PDA

View Full Version : Tmnt


RiseAbove873
05-30-2011, 12:29 PM
Do you guys consider TMNT as part 4?

LeoNerdo
05-30-2011, 12:40 PM
Yes I do, based on what I remember was said by the production team before the film's release. And also the fact that it didn't re-tell the origin and had the scene with the trophy case/shelf.

Redeemer
05-30-2011, 01:02 PM
Yes I do, based on what I remember was said by the production team before the film's release. And also the fact that it didn't re-tell the origin and had the scene with the trophy case/shelf.

I would have to say I agree:P

They were actaully suppose to make a part 5. Shredder was rumored to return, but then they decided to remake the movie series and start with a dark comic adaptation which made me totally stoked!!! Than a las Nick bought TMNT and it went down the drain, but now there is alot of hope!

Turo602
05-30-2011, 01:17 PM
Nah, I really don't count it. Some things didn't make sense or fit with the previous movies but I enjoyed the references.

Redeemer
05-30-2011, 01:33 PM
Nah, I really don't count it. Some things didn't make sense or fit with the previous movies but I enjoyed the references.

Like what???

Candy Kappa
05-30-2011, 01:34 PM
not as the 4th movie in the film canon. It got some references from the previous films, but it is not TMNT IV

Redeemer
05-30-2011, 01:37 PM
not as the 4th movie in the film canon. It got some references from the previous films, but it is not TMNT IV

For me I jst think it is bc of the wall at the end and what Karia said when fighting the turtles

ToTheNines
05-30-2011, 01:39 PM
For me I jst think it is bc of the wall at the end and what Karia said when fighting the turtles

What did she say?

Turo602
05-30-2011, 01:39 PM
Like what???

I can't recall at the moment, I haven't seen the movie in years but I know some things didn't fit well and whenever I watch the movie again it'll come back to me.

Redeemer
05-30-2011, 03:24 PM
What did she say?

This isn't a exact quote. She said something towards the end. "Thank you for your help, but next time we meet we will not be on the same side, a certain member of your past will return"

And the turtles looked at each other and began to say shredder.. So That really hints to me that this is Movie cannon

I can't recall at the moment, I haven't seen the movie in years but I know some things didn't fit well and whenever I watch the movie again it'll come back to me.

U probably took one too many hits from ur bro :lol:

Candy Kappa
05-30-2011, 03:55 PM
This isn't a exact quote. She said something towards the end. "Thank you for your help, but next time we meet we will not be on the same side, a certain member of your past will return"

And the turtles looked at each other and began to say shredder.. So That really hints to me that this is Movie cannon

It is stated in the beginning of the film that the turtles have defeated Shredder

ToTheNines
05-30-2011, 04:02 PM
This isn't a exact quote. She said something towards the end. "Thank you for your help, but next time we meet we will not be on the same side, a certain member of your past will return"

And the turtles looked at each other and began to say shredder.. So That really hints to me that this is Movie cannon

But The Shredder is a part of the turtles' past in literally every version of Ninja Turtles. So why would that link this to the movies? Just because they were both given theatrical releases means nothing.

Gordon hinting at the Joker at the end of Batman Begins did NOT mean it was tied to the previous Batman movies. But he was going to show up because he's a classic Batman villain (Just like Shredder's a classic Ninja Turtles villain).

sdp
05-30-2011, 09:24 PM
No, because it is not.

Kevin Munroe mentioned it wasn't actually part 4 but a new take all he mentioned is that all you needed to know was that the Shredder had been defeated (which has happened in most every TMNT continuity), he did mention you could take it as a loose sequel to the first and "maybe" the second and I wanted to believe for the longest time that this was part 4 like a lot of fans but but it makes perfect sense and after a while I realized that this is a new universe. First of all it makes no sense, the turtles are teenagers yet live in the present day while the original three movies were in the present day in the early 90s. not to mention the universes are very different, the live action movies were in a more "realistic" setting than the TMNT 2007 film is. The trophy room is more of an easter egg and even still nothing really explicitly says its in the movie continuity, Shredders helmet is meaningless as is the canister as those are parts of every single TMNT lore as is the Time Scepter, not to mention the trophy room also includes Mousers and Triceraton Guns, things that the movie turtles never did not to mention would feel out of place in the continuity of the first three movies. The prequel comics also has Silver Sentry but that doesn't mean its in 2k3 continuity. This isn't mentioning that April is not a reporter here. The 2007 film is its own continuity and had that movie series continued more contradictions would have been made.

Now on the other hand the fan hated show The Next Mutation actually seems pretty explicitly to be in continuity with the Live Action movies, theres enough connections, of course the fandom for the most part doesn't want to consider it because they don't want the movie universe to be "tainted" by TNM but yeah TNM is more of a sequel to the live action movies than the fourth movie is. Yet more fans will try to shoehorn the very different 2007 film universe just because its a movie.

Revan
05-30-2011, 10:07 PM
No, because it is not.

Kevin Munroe mentioned it wasn't actually part 4 but a new take all he mentioned is that all you needed to know was that the Shredder had been defeated (which has happened in most every TMNT continuity), he did mention you could take it as a loose sequel to the first and "maybe" the second and I wanted to believe for the longest time that this was part 4 like a lot of fans but but it makes perfect sense and after a while I realized that this is a new universe. First of all it makes no sense, the turtles are teenagers yet live in the present day while the original three movies were in the present day in the early 90s. not to mention the universes are very different, the live action movies were in a more "realistic" setting than the TMNT 2007 film is. The trophy room is more of an easter egg and even still nothing really explicitly says its in the movie continuity, Shredders helmet is meaningless as is the canister as those are parts of every single TMNT lore as is the Time Scepter, not to mention the trophy room also includes Mousers and Triceraton Guns, things that the movie turtles never did not to mention would feel out of place in the continuity of the first three movies. The prequel comics also has Silver Sentry but that doesn't mean its in 2k3 continuity. This isn't mentioning that April is not a reporter here. The 2007 film is its own continuity and had that movie series continued more contradictions would have been made.

Munroe said (http://animatedviews.com/2007/director-kevin-munroe-on-tmnt/) There’s so much in the Turtles’ past, as far as adventures and stuff. So when we first started, we were trying to find what we were going to say – what was going to be lore and what wasn’t, for the movie. At the end of the day, we just realized, ‘Let’s just make the whole thing lore.’

Basically, they’ve lived all these adventures, and they’ve defeated all these villains. Now, they find themselves without direction, because they don’t have a common enemy to fight anymore.

He seems to suggest that the events of the first 3 movies and the 4kids series have all transpired. Personally, I always just looked at it from the same point of view I took Superman Returns.

ToTheNines
05-30-2011, 10:33 PM
Splinter's ear...

April's job...

New lair...

sdp
05-30-2011, 10:42 PM
Well you can search Munroe's posts (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/member.php?u=2775) here in the drome, he was asked this constantly and yeah his stance that never changed was "all you need to know is that Shredder has been defeated and the turtles have had adventures", he never explicitly stated that it wasn't in continuity since he didn't want to make people angry and left it ambiguous because of it. But yeah his responses pretty much confirm that he saw this as a new universe, and at first I tried to shoehorn it as TMNT 4 but after re-watching it on DVD/reading the prequel comic I realized it really made no sense to do so just because its a movie when its clear this is a different universe.

TheCanadiandrome
05-30-2011, 11:21 PM
i dunno, maybe it's a stand alone thing

Eiko
05-30-2011, 11:33 PM
I always thought it was a stand alone till the end where we see Shredder's Helmet and that scepter now im not so sure.

ToTheNines
05-31-2011, 06:37 AM
I always thought it was a stand alone till the end where we see Shredder's Helmet and that scepter now im not so sure.

How does that connect them? The turtles never get Shredder's helmet in the movies, they just leave him burried. Plus, he grinds it up in SotO the have all the spikes on it.

BubblyShell22
05-31-2011, 08:10 AM
I'd say it's a different universe as it's true that the Turtles never retrieved Shredder's helmet, unless Splinter somehow retrieved it later as a trophy. Or maybe it's a replica of Shredder's helmet to signify that the Turtles have defeated him. That would make sense.

Eiko
05-31-2011, 09:10 AM
How does that connect them? The turtles never get Shredder's helmet in the movies, they just leave him burried. Plus, he grinds it up in SotO the have all the spikes on it.

Oh yea that right they never did. It has been awhile since i have watched those movies.

Redeemer
05-31-2011, 12:21 PM
Splinter's ear...

April's job...

New lair...

New Lair??? When Mike is skate boarding down he has to go down that whole like in the third movie.

Also when going down the stairs its the exact same set of stairs.

I cant recall if I saw the rail car system.

But as far as Monroe stating it as not being cannon then I guess it ends the discussion, but I will always considerate as cannon personally

gobo
05-31-2011, 01:59 PM
Do you guys consider TMNT as part 4?
Hell no. Splinter's ear was all the reason I needed. Since Superman Returns was brand-new at the time, I wasn't at all surprised that they tried to make it a pseudo-sequel.

ToTheNines
05-31-2011, 02:08 PM
But as far as Monroe stating it as not being cannon then I guess it ends the discussion, but I will always considerate as cannon personally

Not that I discourage discussion, but personal canon is all that should really matter to one's own self.

Master Splinter
05-31-2011, 02:08 PM
I don't really consider it a sequel. Just a new take on the TMNT with a couple of homages to the old movie(s)...

-ms

Xav
05-31-2011, 04:53 PM
The trophy room is more of an easter egg and even still nothing really explicitly says its in the movie continuity, Shredders helmet is meaningless as is the canister as those are parts of every single TMNT lore as is the Time Scepter The Time Scepter is not in every TMNT lore. Splinter's ear... Kevin Munroe explained that he had otoplasty.

sdp
05-31-2011, 05:09 PM
The Time Scepter is not in every TMNT lore. .

http://tmnt.wikia.com/wiki/Time_Scepter

Mirage, TMNT III, TMNT 2007, 2k3, Videogames. I'd say its appeared in plenty TMNT lore.

CyberCubed
05-31-2011, 05:35 PM
I consider it the 4th movie. The movie prequel comics Mirage put out fill the gap between the third and fourth movie.

ToTheNines
05-31-2011, 05:37 PM
I consider it the 4th movie. The movie prequel comics Mirage put out fill the gap between the third and fourth movie.

Correct. Just like 5 square pegs in one round hole.

Powder
05-31-2011, 06:00 PM
I consider it the 4th movie. The movie prequel comics Mirage put out fill the gap between the third and fourth movie.

I guess I now have a reason to check those out!

CyberCubed
05-31-2011, 06:03 PM
People didn't read the movie prequel comics?

They show how Raphael first became the Nightwatcher, Leo's adventures in the jungle where he earns his nickname, Don sees the vampire bat prior to the movie, and April begins working for Winters.

We also discover through dialogue that the movie Turtles met the Triceratons and Utroms at some point.

Powder
05-31-2011, 06:06 PM
I'm sure many people did, I'm just one of the ones who didn't.
I've read Aprils, but only 'cause it was tossed in for free with an order of comics I got on ebay.
Even so, I wasn't impressed with it so I never bothered to check out the other ones.

sdp
05-31-2011, 06:11 PM
Theres also the Kids books "Legend of Yaotl" and "Who's the Nightwatcher", don't know if there were any more, they were meant for kids but were prequels and did have information not in the actual movie or comic.

Redeemer
05-31-2011, 07:34 PM
People didn't read the movie prequel comics?

They show how Raphael first became the Nightwatcher, Leo's adventures in the jungle where he earns his nickname, Don sees the vampire bat prior to the movie, and April begins working for Winters.

We also discover through dialogue that the movie Turtles met the Triceratons and Utroms at some point.

????WTF really were can I read these??

CyberCubed
05-31-2011, 07:38 PM
A trade collecting them was also released way back in 2007, along
with a comic adaption of the movie itself, similar to the Archie adaptions of the old movies.

Krys
05-31-2011, 07:40 PM
^^yea i would like to know also, I always thought TMNT was just more of a loose sequel and not a direct link to the third tmnt movie.

EDIT: never mind you answered it :P

Candy Kappa
05-31-2011, 07:59 PM
People didn't read the movie prequel comics?

those comics do not "connect the dots" between the films. They're just Prequel comics that expands the TMNT movie's universe for those who want to read them

ToTheNines
05-31-2011, 08:15 PM
I guess I now have a reason to check those out!

Trust me, they don't connect TMNT to the original movies. I have no idea what he's talking about.

However, you definitely need to read the Leonardo issue. That's a great story and it makes sense of some of the stupid stuff in the movie. Mike's is good, and the other two aren't a big deal but you should definitely get the Donatello issue because it's drawn by Lawson, who tweaks his style to resemble the movie designs.

gobo
05-31-2011, 08:17 PM
^ Another idea that seems directly lifted from Superman Returns...

Powder
05-31-2011, 09:07 PM
Trust me, they don't connect TMNT to the original movies. I have no idea what he's talking about.

Now I've lost interest.

However, you definitely need to read the Leonardo issue. That's a great story and it makes sense of some of the stupid stuff in the movie. Mike's is good, and the other two aren't a big deal but you should definitely get the Donatello issue because it's drawn by Lawson, who tweaks his style to resemble the movie designs.

Now I've gained interest again!

ToTheNines
05-31-2011, 09:43 PM
Now I've gained interest again!

Lol, good to hear.

Also, the Leo issue isn't exactly a prequel. Most of it's a prequel, but part of it is intertwined with his conversation with April while in South America. I consider it a "must read".

Xav
06-01-2011, 08:07 AM
http://tmnt.wikia.com/wiki/Time_Scepter

Mirage, TMNT III, TMNT 2007, 2k3, Videogames. I'd say its appeared in plenty TMNT lore. Yes but you said every single lore.

sdp
06-01-2011, 11:45 AM
The only thing consistent in every TMNT lore is they are mutated turtles.

Bauer536
06-01-2011, 10:36 PM
The Leonardo Prequel sounds interesting, but I’m not too keen on them adding a few characters that I’m glad the movie didn’t use. As much as I don’t like the Ancient One, he looks better in this issue (because he’s wearing a robe . . . I think). I’m just hoping in this one, he doesn’t call Leo a “Poor, dumb, kumquat” like he did in the 2k3 series (I hated that line!).:tmad: Plus, what is the real reason Leo was sent on this trip? Was it punishment or was it a reward? I think it was a reward after looking at this page from the Raphael issue, but I may be climbing the wrong tree.:tconfuse:

Candy Kappa
06-02-2011, 06:22 AM
what is the real reason Leo was sent on this trip?

to become a better leader

ChetTurtle
06-02-2011, 06:31 AM
The only thing consistent in every TMNT lore is they are mutated turtles. LOL:D (But actually a good point)

Plus, what is the real reason Leo was sent on this trip? Was it punishment or was it a reward? I think it was a reward after looking at this page from the Raphael issue, but I may be climbing the wrong tree.:tconfuse:
I haven't actually read the comic although I would guess it was for similar reasons to the 2k3 series (He was unsatisfied with his crurrent training)

I think it is as others have said it's own universe but closest to the first 3 movies and 2k3. Was it's "screen" in turtles forever separate to the movies?

Revan
06-02-2011, 08:47 AM
As much as I don’t like the Ancient One, he looks better in this issue (because he’s wearing a robe . . . I think). I’m just hoping in this one, he doesn’t call Leo a “Poor, dumb, kumquat” like he did in the 2k3 series (I hated that line!).:tmad:

nope. same old ancient one

http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/pics/ancientone.jpg

Bauer536
06-02-2011, 08:50 AM
Thanks, Neutrino. What happens next? Do you have the next page?

Revan
06-02-2011, 08:52 AM
I have all the books but I don't believe I should be posting them here

buy them. they are worth the read, if only for some entertainment

Bauer536
06-02-2011, 09:09 AM
Alright. Can you at least tell me what happens? I'm sorry. Why is Ancient One insulting him and calling him names that are not true? I've asked a lot of people here, and many outside of Technodrome, if any of the turtles were stupid. They say "no," which makes me believe that Leonardo is intelligent. Just tell me, why is he being called "stupid" from this guy? I don't like it.:tcry::tmad::tgrumble::tshifty:

FearlessLeader
06-02-2011, 10:29 AM
Alright. Can you at least tell me what happens? I'm sorry. Why is Ancient One insulting him and calling him names that are not true? I've asked a lot of people here, and many outside of Technodrome, if any of the turtles were stupid. They say "no," which makes me believe that Leonardo is intelligent. Just tell me, why is he being called "stupid" from this guy? I don't like it.:tcry::tmad::tgrumble::tshifty:

Do you ever watch old Martial Arts films or old Samurai films??

It's kind of a staple that the wise Sensei calls the younger student names. Takes them down a peg or two and makes them realize they are still young and have a lot to learn about the world around them.

Pretty much everything about the Ancient One is an homage to this which I why I like him so much.

Also basically what happens next is the Ancient One disarms Leo, calls him a "baby Ninja" and tell him he still has a lot to learn about the world and the "five fold path" which is what Leo is suppose to be out learning about on his training mission. Which pretty much just plays into what I say above.

Revan
06-02-2011, 11:41 AM
Alright. Can you at least tell me what happens? I'm sorry. Why is Ancient One insulting him and calling him names that are not true? I've asked a lot of people here, and many outside of Technodrome, if any of the turtles were stupid. They say "no," which makes me believe that Leonardo is intelligent. Just tell me, why is he being called "stupid" from this guy? I don't like it.:tcry::tmad::tgrumble::tshifty:


What fearless leader said

Basically, Splinter send Leo to the jungle to learn the "five fold path." Ancient one decides the best way to teach Leo is to humble him; make him understand that though he thinks he is good as Splinter, he still has much to learn. Then Ancient one tells Leo one does not face the five fold path alone, the path begins and ends with others. Leo realizes he needs to return home.

Ancient one does not really think Leo is stupid. His comments are merely a teaching technique

Bauer536
06-02-2011, 01:58 PM
What fearless leader said

Basically, Splinter send Leo to the jungle to learn the "five fold path." Ancient one decides the best way to teach Leo is to humble him; make him understand that though he thinks he is good as Splinter, he still has much to learn. Then Ancient one tells Leo one does not face the five fold path alone, the path begins and ends with others. Leo realizes he needs to return home.

Ancient one does not really think Leo is stupid. His comments are merely a teaching technique

Ya know, funny you say that. I originally thought he said those things because it was how he trained his students. I guess that makes me feel a whole lot better now. I must have been right in the beginning, but doubted that was the answer. Also, I've been taking the word "stupid" too literally. It's really like an expression, like slang. It does not always define someone's intelligence level, but really, the stupid thing they did at the moment. Which goes to say: there's a lot of smart people in the world, but those same people can be idiots, too. Everyone has those moments.:tsmile: