartoon and movies, dunno.
Andrew NDB
04-22-2011, 11:18 PM
Peter says somewhere in the letter column for volume #4 that he would consider the Foot to be more close to the main adversaries of the Turtles, and that the Shredder is part of that; but not all encompassing.
I agree with ToTheNines in saying I don't believe the Turtles really have an "archenemy" in the comics as I don't really consider them a "superhero" book.
I agree with all of this but at the end of the day Oroku Saki is the guy they were trained from the time of their mutation to one day go out and kill. That they managed to do so in the first issue doesn't really take away from the fact.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.