PDA

View Full Version : Don had Mike's lines in the 1st movie


saul
06-05-2011, 02:41 PM
Think about it:

-Comforting Raph about his sai
-Joking that he's "actually turning red"
-Comforting Leo that "of course Splinter's alive"
-Brining marshmellows to the fire

Don't these actions seem more appropriate for Mike? It would seem more in line for Mike to egg on Raph. Don probably should have spoke less. And I find it weird that Mike never directly talks to Raph at any point in the movie.

gobo
06-05-2011, 02:56 PM
A bit. It's like they took the dorkier of Mike's jokes and pawned 'em off to Donnie.

ToTheNines
06-05-2011, 03:23 PM
I was gonna start a discussion on Don in the first movie, actually. I don't like Corey Feldman, but overall I though Don was portrayed pretty well in the first movie.

The first movie is one of the least sci-fi based Ninja Turtles stories out there, so they didn't have much need for him to be thinking up crazy solutions and inventing things, so they kind of paired him up with Mikey (which makes logical sense that they'd be pals since Raph and Leo are so intense).

However, there's plenty of hints at Donatello being smart: He beats the other guys' asses in Trivial Pursuit, he diagnoses Casey as a claustrophobic, he' tinkering with some device in the lair after they come back from the farm, he works on the car with Casey, "I'm not so sure if this is, structurally speaking, such a good time for your uh... buddies to drop in".

Powder
06-05-2011, 03:58 PM
We've already gone over this. He's a drunk.

http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=34196

Redeemer
06-05-2011, 04:00 PM
Think about it:

-Comforting Raph about his sai
-Joking that he's "actually turning red"
-Comforting Leo that "of course Splinter's alive"
-Brining marshmellows to the fire

Don't these actions seem more appropriate for Mike? It would seem more in line for Mike to egg on Raph. Don probably should have spoke less. And I find it weird that Mike never directly talks to Raph at any point in the movie.

I see ur point, but those were jst basic jokes, except the Marshmellow thing that I think should have been a Mikey joke.

Ok who else it going to play Wheel of Fortune in the middle of a fight to the death! lol
Who else is going to yell at a tv show turtle telling him to Ninja kick the Damn rabbit!lol
Who leads a joke about Penacillin on Pizza??lol
Mikey and Don were set up as a tag team perfectly!
In fact this interpretation of Don and Mikey is my favorite of any TMNT universe.
Oh and probably my favorite Mikey scene is when he ducks into his shell dodging a axe and popping out to knock out the foot behind! :lol:

My favorite Donny scene is probably when he and Mikey play Rock paper, sciccors to see who fights the shredder,
or when he runs over KC in the truck I can go on and on love this movie:lol:

Abnormal Freak
06-05-2011, 04:48 PM
I like the sillier Donnie in the first movie. His and Mikey's buddy-buddy relationship works great, which certainly feels a lot more fleshed-out and real than the relationship Raph and Mikey have in the Mirage comics. (If I'm thinking right, it doesn't go very much beyond Raph in his one-shot issue saying, "How could I do this to Mikey? He's my best friend!") Mikey is definitely way more outrageous in the movie (you don't see Donnie holding the turtle wax bottle), and I think it's kind of ridiculous to think that Donnie can't be a jokester. Do the characters really have to be so one-dimensional? LEO'S THE LEADER! RAPH'S THE ANGRY ONE! DONNIE'S THE GENIUS! MIKEY'S THE FUNNY GUY! They seem more like actual brothers and believable characters in the first movie than they do in much of the comics.

Redeemer
06-05-2011, 06:33 PM
I like the sillier Donnie in the first movie. His and Mikey's buddy-buddy relationship works great, which certainly feels a lot more fleshed-out and real than the relationship Raph and Mikey have in the Mirage comics. (If I'm thinking right, it doesn't go very much beyond Raph in his one-shot issue saying, "How could I do this to Mikey? He's my best friend!") Mikey is definitely way more outrageous in the movie (you don't see Donnie holding the turtle wax bottle), and I think it's kind of ridiculous to think that Donnie can't be a jokester. Do the characters really have to be so one-dimensional? LEO'S THE LEADER! RAPH'S THE ANGRY ONE! DONNIE'S THE GENIUS! MIKEY'S THE FUNNY GUY! They seem more like actual brothers and believable characters in the first movie than they do in much of the comics.

Hit the nail on the head!!! It really gives Donny as well as the rest of the turtles a lot more depth

ToTheNines
06-05-2011, 06:36 PM
I like the sillier Donnie in the first movie. His and Mikey's buddy-buddy relationship works great, which certainly feels a lot more fleshed-out and real than the relationship Raph and Mikey have in the Mirage comics. (If I'm thinking right, it doesn't go very much beyond Raph in his one-shot issue saying, "How could I do this to Mikey? He's my best friend!") Mikey is definitely way more outrageous in the movie (you don't see Donnie holding the turtle wax bottle), and I think it's kind of ridiculous to think that Donnie can't be a jokester. Do the characters really have to be so one-dimensional? LEO'S THE LEADER! RAPH'S THE ANGRY ONE! DONNIE'S THE GENIUS! MIKEY'S THE FUNNY GUY! They seem more like actual brothers and believable characters in the first movie than they do in much of the comics.

Great post right here. That's the reason I love the first movie so much, Don, Leo and eventually Raph join in on the clowning without losing their definitive characteristics.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
06-05-2011, 08:05 PM
Mike's lines actually aren't the only ones that Don took. When Don was having an ABC's of insults with Casey, he was channeling Raph from the comics.

Jephael
06-07-2011, 08:48 AM
I like to think the Turtles have a unique way of channeling one another's attitudes and personalities since they're so close with one another.

Redeemer
06-07-2011, 02:13 PM
Mike's lines actually aren't the only ones that Don took. When Don was having an ABC's of insults with Casey, he was channeling Raph from the comics.

That I do not agree. Raph is a loner when he is mad, he doesnt even go near KC when he is super amd or depressed and plus wasnt Don with Kc when Raph was recovering????

Abnormal Freak
06-07-2011, 02:55 PM
It wouldn't have made sense for Raph to be buddying it up and fixing the truck with Casey. After all, he's the one who got whupped practically to death, not Leonardo. ;) Some liberties need to be taken to tell a compelling story in ninety minutes. Like, it wouldn't make sense to have April be a programmer, because you'd have to go through the Stockman stuff somehow, and it just wouldn't work.

And all things considered, the first movie is an incredibly faithful adaptation of the E&L comics—and, in my opinion, is a more enjoyable story overall.

shuriken
06-07-2011, 05:42 PM
That I do not agree. Raph is a loner when he is mad, he doesnt even go near KC when he is super amd or depressed and plus wasnt Don with Kc when Raph was recovering????

He wasn't mad though, at least not at that particular moment. But yeah Raph was totally doing the ABC's of insults in the comics. I like Don in the first movie, but his silliness was a tad bit overdone.

gobo
06-07-2011, 06:09 PM
I like Don in the first movie, but his silliness was a tad bit overdone.
WOW... That's quite a talent for understatement you've got there.

Herald7
06-08-2011, 06:41 PM
I liked the different take on Donnie in the first film. It was like he was thoughtful, but sort of quirky at the same time. He takes his time coming up with the appropriate victory cheer and even when he finally does decide on one it's somewhat bizarre, lol.

Donnie
06-09-2011, 12:03 AM
Even as a kid I knew that Donatello shouldn't have been the one to bring the mellows to the fire. That's the only criticism I have of first movie Donny. Other than that, one of my favorite adaptations of Donny, hands down. I've always loved Feldman's voice, too.

ssjup81
06-09-2011, 06:11 AM
I have to agree. The only prob I have with movie 1 Donny, where I really felt that it should've been Mikey is the marshmallow scene. That seemed way more Mikey like than Donny.

Abnormal Freak
06-09-2011, 02:41 PM
Well, I am with you guys there. ;) That's the one part where I've always felt, "Shouldn't Mikey be the one bringing the marshmallows to the fire?"

:p

It always felt like a really senseless thing of Donny to do, whereas you kind of expect it from Mikey.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
06-10-2011, 01:57 AM
That I do not agree. Raph is a loner when he is mad, he doesnt even go near KC when he is super amd or depressed and plus wasnt Don with Kc when Raph was recovering????

Huh? I think you misunderstood me. I was saying that, in the movie, when Don was working on the truck with Casey, that same thing happened in the comics, but with Raph instead of Don.

As was stated, though, a lot of things that happened in the comics that were adapted into the movie had characters switched around and doing things that one of the others did in the comics. In this case, of course Raph wasn't helping Casey with the truck, because in the movie, he was in a coma (in the comics, it was actually Leonardo that got beaten up, though).

I wasn't stating any opinions at all to disagree on, I was merely pointing out another example of some turtle swapping that the movie did. I apologize if my wording was confusing, though. ^^;

ssjup81
06-10-2011, 09:14 AM
After reading the comics, I always wondered why they had Raph get beat up instead of Leo, then we could've gotten Raph hanging with Casey (like in the comics) and Donny fixing everything up on the farm so that they'd have running water and electricity. I also always wondered why they made the place April's as opposed to Casey's, like in the comics.

Abnormal Freak
06-10-2011, 03:22 PM
Why they made it Raph is because Raph works best as the leading protagonist. The whole movie focuses on him and for good reason; he's the most turmoiled one, the one who's anxious to look for Splinter. He was the same way in the comics, so they really brought out his "brash leader's spirit" well in the movie—not that he has an intention of leading, but he inadvertently does so by his actions. With this focus on Raph, it doesn't make sense to suddenly have Leo out and about getting thrashed by the Foot.

As for the house being April's place instead of Casey's...eh, I dunno. :p Works either way.

Jo Dawn
06-13-2011, 11:14 PM
Do I even need to comment in this thread?

Ugh.

Don in the first movie was the worst adaptation of the character (not counting Next Mutation, of which we shall not speak. Mostly because I don't really remember it.). Having grown up in the 80's, I mean, I liked Corey Feldman ok. But not as Don. I just remember watching that movie, thinking 'This isn't right'. Basically, they had a 'name' (Feldman) and needed to use it, so they kind of... threw away the 'character' of Don to make it more fitting to Feldman and his abilities. Which was to be Mikey-lite. Don is not Mikey. No offense to Mikey fans, but this is why I relate to and like Don.

I'm (obviously) not a fan. It totally distracts me when I watch the movie, and the few moments of being actually in character are not enough to salvage it for me.

gobo
06-13-2011, 11:27 PM
Don doesn't 'nyuk nyuk'.

Jo Dawn
06-13-2011, 11:30 PM
Don doesn't 'nyuk nyuk'.

Haha, exactly! Were you quoting an old post of mine? ;) Those 'nyucks'... That... that is Unforgivable. I'd put them out of my head, they disturbed me so.

Thank you for reminding me. *shudders* :P I'll be going back to therapy now.

gobo
06-14-2011, 12:00 AM
Were you quoting an old post of mine?
Why would I do that? :P
I'll be going back to therapy now.
Tell 'em gobo sent ya. ^_^

Tuxedo Moroboshi
06-14-2011, 12:16 AM
As much as I like the first movie more than the second, I will admit that the second movie's Don actually felt like Don to me.

Jo Dawn
06-14-2011, 12:18 AM
Tell 'em gobo sent ya. ^_^

I'm sending you the bill, babe. :P

ChetTurtle
06-14-2011, 05:11 AM
The scene where Donny took Raph's lines..

http://miragelicensing.com/comics/mirage/eleven/pg27.html
http://miragelicensing.com/comics/mirage/eleven/pg28.html

I agree with others that while Donny's personality mirrors Mikey's, but this really does make it seem more like actual brothers.

ssjup81
06-14-2011, 05:29 AM
Don doesn't 'nyuk nyuk'.This is something that I didn't remember until rewatching the movie as an adult, recently. I actually had to rewind it. "Wait, did he just say nyuk-nyuk?" It's sorta like how I had to double-take when Raph said, "bitchin'".:tlol:

PizzaPower
06-14-2011, 08:10 AM
what scene did raphael say bitchin in?

ssjup81
06-14-2011, 08:30 AM
what scene did raphael say bitchin in?
The end of the movie when they were all doing catch phrases.

gobo
06-14-2011, 11:07 AM
The subtitles say "legit", I believe.

ssjup81
06-14-2011, 11:21 AM
Sounds a lot like "bitchin'" to me, but who knows. Maybe it is legit.

Redeemer
06-14-2011, 11:33 AM
He wasn't mad though, at least not at that particular moment. But yeah Raph was totally doing the ABC's of insults in the comics. I like Don in the first movie, but his silliness was a tad bit overdone.

Yeah thats why he shouted splinter's name from the roof

ToTheNines
06-14-2011, 01:39 PM
I'm 100% sure he says "Bitchin". It's quite audible and I remember the closed captioning of my VHS copy said it too.

gobo
06-14-2011, 02:08 PM
In case anyone was confused, I wasn't suggesting that it wasn't what he actually said. I just remember that a subtitle or caption for it I saw once upon a time said "legit". However, the comic adaptation said, in no uncertain terms, "bitchin'".

Redeemer
06-14-2011, 03:43 PM
Really???I cant see him saying that I am pretty sure he yells splinter Then again when Raph rolled over the cab I couldn't understand what the cab driver says

jaymq
06-14-2011, 03:56 PM
Do I even need to comment in this thread?

Ugh.

Don in the first movie was the worst adaptation of the character (not counting Next Mutation, of which we shall not speak. Mostly because I don't really remember it.). Having grown up in the 80's, I mean, I liked Corey Feldman ok. But not as Don. I just remember watching that movie, thinking 'This isn't right'. Basically, they had a 'name' (Feldman) and needed to use it, so they kind of... threw away the 'character' of Don to make it more fitting to Feldman and his abilities. Which was to be Mikey-lite. Don is not Mikey. No offense to Mikey fans, but this is why I relate to and like Don.

I'm (obviously) not a fan. It totally distracts me when I watch the movie, and the few moments of being actually in character are not enough to salvage it for me.

I agree entirely with this. FeldDon is the worst incarnation of any turtle for me in any incarnation with 4kids Mike as runner-up. They wrote around Feldman rather than him using his acting skills (or there lack of) to do the job properly.

FeldDon spent more time channeling other turtles than being what he should be and that ruins movie 1 Don for me. And 3.

Also, I'm still waiting on someone to convincingly tell me what did he do in movie 1 or 3 that was SOOO Donnie-like that he'd actually resemble the character of 'Donatello' in any way shape or form. Pah.

Redeemer
06-14-2011, 04:09 PM
I agree entirely with this. FeldDon is the worst incarnation of any turtle for me in any incarnation with 4kids Mike as runner-up. They wrote around Feldman rather than him using his acting skills (or there lack of) to do the job properly.

FeldDon spent more time channeling other turtles than being what he should be and that ruins movie 1 Don for me. And 3.

Also, I'm still waiting on someone to convincingly tell me what did he do in movie 1 or 3 that was SOOO Donnie-like that he'd actually resemble the character of 'Donatello' in any way shape or form. Pah.

Wow really????This is probably my favorite incarnation of Donny. I love the movie, but then again I have not had the chance to read through either comic series. I know he really didn't show off his techno geek side much, but I thought it showed it off enough I like how none of the characters were one-demensional

ToTheNines
06-14-2011, 04:15 PM
Also, I'm still waiting on someone to convincingly tell me what did he do in movie 1 or 3 that was SOOO Donnie-like that he'd actually resemble the character of 'Donatello' in any way shape or form. Pah.

Well:

However, there's plenty of hints at Donatello being smart: He beats the other guys' asses in Trivial Pursuit, he diagnoses Casey as a claustrophobic, he's tinkering with some device in the lair after they come back from the farm, he works on the car with Casey, "I'm not so sure if this is, structurally speaking, such a good time for your uh... buddies to drop in".

He also refers to the fungus that grew on their pizza as penicillin. Pretty nerdy if you ask me.

Don't get me wrong, I know that FeldDon is not quintessential Donatello and Corey Feldman does have a certain "chode-y-ness" about him. But like I said earlier, this just is not a very sci-fi based movie at all. Just look at the comics this movie is based off of, Don doesn't really do much in any of them.

Would you just like Donnie to keep his mouth shut and chill in the background the whole time?

jaymq
06-14-2011, 04:26 PM
Well:



He also refers to the fungus that grew on their pizza as penicillin. Pretty nerdy if you ask me.

Don't get me wrong, I know that FeldDon is not quintessential Donatello and Corey Feldman does have a certain "chode-y-ness" about him. But like I said earlier, this just is not a very sci-fi based movie at all. Just look at the comics this movie is based off of, Don doesn't really do much in any of them.

Would you just like Donnie to keep his mouth shut and chill in the background the whole time?

Points for effort. But like Jo said, it's not enough to salvage an entire movie of channeling other characters.

Nah, I would expect them to write a script that allows the turtles to all have a part while keeping their core personalities intact.

It amuses me how much people hate the 3rd movie for example, but it's the only one where it's not "leo vs raph" and that's pretty much half or all of the plot. Me? I like it, it had odd bits about it, but I liked it (outside FeldDon obviously).

This isn't to say I hated the first movie, I liked the rest of it, I just prefer movie 2 Don to the other movie incarnations.

ToTheNines
06-14-2011, 04:39 PM
This isn't to say I hated the first movie, I liked the rest of it, I just prefer movie 2 Don to the other movie incarnations.

Adam Carl was certainly a better Donatello, but he was defnitely a bozo in his own right. His antics in the opening fight scene and making out with a mop are prime examples of that.

Jephael
06-14-2011, 04:41 PM
Wait a minute. Why is everybody blaming the actors? It was the writers who came up with these scenes. Also, Lief Tilden was the one wearing the suit and actually doing those things. Feldman and the other guy were just providing a voice.

jaymq
06-14-2011, 04:48 PM
Adam Carl was certainly a better Donatello, but he was defnitely a bozo in his own right. His antics in the opening fight scene and making out with a mop are prime examples of that.

True that wasn't a starring moment, but he also paid attention to other stuff including Perry and helped him making the anti-mutagen.

ChetTurtle
06-14-2011, 05:07 PM
Wait a minute. Why is everybody blaming the actors? It was the writers who came up with these scenes. Also, Lief Tilden was the one wearing the suit and actually doing those things. Feldman and the other guy were just providing a voice.
Well said.

Redeemer
06-14-2011, 06:48 PM
Wait a minute. Why is everybody blaming the actors? It was the writers who came up with these scenes. Also, Lief Tilden was the one wearing the suit and actually doing those things. Feldman and the other guy were just providing a voice.

Best arguement point Ive heard yet.

Points for effort. But like Jo said, it's not enough to salvage an entire movie of channeling other characters.

Nah, I would expect them to write a script that allows the turtles to all have a part while keeping their core personalities intact.

It amuses me how much people hate the 3rd movie for example, but it's the only one where it's not "leo vs raph" and that's pretty much half or all of the plot. Me? I like it, it had odd bits about it, but I liked it (outside FeldDon obviously).

This isn't to say I hated the first movie, I liked the rest of it, I just prefer movie 2 Don to the other movie incarnations.

To me Donny was pretty much Donny.
As others said b4
-He tinkered with the truck
-Pointing out fungus on pizza
-Playing around with junk in the 2nd and 1st movie
-Helps the professor with the mutagen
-Translates geek for his brothers(When prefessor Perry uses too big or too complex words)
-knows Japaneese
-Studies the timeceptor
-Makes a second timeceptor

I mean come on!!! This screams Donny!!!
I jst think that everybody was so surprised by donny's commedy that they jst focus on his comedic aspect. I will say in the first movie I think his comedy over plays his nerd mojo, but not nothing that would upset me. In fact I love it! Give Donny more personality

gobo
06-14-2011, 07:32 PM
-He tinkered with the truck
Are you sure you wanna make this your first bullet point? He SAT IN the truck while CASEY TINKERED. But, since this was first on your list, I have no interest in hearing the rest of your defense. Better luck next time...

ToTheNines
06-14-2011, 07:51 PM
-knows Japaneese

"Hello... mustard?"

Redeemer
06-14-2011, 08:10 PM
Are you sure you wanna make this your first bullet point? He SAT IN the truck while CASEY TINKERED. But, since this was first on your list, I have no interest in hearing the rest of your defense. Better luck next time...

I remember him and KC were dicussing the electical wirering of the truck, KC was doing most of the work, but Donny was still messing with it

"Hello... mustard?"
I didn't say how much :P

Jo Dawn
06-14-2011, 09:39 PM
To me Donny was pretty much Donny.

Then you don't know Donnie. :P


As others said b4
-He tinkered with the truck
-Pointing out fungus on pizza
-Playing around with junk in the 2nd and 1st movie
-Helps the professor with the mutagen
-Translates geek for his brothers(When prefessor Perry uses too big or too complex words)
-knows Japaneese
-Studies the timeceptor
-Makes a second timeceptor

I mean come on!!! This screams Donny!!!


It doesn't, actually. And considering the topic of discussion is the first movie, then all you have is:
-He tinkered with the truck
-Pointing out fungus on pizza

But he doesn't tinker with the truck, Casey does. Don just has a mindless name game going on with Casey. And, uh, any child knows fungus on a pizza. I mean, unless the collective IQ of the world has gone seriously down, then I'd wager any kid knows its penicillin. I did, as a kid.

Still, they were poor attempts at covering Don's personality. Or lack thereof, in the movie.

Give Donny more personality

I agree, just give him HIS personality.

Though, in the interest of positivity, I will say that Don did have one moment in that movie that will always make me laugh, and that is when he tells Casey that he is claustrophobic.

"You're a claustrophobic."
"You want a fist in the mouth? I've never even looked at another guy!"

Jester
06-14-2011, 09:43 PM
"You're a claustrophobic."
"You want a fist in the mouth? I've never even looked at another guy!"
Funny because of Don, or funny because of Casey's reaction?

Jo Dawn
06-14-2011, 09:48 PM
Funny because of Casey's ignorance to the meaning of the word, and supermacho overreaction. But I also did like how Feldman did that line. It was his best work. *teardrop*

Herald7
06-14-2011, 10:45 PM
I agree, just give him HIS personality.

For me personally, even though it's obviously different from other incarnations, I still found this a valid interpretation of the character. He's clearly the more thoughtful one of the group, the way he's tries to have a serious conversation with Mikey about Splinter (fails of course because hey it's Mikey!). Or when he understands and sympathizes with April missing her father. The actor in the suit is always holding or rubbing his chin (even in publicty photos I've seen if I recall), giving the impression he's always thinking.

Though, in the interest of positivity, I will say that Don did have one moment in that movie that will always make me laugh, and that is when he tells Casey that he is claustrophobic.

Lol, love that, and again it does demonstate he's the more em...bookish one, hehe. The only difference is that the Donatello of other incarnations might be too polite to point that out to Casey, lol.

ssjup81
06-15-2011, 07:12 AM
I thought that father thing was with Leo, but never mind.

His comforting Raph after he lost is Sai was really Donny-like to me, and even when Raph pushed him away and he pushed back. That struck me as Mirage Donny-ish.

There's also the campfire scene where it looked like he was comforting Mikey.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
06-15-2011, 12:45 PM
For me personally, even though it's obviously different from other incarnations, I still found this a valid interpretation of the character. He's clearly the more thoughtful one of the group, the way he's tries to have a serious conversation with Mikey about Splinter (fails of course because hey it's Mikey!). Or when he understands and sympathizes with April missing her father.

Now, see, not to change the subject, but this is something I never really liked about all the interpretations of Mike that aren't his comic book version. Donatello tries to have a serious conversation about Splinter with Mike, but it fails because it's Mike? Donatello is the most thoughtful of the group? He's the most understanding and sympathizes with April? All of these things describe the kind of personality that Mike has in the original comics. Sure, the original Mike might still be fun-loving, but he had a gentle, caring side to him that's never really seen outside of the comics. Unfortunately, outside of the original comics, Mike will always be known as a partying, drugged out, surfer dude with the I.Q. of swiss cheese, and not as the most empathic and thoughtful turtle, who's also got a creative mind and even writes his own fiction about ancient Japan. :ohwell:

Although I wouldn't pin it down exactly (as there's still more to him that this), I'd say that the Don of the first movie was actually closer to the Mike of the original comics than any version of Don (still a little less serious, but if I had to say there was anyone that movie 1 Don resembled, this would be the closest thing). While Mike, on the other, was more akin to the 87 toon version of himself.

Redeemer
06-15-2011, 01:03 PM
Then you don't know Donnie. :P



It doesn't, actually. And considering the topic of discussion is the first movie, then all you have is:


But he doesn't tinker with the truck, Casey does. Don just has a mindless name game going on with Casey. And, uh, any child knows fungus on a pizza. I mean, unless the collective IQ of the world has gone seriously down, then I'd wager any kid knows its penicillin. I did, as a kid.

Still, they were poor attempts at covering Don's personality. Or lack thereof, in the movie.



I agree, just give him HIS personality.

Though, in the interest of positivity, I will say that Don did have one moment in that movie that will always make me laugh, and that is when he tells Casey that he is claustrophobic.

"You're a claustrophobic."
"You want a fist in the mouth? I've never even looked at another guy!"

Well it someone said that he wasn't donny like at all for movie 1 and 3 and I was jst pointint out Donny like things off the top of my head he had done in all the movies.

Donny is not my favorite turtle so I am not as magnafied and I dont put his character under a scope. I also have never really read much of any of the comics except Issues 1-19 So I dont know comic book Donny that well, but I definately knew that this character in the movie was Donny jst by his personality

jaymq
06-15-2011, 03:21 PM
Wait a minute. Why is everybody blaming the actors? It was the writers who came up with these scenes. Also, Lief Tilden was the one wearing the suit and actually doing those things. Feldman and the other guy were just providing a voice.

I think I addressed that in a previous post. I felt as if the writers were working around him as did Jo Dawn mention similiar. Oh hey, big name and such. Here we are:
Having grown up in the 80's, I mean, I liked Corey Feldman ok. But not as Don. I just remember watching that movie, thinking 'This isn't right'. Basically, they had a 'name' (Feldman) and needed to use it, so they kind of... threw away the 'character' of Don to make it more fitting to Feldman and his abilities. Which was to be Mikey-lite.

I agree entirely with this. FeldDon is the worst incarnation of any turtle for me in any incarnation with 4kids Mike as runner-up. They wrote around Feldman rather than him using his acting skills (or there lack of) to do the job properly.

--

It doesn't, actually. And considering the topic of discussion is the first movie, then all you have is:

But he doesn't tinker with the truck, Casey does. Don just has a mindless name game going on with Casey. And, uh, any child knows fungus on a pizza. I mean, unless the collective IQ of the world has gone seriously down, then I'd wager any kid knows its penicillin. I did, as a kid.

Still, they were poor attempts at covering Don's personality. Or lack thereof, in the movie.


I agree, just give him HIS personality.

Though, in the interest of positivity, I will say that Don did have one moment in that movie that will always make me laugh, and that is when he tells Casey that he is claustrophobic.

"You're a claustrophobic."
"You want a fist in the mouth? I've never even looked at another guy!"

Agreed in whole.


And ...okay, I liked that scene. That one always makes me giggle.


Well it someone said that he wasn't donny like at all for movie 1 and 3 and I was jst pointint out Donny like things off the top of my head he had done in all the movies.

Donny is not my favorite turtle so I am not as magnafied and I dont put his character under a scope. I also have never really read much of any of the comics except Issues 1-19 So I dont know comic book Donny that well, but I definately knew that this character in the movie was Donny jst by his personality

I don't understand this, you say you don't know the comics, but you know he was Donnie by personality in the movie? Each incarnation is different, yes. But the core of his personality tends to be geeky, smart, analytic, and occasionally aggressive (not at Raph's level of course, but certain things still get him worked up) not constantly making lame jokes or poking fun at his brothers. Mikey's the one that does that. Granted, Mikey's taste in such varies, but it's still something that sticks from turtleverse to turtleverse.

Redeemer
06-15-2011, 03:44 PM
I don't understand this, you say you don't know the comics, but you know he was Donnie by personality in the movie? Each incarnation is different, yes. But the core of his personality tends to be geeky, smart, analytic, and occasionally aggressive (not at Raph's level of course, but certain things still get him worked up) not constantly making lame jokes or poking fun at his brothers. Mikey's the one that does that. Granted, Mikey's taste in such varies, but it's still something that sticks from turtleverse to turtleverse.

I still see the nerd in him is all, but Yeah they actaully gave him a comidic side. So what? He is still a nerd, jst a bit more goofy

gobo
06-15-2011, 05:22 PM
He is still a nerd, jst a bit more goofy
Way to understate... >_<

Herald7
06-15-2011, 07:13 PM
I still see the nerd in him is all, but Yeah they actaully gave him a comidic side. So what? He is still a nerd, jst a bit more goofy

Yeah I think that's true and I personally enjoyed it. I'm not saying it has to be this way in every incarnation. But for this particular incarnation, it worked fine. :)

Donnie
06-16-2011, 12:43 AM
For me personally, even though it's obviously different from other incarnations, I still found this a valid interpretation of the character. He's clearly the more thoughtful one of the group, the way he's tries to have a serious conversation with Mikey about Splinter (fails of course because hey it's Mikey!). Or when he understands and sympathizes with April missing her father. The actor in the suit is always holding or rubbing his chin (even in publicty photos I've seen if I recall), giving the impression he's always thinking.

Exactly. Jo, I completely respect your opinions but I think you're being a little too harsh to others who think Donatello of the first film was a fair (and dare I say "good") portrayal of his character. Donatello's personality is the most complex in my opinion, and he has been written in many different lights through varying TMNT media - that's nothing secret. Naturally the same case can be made for the other three, but from my experience Donny's personality can go a few different ways depending on which media you are speaking of. He's been named the group pacifist on many occasions (from Kevin Eastman himself) but we know that he can get quite rude and angry if you press his buttons, and violent as well. Concerning the films, each film highlights different sides of Donatello while keeping in tact key personality points: brainy, technical, engineering, thoughtful, sensitive, somewhat socially awkward, etc.

Many here have already mentioned great examples of Donatello's personality that is communicated to us through the first film, and might I add another pertaining to his sensitive side (I apologize if it has been already said): It's a kodak moment. In this scene Donatello is portrayed as sensitive (which he is, arguably, the most sensitive) - a key part of Donatello's make-up.

I'm not saying that the first film Donatello was 100% spot on, especially given that darned marsh-mellow bit. In my opinion, they "skimmed the surface" of Donny's character in the first film, but it was still Donny. At least to me.

Jester
06-16-2011, 01:12 AM
She's always had a problem with Donny being so "jovial". "Donny doesn't 'Nuck Nuck'!" And I can't say I disagree with her. Donny Feldman and the script did kind of make Donny "Mikey-lite." It may be that since Raph and Leo were paired, and they weren't sure what to do with Mike and Don led to them being the "Blunder Twins" if you will. :P

ChetTurtle
06-16-2011, 01:52 AM
And I can't say I don't disagree with her.

Say what?


Longer post.

Jester
06-16-2011, 01:59 AM
Never mind me. :D

ChetTurtle
06-16-2011, 02:13 AM
Your post was long enough, the reason I wrote that was because ,mine wasn't.
"Say what?" was for the confusing sentence.:D

Jester
06-16-2011, 02:18 AM
Your post was long enough, the reason I wrote that was because ,mine wasn't.
"Say what?" was for the confusing sentence.:D
Sorry...I'm a bit tired.