PDA

View Full Version : Realistically speaking, how far do you see them getting with the trades?


CyberCubed
05-25-2011, 06:10 PM
There are over 200+ issues in the Mirage comics, if you combine:

- Volume 1 + 4 TMNT one-shots
- Volume 2
- Image
- Volume 4
- Tales of the TMNT Volume 1 + Spinal Tapped story
- Tales of the TMNT Volume 2 + Leo/Raph/Mike/Don mini-series
- Specials and back-up strips

Then this is not including the possibility of Archie trades, which adds up to another almost 150 issues with all specials included.

How much of this should we realistically expect to be collected?

Spitfire
05-25-2011, 06:33 PM
I expect to see volumes 1, 2, 4, and the Tales volumes collected. This is the most likely situation. If 3 gets collected sweet but I'm not counting on it. I never expected to see Archie but if it happens I'd be quite pleased too, though my favorite arcs were already collected.

What I'd like to see is someone take advantage of the great timelines the fans have made and try and collect stuff in order. Meaning splitting the volumes up.

CyberCubed
05-25-2011, 07:07 PM
Considering Kevin Eastman was much more fond of the Image series than PL, I'm sure they'll collect Image once they finish Volume 2. Assuming they get that far.

PizzaPower
05-25-2011, 07:24 PM
cha well lets hope they get that far.

Thorneyeagle
05-25-2011, 09:42 PM
cha well lets hope they get that far.

One volume at a time guys...one volume at a time..we must spread the word and popularity of this comic.

FearlessLeader
05-25-2011, 09:43 PM
One volume at a time guys...one volume at a time..we must spread the word and popularity of this comic.

THIS!

We want to see things published then we just have to buy the collections they put out and encourage other people to do the same. :tgrin:

CyberCubed
05-25-2011, 09:44 PM
I kind of hope they collect the original 7 issue Tales soon, if only because they came out very early on in the franchises history, and introduced very important characters like Rat King and Leatherhead.

FearlessLeader
05-25-2011, 09:53 PM
I kind of hope they collect the original 7 issue Tales soon, if only because they came out very early on in the franchises history, and introduced very important characters like Rat King and Leatherhead.

Well Rat King won't show up in the regular comic line until City at War and Leatherhead not until an issue or two before that with the Dan Berger comic about him, so they have a few trades they can put out before we need their origin stories.

CyberCubed
05-25-2011, 10:03 PM
I'm just saying that before finishing all of Volume 1, they should put out a collected version of Tales of the TMNT similar to the one Mirage put out in 2007.

I just hope they remember to include Jim Lawson's, "Spinal Tapped" story, and the new frontipieces with the old Turtles.

wilddiverse
05-25-2011, 10:43 PM
I just hope they remember to include Jim Lawson's, "Spinal Tapped" story, and the new frontipieces with the old Turtles.

Ideally, the 10-page Nobody story from the 1989 Tales TPB would be included as well.

CyberCubed
05-26-2011, 08:43 PM
The only way I can see the bulk of this collected is if TMNT stays with IDW for a long time and they continually put out trades about every month or two.

How many TMNT trades would they release at a time, one per month? Because if its like one every two months or more, we're never going to get through it all.

PizzaPower
05-26-2011, 09:11 PM
well get through it all if they are popular, plus dont forget idw trades of there own tmnt series :)

ToTheNines
05-26-2011, 10:55 PM
Hopefully they get to Volume 2 at least. I sold mine as a lot.

It would be cool if they made a Volume 2 collected book in black and white... I loved the color in those books but I'm a B&W guy till the end.

CyberCubed
05-26-2011, 11:02 PM
I kind of figure anything that was black and white will remain so, and anything in color will stay color.

Its interesting because #33 of Volume 1 was done in color, so I wonder if that will remain in color when they reprint it alongside other BW issues in the same book.

azrael
05-27-2011, 11:39 AM
I hope IDW doesnt do what mirage did and everytime there was a reprint or collected version they release a "special" back up story. I dont support an ongoing just to have the people that dont wait and buy the tpb and get the cool bonus stuff.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
05-27-2011, 11:59 AM
Viacom is a pretty big company, so the risk of books not selling isn't going to be as much of a concern for them as it was for a company like Mirage. Here's hoping they reprint ALL of it. :tgrin:

Venom
05-27-2011, 01:46 PM
Viacom is a pretty big company, so the risk of books not selling isn't going to be as much of a concern for them as it was for a company like Mirage. Here's hoping they reprint ALL of it. :tgrin:

Viacom isn't the one printing the collections, whoever paid to use the license from Viacom is: in this case, IDW, who is not as huge a publisher as DC or Marvel. So if the collections do not perform at the level IDW needs them to in order to generate a profit, then they will stop producing them.

Archon_Turtle
05-27-2011, 05:49 PM
Viacom isn't the one printing the collections, whoever paid to use the license from Viacom is: in this case, IDW, who is not as huge a publisher as DC or Marvel. So if the collections do not perform at the level IDW needs them to in order to generate a profit, then they will stop producing them.

Though they could also just cut the print run down to compensate.

Adam
05-27-2011, 06:04 PM
Though they could also just cut the print run down to compensate.

I can't speak for IDW, but that's generally not how most publishers operate. What Venom is talking about is reaching a certain plateau that makes the books sustainable. If the numbers aren't adding up -- if sales on one volume aren't what they should be and pre-orders for the next volume aren't what they should be -- they might not be able to justify going back to press at all.

Trades and hardcovers are incredibly expensive to produce, and many are "in the red" for years before they recoup their costs. This is why so many comics are never collected.

And while I don't think the upcoming TMNT collections are in immediate danger, the reality is that books are often canceled because they are under-ordered.

SO -- if you want to ensure that the TMNT collections will come out consistently, the best thing you can do besides spreading the word is pre-ordering. I know some folks on these boards have already ordered the first volume from Amazon or wherever, and that's great -- but I'd like to STRONGLY encourage everyone to do the same for the subsequent volumes when they are solicited. The first volume will probably sell fine; reprints of seminal works usually do. It's the later volumes that we'll really have to support with our pre-orders to ensure that they actually get printed.

ToTheNines
05-27-2011, 07:31 PM
Well it's not like IDW had to pay the artists/authors of these stories and then print them. They're just sitting there collecting dust waiting to be collected at little cost to the publisher.

Adam
05-27-2011, 07:45 PM
Well it's not like IDW had to pay the artists/authors of these stories and then print them. They're just sitting there collecting dust waiting to be collected at little cost to the publisher.

IDW doesn't have to pay the artists for the material, but the idea that these collections can be produced "at little cost to the publisher" couldn't be more wrong.

As I said -- trades and hardcovers are incredibly expensive to produce. This is true whether publishers have the added expense of paying creators for the material or not. Hardcovers, particularly, cost A LOT to print -- especially when you're talking about the high-grade production & paper quality that you tend to get in a collection from a publisher like IDW.

azrael
05-28-2011, 12:17 AM
realistically, the old stuff is going to sell. im willing to say once they get over the hump (1-11) they are going to sale better. the return of shredder arc, shades of gray, and city at war all better come as hard cover, and be released before the lesser semi/non cannon stories are released. the rest should be tpb the only one i would love hc would be soul's winter. i would love if they made it through vol 4 or came out and said he was going to release vol 4 in hardcover. i would also love vol2 and 3 to be hc. the others for me can come in tpb form

ToTheNines
05-28-2011, 12:19 AM
IDW doesn't have to pay the artists for the material, but the idea that these collections can be produced "at little cost to the publisher" couldn't be more wrong.

As I said -- trades and hardcovers are incredibly expensive to produce. This is true whether publishers have the added expense of paying creators for the material or not. Hardcovers, particularly, cost A LOT to print -- especially when you're talking about the high-grade production & paper quality that you tend to get in a collection from a publisher like IDW.

I see what you're saying, but all I meant was that IDW never spent one dime on paying anyone to write/draw the books in the first place. Therefor it's more cost efficient for them in that regard.

Venom
05-28-2011, 12:49 AM
I see what you're saying, but all I meant was that IDW never spent one dime on paying anyone to write/draw the books in the first place. Therefor it's more cost efficient for them in that regard.

That's completely irrelevant. They paid Viacom for the permission to use that material to produce the collections and probably have to give them a cut of the profits as owners of the property.

Stop trying to create a rebuttal when there isn't one.

The bottom line is that if the collections fail to generate IDW a profit then no more will be made.

Adam
05-28-2011, 01:50 AM
That's completely irrelevant. They paid Viacom for the permission to use that material to produce the collections and probably have to give them a cut of the profits as owners of the property.
The bottom line is that if the collections fail to generate IDW a profit then no more will be made.

Exactly. IDW may not be paying the creators, but you can damn well bet they're paying in other ways (paying for licensing, paying percentages of profits, etc). We don't have access to the specifics of their deal, and even if it's a REALLY good deal for IDW -- none of this changes the point that I was making, which is that hardcovers are always expensive to print.


realistically, the old stuff is going to sell.

I hope you're right. But again, I would encourage everyone here -- if you want to see the less-famous TMNT material reprinted, like, say, Volume 2 -- then you need to support these collections. Keep up the pre-ordering! I know I'm preaching to the converted on these forums, but if they solicit a collection for Volume 2, and the advance orders are too low -- they may decide not to go to print. THAT'S how pre-orders can make or break books.

azrael
05-28-2011, 07:21 AM
I will keep pre-ordering, I wish they were cheaper but these better be the best damn hardcover I own quality wise.

Cowabunga Carl
05-29-2011, 01:40 PM
I think if you look at what IDW is doing with GI Joe you don't have to worry. They are reprinting everything. Right now it is a great time to be a Joe fan. I don't see any problem with them getting all the TMNT books out if there is a demand for them.

CyberCubed
05-29-2011, 05:11 PM
I think if you look at what IDW is doing with GI Joe you don't have to worry. They are reprinting everything. Right now it is a great time to be a Joe fan. I don't see any problem with them getting all the TMNT books out if there is a demand for them.

How much did the GI Joe trades sell?

Cowabunga Carl
05-30-2011, 09:29 AM
I don't have numbers but the fact that they are pumping out all the Joe books even the DDP stuff should speak for its self.

On a different note do you always have to make such negative threads?

CyberCubed
05-30-2011, 11:08 AM
Well I am trying to be realistic. I wonder how far we could get before they cancel the trades.

azrael
05-30-2011, 12:24 PM
[QUOTE=CyberCubed;852497]Well I am trying to be realistic. I wonder how far we could get before they cancel the trades.[/QUOT

If you were you would understand that the TMNT never cancel they take breaks. ;)

Just trollin ya