PDA

View Full Version : The Irony of Eastman and IDW


Jimmy Coconuts
05-26-2011, 02:08 PM
Hi guys.

I saw this re-tweeted last week. Do you think this short article has a point or is it needless hatin' ?

http://www.bleedingcool.com/2011/05/20/kevin-eastman-working-for-hire-on-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles/

Spitfire
05-26-2011, 02:12 PM
If they didn't respect Eastman they'd say those things. Would someone really be stupid enough to tell Stan Lee to his face that they can write Spider-man better then he could? I don't think so. Eastman may not be Jack Kirby famous in the comic world but he's still known and one of the biggest independent comic success stories. He will get respect and I'm sure he's not trying to impose his ideas so much as guide the new guys in the right direction so they don't do anything to piss off the pre-established fans.

Roseangelo
05-26-2011, 02:14 PM
Well, I wouldn't call that hating, really, but the person who wrote it is clueless. Kevin didn't sell anything to MTV (or Viacom/Nickelodeon). I think Kevin was just presented with an opportunity to tell TMNT stories again, and he took it. Nothing wrong with that.

CyberCubed
05-26-2011, 02:16 PM
I'm also under the impression that Kevin wouldn't exactly be so strict with what Tom Waltz or other writers would want to do, unlike PL who wanted more full control over what they did.

I seriously doubt PL would ever let a character like, "Old Hob" exist, so I'm glad Eastman is more open to these things.

Jimmy Coconuts
05-26-2011, 02:25 PM
Well, I wouldn't call that hating, really, but the person who wrote it is clueless. Kevin didn't sell anything to MTV (or Viacom/Nickelodeon). I think Kevin was just presented with an opportunity to tell TMNT stories again, and he took it. Nothing wrong with that.

Clueless - no doubt. I suppose hating is a bit of a misnomer but it did seem like it had a bit of a negative angle to it.

My feeling is that a) it's awesome that Eastman is working on a TMNT comic and b) he wouldn't have gotten involved if he didn't think the setup was a fair one.

Adam
05-26-2011, 02:48 PM
Would someone really be stupid enough to tell Stan Lee to his face that they can write Spider-man better then he could? I don't think so.

You'd be wrong. This has happened to Stan, and many other creators in comics. Kieth Giffen, creator of Lobo, was famously told by one editor at DC, "Lobo wouldn't do that."

That being said -- the article is pretty lame. Rich Johnston is a hack who trolls message boards and Twitter feeds, cherry-picking the slightest inflammatory statements, and attempts to drum up fake controversies by making headlines out of them. He's seriously the bottom-of-the-barrel scum of comics journalism.

It's true that Eastman was (and is) a champion for creator rights. Part of creator rights entails the creators getting to decide what to do with their creations -- even if that means selling them. That's their choice to make. Eastman and Laird have both made choices they seem to be happy with. Clearly, Eastman has a different relationship to the property than he once did -- that's stating the obvious. And clearly, Eastman is happy about what's happening with IDW -- so, unless he starts feuding with them in the future -- who cares?

Point is -- we really shouldn't waste too much energy worrying about this.

Master Splinter
05-26-2011, 03:02 PM
That being said -- the article is pretty lame. Rich Johnston is a hack who trolls message boards and Twitter feeds, cherry-picking the slightest inflammatory statements, and attempts to drum up fake controversies by making headlines out of them. He's seriously the bottom-of-the-barrel scum of comics journalism.

This is very true. While I do check the site every once in a while I always seem to imagine Comic Book Guy writing every article...

http://img638.imageshack.us/img638/3368/comicbookguyc.jpg

-ms

Jimmy Coconuts
05-26-2011, 04:47 PM
Y
That being said -- the article is pretty lame. Rich Johnston is a hack who trolls message boards and Twitter feeds, cherry-picking the slightest inflammatory statements, and attempts to drum up fake controversies by making headlines out of them. He's seriously the bottom-of-the-barrel scum of comics journalism.


I'd never been to the site before. Sounds pretty bogus. I now know to avoid.

Andrew NDB
05-26-2011, 04:49 PM
What a stupid article.

oldmanwinters
05-26-2011, 05:03 PM
Wow, I wonder how much he got paid to write those five sentences that are muddied with a false fact and the lack of a clear thesis.

TristanHuwJones
05-26-2011, 05:26 PM
Kinda smells like sour grapes. It's a really pointless article, which happens a fair bit with Bleeding Cool, but a lot of what pops up over there is generally on the money (the whole Rob Granito thing for example). I tend to visit Comics Alliance who had the exclusive on a lot of the interviews and news. Better articles, and it doesn't feel like there's an agenda behind a lot of it (if that makes sense).

There are other ways this could've ben brought to peoples' attention without belittling Kevin, which this seems to.

Adam
05-26-2011, 05:38 PM
Kinda smells like sour grapes. It's a really pointless article, which happens a fair bit with Bleeding Cool, but a lot of what pops up over there is generally on the money (the whole Rob Granito thing for example). I tend to visit Comics Alliance who had the exclusive on a lot of the interviews and news. Better articles, and it doesn't feel like there's an agenda behind a lot of it (if that makes sense).

There are other ways this could've ben brought to peoples' attention without belittling Kevin, which this seems to.

Yeah -- there's always an agenda with Johnston. Incredibly telling are his interviews with Image publisher Eric Stephenson, in which Johnston asks ridiculously leading questions and makes statements that -- since he's actually been an Image creator himself (Johnston wrote the 2010 one-shot Chase Variant) -- are claims that he knows to be false.

He works in manufactroversies.

Krys
05-26-2011, 05:43 PM
Why is this even a article?
Completely pointless drivel.

Jester
05-26-2011, 06:32 PM
I agree with Krysie-Kiwi. It's barely an article. And in the 5 sentences that make up this...paragraph??...he gets his facts wrong. Laird sold TMNT to Nick/Viacom. Kevin left the franchise almost a decade ago, and probably saw now as a good time to come back, or was approached by IDW and he thought, "Why not? Could be fun."

PizzaPower
05-26-2011, 07:48 PM
Well, I wouldn't call that hating, really, but the person who wrote it is clueless. Kevin didn't sell anything to MTV (or Viacom/Nickelodeon). I think Kevin was just presented with an opportunity to tell TMNT stories again, and he took it. Nothing wrong with that.
i agree, he sold the rights to peter, lol.

ChetTurtle
05-27-2011, 07:00 AM
I read the article, then the thread and am surprised this guy has a reputation!! Yet it is a bad one. He seems like one of those people who get into YouTube comment fights and stuff. And yeah, Eastman to Laird, Laird to Viacom.

Why do I feel the need to repeat others? Meh.:tconfuse: