PDA

View Full Version : The TMNT Discussion Thread


Jester
06-04-2011, 12:05 AM
So while watching TMNt as part of my marathon, I realized I don't really like it. Karai's voice actor is lifeless, the 13 monster plot is ridiculous, the dialogue at times is really bad.
Example: Splinter to Winters (after he stops him from helping the Turtles): "They can defeat them, they are a team." Really? So the 4 stone generals aren't a team? Is the Foot not a team? How does that work in sporting contests? "Hey Splinter, who's going to win the NBA finals, Mavericks or Heat?" "They can defeat them, they are a team." "WHICH TEAM!" "They can defeat..." "UH!"

CyberCubed
06-04-2011, 01:13 AM
The family dynamic and the Leo/Raph fight was the highlight of the movie. I liked the animation as well.

Eiko
06-04-2011, 03:00 AM
What really got to me about TMNT was the fact that Don and Mike where hardly even in the movie it was all Leo and Raph there fighting. Gets old very fast just hope in the new Turtle movie Don and Mike get some spotlight.

Turo602
06-04-2011, 03:36 AM
I guess what he meant by "team" is that they are trained as a team and can work together while the Stone Generals just rely on brute force and don't really work together as a team. The whole movie was about the TMNT reuniting again.

As for my thoughts on the movie, I enjoyed it but the TMNT looked too frogish and everyone was skinny. I don't mind the voice actors except Splinter. He sounded like a drunk. The plot was decent but was good enough to be a movie. I could see that in a cartoon but for a movie it was a bit pointless. But I did like the action and the drama going on with the TMNT. It gave me a few laughs here and there but I guess overall it was decent whatever movie.

Ramboraph4life aka Matt
06-04-2011, 05:03 AM
Wasn't a big fan of this movie at all. Extreme disappointment. I hated the the Leo character in this flick...his 'two-faced' personality (I can be vigilante in jungle, but you Raph can not in the city...I can stay for over a year and make my family think i'm dead, thus i come back & get medals and praise from splinter, hugs from donny and Mikey...but oooo, you raph, i'm sooo better than you).

I never really felt this group was a family. They acted more like strangers to each other, even as opposed to the live action films from previous and the 2k3 series. No joking at all between Raph & Mikey (hell...they never even TALK to each other, and the only time donnie and raph talk to each other is one argument)...and I didn't like how they began the plot. Especially as a re-introduction of the turtles after a decade from the big screen. The could have done much more (like the whole 'Mikey being a fan of the Nightwatcher, then finding out it's actually his own brother...you could have gotten some nice scenes of brotherhood in there). Or wouldn't it be nice to have a scene of Leo and Raph actually 'talking' to each other about the fight & making up with each other at the end? But nothing. just 'need u, need u too'...uhhh...that's it?

And why is it that a 2003 cartoon can do more (leo cutting shredder's head...well helmet...off, 'Same as it never was' episode, etc.) in the seriousness department than a big budget (at least compared to the cartoon), mainstream movie? And there wasn't nearly enough action...the only good parts to me were the leo/raph fight (which everyone remembers enough...and it was the most emotional/serious part...hmm, think of that? maybe they should LEARN from that) and the small fight with them and the foot. Or the fact they had some better stories than the one they came up for this one?

City at war would have been my personal choice of a story...for crying out loud even the Turtles in Time video game (reworked to fit a movie) would have been a more better storyline than this damn '13 monster/immortal' crap. Give 'Turtles Forever' that budget (that way you can get the original voice actors of the 80's cartoon, more time on the script to flesh out the 80's characters) and it would've been better.

I felt the fight with the generals was lame...I know in the commentary Raphael was supposed to die then come back, but Peter Laird didn't want that to happen. At one point Leo gets all these swords at one point and then...nothing. Kinda lame.

The 'Nightwatcher' stuff with Raphael to me would have been an extremely more interesting movie than this one (especially that backstory/comic book prequel of the guy who used to be a Nightwatcher-type and got shot and killed, & Raph answered his promise...THAT had more depth than this flick).

Sub-par voice acting (especially Splinter...RIP Mako but i just didn't care for him, or the Sarah michelle gellar/chris evans stuff).

Mikey burping? Oh yeah...great.

Movie felt too damn short, the score was forgettable, and the songs/soundtrack sucked.

So yeah, this movie disappointed me greatly. All I can like is Raphael's Nightwatcher persona...that could be done as a direct to DVD flick like these Batman/Superman ones that get released by DC.

ChetTurtle
06-04-2011, 07:03 AM
I really liked tmnt (probably because it was the first tmnt movie I saw and I was a kid-well I still am a kid but you get the point). I loved the cgi style and detail. I think cgi suited raph the best because he always had really big expressions. I agree that the end monster fight was a bit of a let down and the story was a bit dodgy but the family aspects were really good. It also did a good job of fitting the 2k3 cartoon and the old movies but not really explaining things to newcomers. For me it ties with tmnt 1 as my favourite tmnt movie.

P.S. Leo totally killed that guy at the start.

Revan
06-04-2011, 10:52 AM
Wasn't a big fan of this movie at all. Extreme disappointment.

I thought you liked it
Other than that the film is a well voiced, beautiful looking, wonderful addition to the TMNT universe.

http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/pics/raphr.jpg

must have decided you didn't like it after all?

CyberCubed
06-04-2011, 10:56 AM
That poll was posted way back in 2007 when the "hype" of the movie was around.

A lot of people originally liked the movie simply due to the fact that we hadn't gotten a new movie in theaters in almost 15 years. It was like, "FINALLY A NEW TMNT MOVIE!"

After that original hype died down, people began to view the movie for what it was, and not just, "the first new TMNT movie in a decade!"

Revan
06-04-2011, 11:58 AM
That poll was posted way back in 2007 when the "hype" of the movie was around.

A lot of people originally liked the movie simply due to the fact that we hadn't gotten a new movie in theaters in almost 15 years. It was like, "FINALLY A NEW TMNT MOVIE!"

After that original hype died down, people began to view the movie for what it was, and not just, "the first new TMNT movie in a decade!"

I wonder if this is how a lot of people feel. To me, liked is liked. I liked it then and I like it now. But I suppose I can understand people getting caught up in the moment and just going along with what everyone else was saying.

Redeemer
06-04-2011, 12:16 PM
Truth fully I thought TMNT was the second best Ninja Turtle movie to date. The Secret of the ooze sucked balls, third was ok.

I thought TMNT was a solid movie, the only reason it does not surpass TMNT 1990 is bc the story line was a little weak. I thought it could have been better. The foot wasn't the foot and the 13 monsters was weak.

But I am a Leo fan, I understand why Don and Mikey fans were a little dissapointed.

ToTheNines
06-04-2011, 12:19 PM
I wonder if this is how a lot of people feel. To me, liked is liked. I liked it then and I like it now. But I suppose I can understand people getting caught up in the moment and just going along with what everyone else was saying.

I love it when if first came out, saw it twice in theatres (which is rare for me), and defended it to the end... but now I don't really like it.

There's still some good things about it, but I could go on for quite some time about all the things I dislike about it.

oldmanwinters
06-04-2011, 12:46 PM
http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/pics/raphr.jpg


I'm proud to say I haven't changed my opinion in nearly 4 years! I still give it a solid B, nonsensical plot resolution be danged. All the rest of you "wisened" haters can just go hang with Andrew (who to his credit never got on board the hype train and found it underwhelming form day 1). :-P

Revan
06-04-2011, 12:52 PM
I love it when if first came out, saw it twice in theatres (which is rare for me), and defended it to the end... but now I don't really like it.

There's still some good things about it, but I could go on for quite some time about all the things I dislike about it.

Why did you love it when it came out but not now?

It's the same movie now as it was then. please explain. I'm NOT interested in why you don't like it. But I am interested in the reason for you changing your mind

ToTheNines
06-04-2011, 01:00 PM
Why did you love it when it came out but not now?

It's the same movie now as it was then. please explain. I'm NOT interested in why you don't like it. But I am interested in the reason for you changing your mind

I remember being pumped out of my mind just because a Ninja Turtles movie was coming out. It was mostly all the hype, and I gave it more credit than it deserved as far as fight scene's go for some reason.

Plus the fact that the movie feels like a setup to a sequel that never happened is lame.

Aaaand, some things just have low re-watch value.

Godzilla
06-04-2011, 01:09 PM
The film was alright for what it was I suppose, but I didn't feel it was a particular great way to re-start a potential movie franchise since I remember talking with a number of people who had saw it, and really didn't get anything out of the majority of the story itself other than certain scenes like Leo vs. Raph. And honestly, I completely understood that notion.

All in all, it was an experiment to try something different, and that's appreciated. But at the same time, it didn't quite hit the mark that it should have back in 2007.

Ramboraph4life aka Matt
06-04-2011, 02:08 PM
Reason for me changing my mind on it...when I first saw it, yeah, I did like it. But there are films that hold up and there are films that don't.

I can remember seeing Star Wars: Episode 1 the Phantom Menace in the movie theater and being like 'ooo, cool, I never got to see a star wars movie on the big screen...ooo cool lightsaber battle with Darth Maul', etc. But now I hate that movie with a passion...except the fight with Darth Maul.

There are always differences with movies that excite you at first, and movies that stand the test of time (which proves a real value of a film...rewatchability).

Experience is part of it. Like studying and rewatching the 2003 cartoon series, appreciating and valuing it more when I owned the DVDs and rewatched them...realizing (at least to me) that they did more with the action, characters, more serious story-telling than a 2007 bigger-budgeted flick.

It is like there are films that become BIG box office blockbusters...but then are quickly forgotten...but then there are box office duds that become fun or terrific classics (ala John Carpenter's The Thing, Blade Runner, etc.)

To me, after such a long wait the worst thing to feel for me as a fan was disappointment. Granted, that's my fault more than the film...but it's just my human nature. So TMNT came out and I wanted to like anything I could from it...but as time comes to reflect, you (or I guess I) realize more and more and more things that bug me each time I rewatch it. For example...I'm a huge Rambo fan. Saw Rambo 4 in theaters, loved it to death. BUT...I can revisit that film on blu-ray, and still sit back with a big smile on my face and without disappointment...just satisfaction.

And I can't do that with TMNT, because of the problems I listed above. I'm sure there are many of you who loved films when you were a kid...but you watch them today and can't stand it. Or films that you hear soooo much about how good they are/were, then you watch them and it's like 'this is it?' BUT...perhaps you would have liked them if you never even heard of it, found it like a gem, and went 'hey...this IS alright.'

But yeah, TMNT to me hasn't grown well. Do I have the DVD? Yes, as a collector and fan of the characters. The CGI at times is beautiful...that's why I didn't list that in my complaints. And the Leo & Raph fight was nice to see, especially on the big screen, as well as the fight with the Foot.

But a good movie you can see anywhere, even on a ****** boot-leg or on a 12 inch tv...as well as a movie you can pop in anytime and not be annoyed by a dozen problems. I can watch Ninja Turtles II: Secret of the Ooze and appreciate the fact that the turtles ACT like a family. Raph being mad at Mikey for crunching too loud, and ready to smack him, or Mikey petting Raph's head like soothing a cat or dog when Keno stomps on his foot. The suits and voice actors never getting old for me, and more.

But yeah...I guess that was my explanation on why my opinion changes. It happens to everyone...I guarantee there are movies and films that you either liked back then, but hate now...or movies that have grown on you....or movies that you hated that might have possibly been influenced by hype or people constantly saying 'oh this is the best ever'. It's just natural and about perception.

It's like they say, every film has a hater and every film has a fan.

ToTheNines
06-04-2011, 02:18 PM
Used to love Batman Returns. Hate it now.

Used to hate Napoleon Dynamite. Love it now.

I could list dozens of movies that have had this effect on me.

FearlessLeader
06-04-2011, 02:32 PM
I like this movie quiet a bit for three different reasons:

1) I love the animation, I loved the stylized look of the Turtles in this film and I thought the movement of their fight scenes looked gorgeous in CGI.

2) I loved the family dynamics in the story and most of all the character exploration of Leonardo and Raphael's often turbulent relationship. The film is worth seeing at least one time just for the fight scene between the two.

3) I loved Leonardo's voice actor in this film. Easily one of my favorite portrayals of the character.

And while I am not overly fond of the character the Star Trek geek in me was thrilled that Patrick Stewart was involved in the franchise as Max Winters.

Does this film have flaws, yes, but at least to me it still has parts I very much enjoy watching over again over again. Though as someone stated above I can very easily understand why Mike and Don fans would be annoyed by the film, though had he been given more screen time I think that portrayal of Don's character in this film could have been fantastic. He was brilliant and snarky and everything I really enjoy about the character.

Donnie
06-04-2011, 02:46 PM
Why did you love it when it came out but not now?

It's the same movie now as it was then. please explain. I'm NOT interested in why you don't like it. But I am interested in the reason for you changing your mind

You really went through all of that screenshot trouble just to bully the former poster for changing his mind? Like you have never changed your mind about anything? Jeez, when people get on others for common human occurances it is extremely irritating.

Concerning TMNT, I always loved it for its dark moments and the brief Donny/Raphael argument, but I was upset about the limited screen time both Donny and Mikey received.

Revan
06-04-2011, 02:52 PM
Reason for me changing my mind on it...when I first saw it, yeah, I did like it. But there are films that hold up and there are films that don't.

I can remember seeing Star Wars: Episode 1 the Phantom Menace in the movie theater and being like 'ooo, cool, I never got to see a star wars movie on the big screen...ooo cool lightsaber battle with Darth Maul', etc. But now I hate that movie with a passion...except the fight with Darth Maul.

I suppose this makes sense. With such a long wait between TMNT III and TMNT there were definitely some fans who were ready for anything

Used to love Batman Returns. Hate it now.

Perhaps a big part of that comes with age. If you saw Returns as a young batman fan you probably simply enjoyed seeing him in his own movie

You really went through all of that screenshot trouble just to bully the former poster for changing his mind? Like you have never changed your mind about anything? Jeez, when people get on others for common human occurances it is extremely irritating.

Is this guy for real? :lol:

ToTheNines
06-04-2011, 02:59 PM
Perhaps a big part of that comes with age. If you saw Returns as a young batman fan you probably simply enjoyed seeing him in his own movie.

Well I was 15 when TMNT came out and I'm 20 now. Does that count? lol

Jester
06-04-2011, 03:36 PM
I think I was excited when it first came out, and then when you sit with it at home, can stop it, think about it (where as in the theater you have to sit the whole 90 minutes and you can't ask the projectionist to pause it and let it sink in) it just doesn't hold up as well. I thought the same of the non-Nolen Batman flicks. I recently rewatched them, and Batman Returns is just as ridiculous as Forever (nothing can beat Batman and Robin for being straight up crap, though. to quote the Nostalgia Critic, "A BAT CREDIT CARD!!!"). To me, TMNT doesn't have as much replay value as the other live action flicks. Watching it multiple times only reveals more of it's flaws, IMO.

Candy Kappa
06-04-2011, 06:39 PM
after waiting for a ninja turtles film since I read an article about John Woo directing a new TMNT film back in 97-98 (I think) I was somewhere between pleased and content after seeing TMNT. I was all alone in the cinema, sitting in the middle.

Story-wise there's little to none replay value. But the fight scenes and just enjoying the CGI renders are fun.

Redeemer
06-04-2011, 07:18 PM
after waiting for a ninja turtles film since I read an article about John Woo directing a new TMNT film back in 97-98 (I think) I was somewhere between pleased and content after seeing TMNT. I was all alone in the cinema, sitting in the middle.

Story-wise there's little to none replay value. But the fight scenes and just enjoying the CGI renders are fun.

I disagree I actauly think it has pretty good replay value, at least for me it does, bc I enjoy the movie quite a lot. I have probably watched the movie almost a dozen times :D
I think I have actaully seen TMNT more than the first movie which is quite strange bc I like the first one the best and not jst bc of the nastolgia factor

Donnie
06-05-2011, 10:50 AM
Is this guy for real? :lol:

Using mockery as a form of defense is stale.

I've definitely played the movie out since its arrival on DVD, so I haven't watched it recently...but I do still like it, although I get what people are saying: the 13 monsters being ridiculous, terrible martial arts sequences (besides the Leo & Raph fight,) and the lack of screen time for Don and Mike. That last one to me was the most annoying for obvious reasons. :D

sdp
06-05-2011, 10:28 PM
TMNT 2007 already had a discussion thread when the movie came out, this thread should be merged with that one since it has all the initial reactions and even reactions after the movie came out on DVD.

ssjup81
06-06-2011, 10:00 AM
I didn't see this film until 2009 while laid up in a hospital bed. I came across it, right at the start, when flipping through stations, as I was bored out of my skull having been there for an entire week. I'd always been curious, but always put the film off because I wasn't really interested enough to literally see it. I hadn't seen any film since the third one, and I hadn't watched anything "Turtles" since The Next Mutation. So I saw this way after the hype.

I thought the movie was okay for what it was, but it did seem to be all over the place plot wise. I hated the fact that Donny and Mikey, to me, didn't get to do much of anything and was overshadowed by Leo and Raph's rivalry. I guess for what the film was, it's okay, but not too rewatchable for me, unfortunately.

Sage Ninja
06-06-2011, 11:46 AM
I'm sorry I have to this here. For everyone who thought Don and Mikey got shafted in the tmnt:

http://fc05.deviantart.net/fs18/f/2007/205/8/1/TMNT__Huh__They_saw_it_____XD_by_loolaa.jpg

FearlessLeader
06-06-2011, 01:07 PM
I'm sorry I have to this here. For everyone who thought Don and Mikey got shafted in the tmnt:

http://fc05.deviantart.net/fs18/f/2007/205/8/1/TMNT__Huh__They_saw_it_____XD_by_loolaa.jpg

I had forgotten about this comic :tlol:

It's really funny! Thank you for posting it!

ssjup81
06-06-2011, 02:03 PM
I'm sorry I have to this here. For everyone who thought Don and Mikey got shafted in the tmnt:

http://fc05.deviantart.net/fs18/f/2007/205/8/1/TMNT__Huh__They_saw_it_____XD_by_loolaa.jpgPlease, don't be sorry. That was hilarious!!:tlol:

Revan
06-06-2011, 02:05 PM
why were they in the shower together?:ohwell:

FearlessLeader
06-06-2011, 02:07 PM
why were they in the shower together?:ohwell:

Because they were making fun of there brothers. :trazz:

Revan
06-06-2011, 08:56 PM
ah. wow. totally missed that. It's that stupid "gay characters" thread affecting my judgement... :ohwell:

NameGoesHere1066
06-08-2011, 07:56 PM
1621
I don't know looks like Mikey getting a bit of a hard on here

Redeemer
06-08-2011, 08:40 PM
Lol this was awesome lol I am glad u shared this!!

NameGoesHere1066
06-09-2011, 10:22 AM
I'm sorry but the way that was drawn was...awkward...

ToTheNines
06-09-2011, 04:35 PM
So I just watched this on Blu-ray for the first time (thanks gobo!) and wow... the CGI is excellent. The city and sewers look great, the turtles' carapace looks so real, as do the weapons.

Anyways, this being my first viewing of this flick in over a year, I have some new opinions on it.

I've been ragging on Leonardo pretty hard lately (and nothing excuses his "sweet prince" and "come to daddy" lines) but I found he wasn't that much of an asshole in this movie. Him and Raph are always gonna fight. The real douche in this situation would be Splinter. Why they hell send Leo away and at the same time tell the other turtles to drop everything and wait on him? Splinter sent Leo away in the 4kids show, but he didn't make anyone stop what they usually do just for him.

Of course this brings me back to the whole "we're crimefighters" problem. In the Mirage books and pretty much in the 4kids show the turtles are just good-hearted and adventurous. They generally don't go out "busting up crime syndicates" cause they feel it's their duty, but if they come across some funny business, they're defnitely going to use their ninja skills best they know how.

The jobs are still stupid, even if Donatello's is semi-plausible.

Oh yeah, and they did Casey totally wrong. Casey is supposed to be a nut-job... that's why he wears a hockey mask and beats up thugs. However, eventually he settles down with April and starts acting normal. He still dons the mask and busts heads with they guys when he can, but he doesn't "go out playing vigilante every night" on his own while still trying to start a life with April. This movie tried to mix the two and failed.

CyberCubed
06-09-2011, 06:24 PM
Casey Jones always got worse once he, "settled down" with April. He becomes more of a joke rather than that violent psychopath he's supposed to be.

This happened to him in the 4kids series too and Mirage.

ToTheNines
06-09-2011, 06:32 PM
Casey Jones always got worse once he, "settled down" with April. He becomes more of a joke rather than that violent psychopath he's supposed to be.

This happened to him in the 4kids series too and Mirage.

Agreed on the 4kids part. But his City at War story was great, I'm foggy on Volume 2 these days... but he was still pretty bad-ass during the Image era all while having a wife and kid.

ToTheNines
06-11-2011, 09:24 AM
Why did you love it when it came out but not now?

It's the same movie now as it was then. please explain. I'm NOT interested in why you don't like it. But I am interested in the reason for you changing your mind

I remember being pumped out of my mind just because a Ninja Turtles movie was coming out. It was mostly all the hype, and I gave it more credit than it deserved as far as fight scene's go for some reason.

Plus the fact that the movie feels like a setup to a sequel that never happened is lame.

Aaaand, some things just have low re-watch value.

Another thing Neut: Back in 2007 I hadn't read many Mirage comics that weren't put up on ninjaturtles.com (I actually had a couple Tales and Volume 4 issues), I'd never read more than a couple Archie comics, I only had a few DVD's of the original cartoon and I had read 0 Image comics.

I was a far less educated turtle fan back then, if you will.

Revan
06-11-2011, 05:12 PM
Another thing Neut: Back in 2007 I hadn't read any Mirage comics that weren't put up on ninjaturtles.com (I actually had a couple Tales and Volume 4 issues), I'd never read more than a couple Archie comics, I only had a few DVD's of the original cartoon and I had read 0 Image comics.

I was a far less educated turtle fan back then, if you will.

That makes perfect sense. However, you make it sound like you don't like TMNT compared to the mirage comics. As if the mirage comics effected how you felt about the movie. This actually helps explain why some people liked TMNT and some didn't.

plasticturtle
06-11-2011, 10:13 PM
I loved it then and I love it now. My only problem is that I had to view it in a theatrefull of people who didn't know how to shut the hell up. They talked through the whole damn thing.

The original Live action film will always be my favorite however.

AT-Man
06-16-2011, 11:34 AM
My major complaint is that they are in the same kind of lair as in 4Kids show and Karai exist, even though it's not the same continuity/universe as 4Kids. It also doesn't fit in the previous 3 movies contunuity, so I guess this is just another universe in the TMNT multiverse.

CyberCubed
06-16-2011, 01:16 PM
What? Karai's design in this movie was totally different than what she looked like in the 2k3 series.

Likewise in this movie they made it fairly obvious the Turtles and Karai were meeting for the first time.

Redeemer
06-17-2011, 08:02 PM
What? Karai's design in this movie was totally different than what she looked like in the 2k3 series.

Likewise in this movie they made it fairly obvious the Turtles and Karai were meeting for the first time.

Yeah it was, but I thought the movie Karai was BA!!! I thought she looked so cool in the movie:D and sexy:P lol

ToTheNines
06-17-2011, 11:20 PM
She looked like a character from Jak and Daxter with shorter ears.

shuriken
06-25-2011, 03:54 AM
Yeah my opinion changed over time. At first I thought it was a pretty good movie, like coming out of the theater. Then I saw it a few months after and I thought to myself "this is so underwhelmingly mediocre". I don't hate it it's just not very good. Although the CGI is amazing and the Leo Raph fight is really good. Everything else is just meh. At the very least I could watch TMNT3 and watch how amazingly bad it is, this one is just there.

Leo656
07-24-2011, 02:25 AM
Sorry, wasn't around to throw my 2 cents in a few weeks back...

My girl and I saw it opening day in the theatre and liked it a lot, and I did get the DVD as soon as it came out... but it's probably telling that I haven't watched it in years and only saw it 3 times at most. I feel the quality overall was good, but too many small issues added up to make it not totally satisfying.

We're big Leo fans so we hardly noticed that the others got shafted to the level they did, but yeah, it was pretty blatant. I often mark out so hard for my favorite characters that I don't notice when others get less attention, but every character is someone's favorite so they should all get some attention.

My biggest thing was the movie felt crammed with too many characters and plot threads for a 90-minute movie. The way it was done might have felt more fitting as like a week-long tv mini-series than a big screen feature film. It didn't have that big, iconic feel because there wasn't enough time to develop it.

AK_Mikey_Fan
07-24-2011, 04:03 PM
I saw the movie opening weekend and then saw it again a couple weeks later. I thought it was good film, despite some of the flaws in it (the rushed story mostly). But overall (and everyone agrees) the animation is really good and so is the voice acting. And also I had notice that dark atmosphere that reminded me of the first movie in some ways. I still enjoy it to this day and it's currently tied with Secret of the Ooze as my 2nd fav turtle movie

Donnie
01-07-2012, 01:38 PM
Ross Campbell put up a very insightful and in my opinion very true critique of TMNT 2007 on his livejournal. Check it out here (http://mooncalfe.livejournal.com/179360.html)!

I agree with everything he says here - especially the bastardization of Mikey, the ineptness of Splinter, the plot in general, the nonsensicalness of it all! A lot of things I never thought of before.

ToTheNines
01-07-2012, 04:18 PM
One thing he got way wrong: The main reason Raph was mad a Leo is because Splinter sent him away for a set amount of time, but Leo stayed away much longer than expected. Remember April's line "Splinter said your training period ended over a year ago"?

Still a weird reason to get mad, if I was one of the other turtles and Leo had quit writing and been gone longer than the expected year... I'd think the guy was dead, not ditching out on us.

Metropoliskid41
01-07-2012, 08:17 PM
I think Raph's anger was justified, Leo has always been the leader Raph couldn't be, due to his patience and self control, while Raph has always been too hotheaded and quick to lash out in anger rather than think the situation through. Imo Raph is the physically strongest turtle and most vicious in combat, something in the past that has been known to make a warrior the leader, the fact that he possesses those qualities but isn't the leader Leo is, which he knows, I believe bothers him. Leo is supposed to be better, yet left them leaderless, and Raph has tried to keep his family together, but has seen first hand once again that he can't compare to Leo in that respect. So its kinda rubbing it in his face that Leo is a better leader, and he's off in South America. So Raph feels deserted and betrayed by Leo, who he looks up to.

Ps. As a Raph fan, I loved seeing him kick Leo's ass. That was definitely my favorite part of the movie. Overall not too bad, I found it entertaining, however I think the animation style could've been better. I think they looked more like geckos than turtles, and I wasn't a fan of how the humans looked either. If they changed the animation style and kept the same story I think it could have gotten a better reception.

BubblyShell22
01-08-2012, 09:59 AM
I saw the movie with my BF, and we loved it. Yeah, I felt that Don and Mikey were very under-used, but I loved the Leo/Raph fight on the roof. That was a very powerful scene. I liked the voice acting as well because they chose some good voices for the characters. As for who should take the blame for Leo's absence, I agree that it should be Splinter. He just seemed way too harsh in this film, especially when he was chastising Leo after their fight with the monster. He was putting even more pressure on his son to be a good leader, and I think it just drove Leo over the edge as well as when Raph was arguing with him.

But overall, I really liked the movie, though I wasn't a fan of the monster plot. I think they could've done something better than that.

Donnie
01-08-2012, 10:49 AM
"There are NO excuses when you are the leader, my student!" - so apparently Leonardo is supposed to be flawless, according to Splinter Mussolini. Seriously though, that does seem to be the case for Leo in this film - he's like Splinter's whipping boy, he totally seems like he can't make decisions for himself. There are two parts about this Splinter that I like 1) his voice actor (Mako?) and 2) the deleted scene where Donnie is trying to keep Splinter from having a piece of cake and Mikey sneaks it to him behind his shell. I wish they would have left that in!

Sophie Campbell
01-08-2012, 09:54 PM
One thing he got way wrong: The main reason Raph was mad a Leo is because Splinter sent him away for a set amount of time, but Leo stayed away much longer than expected. Remember April's line "Splinter said your training period ended over a year ago"?

Still a weird reason to get mad, if I was one of the other turtles and Leo had quit writing and been gone longer than the expected year... I'd think the guy was dead, not ditching out on us.

i concede that one! good point, i don't know how i missed that, especially since i've seen the movie a few times. man, i feel dumb, i thought i had this great on-point review, haha. totally a blunder on my part, point taken. :) that does help explain a lot, but i still don't know if i find it completely satisfying, especially since it's kind of a throwaway line and never mentioned again as far as i remember. but i totally agree with your point about how Raph ought to be thinking Leo is dead rather than ditching them, that almost makes the plot point/dynamic more confusing!

thanks for calling me out on that, though. :)

-Ross.

ToTheNines
01-08-2012, 10:35 PM
i concede that one! good point, i don't know how i missed that, especially since i've seen the movie a few times. man, i feel dumb, i thought i had this great on-point review, haha. totally a blunder on my part, point taken. :) that does help explain a lot, but i still don't know if i find it completely satisfying, especially since it's kind of a throwaway line and never mentioned again as far as i remember. but i totally agree with your point about how Raph ought to be thinking Leo is dead rather than ditching them, that almost makes the plot point/dynamic more confusing!

thanks for calling me out on that, though. :)

-Ross.

Yeah, it's still pretty confusing lol. Have you read the prequel comics? The Leonardo one (#5, art by Dario B.) is quite good and elaborates on Leo's training abroad.

Sophie Campbell
01-09-2012, 02:20 AM
Yeah, it's still pretty confusing lol. Have you read the prequel comics? The Leonardo one (#5, art by Dario B.) is quite good and elaborates on Leo's training abroad.

i think i probably made it out to be more confusing than it is, or i just overthought it. maybe i was being too hard on the movie but that was my immediate reaction.

i did read the prequel comics but i don't remember them very well. i like Brizuela's stuff, though, i wonder if i have still have those comics buried around here somewhere. i remember being eager to read the April comic because i thought it would explain her weird career shift or her training to be a ninja.

ToTheNines
01-09-2012, 09:31 PM
maybe i was being too hard on the movie but that was my immediate reaction.

Nah, there's definitely some flaw in the characters logic. Check back a couple of pages on this thread and you'll see I shared a lot of the same sentiments as you.

i did read the prequel comics but i don't remember them very well. i like Brizuela's stuff, though, i wonder if i have still have those comics buried around here somewhere. i remember being eager to read the April comic because i thought it would explain her weird career shift or her training to be a ninja.

Yeah, the Leo one was written by Murphy and is by far the best of the 5. I personally didn't like the April one, I've never been a fan of Jake Black's work, but Andres Ponce did that art and it's pretty nice. It doesn't explain any of that stuff, it does focus on her relationship problems with Casey though lol.

CyberCubed
01-11-2012, 07:42 PM
I really wish Imagi did get a chance to do a sequel, if only to iron out some of the flaws with this movie but deliver us a more improved sequel.

I know the plan was to have the Turtles de-mutate, but PL would have surely rejected that idea before they went into production.

I really would have liked to see the Imagi films spawn their own trilogy, or at least one sequel. Shame it came out in 2007 which was around the time the 4kids era was almost over.

sdp
01-11-2012, 10:14 PM
Well the new movie could've created a new era of TMNT, it's not like 2k3 was ever that popular. I too would've liked to have seen another movie set in the imagi universe, even with the flaws I liked the new universe it had spawned and I would've even taken the "comedy" sequel with mikey over nothing. Kids just weren't interested and adults saw the movie as a "kids" movie because it was CGi and not live action so they skipped it. I remember Kevin said the movie would have to make 100 million to guarantee a sequel or something along those lines, just imagine if it had made that. The movie came out in 2007, we would've had a sequel in 2009 and another in 2011, we could've had a trilogy already, not to mention imagi wouldn't have gone under and we could've gotten that awesome Gatchaman and Gigantor movies they had planned.

It's 2012 and we don't even know when the new movie is even going to come out and it looks like 2014 would be the earliest if it's to happen.

Ravenxl7
04-17-2012, 07:55 PM
Sorry to bump another thread that hasn't been replied to in a while. Figured this would be better than making a new thread that's the same exact topic.

I just watched this movie for the first time. When it first came out I was preoccupied with other stuff, and wasn't exactly liking what I had seen of the designs. I'm still not a big fan of them, but I actually like the movie as a whole.

The story was pretty interesting, and the quality of the animation is great. Looks like I now have incentive to buy the four pack of all the movies made so far. Even though I already own the second one, lol.

One thing I especially like about it, is Raph's whole part of the story. Donatello's pretty much always been my favorite character, but Raph really shined in this one, imho. Much like with Thundercats, I'm starting to like a different character more than I used to. Helps that I'm sort of realizing how similar I am to Raph...in certain ways.

I still think they look more like frogs wearing shells, and that any attempt to have this be a sequel to the live-action movies was foolish. Though in the end, I liked it, want to own a copy of it on DVD, and sort of regret not going to see it in theaters and not getting into it's toy-line.

Brandatello
12-13-2012, 03:31 PM
I was watching the film again recently and i wondered...
if april and casey were together then why was casey living on the couch. was april mad that he still goes out at night and he was in the doghouse?

CyberCubed
12-14-2012, 10:04 PM
I almost feel like this movie could fit into the continuity of the Nick show, almost as if the characters in this movie are "older versions" of the characters in the Nick cartoon. I know there's the Karai plothole, but ignoring her.